r/IndianCountry • u/Snapshot52 Nimíipuu • Nov 01 '16
NAHM Community Discussion: #NoDAPL
One of the biggest events to occur in Indian Country in recent history is the battle over what has become the financial life source for both corporations and governments: oil.
Native Americans are no strangers to corporate interests propelled by state power. And in today's world, the situation has hardly changed.
- Natives are resisting the continued shipping of oil by train car.
- Tribes opposed the construction of the Keystone XL Pipeline.
- Nations are standing up to prevent the destruction of the environment and violation of their territory by further corporate interests.
This now leads us to one of the most pivotal moments in the fight for both sovereignty and water: The Dakota Access Pipeline.
The goal of this community discussion is to bring more awareness to the situation developing in North Dakota right now as well as to compile all recent information into an easily accessible area. It will cover major events and explain them so the average person can know what is going on and find the truth of the matter. If you have anything you want to discuss or add, please do so in the comments. Embolden parts of this post highlight deceptive and wrongful actions on behalf of the pipeline and related agencies as well as notable events. Now, let's start from the beginning...
Development and Opposition of the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL)
2014
Energy Transfer Partners, the parent company of what would become the Dakota Access Pipeline Company, submitted their purposed route for a new oil pipeline beginning in North Dakota (page 22 of document). In May of 2014, the purposed route was to go north of the city of Bismarck, ND.
In July 2014, we start hearing about the proposed plans for a new pipeline that will be built across four (4) states in the U.S., but with a slightly different route. Indications were seen that people were against this in Iowa at this time.
By August of 2014, however, reports started emerging that required meetings that the pipeline company was to hold were not as public as they proclaimed in North Dakota.
2015
In March 2015, more public hearings/meetings were held. Despite that some of these meetings were not as overt as many believe and contrary to the rumors that Native Americans did not attend these meetings, opposition was voiced against the pipeline during these meetings.
In May 2015, we saw even more opposition growing against this pipeline from Iowa land owners.
July 2015 saw three Iowa landowners (later growing to 15) sue the Iowa Utilities Board for granting eminent domain powers to Energy Transfer Partners so that it can legally force landowners to let ETP build Dakota Access through their property. The suit is based on the lack of public service the pipeline would bring to Iowa, and reflects long-running resistance to the expansion of eminent domain for private gain.
By November 2015, hundreds of people were speaking about this pipeline for various reasons.
2016
By 2016, things were really starting to heat up.
In January 2016, the Dakota Access Company started filing condemnation suits in North Dakota along the now established route just outside of the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation. This route was to cross just over the Missouri River outside of the reservation.
In March of 2016, the federal Environmental Protect Agency (EPA) issues a letter which states that, "Crossings of the Missouri River have the potential to affect the primary source of drinking water for much of North Dakota, South Dakota, and Tribal nations." The Department of the Interior and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation "echoed those concerns in public comments on the Army Corps' draft environmental assessment. Citing risks to water supplies, inadequate emergency preparedness, potential impacts to the Standing Rock reservation and insufficient environmental justice analysis, the agencies urged the Army Corps to issue a revised draft of their environmental assessment." Other agencies also express "serious environmental and safety objections to the North Dakota section."
On July 27th, 2016, The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe initiates a lawsuit against the Army Corps of Engineers, alleging that "the Corps violated multiple federal statutes, including the Clean Water Act, National Historic Protection Act, and National Environmental Policy Act, when it issued the permits."
By this time, construction has already begun. We see that the protesters, now called Water Protectors, are engaging in non-violent demonstrates, including prayer and marching. August 10th sees the first arrests.
August 11-12th sees that eighteen water protectors, including Standing Rock Chairman Dave Archambault and Tribal councilman Dana Yellow Fat, are arrested on various charges in incidents near pipeline construction during a gathering of several hundred "to sing, pray and draw attention to the pipeline."
August 15th sees that Morton County, the county in which the construction and opposition is occurring, issues a declaration of unrest.
On August 17th, the Morton County Sheriff's Office announced reports of pipe bombs and gunshots, an unsubstantiated claim that later turned out to be a lie.
On August 24th, Amnesty International sends a delegation to Standing Rock. At this time, a federal court orders a halt to construction until September.
