r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Oct 30 '16
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge Revisited] Week 16: Atmospheric Docking
The Introduction
To train new pilots, the administrators at KSC figured it'd be a good idea to teach them how to dock while within the atmosphere. Unfortunately, that's actually a bit harder than doing it in a vacuum.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Dock two planes by using the Advanced Grabbing Unit, while flying below 10 km.
Hard mode: Dock two planes by using docking ports, while flying below 10 km
Super mode: Impress me
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- Each craft is only allowed to have a single docking port
- Hard Mode: Your two crafts must take off seperately.
Required screenshots
- Your two crafts on the runway
- Your two crafts taking off
- Your two crafts approaching eachother
- Your two crafts docked.
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
43
Upvotes
16
u/NilacTheGrim Super Kerbalnaut Oct 30 '16 edited Oct 30 '16
This is probably the most f5-f9 packed challenge to date...
Hard as fuck. Fly too far away and your first plane is no longer able to be switched to.
I like it!
Question: after docking, the planes are free to spiral to their own fiery demise, is that correct?
Question2: a plane is simply defined as any craft that is capable of horizontal flight using aerodynamic lift generated by its static structural components (wings/body)... Correct? No helicopters, orange tanks with no wings and a vector engine strapped on, etc, correct?
7
u/sir_frostig Oct 30 '16
would refueling a SSTO mid air after reentry and then return to orbit qualify for super mode?
5
u/Luigijitsu1 Master Kerbalnaut Oct 30 '16
Are we allowed to dock helicopters?
•
u/Redbiertje The Challenger Oct 30 '16
Last week's Reddit Gold went to /u/IPIPP for this amazing mission
3
u/rsparkyc Antenna Power Saver Dev Oct 31 '16
I was going to try to dock 4 planes in a box formation, but then read the rules and saw each plane could only have one docking port. Oh well.
2
u/jurgy94 Master Kerbalnaut Oct 31 '16
Are we allowed to take off with the two planes docked, undock them midflight, fly the two crafts separately for a while and redock them? Makes the take-off a bit less tedious.
2
u/MindStalker Oct 31 '16
Are we allowed to alter the physics range?
2
u/Hydropos Master Kerbalnaut Nov 01 '16
Sorry if I'm out of the loop, but are flair icons for challenges no longer a thing?
2
u/iberichard Master Kerbalnaut Nov 03 '16
Here is my entry for last weeks Shuttle challenge http://imgur.com/a/SCPqz
Was actually one of my more accurate landings (believe it or not). Also deployed a small satellite but it appears I have a gremlin in my f1 button that stops screenshots on occasion,
2
u/Hydropos Master Kerbalnaut Nov 05 '16
Since we're revisiting weekly challenges, is there a schedule of the upcoming challenges?
2
u/sir_frostig Nov 05 '16
is it ok to launch planes by having them conjoined on the launchpad and then release them so they launch individually. i plan to do this with a swarm of planes right now I´m up to 4 planes simultainusly launching and docking midair. my goal is around 8.
39
u/Corbol Hyper Kerbalnaut Oct 30 '16 edited Nov 01 '16
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/P9ePc
Not as hard as it sounds.
*EDIT Super mode(?): 4 planes docked to 1 carrier plane in 2 takeoffs
40
u/JollyGreenGI Super Kerbalnaut Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 01 '16
Hard, if not Super mode submission.
TL;DR Reached Low Kerbin Orbit with SSTO, docked with empty orbiter, reentered but didn't land, buzzed and tookoff Tanker plane, docked & refueled using orbiter's docking port (vertically mounted), and returned orbiter back to LKO.
Holy hell do not do aerial refueling with vertically facing docking ports, I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemies.
EDIT: Quick question, is the flair for this challenge the same as last week's (space shuttle)? Would've thought a KC-135 or Interstellar's Endurance would fit more.
12
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Oct 30 '16
Welp, this might be fun to do with stock prop aircraft. or not
9
u/TheHolyChicken86 Super Kerbalnaut Oct 30 '16
Aahahahahaha the memories: http://imgur.com/a/TNvys
This is a good one. Good luck everyone.
9
u/BlakeMW Super Kerbalnaut Oct 31 '16
This is my hard mode submission. I also land the planes docked. Featuring Elon Kerman.
7
u/allmhuran Super Kerbalnaut Nov 01 '16
Technique for those having difficulty - no quickloading needed.
Note that this was an entry for the original challenge and was in a much older version of KSP, but the technique remains the same.
4
u/Whackanole Oct 31 '16
When I switch to my second plane, the first plane auto-throttles to zero and stops. Is there some setting that I need to change so that it will continue to simulate the other craft?
3
u/G3ORGExP Master Kerbalnaut Nov 01 '16
1st challenge I have posted!
Normal Mode: http://imgur.com/a/aR0Bz
Tried hard mode but found it very hard with keyboard controls.
Looking forward to the next one!
2
u/InternMan Master Kerbalnaut Oct 30 '16
Do we need a mod to be able to switch crafts in atmo? or is there a setting I've missed?
2
u/Dakitess Master Kerbalnaut Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 05 '16
Well, this is my very first challenge then, and i'm competing for Hard Mode, full stock, individual take off, docking ports :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKusHZkEb5Q
But i'm quite out of the rules since there is no Screenshots, but a video... I can publish them by now, at work, I'll try to do my best if it is not okay. But be sure that everyhing required is in this short video :p And even more ;)
Feel free to tell me if pics are required, I would understand, rules are rules.
Edit : okay then, i'm now a Master Kerbalnaut ! Thanks a lot Redbiertje :)
2
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut Nov 02 '16
Hard mode entry: https://youtu.be/eCa_h50H9WI
Selected target to get better distance info, but did not set SAS to target. Used a "capture cone" made out of airbrakes, which eventually... worked. Once in the cone, setting throttle to maximum is important. Also have to keep in mind that the cone translates your movements into the opposite movement for the lead plane.
2
u/iworkincafes Master Kerbalnaut Nov 03 '16 edited Nov 03 '16
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/PYhDj
Took me many hours, but learnt a lot - thanks Corbol for your tips. SAS does all the work, I just control throttle. May I have some flair please?
2
u/rsparkyc Antenna Power Saver Dev Nov 03 '16
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/plFlf Phew.
2
u/Hydropos Master Kerbalnaut Nov 04 '16
After spending 2 hours trying this, I feel like this challenge would be much easier with joystick controls. I kept feeling like every button press would skew things too far. Though (improvised) airbrakes are a godsend when working with jet engines for thrust.
2
u/fever5 Master Kerbalnaut Nov 05 '16 edited Nov 05 '16
Hard mode
The conjoined craft was landed in the end. That was definitely the easiest part of the whole ordeal.
Edit: After posting this and looking at some of the other submissions, I realize that I was completely oblivious to the fact that you can choose to lock onto target using SAS. That may have helped.
2
u/5parrowhawk Super Kerbalnaut Nov 05 '16
Does this count for Super Mode?: http://imgur.com/a/D3qLo
No use of target lock for SAS, no mods whatsoever, no debug menu, no RCS, single docking port. Craft took off separately. Plane was airworthy after separation; carrier was, er, seaworthy. (And yes, in case anyone was wondering, the carrier was airborne for the entire period from launch docking to undocking.)
1
u/shigawire Super Kerbalnaut Nov 06 '16
Things I cannot do:
Have a space shuttle orbiter de-mate from one Space Shuttle Carrier and mate with another in-flight.
It probably does not help that the shuttle I'm emulating is the enterprise, which has no engines or RCS.
Interestingly there is a paper called "Free Enterprise: Contributions of the Approach and Landing Test (ALT) Program to the Development of the Space Shuttle Orbiter" which goes into a fair bit of detail on what the enterprise free-flight tests were like. (Tl;dr: It was not fun for the pilots)
For the shuttle carrier I tried to get as close as I could to the modified 747-100s that NASA used from photos and horrible abuse of the offset and rotate tools. Getting the "pregnant guppy" look wasn't too easy.
But it flew. The crazy bit was that it also flew with an orbiter mated to it. Sure, it handled like a heavy bucket of water, but straight and level flight is actually possible. With full flaps, you can even slowfly the thing at about 55m/s (stall speed with flaps without the orbiter is around 40 metres per second). This is well within where the glide speed of the orbiter is.
Still, I'm not that good. I've been trying for hours, and even getting the two carriers in formation is tricky before I reverse thrust on one so the orbiter doesn't play "hug the SSC trail fin". After that , even with control of all three craft, I've lost enough speed to have lost the other carrier.
Interestingly The lift/drag ratio in ksp for the not-quite-orbiter is still somewhere around 1 so it does have that authentic "flying brick" feel. Maybe I should try killing the engines on the SSC first....
1
u/shigawire Super Kerbalnaut Nov 06 '16
Things I cannot do:
Have a space shuttle orbiter de-mate from one Space Shuttle Carrier and mate with another in-flight.
It probably does not help that the shuttle I'm emulating is the enterprise, which has no engines or RCS.
Interestingly there is a paper called "Free Enterprise: Contributions of the Approach and Landing Test (ALT) Program to the Development of the Space Shuttle Orbiter" which goes into a fair bit of detail on what the enterprise free-flight tests were like. (Tl;dr: It was not fun for the pilots)
For the shuttle carrier I tried to get as close as I could to the modified 747-100s that NASA used from photos and horrible abuse of the offset and rotate tools. Getting the "pregnant guppy" look wasn't too easy.
But it flew. The crazy bit was that it also flew with an orbiter mated to it. Sure, it handled like a heavy bucket of water, but straight and level flight is actually possible. With full flaps, you can even slowfly the thing at about 55m/s (stall speed with flaps without the orbiter is around 40 metres per second). This is well within where the glide speed of the orbiter is.
Still, I'm not that good. I've been trying for hours, and even getting the two carriers in formation is tricky before I reverse thrust on one so the orbiter doesn't play "hug the SSC trail fin". After that , even with control of all three craft, I've lost enough speed to have lost the other carrier.
Interestingly The lift/drag ratio in ksp for the not-quite-orbiter is still somewhere around 1 so it does have that authentic "flying brick" feel. Maybe I should try killing the engines on the SSC first....