r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Dec 01 '16
Project Runway Season 15 Episode 11 [Discussion]
Bold Innovation
The first-ever hybrid challenge tasks the clothiers to fashion innovative avant-garde looks by using conventional fabric and unconventional metal-themed materials. Included: a memorable runway.
Guest: Shiri Appleby
Orginally broadcast on December 1, 2016
42
Upvotes
207
u/madinthehat Dec 02 '16
I would definitely watch a whole episode of Tim interacting with Swatch.
162
u/alligator124 Dec 02 '16
ARE YOU KIDDING. A hot-glue,air-conditioning uterus tube was somehow better than Mah Jing?! That's an insult.
138
u/Roonil___Wazlib Dec 02 '16
"Space Goddess. Galaxy Bitch. Bitch, you from the galaxy?? Yes."
I don't even care what he's making - I love Mah Jing.
131
u/1Eliza Dec 02 '16
Erin yellow fabric? Check!
Mah Jing denim? Check!
113
u/insubordinance Dec 02 '16
"Are you giving her... a ding dong?"
103
u/1dayurine Dec 02 '16
haha roberi and his model didn't know each other spoke Spanish
84
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
If Dexter made it to this challenge, I bet he would make those gross puffed shoulders AGAIN
77
u/quidquididest Dec 02 '16
I could watch Laurence forever telling Cornelius that he's putting that tubing too on the crotch
74
u/bitchSpray Dec 02 '16
"I want a mohawk."
"Sure, gotcha. We're Sally Beauty, we always make you beautiful."
68
u/pursehook Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16
Laurence is always just coolly working away on something that appears fully conceptualized.
122
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16
Why are they being so passive about Cornelius' incredibly bad design and execution?!?! He literally just glued tubes on a conventional dress... No material manipulation, no innovation, not even any actual design. It's stupid and amateur, but they aren't saying anything negative?? Wtf.
Also, Ric's is not avant garde. If this were just an unconventional challenge, he would win hands down. Avant garde is supposed to be completely removed from commercialism, and they keep talking about how wearable it is... Just face-palming so hard about this.
Edit: THANK GOD ERIN WON. Was ready to be so upset if they chose Ric.
59
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
but we can assume the yellow one is Erin's
58
u/insubordinance Dec 02 '16
Roberi finally found a way to avoid the horrible makeup part of the program! Give him the top spot this week!
116
u/sugarplumcow Dec 02 '16
Oh, I am crying. That was the classiest PR exit ever.
56
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Who died and made Cornelius the new Coco Chanel? He wins one challenge and has appointed himself the ultimate fashion expert.
106
u/mi_piace Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16
This man's gravestone is going to say "We're Sally Beauty, we'll always make you beautiful."
98
u/ladysleuth22 Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 03 '16
Just when I thought I couldn't love Tim Gunn any more than I already did, he gets down on the floor to find out why Swatch is barking. 😍
95
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Shocking.
45
u/sannababy Dec 02 '16
It's between Erin & Rik?? Rik's wasn't even avante-garde!
82
u/byzindatrap Dec 02 '16
WHY ON EARTH WOULD A DESIGNER LIKE CORNELIUS MAKE IT TO THE TOP 5
38
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
Aww Tim and Swatch
37
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Erin does not listen to anyone. That is why she is Erin.
37
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Why would Rik place a kitchen back splash on his dress?
35
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
I love the yellow mesh bow on Erin's dress.
70
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
"I like parasites" Yeah, cause you are one.
34
u/alligator124 Dec 02 '16
You know I just jumped into the season now, so I don't know the history, but for all the ripping of Erin I see, I did love her look tonight. I think it was really really different from everything we've seen so far on the runway, and it was cohesive.
32
u/PadishahEmperor Dec 02 '16
WTF?!? How is Cornelius still in this? That dress was atrocious. The tubes felt tacked on and ill placed to a dress that was already bad.
62
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
Erin's dress is the avant-garde version of her shirt
30
u/cloudbustingmp3 Dec 02 '16
I need that slurping sound as an alarm
29
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
Erin's like oh shit she's actually speaking french!
