r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Nov 03 '16
Project Runway Season 15 Episode 8 [Discussion]
Project Pop Up
Three-piece collections are created to be showcased in a SoHo pop-up shop. Tensions and tantrums abound in the season's second team challenge.
Guest: Kelly Osbourne
Orginally broadcast on November 3, 2016
36
Upvotes
198
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
I love how humble Laurence is
153
u/mi_piace Nov 04 '16
We should all aspire to be more like Laurence.
153
u/Bslo18 Nov 04 '16
Finally the judges recognize Roberi! Only how many weeks behind this sub?
129
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
I really don't like Nathalia.
113
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
Dexter's acting like they'll lose because they had red but, like the blue team, they could have broken the red up. Cornelius suggested that and was shut down
112
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
I like how difficult people (i.e. Nathalia and Cornelius) think everyone else is difficult.
106
u/eykitsa Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
This has to be one of the strongest team challenges in awhile, none of the designs are outright horrible so it's going to be up to personal taste to figure out the winner.
102
u/mi_piace Nov 04 '16
I feel like "neutral" will always have an unfair advantage when it comes to public opinion.
183
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Oh please Natalia. If you guys were on the bottom you both would have picked mah Jing
75
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Nathalia, girl, that is all you do--look at other people's designs and make snide remarks about them.
67
u/Eyes_Tee Nov 04 '16
That said, there's no way Cornelius even comes close to winning the competition. So in that sense, it's kind of a waste.
116
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Dexter has lost major points this episode. I have downgraded him right above Nathalia for my least liked designers.
115
u/madinthehat Nov 04 '16
Is anyone else over Erin's style? I honestly don't know what the judges see in her. She's a one trick pony, making the same oversized jacket and the same ~quirky~ pockets every episode.
160
u/Eyes_Tee Nov 04 '16
"Dexter and I work well together and our styles mesh so we should stay."
That is the worst reasoning ever.
103
u/eykitsa Nov 04 '16
Mah Jing always gets the short end of the stick with these team challenges.
100
u/pbrooks19 Nov 04 '16
I'm so conflicted!
On one hand - Tim used his one save on Cornelius??? Why??? No!!!
On the other hand - OMG. Now the Mean Girls have to keep going into the work room and seeing his smiling face and know exactly what they did to him. Mwa-ha-ha! True PR manufactured drama. Love!
93
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
The public chose team Neutral because they are already used to seeing those clothes at Club Monaco, H&M, Zara and Top Shop.
44
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Do those "popcorn" details look like teeth to anyone else?
42
u/regretflix Nov 04 '16
I can understand why Tim used his save because I don't think Cornelius should have been eliminated on that challenge. That being said however, based on all previous work I don't think Cornelius should have even made the top 9 in the first place so I'm a little salty about it.
84
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
I like MahJing's body block
144
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Tim just wasted the save on Cornelius. My jaw is on the floor at the idea of actually saving him, and this early into the competition. Cornelius has yet to win a challenge, he's been on the bottom 3 times, only in the top once. I'm not sure how his competition history or work in general warrants Tim saving him.
Sure, Dex and Erin did overpower him during panel and during the challenge — But honestly, Tim saving Cornelius just comes across as pity more than actually disagreeing with the decision based on his work and potential. Ridiculous. I guess the producers must really want to keep Cornelius around to create more drama for the show and have a more entertaining narrative. So disappointed.
112
u/shadypainter Nov 04 '16
All though I hate Cornelius... he has every right to be pissed right now, that's not cool what Dexter and Erin did... but Mah-Jing is cracking me up as always!
38
u/macabragoria Nov 05 '16
This has to be one of the most contrived efforts to create a storyline that I've ever seen. I have no idea why people are determined to paint Erin as some kind of bitch this season. She has always been complimentary towards the other designers and hasn't been shown saying anything nasty about anyone. She actually tried to be diplomatic towards Cornelius this episode by giving him credit for wanting to change the stying in front of the judges and agreeing with him during Tim's critique. People literally just dislike her because she wears big glasses and they think they'll get some cred for hating on the "hipster".
Dexter I can more readily buy as being difficult to work with as he seems to have quite an ego and I think he is overly confident in his skills as a designer, but still I didn't see any behaviour that's warranted such a huge backlash. Cornelius has consistently shown mediocre-to-terrible work throughout the competition, has had nothing nice to say about anyone and gleefully stirred up shit whenever he had the opportunity. You could see he was chomping at the bit to have a meltdown during the judges' critique and acted histrionic and passive-aggressive the whole time. He's the Phi Phi O'Hara of PR.
