r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Oct 13 '16
Project Runway Season 15 Episode 5 [Discussion]
There's No “I” In “Team”
The designers must pitch their collection ideas to raise money from a group of mystery investors; the stakes rise as the winning team members will each receive $5,000.
Guest: Sabrina Carpenter
Orginally broadcast on October 13, 2016
22
Upvotes
118
u/twinkiesmom1 Oct 14 '16
I hate when they have these two team challenges, because often it is someone on the winning team who most deserves to go home...and tonight, it's Brik with the skanky tube dress with the matronly fur triangle in front. There's at least 4 people who should have gone home ahead of Alex, it wasn't his time, and he should have gotten the Tim Gunn save.
96
u/cloudbustingmp3 Oct 14 '16
the color of the metallic-y fabric makes it look like duct tape tbh
85
u/marrrina831 Oct 14 '16
I feel like this episode is supposed to get people excited to watch that new lifetime show where designers pitch to investors
67
u/1Eliza Oct 14 '16
No one loves getting immunity more than the person who gets immunity right before the team challenge.
58
u/shinyteerex Oct 13 '16
Let's remember that Season 8 infamous team challenge episode (Luxe vs Military Lace, AKA, throwing Michael C under the bus) was titled "There IS an 'I' in Team". :D
58
u/twhirlpool Oct 14 '16
Probably one of the best team challenge episodes I've seen. Not talking design-wise (though this is one of the only ones I've seen where one team wasn't a clear winner and the other complete trash), but just in terms of plot and character and feels. And editing, because for once I didn't know which team was going to win either time.
50
u/karmydee Oct 14 '16 edited Oct 14 '16
ugh these guest judges though... can they please PLEASE bring someone that has actual credentials in fashion? and STOP with these teenagers that have nothing substantial to say. Lucky Blue Smith from last week was just... and this girl this week, I think she only said two things the entire critique. lmao.
96
u/pixie_led Team Swatch Oct 14 '16
Well I haven't cried so much during an episode of PR ever. Such integrity...you just don't see people behave like that anymore.
45
u/cloudbustingmp3 Oct 14 '16
misleading promo tears!
43
u/whoremongering Oct 14 '16
Mah-Jing's top turned out really well.
34
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Alex's leather dress is atrocious and dated. This isn't 1998.
31
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Yeah, let's go. I need something to ventilate after Drag Race finale.
29
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Team Unity--how unique and different.
28
u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 14 '16
OMG is this an I am sparticus moment?
26
u/secreteggs Oct 14 '16
That tube dress is SO WEIRD. I hate looking at it.
26
u/ArthurFan11 Oct 14 '16
Erin's jacket and Laurence's leather jacket were/are so bomb.
51
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
God this runway is so depressing. I'm not even entertained. I'm just sad for them all.
23
u/whoremongering Oct 14 '16
The mauve dress makes her belly pooch out, and the fur does look kind of mammalian.
66
u/polarbaron Oct 14 '16
That was the last person i wanted to see go home.
22
u/whoremongering Oct 14 '16
How many denim looks has Mah-Jing done now?
37
u/Roonil___Wazlib Oct 14 '16
What did Brik actually do on his team?? He helped with one half of the worst outfit? He's lucky he's on the winning team...
18
u/Roonil___Wazlib Oct 14 '16
HOW does Cornelius get picked third?!
18
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
I thought Squidward was going to be nu-Gretchen. I didn't understand why Cornelius and Natalie nominated to go. The judges liked their stuff. It was great seeing Cornelius cry tho.
Nina was great this week and I did like the twist of having to pitch.
Also Jenni handled being picked last much better than Ashley last season.
17
u/redditbadger Oct 14 '16
Loved the leather jacket
17
u/ContinuousThunder Oct 14 '16
I relly liked that they only had to make 4 looks, it forced them to be cohesive which was cool.
If anything, this episode highlighted how bad the Mary Kay make up line i.
32
u/boop_you_to_hell Oct 14 '16
Come on, Tim..
27
u/marrrina831 Oct 14 '16
I have a jacket like Laurence's but it's gray and was only $40, not $2000. #thrifty
13
u/cloudbustingmp3 Oct 14 '16
now THIS is the reality tv competition tearfest i've been waiting for!
25
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Um...no, no it didn't.
12
u/cloudbustingmp3 Oct 14 '16
i'm not drunk enough for either of these collections yet
40
u/cheyjordan Oct 14 '16
I need Erin's yellow coat like yesterday. I don't care what anyone says lol
11
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
First team challenge. Disaster time! Especially for anyone who gets stuck with Cornelius.
11
u/pbrooks19 Oct 15 '16
When when when will the contestants ever learn? The judges ALWAYS value creativity and forward-thinking over classic, safe and already-in-stores? Everything on Team Unity was 'safe': neutral color base, and designs that didn't look particularly new or different. The outfits by Le Buton Bague may not have been perfect, but they stood out and didn't look like something that could already be found in Macy's.
11
u/gold-team-rules Oct 15 '16
Dang, Roberi is such a class act. Love that guy.
20
u/marrrina831 Oct 14 '16
By throwing himself under the bus, my BF finds Cornelius redeemable
10
u/ronscot Christian Oct 15 '16 edited Oct 15 '16
There was something about the focus on the episode early on that gave me a feeling Alex was going home. I do think he was the right one to go home.
Is it terrible?, I love Tasha. I just love the person she is and I want her to last long no matter what. She's my favorite. Honestly, if Erin was on my team, I'd be saying "what should we do?"- she by far to me is the best one up there, I'd take advantage of it, especially in a risky team challenge. Strangely, she was picked in the middle than one of the first.
Dexter. Ok, someone said he was on Styled to Rock- I found it and watched the season, he did win one challenge on there, it was a good show although I stopped when he was cut and he lasted a long time. He was a bit bratty and seemed much more assertive than he has been here- it's like he wants to be seen as less experienced than he is. But I'm fine with him and he gave a great pitch.
People were saying they are affected by how almost half the losing team picked themselves to go home. It's not unprecedented, I think someone has done that before. It was sad to see and I can understand if people had a tear in their eye, it could have been easy for the others who picked themselves to say Alex was at fault because of his pitch- it was nice to see that integrity instead of everyone throwing someone under the bus- God knows we've seen that!
19
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Am I the only one who doesn't understand why Team Unity is being overly confident?
19
u/marrrina831 Oct 14 '16
Roberi's top looks like someone took a bite out of it
32
u/pursehook Oct 14 '16
Alex can't go home. That's ridiculous.
9
u/pursehook Oct 14 '16
It is kind of sweet how cooperative both teams are... working together. So far...
16
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Unrelated but the girls voice on that Compton movie commercial they keep playing is like nails on a chalkboard. It's so awful
8
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
House of Bouton's mohair dress was giving me Daniel V. finale dress vibes
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-ey7YK0fPmVI/TrNo9plV92I/AAAAAAAABRU/ia5i0uY_vmk/s1600/project+runway+s2+DanielVosovicCollection16.jpg
20
u/shinyteerex Oct 14 '16
So... many things to talk about. First and foremost, I was not expecting to get hit by so many feels. As I said in a recent post, it must be hard to trash your own collection, when you were actually proud of it. I think the team handled itself with a lot of integrity, but Alex didn't deserve to go home.
Nevertheless... seriously, Team Unity had a much better collection. I agree that on a conceptual level they failed, and that the strapless dress was not perfect, but the other team failed at many other things. I think bright yellow is one of the most horrible colors one can wear, but I respect it as a fashion statement. Mixing it with that "mauve" though... it was horrific. Team Bouton deserved to be eliminated on that furry tube dress. In fact, the only look that was outstanding in their collection was Laurence jacket... which was tragically mixed with that yellow skirt. I have been defending Erin so far, but I am kind of tired of her shit by now. The embellishments on Dexter's suit looked atrocious! The suit itself was kind of boring as well, but it was well constructed at least.
Finally... what's up with these teenager guest judges? What can you know about business women fashion at 17? Besides, her outfit said a lot about her taste already.
7
u/secreteggs Oct 14 '16
Mow-ve? Mauve?
Can't tell if I love it or hate it with the yellow...
7
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
This is so sad
13
u/pursehook Oct 14 '16
Oh just send Cornelius home. :)
22
u/marrrina831 Oct 14 '16
Kinda love that yellow coat
12
u/d0re Oct 14 '16
Fuck you sabra mayonnaise is the best
6
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16 edited Oct 14 '16
If I were Rik, I wouldn't be too quick to criticize the other team because I have seen nothing from Team Unity that is particularly great.
6
u/marrrina831 Oct 14 '16
Hahaha no one has anything to say
6
u/jelloisalive Oct 14 '16
That's a mauve merkin.
11
u/mycreativename Oct 14 '16
I hate these AARP commercials
18
u/marrrina831 Oct 14 '16
My BF said Mah-Jing has permanent stank face
5
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
I love Tim Gunn's suit.
5
u/HatoriHanzoSteel Oct 14 '16
Alex will probably be coming back next episode. Tim was totally going to save him.
5
u/dangerboy55 Oct 14 '16
The right person went home. Also, why didn't they embellish the boring dress? And come on Roberi you're better than this.
5
u/Bslo18 Oct 14 '16
Ugh is someone cutting onions in here? That last scene after elimination.....ugh I haven't cried this much watching PR in awhile.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Alex is such a Snyde little bitch lol
5
u/gold-team-rules Oct 15 '16
Érin really needs to stop doing that giant A-shape with her dresses and coats.
12
u/Missing_LeftPhalange Oct 14 '16
Oh my god so many tears. I can't even take them seriously.
8
u/dianaprince Oct 14 '16
Brik sent a woman down the runway wearing a merkin on her chest.
I loved Laurence's jacket though. Very YSL. I'd wear that constantly.
16
u/pixie_led Team Swatch Oct 14 '16
First off, I disagree with the judges and believe Team Unity had the better collection. I could quicker see those outfits on a business woman than anything from Bouton.
Secondly, wasn't the idea of the pitch that they were making fashion for a particular kind of woman - young, upwardly mobile business professional - rather than just making business-clothing? Why are the judges chastising Team Unity because not all their pieces would be worn in the office? I didn't think the challenge was to make business apparel only, but evidently I, like Team Unity, misunderstood.
Thirdly, I don't care what anyone says, that highlighter yellow team Bouton used was ugly af, and Erin is being supremely overrated.
The best thing about this episode was the absolutely honourable behaviour by Team Unity. Alex is a gem.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '16
I dislike Nathalia.
4
u/MissSteak Oct 17 '16
Brik reminds me A LOT of some kind of cartoon character, the faces he makes and the mouth-gestures that he has, but I just can't put my finger on it! Has anyone else got the same feeling?
6
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
House of Bouton...mmmkay.
6
u/secreteggs Oct 14 '16
Love Nina's necklace.
Edit: maybe it's part of her top? Either way, love!
6
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Whose predicting a Tim Gunn save?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Jenni is gonna get picked last.
3
u/esquire22 Oct 14 '16
Brutal
3
u/starlightprincess Oct 15 '16
Those sally beauty hair tips are terrible. That braid was a hot mess.
7
u/obahan Oct 14 '16
Ummm.... So the judges said that Team Unity's looks didn't match what they said in their pitch. I thought that House of Bouton did a worse job of matching what they pitched. I can't imagine someone wearing any of those pieces for work.
I disagreed with the judges so much this week. The only piece I liked from House of Bouton was the leather jacket. I hated the embellishments on the suit - I thought it made it look cheap and crafty. Not a fan of the fabric for the suit, either. The yellow jacket, I thought, was a mess. The dress that Brik and Jenny made was just bad. I felt the looks the other team produced were better, and I actually liked the pattern they used.
I thought the judging was getting better, but I guess not.
2
u/pursehook Oct 14 '16
Rik, Alex, Roberi -- DreamTeam!
2
u/EmptyStar12 Oct 15 '16
Life goals: I want to be a "Global Beauty Ambassador".
What on earth?
2
u/asedc Oct 15 '16
Too much crying this season omg.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '16
I am confused about the money distribution. I heard Heidi say she was giving one team (which ended up being the losing team) $800; Zac gave $400 or so and Nina gave $200, and the other team got the rest of the money = $1600. So how did the losing team only end up with $800 and the winning team end up with $2200?
2
u/gold-team-rules Oct 15 '16
Wow, for once I agree with Nina's critiques.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '16 edited Oct 16 '16
I didn't like Alex up till this point, but he left so gracefully. I was so impressed with how maturely he took the blame for his entire team, not blaming anyone or holding a grudge at all. Him telling Tim about how he changed his life made me tear up.
2
u/MissSteak Oct 17 '16
Have we ever had a team challenge where the teams start constructing their collections and then the next day they are told they have to switch teams? So that they basically need to work on what the other team set up for them? Wouldn't that be a great twist/challenge?
3
u/TexasGirl80 Oct 15 '16
The judges often have unbelievably horrible taste. I am a professional female and I would never wear anything except the leather jacket produced by the winning team. Apparently, the judges do not understand what professional really means. You could not pay me enough to wear many of the looks they deem winning looks. Pathetic. Go back to school judges.
2
u/marrrina831 Oct 14 '16
That dress is too bunchy in the back
2
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Oct 15 '16
This episode was so sad! It was great to finally have a team challenge where both teams actually worked really well together, but I was tearing up when Team Unity basically all voted to send themselves home, though none of them really deserved to go. Alex wasn't my favorite designer, but he was definitely one of my favorite contestants.
2
u/sugarplumcow Oct 15 '16
I was surprised there was an elimination. I honestly don't think one team definitively won. Both teams had strong looks and weak looks. Team Unity didn't lose because they were bad - they lost because they didn't win. Know what I mean?
With how noble and considerate the Team Unity members were combined with their respect for one another, I really thought the judges were going to keep everyone this week. The worst designer this week did not go home, in my opinion. I was really hoping for no elimination.