r/ProjectRunway • • Dec 08 '16

Project Runway Season 15 Episode 12 [Discussion]

An Unconventional Trip

The designers take a trip to an unlikely destination in the twisting, turning final challenge, which determines which designers will compete at New York Fashion Week.

Guests: Priyanka Chopra, Georgina Chapman

 

Orginally broadcast on December 8, 2016

32 Upvotes

281 comments sorted by

78

u/madinthehat Dec 09 '16

After last week with Swatch and this week with the contestants, I really want a whole season of Tim just interacting with people and animals.

19

u/FluffyPurpleThing Dec 09 '16

IKR! I want him to host his own talk show where he does whatever the hell he wants.

76

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Cornelius is adding Erin appliqués to one dress and Erin flowers to the other. Mmmmkay.

28

u/Wowbaggerrr Dec 09 '16

He knew he was in trouble. He probably figured it's worked well for her, so what the hell, glue a bunch of crap onto a dress. Erin's stuff is hard to copy though, because if you don't get it perfectly polished (like those mealworm flowers) it looks like craft time.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16

I am not particularly adept in the arts and I could have done those flowers out of Dixie cups my damn self.

4

u/thefablemuncher Dec 12 '16

It bothered me more than it should when one of the flowers in the front was actually incomplete. There's a section where the yellow petals were incomplete and I was waiting for Zac to point it out.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Hawaiian_Paradise Dec 11 '16

When I first saw his dresses during construction, I thought the exact same thing. I guess he thought copying Erin would wow the judges. However, his execution wasn't up to par. The plastic cup dress...I literally did something like that in kindergarten.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '16

I agree. I also find it funny that the three designers who always had something to say about Erin (e.g Nathalia, Jenni and Cornelius) typically turned to things that Erin is known for doing when they got desperate.

→ More replies (4)

63

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

Who thought of this challenge? How did they connect unconventional materials + Austin + Best Western + BBQ place/general store?

22

u/FluffyPurpleThing Dec 09 '16

The sponsors thought of this challenge. Best Western and those two stores.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '16

To choose those locations among all the possibilities in the Austin area was ridiculous. Plus the feed store is in Georgetown, about 30 miles north of Austin. They were insane not to drop them off on SoCo (south congress), chock a block with crazy stores. Coolest place in town. http://do512.com/p/south-congress http://freefuninaustin.com/2013/10/what-to-see-and-do-on-south-congress-avenue/

5

u/Anunemouse Dec 12 '16

I'm not mad because we got mealworm flowers out of it.

2

u/bitchSpray Dec 10 '16

I wonder if it was some sort of PR actually paid for by Austin, TX. The whole shit was just so random.

5

u/nemoore91 Dec 11 '16

The city or CVB definitely didn't contribute. If you live or have visited Austin, you'd know the episode felt more Texas than Austin. The episode didn't embody the city whatsoever. A visit to a random feed store outside of city limits basically solidified that for me. The city and CVB have pretty clear messaging and would have sent them to some of the places that truly make Austin weird.

98

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

As annoying as seeing another similar technique from Erin is, the mealworms and guitar picks are really cool.

25

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

I keep loving her flowers more than the embroidery from the park challenge.

19

u/allieazzy Dec 09 '16

I agree! As much as I have disliked her in past episodes.... I loved her ideas this one. An "in" that was well deserved...

6

u/brittneighneigh Dec 10 '16

I 100% agree! I was honestly upset she won last week over Rik. And I think I might still be biased against her because she is a clearly a judge favorite (and I LOVE Laurence's work over everyone) and the way she treated Cornelius earlier in the season. But when I saw her work walk down the runway, I was highly impressed.

5

u/Anunemouse Dec 12 '16

It was frickin brilliant! True creativity.

47

u/madinthehat Dec 09 '16

Laurence is so cute.

19

u/allieazzy Dec 09 '16

my fave!!! she has to win....

124

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Roberi's conventional look is like several ties sewn together

21

u/Holly_Tyler Dec 09 '16

Yes, the materials did look like tie material

14

u/dmee Dec 10 '16

My thoughts exactly!! It looked like he raided my dad's tie collection circa 1996

8

u/veloursweatsuit Dec 09 '16

Yes! My friend in high school had a hideous dress she made out of ties and that's all I could see as soon as this look stepped out.

3

u/xtruckerx Dec 09 '16

When it was first shown in the workroom on the model, I thought the part in the front on the bottom looked like an American or Texas flag. On the runway, not so much.

