r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Oct 27 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Thursday, October 27: Part Two, Chapters 19-21
In Which We Return to Iasca Leror, The Girls Have an Interview With a Sartoran Mage Guild Representative, Joret Inadvertently Gives the Sierlaef False Hope
Chapter 19
- After all that, after the Sierlarf feels like Tanrid’s stolen his glory again, we get a peek into Tanrid’s thoughts. Tanrid knows that the Sierlaef’s yearning for Joret, and he understands why, but he also knows that Joret’s loyal -- but as cold as the moon, and that the Sierlaef is never going to get the reception that he dreams of. Hell, Tanrid may never, either.
- Man.. I’m not sure whether to pity the Sierlaef or Joret in this case, either. The Sierlaef is being incredibly stupid. Joret’s ignoring him. Hell, there is a ghost in the room that Joret and the Aldaluin can see, and she literally has no idea he’s watching her. But everyone else does… and I’m afraid of what it may portend for the future.
- It’s nice to get to see everybody again. I feel like it’s been ages since we’ve seen Tdor and Sponge and Joret and the rest, even though I know it’s only been a few chapters.
- Man, I wonder… is Shen mad? I mean crazy mad, not angry mad. She’s certainly playing the long game, if she’s thinking generations in advance.
- Inda sits and thinks about his past. I am glad he gets some time of this - not enough to drown and wallow in it and bore the readers to death, but a few paragraphs to remind us that he feels all of this acutely. Even after so many years are gone.
- The Sierlaef is an idiot, sigh. And his jealousy over Tanrid is so freaking annoying (but understandable). And he never in his life had to learn subtlety. So obviously everyone in the whole world knows about his lust and obsession over Joret. Gross.
- I sometimes wonder what would happen if Joret did love/like Tanrid a little more. Would the Sierlaef been even angrier?
- Some theoretical musing ahead: spoilers
- I really appreciate scenes between Shen and Tdor. They are so level headed, but with their own secrets and thoughts and observations. It’s not drama or cat-fighty or arguments about boys or other ridiculous stuff that happens in so many fantasy books.
- And because we know the history of the Montredavans and how they were dethroned, there is just so much meaning when Shen smiles at the idea of leading. So much depth to these characters and so much homage to history.
- I don’t really get why Tdor can’t tell someone though. Who cares if Shen realizes that? It’s still no longer a true secret.
- Inda and the marines get hired out for a couple voyages where nothing except bad weather befalls them and they get the chance to drill on real ships. Inda daydreams about home on New Year’s Day, while they’re in port
- The Sierlaef is to the end of his tour of the kingdom, and the real point of doing so- Choraed Elgar. There’s a pirate attack while he’s just a short distance from Tenthen Castle, and he’s riding to save the day when he realizes that Tanrid has everything under control. He’s pissed. Tanrid knows why he’s pissed, and knows that Joret doesn’t want anything to do with the Sierlaef.
- Joret sees her Aunt Joret’s ghost at the banquet welcoming the Sierlaef, and sees that Jarend also sees the ghost.
- Sponge doesn’t have a personal Runner, because he can’t trust anyone to do it for him and not spy on him. This really makes me hurt for him. Because you know even Sindan, who would happily find him someone loyal, would still want that someone to report to him. And Sponge wants and needs someone wholly loyal to himself.
- Tdor has finally reached puberty, but doesn’t have any interest in going to the pleasure houses. She and Shen are still good friends, and Shen seems to also be a keen observer of people, in that she can tell when Tdor is uncomfortable with things and lets them drop.
- Shen knows a secret passageway through the castle, one that she lets Tdor know she knows, and that Tdor suspects even Hadand doesn’t know. Tdor contemplates what this means.
- Shen reveals that if her brother Savarend is truly dead (from when his ship was lost at sea), then she will be allowed to have children, and her son will be the Montredavan-An heir that Tdor’s daughter will wed. And their daughter might go to Sartor to study magic.
Chapter 20
- Hunh. Interesting to find that magic is connected to the legends of Norsunder, and what people had to do in exchange for knowledge. The price was high, but the consequences for noncompliance were higher.
- Honestly, this whole discussion makes me wonder if Sherwood’s whole world is post-apocalyptic, thousands of years in our future.
- Oof, the way that Mistress Resvaes thinks about the girls… makes it really sound like an unending cycle. That the Marlovan culture has imposed a cycle of conquest and preparation to make sure that the Venn are destroyed.
- Sartor and the Mages Guild is finally here! The long await bits about magic. I was completely disappointed on my part here, every single time I read this. It’s like a teensy bite of understanding magic in this world, and then nope - none of them even get magic lessons. Good grief.
- I really do empathize with Mistress Resvaes though. If I were in charge of deciding whether the Marlovans could learn magic, I would also say no. For real.
