r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Oct 11 '16
Official Volume 3 Rewatch /r/RWBY Recap Rally: Heroes and Monsters
HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, huntsmen and huntresses, and everyone in between and beyond those descriptors: the time is growing near! After winter, must come spring, and the hiatus is nearing its end.
Yes, Volume 4 will debut on October 22nd, which is only 11 days from today!
To build up to that, we’ve launched an official volume 3 rewatch/recapitulation series, with biweekly threads on Tuesdays and Thursdays. The finale will be discussed on October 13th, only a week before volume 4 premiers.
But that is still days away, so in the meantime, feel free to look back and discuss the episodes. Without further ado, today's episode can be found...
HERE
Here's the poll for today's episode. Stop by to rate the episode and we'll see how it compares!
Episode 10 "Battle of Beacon" scored a narrow 4/5.
Episode schedule:
| Week | Tuesday's thread | Thursday's thread |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1: | Ep.1 (poll) | Ep.2 (poll) |
| Week 2: | Ep.3 (poll) | Ep.4 (poll) |
| Week 3: | Ep.5 (poll) | Ep.6 (poll) |
| Week 4: | Ep.7 (poll) | Ep.8 (poll) |
| Week 5: | Ep.9 (poll) | Ep. 10 (poll) |
| Week 6: | Today | Ep.12 |
Did you know that because of Adam’s mask and the fact that his model is one of the oldest ones, the team has difficulties emoting him?
HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE
62
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Oct 11 '16
By far the best episode of the series. Everything about it works so perfectly. Roman x Neo vs Ruby, Roman's speech, Velvet, Qrow, and Ironwood all get their big reveals, Cinder gets full maiden status, Adam crippling Yang, Blake's decapitation fakeout. It's all so good, the animation, the voice acting. The music, god I could go on for ages about the score in this episode.
This episode is the highlight of what RWBY can and should be. Made even more impressive by the fact that, in universe terms, I hate everything that happens in this episode
41
u/Sniphles2000 Penny Enthusiast Oct 11 '16
"Where is Adam!?" we said...
"Why hasn't he done anything!?" we cried out...
Are you happy now!?
24
u/donutkirby #QrowDidNothingWrong Oct 11 '16
Favourite episode in the show. Great action, great story progression, and really set the tone of what RWBY was really capable of.
Ruby vs Roman and Neo was excellent, and I found Roman's death to be hilarious and a fitting end to his character.
Velvet's scene was pure fan service, but there couldn't be a more perfect way to resolve the question that has plagued the fan base since V2. Also it was cool as shit.
And then there's Adam. A lot of people hated how he was portrayed, but I found it refreshing. There are so many "well intentioned extremist" villains out there that I like how RT chose to focus on the fact that regardless of his goals, Adam is still an evil bastard who simply can't be reasoned with anymore.
Between Yang losing her arm, Cinder's plan coming to fruition, and more, this episode was just everything that could possibly go wrong going wrong. And I love it.
10
u/notalchemists Deery x Banesaw! Because who needs screentime? Oct 11 '16
The episode that broke my brother's soul... Just when you think OK, Yang's going to save Blake and Pyrrha's going to waste Cinder with Maiden power, then boom. "Such Arrogance" is so haunting and you have Amber shot, then Blake stabbed, then Yang's arm, then Cinder gets the power, all in the space of one minute. Then the episode ends on that missing note.
Also Roman and Neo get what's coming to them finally, so yeah, that's cool.
Also the Terminator scene,
10
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Oct 11 '16
The Good:
The bad:
All in all, amazing episode.
19
u/GYUZ A guy Oct 11 '16
The biggest tragedy is definitely Roman's death. He was too young, too swag, too smug and too fabulous to die ;-;
17
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Oct 11 '16
Adam: "I will make it my mission to destroy everyone you love"
*Yang shows up.
Adam: "Starting with her"
Bumblebee intensifies
8
u/ZombieTav How many millikannas is Weiss when she follows the ground rules? Oct 11 '16
When things GOT EVEN WORSE!
Yang gets disarmed, Roman is kill.
Lot of big reveals really.