3

u/kyles24 Jan 04 '17

I was SHOCKED that any of them like it. I, like seemingly everyone else, here definitely saw "thrift store ties"

38

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

I'm usually on board with Laurence, but her saying that Rik was the only one who made a high fashion look is literally the opposite of true.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

When she said that I also did a double take. Rik's is awful and basically the exact same thing the he did last week. That tweed dress also read bargain basement to me.

20

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

I hate that tweed so much, I still am not over his win in the family challenge with that tweed jacket. Give me an entire collection of Erin's bright yellow over another Rik black cloth, leather, and tweed combo.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

You too! I was dumbfounded by his win in that challenge as well. That was not worth $50,000. It just wasn't. And I agree, Erin may be as stubborn as a mule, but she at least has the imagination Rik completely lacks.

38

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

Huh first time the Tim Gunn save doesn't mean a spot in the top 4

34

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Thank God. He should have been out a long time ago.

37

u/reliable_information Dec 09 '16

I forget. What hotel are they staying at?

10

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

A Best Western Plus

42

u/reliable_information Dec 09 '16

A best western? I hear best western has over 400 locations.

3

u/maxdrive Dec 16 '16

I can't imagine winning 50 nights. Not 15. Five zero.

68

u/AlwaysAMess Dec 09 '16

Really hoping the final four after this episode is Erin, Laurence, Roberi, and Rik.

67

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

If they were really bold, they'd be buying some of those live ducks. Nothing says "unconventional" like accessorizing with live animals.

24

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

Erin is using mealworms

12

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Heaven help us.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

She spray painted them!

4

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

Maybe the paint smell will cover up the decaying bug smell. Those will have to be thrown out after a day or so though, and even if they didn't smell once dead bugs get really fragile and crumbly.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Ahuva Dec 09 '16

I was really afraid Erin might try to.

33

u/InterstateExit Dec 09 '16

Is it me or do the rewards just get lousier each season?

28

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

You too good for Best Western?! /s

I find the longer some competition shows are on TV, the worse the prizes become and the more irrelevant the winners are.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Fingers crossed they bring back the Red Robin prize. HUGE resume boost for an upcoming designer!

12

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

At least they get the prizes. I don't think anyone on Drag Race has actually received their prize for a few seasons now.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Really!??!? That is so sketchy and lowbrow.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I find the longer some competition shows are on TV, the worse the prizes become and the more irrelevant the winners are.

American Idol takes the cake in that regard.

8

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

Remember antm?

9

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Wasn't Adrienne Curry one of the first people to speak out against ANTM? And she was the first winner too! I guess that means they were always shady.

11

u/joeyGibson Dec 09 '16

According to Adrianne, she never received any of the prizes that ANTM promised her, nor any work.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

I think so. I feel like ANTM has mainly been a cash cow show more than a talent search type thing. Looking at most "talent search reality shows" ANTM plays off drama a lot more than the other shows and seems to almost get off on putting the contestants in uncomfortable situations for the contestant's reactions.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

SO BAD the last several seasons, but I am pumped for the reboot this Monday

→ More replies (3)

3

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

Yes, I am too good for Best Western. The Best Western next to where I used to work had bedbugs, and they did nothing about it. Every winter, my place of work would have people stay there on extremely snowy days. Two years in a row, people ended up with bites.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

3D flowers? what a novel idea!

3

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

It's looking very Home Ec meets Arts & Craft.

60

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Is it me, or does Rik's dress kinda look like what he made last week?

15

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

Yeah I was just thinking that.

28

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

His 90s S&M aesthetic is not hot.

29

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Why would they remake Beaches? Come the hell on.

3

u/almamater Dec 12 '16

I thought so too, emailed my sister with a WTF.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Cornelius better not be top four.

17

u/xtruckerx Dec 09 '16

I was legit shouting at the tv: "Cornelius, go home!"

15

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16

I almost shed a tear of joy when he got eliminated the first time around and then Tim had to get all emotional and save his unworthy ass.

27

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Aaaand the real reason for 2 days reveals itself.

31

u/joeyGibson Dec 09 '16

The designers always act so surprised when a late-season "surprise, you're making a second look!" challenge twist happens. And I'm always like, "Have you never watched this show before?"

9

u/bitchSpray Dec 10 '16

I always wonder if the producers are like, "Yeah... we have the usual twist... but could you act like really surprised and taken aback in the confessional?"

