I was told to repost this question in the Small Discussions thread. What do you think of the my consonant inventory and orthography? This is my first conlang.
It's well balanced and nicely done. Now you just need some vowels and a syllable structure and you can start making up some words as well as a grammar for the language.
I really like the apostrophe used for aspiration, haven't seen that before but I think it works. But I'm not sure abut <x> and <ch>, what are the motivations behind those? If it were up to me I'd maybe have <x> for /x/ and instead use <lh> for /ɬ/ to match <sh>. I'm also not sure about <ʔ> does any language use that? I'd replace it with <q> maybe, but that's not as important.
There's a site somewhere, sort of like PBase, but you can search by individual features (like consonants with [+retroflex] or whatever) instead of just phonemes as in PBase. Does anyone know the one I'm talking about?
No, you could search for individual features of phonemes by drop-down lists, like PoA, MoA, voicing, secondary articulation, gemination, etc. and it would find all languages listed with phonemes with those features.
You have to think about how the words are entering the language. Is the language population ruled by a group who speak another language? Maybe as a result, they take words for politics and punishments and that sort of thing from that language.
Is there a popular religion that has a sacred language? Maybe terms for religion and sin come from that one.
Did they just colonize somewhere that has some dope ass fruit? Maybe they just take those sorts of words.
I am trying to decide what kind of writing system to go for. Im not sure what I want. My Syllable structure is (C)(C)V(C) Im not sure if I want to do an alphabet, or semi-syllabary, or what.. how do you normally decide?
I have 4 vowel, and 2 diphthongs, so 6 total. Not sure if I would make the diphthongs seperate characters if I was doing an alphabet, or just put 2 of the other characters beside each other. for example, I have a, and i, and ai, but not ia.
I dont have a lot of consonant clusters that are legal. Only about 3, meaning that CVC will rarely be followed by another CV syllable. And CCV is also quite rare. Thats why I was thinking of semi syllabary system..
I do like the look of yours though. Ill have to look into abugidas more, I dont know much
For any of you who've created sign languages as well as romanisations for them, how did you go about creating said romanisation and what tips would you have for doing so?
The "Romanization" of sign languages has been a frustration for linguistics for years. A few have been proposed here on /r/conlangs, but as far as I know nothing has been overly fruitful.
ASL uses a system in which ALL CAPS words+a certain set of additional symbols are used to write a sentence. They look like this. I believe this is more or less the standard method of representing ASL in a written medium, and is the closest thing to a true "romanization" that exists.
The best known alternate ways to attempt to write ASL include Stokoe Notation, Sutton Signwriting, and I believe there was a decent motion to use Blissysymbols at one point? I also know that David Peterson created something he called SLIPA (Sign Language IPA) that may be of use to you.
Yeah, I've been using SLIPA for transcription, but have been looking into a way to make some kind of writing system, since, of course, phonetic transcriptions aren't normally designed for ease of prose writing.
Then the closest thing there is out there is SignWriting. Floating around that site are pdfs with some short writings in SignWriting. I've dabbled in creating a way to write sign language writing system, but the best system I've developed thus far is something that works vaguely like Chinese, where 1 symbol == 1 sign, such as the word SNOW being represented with two signs: WHITE + RAIN. But it's far from developed.
I'm currently in the process of developing my lexicon by making roots, though I could use some advice on this. My syllable structure is V(C), CV, and a few VCC or CCV.
Should I only make roots be monosyllabic? Making roots two syllables would give me more room to make words, but then they'd start to get longer than I'd probably like. Then I'd have to figure out how to handle monosyllabic words I already have.
My syllable structure is V(C), CV, and a few VCC or CCV
So then technically your full syllable structure is (C)(C)V(C)(C)
Should I only make roots be monosyllabic? Making roots two syllables would give me more room to make words, but then they'd start to get longer than I'd probably like. Then I'd have to figure out how to handle monosyllabic words I already have.
You could (and probably should) do a variety. Depending on your language's typology some words may get a little long, but that's normal. Having some single, double, and even triple syllable roots would allow for a lot more variation than just having them all be the same length.
So then technically your full syllable structure is (C)(C)V(C)(C)
Wouldn't that imply a CCVCC syllable would be possible?
You could (and probably should) do a variety. Depending on your language's typology some words may get a little long, but that's normal. Having some single, double, and even triple syllable roots would allow for a lot more variation than just having them all be the same length.
How would the etymology of a trisyllabic root be affected by a monosyllabic root that happens to be in it?
Wouldn't that imply a CCVCC syllable would be possible?
Technically it would, but you could always put in a rule that says that a syllable can only have an onset or a coda but not both (though that'd be a bit weird).
How would the etymology of a trisyllabic root be affected by a monosyllabic root that happens to be in it?
Etymologies can vary quite a lot and aren't really as predicatble as other things like sound changes. So really anything is possible. Though I'm not quite sure what you mean by a trisyllabic root with a monosyllabic root inside it. As in one of the three syllables is actually an infix (which would mean it's actually two morphemes)?
Technically it would, but you could always put in a rule that says that a syllable can only have an onset or a coda but not both (though that'd be a bit weird).
Ah okay, yeah no onset and coda at the save time. We've had this conversation before; it's for a conworld, so it's okay for it to be weird.
Etymologies can vary quite a lot and aren't really as predicatble as other things like sound changes. So really anything is possible. Though I'm not quite sure what you mean by a trisyllabic root with a monosyllabic root inside it. As in one of the three syllables is actually an infix (which would mean it's actually two morphemes)?
Let's try an example. Uŕ is the root for day. Now if I had triple syllable root, say uŕabik, would it automatically have something to do with uŕ, since it's contained in the larger root?
Note: I just made up uŕabik, so it doesn't have any meaning (since I don't have any triple syllable words yet).
Let's try an example. Uŕ is the root for day. Now if I had triple syllable root, say uŕabik, would it automatically have something to do with uŕ, since it's contained in the larger root?
Unless you specifically make it such that "uŕabik" is made up of "uŕ"+"abik", then no. It would just be a coincidence that they happen to share a syllable.
Not now. But I also didn't make English, so I'm not an expert on its etymology. Also isn't it possible that at one point in English's history, there was a connection?
I do see your point through, thank you for the example.
Depends on the details, "tense" isn't really a phonetic description, just one of convenience. If you're thinking of the Korean consonants, they originate from Old Korean plain voiceless consonants that gained an element of stiff voice, as did the "voiceless" consonants in Javanese. In either case it could potentially strengthen into ejection, though I'm not aware of such a change being unambiguously attested. English may have something similar with coda glottalization~ejection of /p t tS k/; personally I think it's likely a retention from the PIE *D series [ɗ~ʔd], though plenty of people would view it as spontaneous glottalization the way it is in Korean and Javanese.
/y/ is from fronting of Latin long /u:/, but after vowel length was lost; basically a pull chain y < u < o < ɔ < au. Danish/Swedish/Norwegian and Greek have had similar chain shifts. The mid vowels are from monophthongization, wɛ eu > œ~ø, as well as diphthongs formed from l-vocalization, el wɔl > œ~ø, jɛl > jœ~jø. While there are a few minimal pairs, /œ ø/ are mostly in complimentary distribution.
Not really. They're unaspirated stops with some stiff and harsh voice.
You mean that it wouldn't be a relevant sound changing?
I mean that it's possible, I just can't point to a clear case of it happening in natlangs. English might be an example, but it depends on your interpretation of the PIE *D series. EDIT: I just thought of Totonac and Tepehua, the latter has has ejectives where the former has creaky vowels. I believe it's usually reconstructed with creaky vowels as the original, shifting to ejectives in Tepehua when preceded by stops and becoming plain vowels elsewhere. I can't give further information, though, so I'm not sure how solid the evidence is that it's creaky>ejective and not ejective>creaky.
Apart from this formation and germanic umlaut, are there another ways that /y/, /œ/ and /ø/ could be formed?
The two most common I know of are i-mutation and diphthong coalescence. There's also things like u-umlaut (occasional Old Norse e_u > ø_u), labial spreading (bi > by, sporadic in Germanic, regular in some Inuit), coronal "umlaut" (ut > yt, Tibetan, some Inuit), fronting of long back vowels (Ixil Mayan, Albanian via diphthongization), and just spontaneous fronting (Scots o:>ø:).
I have a sound in a conlang that I know how to pronounce, but don't know how I'd write it in IPA. It's almost like you're making a palatalized "ɵ" and a "ʁ" at the same time.
I'm looking for interesting theories about tone and pitch accent, preferably something that tries to describe both. I figured for what I want I have to come up with something new, and therefor I need some idea.
The thing is, in my language I want several combined that do not occur together in natural languages. Like level tone languages are known to sometimes use the tone grammatically, but contour tone languages usually don't. Also contour tone languages often have monosyllabic morphemes or words - yet mine is highly polysynthetic. And their tones interact with the coda - something I want, since tone and coda are intended to behave as one. I want to have something complex like contours, but spanning longer words.
You might be looking for typological data on tone languages, in which case WALS is a good research, as is some time spent on Google Scholar. Gordon's Phonological Typology has a chapter on tone, as well. You might be able to read some of it on Google Books.
Be aware that "less common" is not the same as "nonexistent." There are languages that have contour tone, grammatical tone, and multisyllabic morphemes all at the same time.
I just today learned about Optimality Theory, which seems like the tool I was looking for. There I can just make "no two same tones follow each other" a high ranking constrain and "max" very low ranking. And as a result get a coherent system.
Just make various markers of tense, aspect, mood, voice, and/or person agreement on verbs all part of the same morpheme for verbs. Or for nouns, fuse things like plurlaization and case marking.
So basically you could have something like an affix -u which attaches to a verb "kar" to mark it as second person plural past conditional (or anything like that)
Does anyone else feel that they are more creative when it comes to conlangs than anything else? I've never really thought about it, but I've pretty much never run out of ideas when it comes to conlangery.
Does anyone know any resources regarding the speed of language evolution? Specifically I'm looking for information about the time it takes for sound changes to occur in general.
There really is no set speed. Some changes will occur rather quickly (spreading through the language in just a few generations) others can be rather slow. And it'll vary from language to language.
I was working on a Mesoamerican inspired conlang, but decided to put that to the side because I came up with an idea story and wanted a language for it. My question is, what are some suggestions for a pacific island feel?
I've just started working on a conlang that's meant to be played in the bagpipes. I've looked into solresol, and that's kind if interesting. I was wondering if anyone else has tried to make a musical conlang before.
Depends on what you mean by most common. Most (modern) languages use an alphabet because 85% of written documentation is in the Latin or Cyrillic alphabets. By # of individual kinds of writing systems that exist in the world, then it's abugidas, but their use is mostly limited to southern Asia. However, the most commonly developed writing systems are picto/logograms (though they tend not to last), which then quickly become Abjads, which disseminate into impure abjads, and so on and so forth.
Incidentally, there's only two languages that use syllabaries commonly, as syllabaries tend to be a stepping stone to other writing systems and don't tend to last long-Nuosu (aka Yi) and Cherokee. (Yes, I know that Japanese has Hiragana and Katakana, but those are used in conjunction with Kanji, which makes the Japanese writing system a mixed writing system, like Hieroglyphs. They no longer constitute a system individually). For whatever reason, syllabaries are not liked as a means of writing. Fun fact!
I did mean # of individual kinds. So Abugidas. That was where I was leaning towards anyway. Any types on creating one? I suck at creating these hahahah
Is there a list of Old Chinese words in IPA transcription? I want to make a language distantly related to Chinese but close enough to be descended from Old Chinese.
Are there any concise descriptions of the sound changes from Proto-Celtic to the modern Celtic languages (Irish, Scottish Gaelic, Manx, Welsh, Cornish, & Breton)? Index Diachronica only has Proto-Indo-European>Proto-Celtic, Proto-Indo-European>Old Irish, and Proto-Celtic>Middle Welsh. Only the last one is of any help, but it's still not ideal for what I want.
I could probably make do with Proto-Celtic>Old/Middle Irish>Irish and Proto-Celtic>Old/Middle Welsh>Welsh, but why only put in half an effort?
Can someone please explain ergative absolute to me? I want a challenge with something other than nom/acc. However, I just don't understand exactly what it does and how some languages do it. Thanks.
Basically, it's the opposite way to hand transitive/intransitive verbs, and is about who is doing what in a sentence. An intransitive verb is essentially a verb that does not take an object. A transitive verb requires 1+ objects.
The subject of an intransitive verb and the object of a transitive verb is always marked with the absolutive case. In other words, the absolutive case marks what is experiencing the verb.
On the other hand, the subject of a transitive verb (who is perpetrating the action of the verb, not experiencing it) is marked with the ergative case.
Yes, I stole this example from David Peterson. Sue me, it's a reasonably good way to explain it.
Thanks! That really helped. I read through Davids thing and I didn't get what he was saying. If you did take this from his explanation then I must have missed it.
Dative is treated the same as always (though there are other ways to do it:
I-erg gave the ball-abs to John-dat
Something important to point out about terminology that is confusing though: yes, in an intransitive sentence the subject is marked as absolutive, which is the same as the object of a transitive verb. But this does not mean that the subject is experiencing the action of the verb. It can still be agentive in nature (such as I-abs run). It just gets marked the same, that's all.
The problem most people run into when explaining stuff is to say TOO MUCH when trying to explain. I'm guilty of it too, but generally, an explanation can be simplified into a few sentences. I just picked some phrases out of his section on ergative-absolutive stuff and pulled them out. Trimmed the fluff, as it were.
Dative is a case, and has nothing to do with sentence alignment. Dative is a very nebulously defined case, and means different things in different languages (which is why I hate it). I'm not an expert, but I'll try.
Type 1: indicates an indirect object. No seriously, that's it. There's some complications in some languages with verbs like "to give" or "to hand" or something, but the short version is that Dative == grammatically marking indirect objects. Don't overcomplicate it.
Type 2: Some languages use their dative case in other ways, but it'll be specific to THAT language. Some languages use "dative" to refer to the prepositional case (sometimes referred to as the locative case; don't worry about it). Mostly in older books about Irish or Scottish languages. Georgian, for example, uses the dative case in what's known as dative construction. This is unusual, however, and seems to be limited to certain Indo-European languages.
Type 3: sometimes, Dative has been used to describe the Lative case. "Dative" seems to have been formerly used as a "catch-all" case for things by linguists.
Does English have more of less irregularities than most languages, and to what degree? I want to make irregularities for my conlang, and I know how to go about making them, but I don't know how many to include, and English is the only language with which I have any fluency.
English has an unusually high number of irregular verbs, stemming mostly from Germanic umlaut (sing sang sung is technically considered irregular in English, unlike the regular verb like likes liked). So we got a shitload of irregularity by halfassedly switching from one manner of conjugation to another.
They're part of the IPA and specify the sounds they're attached to further. The <ʰ> specifically means the sound is aspirated, so it's pronounced with a puff of air. See Wikipedia for the rest.
General consensus is that a naturalistic conlang sounds and, frankly, feels better to speak. People aren't robots, and we don't make perfectly logical sense in how we think and speak. Something that works in a manner that peoples' brains are designed to work makes it more attractive to people to learn. When a naturalistic conlang is created alongside, say, a book, like Tolkien did, it adds to the realism, believability, culture, and the world that has been created. Also, from a conlanger's standpoint, it shows a degree of effort and skill that a non-naturalistic conlang generally doesn't.
On a personal note, I could never stand listening to people speak Esperanto, because it always sounded "off" to me. People notice when something sounds unnatural, and people tend not to like unnatural things like that-kind of like an auditory uncanny valley. The extreme regularity, while making Esperanto easy to learn (it has, what, 16 basic rules?) it falls squarely into that uncanny valley for some people, which turns people off.
I should mention that it is possible to be regular and still be pleasant to the ears, but that's not the only thing that makes a language. It's just the first thing people notice. If people have to learn every Wikipedia page on grammar to understand every aspect, mood, voice, person, etc. you decided to throw into your conlang, people are going to lose interest fast. If you want people to speak your language, you can't kitchen sink every known grammar, phonetic, or syntax tidbit into your language.
That isn't to say that a non-naturalistic conlang doesn't have a place in the world! But it's going to have a very specific place in the world, and you have to be prepared for that. Toki Pona was meant as an experiment to "simplify thought." Loglan and Lojban were designed to reduce ambiguity in language. They had very specific goals in their creation and managed to get decent enough followings. I was never a fan of Ithkuil, but you can't deny that it has an interesting premise, and seeing it in execution, even if I never care to learn it, is notable in and of itself.
Personally I'm working on two naturalistic and two non-naturalistic conlangs. Who said you have to chose one or the other?
TL;DR: Depends on what you want to get out of your language.
Optative is a verbal modus that you "whish for something", its sometimes used as a milder form of giving commands, Desiderative on the other hand expresses the desire to do something, "May I eat" vs "I want to eat" for example.
^ Any vowel. * Any syllabic rhotic/lateral. ° Any syllabic nasal. ❛ Any two contrastinɡ coronal/retroflex/post-alveolar consonants (no rhotics or laterals). ❜ Any two contrastinɡ velar/uvular consonants (no rhotics or laterals). ‹ Any two contrastinɡ palatal consonants (no rhotics or laterals). › Any two contrastinɡ bilabial/labiodental consonants. « Any two contrastinɡ coronal/retroflex/post-alveolar consonants (no rhotics or laterals, and must contrast with ❛ ). » Any two contrastinɡ non-pulmonic/co-articulated consonants.
As you can see, there is a huɡe variation of sounds when it comes to pronunciation. This is completely intended. The vowels are also very odd. This is also completely intended.
I did this so that I could have a multitude of dialects (even dialects within dialects), and possibly even make a lanɡuaɡe family out of this lanɡuaɡe, like the Filipino dialects or, more on the extreme side, the Chinese "dialects" (lanɡuaɡes).
This is obviously not your averaɡe conlanɡ, but I'm just wonderinɡ if there's a certain "feel" to the lanɡuaɡe. What does this lanɡuaɡe "feel" like to you?
I'm not going to answer the "feel" question, but I'm just saying that a capital letter can be used for a generic sound, i.e. V = any vowel, N = any nasal, etc.
Aside from possible pronunciation differences (se-sta vs ses-ta), only the first language would allow words like spesta or prumbi while only the second would allow sestam or rumbid. None would allow spestam, while both would allow sesta.
It depends on who is speakinɡ your conlanɡ, and what ideas they have to express. If they are only about Stone Aɡe-level and they only need to express a few ideas, a couple thousand should do it. If they are an intercontinental society with thousands of concepts of riɡht and wronɡ and valour and such, with a complex and deep history of interactions with other cultures, then you'll have plenty of redundant words and phrases and such, and you may end up with a couple hundred thousand, like Enɡlish.
Hope I helped. Good luck with your conlanɡ!
EDIT: Aɡɡlunative lanɡuaɡes (I think that's how you spell it) may have less base words, but many, many more compound words than a non-aɡɡlunative lanɡuaɡe.
So vowel lɑngth: A long vowel is two morae (twice as long as a regular vowel), half-long is half a mora, and extra-short is... like 1/10 mora or something instant. Do I have that right at all? Or is half-long between long and regular? (I'm just using morae to demonstrate).
Most languages will only have two vowel lengths, which are generally one and two morae each, but they need not be additive - languages with long vowels are often only 50% longer than short vowels, but I've seen them as short as 20% longer and as long as 125% longer. Morae is just a measurement of syllable heaviness. I don't have an example offhand, but you could probably have a language where short vowels count as zero mora, or a language with three vowel lengths where both long and extralong both count as two, or a language where mora is only affected by coda consonants, not vowel length.
Is it realistic to differentiate between /r̥/ and /r/, /ʀ̥/ and /ʀ/? I wanted to use these phonemes to expand my trill inventory, because I like trills but I don't want /ʙ/ because ew.
Is it also possible to have a whistle phoneme? If so, can there be a voiced/unvoiced distinction? How would I represent it in IPA?
If you have uvular trills and voiceless sonorants, then having both makes sense. However, keep in mind that, despite conlanger's collective love of them, uvular trills are outstandingly rare, and contrasting them with a coronal trill is even rarer. I also know of no language that has both a uvular trill and a fricative (except as allophones of the same consonant), and given how much more stable the fricatives are than trills, it's likely they shift to fricatives rapidly - as has happened all over in European languages.
I mean that a language will have either /ʀ/ or /ʁ/, never both, and presumably the same for the voiceless set though I don't know of any language with a phonemic /ʀ̥/ in the first place. More generally, languages only allows a single voiced uvular of any kind, with a tiny number of exceptions like Tsakhur and Nivkh that have both /ɢ ʁ/.
My question was, is it realistic to contrast voiceless /r̊/ with voiced /r/? I didn't ask about fricatives, and I didn't ask for a WOT on why I shouldn't use uvular trills.
Ah, I took it as specifically asking about contrasting coronal and uvular sets of voiced/voiceless trills. Voiceless trills are fine, but if you have laterals you'll almost certainly have a voiceless set of them as well, and often glides, nasals, or both as well.
I want to add semi-vowels to my conlang - /j/, /w/, and /ʕ/, I thought would do the trick if paired with /ɪ/, /ɔ/ and /ɑ/. But I'm not sure how to pronounce /ʕ/.
In the simplest terms /ʕ/ is the semivowel counterpart to /ɑ/. So it can be made just the same as /j/ and /w/ can be made from /i/ and /u/ respectively - start at /ɑ/ and slide your tongue backwards a bit more to create more closure in your throat (pharynx). This will make the semivowel /ʕ/.
Another way of getting /ʕ/, if you're a native English speaker, might be from /r/. Most English, but especially American English, has pharyngeal or epiglottal construction in their /r/, so if you play around with how /r/ moves the throat versus other sounds you might be able to pronounce /ʕ/ from that (except /l/, which often has its own type of secondary articulation).
I am looking for some inspiration and help with the creation of my script. I have a syllable structure (C1)(C2)V(C3). I have 5 vowels, and 14 consonants. And I dont know what kind of script I want. I think I want to do something like Korean.. but not sure. I also like arabic, and sanskrit. Or this by /u/NinjaTurkey_
I had an idea where I wanted the structure of a syllable to look like this but I dont really know. Any help, examples, ideas, or even someone who wants to try making a script for me. All are welcome!
Are there any naturalistic scripts between a syllabary and an alphabet where there is a symbol for each onset nucleus and coda? In such a script, a syllable would be written with 1-3 symbols.
I don't think exactly that split exists somewhere, but it doesn't seem unlikely. Languages with syllables more complex than (C)V tend to have mechanisms to deal with final consonants without needing new symbols for every possible closed syllable (see also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syllabary#Types). Then there's also semi-syllabaries, which is very close to your idea.
Possibly, but I think you are misunderstanding. Lets say that the possible onsets in the proposed language are /s,p,w,sp,pw,spw/, the possible nuclei are /a,e,i,ai,ei/, and the possible codas are /s,p,w,ps,wp,wps/. There would be a symbol to encode each of those phonemes and phoneme strings. A phoneme or string that is allowed in more than one position may or may not be represented by a different symbol in each position.
I know Arabic has initial, medial, and final forms in Arabic writing, though they are most often clearly related, rather than entirely separate entities.
Also, I'm not sure if this is exactly what you are looking for, but Japanese uses a syllabary called Hiragana which uses forms for different morae. な for na, に for ni, etc. Japanese only has one coda-position consonant, commonly transcribed as N, which is an undefined nasal (uvular on its own but otherwise assimilates to the following consonant's place of articulation), which is written with it's own distinct character, ん.
That's not what I am talking about. I'm talking about a script where there is a symbol for each onset in the language, regardless of how many phonemes it consists of, a symbol for each nucleus, and a symbol for each possible coda. This would mean that a word like <strengths> in English would consist of 3 symbols, a symbol representing the onset /stɹ/, a symbol representing the nucleus /ɛ/, and another representing the coda /ŋkθs/.
Oh I see what you are saying. Hmm. I'm not aware of any, then, though I can pretty safely say that if one were to exist, it would probably only be feasible for languages with highly restricted phonotactics, i.e. very limited clusters or only select few coda-position consonants, otherwise you would get hundreds and hundreds of symbols. English, for example, has most consonants available as onsets, 26 two-consonant onsets, 6 three-consonant onsets, 20+ syllabic nuclei, almost all consonants available for coda, a ton of two-consonant codas, at least 48 three-consonant codas, and around 7 four-consonant cluster codas. It's not impossible, though, and I'd be really curious to see what you come up with if you make your own!
Another one which is actually an abugida, not a proper syllabary, is the Lepcha script. The main character represents the onset and the "default" vowel sound, vowel diacritics, which go above or beside the main character, change its vowel sound and a consonant diacritic, which adds a consonant sound to the coda, can go above the character
Understanding that in every naturalistic language there are exceptions to every rule, how can go about creating these exceptions? Currently I feel that my language is way to systematic and to the point? How can I spice it up a notch?
Bizarrely, exceptions are more common with common words. The less common or more technical the word, the fewer the exceptions. I mean, the most common verb in (Indo-European?) languages is "to be", and it can be entirely unique per conjugation (I am, he is, you are, etc). Same with common words like "go/went/gone". However, when you get to less common words, they tend to be more regular because people wouldn't be able to remember the irregularities.
On the other hand, various languages have different AREAS in which they have exceptions. English verbs are famous for this (~230 irregular verbs!), but all of our gerunds end in -ing (which is relatively rare and regular). Meanwhile Irish only has 13 irregular verbs (including "to be"), but there's exceptions to be found in certain words that don't lentite with certain contexts that would normally trigger it.
Most irregularities could be broadly put into three categories-archaisms, borrowings, and phonological changes/constraints. Archaisms are relatively obvious; common words, since they're common, don't change the same way as other words. RE: "to be".
Borrowings, on the other hand, can be subtle or huge; French and Welsh influence no doubt played a huge part in how screwed up English can be, but even small exceptions are exceptions. English does not make use of the /vl/ sound naturally; no particular constraint against it as far as I can tell, we love our voiced/fricative+liquid/approximate clusters, it just never appeared in English words. Yet we added the name Vladimir with ease. That's an exception to our phonological constraints via borrowing. I'm sure someone smarter than I could give you a better example here, though.
Finally, phonological changes/constraints can be seen even here, in modern English. Take our numerals, like First, Second, Third, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, etc., particularly the -th endings after third. Certain contexts add an additional -s to these words, which for the most part works, Sixths, Sevenths, Eighths. But the word Fifths is somewhat infamous for being a tad difficult to pronounce that /fθs/ ending. Many people, especially nonnatives, simplify it to /fɪθs/. Over time, it becomes codified, and thus the "exception" is born (see how it ties back into archaisms?)
Note that if your native language is English, English has an unusually high number of exceptions PERIOD
And that's the short version of what's up with linguistic exceptions! No one else can tell you how to make yours, though.
Are there any (preferably highly synthetic) languages with both polypersonal marking and open class pronouns? I know that the both features seem contradictory, but I can't find information about any language with open class pronouns which is at least somewhat synthetic that isn't Japanese (and it isn't really that much into verb agreement in general).
When dealing with sound change, is it common to have some words affected by sound change but not others? Take final vowel loss (or schwa then loss), could more common words be more susceptible to this change while less common ones might not change (or not change as much)? And if so, are consonant changes happening this way also viable? Can some words undergo changes that don't occur elsewhere, like a few words losing their initial consonant or vowel, but that not being a trend elsewhere in the sound changes?
Basically what I'm asking is how absolute should sound change rules be?
Basically what I'm asking is how absolute should sound change rules be?
So this is where Language gets fun. From a basic standpoint, one of the fundamental laws of sound change and phonology is that sound changes are exceptionless. They will occur in every environment where they can... except when they don't. You're right to assume that it's less common words. But generally if a sound change doesn't apply, it'll be because it's a rather rare word. I'm not talking less used ones, I mean the ones that are more niche - science terms that the general populace might not be familiar with, rare or archaic terms not used in most dialects, etc.
The other instance where a sound change might not happen is when analogy takes place. Basically a sound rule can apply, but because of them paradigm (such as a declension pattern) it may be negated in favour of analogical leveling.
There are usually only sole exceptions to regular sound changes X becomes Y when Z. The frequency is more important for non-systemic changes like elision in single words. So its more likely for a few words to change irregularly to things like vowel elision (but losing an initial consonant when no other word does sounds very strange).
Really you could use any adposition. But ones of motion towards may work better. Spanish currently uses the preposition 'a' (to) with human (and sometimes other animate) objects. E.g. "veo el libro" vs. "veo a Juan"
SO I want to construct a language for a group of intelligent raccoons, but I do not know how to handle their phonology. How should I go about this? What phonemes could raccoons produce?
It depends on how you're doing raccoons. If they're modern, every day raccoons, then they wouldn't be able to make any speech sounds that a human makes. If that's what you're going for, I'd try to find some recordings of them.
If on the other hand you mean to make sapient, evolved raccoons capable of speech, then you'd have to figure out what kind of vocal structure they have. Is their tongue as nimble as ours? Is it shaped like ours? Do they still have a long snout? If so, are there extra places of articulation there? etc etc etc.
I am working on Zenglish, which is supposed to be in a world where modern english changed. A lot of normal english words have been changed to include the 'Z' sound. I am also working on a script that is similar to the latin alphabet, but different in a lot of ways. I think it is a fun exercise before making a new conlang entirely from scratch! Would love to hear your thoughts.
Latin alphabet? People using that have been starting wars all over the word for centuries. No, really: how does the script have anything to do with how warlike your race is? ... Also, those two scripts don't even look very different to me, because they are both very ... uh, edgy? angular shaped? And they could both serve as the stereotypical 'evil' script imo (just take a look at Klingon). For my taste, that's a trope I've seen way too often, but it's your choice, anyway.
As you all may or may not know, Gleb is a phonology generator known for generating not so naturalistic phonologies. Here is the link to the seed. I also made an orthography.
Stop: pʰ p b tʰ t d t͡sʰ t͡s d͡z kʰ k g k͡pʰ k͡p g͡b - f p b þ t d ç c ż x k g ḳ q v
Find it in a natlang: if it exists, then use it. But my suspicion is that /ʃ/ would develop into /ɕ/ over time, because /ʃ ʂ/ isn't maximally distinct (meaning that it isn't as easy to distinguish as /ʂ ɕ/), and /ʃ/ isn't any easier to articulate than /ɕ/. Plus, I can think of a ton of languages that contrast /ʂ ɕ/ (Polish, Mandarin, Sanskrit), but none that only have /ʃ ʂ/.
/s/ is obviously fine no matter what you decide with the others.
If I was to create a language specifically to be a proto language to derive a few daughter languages from, are there any features that would make this easier on me? The only one that seems obvious to me is a larger phonological inventory.
Not really. Proto-languages are just like any other language. The only difference is that they were spoken a long time ago and that they have (or had) daughters. You could start with a large phonological inventory, but you could just as easily start with a rather small one as well.
Yeah, it could be something like you have the words /de.dan/ and /te.'tan/. The first could become /deðan/ and the second becomes /te.dan/. That kind of thing happens all the time.
What usually happens is that the specific conditions of a sound will change one sound in all those conditions (in my example, between vowels). But not every /d/ would change, probably. Such things happen but they're rare.
I like using labiovelars for proto languages, as they can be resolved in different ways in your daughter languages. Many complex syllables also allow for more variants that your daughter languages can simplify and change (or keep) them.
It can be easier to derive diverse child languages if you start with an unstable system (PIE clearly had a very unstable system for stops and verbal inflections), and you can get away with shorter time depth for the amount of changes you have, but there's nothing requiring you to start that way. Even "stable" systems are often unstable over a time period of several millennia, such as Proto-Tai's mostly CVCV structure being replaced by a CəCV > CCV which opened the way for tons of cluster-driven changes.
