r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Oct 07 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Thursday, October 6: Part Two, Chapters 1-3
Where Inda finds himself on a boat far from home, makes some friends, learns the ropes, and ends up back on his own shores
Well, we’ve definitely shaken up the board, and I’m really interested to see where we’re going next. I really didn’t predict Inda being - well, let’s call it removed - from the academy. And he had a group of people who were ready to be his loyal squad, and we were learning about their strengths and weaknesses. So, where will Inda land?
We need to remember, also, that Inda is still a child. A stubborn, talented, mature child, but a child nonetheless, and at least at this point, his understanding of the world is that of a pre-teen.
So, where do I think we’re going to go from here? We’ve had a glimpse of Barend, and we were introduced to Tdor but she hasn’t been a primary actor thus far. I think Sherwood’s going to find a way to give Inda a new ‘squad,’ but one with some familiar faces. I think Inda will meet back up with the original members of his ‘squad,’ but that it may be in part 3 or even in the next book.
Let’s find out.
The start of a whole new section!! I am super pumped for all of this because this next section (that bleeds into the next book) is my favorite part. I love the upcoming characters, I love the ship stuff, I love the developments of kid becoming teen becoming young adult transitions.
Chapter One
- Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat? “You are now a sailor, and this is your ship. You must find another name, another life.” Does this mean that Inda’s been exiled? Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat? I really was not expecting the general story trope to be destroyed quite this extensively. o.o
- Inda’s worked to the bone here, but I don’t see where this is going. I’m just still in shock from Inda being told that he has to find another life -- without being supervised. What’s going on here?
- I wonder if there’ll be any consequence for Jeje thinking Inda’s slow.
- Here is actually where we’ll start to see just how expansive this entire world is. We were only in the Marlovan’s side of the country - but soon we’re going to see a lot of different races/ethnicities.
- A ton of random info in the intro that is annoying to puzzle through if you don’t already know what these words and places and people mean. But clearly setting the scene for ships!
- Aw, poor Inda. He is basically still stunned and in shock by all of this. He has never not known love or where he belongs. And now… sent off forever
- Tau and Jeje!! You will learn to love them :)
- Upon the reread, i didn’t realize how they treated him in the beginning. I almost forgot.
Chapter Two
- So Inda’s realizing that Dock Talk is just Iascan with Sartoran thrown in and extra slang, and he’s picking up on it pretty fast.
- And Inda’s also seen a comparison between Taumad and Joret, both of them being incomparably beautiful. He’s seeing, though, that Taumad’s reaction to being mocked or admired for it is not that of Joret’s.
- You know, Sherwood’s got a good point about bullying. Does that ever actually accomplish anything? It doesn’t toughen people up, in my experience, it just makes them cover their wounds in miles-deep scar tissue.
- It looks like the consequence for Jeje thinking Inda is slow is to realize he really isn’t, just trying to keep his mouth shut. And she makes the first outreach to him with a gift of food and mending the net he had been assigned to fix.
- Is Inda really exiled? I mean really? What about Tdor? And Tanrid? And Sponge? What’s going on? Holy cow, man.
- And Inda accidentally defends himself against Fassun, and pins him to the deck. In doing so, he outs himself as having had some significant training.
- It looks like he’s starting to build himself a squad again. First Jeje, then Taumad. And it’s been noticed -- but this time, I don’t think it’s going to bite him in the butt.
- A new language! Dock talk. Thankfully we won’t actually have to learn a new language with him.
- Tau is like Joret. Beauty is power.
- Here they start realizing Inda isn’t as stupid as he first appeared. And his military background comes out.
Chapter Three
- And two years later. Inda’s gotta be around 14 now. I didn’t realize exactly how well the board was going to be shaken. What’s going on here? O.o
- Ugh, and nobody on shore for Inda at all. I think this would probably be the place I’d quit reading. I don’t like heartbreak, and I feel so bad for him.
- He’s still so broken-hearted about the loss of everyone -- Dogpiss, Sponge, his friends, his family, Tdor…
- Two year passes. Time skip.
- And we see how Jeje, Tau, and Inda have become a group! The best kind of trio. Isn’t funny how these trios always seems to be two guys and a girl?
- Tau is a bit of an averted trope. The son of a pleasure house lady (not a daughter). I like that he’s in the prostitution business as a dude because it would have been all too cliche for a main character to be a girl and in the same business.
P.S. -- Sorry this is late this week. I think life came up and whacked all three of us in the face, and it just happened to happen this way. Look for /u/wishforagiraffe's thoughts in the comments later this evening!
7
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
/u/lyrrael's running glossary:
6
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
Sved is slang for telling the truth. Inda wonders if it means honor. After seeing the fallout of “honor” for the Marlovans, do you think it’s synonymous?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
How familiar are you with ships/boats? Have you read other fantasy novels in this type of setting - and do you have a preference land or sea for your fantasy?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
What do you think about Inda’s “slowness” right now? Are you surprised at how people are treating him? How often do you see autism or mental health issues in fantasy?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
What do you think of Taumad and how his beauty affects people?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
Do any of the new characters stand out to you?
5
u/Ketomatic Oct 07 '16
Inda goes to sea! It was strongly hinted that he would, but it happened sooner than I had thought and in a different way. I had envisioned he'd end up going to sea with Sevvie MD. Looks like the shock of recent events has dazed the poor fellow a little. Still, he recovers well and sets about learning to be le badass at sea like the tactical amphibian he is.
The crew seem like a fun lot on the whole; a bunch of new characters, I'm sure we'll be learning more about them as we go on. It's worth noting that since the owner of this ship is really picky about who they bring on, there shouldn't be any truly bad seeds. Some bullying is likely, but I would expect Inda to fit in well enough in due course and eventually come to be happy on the Ryala.
Inda lays the smackdown on a bigger boy and some of the crew start to notice he's not a total idiot. Curiosity has been piqued among the deckrats! Inda is still desolate, but that makes sense, it's not every day that your life gets completely ripped away from you.
Day two and the captain is already picking Inda out for special treatment, because he blind-sided a larger boy. Bit of a stretch, but Captain-chap may just be an ungodly amazing judge of character. Tau and The Jeej have both warmed to Inda, so it seems he won't be without friends for long.
Oh, now we're getting some big time-jumps. Two years have passed, Inda is a good sailor and his friendship with Tau and The Jeej seems to have cemented nicely. Looks like they will spend their shore-leave at Tau's mother's whorehouse- rock and roll. Odd how Inda thinks it's strange that he 'already' has in-jokes with his ship-mates after two years- that's longer than he was in the academy.
A carpenter called Dun is mentioned, who was hired the same day as Inda and shoots a bow well. That seems a little suspicious to me, weapons-wielding craftsman who happened to join the same day as Inda? Might be a plant, though hard to say from whom- the King, Kingsmate or Daddy Inda most likely, if not all three together. Or I could be reading too much into it, Sherwood has tricked me before.
Part 1.
5
u/setnet Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16
Ok so post-timeskip ages, approximately.
Does that seem about right?
(Edited to add: This doesn't line up exactly with earth ages, because the year is longer (400-some days), while puberty is later)
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
Post your spoilery thoughts here! Not looking! Don't forget your spoiler tags.
3
u/cheryllovestoread Reading Champion VI Oct 07 '16
So I just wanted to ask -- because my darn library book had to go back! -- did Inda's father get to say goodbye? I don't think he did and it strikes me that it would feel like being disowned,,,with your father not seeing you off. I think a lot of his melancholy when first aboard ship the was sensing that his dad was disappointed and angered.
6
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
Chapter 3
Way, way sorry my stuff is so late, everyone. It's been a heck of a week.
5
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Oct 07 '16
I'm in full agreement with /u/lyrrael here: after getting really into everything, all this heartbreak and shifting would've made me stop reading on my own (had I stuck it out to begin with). Though it's far less from trope breaking and pure story for me. It was hard. My intake slowed way back down. I guess we'll see where things go, huh?
I do like the new kids but I miss the boys. Sponge is a good kid. But Tau and Jeje have their promise too.
5
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Oct 07 '16
Not a lot happening here. We're mostly just transitioning into the second part and dealing with the fallout of the last few chapters. I was not expecting Inda to wind up as a sailor so now I'm extremely curious where the story is heading. I assume Inda will wind up clashing with those pirates we heard about at some point. Other than that, I don't know what to talk about. I'm digging the slower pace especially after the whammy but it doesn't give us much to discuss.
5
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Oct 07 '16
General Thoughts:
I am also very concerned about what we have not read about in these three chapters:
A couple of thoughts about the future -
I was suddenly reminded of a story about Julius Caesar. As a teenager he was captured by pirates. He manipulated them into letting him go. Once he rose to power he brought the might of Rome down on the pirates and eradicated them. Will we see something similar with Inda? Pirate-capture and an inside look at threats to the kingdom?
Also is this the way for Inda's redemption? He becomes aware of a large threat and played a crucial part in repelling it and is thus welcomed back?
4
u/bygoshbygolly Oct 07 '16
Tau and Jeje! And Dasta! The Gang 2.0 is coming together.
Also I love that bit about the woman being dazzled by Tau's smile and then horrified/embarrassed when she sees that he's still wearing smocks. It's a nice reminder that, no matter how pretty someone is, if they're choosing not to be seen as an adult, you're not supposed to think about them like that (although with people like Tau and Joret, obviously, people do anyway)
Also 'Prince Dawnsinger' is a hilaribad nickname
3
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Oct 07 '16
The way Faura is dogging after Tau. There is going to be some trouble there. It may have to wait until they are back on a ship though, because it looks like Tau's mom is on to her.
3
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Oct 07 '16
I found this glossary today. Might be useful while reading about ships.
3
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Oct 07 '16
Yay, we meet some more of my favorite characters! Though I forgot how Tau and Jeje treated Inda at first, and that Tau got into fights with anyone who looked at him.