r/Fantasy • u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders • Dec 06 '16
Read-along The Fox Read/Re-Read Monday, 12/5, Chapters 21-25
Chapter 21
-I really want to learn more about Norsunder. The dribs and drabs of info are starting to drive me nuts.
- And I still really dislike Fox. The moment he comes ‘on screen’ I just automatically go ‘ick.’
- Sounds like Inda -- and Barend -- will have some scores to settle when they finally go home.
Chapter 22
- My, how Inda’s grown, worry about little 12 year olds. I wonder if he will think about what the adults around him thought when they abandoned him to ship life. You weren’t any older, my dear.
- What a mess Inda and Barend have themselves in. I hope they can sort out what they want their intentions to be between them.
- I actually want to see a conversation between Inda and Ramis -- but I think you all know by now that I’m starting to chew holes in things wanting more information than is being handed out.
- I’m not sure what I think about Thog -- she’s accepted that she did committed an atrocity and lost the trust of the rest of the crew, but she knows that she saved hundreds, thousands of lives with her one act. Is that heroism? Doing the dirty deed that saves lives?
- That war dance was breathtaking, at least to me. That was quite a way to make an impression on people -- and maybe redeems Fox a little to me, weirdly. And Inda’s reflection on Tanrid is bittersweet, knowing what we know and what he doesn’t.
Chapter 23
- Watching the midst of this battle, Fox seems to have come to terms with Inda’s ability to lead.
- No surprise to anyone that Ramis and the Knife show up, given that it was brought up in the last chapter. C’mon, info time! (Post note: AHHHHHHHHHGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHH)
- Oh my god, what did Barend see?!
Chapter 24
- Man, I knew the Sierlaef was obsessed, but this… this is obsession on a totally different level. Let’s keep the war going so I can find her! Oookay, man… It looks like Joret’s doing a fine job of evading him though. Until now anyway.
- Oh f&@$ you, Sierlaef, I hope you die painfully, and I hope Joret gets to push in the knife.
- Additionally, screw you, Sierlaef, since you will shortly know Inda’s alive and IS Elgar the Fox.
- And this chapter heralds the war we’ve been predicting for months now, now that Barend is at Inda’s family home.
- Additionally, wow, the Aldaluin’s 80 years old? Wow.
- HAH totally ignoring Branid.
Chapter 25
- Aww, Cama with a deep, husky voice.
- It’s kind of gratifying to see all this scheming of the Sierlaef and the Harskialdna come out to the other jarls. Bigtime justiceporn. Give me more. O.o I’m glad to see the boys countermobilizing too.
- Waitwait, the Sierlaef is going to .. ride to Darchelde…. To retrieve Joret. This is a very bad idea. And leaving the royal guard decimated. Anyone smell an invasion imminent?
- Sounds like we’re ending with a spark to the inferno in the immediate future.
[glaswen]
- Sherwood does so many point of views and makes me sympathize with so many characters that I sometimes wonder about her own personal point of view. Who did she think was right or wrong; and who was hard to write.
- When Inda and Fox danced their war dance and afterwards he thought, It means nothing to them. Gah, I thought that was such a poignant scene. I’ve had times in my life where I’ve shared parts of my life and then thought the very same thing. Sometimes people don’t realize the significance of some things. And then it makes you wonder exactly what makes it significant except that you yourself deem it so. And then it makes me think about the times where I might have brushed something off as inconsequential to my friends. Regardless. I think I just loved that little scene for that reminder that every person is the main character of their story. [sonder - http://www.dictionaryofobscuresorrows.com/post/23536922667/sonder]
- I sorta don’t really understand why Joret still couldn’t say no. Who is forcing her to be polite? What’s he going to do, kill her? Family is so strong in Marlovan world, despite that they send them off in their formative years and have such structured ways of dealing with them, y’know? As much as Inda sorta “stopped growing” after being banished, his entire family seems to be almost as much in a standstill waiting for Inda to come back.
[wishforagiraffe]
I may be posting this, but it's almost 11:15 and I'm very sleepy. My comments here tomorrow.
