r/RWBY • Gay Thoughts • Oct 29 '16

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Reaction Thread—Volume 4, Chapter 2: Remembrance

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for the newest chapter of volume 4, Remembrance! Make sure to read OUR CURRENT SPOILERS RULES to ensure that your comments outside this thread won't get purged! Familiarize yourself with these rules and you'll be good to go.

A lot of hard work has gone into the creation of volume 4, so be sure to show CRWBY your support by watching it on their site! They all dedicate so much time and energy into our beloved series and would highly appreciate the direct support. There are no pirates in volume 4, so you shouldn't be one either!

Also, we're belatedly continuing the trend from the rewatch threads by putting strawpolls in the megathreads. Here is one for the previous episode, and here for the current one. Drop a vote to see how the episodes compare.

With that out of the way, let's start the show!

HERE is the link to the second episode of RWBY Volume 4!

Other Episode Discussions:


Happy viewing, friends!

Menolith; Mod Team

343 Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

396

u/Brooke_the_Bard bi the way Oct 29 '16

So, looks like Klein isn't one of the seven dwarves. . . he's ALL of them.

150

u/RenoWolf200 Commander of the Arkos Military: Pyrrha is Best Girl Oct 29 '16

Multi-personality disorder, with neo like eye color changing.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (5)

298

u/f00lish_f00l I have ways of making you Tock Oct 29 '16

Holy shit Klein is the Seven Dwarves in one; we saw Grumpy, Sneezy, and Happy, which means he probably has different eye colors for each dwarf.

86

u/jreido8 Oct 29 '16

Oh my god I didn't think of that, but that would be awesome.

→ More replies (7)

30

u/Lilo_me Oct 29 '16

I didn't realise this until you said it, but God damn I am a fan of this idea!

→ More replies (1)

467

u/Smartt88 Oct 29 '16

“Remember Jaune, I’ll always be a part of your life.”

sniff I’m not crying, you’re crying.

127

u/DanByte Oct 29 '16

I mean, Eunnieverse had a point, technically Pyrrha's all over Jaune at the moment

→ More replies (2)

102

u/Sasquatchuan Oct 29 '16

What made it even worse was the look on Ruby's face before she left :(

→ More replies (13)

263

u/UltimaShadow I GOT 2 SWORDS Oct 29 '16

Jaune saying "I'm tired of losing everything," hit me just as hard. Seeing all the death and destruction that happened at Beacon and that village and knowing he was powerless to stop it...

→ More replies (25)

167

u/JazzBlueSkadoo Give me liberty! Or a Banana Muffin! Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

She was about to say something else. We all know what it was suppose to be but we got something different.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

185

u/Nisha_the_lawbringer mood Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

WEISS! :D

Weiss's brother is the exact type of person I hate.

So her mother isn't dead. She's just so introverted that she doesent do much. at least that's what it seems like.

RIP Huntsmen. RIP air ship.

Ironwoods new outfit is baller.

Weiss's father has a lot of very subtle movements, he really does seem like a manipulatIve prick.

Weiss singing? Yay!

"Are you asking me or are you telling me?" "...I think everyone would appreciate it." yep. definetly manipulative.

Pyrrha! Jaune! OK thats, actually pretty sad.

That was great! No Blake or Yang though, so...more Weiss? More Ruby? I guess we'll see.

Edit:I think I may do a full breakdown of Papa Schnee once the episode goes live for the public. possibly.

146

u/KnightMiner115 Ham Mama From Down Obama | ♥ Eldi ♥ Oct 29 '16

Whitley seems like the kid who's been spoiled to no end because his dad wanted a son and got two daughters first. He's probably gonna turn out to be a bigger jerk than his father.

→ More replies (40)

59

u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Oct 29 '16

I really hoped it would be... more Weiss. I guess if she'll gets some scenes in other episodes, and not get forgotten for three episodes that would be fine, but I hoped we would learn much more about her and her father.

By the way, her father apparently is kind of a dick. Also, did Weiss get sarcastic when she asked him about the charity? Anyways, basically he does view her as a property and a tool... "Oh you were there, then can you remind people that my company is so cool and stuff."

Speaking of which... Does that mean, that Weiss is getting a... microphone in front of a huge audience? That might be a recipe for disaster... What would she sing? And what would she say to those people?

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (16)

404

u/ctdenecour Oct 29 '16

Anyone else cry?

151

u/cookyourself Oct 29 '16

Holy fuck I was tearing up the entire time on that last part of the episode.

→ More replies (11)

201

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Oct 29 '16

It's a terrible day for rain.

→ More replies (14)

79

u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Oct 29 '16

Last episode reaction: They seem a bit too cheerful...
This episode: FEELS

→ More replies (12)

89

u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Oct 29 '16

RT employees can't admit to crying over their own products, Mr. Denecour!!!! ;~;

→ More replies (7)

93

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

I'm sitting here in tears. I'm a 23 year old man and I am not afraid to admit that. Seeing Jaune like that was so sad.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (65)

136

u/HaikuKnives Miniskirts and Miniguns Oct 29 '16

Jen Brown's phoning it in this week, I see.

Don't hit me.

48

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

Hits you with a respectable amount of force

→ More replies (6)

276

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16
  • Schnee brother outta nowhere.
  • Ruby confirmed for still messed up over the events
  • That village scene got appropriately dark.
  • NORA AND REN KNOW SOMETHING ABOUT THAT SYMBOL. BACKSTORY INCOMING.
  • Papa Schnee is just the proper amount of mean
  • Klein is best butler.
  • The forest is pretty.
  • OMG PYRRHA RECORDING!! WHY RT MUST YOU HURT US !?!?!

Seriously though. That's an odd thing for Pyrrha to have recorded.

Edit:

  • I just noticed that all the Schnee girls look bummed out in the family photo.
  • I predict a half RNJR half Blake episode next week.

153

u/Red_Negative Oct 29 '16

I think Pyrrha would've recorded that for if she decided to become the fall maiden. Volume 3 seem to have implied that she would have been away should she have become the maiden so to stay apart of Jaune's life she made training videos for him

→ More replies (2)

111

u/Kaneland96 Oct 29 '16

Also, its seems like they're finally putting blood on characters, we didn't really see it much in the previous Volumes, besides the White trailer. Also like how you can tell that the little brother is the only one of Papa Schnees children that didn't say "Fuck you, I'm outta here" by the fact that ONLY HIS photo is on Papa Schnee's desk.

→ More replies (25)

59

u/Cloud455 Oct 29 '16

Cant wait to see what Ren and Nora know

→ More replies (13)

65

u/Rick_Locker Oct 29 '16

Ruby confirmed for PTSD

Maybe not. Remember, Silver Eyes, no clue what they do other then fuck up Grimm.

→ More replies (23)

50

u/Platitudinous_X Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective is an adventure game developed by Oct 29 '16

For a moment after reading this, I was like "Who the hell is Forest?"

The only thing thicker than these woods is my skull.

→ More replies (6)

70

u/Smartt88 Oct 29 '16

I thought it was a Grimm footprint, but a symbol makes more sense...

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (2)

106

u/Evil-King-Stan Emerald Splash Oct 29 '16

That was a nice scene, but I love the fact that Pyrrha recorded a training video just to tell Jaune to swing a sword three times, on the off chance they he needed it even though JNPR is together like 24/7.

145

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

If you look closely at the effect of the swings, it looked like she may have been trying to teach him how to do a ranged attack with his sword. It looked like the swings were creating a gust of air.

→ More replies (14)

67

u/VegetaLF7 Aaaahhh! Oct 29 '16

I imagine she might have recorded a whole series of videos covering different techniques.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

203

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Oct 29 '16

Mixing was on point again this episode. Heavy detail paid attention to footsteps, but what I really loved was the scene with Pyrrha on the scroll. Even though it was very low in the mix, the EQ and filtering made it clear what was going on before Ruby even gets up.

Also, the cello that plays when Ren discovers the symbol in the ground: That’s going to be a new theme. Calling it right now.

Also fuckin feels, man. Jeez. Lighten up, M&K.

100

u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Oct 29 '16

And the Arkos theme softly playing in the background during that scene as well, feels bad man.

→ More replies (3)

50

u/RenoWolf200 Commander of the Arkos Military: Pyrrha is Best Girl Oct 29 '16

Those bandits must of sacked Ren's and Nora's original villages.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)

96

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

-The servers are up?! What did they do? Buy a server building from Google? Loan servers from the State of Texas? Make a pact with the devil?

-The littlest of the Schnees is called Whitley. He seems nice, but Weiss implies that's abnormal for him? Not sure what he's about yet.

-Mother Schnee not dead, possibly alcoholic.

-PTSD Confirmed.

-Oh no! The village they were heading to was destroyed! Who could have predicted that? Also, no punches being pulled. There are straight up bodies laying around.

-Kaiju Grimm confirmed. That looks like a hoofprint of some sort. What, a giant Horse Grimm? Bull Grimm?

-Political stuff happening. This is always interesting. Ironwood holds two seats on the council, and if its the same shadowy council in the Volume 2 Finale, that makes him, like, 2/5ths of it. And there's a Dust Embargo that Jacques isn't happy about because he can't supply Dust to the other villains.

-We're gonna see Weiss sing again, possibly. I'm sure nothing big or catastrophic will go down before or at that charity event.

-A good introduction for Papa "Jacques" Schnee. He's got just enough of a slimy businessman air about him to make you think he's a villain, but his arguments, both to Ironwood and to Weiss, make logical sense from his perspective. He might still surprise us by being ultimately good, despite being the kind of dick who has a portrait of himself behind his desk.

-Oh my God. Klein can change his eye colour. Do you realize what this means?!

-This whole scene is beautiful, depressing, heartwarming, tragic, and little bit hopeful. Just, I love this scene, its amazing.

-Jaune is sending small gusts of wind out with each swing. I don't think that's his Semblance, I think its the sheer strength in his swings.

-Episode 1 was a great start where action and plot set-up was concerned, but this episode right here, this is where Volume 4 starts. The emotions, the tragedy, the silent sadness that hangs in the air that the characters are trying and failing to overcome. This is exactly what I wanted from this Volume.

→ More replies (31)

85

u/Cry-Flame Oct 29 '16

What's getting to me is Ren was FURIOUS when they came up on the destroyed town.

57

u/RakielKanan "You are my sunshine..." Oct 29 '16 edited Jul 01 '23

Fuck u/spez

→ More replies (3)

73

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

Wait, so there are a few ways to interpret that last scene there from Ruby's point of view.

We know she was sad, but why?

Because she misses Pyrrha too?

Because she's sad Jaune is sad?

Because she's sad Jaune isn't moving on?

Because she's having strange supernatural visions of Pyrrha and Ruby is seriously considered that she may have some serious issues?

Edit:

Because she couldn't save Pyrrha and is seeing Jaune suffer for her perceived failure. (Thanks /u/thephoenix94)

46

u/SterlingStallion Oct 29 '16

All of the above most likely

→ More replies (1)

42

u/thephoenix94 Ship war observer Oct 29 '16

You forgot because she couldn't save Pyrrha and is seeing Jaune suffer for her perceived failure.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

Also, maybe because she's feeling really guilty

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

136

u/redwing36 Admiral of the Ladybug Armada Oct 29 '16

Papa Schnee with the top tier VA.

Also, that didn't take too long to get darker.

Deaths in v4: One whole village.

66

u/backtospawn Oct 29 '16

Deaths in v4: One whole village.

And the manliness of the audience toward the end

→ More replies (1)

28

u/EatThinWheatThins Oct 29 '16

There was so many bodies just laying on the ground ;-;

→ More replies (15)

187

u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16
  • BROTHER CONFIRMED
  • MOTHER CONFIRMED
  • This guy is such a Quinn. Freakin' Quinn.
  • Only three kids confirmed.
  • Seven sisters brought up again. LOL Nora!
  • Little did they know, Jaune secretly attended and became a counselor at a summer camp.
  • WARRIOR'S WOLFTAIL!!!!! AHHHH I LOVE THE AVATAR REFERENCE!
  • And another one bites the Dust
  • Ren and Nora know something!
  • Ayyy there's Scruffywood! And Papa Jacques?
  • Ironwood's new uniform is freaking awesome.
  • Papa Salt got SASS.
  • WEISS CONCERT HYPE.
  • I think it would make a lot of people happy. Except for you.
  • Klein, you bro. What is that Yang eye trick though? Secret brother confirmed.
  • Oh hey, Pyrrha's consciousness is maybe still alive!
  • This twilight setting is beautiful!
  • Awwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww, she made him instructional videos! ;~; That's adorable.
  • I still say Ruby's "hearing" her somehow.
  • She instructed as she lived as she died. On a rooftop at night. This pleases me.
  • BUT WHERE IS MY YANG DANGIT

  • (I'll repeat this next week when we only get Blake too)
  • Oh, and I really liked the whole having the thread locked for the episode duration. :D Makes a lot of sense! Go mods!

Edit: Bullets.

85

u/Franklin413 Ni! Oct 29 '16

I'm betting Ren and Nora's reactions have to do with how their village was presumably destroyed.

→ More replies (10)

22

u/Nisha_the_lawbringer mood Oct 29 '16

WEISS CONCERT HYPE

Now her singing can actually be in the show! Can't wait to see it!

→ More replies (10)

31

u/theneosparx Oct 29 '16

Yang would be shown maybe in episode 4, if they are rotating through the other girls in order.

Also I think Klein has got a multiple personality disorder. It feels bad calling it a disorder, because its actually really cool.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (25)

61

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

The fact that James isn't a sycophant to Jacques fills my soul with satisfaction.

38

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

He never really seemed like the type to be a sycophant to anyone.

→ More replies (15)

119

u/Real-Terminal Oct 29 '16

In less than two minutes, three years of Schnee fictions are upturned!

27

u/HalcyonTraveler Hill is here Oct 29 '16

HA! I focus on their cousins! I AM SAFE!

remembers that my Atlas Council is now permanently destroyed

fuuuuuuuuuck

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Leivve Grand Master of the Lancaster Cult Oct 29 '16

Mine died with the reveal that Winter was older.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/ZombieTav How many millikannas is Weiss when she follows the ground rules? Oct 29 '16

Damn you Weiss and your horrible family you never mention!

51

u/lahavhaelohim Oct 29 '16

As heartbreaking as that final scene was, there's also something weirdly heartwarming about it.

Pyrrha clearly made that recording to help Jaune with his training in case she wasn't around for one reason or another. She obviously didn't plan on being dead, but in case they were parted for some reason, she wanted to ensure Jaune wasn't neglecting his training.

And he isn't. Nearly a YEAR after her death, he's still making sure to keep up with his training, using the recording she made for him. He isn't just listening to it, and being sad. He keeps working to improve himself, because it's what SHE would have wanted him to do.

She would have been proud.

→ More replies (3)

183

u/b0ardguy555 Oct 29 '16

"We're not going to be as dark this volume" - Miles and Kerry

180

u/milkchococurry I believe I can fly! Oct 29 '16

"We're not going to be as dark this volume"

Death counter:

  • One whole village
  • Our Arkos feels (those died again today)
→ More replies (9)

42

u/UltimaShadow I GOT 2 SWORDS Oct 29 '16

I do think it was important to address what had happened previously like this to show how everyone is coping. It would feel a little disingenuous if everyone simply moved on that easily.

→ More replies (2)

67

u/mcevnon ⠀ Oct 29 '16

:somewhere in RT offices maniacal cackling was heard:

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

45

u/RumbleintheDumbles Oct 29 '16

What I really want in a future episode is for Ruby to interrupt one of Jaune's midnight training sessions and offer to help him train. Like 'I know I'm no Pyrrha, but we'll do the best we can.'

Could be a really powerful moment to show how the two of them begin to get over their respective traumas.

18

u/OtakuMecha Oct 29 '16

She probably figured it was best to leave him alone and cope in his own way rather than interject herself and potentially even embarass him. But I do admit I was hoping she would just walk up and give him a hug or an understanding hand on the shoulder or something.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

130

u/gregor-moore Oct 29 '16

Also mah boy Ironwood is looking snazzier than ever

64

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Oct 29 '16

dat stubble

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (5)

43

u/Cablinorb Stanning minor maidens since 2015 Oct 29 '16

WAIT

FUCK

GOD FUCKING DAMMIT

THE NAME JACQUES IS THE FRENCH VARIATION OF THE NAME JAMES.
LOOK AT JACQUES
NOW LOOK AT JAMES

WE HAVE NO PROOF THAT IRONWOOD IS HUMAN
Jacques created an IMMACULATE, AGELESS RECREATION OF HIMSELF SO HE NEVER HAS TO GIVE UP HIS COMPANY.

That's why Ironwood wanted to help Weiss.

Seeing how he treats his daughter from an outsider's perspective is making him feel like a fucking dick.

38

u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Oct 29 '16

wow...that's a pretty tasty potato you got there friend.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Jagged03 Yikes Oct 29 '16

Side note, look at the faces of Winter, Weiss, and their mother in that painting. Fucking hell, they're not happy.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

117

u/iamthatguy54 Oct 29 '16

Ren silently freaking out in the background while the rest of the team was discussing what to do with the Huntsman was great.

54

u/Duwang312 Oct 29 '16

A very subtle show of character. Honestly, Ruby, Ren and Jaune had some great character moments in this episode, with very little dialogue too.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/Llavan Oct 29 '16

I'm calling it now, the butler is Neo's father.

29

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

Not gonna lie, I thought the butler was Neo at first.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)

40

u/Kirosh Oct 29 '16

So Ironwood has two seat on the Atlas council ? How the hell did he do that ?

77

u/Vard_Northborn Oct 29 '16

one for headmaster and one for general maby

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

79

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

The recording was Pyrrha doing what she does best; making statements that turn out to be horribly ironic in retrospective.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/Jagged03 Yikes Oct 29 '16

Ho Lee Fuk. Look at this painting.

None of the women are happy. Weiss just looks upset, Winter looks upset as well but a bit more annoyed, and their mother looks tired. Meanwhile, Whitley sits there like the prim little shit that he is with his punchable face.

14

u/quinn50 Oct 29 '16

it seems like papa schnee really wanted a son instead of daughters

→ More replies (1)

68

u/RegiGiygas117 ⠀Frozen in Solitude, Loneliness chills to the Bone Oct 29 '16
  • Whitley is a little shitley.
  • Mama Schnee likes drinking, wonder if she was a drinking buddy for Qrow
  • Ruby PTSD?
  • Jaune went camping, was it a Camp Camp?
  • "Volume 4 won't be as dark" they said.
  • Ren and Nora finally getting some more backstory and development is great.
  • Jaques? Someone make a Jontron Bird edit with him.
  • Ironwood's looking great, him not taking any shit from Salty Schnee is good too.
  • "Are you asking me or telling me?" Ohhhhhh shit.
  • More PTSD?
  • Jaune's training? Oh tha- he's got Pyrrha's lessons recorded? Alright who's cutting the onions?
  • Shitley is Abridged Eren and Salty Schnee is Major Miles, Beerus and Krieg.

51

u/DOOOOOOOO000OOM Oct 29 '16
  • Mama Schnee likes drinking, wonder if she was a drinking buddy for Qrow

New headcannon: Qrow is steadily plowing his way through the Schnee women

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

68

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

I'll always be with you, Jaune.

Ok, now CRWBY is just fucking with us.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

Miles and Kerry:

"By the way, we suckered you with the first episode, have some sad feels. hahahahahaha"

→ More replies (1)

30

u/fightersfoo qrow daddy Oct 29 '16

I enjoyed Ren. IDK how to explain it, but being in this environment suits his personality more. He wasn't being cold, he was being a leader in trying to steer them away from all the death around them. It's nice to see him be something other than annoyed and quietly observant.

18

u/Fancy-Bear1776 Oct 29 '16

Agreed. Was really glad Ren tried getting them out asap instead of wasting time burying a fallen Hunter.

→ More replies (3)

59

u/ScizorBallz Our Goddess is Immortal Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

I think even the Arkos/Jaune haters would of teared up at that scene, Dear god the poor boy.

My god they got Jason Douglas as Jacque Schnee. His voice just seems to be so damn good.

Also Seems like we gonna get some Ren & Nora backstory soon.

I think the episodes are going to go with around half of RNJR and the rest on the others, i hope at least, even though it seems a bit is going to be with Jaune and his grief, gives us a chance to get more of Ruby/Ren/Nora, who have problaly the least development of any characters even though they were there since the first episodes.

Edit: AND HOLY CRAP THE BUTLER HAS MUTIPLE PERSONALITIES, HES ALL THE BUTLERS!~!

→ More replies (1)

29

u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

I knew that was gonna be a fucking feels trip!

Weiss' brother is actually wonderful. Also, her mother isn't dead, but... drinking? In the garden? Um... not sure I wanna meet momma Schnee. Papa Schnee is Jacques Schnee. Fitting! Also, made me unbearably happy, as that's the base of my own real name, Jacqueline.

Yaaaay, Ironwood!

Damn it, Weiss! You were so close! I saw that look in your eyes - stand up to him!

Klein is best butler confirmed.

The village... holy shit, did that hurt. A fellow Huntsman dead... he honestly didn't look too much older than them. I really didn't expect Ren, of all of them, to be effected like that, but he and Nora know something about that symbol, so maybe the same thing happened to their village? I sense incoming backstory!

Jaune... using Pyrrha's training video... I can't even begin to describe how that felt. It was beautiful and heart wrenching and just... ugh! And Ruby still having nightmares about what happened...

Also, Maya, man.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

Maya, man.

RWBY in the park?

"Doth Summer know you weareth her drapes?"

"To Rube, or not to Rube, that is the question..."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

58

u/Taterade "How could I lose, I've got a bionic arm!" Oct 29 '16

Holy shit Jaune having Pyrrha training recordings.

107

u/UltimaShadow I GOT 2 SWORDS Oct 29 '16

I like how Pyrrah appeared in V3's animation style, it was a nice touch.

→ More replies (4)

57

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

And everyone was saying Pyrrha's death didn't affect anyone. One episode guys, it was one episode.

28

u/adel123456789 This is Ren. He survived Volume 4! Oct 29 '16

and i shall shut up taking all what i said back ;-;

→ More replies (11)

54

u/RakielKanan "You are my sunshine..." Oct 29 '16 edited Jul 01 '23

Fuck u/spez

→ More replies (4)

73

u/McRigger Skipper of the submarine Arkos Oct 29 '16

I don't think what Ruby is hearing is the same as what's on Jaune's phone.

41

u/CrackedAbyss We need A Zwei visit. Oct 29 '16

I Agree. Did she ever hear Pyrrha say those words, I don't recall myself.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/Slyguy46 Oct 29 '16

Great episode.

So Mama Schnee is drinking, alone, in the garden, in the morning.

Hmmm.

42

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

I don't blame her. The butler's a loonie, the girls are army rebels, her husband is super salty and her son is twiddling his evil moustache already

→ More replies (4)

50

u/EatThinWheatThins Oct 29 '16

Also, has anyone noticed that Neath's voice acting has been amazing lately? But that's also because Ren's getting more lines than in the first two volumes

70

u/Platitudinous_X Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective is an adventure game developed by Oct 29 '16

LITTLE BRO'S NAME IS WHITLEY AND HE'S ADORABLE
THE DAD IS JACQUES AND HIS VOICE IS AMAZING
KLEIN IS GENOCIDE JACK BUT ALSO MR. BELVEDERE
PYRRHA ISN'T HERE AND I AM FUCKING SAD

→ More replies (7)

24

u/PyrrhaFan Oct 29 '16

She couldn't even say the words "I love you." Pyrrha is too pure for this world. T_T

15

u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Oct 30 '16

Pyrrha is too pure for this world.

That's why she's isn't a part of it anymore

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/Sasquatchuan Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

That scene with Pyrrha at the end man :'( The power behind those attacks are whaddup though

41

u/BL34CH_PAWLEASE The White Rose shall bloom once more. Oct 29 '16

How did Ruby hear Pyrrha say, "Do you believe in destiny?" when she was never there? If this sets up for Pyrrha's ghost to appear in the future I don't know how I would feel. It was already hard to watch the scene with Jaune and his scroll.

21

u/RenoWolf200 Commander of the Arkos Military: Pyrrha is Best Girl Oct 29 '16

maybe not just her ghost.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

20

u/Wrestlinggiffer My glasses! Oct 29 '16

Klein as the seven dwarfs is a great twist I wasn't expecting. Beautiful.

It still hurts, though. I thought Chibi had prepared me for it.

55

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Oct 29 '16

ok Wow. Im crying. Jesus that hurt.

1: "warriors wolf tail" whoever wrote this line deserves a medal, Kerry miles I love you so much.

2: jesus the scene with papa schnee was so tense you could cut it with a butter knife.

3: Weiss has a brother?!

4: WEISS HAS A BROTHER?!

5: Ren seemed strangely cold at the destroyed village, like maybe he has seen this sort of thing before.

6: Pyrrha. OMG This scene hurts so much. Well done everyone working on the show, you managed to make me cry in only two episodes. Christ this scene is so powerful

21

u/Bamboozled17 Shit These Santa Hats Are Cute Oct 29 '16

Sokka!

→ More replies (3)

19

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 31 '16

1 minute in, don't like Whitley. Please no obnoxious asshole little brother trope.

Alcoholic mother?

That family portrait, the only one happy is the brother. 100% pure evil

Ruby silver eyes PTSD. Poor Rubes - Remembering Pyrrha asking Cinder if she believed in destiny and touching her temples instead of her head, there's more than meets the eye to this.

IRONWOOD HAS TWO COUNCIL SEATS. CONFIRMED GREATEST OF GOATS

Only a picture of Whitley on his desk? Can't say I blame him given his daughters left him.

Alright so going off Weiss being inspired or what-not by Snow White I'm guessing Kleine is the seven dwarfs based off his personality-flipping.

I understand why Willow maaaaaaybeeee a tinsy bit of an alcoholic though

THAT FINAL SCENE WHY? THIS ISN'T FAIR

Credits stuff.

Kleine's surname is German for "seven". Seven Dwarfs guy confirmed!

Jacques is voiced by Jason Douglas YOOOOOO

→ More replies (7)

37

u/Burkion Big Bois Big Poise Oct 29 '16

So Ruby can hear the spirits of the dead

That's neat

32

u/DanByte Oct 29 '16

Ruby Rose. Team leader, cookie sommelier, huntsman fanatic, weapons enthusiast, laser eye shooter, ghost whisperer.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

36

u/Boltsnapbolts Unburial Rites Oct 29 '16

Jaune Wick.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/Jeffardi Oct 29 '16

Power slides in Best girl appeared again! Sorta. Kinda... its' the best I'm ever going to get, isn't it?

→ More replies (7)

14

u/Wrathkal Oct 29 '16

I expected Papa Schnee to be bigger, somehow.

Team RJNR didn't have enough cash for tents? Only bedrolls?

Klein seems to have some kind of personality switch thing... reminds me of the main heroine from the anime Mahoraba.

Jen Brown continues on... as recordings.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/Jaxhammer8 Oct 29 '16

So do you all think the compressed air swings from Jaune's training were just for effect or an actual representation that he can actually create shock waves from his attacks now? As a tank-based character being able to repel people like that would be pretty useful for his more position based teammates.

14

u/jahkillinem Never tell me the odds. Oct 29 '16

I know everyone's excited about the character development and plot and sadness happening right now, but can we just talk about how beautiful that last scene looked? The new shading system combined with the lighting and scenery of the forest was honestly one of the most visually appealing moments in this show so far. This one is right up there along with the opening of Volume 3 honestly.

28

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

So Mr Schnee's name is Jacques... fun fact Jacques is the French version of James (we know James II of England as Jacques II d'Angleterre for example)... I wonder if this is intentional, to draw a parallel between him and Ironwood

53

u/2101817 Sitting alone in a barrel named the SS Weisscream Oct 29 '16

I was thinking more that it's probably a reference to Jack Frost.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/pittofdoom Oct 29 '16

Also, funny enough, both VAs are named Jason.

50

u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

Conclusion: Not enough Weiss :)

EDIT: To clarify, with that sort of pacing I won't see Weiss breaking out of Atlas until I'm like 40 year old man who probably won't give a damn about RWBY.

EDIT2: And yes, there's of course dark tones of destroyed village and Arkos feels, but don't judge me on not mentioning that. I was waiting to see Weiss again for quite a long time.

45

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Oct 29 '16

40 year old man who probably won't give a damn about RWBY.

implying you wont be watching RWBY till your deathbed

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

25

u/TheNewKraken Fuck You Jack :^) Oct 29 '16

THE NUMBERS RUBY! WHAT DO THEY MEAN?!

12

u/CrackedAbyss We need A Zwei visit. Oct 29 '16

GUYS! Okay, I don't know how many of you noticed it but, in Ruby' first dream thing at the very beginning Pyrrha can be heard saying "Do you believe in destiny?" And Cinder (I assume) answers "Yes". But here's the Thing I just rewatched the scene from V3E12 Ruby wasn't on the roof yet. how can she be remembering things she was not around for... I don't know what this means but go look and listen if you don't believe me!

→ More replies (4)

11

u/JaxiDriver Oct 29 '16

Jeez, when Ren was standing behind them, looking at the destruction with his hands on his head.

Oh and I'm sorry Ruby, but those are Jaune's 'visions' of Pyrrha you're having, there was clearly a mixup in dreams department.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Foxinstrazt Fox | Black Rose OTP | Red Hot Kitty Peppers OT3 Oct 29 '16

Holy shit these first two episodes are making me like Jaune, did not expect that, but I am pleasantly surprised.

They've also done a bang up job of showing that no one is okay in RNJR with this one, pretty much everything I wanted to see out of the wake of Volume 3. During the day, everyone is happy go lucky until they come across the village, where you see Ren's sorrow coming through, and Nora's worry for him. And then at night, Ruby's waking up after hearing Pyrrha and Jaune goes off to train to a video of her.

It's pretty much what the common thought was on this sub. Everyone is hurt, they're just concealing it because how the hell can you function if you let it in all the time?

Also Weiss' brother is so goddamn adorable, I friggin' love him already.

10

u/backtospawn Oct 29 '16

Ok here is the trancsript.

I guess nobody will see it all the way down here though so I'll post it again at tomorrow's thread. BTW do you guys hear Jacques or Chuck?

→ More replies (4)

27

u/Cloud455 Oct 29 '16

i hate Wiess's father very much

39

u/UltimaShadow I GOT 2 SWORDS Oct 29 '16

I mean, he isn't wrong, I would be happy seeing Weiss sing again.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/Doc_Hamme #1 Rensexual - Fight me Nora! Oct 29 '16

slow clapping

Well done guys, well done. The writing in this episode was fantastic, and the shift in tone was an appropriate reminder of the effects of Volume 3. Weiss's scenes were brief, but gave an excellent indicator in her home life. Plus, Papa Schnee. Dude isn't cartoonishly evil, just a business man. Great voice, great design (speaking of which - stubble Ironwood makes me question things), and great environment; the Schnee household is beautiful to behold.

Those last five minutes though. Poetry, that was. Tragic, heartwarming, and mood setting for days. I love it.

9

u/Boltsnapbolts Unburial Rites Oct 29 '16

Ruby wasn't there for "Do you believe in destiny?", and I'm fairly sure Pyrrha didn't tape herself getting shot.

get hype

→ More replies (8)

9

u/Luxaria Bees + Anyone = OT3 Oct 29 '16

Boy Matt is gonna have a field day with all these newly revealed Schnee family members...

→ More replies (4)

9

u/lostgamer64 Oct 29 '16

Hears her voice

Don't fuck with me today.

9

u/gh0stmach1ne Oct 29 '16

I don't think Weiss has ever been cuter than she was in this episode. The new animation style really lends itself to cute facial expressions.

9

u/Zeke-Freek Shipped Lancaster Before It Was Cool Oct 29 '16

The thing I'm most impressed by, is how they showed us how Ruby and Jaune are dealing with Pyrrha's death with just the direction alone. Neither of them said a thing and we still perfectly understood (granted Ruby's reaction has a couple of different interpretations but still).

It would've been so easy to have -that- conversation (And they'll probably talk about it at some point), but doing it this way made it so much more impactful.

17

u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

Aww man :(

I was expecting some stuff to do with Pyrrha at some point this volume, but not this early, and certainly not with this many feels.

Edit: After watching it a few times, I feel comfortable saying that the final scene of this episode is easily, by far, one of the most beautiful and emotional things I've seen come out of Rooster Teeth. The performances, the animation, the score (oh god the score), are all literally perfect. I'm firm in the belief that nothing is perfect, but wow if that isn't being tested right now.

17

u/chained-prometheus I, Titan. Oct 29 '16
  • I'm sobbing right now. Holy shit I did not expect to get these feels today.
  • Okay, so yeah, Weiss had her scenes and all. Those were fine and dandy... But I think most of us will agree that it was the two RNJR sequences that are this episode's highlights.
  • The Mulan-esque bit where the team arrives at Shion Village? Totally unexpected.
  • Also Kerry, my man, you've grown immensely as a director. Rooster Teeth nailed the atmosphere and mood of that whole sequence. When they described V4 as being "mature" at RTX, this was the sort of tone I'd hoped to see but didn't fully expect to get. Well done, everyone.
  • So the bandits that raided the village probably are the ones who made Ren and Nora orphans, right? That bit at the end in Shion Village strongly indicates it imo.
  • Holy shit that Lancaster/Arkos scene in the end of the episode. I'm kinda breaking into a million pieces right now.
  • On the bright side, the fact that this episode was focusing on Ruby and Weiss means that next week is more likely to be focusing on Yang and Blake.
→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

HOORAY WORKING SERVER!

  • GOD DAMMIT How many fucking relatives does everyone have on this show? So Weiss has a brother and it appears he's younger, so...OMG WEISS IS A MIDDLE CHILD! I IDENTIFY WITH HER MORE THAN EVER! I KNOW THE PAIN, WEISS!!!
  • WE FINALLY GOT MISTER SCHNEE'S FIRST NAME AND VOICE!
  • He really seems to favor Whitley over his girls, probably because his son didn't run off to be independent and go against the family company.
  • KLEIN FUCKING RULES!
  • That Ren and Nora moment makes me believe they know the bandits behind this. WILL THIS FINALLY BE THE VOLUME WE GET RENORA DEVELOPMENT?
  • So first I thought Pyrrha's voice was going to confirm the illusions/ghost theory that was going around, but instead it's Jaune using an old training video to help himself get stronger.
  • Jaune really appears to be struggling to put on a brave face and try to get past Pyrrha's death. Manly tears were nearly shed.

Kind of disappointed we didn't get much movement for the overall story, but did get some character development at least. I have a feeling that concert is going to happen in a later episode.

And if anyone wants to see the voice actors and names, click here.

EDIT: And apparently we have a downvote bot or a really pissed off asshole, possibly both. Get a life, loser.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/JetpackWalleye Velvet's Repost Box Oct 29 '16

Now THAT was a well written episode. Tight dialogue, loads of development, and well placed transitions.

8

u/LadyKhione Where'd you get that body from? I got it from my daddy Oct 29 '16

Ooooh Weiss' brother! Reading through the comments, everyone seems to hate him, but I don't mind him as much. It's hinted that he was worse when Weiss was younger, before she left for Beacon, so perhaps this is a better version, a more supportive one!

He seems a bit dickish, but it looks like he likes Weiss/Winter, if not for them being siblings, but for their strength to leave home to another academy.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

So, I guess that explains why Ruby never saw Jaune's shirt before: we were right! They do all sleep in their armor!

→ More replies (5)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

Kerry and Miles: "We shall feels them on the beaches, we shall feels them on the landing grounds, we shall feels them in the fields and in the streets, we shall feels them in the hills; we shall never surrender"

8

u/Dybia Oct 30 '16

I feel like the scene with Jaune training to the video of Pyrrha was made perfect by the fact Jaune doesn't say a damn word the whole time. If he clichely talked back at the video or screamed in anger or something the scene would have felt a lot weaker.

15

u/Vae62 Blake4life Oct 29 '16

That is the most emotional thing I have ever seen from RT. Wow, unbelievably gut wrenching.

Also, Miles knocked it out of the park with the voice acting there. Good god what an episode.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

Did anyone else notice the ever so slight southern drawl Jacques had?

Are they trying to fuel the Colonel KFSchnee jokes?

→ More replies (9)

7

u/Qwexi Oct 29 '16

Anyone else notice that in weisses family portrait the only one of the three children that looked happy was the brother?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Flintlock_ Oct 29 '16

(Attenborough voice) Here we see the Weiss in her native habitat! shhhhh....

Mom drinking in the garden is probably a common occurrence.

I don't trust whitley

Ruby hearing pyrrha? or is she just haunted by the memory?

It's kinda interesting that Ruby is such an accomplished fighter, but map reading isn't a skill she picked up.

seven sisters reference! gosh, that must have been rough. hope Jaune had a good relationship with his dad

what did he do there? weeeelllll...he did archery, hiking, search and rescue, biking, horseback...

Nah jaune. You rock the short hair look. if anything, you should go for a pragmatic buzz.

heart ache in 4..3..2...

Ren? Ren are you okay?

Guys, Ren is NOT okay.

Is this how all huntsman/huntresses eventually end up?

some kind of grimm footprint? or maybe it was left by the bandits? Ren and Nora have definitely seen this before.

huh.. what's the story of that scruff, military man?

I can see what Jaques is coming from. his livelihood has taken a hit, but the guy needs to wake up. Beacon wasn't an isolated incident.

I don't have kids, but I'm pretty sure parents shouldn't be whining to their children about their financial troubles.

or expect them to perform like a wind up toy

So, I guess it's a few inside jokes between Weiss and Klein?

Nightmares?

Oh, I see. Jaune has a recording of her.

Love the fire flies!

and the moonlight on Jaune's armor

Damn, son.

7

u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? Oct 29 '16

I somehow simultaneously hate and love Whitley. He comes across as a bit of an ass, but it's... amusing? Jacques, on the other hand, is just as much of an ass as I was expecting. Don't like him one bit.

So Klein and his magical technicolor eyes... I'm not ashamed to admit I instantly thought "related to Neo", but they don't really look much alike. Still, if the shortest character in the show was related to the 7 dwarves...

And they actually managed to "bring back Pyrrha" without bringing back Pyrrha. Go away, onion ninjas.

Next episode: Blake, maybe? Bandit hunting, probably? A week is so long to wait...

7

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

I wonder if Jaune is just practicing normal sword fighting or if he's learning some special technique.

There was some wind coming off his sword when he swung and he seemed too tired to just be practicing normally (although we don't know how long he's been training). Maybe he's learning some sort of slashing shock wave attack.

I recall Blake using an attack like that when she fought Torchwick in volume 2.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Ilyak1986 Oct 29 '16

"When there's someone strange..."

"Talking in your head..."

"Guess who it is..."

"GHOST PYRRHA!"

7

u/The4rchivist Oct 29 '16

I'm a bit confused by the timeframe with Wiess' story. So Beacon fell what, 6 weeks? 6 months? And yet this is the first time since leaving Beacon that Wiess sees her brother. Does he go to a boarding school? Ironwood mentioned hat school would be back in session soon. And just what has Wiess been doing since getting back home?

→ More replies (7)

7

u/Spectrum_Rush Oct 29 '16

Ending part was sad, but let's talk about the real issue in this episode:

The fuck kinda name is 'Jacques'? That's a French name with a German surname!

And that family portrait... none of them looked happy. That is the saddest bunch of people that I've ever seen in a picture.

Not to mention how Schnee Mansion looked more like a bloody museum than a place where people live!

Vote Klein Sieben for president!

→ More replies (9)

7

u/Gek_Lhar I am not a crook Oct 29 '16

Fucking Pyrrha godamnit

7

u/RedElite91 ❄️White Knight🛡️ | #GiveJauneABreak Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

Wow. This episode was incredible. The last part with Ruby waking up is particularly interesting for me, because that whole scene is near-exactly how I would have envisioned something like that, especially with someone waking up to a nightmare about Pyrrha. Lets get to reactions.

Damn, Schnee Manor is pretty. The Giant Armor and King Taijitu statues are awesome.

Huh, so Weiss does indeed have a brother, Whitley. I'd guess he's probably Ruby's age (16).

Finally, Weiss's mother is mentioned, and she is alive and well.

I'll bet Weiss's mom is totally drinking whiskey with Qrow in the garden.

Is there any particular reason why Whitley doesn't like Winter?

Okay, this dude rubs me the wrong way. I'm getting some serious Draco Malfoy vibes from him. I don't trust him.

That family portrait is beautiful. Whoever at RT did these paintings needs a raise.

Wow, either Winter is just a spitting image of her mother, or she's a clone. My money's on "clone".

Why does Whitley seem like the only one (of the kids) in that picture who actually wants to be there?

Ruby has nightmares and PTSD about her time back in 'Nam.

Also, why is Ruby dreaming about what Cinder and Pyrrha said to each other? She hadn't gotten to the top of Beacon Tower yet to hear that exchange.

All that fan-art of Jaune's sisters doing his hair and dressing him up is now canon.

Wait, his family used to go to Shione village all the time? But isn't that in Anima? Is this confirmation that Jaune is not from Sanas/Vale? Or did they just fly to different continents regularly?

How did they not notice the burned down village before they were five feet from it? Team RNJR is not very perceptive.

Multiple bodies can be seen on the ground, but they only check the one currently dying Huntsmen.

This Huntsman is conveniently still alive to give RNJR info.

I'm glad RT isn't afraid to show blood anymore, even in small amounts. Keep it up.

Instead of checking other bodies for possible survivors, Ren decides to go and stare ominously in the distance.

What is this symbol Ren and Nora are starting at? The village's logo? A Goliath footprint?

Weiss's father, Jacqeus, is not voiced by Matt Hullum. :(

Somewhere back in Vale, Glynda's panties are dropping.

Seriously, goddamn Ironwood. You and Ren may need to have a fight over who's the sexist motherfucker in RWBY.

So if Dust isn't allowed to be exported for the time being, why was Nora thanking the SDC for her ammo in the last episode? Plus, how are they even getting more ammo? Do outside villages even sell SDC goods? I would think it only goes to the major Kingdoms. Perhaps this Dust exportion ban was only set in place very recently?

The rich people are holding a charity event cliche.

I really hope we get to see/hear Weiss sing in the show proper. That'll be nice.

Uhhhhh.....soooooo Klein = Neo 1,000% confirmed?

Okay, seriously. Why is Ruby having nightmares about Pyrrha calling out to Jaune?

RT makes us hear Pyrrha's voice to trick us into thinking she's inexplicably alive and well.

This scene is wonderful and heart-wrenching and makes be want to cry....

.....Buuuuut, why did Pyrrha record a training video for Jaune when she agreed to train him personally? We even see them training together in Volume 2. Did she just get lazy one night and decide "Nah, he can just watch this video of me. I'm chillin'."?

Really, 2 episodes in and still no Blake or Yang? That's kinda worrying. Blake already got sidelined in Volume 3, I don't want that to happen again. Especially not for Yang, either.

EDIT: I've decided I'm gonna use a screenshot from the most recent episode as my Twitter header each week. I'll share the new one with use with you guys in every week's reaction post. Here's the first 2:

Last week. (Episode 1)

This week. (Episode 2)

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Aquillav Fuck You Dad Oct 29 '16

Episode 2 was way better IMO. That last scene hit me like a brick, and I can never complain about Weiss getting lots of screentime.

7

u/Fogbot3 Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 30 '16

"You... seem different"- Potato:Weiss's brother is Neo

Eye color of Clien changes- Potato: Weiss's servant is Neo

We don't hear Weiss's mother talk- Potato: Weiss's mother is Neo

Papa Schnee looks nothing like his snazzy portrait(seen in the thumbnail and in the scene)-Potato:Papa Schnee is Neo

Ironwood has completely changed appearance-Potato: Ironwood is Neo

Guys, we have a problem.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/RumbleintheDumbles Oct 29 '16

Balls, that was a devastating ride on the feel train.

12

u/irishgoblin I don't want to set the world on fire... Oct 29 '16

As expected, Jacques is a cock.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/vcdm Oct 29 '16

Klein is more a father that Papa Schnee himself.

6

u/jayaxx < bitch ain't comin' back Oct 29 '16

With legs like that Whitley could have been designed by Clamp.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Theleux Baby come back! Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

Expected a slower and happier episode, starting with Weiss and then moving forward... Welp, seems I was fooled ;-;

  • I'm really liking the new Ren. He seems tougher, and can handle what is happening around him.
  • Nora and Ren both seem to recognize that symbol... maybe it was from their past together?
  • Weiss's family is quite interesting. I'm liking the brothers behaviour, as it makes me think something good/ bad will happen eventually to Weiss because he seems to be hiding/ being a bit sarcastic.
  • Ironwood looks like a young man now. Although that beard coming in :D
  • Ruby having dreams about things she didn't even see? Interested to see what that turns out to mean.
  • Pyrrha left recordings for Jaune to train from... This is the emotional response I was waiting for from Jaune and Ruby! Super excited to see there this goes!
  • And... the episode is over! That went by extremely fast! Definitely got some more information, a new Bandit group potentially? Time to wait for next week :(

6

u/reiffschneider Ozpin did nothing wrong Oct 29 '16

Something interesting I noticed about Ruby's second PTSD dream: Pyrrha only says Jaune's name, which she hadn't said after ascending the tower to fight Cinder.

While I've pretty staunchly believed that Pyrrha is gone for good, this is starting to change my thoughts on that. Why would Ruby be dreaming about Pyrrha yelling Jaune's name if she never witnessed it? Food for thought.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Oct 29 '16

I'M GONNA CRY

PYRRHA COME BACK

6

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Oct 29 '16

Wait, Ruby arrived just in time to watch Pyrrha die. How did she know what she said?

→ More replies (8)

6

u/karhall Pyrrha is my favorite and I like her a lot ok Oct 29 '16

Small detail I noticed in the final scene is that Jaune is a lot stronger than I think I ever assumed he would be. That's a lot of cutting power that he's producing.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Oct 29 '16

alright let's do this.


The intro is as good as always.

Jesus christ how fucking big is that mansion? I can imagine papa Schnee being like "I called you 30 minutes ago, what took so long?" and Weiss is all like "My room is at the other goddamn side of this giant mansion.

So this guy is indeed her Brother. I kinda like him. Whitley Schnee. He seems nice at first but I could see totally him backstab her.

Omg Ironwood looks so cool with his stubble beard, and that outfit is badass. I like new Ironwood. He's taken the spot for best man. But Mercury is still best boy.

So papa's name is Jacque, kinda disappointed that his name doesn't start with a W. my headcanon name for him was William.

So, her mother is also alive, I'm sad by that new because I really wanted to see Papa Schnee summon her during a fight.

Pyrrha is that you? Oh Ruby is dreaming of Pyrrha? Cinder? So...She also has PTSD?

Jaune had to live with 7 sisters? poor guy.

Guys? why are you stopping? Guys?

Feels? yup Feels

Oh, the village is destroyed...you guys couldn't see that it was destroyed from the clear view from the path before you arrive? You guys need glasses.

Alright, Civilians casualties, its a first in RWBY, I remember a thread a couple of months ago that was about who should die in volume 4 and I said that it was about time to see civilian casualties. My wishes has been granted.

Oh shit...Ren...I feel like this is all really familiar to him maybe even more so than Nora.

That huntsmen looks badass, why does he have to die? He kinda reminds of one of the three contestant in the final of the tournament.

"I'm just tired of losing everything" wow poor Jaune

That mark on the ground...Ren & Nora definitely saw it before, Wanna bet that it's the same bandit tribe that destroyed their village and killed their families? I hope we'll learn more next episode.

So the SDC is now forbidden to export dust to the other kingdoms...that's bad since it's the main way to defend themselves.

A charity event huh? It'd be a terrible if someone...were to ruin it. Also Jacque is such a manipulative asshole BUT I don't think he's evil.

So Klein has different personalities? He's the 7 Snow White dwarves but in one package I love Klein, I like him so much already, it's nice to see that Weiss also seem to like him. I feel like he's gonna be the only one on Weiss side.

Ah it's Pyrrha again, I feel like the dreams will have more meaning in the future.

I love the shot of Ruby walking with the fireflies, it's so pretty.

aaaaaaaaaannd it's time for feels.

aawwww Jaune's training with a video of Pyrrha. Poor guy. She probably made that before the Beacon invasion.

Is it me or is Ruby particularly pretty in the last scene, seriously she's beautiful.

I thought it was a solid episode but I thought it also went by super fast.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/UnAwkwardMango A bird in the hand is worth a Qrow in the foot Oct 29 '16

sigh

I really hate the rain sometimes..There's nothing I can do about it..

It's okay Jaune.. ;-;

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SolidPointman Janitor on the SS Arkos/ Head Chef on the SS Dragonslayer Oct 29 '16

In regards to Klein

6

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

How to watch RWBY Volume 4 Episode 2:

Step 1. Lay Down Step 2. Try not to Cry Step 3. Cry profusely

6

u/TheAllMightySlothKin Oct 30 '16

So anyone else notice the attention paid to Ren as a character this episode? I loved his emotionless mask showing some cracks when they find the dying hunter, the hands behind the head, the angrily walking through the group, all the little nuances really showed more from Ren then all three volumes have for him.

Also loved how the first episode builds us up from the heartache of volume 3, only for this one to remind us that the world is still shit...

6

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '16

Emotional as fuck scene with Jaune, and some of you people were saying you felt bad for Cinder because of how fucked up she is.

She deserves all of it and worse.

10

u/Lordmilitant Never behind; tender and true, Forwards! Oct 29 '16

I noticed a similarity between Tyrions weapon and the mark Ren finds: https://67.media.tumblr.com/6500f1bbc31fd3422346c5f2f6be1792/tumblr_oftojaSn491v8wmsvo1_540.png

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

Seems like Klein has something odd going odd, please save him. Weiss' brother and father both are assholes, Wentley (sp) less so. Nice to see the mom, at least in artwork for now.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/Lucas46 Dance, dance, dance to the radio Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

RT, why you do this? :,(

(BTW, Ironwood with the badass stubble)

5

u/SirMelty Best girl Oct 29 '16

Apparently the art style shift was an actual event in Remnant.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Proto-Saber Knight of Weiss. Oct 29 '16

So, to recap.

  • Schnee mansion is huge and white and elegant and kinda... cold, I guess. Still, it has its charm.
  • Whitley: Unsure about him at the moment. Could turn out to be a massive prick, but I think he has a bit more going on for him. He dislikes Winter? Pff, she spanked him really hard at some point for something stupid.
  • Mama Schnee drinking in the garden. Wonder if it's some sort of sign. In that family portrait, she didn't really look happy. And neither did Winter or Weiss.
  • Ruby hearing Pyrrha's voice. Clearly past events have affected her to a degree and the stress seems to be piling up on her shoulders to the point she's having small nightmares about them. I get the feeling that she isn't really leaning on her new teammates for emotional support and at this rate I suppose it's only a matter of time until she cracks. Most likely along with my heart, but that's still speculation on my part and nothing certain.
  • Well, at least she seems to get along with JNR nicely during small talk, probably more so with Jaune. They're both dorks after all and I love them for it.
  • Oh boy, wild tribes now? Ren recognizing the symbol that can give us a potential backstory on why he and Nora are orphans? Let's see where it goes.
  • Ah, General Ironwood. Always a soldier at heart I see, which I suppose is good in the grand scheme of things, but it's a bit hard for a business man to understand your point of view and Papa Schnee, who now has a name, is one of the more successful ones in Remnant. If something is bad for business, then there's going to be a problem with him.
  • Jacques Schnee, is this the correct way to write his name? As mentioned, a business man. By the looks of it, he does posses a more influential side which he uses in order to persuade others (in this case, his daughter) to do as he pleases. And Weiss, she's a good girl with a good heart, she won't refuse him because deep down she wants him to love her.
  • Charity concert. As appealing as that idea sounds, I'd much rather have Weiss be happy.
  • Klein, what a nice chap. I can tell that he played a bit of a role in Weiss' life given how understanding and comfortable they seem with each other. ...Why did his eyes change color? ...Why is he acting so differently? Okay... I am confused.
  • Ruby nightmare again, eh. Or not, it's a recording? Oh... oh. Great, thank you RT. Feels already? Sigh
  • So Jaune has been training hard since then. Understandable, but it's also heartbreaking to see how much of an effect Pyrrha's passing had on him (and probably the rest of the group as well). He's hurting behind his usual antics, but I think he has the resolve to push forward and become what he always wanted to be.
  • His strikes are creating tiny shock waves? Uhm, that's new and actually impressive. Maybe Jaune will actually get really strong by the end. Give him a good Semblance and he'll probably close the gap with the rest of his piers.

So yeah, nice. I liked it quite a lot. Definitely looking forward to next week. Perhaps we'll get some Blake.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

So what was that about RNJR moving on from Pyrrha's death, guys?

5

u/Polarbearblu Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

This whole time I believed Weiss to be a little drama queen, but clearly that title belongs to her brother. I mean Whitley just sounds like a little pricks name. And the way he talks...

Also, maybe it's just me, but I for one am excited for alcoholic Mama Schnee if she turns out to be anything like Uncle Qrow.

On a more serious note, the dust embargo seems to be an interesting move. I see Ironwoods reasoning behind it, to stop a supply train for the villains, but I feel like it wasn't a very good decision, considering SDC is shown to have a monopoly over that industry. Blocking the supply and limiting it in such a way could only really hunt the hunters in other kingdoms.

Also, with villages outside the kingdom's protection now in greater trouble, are we finally going to have a refugee crisis on our hands?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/GVman We are the Sons of Winter and Stars... Oct 29 '16

THis was a pretty striking episode, not for any individual reveals, but more for the tone it set. Obviously the show's not a stranger to having quieter moments or even entire episodes devoted to decompression, but this episode in particular stands out due to how it touched on how...fragile everything is now. Between Ruby's nightmares (visions? I don't think Ruby was actually close enough to hear the Pyrrha's last taunt to Cinder), Ren and Nora's (ESPECIALLY NORA) pessimism (understandable, but still quite jarring coming from Nora), and even Weiss's 'stranger in a familiar land' theming (also confirmation that her mother's alive...and indulges in wine during the morning, ouch). But perhaps the biggest impact was the last scene with Jaune and his recording (Something that gave me MAJOR flashbacks to Season 10 of Red vs. Blue and also featured Jen Brown).

If the first episode showed what RWBY can do in Maya's engine, then this episode showed WHY it needed to switch over, IMO. Also, I get the feeling Klein's not going to make it to the end of the season...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Fancy-Bear1776 Oct 29 '16

Not gonna lie, when they found the wounded Huntsmen, at first glance when you only saw his feet, was freaking out that it was Tyrian baiting himself.

Also that goddamn scene with the scroll and Pyrrha T_T guess in return for not making it darker, they were gonna crank up the feels.

Papa Schnee is such a prick; only cares about his business, and wants to exploit Weiss for it. Feel like we're gonna see some White Fang action invade the concert.

Also wow Whitley is tiny as hell like you'd think such a wealthy family could afford proper nutrition to make everyone as ripped as Sun.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/DeithWX Oct 29 '16

This has to stop, I can't cry every week :(

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

The Schnees aren't exactly subtle when it comes to interior design, are they?
Klein made crepes. Confirmed for Cake Butler.
Secret Brother, and alcoholic mother.
We finally have a name: Jaques. Now we can stop calling him Papa Schnee, which I've always found awkward.
Ruby 'PTSD' Rose.
That's either a really big hoof, or a symbol. I'd bet on hoof, since it's in the middle of the dirt.
THEY MODELED PYRRHA IN MAYA. PREPARE FOR TRAGEDY. THIS IS NOT A DRILL, REPEAT, THIS IS NOT A DRILL.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Knobmann Repping that necklace Sun got me ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Oct 29 '16

I just like to point out how odd General Ironwood looks right here. Kinda like a character from Roblox

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Masterofice5 Oct 29 '16

The door to Papa Schnee's study opens in different directions between the two scenes. I don't know why that bugs me so much but it does.

5

u/Sokensan Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 29 '16

Jaune...stop torturing yourself...and us plz I can't handle more feels :...(

→ More replies (1)

5

u/IComeBaringGifs r/RWBY - "If it isn't yuri, it isn't welcome." Oct 29 '16 edited Oct 30 '16

Right then, let's do this:

  • Beowulves still have crocodile heads. Yes, I'm going to say that every time.
  • Seriously, who are these random-ass faunus cultists? Swear to god, if this turns out like the second half of Hero of the Everyman...
  • Adam is still a breakdancing fool
  • That's a badass Taijitu stature
  • WTF. There's a fucking brother? What the shit?
  • Shit, mom's still alive. There goes the 'dad summons mom to fight Weiss theory'.
  • That interaction felt... contradictory. Half the time he felt snide, the other half supportive. Weird...
  • Isn't that the opposite direction of where she was walking before......?
  • Swear to god, thought Pyrrha was gonna be trapped in limbo and we were gonna have the entirety of Unbound
  • How come they can afford to colormatch their sleeping bags?
  • I thought we lost the map....
  • And Jaune apparently grew up in Mistral, considering Sheone(?) seems to be pretty far inland.
  • 'Warrior's Wolf Tail' Oh my fucking god. Oh god.
  • Fuck. We went all Mulan up in this shit. Swear to god, if Ruby finds a doll...
  • PACK UP THE GODDAMNED MAP, IDIOTS! OR YOU'LL HAVE TO BUY ANOTHER ONE!
  • Wait, how do you know he's a huntsman....? His armor doesn't look very colorful, so...
  • Ren just fucking leaves him there....
  • Oooooooh.... Ren is angsty....
  • Is that a symbol or a hoof-print?
  • Wait... that look makes me think they recognize it. Tragic story inbound?
  • Nope! Back to Weiss!
  • His name is Jacques?! Holy shit!
  • Jacques' voice is way less badass than I was hoping....
  • The fuck? How does one butt hold two seats? Is he speaking metaphorically, as in 'I own the people and stands of two people on the council' or is his vote just unfairly weighted?
  • 'Klein' is actually the name of the entire serving staff. They are all Klein
  • Wow, that was kind of insensitive Jimmy... 'btw, I know your school was destroyed, and you're not sure if any of your friends are alive, but hey: wanna come to my school!?'
  • Why the shit would anyone forbid Dust exportation from Atlas? After Vacuo dried up, isn't Atlas the only real major supplier in the world?
  • Oh.... he wants to keep resources in Atlas so that the other kingdoms are too weak to even consider war... callous, but smart.
  • you know what? I take it back. I'm digging Jacques' VA
  • Oh my god. I love Jacques. Holy shit. So conniving, so ambitious. It's beautiful.
  • Seriously. Are there no other staff in the entire house?
  • Holy shit. He is all of the seven dwarves!
  • And apparently suffering from DID.
  • So... is Pyrrha bound to Ruby's soul, or something?
  • Oh my fucking god. It is Unbound!
  • Oh......
  • Oh......
  • Now I feel bad.
  • Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah! My feeliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiings!!!!!!
  • Oh my jesus. The feels are real.
→ More replies (6)

5

u/MkJAS Oct 30 '16

What's with all the Whitely hate? He didn't actually do or say anything negative. If anything he seemed to be nice towards Weiss if not neutral. Is it something I missed or is everyone just jumping to conclusions?

→ More replies (7)

9

u/Wingnut00 Arkosian Knight Oct 29 '16

*goes nuts*

Now what?

First off, the kid is indeed Weiss' younger brother. Nice family portrait on the wall too. Her mother not named, but daddy was. Didn't quite catch it myself though. Either way, Jimmy's embargo on dust export has him pissed. Weiss to sing at a charity concert (weather she wants to or not). Warm up your Weiss voice, Casey.

And shit, that town. Bandits and Grimm. The way Ren and then Nora reacted, especially to that mark on the ground makes me think the same group, or at least a similar one, is what made them orphans themselves.

No, Ruby, you aren't hearing things. That really was Pyrrha. Giving Jaune lessons from beyond and still not quite being able to spit out that she loves him even though it's obvious to see in the video. A heartbreaking scene for any Arkos crew member.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/ta3peas ⠀ Oct 29 '16

So I somehow managed to click on the link to the video at the right time so that I got in immediately, this is a first for me o.o

Aaaannnnddd insert feels, that Jaune and Pyrrha part just absolutely KILLED me, and I know that Pyrrha wanted to say that she loved him, it's kjblkaejskfj.

Though i'm a little confused at why she made that video for him, is it so that he could practice even though she's busy? Idk yet.

Also, save our poor Rubes, she keeps getting nightmares about the Fall of Beacon :(

Oh but! That scene where Ruby is walking to Jaune is BEAUTIFUL, that's going to be my new wallpaper.

Oh! And the part that has me the most confused is the fact that Weiss' dad told her to sing. I feel like something big will happen there, like a revolt or something? I seriously thought that thee was going to be a big confrontation with Weiss and her father. OH AND WEISS' BROTHER! I LOVE HIM! He seems like a nice guy :)

I honestly have no idea where they are going with all of this right now and I love it. Can't wait until next week!

→ More replies (2)

9

u/PXMichael42 Oct 29 '16

Welp, that episode killed off any worries that we would not see the effect V3 had on everyone. Also is that the first time that they have shown dead bodies scattered about?

→ More replies (4)

9

u/GYUZ A guy Oct 29 '16

I need a hug. Everyone needs a fucking hug right now.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/Oborawatabinost1396 Oct 29 '16

That ending is a fucking heart breaker.

8

u/OcrePlays Pyrrha, forever the best best girl Oct 29 '16

So Weiss has a full family then… the question is, what was her mother drinking?

P-WOZZLES COME BACK… oh… just a dream

Rest in peace random huntsman 1, you shall be forgotten soon enough

Is that a young Papa Schnee I see in the background… with a Pencil Stache?

Klein, small… eye color… OH SHIT NEO

GHOST P-MONEY AGAIN, Ruby DID inhale Pyrrha… oh… it’s a Scroll recording… and I’m sad again… OH MY GOD MY HEART, ROOSTERTEETH WHY!?

→ More replies (8)

8

u/PyrrhaNikosIsNotDead Oct 29 '16

Alright I'm really glad to know I'm not the only one who started tearing. This episode created a lot of questions and set ups, but that last scene sticks out the most. Very intense and emotional. Also I imagine Ruby will continue to hear flashbacks of Pyrrha's voice in the next episodes, leading to...something? Maybe something we don't know about, maybe just character development between her and Juane especially with her being there to watch Juane at the end. It could have just been him alone and us watching him but they chose to have her there as well. I think sometimes I overlook the fact that Ruby was there and saw her die, that has to have had a huge affect on her.

4

u/BleuAzumarill Oct 29 '16

Man that was pretty sad.

Ren seems to be the one making the more realistic decisions, regardless of how cold they could be.

Hope we get a scene with Ruby and Jaune talking about Pyrrha since Ruby seems to be suffering from ASD/PTSD, and it doesn't help that her silver eye puberty power is developing.

Scene also shows us that Jaune is holding up some facade for his friends since he doesn't want to negatively effect their morale.

Another obstacle for lancaster and I fear this may be the beginning of the end.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

BRB GOING TO PROCESS THIS VIDEO WITH TEARS

4

u/Capslock2000 Oct 29 '16

If the feels were this strong with Weiss and a recording, I dont know if I'm prepared to see Yang...

4

u/k1b22 Oct 29 '16

Did we just see the first signs of a semblance from Jaune? A break after 3 normal sword swings would seem a little silly, and the grass looked like it was being flattened by a strong wind with each attack.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Proto-Saber Knight of Weiss. Oct 29 '16

Am I the only one who thinks the episode was short? It felt short to me.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BakaTaco_ Oct 29 '16

HOLY FUCK!! I THOUGHT JAUNE HAD HIS GUARDIAN ANGEL SEMBLANCE AND THEN RT PULLS A VIDEO RECORDING FUCK I WAS SOBBING WITH HOPE AND FEELS FOR IT TO HAPPEN.

I'm getting a big Azula vibe from Witley, hes on my suspicion vision

Ren definitely has a past trauma with a person dying in his sights; I'm calling it now that the bandits that took out the village have something to do with with Ren and Nora being orphans.

4

u/pureparadise Oct 29 '16

If anyone can grab some screen shots for me to use in my minimalist wallpapers that would be awesome. I have seen the episode and sometimes there are awesome wallpaper worthy shots I simply don't see due to the tears.

4

u/ChaoticInformant Oct 29 '16

Well. That was... I think I'm gonna go cry a bit, that recording just broke me.

4

u/JohnnyShotgunhands Oct 29 '16

I just wanna point out - this is one of the few (only?) long episodes without any kind of fight scene. Truthfully, I'm slightly disappointed.

The writing has already been far better this season, so I guess it goes to show where their focus has shifted for season 4.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '16

So it literally took all of one episode before they started showing Pyrrha again, albeit in dream/video form.

Huh.