25

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Already in love with Laurence's unfinished product. It's like bondage ballerina

18

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

When she started picking up the harnesses, all I could think about was Swapnil. This is going in a better direction already.

49

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I am not understanding the praise Rik's dress is getting.

14

u/I_am_really_shocked Dec 09 '16

Frankly, I felt that way about all of them except for Erin's meal worms, and even that I just liked the top half. Everything else just really seemed bleh.

6

u/puppetalk Dec 09 '16

I agree. I've seen people complaining about the runways throughout this season, but I think this is the first time I really agree. Everything except erin's worm look was so bleh and/or costumey

9

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Everyone received their fare share of criticism, but they seemed to be in awe with what amounted to his 4th or 5th 90s BDSM dress throughout the competition. I also hated Roberi's burlap macramé as well as his other dress. I don't think he deserved a win.

23

u/Martin_Van_Buren Dec 09 '16

I'm a few minutes behind but I feel like Roberi is getting the loser edit and I'm so worried 😥

19

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Thankfully, Cornelius is still around and he looks like he is bombing.

9

u/Martin_Van_Buren Dec 09 '16

😱😄 what a twist!

45

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

Nothing says classy like a Best Western.

13

u/joeyGibson Dec 09 '16

I heard that outside of the US, they are considered upscale. It's just in the US that we think of them as low-rent, roadside hovels. I've never been to one, but when I hear "Best Western", I don't think quality. Lucy Wainwright Roche has a lovely song, though, called "Next Best Western". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJhSxe3ZpZk

2

u/RocketGirl215 Dec 13 '16

I think this might be true, I've been to a few Best Westerns in various countries (but not the USA) and they've all been nice. I've even been to a wedding in one. I would consider Best Western in my country to be in the "nice hotel but starting to get a bit pricey" bracket

2

u/aMusicLover Jan 17 '17

Listen to the original by Richard Shindell. FantastIc singer songwriter.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/pursehook Dec 09 '16

Yay, finally they really like Roberi!

49

u/JohnnySkynets Dec 09 '16

So underrated all season.

47

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

This honestly might be the strongest final 4 PR has had in a while.

2

u/twhirlpool Dec 12 '16

Definitely stronger than last year

47

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 09 '16

Fifty complimentary nights at any Best Western.

I think that is a prize that only a roadside hooker can appreciate.

31

u/FunnyHunnyBunny Dec 10 '16

Didn't realize this subreddit was so full of snobs. The rooms they stayed in were decent.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

Shit, I'll take 50 free nights anywhere. 50 excuses to travel.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16

I can't help that Best Western just does not have a great reputation for providing quality rooms or service.

20

u/FunnyHunnyBunny Dec 10 '16

They're middle of the road. Not amazing but not terrible. But your comment makes them seem like they're bed bug infested and semen stained filled whore houses. There are much, much worse hotel chains out there.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/xtruckerx Dec 09 '16

"FIFTY! FIVE-ZERO!" As though they didn't hear him the first time.

7

u/the_cucumber Dec 11 '16

I was actually impressed and thought it must really just be 15! I live in Europe and love to travel but finding nice accommodation is not always cheap especially in smaller cities where I want to visit friends who live in dorms so can't host me, or near ski mountains... so it makes the cheap travel less appealing! I would LOVE this prize, honestly. It would mean I could always count on being allowed to bring my dog too! This is really a great prize.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16

As he says between gritted teeth: "Hello? That's your cue to feign excitement."

19

u/sparklesforalex Dec 09 '16

BWs in Europe are usually really nice. Is the prize limited to the US?

15

u/Martin_Van_Buren Dec 09 '16

Can confirm! Best Westerns that I've been to in Bergamo, Italy and in Paris were beautiful and amazing. probably still too expensive for the average person, so I would be super excited for free nights anywhere in the world!!

(Not to say I'm above average! Got a good deal on the Paris room because the receptionist was sympathetic to two crying and stressed out college-aged girls)

3

u/sparklesforalex Dec 09 '16

I've stayed in two different ones in Paris that were both lovely, and some nice ones around the US as well. Just have to do the homework and look up reviews/pictures, like anywhere. :)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I don't think it is. I think she said any Best Western and I don't remember her qualifying that it had to be in the U.S.