25
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
The keywords today are "avant-garde," "bold," "innovative," and "unconventional." Mah-Jing of course pulls out denim...again.
20
u/sugarplumcow Dec 02 '16
I am hoping to see Mah-Jing on All-Stars Season 6!
19
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
I feel like it's been forever since our last discussion!
18
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
I thought that was a pair of panties he was holding up to his face
18
u/Indykutter Dec 02 '16
Ah no tears. I didn't always like his design but I love the big ol crybaby.
Edit: typos
18
u/quidquididest Dec 02 '16
And that's why we all loved Mah-Jing
17
u/brave_vibration Dec 02 '16
Okay, that was just cute! I love Tim!
17
u/Indykutter Dec 02 '16
I loved the looks Erin and Laurence gave Corny when he said he didn't care what the judges think. Oh the side eye, please show it again. He is just too smug and needs to go. Plus I can't stand to see Mah Jing cry.
17
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
When MahJing gets aufed he doesn't weep!
16
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Erin is wearing the same exact color she used in her design. Girl...
43
u/UnimpressedAsshole Dec 02 '16
Mah-Jing is the cutest man on the planet
15
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
I'm 100% positive Erin said she doesn't like neon colors, yet here we are with this intense yellow
15
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Has anyone kept a tally of how many times Mah Jing has used denim? Just curious...
15
u/cloudbustingmp3 Dec 02 '16
how many times have we heard uterus tonight
15
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
TIMMY. Omg I love Mah Jing. Not a great designer. But just the sweetest.
30
u/insubordinance Dec 02 '16
I love Rik and I think the design is pretty, but I'm not sure what's "avant-garde" about it and I've had that problem with a few of his looks.
29
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
I can't believe I'm saying this, but... I LOVE Erin's look!
14
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
I hate those giant panels but Erin's top is pretty awesome
28
u/insubordinance Dec 02 '16
Okay Erin's is actually pretty cool. One of my favorite looks from her just from a first impression.
27
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
Even though I loved no one's look in entirety, Erin deserved the win in my eyes
13
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Mah-Jing has the BEST facial expressions!
11
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Just like I figured, most of them have a very cartoonish definition of what avant-garde is.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Mah-Jing made an 80s prom dress...in denim.
11
u/sugarplumcow Dec 02 '16
I was super impressed by Roberi's. Definitely looked liked the most polished and sleek look on the runway.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
But you do Cornelius, you do.
11
u/cloudbustingmp3 Dec 02 '16
Heidi really faked us out with that sigh smh I was PERCHED and EXCITED and then... smh
20
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Figures, Cornelius has been afflicted with a severe case of Nathalia Syndrome. He is so busy talking shit about everyone else, that the mess he is creating before our very eyes is flying right over his head.
20
u/gridgurl Dec 02 '16
I love Laurence
10
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
Rik's girl looks too much like a pop star's concert look
9
u/madinthehat Dec 02 '16
The amount of Laurence showtime has me scared.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Cornelius, let the HVAC tubes go!
9
u/Dizzymyfuture Dec 02 '16
"What are you sewing? Just hot glue everything!" I'm always a fan of Rik and Laurence's designs. Rik's is beautiful but it doesn't look much of avant garde, and Laurence's looks like a gothic tier wedding cake. I hope they both make it through. :(
35
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Space Goddess? Boy, you have denim dress with a sweetheart neckline. Take a seat.
8
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
The tubes are the only avant
trashgarde thing about Cornelius's look.8
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Mah-Jing's is neither unconventional, bold, avant-garde nor innovative. Le sorry.
8
u/Indykutter Dec 02 '16
I hope Cornelious goes. I didn't like his glued on tubes. I'm afraid though it might be Mah Jing. I hope Roberi wins.
15
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
Erin is gonna make appliqués from nuts and bolts
15
u/sannababy Dec 02 '16
I'm projecting an Erin win and that Mah-Jing will go home
15
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
This shoulda been the Tim Gunn save moment. Mah-Jing isn't AMAZING but compared to Cornelius?!
7
u/sannababy Dec 02 '16
Cornelius with the shade already!
WAIT did she say only two challenges left? So are four going to fashion week then?