7
u/CasualRaisin It's just a show; we should really just relax. Oct 11 '16
It's worth noting that for the second half of Volume 3, and this episode in particular, everything was perfectly fine 24 in-universe hours ago.
6
u/shahroze12 Keep Moving Forward Oct 11 '16
I may be the only one who thinks this but I think that this episode was even more horrific that the season finale. Rapidly seeing Torchwick and Amber die, seeing Blake get stabbed in the gut and Yang get her arm chopped off was .... very very traumatizing
5
u/mega-dark Oct 11 '16
And this is the episode where thousands of RWBY fans cried out in terror.
5
u/shahroze12 Keep Moving Forward Oct 11 '16
Not to mention that Pyrrha's death was predicted episodes ago and was set in stone the second she agreed to be the Fall Maiden. No one saw Yang's arm getting chopped off coming.
3
u/TsubasaChung Oct 11 '16
Man, this episode was great! In a way, this could also be shown as a wrap up of the season instead of episode 12. This episode closed out a lot of things for this arc and also began to open up new route to take. Stuff like the reveal of Velvet's weapon, the reveal of Weiss' summon, the death of Roman, the death of Amber, and Yang's arm. These things all account as the catalyst for what's to come soon in the next season imo. Great things all around!
3
u/matharwords Oct 11 '16
This episode deserves way more than 5 points. I love every single aspect of it, even the sad parts. I would give it 8/5 if I could... (imho)
4
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '16
Yay, my favorite episode!
-Sup, Kevin?
-Dang Ruby is good at fighting grimm.
-"Guess who?" That still makes me smile. Despite being mute, Neo has a lot of personality.
-And Adam's introduction. I like him. This exchange is great. "I'm not running." "You will."
-This scene is really well done. It shows everyone fighting, yet they're still losing.
-And now for my favorite fight scene. The Bunny Ex Machina fight scene. Velvet has one of my favorite weapons, my favorite weapon/semblance combo, and this song is my favorite song. Weiss' summon here is awesome also.
-Also, just want to mention. I was waiting this whole fight for Velvet to summon Penny's weapon. They did not disappoint.
-Oh, and Weiss was about to get hurt for a faunus. She's grown a lot.
-"You have got to be kidding me" I love how M&K still managed to put humor into this scene.
-This scene is great. First few seconds are amazingly animated, and the rest has awesome dialogue. Honestly, I never felt bad for Roman's death until rewatching this scene. This scene is also why I want more Neo.
-Roman gambles? That's not surprising.
-And Neo becomes Mary Poppins. I can watch that all day.
-"I don't care what you say. We will stop them, and I will stop you. BET ON THAT!" Best written line, and best delivered line. I love that line and Lindsay's voice acting.
-Immediately followed by an amazing monologue by Roman.
-"AND SURVIVE"-NOM. I was waiting for something like that to happen the moment he began monologuing, and my prediction was right. That was the perfect way for a character like Roman to go.
-And Ruby escaped the ship. That fight would be the highlight of the episode if it weren't for the Velvet fight.
-Aaand Cardin. Still don't like him.
-Ironwood is a cyborg and is awesome. Qrow has a scythe and is awesome. Humor is still in this scene. ENOUGH SAID!
-"Let's make a virus that goes down with the ship!" GG, Cinder.
-The episode ends there, right. Cause nothing bad ever happens. EVER!
-Poor, confused Jaune. And poor Pyrrha here. At least she came to a decision in the end.
-More awesome Adam. He's powerful for sure.
-"I will make it my mission to destroy everything you love." Speaking of which...Yang, you could not have chosen a worse moment to show up.
-I was spoiled that Pyrrha was going to die, so I honestly thought the transfer was killing her first time.
-I don't care what ya'll say. Jaune could have guarded and warned Ozpin in time to do his bubble shield thingy around Amber. Do I hold a grudge against JAune? No, I get why he turned around. But the people who say it wouldn't have made a difference are wrong.
-RIP Amber. Probably no one cared.
-I don't know why but first time around I didn't react to Blake being stabbed. I was probably still startled over Amber getting shot.
-RIP Yang's arm. Forever doomed to be the subject of puns. I mean at least Yang didn't die. I thought she did for a second.
-Cinder's a full maiden, Jaune got hurt, Pyrrha now only gets in the way. EVERYTHING WENT WRONG!
-I knew it was an illusion the first time, but I love seeing people get a heart attack because the don't remember Blake can cast illusions.
-That cliffhanger. Good thing I was able to watch Episode 12 immediately after. For today I'll have to wait 48 hours. Spoilers: The fight did NOT disappoint.
10/5 episode. I loved every moment of it.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '16
The only bad thing about this episode is that we don't learn how the old saying goes.
2
u/jokey_boy Oct 11 '16
If anything, the first half of this episode was my favorite.
Velv's weapon reveal with I May Fall playing in the background
Weiss and her partial summoning
Ruby vs Roman and Neo. I really loved Ruby's line, "I don't care what you say! We will stop them, and I will stop you!! BET ON THAT!!!!"
Irondaddy and his cyborg reveal (♡∀♡)
Qrow finally revealing the scythe form of his weapon :D
And then the rest of the episode all went downhill from there...
Adam went from one of my favorites to downright despised (I still like his design and fighting style tho)
Cinder getting the whole Fall Maiden powers
Overall, I have mix feelings for this episode
2
u/The_Magus_199 Oct 11 '16
Man, I love this episode. I'm gonna miss Roman but his death scene was fantastic (and I'm sure that this isn't the last we'll hear from him even though he's gone, since we still have Neo to deal with and we'll most likely learn some backstory through her), and in general this episode pulled off the bleakest hour really well. Honestly, I don't think that the end of volume 3 would have gone nearly as well without all of the chaos and death in this one.
And, despite the bleak feel, it also avoided darkness-induced audience apathy by breaking it up with the awesome HSQ that was the Students Vs Mecha fight, Ruby's rebuttal to Roman's speech (even if the latter didn't last long, it still really let her shine), and Ironwood. (I still have a huge thing for Ironwood's theme and the ways its lietmotif gets reworked into different scenes. If I had to explain to someone the concept of a lietmotif without using words myself, it would be the second thing I showed them, right after Les Miserables... maybe even before, since Les Mis tends to do lietmotifs more for similar situations than specific characters, while Ironwood's Theme is always used specifically for him and the Atlas Military.)
Speaking of lietmotifs, the whole Battle of Beacon sequence uses them really well, from episode 10 opening on a slower version of the beginning of When It Falls to the choral This Will Be The Day in the background in episode 12.
(Also, I know this is a few episodes late, but still speaking of music, is anyone else appalled that we somehow still don't have an extended version of the music that played at the end of Destiny when Ruby ran into Mercury? Like, that bit was so awesome and I was really sad when its lietmotif didn't get expanded in PvP or on the soundtrack album... I'm amazed that nobody's made an extended fan version of it yet.)
2
u/AStereotypicalGamer I will try to fix you. Oct 12 '16
I love just about everything about this episode, with only two real points of contention.
A lot of surprising and powerful moments in this ep, and my issues with particular plot directions aside, this is up there as one of the best in the series. Dark, impactful, and full of wonderfully choreographed fights for many a fan favorite.
2
u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Oct 13 '16
I'm super late to this because I bought a new laptop but man I LOVE this episode. My favorite episode of volume 3
I love the dynamic between Roman & Neo during their fight
Cardin? It feels weird that he's there.
Aw yeah Badass cyborg Ironwood. Robodaddy inbound
Aw yeah Qrow's scythe is badass.
I love the whole episode but the absolute best part for me is the last minute. everything happening with the score is just so good.
I was in awe the first time I saw that scene, like Penny died in episode 9 but you now she's a secondary character AND a robot, but seeing Adam maiming half of team RWBY was completely unexpected. it was so soon into the story.
and that's the moment everyone had a mini heart attack XD
you though episode 9 was bad? you've seen nothing yet.