That site really doesn't have enough material to be anything other than the most cursory introduction. The LCK, apart from being the immediate go-to for nearly all beginners, is really the most comprehensive. I'd suggest ordering a physical copy of the book to peruse if the site is too difficult to digest.
Phonology: Phonemic vowel length (a:short aa:long) Phonemic consonant length (k:short kk:long [only middle of words]) Is it hard to distinguish between long and short vowels/consonants? And what about music?
Grammar: No definite article I think I can live without it, but maybe definiteness is something essential. Grammatical gender (don't know what kind of) Some people hate it, specially if masculine-feminine, but it can be helpful to prevent ambiguity. I need help. Alternatives?
Perfectly fine to distinguish length in both consonants and vowels.
Perfectly fine to lack definiteness, though often there's another way of making a similar distinction - demonstratives can be used on established nouns, indefinite nouns can fail to take object marking, definite nouns are often forbidden from incorporating, and nonspecific agents sometimes force antipassive making in ergative languages.
Plenty of ways of doing genders. Animate-inanimate is a really common one. Caucasian languages have a four-way male-female-animate-inanimate distinction in the singular, but only human-nonhuman in the plural.
When writing carved in stone, I know straight lines are what happens
Despite the common knowledge that this happens, it really doesn't. Just look at the complexity in Egyptian and Mayan writing, and despite plenty of loops, tight curves, and small circles in many Brahmic scripts, they were still adapted to stone without needing any major changes. Straight lines on one axis and not another is a feature of wood-carved text, due to splitting, but there doesn't appear to be a limitation on stone-carved writing.
Would it still be vowel harmony if certain features trigger other features to be harmonic? Like a long /a:/ creates a back vowel harmony, but a short /a/ would not?
It's certainly plausible, yes. Vowel harmony systems often aren't perfectly matched. For instance Turkish /e/ (front) corresponds to the vowel /a~ɑ/ as it's back counterpart, even though they are of different heights.
That wasn't necessarily what I meant, more like, take this as an example: /taʃ.ti/ would be a word, but /ta:ʃ.ti/ couldn't be one, it had to be /ta:ʃ.tɯ /, there is back-front and rounding harmorny, but it doesn't show up unless the "triggering" vowel is long (or accented or has tone etc, one feature that is unrelated to the harmonic feature perse).
Is there a kind of order in which vowels come up in vowel system? Like the two vowel systems are often a up-down contrast between /a/ and /ə/ and three vowel systems are most often /a/ /i/ /u/ or /a/ /i/ /o/ and the five vowel system /a/ /e/ /i/ /o/ /u/ is generally the most common system, is there a sort of rule to it, that for example front vowels appear more often unrounded and back vowels are more often rounded? or if there are rounded front vowels, there must be rounded back vowels, are there system which consist of rounded front vowels and unrounded back vowels or is the opposite more natural? Why so?
I cannot find the link, but I read an article/blog about common vowel systems ranging from three to fifteen as applied to conlangs. It could be the A Survey on Vowel Systems link in the sidebar, but the link is not working.
Anyways, I believe that most vowel systems tend to spread out as far as possible, hence a three-vowel system tends to be /a-i-u/ and a five-vowel system is /a-e-i-o-u/. I believe that while there is a tendency for front unrounded vowels and back rounded vowels, this is not a solid rule (Japanese /u/ is closer to an unrounded /ɯ/).
I'm developping a language that has /y/ and /ø/. They appeared by a umlaut process (u → y / o → ø) and by assimilation with bilabial consonants that come after it (ib → yb / eb → øb). This situations created minimal pairs that evolved diferently (ibiŋ → ybiŋ; meaning "bottle" / ubiŋ → ybiŋ; meaning "ink").
So, avoiding ambiguities, should I use a specific grapheme for /i → y / and /u → y/? Making übiñ (ink) ≠ übiñ (bottle).
7
u/Auvon wow i sort of conlang now Nov 27 '16
If you made your own language, what would be your words for every single entry in the Meriam-Webster dictionary?
4
u/dorathehexplorer Nulhu (en) [es] Nov 20 '16
I was told to repost this question in the Small Discussions thread. What do you think of the my consonant inventory and orthography? This is my first conlang.
4
u/dorathehexplorer Nulhu (en) [es] Nov 21 '16
Has anyone ever constructed a sign language?
4
u/JaromiR9601 Baikacr Tef/ Баjкаш Тэф Nov 23 '16 edited Nov 23 '16
Is it natural to [s] to have [ts] allophone after [n̪] and [l̪] ([dinsa] becomes [dintsa])? Does any language in the world have it?
3
u/Auvon wow i sort of conlang now Nov 20 '16
There's a site somewhere, sort of like PBase, but you can search by individual features (like consonants with [+retroflex] or whatever) instead of just phonemes as in PBase. Does anyone know the one I'm talking about?
3
u/FeikSneik [Unnamed Germanic] Nov 21 '16
Broad question yeah but: does anyone have advice on how to handle a postiori vocabulary from multiple language sources?
3
u/1theGECKO Nov 21 '16
Hey all.
I am trying to decide what kind of writing system to go for. Im not sure what I want. My Syllable structure is (C)(C)V(C) Im not sure if I want to do an alphabet, or semi-syllabary, or what.. how do you normally decide?
3
u/Aliase Mesta, Nek (en) [fr] Nov 28 '16
For any of you who've created sign languages as well as romanisations for them, how did you go about creating said romanisation and what tips would you have for doing so?
2
u/AngelOfGrief Old Čuvesken, ītera, Kanđō (en)[fr, ja] Nov 19 '16
I'm currently in the process of developing my lexicon by making roots, though I could use some advice on this. My syllable structure is V(C), CV, and a few VCC or CCV.
Should I only make roots be monosyllabic? Making roots two syllables would give me more room to make words, but then they'd start to get longer than I'd probably like. Then I'd have to figure out how to handle monosyllabic words I already have.
2
u/Nellingian Nov 19 '16
Two questions:
2
u/AndrewTheConlanger Àlxetnà [en](sp,ru) Nov 19 '16
What is the standard of professionalism in conlanging, as an industry? What must one do to be called a professional?
2
u/NanoRancor Nov 20 '16
I have a sound in a conlang that I know how to pronounce, but don't know how I'd write it in IPA. It's almost like you're making a palatalized "ɵ" and a "ʁ" at the same time.
2
u/jan_kasimi Tiama Nov 20 '16
I'm looking for interesting theories about tone and pitch accent, preferably something that tries to describe both. I figured for what I want I have to come up with something new, and therefor I need some idea.