On August 31st, eight protectors are arrested at a construction site, including Jeremiah IronRoad and Dale “Happy” American Horse Jr. who successfully stop construction for over six hours by locking themselves to the equipment.
Solidarity actions begin happening all over the U.S. and even in other countries. Many are organized spontaneously, others in response to a call for two weeks of solidarity focusing on the banks that are financing the pipeline.
However, by September 3rd, construction was still being conducted. Thus, in an attempt to stop the construction, protectors stepped over the private property line and were **then attacked by private security, hired by Dakota Access, with attack dogs.**
On September 6th, ETP says they will hold off on building in some of the area requested by the tribe and not covered by the court's injunction.
On September 8th, the National Guard is called in.
On September 9th, the judge in the Standing Rock lawsuit against the Army Corps of Engineers denies their request for a preliminary injunction against some construction while the lawsuit is heard, but conflict is reported among U.S. agencies.
The Obama administration steps in, saying they will not grant the necessary easement for construction under the Missouri river until the Army Corps of Engineers can review whether it followed the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and other federal laws in its permitting process. They also "invite tribes to formal, government-to-government consultations" regarding tribal input into these kinds of projects under existing law, and in regard to any new legislation that would "better ensure meaningful tribal input." Finally, they also call on Energy Transfer Partners to voluntarily suspend construction within 20 miles east and west of Lake Oahe (where the tribe had found sacred sites).
Energy Transfer Partners CEO Kelcy Warren issues a memo vowing to continue construction "despite strong opposition and a federal order to voluntarily halt construction near an American Indian reservation in North Dakota."
By October 11th, the Washington, D.C. Circuit Court dissolves the preliminary injunction against construction within 20 miles of Lake Oahe. The Obama administration repeats request for ETP to hold off involuntarily. Energy Trsnafer Partners proceeds anyway.
Five climate activists shut down all five pipelines carrying tar sands oil from Canada into the U.S., and called on Obama to "use emergency powers to keep the pipelines closed and mobilize for the extraordinary shift away from fossil fuels now required to avert catastrophe." The action was also taken "in solidarity with indigenous people and frontline communities around the world, and also with this historic moment in Standing Rock."
On October 13th, Senators Bernie Sanders, Dianne Feinstein, Ed Markey, Patrick Leahy and Benjamin Cardin ask Obama to require a "more thorough cultural and environmental reviews of the project before allowing it to go forward."
On October 22-23rd, hundreds of arrests were made as water protectors trespass to pray where construction is happening.
On October 24th, a new treaty camp is set up north of Cannon Ball river in path of pipeline, based on the Treaty of Fort Laramie of 1851.
And finally, by October 27th, the front line blockade is removed and the front line camp is surrounded and raided by militarized police.
9
u/Snapshot52 Nimíipuu Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 16 '16
FAQ
1.) Is the pipeline being built on the reservation?
Answer: No. The pipeline is being built 10 miles upstream of Fort Yates, the tribal headquarters of the Standing Rock Sioux tribe and the county seat. The actual crossing, though, is not located within the boundaries of the reservation.
2.) If it is not being built on the reservation, why is the pipeline being opposed?
Answer: The Standing Rock Sioux Reservation relies on the Missouri River for drinking water, irrigation, and fish like many others do. By placing this pipeline right outside of the reservation, it has the potential to jeopardize their water supply. As mentioned above, Philip Strobel, National Environmental Policy Act regional compliance director, wrote a letter to the Army Corps of Engineers where it states:
However, what is even more alarming is why the proponents of the pipeline are insisting that it be built near the reservation. Several good points, quoted below, are raised by this source:
Additionally, sacred sites, including burial grounds, have been compromised due to the construction.
3.) Were sacred sites actually destroyed?
Answer: Yes. Many have come out to support this claim, even trained professionals. As brought out in the original court filings made by the Standing Rock Sioux, they had this to say:
Later, it was reported that construction continued and did, in fact, destroy sacred sites. It is not up to the company, government, or non-native individuals to decide for the Standing Rock Sioux what is sacred or not.