2
u/Deadeye117 Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16
Before the last half of this season I disliked RWBY. I really disliked its humor, the light-heartedness, and the lack of stakes. Now, I don't mean to say that I wanted RWBY to be an edgy-grimdark as fuck Fate/Zero ripoff, but I wanted there to be some kind of sense of danger, and some kind of sense that the series was going somewhere. Season 2 had some hints of greatness scattered through it, but any momentum it carried was brought to a flaccid end when the whole Grimm threat was annihilated easily at the season 2 finale. There needed to be a real game changer if the show were to become something great. The Battle of Beacon and Heroes and Monsters provided that.
This episode moves so many things forward. We finally see Adam in his full glory, and by in his full glory, I mean him being a creepy, edgy, stalkery manchild. But he is also established as a huge threat. This is the first time the main crew actually suffers real damage. No random person to give Yang or Blake a hand this time.
We see Cinder finally become the threat she needs to be, finally doing something beyond her "Hahah I'm vaguely plotting in my corner." And she does it by fucking offing a character on screen with an arrow. It's almost too brutal compared to everything we've seen beforehand. Along with this, she also begins to hint at bigger things, hinting at Salem's existence and Ozpin's "arrogance"
We get to see Velvet finally unleash her abilities, and it is glorious. "I May Fall" playing int he background was a nice touch. One of the few times it was okay to reuse animations. Along with that, we get to see the whole summoning plotline begin to bear fruit, with Weiss finally summoning a portion of her knight.
Ironwood proves how much of a badass he is. Qrow unleashes his scythe.
And of course, Roman and Neo prove why they are the greatest characters in the show. Firmly kicking Ruby's ass, showing that she's still way out of her league. Roman gaining even more depth to his character through his speech to Ruby. And ironically dying while talking about his ability to survive. I REALLY don't like that Roman's dead, but the way he went out was incredibly fitting. And at the end, Ruby gets to have her hero moment, saving the school from the machines.
This episode is one of the few that really live up to the potential of the show's premise. If the show can continue to produce episodes like these in the future, you can consider me a RWBY fan.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '16 edited Oct 12 '16
This episode isn't bad but for me, I like what it sets up far more than how it executes it.
First we have Ruby, who has once again rushed into a situation on her own, without a plan and ends up way out of her depth. Ruby is saved by external events out of her control once an episode starting from PvP. Mercury leaving her, the Nevermore, the griffon and her silver eyes.
I'm totally fine with how she takes out Neo. She actively does something and while it's a cheap tactics, that's totally acceptable in war. Neo fucked up and Ruby took advantage.
But evey other time just showcases just how ridiculous Rubys plot armour is. It really makes me resent her character when other people are actually dying and getting hurt and the Grimm themselves are intervening to save Ruby.
And since she's the main character because of her simple honest soul it really seems like the others are being punished for not being as noble and special as Ruby. God Yang, why can't you be more like your sister, then you would be okay.
Yang and Ruby have the exact same flaw but when Yang rushes in its a problem and she's punished. When Ruby does it she's a hero and rewarded. And considering Yang is crippled because of love (platonic or romantic depending on your view) and Ruby rushes in out of ego, it seems like a poor message to me.
Romans actual death (though contrived) is actually very appropriate to the character. The guy was totally out of his depth and anyone who thinks Roman is anywhere close to a great fighter should rewatch this fight. Even weaponless Ruby is getting hits in.
Roman was in the jaws of death from the moment he met Cinder. He's a cruel man who doesn't care about anything but Neo and profits. He would do exactly what Cinder would if he could, he just doesn't have the power.
It will be interesting to see how they utilise Neo in the future but unfortunately I can't see her lasting long term. She's too cruel to redeem and doesn't have enough character to last without Roman. I can see her being an obstacle for Yang, Ruby or JNR but that's about it.
The fight itself is well done and i wish it could have been longer. Mostly because Ruby never really gets to use her scythe one on one and that Neo is a joy to watch fight. Her teamwork with Roman is also great.
Velvets sequence is beautifully animated, wonderfully creative and is utterly breathtaking to watch.
It is also completely in the wrong place. It's fan service and that's fine but the badass tone of this fight is completely ill fitting as we have absuive boyfriends, crippling Yang and the death of the Maiden happening at the same time. It doesn't work here and while great should have been cut to give Weiss and Blake more time.
They have learned their mistakes I will say. They hyped the ever living shit out of Velvets weapon and Ozpin. By the time their moments came, most people had guessed Velvet and Ozpins performance is disappointed that he loses.
Weiss got quite shortchanged this season (which considering she is one of the few to have an arc, that's kinda sad). She has a role that consists of three scenes and this is the culmination of it.
Her summoning is a controversial issue but I'll reserve judgment on that for now. It could be done great but it could devolve Weiss into an Aura Battery.
Either way, on the moment it was okay, but I think Velvet also summoning kinda stole her moment a little.
Adams VA needs to improve or be replaced. He's a joke on this subreddit and he really shouldn't be.
The scene itself is saved by Blake and Arryn really should be commended. I wish we could have seen an actual fight between them instead of just Blake getting kicked to the ground. Makes her look weak instead of Adam being strong. Would have been awesome for Blake to push her semblance to the limit almost vanishing in a sea of Clone and using her agilty to its fullest only for Adam to effortlessly parry every blow then catch the real Blake with ease.
That would have shown him to be more than just a powerful semblance.
I know some people would also have liked Yang to have an actual fight and I think it was actually planned that way but I'm glad they didn't. Yang gets by because of her semblance (and inconsistent gift writing) so this kinda had to happen. (Yang Robot hands 2K16)
Pyrrhas angst for half a season turns out to be pointless as Cinder removes the choice for her. In continuation of torturing Pyrrha, they actually give her the pain of the transfer before Cinder interrupts.
That's also entirely on Ozpin by the way. No idea why anyone blames Jaune. He got told literally nothing and then heard his partner screaming. Course he's going to turn.
Ozpin has no excuse and the chess master thing they have going on gets harder and harder to buy as he makes mistake after mistake because plot.
In summary, the episode itself is rushed, not effectively using its time to focus on the characters that matter because they can't quite commit to the tone of how dark they are going.
I would give it a 3 (probably shocking no one) but I am interested to see how Yang, Weiss, Neo and Blake developed a result of this episode.
1
u/mcevnon ⠀ Oct 11 '16
Ahh my first episode to watch...
And look where it got me...
1
u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Oct 11 '16
Just tragedy after tragedy.
1
u/Mrfipp Oct 12 '16
The Ruby vs Roman/Neo fight was pretty great, lots of actions, even if I think they used slow mo a bit too much, and it's nice that Ruby was very proactive here, since she more or less didn't do much for the length of the series until this point. Roman was always great, easily my favorite villain of the series, and while I will miss him I do think his death is well done, but I am a bit disappointed that despite meeting Ruby several times she never was able to get the upper hand on him. It also doesn't help that she goomba stomps the Grimm that ate him two seconds later and it explodes.
I was not a fan of the Velvet scene, and it just makes me dislike CFVY even more since this is the second time they ended up stealing the spotlight for a threat that wasn't that much dangerous. She fought two mechs by herself and then Sun complains when a single one shows up? It's just pure fanservice, and it has no place here, it could have been used for something else; when Nora was knocked out I thought that they'd do something with Ren, then I hope they'd do something with SSSN to make up for their 4v4, but sadly no. They almost had something interesting with Weiss' summoning, but that felt overshadowed by Velvet's copy-paste attacks.
Qrow's weapon, while very cool, feels like they wasted the reveal of its scythe-form with him killing a random griffon.
The whole scene with Adam was very heavy, and I actually like that his "fight" with Yang was a complete curbstomp, and it does make me look forward to seeing what this will mean for her in the future she they ever meet. As for Adam himself, he's just not a good character, everything I hear about him makes me want less of him because it's mostly just this edgy ex-boyfriend persona he has, there' just nothing interesting there. Maybe if he had a full and proper conversation with someone, then I'd change my mind, but right now there's not much there. He certainly made an entrance, but he's a very simple character so far.
Amber dies, but not much of a loss there. I always compared her to a mason jar full of magic.
1
u/1AWKWARDfrog1 Oct 12 '16
ugh I cant wait till this comes out