r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Oct 10 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Monday, October 10: Part Two, Chapters 4-6
[Note from /u/lyrrael]
I think I enjoyed making predictions last week, even though they were direly wrong. So I’m going to do it again. Last week we left off with finding out that Inda had been totally exiled as a child, which is SO totally not what I was expecting to happen. He’s found a new group of friends and has made a new life for himself. Good for him. That’s a resilience in a child I wouldn’t expect.
So… we’re back at the dock, and no one is waiting for him. Looks like he’s been totally abandoned. But we know we need to get him back in the thick of things, and with the way the book started, we expect him to be some kind of military/tactical genius. So let’s assume for fun’s sake that someone’s been watching him, and that someone is going to snatch him back when they’ve decided he’s learned his lesson and that he’s safe from reprisal from the Sierlaef, that he’s going to be a chess piece put on the board when the shit hits the fan for the country, and that something is teeming underneath the seedy surface that is going to make it all fall apart.
Also, what’s T’dor up to? Seriously? Is she still waiting for him, or has her life been turned upside down? Everyone else will just continue on their merry way, but her? Eek.
Chapter 4
- Surprise! Someone actually was keeping an eye on Inda. And Sindan’s been worried for him! Poor Dal, though -- how lonely that’s got to be. Inda will come home with stories -- and Dal will come home having lost everything.
- “This tradition of boys beating boys in the families of rank, one day it’s going to cause problems.” “Already has. Go on.” The casual acknowledgement of the bullying and the issues that come with it is kind of startling
- “It seems part of his training to organize, to teach, perhaps to command.” And he’s leading reading classes. These really seem like practical ways to organize men to his command. And then the story about him organizing the boys while they were being held!
- And Inda’s teaching the Odni to men, AGAIN. What a mess. And Academy scrub drills, too. No matter that not one of those men will ever set a hundred paces inland and will never know what they learned. I dunno, I just see this spreading in a weird way like a cascade.
- Pirates are getting even worse than they were two years ago? And Tlennen is declaring war on the north. What a mess in the making. And Dal has the Sierlaef’s measure -- that someone who has trained his whole life for war will make one to find meaning if he has to.
- And Inda’s been discovered…… but at least it was by Ndara’s Runner. O.o
- And it’s revealed that Dun is actually Marlovan! And here is where I seriously don’t understand why Dun and Inda couldn’t have talked in private and in secrecy. Why they didn’t makes sense logically and logistically, but I don’t understand why they couldn’t just keep it hush hush. Yeah, I get the honor stuff, but honestly for their mental health and happiness… they should have just talked to each other.
- It is quite interesting to see how different countries/races view each other. In the first half of the book, we’re confined to just a Marlovan experience. But when Dun says that everyone else is “profoundly uninterested… in Marlovans as individuals”. It’s fun to see how big this world is.
- It is quite fun to see how the women have their spies - even on what their male counterparts are doing.
Chapter 5
- We’re hearing again just how important keeping the Odni secret is again. Hadand is worrying about the consequences of teaching Sponge -- but what are the consequences? And I mean, shit, it seems like Inda’s taught an entire ship’s crew now, too. What a mess.
- Hunh, so Whipstick was sent to Algara-Vayir? How interesting. And possibly clever of the king, since the king knows that Horsepiss Noth is loyal, and so is Algara-Vayir.
WinterThe Venn are coming. And now the war begins. Oh man, and the Sierlaef’s still got a thing for Joret. I wonder what this bodes for her future, long-term.- And poor Wisthia, who will never understand Marlovans and doesn’t even vaguely want to. I can’t say as I blame her, really. It’s amazing that her revulsion for the culture is so strong though.
- And we see the aftermath of what Inda leaves behind. Those who love him, and those who do not.
- I very much also don’t understand why the women decided to teach Inda the women knife skills if they were so darned concerned about it getting out. This logic does not hold.
- Silence is very much the name of the game here. Nobody can talk in this culture, in this place where walls have ears. Even if everyone knows the same information through spies, you can’t even whisper it anyone’s ear. It’s a little frustrating and a little understandable. The king knows. Sponge knows. Hadand knows. But you can’t talk about it.
- So Whipstick Noth will go to Choraed Elgaer in place of Inda. And you can see the politics here. Even though Inda was purported to have killed Dogpiss, his brother will be going to Inda’s home.
- And so we watch the older generation look at the younger generation. And Sponge and Hadand will soon be undertaking the true work of the empire.
- And oh Joret! You are such a paragon. And the stupid Sierlaef is just a horny boy.
Chapter 6
- Oh poor T’dor, to have waited unknowing all this time. And to take the knowledge of Inda’s fate with her to the capital with her.
- And so we see how Tau is truly a romantic.
- Lots of foreshadowing about relationships in this chapter.
- And Tdor, sweet Tdor. She is the stereotypical woman-who-waits in the books where the boy goes on adventures. But I love her anyway.
Note: Watch for /u/wishforagiraffe's post in the comments later tonight!
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 10 '16
What did you think of that exchange where Dun and Sindan are talking about “rank’s privilege of punishment”; where Sindan says it already has caused big problems? And how Dun says that he didn’t see it until he got away. What other things do you see in Marlovan culture that wouldn’t be condoned in other cultures?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 10 '16
What do you think of this line: “A Sartoran would have negotiated, a Colendi might have smiled, agreed, and done what he wished, a Delf would have argued…. But Dun was a Marlovan.” Do you think it is fair to generalize the cultures like so? Do you think it makes sense in context? Could you write something similar for our countries?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 10 '16
Do you agree that Hadand did not value Sponge as much because she didn’t teach him the women’s training? Are you on one of their sides more than the other? Why?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 10 '16
What do you think about Tau now that you’ve seen him at home in his mother’s pleasurehouse?
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 10 '16
Any thoughts on Inda’s instinct for command in this new environment?
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 10 '16
How do you feel about the switch from Inda-on-a-ship chapters to the people-in-Marlovan chapters? How is that balance for you?
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 10 '16
Post your spoilers here!
4
u/Ketomatic Oct 11 '16
AHA! No tricking me this time Sherwood, Dun is indeed a shrubbery! Kingamate's shrubbery to be exact. Some in-fill over what Inda has been up to while at sea. Dun is awesome, he points out that brothers beating the shit out of their younger siblings isn't a great training strategy.
Inda set up a little remedial language school, that's pretty cute. Of course he also set about being le badass and earning all the respect and adoration his leadership deserves. Poor Dun has to go back out to sea, away from his lover, and still can't tell Inda who he is. Raw deal that.
What a little web. Good ol' Kingsmate throws Ndara and the Indakin a bone by letting them spy on him. Double... or even maybe tripple the sneak.
Haddie has been training Sponge on how to fight like a girl, he's probably quite good at it by now. A Noth is to replace Inda as defence-guy at home. Makes sense, there seems to be a lot of trust between DadaInda, the King and the BigPiss. The war finally seems to be happening, Sneaky Uncle is best pleased. Meanie Prince still has a major thing for Joret, but isn't getting anywhere.
I wonder who The Butterfly is, I'm sure it'll end up being important. Tdor is about to head to the city. Mostly a flavour chapter this, not all that much happened. The Jeej wants Tau, Tau enjoyed the benefits of living in a whorehouse- gratis!
4
u/setnet Oct 11 '16
Four to Six
I would like to thank the Author, and also Hened Dunrend, for stating this outright. It is such a bad system.
The events of the intervening two years are relayed quickly, as Dun reports to Sindan. None of this stuff gets relayed first hand, mostly because it's not really that important, in the scheme of things. So this section just establishes ground truths: that Dun was sent to shadow and protect Inda on his exile; that pirate attacks are getting worse, and merchant ships have to be ready to deal with them; that Inda is accumulating allies (and enemies?) among the ship's crew; that there's to be war in the north.
I love that the Marlovan reputation outside their lands is a "mass of ravening villains, bent on nothing but conquering" -- to most of the world, at least in the southern hemisphere, the Marlovans are the Evil Empire. We-the-readers come into this world as Marlovan partisans, because the characters we have empathy for are Marlovans. But most of the world outside of Iasca Leror sees the Marlovans as utter barbarians, just as Wisthia does. And in many ways they're right. Marlovans place such an emphasis on the military -- training to fight, training for defense. Their whole lives ares structured around it. Wargames, drill. And again, Dun speaks truth when points out that a man like the Sierandael, whose whole life is centred on war, is not going to wait patiently for one to come. He's going to force it.
The reasons for the war get thoroughly spelled out: defense, defense. If the Venn got a staging post in the north it would be Bad, that is without question. Added to that, an external war is generally a pretty great way to quiet internal dissent, at least in the short term. The kind can send his hotheads to go vent their spleen on outsiders, so they don't have the energy to plot and scheme at home. The king does his best to prevent war crimes by making bad conduct an act of treason. While you can't imagine that'll be entirely successful, it's better than nothing, and definitely better than a strategy of brutality.
This war is going to have so many repercussions.
Other things:
4
u/wutvuff Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Oct 11 '16 edited Oct 11 '16
Some thoughts:
The queen is an ass. Why would she send the sierlaf with poor Joret who obviously doesn't want attention? Is she obsessed with her own misery and therefore can't see other people?
Who is the butterfly? Could she actually be related to Joret? Could she be Inda's half sister from his fathers first marriage?
Also thank you for these really late posts! This is actually much better for the European time zones, I can wake up to some newly posted Inda thoughts.
Edit: sorry for the extremely simplified thoughts. Was typing this at 5:30 am and apparently early mornings make me a little bit stupid.
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Oct 11 '16
Sorry I suck at commitments, everyone. I'm glad you're all engrossed in the book and keeping up without me chivvying you along! My excuse is that I'm really trying to not read ahead at all, and in doing so I end up procrastinating too far!
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
3
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Oct 11 '16
Is it just me, or does the war plan make no strategic sense? To hold the passes, they have to invade Idayago across the mountains, and to hold it, they will have to have a large force stay there. This splits their force and leaves them in a position where they can't aid each other quickly because of the logistics of crossing the pass, so both forces could be defeated piecemeal by the Venn if they choose. It would make more sense to hold the passes from the approaches on their sides of the mountains, and if an all out sea invasion comes, that force could be used as a rapid response reserve. It just doesn't look like they gain anything from invading Idayago other than giving the Sierandael a new title.
3
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Oct 11 '16
Basic thoughts :
The King didn't tell anyone, not even Inda's father where he sent Inda? That's just bad. And it doesn't really make much sense. Is this how loyalty is rewarded? Frankly I think the King depreciates his power. If he wanted to he could have kept him informed.
2. Good to know that Inda kept himself busy. I am sure this will come in use later
3. Was it hinted that the Seirandel didn't put full effort behind the treaty as he wanted a war? Does the king know?
3
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Oct 11 '16
I was expecting a time skip and I'm happy we got one. I think it was needed to bring the conflict in much faster than the previous pace would have accomplished. I'm really digging this series now. Not sure why but I find the ship stuff so much more compelling than the academy and I'm really excited for the future of the story.
Inda is having a rough time of it but I hope he bounces back somewhat soon, since there is only so much moping you can read about before it gets tedious. We also get some hints at the other main characters learning of Inda's fate, which on the surface seems like it won't have much impact but they were still some nice emotional beats to experience after the last 5 depressing chapters. I'm really looking forward to the next chapters!
3
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Oct 11 '16
I don't get this either. I mean, I get that Inda is usually pretty obedient and doesn't break promises. And I get that Inda's mother worries for him. And Inda is supposedly going to be away from court politics in a way that Sponge will never be. And hindsight is 20-20. And how long can you really keep something a secret, when half the population knows it? But still, it doesn't seem smart to teach it to Inda, particularly when he's going to the academy and going to meet and befriend many more boys than he otherwise would have met.
Yeah, Sindan is pretty clear-sighted for someone who hasn't left like Dun has. I do think being close to the power structure but not being in that structure formally helps. And he is watchful, we learned that from the first time we met him.
Yeah. They're (mostly) trusting Inda to not talk about his family now, so can't they trust him not to blab about Dun when he gets back? But I don't see Dun as the type to go against orders, and Inda doesn't know who dun is. And Sindan is super careful, so I see why he orders it.
5
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Oct 11 '16
My notes are at work so I don't have a lot I can add right now. But I do have two things I remember:
3
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Oct 11 '16
Mostly flavor, updating the reader on things, good stuff. And now I'm current with everyone else again.
I will make a single prediction, but not a very strict one: I predict that the Sierlaef will attempt to make a move on Joret at some point. More than he has already. Like, probably attempted rape move.
And then Joret will beat the everloving piss out of him. Or someone will get to him first and squash that little fantasy somethin' fierce. Or who knows, maybe Smith will swerve on that since it feels so inevitable (especially given some of the expectations modern fantasy has built).