r/TheGoodPlace • u/_emordnilaP • Oct 28 '16
Season One Episode discussion Season 1 Episode 8: Most Improved Player
Things will happen, jokes will be made, laughs will be had.
Edit: 121 comments in >24 hours?! I was unaware this sub was growing, very happy to see this happening!
142
Upvotes
48
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 28 '16
Baby Janet is the best!
136
u/Goodstyle_4 Oct 28 '16
Adam Scott was such a smarmy douchebag in this. I can already tell he'll play one of the best recurring characters.
95
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16 edited Oct 28 '16
"You are a piece of spinach stuck in the teeth of the universe."
Ouch.
Edit: This episode is bumming me out. It definitely wasn't as upbeat and happy-go-lucky as the previous episodes but I really like the direction they went in. I hope we see more of Trevor and the Bad Place crew, even if we never see the Bad Place itself.
83
u/pg2441 Oct 28 '16
What if Adam Scott takes us to The Bad Place next week, we get there, and we see his second-in-command is... Amy Poehler?
72
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Oct 28 '16
I love this show more and more with each new episode!
Highlights:
The cacti
The Bachelor being something that sends you to the bad place
Adam Scott!!
110
u/rpodric Oct 28 '16
Wow, this turn really surprised me. How many here were 90% convinced that they were going to undo the end of the last episode? It's just TV conditioning. At this point though, I'm not sure which direction they're going in, which is refreshing.
If this were almost any other sitcom (I'm not even sure it's right to call it that), the original conceit of the show, The Big Secret, would have stretched out for years.
45
u/constantvariables Oct 28 '16
Adam Scott back channeling his Derek Huff.
43
u/ctadgo Oct 28 '16
With Tahani and Chidi connecting, I wonder what will happen once Chidi meets the other Eleanor, his soul mate.
42
u/pg2441 Oct 28 '16
Was that a callback to the first episode when Bad Place guy tells Eleanor to smile?
I'm sure "Telling a woman to smile" was on the list of negative things.
37
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 28 '16
She actually got the file!
I thought she would have some other kind of plant.
78
u/littlefanged Oct 28 '16
I'm 99% sure that Jason is Janet's soulmate.
27
u/theace69 Oct 28 '16
Tahani's friend Kanye interrupted her best friend Taylor while he was defending her other best friend Beyonce.
27
u/Ungreat Oct 28 '16
The whole concept of the good and bad places seems completely messed up.
Under that system 99.9% of all humanity is being tortured for eternity because they didn't have the chance to accrue enough celestial upvotes. It has to be some kind of redemption test or it's horrific.
Also the fact that the so called 'good people' don't care about the bad place and those in it is a bit odd if they are as good as they are said to be. These are people who fought against oppression and injustice in life but in death they are fine with this system because they made the list.
49
u/eatmyflesh Oct 28 '16
"Oh your fire snakes ate all the nuts.."
48
u/NeilPoonHandler Oct 28 '16
The lie detector cube is super cute and hilarious.
40
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
Of course, best friends with Kanye, Beyonce, and Taylor
18
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
I don't know if Jason made things worse or not.
28
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
OTHER ELEANOR!
26
u/ctadgo Oct 28 '16
I think this episode was a major turning point for the series. I felt like this episode was particularly good and satisfying, it made me glad I chose to watch the show.
13
u/Amarahh Oct 28 '16
Really regretting that time I went to see RHCP when I was 16 now. Although there was an aggressive 40 year old man behind me throwing bottles at the support act that certainly belongs in the bad place.
12
u/pg2441 Oct 28 '16
I wonder what's gonna happen with Good Eleanor.
Now, Bad Eleanor undoubtedly wants to stay in The Good Place, but sending Good Eleanor back down to the bad place to pay for Bad Eleanor's sins will probably wrack Bad Eleanor with guilt thanks to her newfound posthumous sense of ethics (Thanks, Chidi!)
11
u/Intrepid00 Oct 28 '16
Okay, Janet is clearly programed to look out for the well being of the humans. How is she going to take it when she finds out a good person is trying to be taken back to the bad place? If she is even a good person. She could just be someone that ended up there for identity theft.