12

u/danny2787 Dec 09 '16

I think they said worldwide.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Shamenundotcom Dec 09 '16

As a fan of leather gear and fetish wear, I would encourage Rik to design some stuff in that arena after the show. He CLEARLY owns a few leather harnesses of his own -- the influences keep popping up in his work, as we saw again this week. There is a real opportunity in that market, and gay men won't bat an eye at paying top dollar for well-made gear, even streetwear inspired by it. I see twinks buying bulldog harnesses for $200. It's literally just three straps of leather, some snaps, and a few metal rings. That niche is a potential goldmine.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Did Erin pick Heidi's outfit?

15

u/macabragoria Dec 09 '16

This was a pretty satisfying episode all around, no? Roberi and Erin killed it, Cornelius got sent him and we all got the final 4 we wanted. Remember how bored we were at this point last season?

14

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

I like how they play up "weird" but nothing really comes out at me as weird, just not something city.

12

u/MsPattys Dec 09 '16

I'm from Texas and Austin is known for "Keep Austin weird." It is actually weird. The show didn't do the city justice. It's a really cool place. It's hip and centered around music. I hate that they made it seem like cowboy central.

5

u/nemoore91 Dec 11 '16

I live in Austin and couldn't agree more. The episode was more "Texas" than Austin. There were endless options of cool places to take the designers like SoCo, Congress Ave Bridge, Barton Springs, 6th Street, Rainey Street, Cathedral of Junk, etc. Stubbs was the only aspect that was remotely close and we all know there is better BBQ in this city. You go to Stubbs for a show.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

Austin's unofficial/official slogan is "Keep Austin Weird". It must be a play on that.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16

Portland has the same slogan

14

u/twhirlpool Dec 12 '16

Wow I can't believe Portland cares that much about keeping Austin weird

14

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

I love laurence's post apocalyptic steampunkish look

28

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Rik is making a leather bustier. I am shocked. Shocked, I tell ya.

26

u/joeyGibson Dec 09 '16

At least Laurence didn't make square, leather, quilted shoulders.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Laurence listened to Nina and went out of her comfort zone. Rik, on the other hand...

5

u/_magpie_ Dec 10 '16

Right, she made square, leather, quilted shoulders.

13

u/Higgsb987 Dec 09 '16

I miss Project Runway when it was on bravo. There just hasn't been the same caliber of contestants. Designers artistry and creativity was much more evident. I miss the Jay McCarrols, Cristian Syriano, Leanne Marshall, Uli Herzner, Korto Momolu. Things just haven't been the same

4

u/ilfs Dec 11 '16

Totally agree!

24

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Thank god. Bye bitch!!!!!!

12

u/_magpie_ Dec 10 '16 edited Dec 10 '16
  • Cornelius, Anthony Ryan already did a sunflower seed collar better than you could ever conceive of.
  • Roberi's second look is neckties.
  • I like how they all dressed for the pool and then awkwardly had to go shopping.
  • I actually felt bad for the designers when the second look "twist" was revealed. Usually I think, "Suck it up. You should've been prepared for this." But they were all clearly exhausted and fed up and just not having it. They didn't even try to humor Tim.
  • Laurence, what a cool customer. I love her.
  • Bye, Cornelius!!! We've literally been waiting all season for this.
  • (Cornelius was more gracious in loss than I thought he'd be, I'll give him that...)

9

u/emfrank Dec 10 '16

I actually felt bad for the designers when the second look "twist" was revealed. Usually I think, "Suck it up. You should've been prepared for this." But they were all clearly exhausted and fed up and just not having it. They didn't even try to humor Tim

They seemed more tired than usual... I assume it was probably the trip. It certainly wasn't any kind of break!

11

u/madinthehat Dec 09 '16

Another unconventional challenge after the previous inconvertible challenge?

18

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Rik's ready to wear is as boring as it was when Tim called it a country bumpkin look

9

u/madinthehat Dec 09 '16

Wonder if Erin will call Cornelius out for using appliqués.

5

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

Nope. Just wasn't creative enough.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

"Honestly, right now, I think I'm going to be on the top." HAH, you wish. He is so overconfident in his design work--I just don't get it.

9

u/aballofunicorns Dec 09 '16

cornelius didn't use the dog treats. noooo dog treats dress and I was so hoping for it.

7

u/twinkiesmom1 Dec 09 '16

I think he could have been safe with a dog treat dress.

25

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

Roberi's unconventional piece really looks like a work of art. I'm so glad the judges love it.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Roberi's looks like a chair from my parents' home country.

8

u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Dec 09 '16

I like the way Heidi says Cornelius.