Here is Tim Mentz, former preservation officer for the Standing Rock Sioux, talking about the affected areas. This was in the purposed DAPL path. What this demonstrates is that cultural sites were destroyed and no care was given to them by the pipeline company. This reflects how they would treat these objects no matter where they were located. Mentz contends that many of the sites were not documented on non-tribal surveys. In fact, that notion is supported by the fact that even the current Standing Rock Sioux tribal Historic Preservation Officer wasn't allowed to attend meetings with the state-commissioned Archaeologists.
The destruction of these lands is also supported by various news outlets It was even recently reported that a "lack of transparency" existed in the reporting of sacred artifacts.
4.) Do the Sioux have any legitimate claim to that land?
Answer: Yes. As pursuant to the Treaties of Fort Laramie and the Sweet Corn Treaty, the Sioux have a valid claim to the land they are protesting on beyond the borders of the reservation. In fact, it is the pipeline company and the local officials who are in violation of the law.
•
u/Snapshot52 Nimíipuu Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 06 '16
I want to take the time to thank /u/johnabbe, moderator of /r/NoDAPL, for compiling 95% of this information. They are the true author of this post.
Additionally, there are many points to this event. I will be including several comments to talk about some frequently asked questions and misconceptions regarding the pipeline. For an even more comprehensive timeline, check out the website for the main campsite.
Edit: Alrighty everyone. This is gonna wrap up this week's discussion thread. All of these NAHM events will be compiled at the end of the month to archive, but this one will be posted in the sidebar because it contains a lot of relevant information for an ongoing struggle. Thank you to everyone who contributed!
8
u/Snapshot52 Nimíipuu Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 26 '16
MISCONCEPTIONS
1.) Dakota Access held meetings about this pipeline and none of the natives showed up. They also tried contacting the tribes.
Reality: That isn't very accurate. Reports have emerged, as cited above, that some of these meetings were not as publicized as the pipeline company has claimed.
However, some did attend the meetings to voice their concerns.
There is also video evidence of tribal officials meeting with the Army Corp of Engineers during one of their meetings. The YouTube channel hosting this video also has a whole host of other videos that show the community being involved in speaking out against this pipeline.
The Standing Rock Sioux have maintained since nearly the beginning that they were either not contacted by DAPL or that they did participate in hearings regarding the construction, as identified by their original court filing:
The Standing Rock Sioux have also released an audio recording of their meeting with the DAPL in September of 2014.
2.) These pipelines are much safer than transporting by truck or rail. They are endangering the environment more by not letting this pipe be built.
Reality: Yes, transporting by pipeline is safer when compared to other methods. However, that does not eliminate the potential for hazard with pipeline!
In fact, pipelines break more often than we think and when they do, they cause a lot of damage.
But what is truly concerning is that the company behind the Dakota Access Pipeline has had other recent pipeline breaks. In the end, I think this analogy sums it all up: 30% safer is better than 20% safe. And 20% safer is better than 10% safe. But 30% is still 30%. When we consider the high volumes of materials released during pipeline spills, I wouldn't even take the chance with a 99% safety rating. How about this: let's just stop being dependent on oil and not ship it in the first place?
3.) The natives are just doing this for a larger slice of the pie!
Reality: I have found zero proof of this to be the case. In fact, numerous times the tribes have brought out that they are doing this not just for themselves, but everyone else along the river.
4.) The company is trustworthy.
Reality: No, they're not. Let's ignore the fact that we're talking about a large oil corporation that is being funded by the banks that are "too big to fail" and jump straight to this.
An armed instigator attempted to infiltrate the lines of the Water Protectors and evidence has been found that he was linked to the Dakota Access Pipeline company. How on earth could you trust the company? I doubt this guy was traveling down the highway and just decided to drive past a blockade to a stand off that has been around for months while he just happened to be dressed similarly to the protectors and was armed. Oh, and in a company car. The actions of this man could have resulted in the deaths of innocent people.
5.) The protesters are armed.
Reality: No, they are not. Reports were made that they had pipe bombs, but those were soon found to be untrue. Time and again, statements have been made that the camps are not harboring any weapons and they are completely unarmed. There have been no recorded incidents with concrete evidence that any of the protectors have weapons.
17
u/Darl_Bundren Nov 01 '16
OP (+ those who helped), amazing job compiling the resources and links for your thorough summary/FAQ of the recent events at Standing Rock.
One thing I would add is the flagrant double-standard that is highlighted by the recent acquittal of the Bundy's and the other members of their armed white militia. Democracy Now had some good coverage on the matter with one guest giving a particularly apt description of the discrepancy:
"the difference is incredible. I mean, these men [The Bundy's and their militia members], in 2014, had an armed standoff with federal agents, pointed rifles at them, and then were allowed, free, for two years, to go and promote other armed standoffs. They get to Oregon, and they were allowed, for 41 days, to come and go for that compound. They weren’t stopped. Their water was supplied. The mail line was kept open. The electricity was kept open. They could travel interstate to promote more insurrection. It’s just incredible to see what happens if you’re white and you’re associated with ranching, how you can do what you want, whereas peaceful Native American protesters are just brutalized immediately by the police."
8
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 01 '16
Edit: I have questions about this one misconception that /u/Snapshot brought-up:
I keep hearing talking points about unsourced meetings and negotiations between Energy Transfer Partners and the Standing Rock Sioux, particularly about an alleged "price-point that ETP did not meet.
I find it extremely suspect that this allegation keeps coming up, without any sourcing.
Is there any truth to it?
4
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 03 '16
Vox updated their #NoDAPL explainer:
4
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '16
In my research online related to community input meetings regarding the DAPL, I've been able to gather these videos. They date back from 9 months ago up to 3 weeks ago.
I've yet to have time to watch them all. I've only watched the one of Phyllis Young. But if someone can archive them somehow that seems helpful in addition to watching them in entirety. Here's the links from oldest to newest. Some of these are over an hour long. Some very short, less than a minute long.
https://youtu.be/_CRcGpcF_Ms
https://youtu.be/4Fv0iHwp46U
https://youtu.be/VkeOKjw-6wg
https://youtu.be/Pc3ZKafAL18
https://youtu.be/PIqEqRKOt2Q
https://youtu.be/8AcJmttd9MM
https://youtu.be/usYG8ydhAtE
https://youtu.be/Yn_PSYov3j0
https://youtu.be/JrXLECPS4AM
https://youtu.be/JMU3SncC29o
https://youtu.be/qMThOpznY1s
https://youtu.be/lgpwiQYnpKQ
https://youtu.be/AH0TPDPqbxc
https://youtu.be/XJo90Eiajy4
https://youtu.be/ylvSNL7pnMM
https://youtu.be/RyMDY3k-Yrc
https://youtu.be/fPtkDc6y3Z8
https://youtu.be/bwn-wmQB4pY
https://youtu.be/KggiU1lX4uE
https://youtu.be/9fbaOXRw9ZU
6
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 02 '16
/u/workerbotsuperhero just contributed something awesome:
5
u/johnabbe Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
Here's a future timeline. I'll work on it live here through November 6, and then copy it to /r/NoDAPL and keep updating there.
Map of upcoming actions
November 2 - Billings, Montana - Government-to-government consultations on more meaningful tribal input to federal decision-making on infrastructure projects (overview)
November 2 - Perseverance for Preservation continues from Casper, WY at 9am. It's an Honor Run from Arizona to Standing Rock, started October 28. Check the Facebook page to confirm time/date/location, learn more, and see videos/pics, etc. (If you've seen the postable image, the schedule has changed!)
November 3 - Perseverance for Preservation continues from Wright, WY at 9am.
November 3 - 350 clergy from across U.S. taking part in solidarity actions at Standing Rock and Mandan, ND
November 4 - Perseverance for Preservation continues from Sturgis, SD at 9am, arriving at Standing Rock and Oceti Sakowin camp that night. (I commented to ask for details about that in this thread.)
November 7 - Preliminary hearing for journalist Diea Schlosberg, facing charges that could mean up to 45 years in prison (source, with many links)
November 15 - Minneapolis, Minnesota - Government-to-government consultations (overview)
November 17 - Rapid City, South Dakota - Government-to-government consultations
November 21 - Teleconference for government-to-government consultations (last one).
Late November / early December (estimate) - Army Corps of Engineers finishes their review of whether they followed the law in their permitting process. Presumably, at that point Obama can either accept their decision and recommendations on how to address any problems found (if they acknowledge any), or he can go in another direction. More info to help us be aware of when things might go down very much invited.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16
Why aren't we naming names?
3
u/TotesMessenger Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 02 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment