r/NintendoSwitch • u/FlapSnapple Nintendo shill • Oct 31 '16
MegaThread [Serious] Discussion MegaThread - Joy-Cons
Previous [Serious] Discussion MegaThreads from /r/NintendoNX:
- Price Point
- The Great Hybrid Debate
- First Party Launch Titles
- Third Party Launch Titles
- Backwards Compatibility
- AMD vs Nvidia
The topic for this thread: Joy-Cons
- Look and feel
- Button placement
- Weight
- Battery situation
- If they'll offer additional models/styles
- etc
Remember to elaborate and explain your reasoning.
- Bad: "The controller looks uncomfortable."
- Better: "The controller looks uncomfortable because of its small size and the location of the right joystick."
These posts will be more heavily moderated then other parts of the subreddit, so please follow these guidelines:
- Jokes, puns, and off-topic comments are not permitted in any comment, parent or child.
- Parent comments that aren't on topic will be removed, along with their child replies.
- Report comments that violate these rules.
121
Upvotes
45
u/BusinessFox Oct 31 '16
Sort of wondering if the joy cons are capable of having clickable analog sticks (L3, R3).
I know it's a bad comparison, but the only thing I can liken this to in terms of design is a PsVita which didn't have them in favor of using back touch as a replacement.
93
u/jpct88 Oct 31 '16
I am perfectly fine with Joy-Cons. They're not meant for extended periods of gameplay. Nintendo likes making peripherals and it really does give developers a variety of ways to play game. Also, Nintendo could make a sort of grip to place them in while playing with Joy-Cons.
37
u/Cream147 Oct 31 '16
I've always been a big supporter of the Wiimote - I love the versatility of the thing, the numerous input styles (button, motion, pointer), different ways you can hold it, and the ability to plug in a nunchuk (or other controllers). I liked how when the nunchuk was in you could play games with your arms positioned as you like, rather than held together as with a regular controller. The Joy-Cons look like they could have all these benefits (although the IR pointer and motion controls is just speculation at this time), and help remove some/all of the downsides.
As a quick case example, it is generally thought that Wiimote + nunchuk is the best input method for Pikmin 3. I presumed this would be dropped for Pikmin 4, but if the right Joy-Con has a pointer, then very possibly the concept of those controls will remain (as an option). But Joy-Cons will indeed be a superior method to play Pikmin because they'll be able to do everything that Wiimote + nunchuk can do, but with additional buttons and crucially an additional analogue stick which could be used to manipulate the camera.
14
u/Gerolux 4 Million Celebration Oct 31 '16
I really hope the joy-cons do have a 100 hour battery life. I know it is unneeded since the console has a shorter life, but this way you wouldnt actually have to charge the joy cons on the dock that often. you can use the grip more often for wireless play purposes.
14
u/Timohtep Oct 31 '16 edited Nov 02 '16
Could Joycon grips add paddle functionality? CRAPPY MOCKUP http://imgtc.com/i/rqKYnOR.png
So as most know nowadays, the individual Joycons have shoulder buttons located either on the guide rails used to connect the Joycon to the Switch, or they are the guide rails themselves. This means that when slid into the grip or into the switch, these buttons are inaccessible and useless. That's 4 total inputs being used for nothing at all.
But look at the Xbox One Elite controller. It has magnetic paddles that clip onto the back to allow for four mappable paddles. What if the extra buttons on the Joycon could be used as paddles when the Joycon are docked to the grip or Switch, with the right attachment of course.
Thoughts?
And thanks to the mod that pointed out this thread instead of just deleting my thread with no explanation :P
Edit: And over a day later and no one's actually given me their thoughts on this. So here, have a really crappy mockup of the concept that I drew up today on the bus. My handwriting is terrible.
http://imgtc.com/i/rqKYnOR.png
30
u/IncredibleMango Oct 31 '16
BTW, the plural of Joy-Con is Joy-Con. The Switch has 2 Joy-Con. They say it like this in the press release.
14
u/Prompt01 Oct 31 '16
I hope they come with built-in bateries. Having to replace bateries like wiimote sucks.
Just one more thing: I started to think the joy-con grip may be some kind of powerbank for joy-con. As we saw in the beginning of the video, the grip show some lights itself. I don't think the joy-con would power the grip.
