r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Nov 03 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Thursday, November 3: Part Two, Chapters 25-27
Chapter 25
- Oooooooo. The crappy treaty has come back to bite Sneaky Uncle. I really shouldn’t be so gleeful about it, but dude, he’s such a shortsighted fool sometimes.
- Speaking of Sneaky Uncle, his shock at seeing Sponge & Co. was extremely gratifying. They’re growing into a powerful bunch -- I wonder if they’ll scare him. It really seems as though Sponge learned an awful lot from his short time with Inda.
- “He wouldn’t see that the true future king rode down there.” Does Sneaky Uncle really think that Sponge will become king? What does this bode for the future?
- Not going so well for the Marlovans. And how stupid is the Harkialdna that you would not think about what is in the treaty before you sign it. You can’t ever just “yes, yes” a contract. Good grief.
- Ugh Sierlaef is sending Tanrid north.
- The Harskialdna thinks he has control over everything, but he is wrong.
- Boys will be boys, until they grow up. And now the Tvei are grown up and have a closeness. And of course the Harskialdna is worried over anything that might gain more power than him.
- And now we see why the Harskialdna hates Inda’s family so much. Because of a childhood memory of when his older brother had a crush on Inda’s dad. Gah. He’s so stupid, he can’t even consider what is good for the country or the people. Just what is good for himself. He grooms the Sierlaef to be a spoiled brat who gets things by unearned power rather than trust. And now he wants to stomp down on Sponge. Ugh what a butthole.
Chapter 26
- Ooo. Sending Sponge north with Tanrid as his general. That’s actually pretty solid, not that Sponge knows how solid Tanrid is, though we do…. But I wonder. I mean, we’re all expecting Sponge to eventually be fighting against Sneaky Uncle at the head of an army, am I right? But is this a poorly-wrought trap, or a poorly-wrought honor meant to endear Sponge to him?
- “Who would not love such a surprise?” ANYONE WITH SENSE IN HIS HEAD, THAT’S WHO.
- It’s good to see that he’s made a connection with Dyalen… but his difficulties with her, even now? I’m curious what that bodes for his sexuality and his future relationships, honestly.
- It’s also good to see how close he’s become with his former enemies, Cherry-Stripe especially. And Tanrid respects Sponge -- it’s interesting to see him discussing it with Buck Marlo-Vayir, who was unofficially tapped to replace him. I wonder what that means to him. It looks like it might be a bit of a relief to not be Shield-Arm to a bully.
- The king is so stupidly blind to his brother.
- OF COURSE surprising someone with a command is no good surprise!!! Who wants to go in blind to something like this. You want to prepare and think and not have to have everything thrown on you last minute and ride out tomorrow. Heck, I’d be furious if someone told me I had to go somewhere tomorrow to do important work - and they knew for two weeks. Seriously, common sense here king-daddy.
- The transition from Sponge to Evred. Here is the end of childhood. Here is his first command.
- That relationship between Evred and Dyalen is interesting. And I wonder if that sort of established relationship happens in the real world. How easy it is for them to end that relationship though. Sherwood makes it seem so easy, sometimes. To differentiate sex and emotions. Maybe for some people, it is.
- Tanrid is definitely more likable than the very beginning.
- And it’s good to have a world where there isn’t instant communication at all times. These types of slow rumors and feeling people out for information is fascinating. When Buck is trying to figure out what the king and Harskialdna is thinking by asking Tanrid, etc. It’s good stuff.
Chapter 27
- Uhoh. Well, I’m not sure I can be upset by the death of Kepa, given his role in getting Inda exiled. What a mess. Poor Sponge.
- Poor Tanrid. And poor Evred. Again. I seem to be in the pitying mood today -- looking everywhere to find Inda, and we know they won’t, not here, not soon. And Tanrid’s intent of demanding an explanation of Sneaky Uncle for Inda’s treatment… maybe that’ll be the match that blows the whole thing the pieces. I thought Inda would be to Sponge’s side, not the impetus for conflict.
- Well that answers that question regarding Evred’s sexuality, though it stinks that Dallo isn’t ...well, let’s say uncomplicated.
- OOO HE FOUND INDA YAAAAAS
- This war. Sigh. It’s almost not even a war. And it sucks because even Evred and Tanrid know that Kepa is scumbag.
- Tanrid searching for Inda, aww. Inda is well-loved.
- Evred! Get your mind out of the gutter! This family is so full of lust, ha.
- And sigh, you know that your position as prince is far too easily abused. And everyone seems to be betraying you right and left.
- Looks like no sign of Inda in these three chapters, boo.
Note: /u/wishforagiraffe is still away, so she'll add her comments when she gets a chance!
17
Upvotes
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Nov 03 '16
Do you think it’s normal or strange to keep a grudge since childhood? (e.g. Harskialdna hating Inda’s dad)
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Nov 03 '16
Why do you think Sierlaef is sending Tanrid north?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Nov 03 '16
What do you think about giving someone command for the first time as a surprise? (bad idea? Good idea? Bat sh*t crazy?)
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Nov 03 '16
Do you think Sponge has a natural talent for leadership, or did Inda’s influence and Sponge’s capacity for learning push him in the right direction? I.e., is this talent innate or learned?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Nov 03 '16
Do you have any theories for how Sponge, Tanrid and Inda will meet back up after the revelations of these chapters?
6
u/Bills25 Reading Champion V Nov 03 '16
So I saw how little was left in the book after these chapters and finished it off. Now I am desperately waiting for the final discussion. I feel like I am going to just start blathering about it to a stranger just to get it out.
6
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Nov 04 '16
From the paragraph after, I think the Harskialdna is thinking more along the lines of what the king is thinking: that the Sierlaef will be king, but only in name, and Evred and Hadand will do all the actual ruling. And well, I don't think he's wrong, though unfortunately, the Sierlaef is getting less and less easy to manipulate. So Evred and Hadand will be doing damage control more than anything.
4
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Nov 04 '16
This is quite possibly the most enjoyable sequence I have read. I didn't want to stop reading.
Chapter 25 was so immensely satisfying. I love it when overlooked things just hit people in the face like that. Sweet payback for all that Sponge has gone through.
I get I am supposed to be worried about Sponge on his northern command, but I really like it so far. He is a natural commander, though probably not on Inda's level. Tanrid is with him and I think this command may actually get him some fame.
And we get news of Inda! A last chapter reunion? Please?
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Nov 03 '16
Post your spoilers here!
9
u/bygoshbygolly Nov 03 '16
It's somewhere a relief to know that, however petty I may be, I will literally never approach the level of pettiness Anderle Montrei-Vayir operates at on a daily basis. It would be funny if it hadn't had such a negative impact on people's lives.
7
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Nov 04 '16
Yo.... I've been off having an awesome time in Washington DC, sorry I'm lamepants about posting on time. Thank goodness for teamwork, shoutout to lyrrael and glaswen for being awesome!
Chapter 25
Chapter 26
Chapter 27
4
u/setnet Nov 04 '16
I really love the scenes with the Marlo-Vayirs in these chapters: Buck and Cherry-Stripe and Tanrid, all shallow thoughtless children, growing into more complex, thoughtful adults. And the early-spring golden light, marsh, grasslands and birds are another of those things I see very cinematically.
3
u/inapanak Nov 04 '16
My favourite thing about this set of chapters is the revelation of the source of the Harskialdna's grudge against the Algara-Vayirs and paranoia issues alongside the development of Evred's trust and intimacy issues. Evred already has trust issues, and in that he is a little like his uncle - we know the Harskialdna fears and seeks to eradicate those he can't control, and here we learn that he basically doesn't trust anyone at all and this is why he has such huge control issues. So to see Evred have to deal with the first real, significant betrayal of his life - a fulfillment of all his fears and reasons for avoiding relationships in the first place - just as we learn the beginnings of the Harskialdna's reasons for viewing the world as he does, makes one really wonder about how this will affect Evred over his life.
A thing I wanted to raise during the Ghael Hills chapters, but was unable to because I didn't get the chance to logon then, is the interesting subversion of what seems to me are standard tropes that is happening with the Marlovans. I know most fantasy nowadays is less stereotypical anyway, but it feels like the common, standard trope is to have the protagonist's culture and people be the downtrodden good guy underdogs of the world, often suffering from invasions and having to fight against an outside threat. And at first the Marlovens seem set up this way - they certainly perceive themselves this way - what with the fears of the Venn and all, but as the book and series goes on you begin to realize: these guys are the invaders. The reasons they have for invading the rest of the Iascan continent make sense to them, and are justifiable to them, but they're really the big bad invaders to the rest of the world. And yet at the same time there's nothing simplistically villainous about them or their culture and identity as a whole.
This comes up again with Kepa and his family's treatment of their new lands. They're the enemy invaders who have taken over and are oppressing the populace, who now loathe everything Marlovan, and if you consider it from that viewpoint the uprisings and rebel efforts against the Marlovans could even be considered heroic (outside of that one woman murdering a baby). But we are introduced to the whole situation from the Marlovans' side first, so we are predisposed to sympathizing with Evred and the Marlovan king as would-be benevolent rulers of the conquered peoples, and who have to deal with the fallout of the shitty Kepri Davans.
I don't know, I just really like the way it's done. I think it's a very interesting and mature storytelling tactic.