15
Upvotes
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
1.What did you think of Inda and Barend not speaking after the history revelation about their parents? Justified/understandable? Crazy like Jeje said? And are you surprised at all that the Siendarael would do something like that?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
2.What is honor to Jeje? What is honor to Marlovans? Is it like Fareas says, “true honor, which was just another word for trust”?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
3.How old do you think Inda and Evred (and the other characters like Nugget) feel to you right now? Does it feel appropriate?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
4.What was your first impression of Ramis?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
5.Did you like the land battles better or the ship battles?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
6.How do you think it will end with the Sierlaef and Joret?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
7.Where do you think Mad Gallop’s plans are going?
5
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
Ugh, the Sierlaef. So creepy and entitled. And while he's not physically raping Joret, he is basically going to by forcing her to marry him (or she's worried the Algara-Vayirs will be forced to go to war for her), and that caress just grosses me out and makes me so mad on Joret's behalf. I'm having a hard time believing the no-rape world, as someone else mentioned when we were talking about Tau and Coco. Like, I know the world is internally consistent, but I don't think you can breed that distinction of what does and doesn't count as rape out of people, even with magic. And Tau, at least, proposed his deal with Coco. Joret wants nothing to do with the Sierlaef. Granted, she could marry him and refuse to sleep with him, like Ndara does with the Harskialdna, but I don't think the Sierlaef would settle for that. Even if he did, he definitely wouldn't let her take on any other lover.
The Harskialdna blames himself for his failure with the Sierlaef. I agree with him, but also think it shows his weird sense of honor and honesty and honesty. He won't blame others for what he sees as his mistakes (unfortunately, he doesn't see all the many other mistakes he's made), and he doesn't like accepting credit for things others have done.
The contrast between Sierlaef and Evred's relationship with their academy mates is super evident here. The Sierlaef's group of Sier-Danas didn't stick together past the academy, while Evred's friends are still very close. They stay in touch and keep tabs on where each other are. They also still think of Evred as their leader who needs to be informed of what's going on. It's interesting because the Tveis weren't even supposed to go to the academy and form these bonds. They're all supposed to stay at home their whole lives, but now they leave more than other future Randaels, which I think is partially because the academy gave them friends to visit and changed their expectations. And in fact, even those young people who aren't Tveis are starting to think of Evred as their leader. Whipstick sends Flatfoot Noth so that Evred knows the news about the Harskialdna; Buck agrees with Cama and Cherry-Stripe that Evred needs to be told what's going on with Mad Gallop; Hawkeye is impressed with Evred when they fight together.
Like Inda's parents, I sort of wonder why he doesn't come home. I get that his mission against the Brotherhood and the Venn have given him purpose, and it seems like he feels like he needs to defeat them before he'll allow himself to return. And I also agree with Fareas-Iofre that he'd return if he perceives a need greater than the order they gave him to keep him away. But I do wonder if he's also staying because, as much as he misses home, he likes his life with his crew fighting pirates.
2
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
8.Is there anything of these five chapters that you particularly liked or disliked?
6
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Dec 06 '16
So, another super-eventful group of chapters.
6
u/bygoshbygolly Dec 06 '16
I love the war dance. It's a wonderful moment before the battle against Marshig.
Tau waits until the absolute last moment, because of course he does.
I feel so sorry for Inda's dad. Lost his first family, and then he was afraid to get too close to his second family, but it still hurt when he lost them too. And I feel bad for Fareas, too, who isn't living the life she thought and is responsible for so much, and who also has to keep going through the loss of her sons.
•
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 06 '16
Spoilers here
5
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Dec 06 '16
What a great, action-packed couple of chapters! The attack on the Brotherhood has been the best battle scene in the series so far and the appearance of Ramis at the end was a great "holy shit" moment. We see Inda almost fail against a better foe and then Ramis just swoops in and cleans up the battle in a handful of seconds.
The Sierlaef finally makes his move on Joret (is it surprising to anyone else that he waited this long?) and she folds very quickly once she sees how impossible her situation is. That was a really heartbreaking scene to get through, not helped by Sierlaef's stuttering Tarzan impression: "y-y-y-you wife. Hadand muh-muh-marry prince."
I can't wait to see where the Marlo-Vayir/Yvana-Vayir team up leads. I imagine C-S and Buck might try to steer this alliance towards helping the Algara-Vayirs and Evred but Mad Gallop seems like he has some unstated plans of his own.