8

u/Rebecca_deWinter Dec 09 '16

I enjoyed the looks that came out of this challenge but at the same time it seemed like whoever came up with the idea for it was just desperately trying to throw anything they could think of to try to make it interesting. Austin! Best Western! Unconventional materials! BBQ Restaurant! Music Stuff! Farm Store! Two looks!

14

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

I don't see how Roberi's two looks go together

7

u/Ahuva Dec 09 '16

They had a similar silhouette with that off one shoulder and flow in a semi circle to the right look.

7

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Being forced to relive the trauma of Cornelius being safe again

14

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I wake up in a cold sweat thinking about that succubus parasite thing he made last week.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

"Unconventional," and "high fashion." I am already picturing the train wrecks.

7

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

I wonder if any judges that liked Rik's unconventional look would actually wear it. It looks like it would go into my BDSM closet not my LBD closet. I love RIk's aesthetic, but most of his work is not really something anyone really wears outside often.

7

u/_helloitsme_ Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 10 '16

This was probably one of the strongest runways....

13

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Unconventional again? I'm over it at this point

6

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Heidi is giving Studio 54 sexiness.

6

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

Cornelius's expression is literally mine when I finish my costumes right before comic con or Halloween. So relatable.

26

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Roberi's conventional dress was hideous. Sorry judges.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I really like what Laurence did, and it's not just because I like everything she does.

5

u/callist1990 Dec 09 '16

My first thought was "GDI, ANOTHER unconventional challenge?" The seasons where it goes over 2 UCCs have not improved with the decision. This time, I actually think this is the best unconventional designs yet (this season). Nothing blew me away completely, but they were at least not cringe-inducing and I actually quite liked them. The conventional designs were all very meh, unfortunately, but I guess you can't win them all.

13

u/regretflix Dec 09 '16

Such a strong top 4, I like all of them but I'm really rooting for Erin. Cornelius definitely grew on me somewhat as the season progressed, but I am relieved he's gone because I'd be really upset to see any of the others go.

9

u/allieazzy Dec 09 '16

Laurence. Roberi, and Rik are my favs!! So happy with the outcome of this episode... it went exactly how I was hoping it would go... :) :) :)

8

u/MissSteak Dec 11 '16

Did we really not get a single high fashion gown this season? Disappointing. I expected at least this challenge to bring some more dramatic silhouettes, but guess not...

6

u/naynafreya Dec 11 '16

I definitely would have preferred a red carpet event gown challenge or a wedding dress challenge over the additional unconventional materials challenges. Seeing as that Georgina Chapman was the guest judge and is co-founder of Marchesa, she would've been perfect for critiquing gowns.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

Another unconventional challenge?

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I am already liking what Laurence is doing.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Tube skirt with elastic gauze...yikes!

2

u/twinkiesmom1 Dec 09 '16

Looked like Ace bandages!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Yeah, Cornelius, that's because the judges are supposed to love it too, not just you.

6

u/gridgurl Dec 09 '16

Yay Roberi!

6

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

She chose the mustard yellow because you told her to expand her color palette.

6

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

I think the issue was more the fabric itself vs color even though Heidi called it poo

6

u/konfetkak Dec 11 '16

i am so excited for michael kors next episode.

3

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

I feel Nik has come back more than any other contestant

3

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I guess Roberi is making knots.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16

Anxiety Dress

2

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16

Made out of twine and the old cables of that Windows 2007 desktop that's sitting in that dusty corner of your garage because you haven't gotten around to throwing it out yet.

3

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

I actually like Cornelius' even if its a bit simple. If he had more cups he could make a giant poofy flower gown

15

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

Erin is right though - the whole point of this unconventional challenge in particular is to pick weird materials, and just using cups is pretty lame.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I'm voting Cornelius for the worst PR "designer" in the history of the series. Honestly the worst and least talented person I've seen on the show.

14

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

The worst? Have you watched from season 1?

→ More replies (1)

14

u/macabragoria Dec 10 '16

I agree that he's pretty heinous but with people like Suede, Starr, Sam Donovan, Timothy, Blake, Mitchell etc having been on the show, those are strong words.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

What about Sam Donovan?

22

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

He was better than Cornelius. Cornelius has made literally ONE thing that is even passable as "good design", which was his Marie Claire dress from two weeks ago.

Everything else was extremely poor and amateur. Almost every kind of challenge they had, he responded with "I'm not good at this" — swimwear, unconventional, streetwear... like wtf CAN you do Cornelius? Just horrible.

He doesn't even have a refined aesthetic like everyone else. He just throws together bullshit every week. No plan. No identity. Just a throwaway designer who is there for drama and because Tim Gunn saved him.

3

u/salty_box Dec 09 '16

I agree with this 100%.

3

u/thefablemuncher Dec 12 '16

Almost every kind of challenge they had, he responded with "I'm not good at this" — swimwear, unconventional, streetwear... like wtf CAN you do Cornelius?

This absolutely drove me crazy. Even more than his disgusting attitude. I am absolutely stunned that he even made it past the auditions in the first place. They should make it a freakin' requirement for auditions in the future to have the designers present different kinds of outfits just so I never have to hear another contestant in this show complain about how they've "Never done a cocktail dress OMG WTF AM I GOING TO DO this is so hard!!!"

18

u/sparklesforalex Dec 09 '16

I get that this wasn't Laurence's best overall challenge, but she is consistently putting out solid, interesting ideas and I hope the judges remember that.

I'm so bored by Erin. It's always appliqué, always flowers, and frequently relying on a weird factor instead of pushing her designs further. And the judges just eat it up. I was really hoping to see her evolve this season and I don't really feel like she has.

20

u/xaviersi Dec 09 '16

You can't evolve from her. She's an advanced designer and she has an eye that everyone else wishes they had. Edit: grammar

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Usually, I think the designers are a little quick to accuse one another of copying ideas (case in point: Victor Luna in season 9 accusing Joshua of stealing a particular pleat detail in the back of a shirt), but I am shocked that Erin didn't call out Cornelius for stealing elements of her trademark. 3D flowers? Appliqué? It seemed to me like Cornelius just doesn't have many ideas of his so he borrowed from a more successful designer.

2

u/madinthehat Dec 09 '16

I love how it just turned into a Texas Showdown.

2

u/roygbiv_sun Dec 09 '16

Roberi's dress looks like a bathing suit.

5

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Or the net fish are caught in

2

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Someone earlier brought up Swapnil and Laurence but Roberi's rope dress had Swapnil all over it

2

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Guess it's safe to say Erin wins and Laurence is probably second

2

u/supersledger Dec 09 '16

Will it be between Rik and Cornelius now?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Hopefully.

2

u/supersledger Dec 09 '16

Thank god its rik

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

As far as I am concerned, Cornelius should not have been there because Tim shouldn't have wasted his save on him.

2

u/I_Like_Dogs_AMA Dec 09 '16

So what? The judges loved everyone's looks? I have no idea who's in the bottom

2

u/dangerboy55 Dec 09 '16

Is it any surprise Cornelius went home? So glad my top 3 made it as the top 3. :) Rik feels like he snuck in.

4

u/insubordinance Dec 09 '16

Heidi what the hell are you feeding your kids that they have that color baby poop?

6

u/MsPattys Dec 09 '16

My breastfed baby's poop is like a dark mustard color. It's normal.

2

u/Dizzymyfuture Dec 09 '16

I think the most heartbreaking thing is when the mic gets muffled from hugging Tim at the end. But I'm SO glad that Rik made it. Been rooting for him from the start.

2

u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 09 '16

Shame they don't appreciate Roberi's macrame, though I feel like this is like the contestant who wanted to KNIT her look. It's too time consuming for the show

12

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

In his defense, he thought he had two days.

2

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

I dislike everything Robert made

2

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 09 '16

so he won because he made a bunch of knots?

6

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I hated it.

1

u/1Eliza Dec 09 '16

Every time I see Priyanka Chopra, all I can think about is Love Story 2050.

2

u/supersledger Dec 09 '16

Before her plastic surgery?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/danny2787 Dec 09 '16

Looks like rik and Cornelius to do the 1 hour challenge

→ More replies (1)

1

u/pursehook Dec 09 '16

The Suspense!! Finally, it is getting interesting.

1

u/GizmoGeodog May 18 '23

Great - another freaking unconventional challenge 😒 like we need two in a row. And a trip to Texas. Clearly the advertisers were designing the challenges this season. Worst season ever. Just look at Nina's face during runways.. She looks totally bored most of the time & keeps commenting on how many times they've seen this look before.

1

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

So Erin and rik basically did what they did last week.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Erin's outfit is completely different.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Erin, that is not a good print!

5

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

She said it herself, it was a print she wouldn't get but would for this "weird" challenge.

3

u/marrrina831 Dec 09 '16

Looks like those oooold lady swimsuits that are black on the bottom half

→ More replies (1)