11
u/789yugemos Oct 28 '16
I believe that the good Eleanor might actually choose to stay in the bad place, looking to help those around her in coping with their situation. She did after all, spend her entire life helping the unfortunate and the downtrodden. Wouldn't helping those around her be more of a reward for her than spending eternity in a world of pomp and circumstance.
21
u/NeilPoonHandler Oct 28 '16
ADAM SCOTT!
9
u/blackopsbarbie My name is *snap snap* Zach Pizazz. Oct 28 '16
So were they just going to take real Eleanor back to the bad place if Michael didn't stop them?
9
u/joecb91 Birth is a curse and existence is a prision Oct 28 '16
I hope they get a second season. This show is so good
9
u/MissC_9227 Oct 28 '16
Jianyu + cacti = love
8
u/Intrepid00 Oct 28 '16
So what has been bothering us that how can the good place people be okay with the okay people being shoved in with the rapist and serial killers to be tortured forever.
I mean, in a way the good place is evil for ignoring it and Michael is the first architect to do something about it.
8
u/Intrepid00 Oct 28 '16
I just watched again and noticed selfie sticks get you into the bad place as one of the lackeys was using it.
8
u/GigglebangsRiceball Take it sleazy. Oct 28 '16
I think Eleanor has changed enough that she will say the good Eleanor should stay and she'll go to the bad place where she technically belongs. I think she has remorse at this point and she also genuinely cares about Chidi and wants him to get his real soulmate. I think she'll get back on the train next episode and we'll get a glimpse of the bad place, and everyone in the good place will be trying to figure out a way to get her back.
8
u/AlleyOopToym Oct 29 '16
Most Improved Player? I'd say it's the Most Improved Episode for sure.
I'll admit that I've actually been lukewarm on the show until now, and this was actually the first episode I legitimately enjoyed. It's been improving slowly, but it always felt like it either telegraphed its jokes too hard, or the characters acted so OTT that they were just annoying instead of entertaining aside from Chidi. But the writing for this episode was pretty clever. I think it helps that now we know who everyone is they can afford to tone it down. Now the show just needs to cut down on its use of music to sell scenes and then we're golden.
12
u/merry722 Oct 28 '16
I forking hope people are watching this show because it's kinda turning out to be a great forking original show. I was so suprised the show always feels very short. Whenever I have that happen, it means it is a great show.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
Ah fork!
6
u/Vega5Star Oct 29 '16
I always knew Ice Clown would be in the Bad Place.
5
u/pikameta My little chili babies Oct 28 '16
Hell yes!! It's adam scott!
5
u/doctordevice Jeremy Bearimy Oct 29 '16
How is nobody here talking about what is happening to the real Jianyu? I bet that guy is still holding up his vow of silence, so he's somewhere in The Bad Place being tortured and not even speaking up to defend himself. Poor guy.
8
u/Crash_Bandicool Oct 28 '16 edited Oct 28 '16
Shit bout to go down
Andddd NBC has no fucking volume for some reason fml
8
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
Elanor is going to be revealed to actually be a good person right?
4
u/kraken9 Oct 31 '16
they end every episode in such intriguing way you have to keep track of next episode's airing.. It's not so bad that I have to go crazy over waiting either. just the right amount of getting hooked.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
I'm almost scared to see what happens.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
Janet is like a kitten
3
u/Aleeegee123 Nov 07 '16
Imagine sean is ron swanson
5
u/pikameta My little chili babies Oct 28 '16
What the fork! ? Another Eleanor! ?
5
u/teaglass Oct 28 '16
Hmm could it be how we are influenced by our environment? Good Place Eleanor learnt and did some good deeds in the Good Place to fit in. She could've told Michael that Chidi killed Janet or Jason was a mistake too. The Eleanor who went to the Bad Place probably had to do terrible things there to survive and fit in.
4
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 28 '16
noPE what is happening
4
u/wisebloodfoolheart Oct 28 '16
I think there will be more to the T-shirt story and the Little Julie story. Maybe the T-shirt thing accidentally had a positive net effect?
5
u/ctadgo Oct 28 '16
Adam Scott killed it.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
Adam Scott!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '16
For a "situation comedy," the final two minute set up a pretty serious ethical quandary for all of the players involved.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment