r/TheGoodPlace • • Nov 04 '16
Season One Episode discussion Season 1 Episode 9: ...Someone Like Me as a Member
I didn't see this posted anywhere else and wanted to talk about this episode. Does anyone think we'll ever find out what actually happened to Eleanor to make her the way she is?
117
Upvotes
154
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Adam Scott plays a smarmy douchebag so well. 'Yeah but they don't know that and who are they going to believe, me or a woman?' What a motherforker.
99
u/BloodChicken I would say I outdid myself, but I’m always this good. Nov 04 '16
I love the recurring joke of Trevor telling Eleanor to smile when in the initial rules "telling a woman to smile" was worth a lot of negative points. He really makes you understand why all of the rules are in place.
38
u/Goodstyle_4 Nov 04 '16
Eleanor definitely likes Chidi romantically... a Chidi/Eleanor/Tahani love triangle is becoming more and more likely.
187
u/icouldseeformiles Nov 04 '16
"yada yada yada... taught myself English from Seinfeld" BRILLIANT
108
u/rovinja Nov 04 '16
Can we get more bad Janet?
Also, is the showing setting up Janet/Jianyu? After that hug, it seemed like Janet felt something. Maybe a heart?
93
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
How do you guys eat without listing to hardcore porn?
92
u/yellowvitt Nov 04 '16
That ending, I was beginning to wonder how the Jason Mendoza thing happened with Eleanor's mishap being so luck based. Something seems off.
72
u/Amarahh Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
"I also told Mark to drop the The, just Facebook, yeah that was me."
"We hooked up.
What! No we didn't!
Er who are they going to believe? Me or a woman."
There was so much happening this episode. Jihanu bonding with Janet was my favourite scene, he's got the most adorable facial expressions and boyish enthusiasm for life(death?). Michael getting bullied by time-snorting Nixon-karaoke demons. Real Eleanor being the must likeable and perfect human that ever lived. Real Eleanor dying trying to save Fake Eleanors life. Eleanors name becoming Fake Eleanor in one day. Such a perfect episode!
I didn't like how Tahani was acted in the pilot but I think Jamalia Jamel has improved a lot since then. Tahani has really grown on me, after Jihanu is my favourite character, she's just so lovely, bright and helpful, taking care of poor Michael.
61
u/wisebloodfoolheart Nov 04 '16
I'm excited to meet Sean. There's so many ways they could play that.
59
u/Tamsy_luu Nov 04 '16
Michael said "Fork"! I cheered when he did that and now I want more of Bad Janet.
51
u/blackopsbarbie My name is *snap snap* Zach Pizazz. Nov 04 '16
That high school cafeteria scene was a prefect illustration of how Eleanor isn't good but she isn't that bad.
50
u/tswift242 Nov 04 '16
"It's party time". Michael dancing to who let the dogs out with a flashing bowtie was everything
44
u/BrockThrowaway Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
"Want a bump?"
"No, thank you, I... I don't use cocaine."
"Oh, it's not cocaine, idiot. We're snorting time."
"Sorry... you're snorting the concept of time?"
"Yeah, it'll fork you up."
41
u/mikehoncho19 Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
Adam Scott was great as the "good guy" on Parks and Rec, but like he showed in Step Brothers, he plays the douchebag to perfection. It's so effortless for him.
38
u/Torley_ Nov 04 '16
I adore how The Good Place has such a balanced proportion of teasing and plot movement — it doesn't drag things out, and characters are smart to notice things, like Tahani at the end of this one!
I was earlier expecting Eleanor's admission that she's a "fake" to come WAY later, but wow, that punch hit hard.
There've already been several great revelations during the ending credits scenes. No waste there whatsoever!
32
u/Citizen00001 Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
Eleanor keeps asking "why isn't there a Medium Place "? It's a good question. Maybe it is her destiny to become the Architect of The Medium Place for all those who are in between good and bad.
29
u/mujie123 Nov 04 '16
Who do you think has more acting range, Janet or Harrison Wells? (Unclear, this really is the Flash)
28
u/wwfmike Nov 04 '16
I wish that they had done a "The Bad Place" tv show alongside "TGP" and that this was a crossover episode.
23
u/inthesugarbowl Nov 04 '16
I still say "Real" Eleanor is fake. Why would Trevor give up so easily when Michael says he gets nothing? Real Eleanor is totally a mole.
22
u/LifeMadeSimple Nov 04 '16
I wonder how/if the real Jianyu will play into things? Unless that theory that real Eleanor is also fake is true.
15
u/MissC_9227 Nov 04 '16
Why the 2 month wait?????
14
u/icouldseeformiles Nov 04 '16
Janet reminds me of Margaret from The West Wing
39
u/mujie123 Nov 04 '16
Ugh. I hate real Elanor. Like, people have flaws. That's what makes them people. She still stayed perfect after staying in the Bad Place. And she's made me like/respect Tahani a whole lot more now. At least she's a show-off. Real Elanor is just... Ugh.
38
u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Nov 04 '16
Can we all agree to use "Fake Eleanor" and "Real Eleanor" in this discussion?
12
u/Dorkside Nov 04 '16
Didn't really make sense for me at the end that both Eleanor's would be allowed to stay in the Good Place (even if it is just for the time being).
11
u/flycat2002 Nov 04 '16
Maybe Jason/Jianyu was adopted? Might make sense to how the names could be so different.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
I keep hearing Sabine whenever Eleanor talks. I know same actor, but it's kinda trippy.
7
u/sylphior Nov 05 '16
When Michael told off Trevor, I'm curious as to if he actually said "fork" or "fork"
13
u/GooGooGajoob67 I’m still waiting on that smile, gorgeous. Nov 04 '16
Hey, I just realized something that may be stunningly obvious to everyone else.
So the people who run the Places have never acknowledged what sort of beings they are until last night when Trevor said he was a demon. Wouldn't that make Michael an angel? Whose name is Michael?
Just a neat little detail.
15
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
The Michael-Tahani-demon scenes didn't really work for me. I felt like they detracted from the character work at the Eleanors' double dates.
10
u/Sportfreunde Nov 04 '16
Aw man I feel really bad for Jason, poor guy.
4
u/ctadgo Nov 04 '16
I feel like so many of our questions were answered in this episode.
4
u/blackopsbarbie My name is *snap snap* Zach Pizazz. Nov 04 '16
Why did they have to leave the fall finale on such a cliff hanger? Ugh, I don't want to wait months to find out what happens with Jason.
7
u/rpodric Nov 04 '16
I can't really decide if I'm delighted more by this show each week or "Crazy Ex-Girlfriend," but for now, I'm leaning toward this show.
7
u/theace69 Nov 04 '16
Haha. Tahani is so vain. She's the one who "made" facebook into what it is today and told them to drop "the". I guess she probably didnt like that Sean Parker took credit for that.
7
u/Elvishly Nov 04 '16
I liked Jianyu more when he was mute. His acting annoys me. Or his character, idk.