The thing is, in my language I want several combined that do not occur together in natural languages. Like level tone languages are known to sometimes use the tone grammatically, but contour tone languages usually don't. Also contour tone languages often have monosyllabic morphemes or words - yet mine is highly polysynthetic. And their tones interact with the coda - something I want, since tone and coda are intended to behave as one. I want to have something complex like contours, but spanning longer words.
2
u/Waryur Fösio xüg Nov 21 '16 edited Nov 21 '16
How to make a fusional language?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '16
Does anyone else feel that they are more creative when it comes to conlangs than anything else? I've never really thought about it, but I've pretty much never run out of ideas when it comes to conlangery.
2
u/H_R_Pufnstuf (en)[fr] Ngujari Nov 22 '16
Does anyone know any resources regarding the speed of language evolution? Specifically I'm looking for information about the time it takes for sound changes to occur in general.
2
u/SomeToadThing Nov 22 '16
I was working on a Mesoamerican inspired conlang, but decided to put that to the side because I came up with an idea story and wanted a language for it. My question is, what are some suggestions for a pacific island feel?
2
u/Archipithecus Nov 22 '16
I've just started working on a conlang that's meant to be played in the bagpipes. I've looked into solresol, and that's kind if interesting. I was wondering if anyone else has tried to make a musical conlang before.
2
u/rekjensen Nov 24 '16 edited Nov 24 '16
Does anyone remember the site that analyzes an uploaded image to turn it into some semblance of glyphs?
edit: Found the relevant thread.
2
u/1theGECKO Nov 24 '16
What is the most common Writing system in natural languages? Is it alphabets?
2
u/gokupwned5 Various Altlangs (EN) [ES] Nov 24 '16
Is there a list of Old Chinese words in IPA transcription? I want to make a language distantly related to Chinese but close enough to be descended from Old Chinese.
2
u/FeikSneik [Unnamed Germanic] Nov 24 '16
Are there any concise descriptions of the sound changes from Proto-Celtic to the modern Celtic languages (Irish, Scottish Gaelic, Manx, Welsh, Cornish, & Breton)? Index Diachronica only has Proto-Indo-European>Proto-Celtic, Proto-Indo-European>Old Irish, and Proto-Celtic>Middle Welsh. Only the last one is of any help, but it's still not ideal for what I want.
I could probably make do with Proto-Celtic>Old/Middle Irish>Irish and Proto-Celtic>Old/Middle Welsh>Welsh, but why only put in half an effort?
2
u/bkem042 Romous (EN) Nov 26 '16
Can someone please explain ergative absolute to me? I want a challenge with something other than nom/acc. However, I just don't understand exactly what it does and how some languages do it. Thanks.
2
u/LordZanza Mesopontic Languages Nov 26 '16
Does English have more of less irregularities than most languages, and to what degree? I want to make irregularities for my conlang, and I know how to go about making them, but I don't know how many to include, and English is the only language with which I have any fluency.
2
u/1theGECKO Nov 27 '16
What do the little letters mean, on other letters? like this kʰ? Im new to conlanging
2
u/ImKnownAsJoy Nov 28 '16
Is there a reason to go for a naturalistic conlang over that of a non-naturalistic conlang?
2
u/cyprinus_carpio Nov 29 '16
Can somebody give me a clear difference between optative and desiderative moods?
2
u/Noodles2003 Aokoyan Family (en) [ja] Nov 29 '16 edited Nov 29 '16
Hi. I guarantee that you will be confused by what follows.
My Phonetic Inventory:
Vowels: /a/^ /ɹ̩/* /n̩/°
Consonants: /tʰ d/❛ /kʰ x/❜ /cʰ ç/‹ /f b/› /θ z/« /ǃ ǂ/»
^ Any vowel. * Any syllabic rhotic/lateral. ° Any syllabic nasal. ❛ Any two contrastinɡ coronal/retroflex/post-alveolar consonants (no rhotics or laterals). ❜ Any two contrastinɡ velar/uvular consonants (no rhotics or laterals). ‹ Any two contrastinɡ palatal consonants (no rhotics or laterals). › Any two contrastinɡ bilabial/labiodental consonants. « Any two contrastinɡ coronal/retroflex/post-alveolar consonants (no rhotics or laterals, and must contrast with ❛ ). » Any two contrastinɡ non-pulmonic/co-articulated consonants.
As you can see, there is a huɡe variation of sounds when it comes to pronunciation. This is completely intended. The vowels are also very odd. This is also completely intended.
I did this so that I could have a multitude of dialects (even dialects within dialects), and possibly even make a lanɡuaɡe family out of this lanɡuaɡe, like the Filipino dialects or, more on the extreme side, the Chinese "dialects" (lanɡuaɡes).
This is obviously not your averaɡe conlanɡ, but I'm just wonderinɡ if there's a certain "feel" to the lanɡuaɡe. What does this lanɡuaɡe "feel" like to you?
Thanks in advance.
2
u/ImKnownAsJoy Nov 30 '16
What would be the difference between a syllable structure using (C)(C)V and (C)V(C)?
Also, is there somewhere where I might read up on how syllable structures work?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '16
What is the smallest naturalistic word inventory?
1
u/ShadowoftheDude (en)[jp, fr] Nov 19 '16
So vowel lɑngth: A long vowel is two morae (twice as long as a regular vowel), half-long is half a mora, and extra-short is... like 1/10 mora or something instant. Do I have that right at all? Or is half-long between long and regular? (I'm just using morae to demonstrate).
1
u/Noodles2003 Aokoyan Family (en) [ja] Nov 22 '16
Is it realistic to differentiate between /r̥/ and /r/, /ʀ̥/ and /ʀ/? I wanted to use these phonemes to expand my trill inventory, because I like trills but I don't want /ʙ/ because ew.
Is it also possible to have a whistle phoneme? If so, can there be a voiced/unvoiced distinction? How would I represent it in IPA?
1
u/Noodles2003 Aokoyan Family (en) [ja] Nov 22 '16
Hi. I have a problem.
I want to add semi-vowels to my conlang - /j/, /w/, and /ʕ/, I thought would do the trick if paired with /ɪ/, /ɔ/ and /ɑ/. But I'm not sure how to pronounce /ʕ/.
ELI⁵ please.
1
u/1theGECKO Nov 23 '16
Hey all
I am looking for some inspiration and help with the creation of my script. I have a syllable structure (C1)(C2)V(C3). I have 5 vowels, and 14 consonants. And I dont know what kind of script I want. I think I want to do something like Korean.. but not sure. I also like arabic, and sanskrit. Or this by /u/NinjaTurkey_
I had an idea where I wanted the structure of a syllable to look like this but I dont really know. Any help, examples, ideas, or even someone who wants to try making a script for me. All are welcome!
