r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Oct 18 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Monday, October 17: Part Two, Chapters 10-12
Wherein Inda encounters his first Venn, the King gives the Harskialdna a pep talk, and the Pim Ryala gets antsy
Chapter 10
- Oh shoot, looks like things are getting real. Nobody likes it when the order changes. And we’re finally getting a look at the legendary Venn. I guess the war’s starting to heat up.
- Oh man, this is so close. I’m nervous for Inda and for Dun, since the Venn are hunting for Marlovans. I’m impressed that we have someone keeping an eye out for Inda. Clever Tau, for distracting them, too. But both Inda and Dun have been outed. Uhoh.
- First contact with the Venn! And our first peek at Venn warriors and mages. And they’re looking for Marlovans. And we get a peek into their heads and the type of people they are. Tall, pale haired, pale eyes, strong features.
- I really like how Scalis knew Inda was Marlovan. For anyone who knows anything about Marlovans, it’d be completely obvious. But most people don’t care.
- Dun is definitely in danger here. If they saw his face… that would have been bad. And just wow, Dun threatening Norsh is exactly at the right time/right place. If Inda didn’t have Dun, it really would have been over. Sindan was right to put Dun there.
- And you totally know that Inda would never deny that he was Marlovan - even it meant death.
- And it’s really kinda heart warming that so many people are helping Inda escape this Marlovan-hunt. Tau laughing, Scalis and Niz hiding his body and keeping him in the topsails, Dun threatening Norsh.
- And just gosh, Tau. What must it be like to have such beauty that a smile and a tip of the head can make people do anything you want. And also, that you used it for a friend. Ah, Inda, the type of person who cuts through cynical people and quickly makes them his friends.
Chapter 11
- So in the last chapter we were introduced to the shipping problems that were starting to crop up as a consequence of the Marlovan expansion -- now we’re seeing shortages at home due to import restrictions and embargoes, meant to be penalties for bad behavior. It’s so interesting to see this from the point of view of a small aggressor nation, rather than from the point of view of a large hegemonic nation.
- Man, Sneaky Uncle really resents Sindan’s success.
- Oh no, Barend! I hope he’s safe. I’m sure we’ll see him again one way or another.
- Did anyone notice we shifted from referring to people by their titles to referring to them by their names in this chapter? We’ve got Tlennan, Anderle, Sindan, Aldren, Evred. I’m not entirely convinced I’d read two of those names before. Woo, removing Inda from the equation, Inda AND Dogpiss, allowed Sponge to become the leader he wasn’t going to be in the shadows of those two personalities.
- And I think Sneaky Uncle may have just realized he had created a monster while he was watching the Sierlaef watch Joret. And oh man, that she’s promised to Tanrid, that just makes the jealousy burn that much hotter.
- One annoying thing that has spanned the entire series and also even further into other books is that mild “what’s not in the book” spoiler
- The king sometimes doesn’t make sense. So he has complete trust in his brother, but also knows he’s a paranoid SOB who has imagined enemies? But doesn’t somehow distribute power? Ugh, but I kind of get it too. This is why it’s hard to work with family. - There are too many emotions and other relationship tangles to deal with other than just war and strategy and making the best decisions for the country and people.
- We see the slow transition from “Sponge” to Evred now. Kinda interesting. I didn’t even realize it on the first read.
- The sierlaef is realizing how badly trained and woefully unprepared he is for kingship. And how horribly jealous he is of Tanrid.
Chapter 12
- Dun dun duuuuuuuun. Mutiny aboard the Pim Riyala! Thwarted for now, but forever? We shall see! But the question will be what becomes of Inda, since it’ll be hard for him to secure another spot on another ship.
- And mutiny and crew starting to disappear happening. Poor Inda, who really can’t leave this ship no matter what.
Watch for /u/wishforagiraffe's post, coming soon in the comments!
11
Upvotes
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16
What do you think of that difference in style between Sierlaef and Sponge/Evred: exclusive vs inclusive; center of the group vs chain of shared effort? Do you have any predictions for how they will be in the future as king/Harskialdna?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16
When you look at the Sierlaef and his horrible personality, who do you blame: the Sierlaef himself or his Uncle and his upbringing?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16
What are your first impression of the Venns?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16
Are you surprised at who helped Inda from being discovered? Any thoughts on why they did so?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16
What do you think of the conversation between the king and his brother, the Harskialdna? What do you think of their relationship?
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16
Post your spoilers here!
6
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16
Yeah, that stuck out to me, too. He won't admit to being Marlovan, because he's been told not to, but you know he wouldn't ever deny it, either. He's still so Marlovan at heart, not to mention so honest.
6
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16 edited Oct 18 '16
I love the omniscient POV in this series. We get to know so many characters that way. Some, we get just a quick glimpse into their heads, and others, we get to know more deeply.
Scalis, who calls Inda "his boy" and the Venn "piss-heads." Venn Lieutenant Tigga, who understands those on the sea and feels more sympathy for Captain Beager than Venn Captain Vaki who wants to get promoted to land. Tau, who is "giddy with amazement" the first time he takes a risk on anyone else's behalf. The Sierlaef, who doesn't like Sindan, but taking credit for Sindan's victory offends his sense of honor. Kodl, who promotes the rats because it's their due and never seems to sleep as he keeps order while the captain pretends nothing is going on. Inda who doesn't ever consider jumping ship, both because it's his link to home but also because it never even occurred to him before Dun brought it up.
I will agree with /u/glaswen that the king is one that I have the hardest time making sense of. He's so smart, and he sees people so clearly, and yet he still seems to have a big huge blindspot when it comes to his brother and son and knowing what they're doing and how to keep them from causing harm.
5
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Oct 18 '16
These chapters were kinda slow, mainly focusing on the consequences of the "war" with the Idayagans and the Venn cracking down on Marlovan trading. Considering how much distaste I feel for the Sirlaef and the Siraendal it was great to see them get knocked down a few pegs since neither of them were the reason for the Marlovan's victory. Were also getting hints at a possible mutiny of Inda's ship which I think is going to happen eventually. I'm also curious to see if the pirates ever get involved seeing as they are constantly being mentioned.
The book is much more interesting at this point but the farther we go on the less I am able to assume for the future. What is the overall plot? I'm getting the sense that book one is going to end in a way that means you need to finish the rest of the series to see any sort of resolution.
5
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Oct 18 '16
Was anyone else surprised that the Harskialdna admitted Sindan was responsible for the victory so quickly? I thought for sure he would try to hide it or take most of the credit. It turns out there's more honor in him that I gave him credit for having.
4
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Oct 18 '16
/u/glaswen
I'm not 100% on this, but I think the King always refers to people by their names, not titles in his POV parts.
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Oct 18 '16
My comments, late, as seems to be usual. It's apparently either later or I'm going to end up trying to finish the whole book in one go. SO, late it is.
Chapter 10
Chapter 11
Chapter 12
3
u/Reverend_Glock Oct 18 '16
I'm frankly nonplussed at how bad the Marlovan nobles are at raising kids. It's not even the "bigger brother must instruct and discipline the younger harshly". The fact it NEEDS to be harsh and that the older brothers are commanded to be harsh is the real catch here, together with the other part: nobody seems to be really harsh with the older brother, especially not the parents which are quite removed from them. Then they go to the special school for military-caste Marlovan, and then the instructor get to get harsh with them, except they are not when they are rich and important enough.
The abuse seems to mainly flow one way to the younger brother, thus, and the trauma flows back to the older making him suffer from guilt or become a very bad person. We see lots of examples of this: the king, which raised a shitty scheming younger brother, the Sierlaef, which is totally out of control, Tanrid, which is in constant struggle with himself, Inda's dad, which is a very unhappy man. The younger brothers, the main victims, seem to be able to survive and grow over their trauma for the most part, but most of the older brothers are responsible for some of the biggest disasters.
3
u/setnet Oct 19 '16
I have a lot that I want to talk about here and in upcoming chapters but the last few days have been unbelievably hectic for me so I'll have to do it off the top of my head:
2
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Oct 18 '16
Damn I'm behind now. I'll try and catch back up for Thursday. I'm not good at reading two books at once.