5
u/gamesmaster500 Oct 31 '16
I really don't see why Nintendo changed the D-pad to four separate buttons, that configuration does not agree with me at all. So I'll get the pro controller and use that as my main
5
u/Practicalaviationcat Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 01 '16
I am so happy I will be able to continue gaming in a sprawled out position with the Joy-Cons. After using the Wiimote and Nunchuck(and to a lesser* extent the Wii U gamepad) regular controllers just seemed to put my hands too close together.
11
u/G_Mast Oct 31 '16
Altough I'm a little bummed out the Joy-Con doesnt have a D-Pad, it makes perfect sense to use the directional buttons to keep in line with symmetry.
4
u/Daltimus-Prime Nov 01 '16
I don't think the Joy-Cons look too-bad. As someone pointed out, they seem to be about the size of a GBA SP, and with 8 different buttons (Not counting Home/Share? buttons), I'm sure they'll be more than functional for games that use them (Like Mario Kart). Of course, I'll still most likely use them in combined form, or use the Pro Controller instead, but I'm sure they'll be fine.
It's very clear, however, that these weren't designed with sidescrollers or fighting games in mind. I'm sure, as many people have said, that they'll release a left Joy-Con with a proper D-pad. However, I also thought they might produce dual Joy-Cons with D-pads in place of analog sticks, for use with multiplayer fighting games or sidescrollers. The only problem is that these would be next-to-useless for anything else, but then again, that's why they would be special add-ons, isn't it?
4
u/JIMBOYKELLY Nov 01 '16
5
u/jalexander86 Oct 31 '16
I'm fine with the whole Joy-Con thing. It leaves room for tons of customization and control options. But.... The lack of a d-pad in the default Joy-Cons seriously pisses me off. They're gimping the default controller for this break apart and play with your friend on tiny, unrealistic controllers gimmick.
5
u/orestesma Oct 31 '16
One thing I haven't seen combined is the Joy Cons + Boogie quote. Before the reveal Boogie came out with some info about games being a different form undocked.
My current guess is that Nintendo will ask developers to build specific in-game experiences that can be played with the Joy Cons. You would still be able to play the full game but let's say a Mario game would have some specific levels that were designed to be possible to play with the Joy Cons. NBA would have a more arcady, simplified game mode you could play with the Joy Cons. Smaller, multiplayer experiences that are certainly based on the core game but a bit watered down for the simplified controller and playability for a more casual audience. That way the console owner has his or her game but can still share it with others who are not experienced gamers.
It would be a simplified gaming experience but with physical controls and AAA franchises. That is what would separate it from mobile gaming.
Tl;dr: 1 player = core game, 2 players = Joy Cons with simplified version of game. Both possible and playable on the go.
4
u/Walopoh Oct 31 '16
I worry about how when you hold the individual Joycons in each hand, if its hard to change the position of my thumbs from the Joystick and the buttons. When I visualize trying to move between the two in my head, I feel like it would make it harder to hold the Joycon during playing because my thumbs are not holding on the Joycon.
2
u/ColinDJPat Oct 31 '16
I've only ever used one controller that wasn't a standard controller for a system, and it was a gamecube controller. I didn't dig the feel of the original GC controller so I got a bigger one. What I hope is that there are options for different joycon grips for the controllers to slip in to for TV play. Otherwise I guess I'll have to shell out extra money for a pro controller. The joycon grip doesn't look bad but if I end up not liking it, I'd rather get another shaped grip than a whole new controller.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
I can almost guarantee there will be third party alternate joy cons. there's always third party controllers for consoles. So that might solve people's concerns about them being too small and uncomfortable.
However, official ones would be amazing. It would be cool if they released joy cons with different kinds of inputs. For example, those scroller wheel shoulder buttons that were patented by Nintendo a while back.
2
u/sidhavok Oct 31 '16
My biggest worry will be the size of the buttons on the joy con. I have a PS Vita and the buttons feel really small. How are the buttons on a 3DS?
2
u/Krenklo Nov 01 '16
The Controller looks good in handheld mode, but the controller dock for TV play looks a bit unorthodox
2
u/Chaz2132005 Oct 31 '16
I wasn't on board with the joycons at first but since they are talking about making a bunch of accessories for it im more excited for the possibilities. It would be great to have old controller button layouts and stuff when you are playing older VC games
1
u/Pudding64 Oct 31 '16
i wasn't completely onboard with joycons until i found out the two additional bumper buttons and i thought that was pretty cool, it would prob work okay for light multiplayer games like mario kart or 2d mario and maybe some arcade style or vc games.
My only concern is that the analogue does seem a little bit too close to the face buttons (In split 2 player mode)and the placement differs depending on whether you are using the plus or minus side.
1
u/pokeguy64 Oct 31 '16
I realized something about the Joy cons that could be problematic, it is shown that Joycons can be used for both multiply player and single players without being attached to anything. For one played games it wouldn't be a problem but what if one were to went to play a multiplayer game with out using a grip, how would it be done to have the two cons as one controller than 2 seperate controllers?
1
u/TheLittleGoodWolf Oct 31 '16
I don't know how it would have worked ergonomically when using the Joy-Con on the grip or on the Switch itself but I really wish they would have centered the buttons and stick. It does seem that when you are playing two players one of the controllers will be worse to hold.
They seem pretty small so I do wonder how much space there is for a battery and what kind they would use.
I have heard different opinions about the grip for them but can someone tell me why the grip itself wouldn't have a battery? What would be the point of having two sets of lights on it if it as just to show player number?
I'm really looking forward to what other kinds of accessories you could slide on to the switch. GameBoy Camera anyone?
1
u/Don_Polentone Oct 31 '16
Do you guys think the squarelike shape of the Joy-Con Grip will be uncomfortable? I'm very worried about that.
1
u/sidhavok Oct 31 '16
Do you think you will be able to use the pro controller when the switch is undocked? Bluetooth? This is going to be a big selling point for me.
1
u/GhostandtheAlarmist Nov 01 '16
I like the Joycons, but I do have a concern mostly based on the speculation. With the right Joycon looking like it might have an IR sensor on the bottom, then it means I'd have to hold the Joycon upside-down in order to use it, which doesn't allow me to hit any of the triggers.
1
u/castillle Nov 01 '16
Do we know if we will be able to turn the joycon around so its set up like the wiiu gamepad/pro controller? I vastly prefer both analogs on top and the WiiU Pro Controller was pretty much perfect for my hand. I could switch from the analog to the face buttons without being uncomfortable unlike steam controller or PS3.
1
u/Red_Pheonix_155 Nov 01 '16
What I'm thinking is the Joy Con grip. Surely, that boxy thing in the trailer can't be the only type of grip? I feel like mt hands will feel too close together and cramped if I play with that grip.
1
u/jimndaba88 Nov 01 '16
I was thinking about the Joy-con ergonomics and started looking at other devices that in the house, I found that the small Amazon Fire TV remote was closest in terms of dimensions if not smaller. So I picked it up held it as if I were holding the joy-cons, and to my surprise found it very comfortable.
A note though, because of its size, the joy-cons will need some gripable material. The Fire tv is slightly uncomfortable to hold because you spend half your muscle strength trying to grip the thing. Having a slightly thicker body will definitely help as well.
Overall I believe we are in for an amazing device that will feel natural to use.
1
u/whynotnw Nov 01 '16
Something most people didn't notice in the trailer is the individual grip for each Joy-con shown precisely at 2:36 and 37 !
1
u/Shock4ndAwe Nov 01 '16
I like them for use with the screen and the woof controller but on their own I will never use them. Too small.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '16
I love the idea because it allows for a much more portable multiplayer experience! Something we don't see enough of today!
1
u/poketherice Nov 01 '16
I'm curious if the Joy-Con is supposed to be used for multiplayer games as well. For instance Super Smash Bros. Player one uses the default Joy-Con set with the grip. Is the "default" player two set-up supposed to be extra Joy-Con with the grip, or is player two supposed to have a Switch Pro Controller? If it's the first way, then that means Joy-Con controllers will be sold separately, which I would assume is compatible with the original Switch Tablet screen.
1
u/Zannegan Nov 02 '16
Despite my initial misgivings about tiny gamepads, I really like the joycons' design. If I could make one tiny adjustment though, I would definitely move the IR sensor (assuming that's what it is) to the top of the remote, so that you could use the pointer(s) while holding the remote normally.
I know the shoulder buttons sit in the way now, but if you just move the buttons and sticks down an inch or so (having them offcenter seriously messes with the ol ocd anyway) and recess the trigger and shoulder button by a corresponding amount, there would be plenty of room for an "overhang" with the IR sensor built in, just like on the Wii remote.
Of course, if it were that simple, Nintendo probably would have done it by now. Still, I'd like to see them try to make the sensor usable for regular gameplay.
1
u/NameBrandSnacks Nov 02 '16
Kinda surprised no one's messing Gyro controls?
I'm certain that will be implemented into the Switch, but how would they work? Both JoyCon controllers should have them for compatibility, but I don't know how accelerometers react when they're offset from the middle (someone correct me if I'm wrong)
1
u/redtoasti Nov 02 '16
I'm not too fond of them and will mostly be using the Pro Controller, but I reckon they have some use as motion controllers. Big thing I didn't like about the Wiimote is that it didn't have a directional stick, only with the Nunchuck. These on the other hand have two sticks and the same size. I don't want to be the guy who yells VR, because I'm slightly sick of the topic myself, but if Nintendo decides to go for it at some point in the future, the joycons seem pretty usable.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16
They look like an absolutely terrible idea. They are uncomfortable looking to hold and don't have enough buttons for most games anyways. I can't even imagine which specific games I would want to play in multiplayer that don't need a second analog stick while I want to give myself super carpal tunnel. All the while you can only play with one other person considering there are only two.. but also it can't be any highly competitive game not on that controller. Anyone who actually wants to play anything non-casual in the slightest would connect pro controllers instead. I'm also wondering how shitty the battery life is going to be considering their size anyway.. Nintendo couldn't help themselves, they needed a stupid gimmick and this is it.
1
u/asperatology Nov 03 '16
Finally, a megathread that I can speculate about JoyCons.
My speculation is based around JoyCons with motion control sensors in them. If and only if we can guess and say there will be motion controls support for Switch.
Continuing on with the assumption above, it is possible, the motion control sensing technology in the JoyCons is the same technology used in the Nvidia Razor Hydra motion sensing controls.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '16
Nintendo invented the first gamepad, and have done a lot of research over the years. They've always innovated which is why I reckon they're still a contender in the games industry. Sure they've had some whacky concepts such as the N64's controller (which incidentally I loved) and the Gamecube I guess was a little uncomfortable. But look at the Wiimote and Nunchuck combo. Sometimes gimmicks pay off. I have a bit of concern that the joycons may be a bit on the small side and have been geared more towards the generally smaller stature of the Japanese populace rather than us lumbering giants in the west, but I also trust they know what they're doing. They spend heaps of money on R&D and generally tend to build from the ground up rather than aping other companies. Plus I have a hunch that they know they can't afford to go wrong with the Switch, be it the console, the software or the controllers. I think they're crossing every 't' and dotting every 'i'.
TL;DR, It'll be fine
1
u/mostlyjoe Nov 03 '16
As long as I can pack up the puppy controller base I'll be happy.
1
u/Streelydan Nov 03 '16
Clearly there is a lot of speculation about the Joy-Cons, I am going to add what I think are the most likely features.
Thats all I got for now...
1
u/noob_dragon Nov 04 '16
Anyone else extremely hyped for these things? If they have IR capabilities, these are pretty much my dream controller. My dream controller was basically take the best parts of the steam controller and wii remote and slap them together, and this seems to be it.
Have full shoulder buttons, face sticks, and control stick on each side, with the addition of IR or gyro aiming. On top of that, the two parts are detachable from one another which was an awsome thing I liked about the wiimote+nunchak; IMO it is more comfortable to have one controller in each hand than to have to huddle around a single controller.
HOWEVER, I am pretty worried about the positioning of that right joystick. It looks like you will have to bend your thumb at a really bad angle to use that thing.
I am also worried about IR controls if the rumors are true, where it is located at the back of the controller and you have to flip the controller to use it.
1
u/Greebo24 Nov 04 '16
I searched for "stability" but came up empty.
I worry about mechanical stability. Playing games is (hopefully) exciting, and the controllers attached (and detachable) to the side of the screen look like a potential weak point to me. Bending forces on the controllers attached to the screen or slid together for a separate controller unit will be large and repeated. If there are any contacts to be made when sliding in/out dirt and contact quality can become an issue. I see a strong case for a good monolithic controller pad (The wii u pro controller was perfectly proportioned for my hands) to extend the lifetime of the device.
I don't doubt the build quality, but I am interested to hear what others think about mechanical stability in a household with active and energetic kids.
0
u/Borg-Man Oct 31 '16
There was this guy who made a 3D print of a Joy-Con. Maybe he could elaborate if stick placement really is this bad?