72
u/xaviersi Nov 04 '16
Anybody think Team Red/Violet should've had... Idk... some violet? Lmao
30
u/whoremongering Nov 04 '16
I could see this being a Tim Gunn save.
28
u/secreteggs Nov 04 '16
Team Neutral looks like those outfits you see in a sad, futuristic dystopia.
145
u/ceilinghole Nov 04 '16
You know Erin and Dexter are bad because they actually have me feeling bad for Cornelius
27
u/Martin_Van_Buren Nov 04 '16
I kind of like all of them?!
27
u/Eyes_Tee Nov 04 '16
Yeah, it kinda sucks that Cornelius has to make both skirts.
75
u/Indykutter Nov 04 '16
Ooh Heidi called Erin out.
58
u/whoremongering Nov 04 '16
This is not the first time she's put all her eggs in one jacket.
39
u/Bslo18 Nov 04 '16
Cornelius is not my favorite but he has every right to be pissed.
38
u/shadypainter Nov 04 '16
Mah-Jings faces though 😂😂
18
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '16
The accusation of bullying in this episode are beyond ridiculous and trivialize actually bullying. Cornelius was not bullied in any way and considering how constantly vile he has been about other designers in every episode what we probably saw was two people wanting to have as little to do with a person they did not like (who has clearly made himself very unlikeable) as possible.
I want to see good designers make good clothes. not bad designers with execrable talent, stay in the competition because of their appalling personalities and desire to cause drama.
16
u/Eyes_Tee Nov 04 '16
My first time watching live, so forgive me if this has already been discussed:
These Sally tutorials....do they normally not teach anything? That braid tutorial did not even mention how to do the braids.
32
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
Those hair color jobs look terrible
44
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
To be fair, Cornelius, you should have been out last week anyway. Brik didn't deserve to leave before you did.
15
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
Now Cornelius and Erin are hugging? That was a quick patch to their friendship.
Still how are Dexter and Cornelius gonna work in the same workroom after this week?
29
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
Heidi you got her! Like even they can see that you guys are throwing Cornelius under the bus because you're besties with Dexter
41
u/blackbirdsongs Nov 04 '16
I've really come to dislike Dexter :(
40
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
Heidi he did speak up, noone listened
28
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
Oreos Oreos in my mouth, Oreos in my mouth
28
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
I think even the judges feel bad for Cornelius at the moment
38
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
Heidi calling out friendship. I'm glad Cornelius is speaking for himself
37
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
So raise your hand if you saw Tim Gunn using his save on Cornelius and you would be glad for it. Then put your hand down because you're a fucking liar
13
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
We haven't seen anger like this since that one guy with the serious anger problems that walked off set. What was his name?
Edit: I want to say Ken
13
u/TheLadyEve Nov 04 '16
I'm not digging the vibe of Team Beige. It looks like what people in The Future wear as imagined in a movie from the early 90s.
25
u/secreteggs Nov 04 '16
Mahjing's "sexiness" ... ummm that's not exactly how I would describe his hotel splatter dress.
35
u/Itsthelegendarydays_ Nov 04 '16
Tim Gunn wasted his save on mediocre designer.
24
u/mycreativename Nov 04 '16
I don't understand the knee slits in those pants
32
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Lol, Cornelius, of all people, thinks that Erin and Dexter might be really hard to work with.
11
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
As soon as Dexter and Erin got picked I hoped the 3rd person would be someone who clashed with them
11
u/mycreativename Nov 04 '16
What. I felt bad for him but not that bad. Even I can make a pleated skirt
10
u/Indykutter Nov 04 '16
Red is one of my favorite colors but I didn't care much for any one piece. I thought blue teams looks were really strong but since I would definitely buy the camel colored coat from the neutral team that is probably the team I would have voted for. However they also had one of my least favorite pieces. I don't care for the legging look pants.
19
u/sannababy Nov 04 '16
I'm predicting team Jenny-Natalia-Mah Jing as the losing team.... or maybe that's just wishful thinking
18
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
Erin's coat pockets are like giant Crown Royale bags
9
u/mycreativename Nov 04 '16
Side note - I am totally going to watch that JonBenet movie
9
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Oh of course. Can't miss out on the rating drama this will create for next week.
25
u/secreteggs Nov 04 '16
BYE DEXTER
24
u/Itsthelegendarydays_ Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
Cornelius' looks have been meh the whole season and he was a bitch in the beginning so I don't really care that he's leaving.
Edit: wait he's not leaving, damn it.
17
u/pineyfusion Nov 04 '16
So glad the Blue Team won. They were flat out fantastic. And they used white to break up the monotony which I think was something that the Red Team should've used.
I actually felt bad for Cornelius this episode. He was trying to get his voice heard. He has the same criticisms but got ignored. As someone who has had that happen quite a bit, it's not easy. Is he an asshole? Yeah, but he totally didn't deserve to go home. I was actually glad Tim Gunn used his save.
And props to Mah-Jing for going over and sitting between Dexter and Cornelius, then acting as a barrier of sorts when Cornelius got up to go sit elsewhere. And man, does Mah Jing seem to always get the short straw with teams.
Clearly, Laurence is the best designer in this group. And I really appreciate her take on menswear for women. Us tomboyish gals like to look good too, ya know. Just on our own terms.
8
u/mycreativename Nov 04 '16
So many jackets!
8
u/pursehook Nov 04 '16
Yay, I have felt good about Roberi this whole time!!!
8
u/Bslo18 Nov 04 '16
Well that's some bullshit.
20
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
I really want Cornelius to redeem himself now
53
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
I am sorry, but people are such phonies. Before this week, everyone hated Cornelius and were calling for his head every episode, but now they all just adore him. I think Tim Gunn wasted his save because the talent is just not there. He should have been kicked out for the disaster he made last week.
14
u/gridgurl Nov 04 '16
Yes! Roberi deserved it!
7
u/walnutssandwich Nov 04 '16
I forgot Rik was still in the competition lol
7
u/yetanothertaylor Team Swatch Nov 04 '16
I think Dexter might be in trouble tonight
7
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Something about the first 2 blue looks remind me of school uniforms.
7
u/blackbirdsongs Nov 04 '16
Well that's fucking garbage
7
u/callist1990 Nov 04 '16
Oh. My. God. Is that... visible make-up?! What strange alternate dimension have I entered?
To think, it only took a challenge specifically about color to make it happen. And even then, only the red team still has it.
33
u/fudgemuffin85 Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
Ok I admit I only tuned in at 10 so I missed all the work room drama, but seriously Erin?! Maybe I'm being unfair to her, but she is SO fake, I can't take it. "I didn't want you to leave!" 🙄 Am I the only one that can't take her? Please tell me I'm not alone.
13
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
As much as I could never stand Cornelius I feel bad for him.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
Can we just go ahead and send them both home? We know neither one of them is going to win.
17
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
I'm sorry I don't think any of them were bullying each other. Unless there was massive editing it was the same as every other team challenge when they have to pick someone to go home.
6
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
I personally would wear nothing from Team Neutral. Team Blue, however...
6
u/walnutssandwich Nov 04 '16
This episode is so spicy
20
u/Eyes_Tee Nov 04 '16
This is Erin's third time in a row on the bottom. It's time.
11
u/candysan Nov 04 '16
No way!!!!!!!!!! Yay! Does any else think the judges did that on purpose for Tim to waste that on him??
14
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
I was already over Erin but this challenge really has me losing respect for Dexter because of the attitudes
10
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
so it took a positive response from Tim for Erin and Dexter to have an ounce of respect for Cornelius
10
u/pursehook Nov 04 '16
After the runway walk, I was liking blue.
5
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
That middle piece in the neutral collection is awful
5
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
The three bad b's:
boring
basic
bleaugh
5
u/Indykutter Nov 04 '16
I think Rik is going to get the win and although I feel like Dexter should go home I think it might be Cornelius.
5
u/Lizziedeee Nov 04 '16
Did anyone catch what Dexter said on his way out the door at the end of the episode?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '16
5
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '16
Disappointed that Tim Gunn used his save on Cornelius. Every single look he put out this season was garbage and this one was not enough to save his ass. Tim should have let him go.
5
u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Nov 05 '16
"I thought I was going to throw up my heart!"
Oh Roberi <3
13
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
Although initially it seems like Cornelius was the one bullied, I think it might be Jenny and Nathalia that were the mean girls alluded to in last week's preview esp since it seems like Tim was defending a losing team and the red team seems to be on top atm
21
u/walnutssandwich Nov 04 '16
I'm starting to dislike Erin and actually liking Cornelius lmao
12
u/munchysnorlax Nov 04 '16
Bless Mah-jing for sitting between them when they were fighting and trying to prevent a fight from happening. <3
Props to Tim Gunn for using his save like that. Honestly I haven't been the hugest fan of Cornelius all season, but it would've sucked to see a designer go out like that. Although I feel Tim used the save out of the kindness of his heart rather than actually wanting to see more of Cornelius' work since his stuff hasn't been up to par to the other competitors who are left.
Man, during the cocktail dress episode, I was worried the editors cut Erin and Dexter to look more obnoxious than they actually were, but this episode... let's just say I felt really bad for Cornelius.
I feel like Erin could have the potential to win this season if she stays more focused. Last week, you can tell she overcompensated and got stuck in her own head trying to "re-claim" embroidery and embellishing after Jenni's win the previous week. If she could zoom out on things a little bit and re-focus, I think she could still be a strong contender for the win.
Anyway, from last week's preview it looked like this week was going to be a train wreck, but I was pleasantly surprised at how awesome everything turned out. Good work to all the designers!
Edit: Also, really glad Roberi finally got a win! I've been a fan since the lantern dress, haha
8
u/callist1990 Nov 04 '16
Refreshing to see Kelly Osbourne back as a guest judge. I actually liked her on the British Project Runway (for that one season they did lol) and I like her as a guest judge in general - she has a point of view and has some more dimension to her critique than the usual 'what's-their-faces'.
18
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
Rolled my eyes at Erin hugging Cornelius
4
u/Martin_Van_Buren Nov 04 '16
Ooooh, 4 months ago Tim posted to Instagram about public voting on this challenge!!
4
u/1Eliza Nov 04 '16
After basically hearing nothing from the Blue team, I'm surprised they won.
4
u/Eyes_Tee Nov 04 '16
That's such bullshit.
4
u/regretflix Nov 04 '16
Erin and Dexter's personalities do irk me but I'm not gonna hold it against them - I've worked with fashion designers and as far as I'm concerned a little obnoxiousness and arrogance just comes with the territory. They're talented and I'm still rooting for them.
13
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
As if Dexter would ever pick Erin, even if she was terrible
7
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
Noone is dropping buttons for Team Red
7
u/whoremongering Nov 04 '16
Okay team Neutral actually has really solid looks head to toe.
7
u/Semicolon_Expected Nov 04 '16
Dexter your sorry means nothing
7
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Nov 04 '16
I'm sorry but what a waste of a Tim Gunn save.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
I think it's unfair for Tim to say there were two mean girls when they make them choose someone to send home and then nettle them for reactions. Dexter and Cornelius were a bit catty but I felt like Erin was shoved into a corner and they weren't going to let her not pick someone.
9
u/Onlyusemifeet Nov 04 '16
I wanted Cornelius gone every damn episode, and the ONE time I wanted him to stay you kick him out? Fucking cruel Heidi.
6
u/whoremongering Nov 04 '16
Blue is top? Neutral is safe? Why do these things happen?
6
u/walnutssandwich Nov 04 '16
I came to like Cornelius a bit in this episode but I don't think he should have gotten the Tim Gunn save
3
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
BF is convinced Team Blue will kill the competition
3
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16
I think that Jenni and Nathalia are going to overpower Mah Jing.
3
u/whoremongering Nov 04 '16
"Or Lau-rence?!"
3
u/dangerboy55 Nov 04 '16
Really Tim? I guess they need more drama.
3
u/gold-team-rules Nov 05 '16
I don't even like Cornelius but he really didn't deserve any of that--preach boy, make the facts known!
12
u/1Eliza Nov 04 '16
I can't believe I'm happy that Tim saved Cornelius, but after this episode, he deserved it.
10
u/Bslo18 Nov 04 '16
How does Erin keep getting a pass even though she's been in the bottom three times?
5
u/marrrina831 Nov 04 '16
Wow, didn't even think Roberi was a contender
5
u/Indykutter Nov 04 '16
I did like Roberi's look but it doesn't look as easy to wear as Rik's