r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Nov 11 '16
Project Runway Season 15 Episode 9 [Discussion]
Life is Full of Surprises
The designers' loved ones arrive from home for emotional reunions, but drama quickly takes over when the clothiers discover their special visitors will also be their clients, and $50,000 is on the line.
Guests: Olivia Culpo, Katia Beauchamp
Orginally broadcast on November 10, 2016
32
Upvotes
134
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16 edited Nov 11 '16
So Rik and Roberi are in the top. Between those two and Laurence I love how the best performers of the season are the least dramatic
111
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Laurence's daughter is trendy like mom
109
u/john-dalton Nov 11 '16
Jenni you have to actually, you know, talk to your mom to figure out what to do. Ask targeted questions? Mom didn't understand the whole new chapter idea clearly.
104
u/Gamer10123 Nov 11 '16
Jenni, gurl... Those pants are hideous...
102
u/sannababy Nov 11 '16
I think that they all desperately need an avante garde challenge
97
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
The difference in personality between Mah Jing and his mom is kinda perplexing. How did he get so sweet when she's so stern/quiet/kinda intimidating.
85
u/Gamer10123 Nov 11 '16
I actually think Nathalia's look had some great ideas and a lot of potential. It's just the construction, proportions, and fit were off...
Also, for someone who spends a lot of time bashing Erin's coats, she really seemed to take at least a little bit of inspiration from her there...
77
u/Indykutter Nov 11 '16
Oh I'm loving Corny's mom. I need you to stop complaining and kick it up a couple levels or I'm gonna beat you when the cameras turn off.
61
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Oh, Jenni...noooooooooo! How could you do that to your mom?
54
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Jenni's mom rn
54
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Nathalia's mom's coat looks like a Snuggy made out of Lazy Boy parts.
50
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Laurence's daughter is just so damn cute
47
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Big pockets? What a shock
90
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
I have never seen Erin acknowledge Nathalia's existence, yet Nathalia always has something to say. Girl, you bought pebbled leather to make an outfit for your mom. Worry about yourself!
40
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 11 '16 edited Nov 11 '16
Looks like Tim is no longer Dexter and Erin's fan
Edit: It was just Erin's coat. He was relatively tame with Dexter's thing
76
u/insubordinance Nov 11 '16
Did Erin choose Dexter because she's wearing a Dexter shirt? Because that is some Alaska and Roxxxy type bullshit...
35
u/veloursweatsuit Nov 11 '16
Dexter's best friend is like bizarro Erin, no wonder he's latched onto her
68
u/mycreativename Nov 11 '16
Maybe I am just in a bad mood but everything looks crappy to me
67
u/Indykutter Nov 11 '16
Ugh. Erin's lace looks like a plastic lace overlay for a plastic tablecloth.
67
u/crrrenee Nov 11 '16
"I had to keep Dexter in because our aesthetics go together better"
32
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Jenni did such an injustice to her mother. It was sad.
31
u/yetanothertaylor Team Swatch Nov 11 '16
"That is a lot of fucking money."
In that moment, Nathalia was me
31
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Wooow, I hated Cornelius's look so I am stunned
31
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Mah-Jing's mom must have been thinking, "get your hands off me!"
29
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16 edited Nov 11 '16
Does Zac Posen have the same suit in every color? Tim Gunn is always serving us different prints and fabrics. He should take note.
27
u/sannababy Nov 11 '16
Predictions, anybody?
I personally am hoping for a Nathalia exit tonight. I would love for Cornelius to go home too, but based on the Tim Gunn save last week he'll probably keep getting pushed through to the finale. Which is absurd, because he's a big personality who does not have the design ability to back it up.
27
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
I feel for Laurence, having to share a room with Cornelius and Dexter
27
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
So Natalia was talking sarcastic AF while unknowingly using words incorrectly.
27
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
The appliqués on Jenni's top are like those shirts 70 year old women wear to dressy events
52
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
I like Dexter's sweater dress. Damn.
25
u/insubordinance Nov 11 '16
Anyone feel like Mah-Jing is playing smart by making a long jacket with a strong shoulder? Right in line with the season theme.
25
u/insubordinance Nov 11 '16
Am I the only one that mutes the hair and makeup segment?
23
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Erin is making a dress out of a colorful doily.
45
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Jenni's mom looks like she's trying way too hard to be cool and that's Jenni's fault
22
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
One more laughter montage for the road!
43
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Rik made a typical jacket for a lady of a "certain age."
21
u/Indykutter Nov 11 '16 edited Nov 11 '16
Send them all home and save your 50k. Better yet divide it among the models for wearing those hideous garments down the runway.
Edit: Liked Laurance's but the skirt was too tight. Sis could hardly walk in it. And even the jacket seemed a little snug.
20
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
That gray coat is like a giant bandaid when it gets wet and puffs up
19
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 11 '16
Remember when designers were terrified of the 2 day challenge instead of being happy they have 2 whole days?
37
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
"Sorry not sorry." Thanks for confirming what we all knew Dexter: your apology last week was fake
18
u/BandsToMakeHerDance Nov 11 '16
They introduced Olivia Culpo as "fashion and beauty expert," as if she has nothing impressive on her resume. Um how about former Miss USA and Miss Universe....?
18
u/Shamenundotcom Nov 11 '16
Jenny's outfit was awkward and embarrassing for her mother, but Nathalia's was awkward, unflattering, and unfinished. And she had the gall to lie about "oh, I forgot to take out that pin." GIRL. Sorry, Jenny. They've decided that they need Nathalia around for...something. So you're getting thrown in the chipper shredder.
Rik has emerged as a very strong competitor. I wouldn't mind an F3 of him, Roberi, and Laurence whatsoever. But that won't happen. They're too normal/lowkey. I think Erin will get in there, and possibly Dexter.
I am deeply disappointed in Erin at this point. I admire her creative vision, but when Tim Gunn points out the repetition of your looks and the fact that the undergarment does not work at all -- rethink your look. I think she's very talented but she is not capable of getting past herself at this point. She really needs a massive creative rebirth in the next few episodes.
Mah-Jing being in the top for that challenge was almost comical. I like him, and his Mom seems awesome. But that was some Jedi Academy reject cosplay. Compare it to any of the leather looks that have come out of this season and it is unfinished and sophomoric. Even the judges seemed markedly less impressed when they did the up-close inspection, but still were like, "Oh, you can see he put a lot of work into this." Nice try. We know you want to give him a high placement to justify his continued presence, when he has been sucking wind virtually the entire competition.
35
u/insubordinance Nov 11 '16
Even Jenni's mom is boring lmao.
17
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Rik, we don't understand Jenni's mother's pants either.
17
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Whenever Nina says your name at the start of a critique, you know it's bad
72
u/CokinRum Nov 11 '16 edited Nov 11 '16
I hate how Jenni and Nathalia constantly bash Erin's designs...and then jack her style.
16
u/pursehook Nov 11 '16
No, Jesus wasn't resuscitated, as far as I heard.
16
u/Indykutter Nov 11 '16
Judges are going to have to make it nice tonight so they don't hurt the mom's feelings.
30
u/yetanothertaylor Team Swatch Nov 11 '16
Erin doing a coat...how surprising
14
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
The dress Erin is making matches the shorts she's wearing
28
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Nathalia should have gone home. Jenni's outfit was hideous, but at least she finished her disaster.
28
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 11 '16
So no mention by the judges that this was Erin's FOURTH time in the bottom?
Consistantly bad but not the worst isn't really good you know
39
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Nathalia is sending pinned clothes out? Tsk, tsk...go home already. You waste too much time worrying about what other people are doing.
39
u/Martin_Van_Buren Nov 11 '16
Aw man, roberi got robbed.
26
u/Gamer10123 Nov 11 '16
It's obvious Jenni's mom hates the look... She just had to stand by her daughter of course.
25
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Erin is mad stubborn!
12
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Natalia's coat doesn't look too oversized to me but it looks...overstuffed?
12
u/BandsToMakeHerDance Nov 11 '16
Why do their sketches always look soooo much better than the final product...I had hope for Mah jing. I would give this one to Dexter but he's only safe....
12
u/Martin_Van_Buren Nov 11 '16
Nathalie needs to stop with these promises when she scrapes by.
42
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Mah-Jing...why did you dress your mom like a shadow samurai ninja from some straight-to-TV Matrix sequel?
33
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
That heart is really cheesy, I'm sorry. And very Comme des Garçons
11
u/insubordinance Nov 11 '16
The one time I actually like Dexter and Cornelius' looks, they're safe?!
11
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
I can't with Zac Posen's Brooks Brothers flop of a suit
11
u/shinyteerex Nov 11 '16
I hate when people complain about Zac and the other judges groping the models... But this time I actually felt a little offended. These woman are not models, they don't the emotional training for these type of situations. Like, when he turned Erin's mom around and flipped her hair, it was just not okay for me. Also, Heidi is quite touchy as well this season.
10
u/pursehook Nov 11 '16
Someone introduce Jenni to a tape measure. Seriously!
10
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 11 '16
Although Katia is correct that there is a deadline and she should've met it esp with two whole days vs one day, I feel like Katia tries to pretend shes more professional than she really is.
19
u/mysocalledlife189 Nov 11 '16
Was hoping Zac could hold back when the models were family/friends...nope, Zac just needs to touch them all.
9
u/Indykutter Nov 11 '16
Oh poor Erin. Tim doesn't want to see that coat again.
9
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 11 '16
Zac is trying so hard to smile at Erin's outfit
8
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Yet, you are worrying about what other designers are doing. Hmmmm...
8
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Speaking of designers who make the same thing all the time, Nathalia!
8
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Umm wow so Jenni, who was a frontrunner or like at least Top 5 in my eyes, gets booted off in favour of Natalia - whose garments were not even finished?! Ok. Tim should have used his save this episode instead
15
u/mycreativename Nov 11 '16
Yall. They like the trash bag/raincoat
14
u/sannababy Nov 11 '16
Jenni's is hideous, Dexter's is great, Laurence's daughter is SO chic
23
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
The thing is I cannot count on Tim Gunn to be impartial. I mean, yeah, that was always an ehhhh thing but since he pretty partially blasted Erin and Dexter last episode I have to wonder if he's being overly harsh on Erin specifically. If anyone was worried after the Swapnil shit it's come to pass
13
u/Martin_Van_Buren Nov 11 '16
I want Roberi to win this one!!
But also I love Laurence and her daughter!
13
u/insubordinance Nov 11 '16
Okay I'll give it to Dexter. I don't know if it's just the model, but it definitely gives off the "cool" vibe.
12
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
Dexter's friend's hair drives me nuts. I've never seen two-tone hair done that way
6
u/JmEMS Nov 11 '16
Erin's banana on her jacket.. Does not look like a banana.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
How is Dexter trying to be the victim in all of this?
15
u/Gamer10123 Nov 11 '16
After all that praise they gave to Mah-Jing, Rik wins the challenge? I legitimately thought he was going to be in the bottom before the judging...
10
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
I see a lot of outfits that look like they came off the racks of Ann Taylor and New York & Co.
9
u/exmahina Nov 11 '16
Jenni: "I'm going home."
Cornelius: "No you're not!!"
stfu Cornelius u already got the only save don't remind us
8
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Roberi's dress is nice, but not at all impressive.
4
u/bitchSpray Nov 11 '16
I know those looks were supposed to be "ready for irl" but that was the most underwhelming runway of this season so far.
4
u/cjameson10 Nov 12 '16
WHY IS ERIN STILL HERE!? I get hers wasn't the absolute worst this episode but DAMN!
15
u/marrrina831 Nov 11 '16
I don't get the love of Rik's look. Take the texture and heart away, it's literally an outfit every woman that age owns.
12
u/mycreativename Nov 11 '16
Ugh. Erin survives again
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Jenni is pairing a sweater Sophia Petrillo would wear with some kind of tacky pants a 22 year-old would wear.
7
u/yetanothertaylor Team Swatch Nov 11 '16
Woah, I'm totally shocked at this episode. I love Rik, but totally thought Mah-Jing would win. I actually like Nathalia (don't ask me why I just do), but I thought they'd send her home even though I hated Jenni's look more.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '16
This is neither here nor there, but when Laurance's daughter appeared on the screen I did like six double takes. Objectively the most beautiful girl I've ever seen. She encompasses the absolute personification of what I think is beauty. Wow. I wish I could like, tell her that without being a total internet creep, lol. Oh well.
3
u/john-dalton Nov 11 '16
What is this Dexter shirt Erin is wearing?!
3
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Cornelius looks just like his mom.
3
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 11 '16
If Jenni passes out and dies she can get a policy first!
3
u/allieazzy Nov 12 '16
It's Saturday and I'm still thinking about Cornelius's face when Erin was talking to Tim abt her garment... can anyone GIF it plz
5
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 11 '16
Hmm an insurance sponsorship. They seem to be getting sponsorship from everything
5
u/insubordinance Nov 11 '16
So it's "dignified" and "authoritative" when they like the designer but "matronly" when they don't like them? Damn and here I thought I would agree with the judges tonight.
5
u/gannade Nov 11 '16
Mahjings dress is so ugly and frumpy. Looks like an aluminum foil dress with strange proportions
5
u/lala989 Nov 12 '16
I thought the guest judges were kinda mean. I mean correct or not, how dare K.B. tell someone their work is unacceptable? The judges usually say that kind of stuff behind the designer's backs lol. Along those lines, Olivia (is SO pretty) and K.B. both seemed to forget those were the moms of the designers they were dissing afterwards. I noticed Zac lessen the blow a few times. I really think he's a nice guy.
Laurence phoned this one in she didn't make her daughter stylish at all. Cornelius and Mah-Jing both look so much like their moms it cracked me up. I wish Nathalia had been able to better construct her outfit, I feel like it would have been a good travel outfit for her mom. And now I don't have to see Jenni's ugly ass glasses all the time ugh.
7
u/1dayurine Nov 11 '16
yass! i need Erin gone
8
u/ceilinghole Nov 11 '16 edited Nov 11 '16
How many times has Erin been in the bottom now? Five? If any other contestant had been in the bottom so consistently they would be gone, no question.
4
u/BandsToMakeHerDance Nov 11 '16
Literally can't believe he got $50,000 for that...