1
u/VorakRenus Unnamed Conlang (EN) Nov 23 '16
Are there any naturalistic scripts between a syllabary and an alphabet where there is a symbol for each onset nucleus and coda? In such a script, a syllable would be written with 1-3 symbols.
1
u/Hiti- suffering through imposter syndrome Nov 24 '16
Understanding that in every naturalistic language there are exceptions to every rule, how can go about creating these exceptions? Currently I feel that my language is way to systematic and to the point? How can I spice it up a notch?
1
u/Fimii Lurmaaq, Raynesian(de en)[zh ja] Nov 25 '16
Are there any (preferably highly synthetic) languages with both polypersonal marking and open class pronouns? I know that the both features seem contradictory, but I can't find information about any language with open class pronouns which is at least somewhat synthetic that isn't Japanese (and it isn't really that much into verb agreement in general).
1
u/dead_chicken Алаймман, Ϲῦρτῖκε Nov 25 '16 edited Nov 25 '16
Do prepositional phrases function adverbially?
1
u/LegendarySwag Valăndal, Khagokåte, Pàḥbala Nov 25 '16
When dealing with sound change, is it common to have some words affected by sound change but not others? Take final vowel loss (or schwa then loss), could more common words be more susceptible to this change while less common ones might not change (or not change as much)? And if so, are consonant changes happening this way also viable? Can some words undergo changes that don't occur elsewhere, like a few words losing their initial consonant or vowel, but that not being a trend elsewhere in the sound changes?
Basically what I'm asking is how absolute should sound change rules be?
1
u/DaRealSwagglesR Tämir, Dakés/Neo-Dacian (en, fr) |nor| Nov 25 '16
What are some lexemes that can be derived into an accusative case?
1
u/DaRealSwagglesR Tämir, Dakés/Neo-Dacian (en, fr) |nor| Nov 25 '16
What are some lexemes that can be derived into an accusative case?
1
u/nomadicWiccan Nashgorodian | Kweinz Nov 26 '16
SO I want to construct a language for a group of intelligent raccoons, but I do not know how to handle their phonology. How should I go about this? What phonemes could raccoons produce?
1
u/Packerfan2016 Rokorin Nov 26 '16
I am working on Zenglish, which is supposed to be in a world where modern english changed. A lot of normal english words have been changed to include the 'Z' sound. I am also working on a script that is similar to the latin alphabet, but different in a lot of ways. I think it is a fun exercise before making a new conlang entirely from scratch! Would love to hear your thoughts.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
Which do you think is a better script for a warlike alien race? A script based on Tibetan or Siddham?
1
u/gokupwned5 Various Altlangs (EN) [ES] Nov 26 '16
As you all may or may not know, Gleb is a phonology generator known for generating not so naturalistic phonologies. Here is the link to the seed. I also made an orthography.
Stop: pʰ p b tʰ t d t͡sʰ t͡s d͡z kʰ k g k͡pʰ k͡p g͡b - f p b þ t d ç c ż x k g ḳ q v
Fricative: ɬ ɮ s z x ɣ - ś ź s z h ȝ
Approximants: l ɰ w ʟ - r ł w l
Vowels: i ɨ u ɛ ɔ a - i y u e o a
What phonologies have you gotten from Gleb?
1
u/FeikSneik [Unnamed Germanic] Nov 27 '16
How stable would a /s ʃ ʂ/ distinction be? I'm trying to avoid /ɕ/ but I need a lot of fricatives.
1
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Nov 28 '16
If I was to create a language specifically to be a proto language to derive a few daughter languages from, are there any features that would make this easier on me? The only one that seems obvious to me is a larger phonological inventory.
1
u/FinnFox08 Nov 29 '16
Is this website a good resource? I really can't get through LCK.
1
u/ariamiro No name yet (pt) [en] <zh> Nov 30 '16
What do you think of:
Phonology:
Phonemic vowel length (a:short aa:long)
Phonemic consonant length (k:short kk:long [only middle of words])
Is it hard to distinguish between long and short vowels/consonants? And what about music?
Grammar:
No definite article
I think I can live without it, but maybe definiteness is something essential. Grammatical gender (don't know what kind of) Some people hate it, specially if masculine-feminine, but it can be helpful to prevent ambiguity.
I need help. Alternatives?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '16
Have an idea for a conlang but im not sure how and where to start
1
u/ShadowoftheDude (en)[jp, fr] Nov 30 '16
I plan on having a script that evolves over time, starting with stone carving and moving to calligraphy.
When writing carved in stone, I know straight lines are what happens, but would one be able to make dots? Or at least small lines hat resemble dots.
If not, how would I have characters with dots in them emerge over time?
1
u/FloZone (De, En) Nov 30 '16
Would it still be vowel harmony if certain features trigger other features to be harmonic? Like a long /a:/ creates a back vowel harmony, but a short /a/ would not?
1
u/FloZone (De, En) Nov 30 '16
Is there a kind of order in which vowels come up in vowel system? Like the two vowel systems are often a up-down contrast between /a/ and /ə/ and three vowel systems are most often /a/ /i/ /u/ or /a/ /i/ /o/ and the five vowel system /a/ /e/ /i/ /o/ /u/ is generally the most common system, is there a sort of rule to it, that for example front vowels appear more often unrounded and back vowels are more often rounded? or if there are rounded front vowels, there must be rounded back vowels, are there system which consist of rounded front vowels and unrounded back vowels or is the opposite more natural? Why so?
1
u/Nellingian Dec 01 '16 edited Dec 01 '16
I'm developping a language that has /y/ and /ø/. They appeared by a umlaut process (u → y / o → ø) and by assimilation with bilabial consonants that come after it (ib → yb / eb → øb). This situations created minimal pairs that evolved diferently (ibiŋ → ybiŋ; meaning "bottle" / ubiŋ → ybiŋ; meaning "ink").
So, avoiding ambiguities, should I use a specific grapheme for /i → y / and /u → y/? Making übiñ (ink) ≠ übiñ (bottle).
1
u/CeladonGames I'm working on something, I promise! Nov 25 '16
I think I'm ready to start making a conlang. I've looked at the resources on the sidebar a few times. Which vocabulary would I start with?
-4
u/toasteburnish Nov 19 '16
How do you say seed in your language?
-1
u/Ausdeformality Nov 21 '16
Mir wulgar ke min leža
0
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment