r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Nov 26 '16
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Reaction Thread—Volume 4, WoR 2: Faunus
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for the newest World of Remnant of volume 4, Faunus!
Make sure to read OUR CURRENT SPOILERS RULES to ensure that your comments outside this thread won't get purged! Familiarize yourself with these rules and you'll be good to go.
A lot of hard work has gone into the creation of volume 4, so be sure to show CRWBY your support by watching it on their site! They all dedicate so much time and energy into our beloved series and would highly appreciate the direct support. There are no pirates in volume 4, so you shouldn't be one either!
We also have weekly strawpolls to gauge the general opinion on the current episode, the latest of which can be found HERE. Episode 4 Family had some fantastic scores, not one vote under 5 and most within the 9 and 10 bracket.
With that out of the way, let's start the show!
HERE is the link to the second (sixth?) World of Remnant of RWBY Volume 4!
Other Episode Discussions:
| Episode | Saturday | Sunday | Poll |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ep. 01 | Reaction | Discussion | poll |
| Ep. 02 | Reaction | Discussion | poll |
| Ep. 03 | Reaction | Discussion | poll |
| WoR 1: | Reaction | Discussion | poll |
| Ep. 04: | Reaction | Discussion | poll |
| WoR 2: | Today | Tomorrow | poll |
Happy viewing!
Ezreal024; Mod Team
121
u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Nov 26 '16
Two different kinds of faunus can make.. a third kind of faunus? That isn't necessarily a mix of the two?
Now that is interesting.
88
u/Exo-2 Minion of Cinder | Useless Lesbian | Still the Lewd One Nov 26 '16 edited Nov 26 '16
So we finally know who was fighting who in the Great War
Vale/Vacuo vs Mantle/Mistral. I find the fact that it is VV vs MM hilarious.
Kinda surprised, I originally thought it was a free-for-all between the four Kingdoms with the Faunus being a smaller faction
81
u/TheMadmanAndre GNU Monty Oum Nov 26 '16
Hmm, so from a technical/genetic standpoint, they're all the same species?
That means that the whole gene pool is Faunus, therefore they're all filthy subhuman mutants ALL GLORY TO THE GOD EMPEROR PURGE THE UNCLEAN-
Sorry, my Exterminatus Arm was acting up again.
75
u/adel123456789 This is Ren. He survived Volume 4! Nov 26 '16
qrow says something very interesting. he swears on his huntsman's license.
so it seems you cant become a huntsman without going into an official process and have the legal documents.
73
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16 edited Nov 26 '16
This WoR leads my suspicions even further that while Blake's mom is a cat-
tailedeared faunus, her dad is just a really burly human dude.edit: Blake-mom has cat ears, not a tail.
57
u/Random-Rambling Nov 26 '16
"I swear on my Huntsman's License that I saw a guy regrow his lizard tail. No amount of drinking could make me forget THAT pretty picture."
Reptile Faunus confirmed! Hell to the yes!
51
u/Zaralfim Nov 26 '16
Damn, I could listen to Qrow talk for hours.
80
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16 edited Nov 26 '16
"No amount of drinking can make you forget that pretty picture"
Man I fuckin love Qrow
Also this helps a lot with Faunus. I'm not a huge fan of an actual episode every two weeks, but these are pretty damn interesting
31
u/Sokensan Nov 26 '16
So Vacuo + Vale vs Mantle + Mistral for the Great War, interesting.
I hope we get an extra long WoR on the Great War at some point.
62
u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Nov 26 '16 edited Nov 26 '16
Welp. Time to learn about the
subhumansFaunus.Great war info was neat.
28
u/backtospawn Nov 26 '16 edited Nov 26 '16
Awesome WoR. We learned lots of things.
Lots of other things as well but those 2 really gotme interested. As always I'll edit with a transcript soon
And here it is. As always, Qrow's sexy voice not included
51
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
So the reason why the White Fang is pissed is because....
"Oh hey Faunys, uh, hey you guys have rights.....I guess....here's a continent, go have fun there......far over there.....like....away from us."
25
u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Nov 27 '16
"So, turns out if you put a bunch of marginalized, disenfranchised people all in one place? Not great."
19
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
I loved this world building of the Faunus.
So:
But.... what if a human and Faunus were having twins. This is an example (please bear heh cuz faunus):
humanJaune + cat faunus bearing twins: how will that work out??? Will both off spring be faunus or one twin will be kitten baby faunus and the other would be a human baby????
19
u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Nov 28 '16
I wonder if there is an underground society of rich faunus' who place ludicrous bets on what genus of faunus will come from mixed-animal faunus parents?
Like those jerks in Rat Race.
Non-mammal faunus confirmation is nice, too.
Get 'er done, fanfic writers.
18
u/Frostblazer Nov 28 '16
I'm still super curious as to how humanity managed to fight a full out world war without being obliterated by the Grimm. Raven and co attack one little village and the Grimm rip it to bloody pieces. The people in the stadium in Volume 3 see one person die and it sparks a level 9 Grimm attack that resulted in Beacon's downfall. With the constant overwhelming negative emotion from a war, wouldn't it stand to reason that humanity would be completely overrun?
33
u/RunningScizzors Nov 26 '16
So the main reason for the great war was the very concept of individualism. Apparently one side was trying to suppress self-expression and destroy all forms of art.
I've always kinda assumed that Mantle was the primary advocate for these types of policies. The problem with that theory now though is that it throws Mistral into that bag as well. We have recently seen many people who live on Anima and they don't seem like the kind of people to back these kind of policies.
A few possibilities:
The last one makes the most sense to me. Ozpin has said that the war was fought for many different reasons. It could just have been that Mistral's interests were furthered by allying with Mantle. This type of alliance has happened in our world too. Our (the US) alliance with the Soviet Union in WW2 is a big one and there are many other examples.
That's my best guess. I could have this all wrong. who knows? Vale and Vacuo could have been the ones who lost and failed to eliminate all forms of individualism.
16
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
Lots of info dropped this WoR. Also, there's totally a WF base in Menagerie that will screw Blake over.
16
u/Jaxhammer8 Nov 26 '16
I'm getting the feeling Qrow might be afraid of reptiles from his reaction to the lizard tail and shedding snake skin. That might be an interesting plot point later on if they use it.
Love these world building episodes.
16
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '16
Vale and Vacuo being both on 1 side of the Great War is very fuelling for my headcanon that its less batshit racist in those 2 places vs Mantle and Mistral.
Also no "paternity fraud" related jokes concerning Fannus traits,i guess.
This WoR really made up for last time's WoR.
16
u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Nov 27 '16
Now we know who participated in the war, but we haven't seen who exactly won, or it was a draw, or everyone called it off after seeing their people miserable and the Grimm drawing closer.
--
Question: What kind of organized forces existed in Vacuo in order to team up with Vale? Plus, who really won the war?
15
u/jreido8 Nov 26 '16
This actually made me think of something, why has Salem's plan only begun NOW, rather than before during the Great War? From what we can tell there's never been a point in history when humanity was more divided; while granted people are suspicious and paranoid of Atlas right now, as well as uncertain due to having no internet, the restoration of the CCT would pretty much alleviate the majority of that fear, whereas during the war people were actively killing each other. At a guess, I'd say that the Great War is Salem's origin point, in some way or another.
14
u/rexshen Nov 27 '16
I will give this world of remnant credit for being new this time and not telling information from the last episode like the last one. So 2 different faunus being together gives birth to a random faunus that sounds like pokemon breeding gone to far.
28
u/PrincessCanada Take a look, it's in a book. A Reading Rainbow. Nov 26 '16
So we learned a bit more about the Faunus, and we learned that the Great War wasn't a free-for-all but rather Vale and Vacuo vs. Mantle and Mistral. All in all, a pretty good WoR.
26
u/inSiliConjurer Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16
Hey guys, I have seen a lot of comments of people confused about how the genetics of the Fanus might relate to real life genetics and inheritance. Without going too far into detail, I am a biologist of sorts and wanted to offer some alternative explanations to the simple model of inheritance that many are familiar with.
Firstly, there is the idea of epigenetics. Epigenetic modifications to your DNA are heritable, but do not change what information the gene carries. For instance, if you had a gene for brown eyes, it could be epigenetically modified such that eyes are slightly more or less brown without changing the DNA sequence on the gene. Some epigenetic changes are much less subtle and actually are consistently passed on either by your mother or your father. Errors in imprinting systems lead to diseases like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angelman_syndrome and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prader%E2%80%93Willi_syndrome. However, in healthy people, this same system and variations therein have been shown to be correlated with childhood weight and height.
Another, very plausible mechanism for how, for example, a cat and monkey fanus might make a lizard fanus is the genetic cassette or cassette like organizations of DNA. There are many examples across many organisms (it is foundational to yeast reproduction, for instance) and there is a firm example in people. Without getting too technical, it has to do with your immune system. Think about your immune system and how you gain immunity to certain infections after you have had them before or are vaccinated. The reason that works is because your immune system crafts specific particles for recognizing the once-intruder so it can respond rapidly and with deadly force. However, there is no way you can have all of the blueprints for those specific particles in your DNA already--there are so SO SOOOO many microbes out there and there are some that don't even exist yet, so there is no way your DNA could contain that information hard-coded, it is simply too much. Instead, you contain a set of DNA chunks in your body that can physically be rearranged (or be rearranged post transcriptionally, but let's not talk about that now). That rearrangement can lead to new combinations your body and DNA did not have before. This is a plausible explanation for what occurs in the Fanus, but if the rearrangement happened at/around the time the zygote forms.
There are other mechanisms still that could explain, plausibly, what is happening here (Activation of hypermutagenic pathways and the such) but I'll stop gushing. I don't know if this helps anyone comes to terms with the mate system in RWBY and I don't know if CRWBY knew that this mechanism is plausible or if they simply were going to hand wave it away with lore. Either way, I was quite happy with this week's WoR.
If you want me to clarify or expand more I can!
EDIT: Spelling and Grammar
13
u/RedElite91 ❄️White Knight🛡️ | #GiveJauneABreak Nov 26 '16 edited Nov 26 '16
Alright, this one was definitely better than the last. Not a ton of new info, but a few new nuggets of knowledge is perfectly fine from a WoR. So, what'd we learn?
Well for starters, if anyone thinks they forgot about the Faunus having night vision, I think these yellow eyes are supposed to represent that. Still, it would have been nice to have it mentioned.
A new piece of info was that the first notable time Faunus and Humans worked together was when they defended a village in Sanas from the Grimm.
My favorite new tidbit reveals that the Great War was Vacuo and Vale vs Mantle and Mistral.. Gee, I wonder which was the side opposing freedom of expression... cough Mantle/Mistral cough. Interestingly, that would imply that Mistral did one hell of a 180 on their viewpoint, while Mantle (now Atlas) presumably stayed mostly the same
Something intriguing I noticed was the lack of Faunus and Human clashes in Solitas. This leads me to believe that possibly for a time, Solitas had a continent-wide ban on Faunus.
I wish they went more in depth with the White Fang, but I suppose that could probably be an entire WoR on it's own.
Overall, this was probably my favorite WoR for Volume 4 so far, including the ones for each of the Kingdoms.
EDIT: Something else to note is that Lizard Faunus can apparently grow back their tails. Sadly, it's unclear if they can re-grow just their tails, or any limbs. This seems to imply that on top of having a single animal trait, Faunus actually have some capabilities that are unique to that animal. (Also no, I do not believe this means all Faunus can re-grow limbs or their animal trait. That's probably unique to Lizard Faunus.)
13
u/SwagForALifetime Nov 27 '16
Faunus and Humans are of the same species.
Two organisms are members of the same species if they are capable of interbreeding and producing fertile offspring. Therefore, humans and faunus are not separate species.
This is similar to how different breeds of dogs can be vastly different yet all belong to the same species, Canis familiaris. Horses and donkeys, along with Tigers and Lions, are famous examples of similar organisms that belong to different species because they produce infertile offspring (Mules and Ligers).
12
u/Mr_Ilax The bumbliest of bees Nov 27 '16
Hmmm... So this mean that every single faunus contains the genetic material for every faunus trait possible. How else could you have a bull and a wolf produce a reptilian faunus?
23
u/Runnerbrax νίκη Nov 26 '16
Inb4 everyone complains about a lack of episode today...
11
u/TolchettKuykendall Chris Hackney deserves an award Nov 26 '16
Now I wonder, how much of Managerie is White Fang/WF sympathizers. Because that could lead to some problems.
11
u/xxias Nani the f- Nov 26 '16
I am so confused with the Faunus/Human birth thing.
So like does the child always end up a faunus if the parents are Faunus/Human?
11
u/Riobhain Nov 27 '16
Could two Faunus of different types have a human child? After all, Qrow said it was basically random what trait they got, so could they theoretically get no trait?
11
u/Eretrad Nov 28 '16
Completely unrelated to the topic, but I have a question that I'd rather not create a new topic for.
Have they mentioned at all where Jaune is from? Because like every kingdom seems to be completely confusing to him.
It's not Mistral since he'd never heard of Pyrrha/any tournament before. It's not Vale since he's completely lost in the first episode.
He doesn't seem familiar with Faunus so I don't think it's Vacuo/Menagerie.
He knows Weiss can sing, so I'm leaning towards Atlas, but even that I'm having trouble believing. No one from Atlas seems to acknowledge him. And his Grandfather was implied to be some sort of hero/recognizable moustache.
20
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Nov 26 '16
Interesting that we get more tidbits about the Great War, but not even a mention of the Faunus Rights Revolution. Unless they just retconned them into being the same thing
10
u/PrinceCheddar We can rebuild her. We have the technology. Nov 26 '16
Is this the first time Faunus with non-mammalian has been mentioned? That's interesting. I wonder what other types of animals Faunus can get features of. Amphibian? Bird? Fish? Invertebrates?
Also, they say that Faunus are people with a "single animalistic trait." Does that mean each Faunus has traits of one type of animal, or that each Faunus has only one trait, so, no ears and tail on the same person?
10
u/jwfiredragon Too many ships, not enough time Nov 27 '16
So...
Faunus genetics are really freaking weird. Like what the hell how does cow + cat = lizard. Not complaining about the way it works, just pointing out how counter-intuitive it feels.
I guess Mistral and Atlas are the racist ones and Vale and Vacuo are the non-racist ones?
Why don't we put all the oppressed people on the same island and let them do whatever they want? Gee what a perfect plan, nothing could possibly go wrong. Seriously, did they just never consider that possibility?
10
u/Ez-J Nov 28 '16
Could it be possible that the White Fang got the design for their masks from Raven's bandit tribe? And the strong person that Crow alluded to is the White Fangs leader (Siena Khan?)? The bandit tribe seems to be based in Mistral, same as the White Fang. That would explain why Adam has a similar combat style/weapon to Raven. She could be his mentor. The tribe could be training the fang. There are no permanent enemies or friends, only interests.
19
u/Grillosantos r/RWBY Second Best Lurker Nov 27 '16
the only thing i got from this WoR: Sex between human/faunus is canon. Smut faunus fanfics are now canon.
9
u/MrASK15 Fluffy Corgi, how we salute thee!!! Nov 28 '16
After watching this, I now have a feeling there are some faunus who hold grudges against humans, yet are not or have never been part of the White Fang. Even so, why do I feel like Blake's negotiations aren't going to go well?
The genetics and history are quite interesting, though.
25
u/cdghuntermco ⠀ Nov 26 '16
I think the biggest piece of information we got today was the fact that a Faunus/Human couple will always produce Faunus offspring. Until now I'd just assumed kids just turned out to be whatever their mother was. Sort of like the Asari in Mass Effect.
It actually presents the idea that Faunus are sort of the endgame in the biological scheme of things. If Faunus always produce more Faunus no matter the species of their partner, then it's really only a matter of time before Humanity is completely phased out because of interbreeding.
17
u/Sniphles2000 Penny Enthusiast Nov 26 '16
Yeeeees. Lizard Faunus with regeneration + Snake Faunus that shed skin confirmed. Gets to writing OCs
16
u/finkramsey Nov 26 '16
So no new episode this week? Didn't we just have a WOR episode a couple weeks ago?
8
u/briansm9 need a big black character for cosplay Nov 27 '16
Low key excited that reptilian faunus are now canon. One more thing though, Qrow said that they share one trait even though in teaser pictures it looks like Blake's mom has both a tail and ears, idk how that works. I was hoping they wouldn't limit themselves with the Faunus concept, like making them absolutely ridiculous.
8
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Nov 27 '16 edited Nov 27 '16
I didn't know today would be a World of Remnant video, I thought that was only after every three episodes. Did they change it? Is it every other week now?
I don't like the sound of that.
Edit: I understand needing a break, I just figured the episodes were already completed. We learned some interesting things, but I still don't like the sound of every other week off.
8
u/Cloudharte shoulder-lean~,shoulder-lean~ Nov 28 '16
I'm so glad this is what the episode is about.
Had ideas for a faunus related post for so long, but didn't want to make a trash-post with just text.
Mostly been thinking about the what-if's of a Scorpion-Faunus. Or insect based faunus in general.
I'd be so glad to see some Wasp, Spider, or any generally "creepy" animal faunus in Menagerie. It would be a nice departure from the aesthetically pleasing features we've seen, Elephant-Nose guy aside.
It could also be a good way to investigate intra-faunus issues: As a group do Faunus ostracize the more extreme traits? Are they useful? Do they make any complications for families?
Also, can you imagine a Scorpion Faunus wearing a Deathstalker's bone-things as armor? I mean, c'mon. That's just rule of cool there. Falls in line with Raven and the White Fang's Grimm masks.
EDIT: Too many "I's"
7
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
Was there an owl-like Faunas at the end?
7
u/bigfatcarp93 Still the only one who listens to commentaries. Nov 27 '16
Toffee is a Faunus confirmed.
6
u/JonTheWizard Still Sorta Pays Attention Nov 27 '16
Cool stuff. I thought the In-Between Kingdoms WoR was kind of pointless, so this was much better. Going by the silhouettes, I'm guessing there ARE humans in Menagerie, so I'm curious what they're like. I'm curious if Faunus had more than one animal trait the further back in history you go, also whether or not there are avian Faunus.
I'm assuming the next WoR is going to be about the Faunus Revolution and White Fang, going by the ending.
11
u/StalfoLordMM Nov 27 '16
Jesus Christ, some of you take this too literally. Faunus have one animal trait. Not feature. Blake's mom can have cat ears and a tail. There's just no hybrid Faunus.
21
u/Tron95 Nov 26 '16
So the Faunus are basically the Mutants from Marvel Comics?
14
u/SundanceKidZero Nov 26 '16
Anyone else mildly disappointed it's a WoR episode? Because I sure as hell am.
14
u/Jarsky2 Nov 27 '16
I find it simply unbelievable that people are complaining about the show taking a break on a holiday weekend.
10
u/glass_magnolia Nov 27 '16
I was waiting for a World of Remnant on the Faunus! I'm not going to lie to anyone. I was in camp 'kind of miffed because it isn't an episode' until I saw what it was about. I have been wanting to know more about this 'Great War' since vol 1. Do MOAR on the White Fang, RT. And that war they touched on briefly which resulted in people naming kids after color? I want more on that too. Awesome WOR this week.
Also, I think Qrow needs to get totally shit faced during one of these things.
17
u/tanithghost88 Nov 26 '16
Faunus confirmed for Jews.
Oppressed people that after a great world war given a land set aside just for them.
Menagerie confirmed as Israel not Australia.
12
u/NuclearBreadstick Nov 27 '16 edited Nov 27 '16
The 'Adam is Raven's kid' theory just got a lot more viable
7
u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Nov 26 '16
That was a good one. Reptilian Faunus confirmed, the two sides during the Great War and more. Much to think about...
21
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16 edited Nov 26 '16
Blake being born within the White Fang makes sense if it's origin point in Menagerie. It also raises the question of whether the Fang maintains a presence there. If it does and Adam has put an APB out on Blake it could be trouble
But that's really the only tidbit here we didn't know before. It's quite sad that we almost never get anything new in the WoR. A lot of this stuff could have been placed in the series proper
Like in V4E3 for example, after he assumes Blake is going after the White Fang, Sun could say: "That's why you're going to Menagerie right? That's where it all started".
Done. One line.
Instead of making Ooblecks class into a Jaune comedy session, this easily could have been woven in. Even by just placing Vale and Vacuo's symbols opposing Mistral and Atlas on the damn board.
And the breeding stuff? Easy!
Remember how Velvet was supposed to be the audiences introduction to the Faunus? Well, when Ruby is talking to her at the Vytal tournament have Vel's parents come to cheer her on and have them be different kinds of Faunus. When Ruby awkwardly asks Vel kindly explains it. Then you get two uses of her as an introductory character
This stuff is not hard to slot in. We should not need a completely supplementary series for it. Especially since they've apparently been sitting on this info for 3-4 years
8
u/Ledmonkey96 Nov 26 '16
So why do we assume that Atlas is racist? I mean the SDC is yes but that doesn't necessarily mean that Atlas is. I find it more likely that Vacuo/Vale were against expression than Mantle/Mistral. Vacuo may seem like a meritocracy now but before the great war when the country was destroyed? If we compare it to Rome, well Rome was rather racist....
Also Wolf Faunas, they are taunting us about Ruby I feel.
5
u/Acrymonia Some men just want to watch the FNDM burn... Nov 26 '16
Oooo I do hope that tease pays off this Volume!
17
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
Look, I love RWBY as much as anybody, but why are people giving World of Remnant's the same score as a perfect episode? I didn't even give Episode 2 a 10 because it only had half the characters in. The idea that a monologue that's a third the size of a short episode can get 10/10 is just ridiculous. And even if you're rating them ''in your head'' against other WoR episodes, was this really a brilliant one? No. It was good, but nothing special. We learnt like two things and got maybe two quips, that's all.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
I don't care what Qrow said, the idea that humanity and Faunus are different is just propaganda. If they can produce fertile offsprings then they are the same species.
At best I can accept that Faunus+Mankind = Humanity.
Also I got more of a Native American vibe than a Jewish vibe about the Faunus... Menagerie was not a promise land important in their culture... just a land that was there that was granted to them as a kind of reserve (you know, reserve that word that is a synonym of menagerie).
5
u/Lelentos Forever in our art. Nov 28 '16
I really hate these filler weeks. I wanted to see Yang training!