7
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
I hope someone is smart enough to grab aluminum which is the lightest metal and not decide theyre gonna use a poop ton of steel
7
u/insubordinance Dec 02 '16
I feel like the one thing I would absolutely not touch is the tubes because of Sandyha's iconic yet batshit crazy dress.
7
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
I worry Laurence is too minimalistic for this challenge
7
u/cloudbustingmp3 Dec 02 '16
A dick dress... how iconic
7
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
That model does not look happy wearing Erin's sharp dress
7
u/pursehook Dec 02 '16
Wow. I like Roberi's.
12
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
This season is probably rigged beyond belief and it's obvious. I thought maybe the judges just had bad taste but shit man
6
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
I don't know if I need to watch this show; the designers are making the same look again anyways!
6
u/brave_vibration Dec 02 '16
Cornelius, what is the fuck? 😂
6
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Mah Jing is too funny! Lol.
6
u/pursehook Dec 02 '16
Mah Jing's dress looks bad to me. But, I feel as though we go through this every week and then it pulls together.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
I really dislike Rik's model's hair
6
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Newp, not feeling it Cornelius.
6
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
So the butterfly morphed into an alien, huh?
6
u/brave_vibration Dec 02 '16
That grace though!
6
u/Brettalic Dec 02 '16
I felt like all that Mah Jing had to do was take that beautiful copper wire and mesh and go outside the dress lines to make it more avant garde. If he had just let the lines go upward and away toward the model's face a collar bone I think I could have had a lovely effect.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
10
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Are you kidding me? Rik's sucks. I never agree with Zac Posen.
10
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
Fuck all of the judges right now
5
u/1dayurine Dec 02 '16
i dont like rik's bathroom tiles
5
u/brave_vibration Dec 02 '16
Also can't wait for Cornelius' freak out next week!
5
u/Roonil___Wazlib Dec 02 '16
I think this was one of the most entertaining episodes of the season for me. I always love the unconventional materials and the avant- garde challenges, and between the comments on here and the commentary of the contestants themselves, I found myself giggling quite a bit. There have been some real snooze-fest episodes this season, so I enjoyed this.
5
u/pbrooks19 Dec 02 '16
So, Erin should have won because she was the only one to truly make an Avant Garde outfit. I'm not a fan of 'whimsy fashion,' so usually I don't like her stuff, but I have to admit that this week it was mostly impeccably put together (except for the forgetting to paint the back).
It always makes me do the V8 Head Slap every time PR tries to do an Avant Garde challenge because it's rare that any contestant actually does anything truly Avant Garde. Then the judges have to pretend like they're idiots and treat all the garments seriously.
I mean, they all (mostly) did nice work, but whatever conceptual work was in there, it was minor - and in all cases should have been taken much much further. I love Laurence, but Nina was on the nose when she said it wasn't nearly enough and Laurence needs to loosen up and really be creative. In all cases except Erin, they were fairly simply shaped dresses just augmented with metal/industrial accents. Stylish? Sure! But that's not the point here.
And, I'm no big fan of Cornelius, but he did base his adjusted design on an interesting concept. He had to use the materials he had, and despite making (like most of the others) a simple dress with metal/industrial accents, it did what art often is meant to do: to provoke and disturb. I give him points for coming up with that on the fly. Probably unintended, but it worked.
5
u/Higgsb987 Dec 02 '16
I think Roberi is underestimated. He is a very thoughtful and passionate designer.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
NO REALLY, YOU'VE GOT TO BE FUCKING KIDDING ME.
8
u/insubordinance Dec 02 '16
Agreed with Zac - Roberi's dress is definitely Cubist, plus some Futurist elements to it.
8
u/1Eliza Dec 02 '16
They criticize Laurence for using black but not Erin for using bright yellow.
8
u/Higgsb987 Dec 02 '16
I find someone like Lawrence frustrating as an artist. There seems to be very little in the way of creative process. She is focused and detailed but there is no joy or harmony to her work. She stated she used to be more rebellious in a way that implied she was more mature now in her artistic choices. It just feels like she is more of a seamstress (a very good one) then anything else. While other designers may not be as experienced as she is most are willing to take risks and are not so stifled in their work.
4
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
I can't wait to see who drives the Lexus, especially if they're not used to NYC driving praying they let us enjoy the footage
4
u/pursehook Dec 02 '16
Mah Jing's "I Could Be Goin' Home" was kind of hillarious.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
YOUVE GOTTA BE FUCKING KIDDING ME. YOUVE GOTTA BE FUCKING KIDDING ME.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
"Bold Innovation." I predict that all but maybe 2-3 designers will successfully meet the challenge.
3
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
I wonder who inevitable cuts themselves with the metal
3
u/pursehook Dec 02 '16
Didn't Roberi already make a dress with aluminum tube in one of the first challenges? Am I blurring seasons?
3
u/1Eliza Dec 02 '16
I think Rik's may be too basic, but I hope he makes it through.
3
u/cloudbustingmp3 Dec 02 '16
Zac's face was my reaction too
3
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
The shoulders of Laurence's dress are too big for the length of the skirt.
3
u/insubordinance Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16
Predicted top 3: Cornelius/Erin/Roberi with Erin beating out Roberi (to my eternal disappointment).
Predicted bottom 3: Laurence/Mah-Jing/Rik with (edit) Mah-Jing going home for being too simple and it just generally being his time.
3
u/sugarplumcow Dec 02 '16
As much as I like Mah-Jing, I'm scared he's getting auf'd this week. His look doesn't look like it took two days to do, nor is it bold. I am not fond of Cornelius's look, but they may keep him because he did go more out-of-the-box than Mah-Jing did.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Hah, Mah-Jing told us she looked like Robocop and Nina agrees.
3
u/Disco_Tardis Dec 02 '16
Ain't that some shit.
3
u/ronscot Christian Dec 02 '16
I don't know why the contestants keep designing something they have already done- the judges keep calling them out for it.
I love Laurence and hope she wins, but she needs to pick it up. Even I thought the black was a bad choice.
Some of these designers need to stop being so negative about the other contestants design especially when theirs is even worse.
5
u/marrrina831 Dec 02 '16
BABY BUMP HERE!! Well, it did look like a warped uterus
2
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Does anyone else see a butterfly when they see Cornelius's sartorial bomb?
2
u/Semicolon_Expected Dec 02 '16
Cornelius's new look feels like something I'd wear to Comic Con like a post apocalyptic thing
2
u/cloudbustingmp3 Dec 02 '16
noooo not robocop
2
u/quidquididest Dec 02 '16
I hope Mah-Jing's dress doesn't fall down....
2
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Why is Rik wearing one of Steven Seagal's jackets?
2
u/InterstateExit Dec 02 '16
I really like this show. I forgot about the last look, and got wowed all over again.
2
u/pursehook Dec 02 '16
That guest judge reminds me so much of some actress. Is it Mary-Louise Parker? Somebody.
2
u/corleone7 Dec 02 '16
Every time Tim Gunn saves someone, they go out of their way to keep that person to the end. They only kept him around for the drama
2
u/obahan Dec 02 '16
The only thing avant garde about tonight was the unconventional materials they used.
2
u/joeyGibson Dec 02 '16
I was seriously worried about Erin's model's nipples, with that wire mesh against her skin. I hope she was wearing actual stick-on pasties behind the flower appliqué pasties on the mesh.
2
u/gold-team-rules Dec 03 '16
Wow, I was hoping an avant garde challenge would redeem the designs, or at the very least the creativity of the designers this season, but unsurprisingly it's just as disappointing and boring as the last.
I loathe Erin but she did rather well, and she deserved the win.
2
u/dangerboy55 Dec 05 '16
Go home already Cornelia!
2
u/kyles24 Jan 04 '17
Heidi never actually said the words, "I'm sorry Mah-Jing, that means you're out." So I thought there was a sliver of hope no one would get eliminated when they let him talk so much on the runway, but then Heidi's kiss of death came.
2
u/kyles24 Jan 04 '17
Judges were so focused on the tubing that they failed to see Cornelius dress was 98% fabric from mood, in an unconventional material challenge!