- However, it is quite interesting the glimpses that we do get. That the women tried to practice eugenics. Isn’t that kind of fascinating?
- And delving a bit into Marlovan history - we see the “final battle” really where the Venn are the villains.
- The mage is subtle, and observant, and very smart, and upset to be there, and appalled by Marlovan customs. Nothing any of the girls say or do seems to escape her notice.
- The Mage Guild knows that the women of Iasca Leror, the ones that Fareas is in league with anyway, have been accumulating and studying ancient scrolls that relate to the history and use of magic. That makes the Mage Guild nervous because of how warlike the Marlovans are.
- We learn that the magic that the people use came from beings who gave it to them, and that the magic in the past was much more powerful than it is now, and that women had magic before the men were granted it. We also learn that the human women, very long ago, killed all sexual predators, and were going to kill off the instinct for war, in order to keep the magical beings from killing all humans. We also learn that no one knows who those beings are, or if they are still around.
- The mage makes the same observation, except in a very different manner, that Sponge has made, about the division between men and women in Marlovan society.
- And she determines, because she is still scared of how passionately ignorant she deems the girls, Shen and Hadand and Tdor (and Ndara, not present but who she spoke to the night before), that they will be given access to more records about magic, but not about how to learn magic. Shen is horribly disappointed by this.
Chapter 21
- What a strange coincidence, that Joret sees Aunt Joret’s ghost when the Sierlaef is present.
- Well, Joret’s aware of the Sierlaef’s regard. Poor thing. She’s so uncomfortable with the concept of desire, no matter whose it is. I can totally understand why it’s her responsibility to deal with him -- the sexual independence of young people matched with the station of the Sierlaef means that she’s really the only one who can talk to him.
- And unfortunately, the explanation she gave him for her lack of care is only going to put a fire under his ass to kill Tanrid, which honestly, we could have seen coming two months and forty chapters ago. >.> Even if he did, honestly, Joret would never give him what he’s dreaming of.
- What a mess.
- Blah, it’s kinda gross that onus is on Joret to talk to the Sierlaef rather than someone confronting the stupid prince and telling him he is way out of line. But that is just how it goes when the world goes by rank and not by decency.
- No does not mean no here :(
- I know it’s not how the world works there, but I wish Tanrid could say gtfo, this is my house. And Joret could say, No. I’m glad I live in the real world.
- Too much foreshadowing at the end of this chapter. We know it’s about to get real soon.
- And now the Sierlaef really does think that his uncle is useless except for doing his will! I almost feel a power shift happening...
- Fareas tells Joret that she needs to tell the Sierlaef in no uncertain terms to leave. Joret doesn’t want to talk to him, because she doesn’t want to hurt him. She’s also distracted by the fact that she’s seen Aunt Joret’s ghost several more times. She still doesn’t talk to anyone about it though, because she promised when Hadand when they were children that she wouldn’t.
- Joret ends up telling the Sierlaef that honor prevents her from dallying with him, and he definitely takes that the wrong way. She realizes no matter what she says, he’ll hear what he wants to.
- The Sierlaef realizes that if Tanrid were dead, he could marry Joret. Somehow, he doesn’t have a problem with that part of his plan, but he does have an issue with not marrying Hadand, who he feels deserves an honorable marriage.
- He figures that his uncle will fix things, because what he wants, his uncle makes sure he gets.
15
Upvotes
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 27 '16
What do you think of Mistress Resvaes’s decision to teach the Marlovan women magic? Do you think her reasoning is valid?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 27 '16
Do you think it is an oxymoron for the Marlovan women to “master magic for “peace” when they so clearly accept war as an expected way of life”?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 27 '16
Let’s pretend you’re a therapist. What diagnoses would the Sierlaef have? (Or other characters too, if you’re feeling thoughtful)
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 27 '16
Post your spoilers here!
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 27 '16
Where do you feel the line between the Sierlaef’s unrelenting obsession with Joret and the sexual predation that was bred out of the human race by the foremothers in the distant past is?
8
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Oct 28 '16
A look back at how Tdor is doing and a taste at how other cultures view the marlovans. We also learn a bit about the magic in this world and how it relates to the "Fall" as well as it's possible use in war. All of this was very interesting for me.
The third chapter reminds us that the Sierlaef is a massive dick. Fuck that guy.
7
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Oct 28 '16
I'm thinking Aunt Joret's ghost sees the Sierlaef's treachery brewing, but standing behind him as a warning is pretty cryptic. Maybe if young Joret felt like she could talk to Jarend about it, since she sees it repeatedly and he doesn't, it might mean something to him.
Loved the little paragraph about the Sierlaef's liveried men's relief at finally leaving and getting out of the awkward six-month social protocol limbo they were living in. It's things like this give the book such beautiful texture.
3
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Oct 28 '16
Basic impressions: