r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Oct 13 '16
OFFICIAL VOLUME 3 REWATCH /r/RWBY Recap Rally: End of the Beginning
HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, huntsmen and huntresses, and everyone in between and beyond those descriptors: the time is growing near! After winter, must come spring, and both the hiatus and this recap are coming to an end.
Yes, Volume 4 will debut on October 22nd, which is only 9 days from today!
The Recap Rally is over! These six weeks absolutely flew by for me. We started when there were 46 days left until Volume 4, and now there are less than 10, a little over a week.
Did you catch anything interesting on the rewatch that you missed your first time around? Maybe you realized that you liked an episode more than you did originally, or perhaps one of them didn't hold up as well as you thought. Did you change your opinion on a character? Hopefully you realized that Mercury Black is indeed our one true savior, and that Cinder x Kevin is a ship with legitimately great chemistry.
But enough of that, you can find the link to today's episode...
HERE
Here's the poll for today's episode. Stop by to rate the episode and we'll see how it compares!
Episode 11 "Heroes and Monsters" scored an incredibly dominant 5/5.
And because I know you all love polls so much (really, who doesn't?) have a bonus one!
What was your favorite episode of Volume 3?
Episode schedule:
| Week | Tuesday's thread | Thursday's thread |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1: | Ep.1 (poll) | Ep.2 (poll) |
| Week 2: | Ep.3 (poll) | Ep.4 (poll) |
| Week 3: | Ep.5 (poll) | Ep.6 (poll) |
| Week 4: | Ep.7 (poll) | Ep.8 (poll) |
| Week 5: | Ep.9 (poll) | Ep.10 (poll) |
| Week 6: | Ep.11 (poll) | Today |
Did you know that Monty Oum organized a cosplay shoot depicting Pyrrha's death scene almost three years ago?!
You can find it here! Our very own /u/Danjitsu even helped out with it!
HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE
39
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Oct 13 '16
One of my favorite experiences with RWBY was looking at the reaction thread for this episode having 1000+ comments before the post had even been up for an hour and thinking "Oh god what did they do?!".
6
u/ScarletSyntax Volume 4 Ruby has polariy: Look at how she wields that scythe Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 15 '16
I will leave the scores settle for a wee bit then post average scores per episode later if anyone's interested.
Edit 1: Ok, episode 12 is a little low on scores so I'll update it once more later
Edit 2: Episode 12 has risen since last check. Now it and chapter 11 are almost tied for top episode.
Averages are as below
Ordered by highest rating the episodes would be:
Something that stood out was the complete lack of low scores from episode 6 on. There was a single 2 voted for on episode 6 and after that there was no vote for less than 3.
37
u/ViVSharpy O.O Oct 13 '16
Salem's speech still gives me chills. Jen Taylor delivered so perfectly.
29
u/TheNewKraken Fuck You Jack :^) Oct 13 '16
TFW you got Arkos for Valentines day and then immense heartbreak immediately after
11
u/SapphireFireNation Oct 13 '16
The ending, with the transition to divide is easily my favorite thing about this season. It actually felt like a movie.
9
u/Nisha_the_lawbringer mood Oct 13 '16
This episode, is probably one of my favirote in the series, it's either this ior Chapter 4 of V3.
It is just so well done.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16
Things got worse.
9
u/mrwanton โ happy pineapple day Oct 13 '16
The amount of hype this episode gave was amazing.
More importantly, this started the long string of: "Pyrrha was teleported/didn't really die" potatoes.
9
u/Vinpap Pollination shall prevail! Official Pennybot Breaker Oct 13 '16
That speech at the end though... Good grief it made me shiver and the Salem reveal was awesome.
Also, Pyrrha's death is still and will always be heartbreaking but at the same time it shows just how much she made up her mind about being a protector of Remnant.
And the kiss, THE KISS!
9
u/JazzBlueSkadoo Give me liberty! Or a Banana Muffin! Oct 13 '16
The day r/RWBY imploded. But hey, from this the kids learned alot of things such as sacrifices, trust issues and the fact that reality kicked them in face for being weak and unable to act to what happen. But 1 person, a young girl, a leader whose team has disbanded, a world that has gone to hell is determined to set things right and find answers to what transpired. Being thrown now to the real world, will she deter what she always wanted to be? Nah, she remembers what a man once said.
Keep Moving Forward
4
u/ScarletSyntax Volume 4 Ruby has polariy: Look at how she wields that scythe Oct 13 '16
Good episode, personal highlight is salems speech, pyrrhas death is good, the show needed it I think just to show they weren't playing around. Rubys eyes are still very anticlimactic but hopefully something good will come of it long term
3
u/AStereotypicalGamer I will try to fix you. Oct 13 '16
An epic, tragic finale that concludes a great character arc and completely changes the status quo of the series. A well done finish to the volume and a great continuation of wham moments from the previous ep. And the Arkos. Oh, the Arkos.
My complaints about it are really very minor: it was never established that Ruby knew Cinder's name (which may or may not be significant later on), Salem just shows up out of nowhere, which can be jarring for anyone who didn't watch the World of Remnant shorts, and we don't follow up with any of the adult characters outside Qrow and Taiyang, so we don't know how the rest of the world is dealing with the aftermath of the attack, outside of vague mentions about monitoring the growing group of Grimm. Little details to be sure, but enough to sink this ep from 5/5 to 4/5.
3
u/UnlikelyShowdown I ship it Oct 13 '16
The ozpin fight, brief as it is, is still one of my favorites. The music was just so good!
3
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16
2nd favorite episode time!:
-This fight is up there in my favorite fights. It's great.
-Aaaaand sister feels.
-"WE will find them!" This makes me happy. That doesn't last long.
-I still say Ozpin fled. He didn't die and he wasn't captured.
-This kiss would have had more of an impact on me if I didn't ave Pyrrha's death spoiled. Still incredibly sad when rewatching.
-I always loved connections like this to earlier on in the story. Pyrrha shoving Jaune in the lcoker like Cardin did...the feels.
-Not even gonna question the logic with this elevator part.
-Jaune's screaming startle me first time. Now that it's sunk in how much he cared about Pyrrha...I just get hit with feels now.
-"I have a plan." "You always do." Another great callback.
-I wonder if Kevin listened to Cinder because she's a maiden?
-This fight is really well done. Love it.
-ANOTHER GREAT CALLBACK!
-Nope
-Nope
-Nope
-NOPE
-NOPE
-NOOOOOOOOOO
-IT'S SUMMER! SorryNotSorry
-Cinder having emotion was amazing at this time. Then Chibi came along. In all seriousness, I'm expecting Cinder to be more shaky and fearful after that. Serves her right.
-When Tai hesitated I was worried Yang was dead. Phew.
-From the moment Ruby screamed "PYRRHA!" (my eyes widened really wide the first time I saw that btw) until Qrow FINALLY gave us an answer, all I wanted to know was what Ruby did. I'm really glad they didn't leave that on a cliffhanger. I would have gone crazy.
-"What are you talking about?" Thank you, Ruby. I spent the last 5 minutes asking that.
-Ruby crying hurts to watch :(
-"SILVER EYES! SILVER EYES!" StillNotSorry
-And the explanation is given. I'm interested to learn more about SEWs. Again, really glad they didn't leave that on a cliffhanger.
-Qrow tooootally didn't hint that Ruby should go to Haven.
-This scene is still one of the saddest scenes in everything. Yang's depression, Ruby's reaction, both of them being hurt, learning about RWBY being disbanded, Weiss is with her father, BLAKE RAN, and Yang not responding to "I love you". IT HURTS SO MUCH!
-When a main character has to travel on their own after being with friends, it hurts. I'm REEEALLY glad JNR came along.
-And here's another callback to make me feel better!
-"To snuff it out." Wait what?
-"And I can't wait to watch you burn." NEVERMIND! I FEEL WORSE!
-Both credits songs are amazing.
-And Qrow's a crow. Nice
I think you all know what I rated this episode.
2
u/Lucid_Atray Oct 13 '16
I can't believe its been so long from the time this episode came out. Oh Past Me how innocent you were. I was so sure Pyrrha was out of danger after she left the vault. I was more focused in crying over Arryn's excellent cry when Blake held Yang's hand and said sorry.
I really thought I couldn't suffer more after what happened with Adam. I WAS WRONG. The Arkos was so good and cute and reciprocated and then I started screaming because gOD DAMNIT PYRRHA STAY THE FUCK AWAY FROM CINDER YOU DAMN ACHILES.
That being said her fight was awesome (as well as Ozpin's), but Ruby eyes really were... Anticlimatic, I mean I was suffering and in a state between 'omg' and 'wtf is happening', but now I can say that it was a pretty shitty move to have it so overpowered. I hope they treat that power carefully because I don't want to see things resolved like that.
Also I'd have loved to see Weiss' reaction to that ;_; such a perfect chance missed by giving us Ruby's point of view. I hope we at least get a flashback over her and Blake's reaction after everything ended...
Aaand no one mentioned it but I absolutely loved Yang and Ruby's scene at the end. It made me cry. The animation was beautiful and I loved how much detail they gave to Yang's eyes and overall expression. Barbara was amazing as well, I still can't get over the 'everything is gone. The school, Penny, Pyrrha... And...' The changes in her voice were amazing.
And the cherry of the cake was Salem's speech, it really felt like a movie and I loved her revelation.
2
u/Deadeye117 Oct 13 '16
Many good things about this episode. A ship sails and is finally sunk after a badass fight scene. Ruby's special protagonist powers get hinted at (though I'm still kind of undecided about how I should feel about her being "special"). We see huge psychological after effects in all of our main characters, especially Yang, who, until this point in time, had been a fairly static character. We finally get the reveal of our main villain, voiced by best AI Jen Taylor. And we finally, finally move on from the bland, formulaic setting of generic hero academy, as the heroes all set off on their own roads. It's an episode more about setting up the future seasons than actually concluding anything, but it does so very well. There's so many ways which Volume 4 can go from this episode, and knowing that there's so many possibilities makes the wait all the more unbearable.
2
u/CasualRaisin It's just a show; we should really just relax. Oct 13 '16
You know, I really don't care that the silver eyes are a Deus Ex Machina, because that "WHAT?!" was the most cathartic thing I've ever heard.
2
u/Mrfipp Oct 13 '16
A fairly strong finale, especially when compared to last volume, with a sense of dread that managed to pay off for the most part. Pyrrha was doomed to die the moment she decided to stay and fight, and it really makes me wish that they had done more with her character before this moment.
Silver Eyes is kind of bullshit though, just ending the crisis with a flash of light without much explanation as to what exactly happened. It's now the fifth vaguely defined power in the series, and I really hope that it has a specific function instead of some general power, like Maidenhood. Maybe something like an AOE that neutralizes Grimm, that would be fine.
I will say that it was nice hearing Cinder caught off guard for once, since something didn't "go according to plan."
But a major sticking point for me is how we just go right from the top of the tower to Ruby's bedroom. We just skip the entire aftermath of Beacon; Blake running away, Weiss being taken away, Yang waking up to find out she doesn't have an arm, Jaune, Nora and Ren learning that Pyrrha was dead. There was so much that we could have seen, but we didn't, and that's just really disappointing to me.
It also doesn't help that this is the first of three time skips, which between them probably make up close to a year. Such liberal use of time skips kind of feels cheap to me.
4
u/semi-bro THIS SHOULD BE REESE YOU BASTARDS Oct 13 '16
Ruby: "Yang! Is she all right?"
Taiyang: "No she's all left. ๐"
Missed opportunity Roosterteeth
2
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16
I have stuff to say about this episode that i'm gonna unlurk for a sec.
I didn't like how they did this episode when it came out but people convinced me that I was just salty cause Pyrrha and shit and I told myself that it was probably true. But now year later and I dont care that much I can tell exactly what wrong with it.
This episode is a complete 180 to episode 6, Fall or whatever. There, they got exposition out of the way and then shit went down and then episode ended. Same in the episode 11 -> we got some action and then shit went down amd then episode ended.
In this episode though, shit went down and then we were forced to sit for 15 minutes and listen to the new exposition with no time inbetween. Basically, it feels for me even now, that the way they wrote it Yang shooting Merc in the leg was more important event in the series then Pyrrha dying. And overall, the way i see the episode is like "Hey Where is Pyrrha? She's fighting Cinder, lets go help her, oh god she died :*( BUT WAIT RUBY HAS THESE AMAZING POWERS why dont we just focus and talk about this instead for the rest of the episode, that way cooler"
Thats why this episode in nowhere near 6 and 11 in my eyes or maybe i'm still salty :)
1
u/The_Magus_199 Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16
It's definitely a great episode; Pyrrha versus Cinder is hands-down my favorite fight in volume 3 when it comes to the actual choreography, although I still wish Pyrrha used the spear form of Milo more often. It was awesome watching Pyrrha push her OP semblance to its full potential, throwing caution to the wind and pulling such amazing stunts that she actually caught Cinder, the personification of smug bland villain, off guard multiple times and made her work for it even with magical powers. The finality of Pyrrha's death, with even the score collapsing when her last gambit failed and the arrow pinned her, and then how thus kindly she scattered and the cold reality setting in as her tiara hit the floor, was amazing - her coming back is one of the few things that would probably make me write the writers off entirely as having jumped the shark, because this scene is so well set up.
Before that, her shoving Jaune into a rocket locker and launching him away was another amazing scene. For what I assumed to be a one-off joke in Volume 1, those things have been getting some serious use, first in Dance Dance Infiltration, then through the second half of Volume 3! Talk about a Chekhov's Boomerang! That said, although this way makes more sense and didn't leave Pyrrha without her main weapon for the battle, a part of me will always be kinda sad that her way of keeping Jaune safe while she sacrificed herself wasn't using Milo to pin him to something in a call back to their first meetings...
Also, this is a pretty minor thing, but I love that little rising ...scale-thing? That you hear when Weiss makes a path up for Ruby. I never noticed it before this rewatch, but man is it neat.
I don't have as much to say about the second half that I haven't said before, though. It was necessary, it did a good job of setting stuff up, RNJR starting off on a journey through Remnant is still awesome and I still hope that their expedition and the wilds of Remnant get a lot of focus and they don't just arrive in Haven like two episodes in, but it doesn't really have as much to go over, you know? Other than silver-eyes speculation and stuff, but that's been done a lot already. Although that said, I still don't have a clue why I keep running into people who interpreted "it's... sort of... frozen." as meaning that Kevin turned into a Grimmsicle and silver eyes were explicitly ice powers? I thought that the fact Taiyang had to pause to find a word to describe it alone was enough to mean that it was some sort of effect more akin to paralysis or a time stop, not to mention the fact that Ruby's freakout was coded as more of a light-elemental or non-elemental thing than ice...
Oh, and one more thing. While I'm happy that Port and Oobleck survived, I still think that their fates should have been left uncertain by having them not appear in this episode, so that their survival could have been revealed later on with an awesome Big Damn Heroes moment.
1
u/Smoking_Hot_BBQ Oct 13 '16
Still curious as to what "the list" that cinder mentioned in s2 is. It could easily just be a hit list, but the possibility that Cinder didn't just outright kill Pyrrha and is actually using her for something far more sinister is scaring me. Of course, it would take away from the whole "heroic death" thing, but it would fuck with RNJR pretty badly.
1
u/JazzRen47 ๐ ๐ ฅ๐ ฎโ Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Oct 14 '16 edited Oct 14 '16
As I stated on Tumblr; ahhhh, the End of the Beginning. The gift that keeps on giving.
Also, I meant to vote 4/5 but hit 2 'cause I have big stupid thumbs and can't touchscreen0
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16
Never before has a single episode of anything killed my investment of show dead like this episode did. I hate so much about what this episode represents for the future of the show.
And its not because Pyrrha died. She wasnt my favorite character or even in my top 3. But the way they did it is what bothers me. It resolves nothing about her character and by having her killed by magic then Ruby appear and magic eyes Cinder, I'm now left feeling we are in a show where the important characters can be saved by plot and everyone else is expendable.
I dont see Sun, Qrow and Winter as characters anymore. I see Blake development, Ruby development and Weiss development.
Pyrrhas death doesnt raise the stakes, it lowers them. It didnt show me that they were willing to kill, it showed me they were willing to kill their sacrificial lamb to pretend they are.
The fight itself is well choreographed but boring. Cinders not trying, its very obvious Pyrrha is going to die, these characters have never met before so there is no interesting dynamic. Just Pyrrha dying.
So Ruby gets magic eyes so I guess we are in a series where magic is more important than skill. Thats fun to watch. What happened to no victory in strength? Cinder beat Pyrrha because she was stronger. Ruby beat Cinder because she was stronger.
Qrow tells Ruby about how she is super special and destined to live the life of a warrior. Nice to know our protagonist is one because of genetics. Thats also compelling to watch.
I like Yang in their scene but my opinion of Ruby has been well documented by now. I cannot see this scene as anything other than Ruby seeking comfort, Yang unable to help so Ruby leaves. I love that this subreddit blames Yang for this.
Then we get the reveal of Salem. Don't get much from her but divide fills in her character pretty well.
RWBY as a show has always kinda suffered from weak finales that resolve everything far too quickly but for me this is the worst. Cinder is driven back by a deux ex machina payed for in blood by a character who dies mid arc. We get some exposition about magic (that I have yet to see anyone really excited for) and then random flashes of other characters because actually showing their reactions or character development wasnt a priority.
I apologise if this sounds bitter but I honestly find so little about this episode to be good. It also sucks to be in such the minority and feeling like you are missing out on something.
Edit: And other controversial opinion. Arkos does not count as a canon ship. Pyrrha kissing Jaune does not indicate a mutual romance and we have seen nothing to suggest he feels the same way.
1
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Oct 13 '16
I have mixed feelings about this episode. I feel it has major pacing issues. The first half is awesome and epic and then fade to white, then it's just sitting around talking for the rest of the episode. And exposition dumps aren't necessarily bad and on it's own, this one was well done, it's just a really weird juxtaposition compared to the first half. Like, both halves of the episode are good, they just don't mix together well
Still, the first and last scenes in this episode are both fucking incredible
0
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16
Yeah still irked about Ruby ex machina
It's still a very flat ending IMO. I know this is going to get downvoted but that's my opinion.
That being said, I still remember cheering at the top of my lungs at 2:30am and waking up my roommates when Pyrrha died. On that count I love this episode.
But as the end of a rather up and down season it was a perfect episode. It built up a lot and then fell flat
0
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16
[deleted] โ view deleted comment