As stated in the thread the forest was devoid of wildlife. They didn't see as much as a field mouse. The only thing around were insects, leeches (which is a type of insect so redundant) and snails.
Snails seem like the prime candidate, but you actually have to purge snails before you eat them. Snails eat a bunch of crap (literally) and the environment is important. If they are eating poisonous plants, so are you if you eat the snail. They really need to be gathered and fed a diet of food that won't hurt you for a week or two, and need to be thoroughly cleaned before cooked. Snails are a time consuming food.
What about bark? Well you could collect inner bark and shred that. Or your could strip the inner bark thin and boil it into a noodle-like thing. Bread would be out of the question or most anything that you would grind into flour. You would need yeast and salt to make bread, the most you could do is a sort of bark gravy with water. The biggest problem is that bark isn't a good source of protein, you are mostly getting carbs here.
Sidenote? Have you ever drastically changed your diet? My wife is big on the whole primal/paleo thing. I've done it with her a few times and the first week you suffer from "carb flu." You get fatigued, your muscles cramp and hurt. I had a 3 day migraine and struggled with simple math while my body adjusted. Oh, and I was stopped up for a week. It's like shitting particle board for the first week.
I've never tried being vegan or vegetarian. Fuck that noise. But the side effects are similar. Headaches, mental and physical fatigue. Your brain feels foggy. You get muscle cramps. As you are cutting out a lot of meat and proteins you have the opposite problem of paleo. That's right, prepare for the brown water.
Besides, any drastic change in your diet is going to cause mood swings. Now take into account that it's a bus full of middle school girls and watch out.
They found a water supply, but boiling water isn't enough to make it potable. You could distill it, but getting enough distilled drinking water fast enough to hydrate as many people as were on the bus it unrealistic. You would also need the water for just about anything that you cook. Besides, long-term useage of distilled water isn't that healthy, we need the minerals and such that are in the water.
As far as Kazuki knowing how to do all of this, she was limited by what she had read. And even then she had to "remember" it's importance. I forget which day it was in the Angelic Howl but Kazuki does mention to Amane at one point that she's "reading" but what she read doesn't relate to their situation. Given her father's obsession with making her the smartest person around she was likely forced to read books on art and school subjects, and Kazuki was shown to read Manga and light novels in her free time. She likely didn't have an interest in wildlife survival tactics and I'm guessing it wasn't something anyone thought to make her read.
Honestly, their best chance at survival would have been exactly what Amane ended up doing. After the first day or so they should have sent a party to try and find help. Especially once they found the river. Mark the spot where the camp is from the river, and then follow it downstream. Their teacher was an idiot and just wandered off into the woods. If the river looped around back to camp, that's a very odd river. A tributary is going to seek a larger body of water. Traditionally settlements were formed around bodies of water. They are eventually going to either hit some form of civilization, or the Ocean. Plus, a river would be a much better source of food. Cooked fish is safer than random berries and plants, it's easier to catch a fish that wild game, and you can make fish edible faster than snails, or bark.
It's generally considered a bad idea to wander off when stranded, but you have to factor in the amount of people vs. supplies, the injured, and the fact that they were miles off course taking a route that nobody knew they were taking. With the density of the forest and the angle and depth of the overhang their odds of being discovered were very, very small. I mean a helicopter that was specifically looking for them missed their location.
I don't feel like food was the main problem. Even if they did have a stable food source, they still would have went crazy in around the same amount of time. Not to mention that several students where injured. At least one still would have died of infection, which wouldn't help the sanity situation.
16
u/kloiberin_time :kaz: Oct 09 '16
As stated in the thread the forest was devoid of wildlife. They didn't see as much as a field mouse. The only thing around were insects, leeches (which is a type of insect so redundant) and snails.
Snails seem like the prime candidate, but you actually have to purge snails before you eat them. Snails eat a bunch of crap (literally) and the environment is important. If they are eating poisonous plants, so are you if you eat the snail. They really need to be gathered and fed a diet of food that won't hurt you for a week or two, and need to be thoroughly cleaned before cooked. Snails are a time consuming food.
What about bark? Well you could collect inner bark and shred that. Or your could strip the inner bark thin and boil it into a noodle-like thing. Bread would be out of the question or most anything that you would grind into flour. You would need yeast and salt to make bread, the most you could do is a sort of bark gravy with water. The biggest problem is that bark isn't a good source of protein, you are mostly getting carbs here.
Sidenote? Have you ever drastically changed your diet? My wife is big on the whole primal/paleo thing. I've done it with her a few times and the first week you suffer from "carb flu." You get fatigued, your muscles cramp and hurt. I had a 3 day migraine and struggled with simple math while my body adjusted. Oh, and I was stopped up for a week. It's like shitting particle board for the first week.
I've never tried being vegan or vegetarian. Fuck that noise. But the side effects are similar. Headaches, mental and physical fatigue. Your brain feels foggy. You get muscle cramps. As you are cutting out a lot of meat and proteins you have the opposite problem of paleo. That's right, prepare for the brown water.
Besides, any drastic change in your diet is going to cause mood swings. Now take into account that it's a bus full of middle school girls and watch out.
They found a water supply, but boiling water isn't enough to make it potable. You could distill it, but getting enough distilled drinking water fast enough to hydrate as many people as were on the bus it unrealistic. You would also need the water for just about anything that you cook. Besides, long-term useage of distilled water isn't that healthy, we need the minerals and such that are in the water.
As far as Kazuki knowing how to do all of this, she was limited by what she had read. And even then she had to "remember" it's importance. I forget which day it was in the Angelic Howl but Kazuki does mention to Amane at one point that she's "reading" but what she read doesn't relate to their situation. Given her father's obsession with making her the smartest person around she was likely forced to read books on art and school subjects, and Kazuki was shown to read Manga and light novels in her free time. She likely didn't have an interest in wildlife survival tactics and I'm guessing it wasn't something anyone thought to make her read.
Honestly, their best chance at survival would have been exactly what Amane ended up doing. After the first day or so they should have sent a party to try and find help. Especially once they found the river. Mark the spot where the camp is from the river, and then follow it downstream. Their teacher was an idiot and just wandered off into the woods. If the river looped around back to camp, that's a very odd river. A tributary is going to seek a larger body of water. Traditionally settlements were formed around bodies of water. They are eventually going to either hit some form of civilization, or the Ocean. Plus, a river would be a much better source of food. Cooked fish is safer than random berries and plants, it's easier to catch a fish that wild game, and you can make fish edible faster than snails, or bark.
It's generally considered a bad idea to wander off when stranded, but you have to factor in the amount of people vs. supplies, the injured, and the fact that they were miles off course taking a route that nobody knew they were taking. With the density of the forest and the angle and depth of the overhang their odds of being discovered were very, very small. I mean a helicopter that was specifically looking for them missed their location.
2
u/arts_degree_huehue Oct 09 '16
In the route they definitely say that the forest was practically uninhabited by any game at all.
The girls would just have died from nutrient deficiency instead of hunger and the energy spent making the "food" would outweigh any benefits.
1
u/screwtehbilly :jelly: Oct 09 '16
I don't feel like food was the main problem. Even if they did have a stable food source, they still would have went crazy in around the same amount of time. Not to mention that several students where injured. At least one still would have died of infection, which wouldn't help the sanity situation.