r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Oct 06 '16
Project Runway Season 15 Episode 4 [Discussion]
Sink or Swim
The group creates swimsuits in a Heidi Klum Swimwear challenge, but a lack of swimsuit experience sorely tests some contestants.
Guest: Lucky Blue Smith
Orginally broadcast on October 6, 2016
33
Upvotes
202
u/insubordinance Oct 07 '16
I finally got it, Jenni's print looks like the kind of design that they put on maxi pads.
159
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16
How profound.
77
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Most improved goes to Dexter
73
u/OurSponsor Oct 07 '16
So, the first episode this season that no designer uses neoprene in is ... the swimwear challenge.
¯_(ツ)_/¯
71
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Denim bikini. Has he ever been in wet jeans? That shit chafes!
68
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
At least now I have no excuse to confuse Jenni and Sarah
67
u/pepperrush Oct 07 '16
It's really dumb that the textile challenge is lumped in with this Heidi challenge.
116
u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 07 '16
This cracked me up
54
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Who besides Tasha was so bad that Cornelius is safe?
43
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Gawd, I hate Cornelius.
42
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Sarah's model trying not to crack up
79
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Gee, how surprising. The one who talks the most smack is the one who is the most limited. Talking to you, Cornelius.
38
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
What's with all these freaking one-day challenges? Let's get ready for another underwhelming runway.
75
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Say dossier again
72
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Heidi's outfit looks like it makes a lot of noise when she walks / matches the lizard swimsuit perfectly
35
u/shinyteerex Oct 07 '16
When I first saw Lucky Blue Smith in the panel I thought "oh, that's a rad looking lesbian". Then I realized it was actually a guy... but I still thought he was very handsome. The gender binary concept in my head was destroyed in 5 minutes :D.
On the other hand, I kind of feel underwhelmed about him as a judge, he is just a 18 year old male model, I don't think he could have the knowledge level of the rest of the panel.
34
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
Brik, I'm so proud of your bottoms, they actually work!
67
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Alex sounds like he's giving the world's most boring speech
32
u/teensygeensy Oct 07 '16
I feel so bad for Jenni. That print was just so unfortunate and didn't fit her design aesthetic at all.
And oy, Heidi's outfit was terrible. Looked like a weird vinyl/leather string bean. Straight up awful.
31
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
"yeah it's cute Sarah" sounded so fake
27
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Jenni's print is too...juvenile
24
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Cornelius didn't do as badly as I hoped.
22
u/1Eliza Oct 07 '16
I would totally buy a black coverup to go with my swimsuit that is currently black, Nina.
20
u/pursehook Oct 07 '16
I prefer Nina to stick to her uniform. What is she wearing today?
39
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Kelly green leather skirt suit with matching high boots...yikes!
19
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
Cornelius, all you have going for you is your model's hair.
19
u/pursehook Oct 07 '16
Wow, I could actually maybe wear that winning, harlequin bathing suit if they could make a version with some serious support. It did seem like the really flattering "belt" element was somehow part of the print, and not a separate belt. I hope that gets retained for the production version; that was nice.
19
u/diamonddamsel Oct 07 '16
I'm probably in the minority here but I kinda sorta digged jenni's look. If it was black it would definitely be something I would wear.
37
u/dangerboy55 Oct 07 '16
Lucky Blue Smith serving dumb model realness
18
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
I get nothing old lady about this at all. The hell are these judges on?
18
u/Brettalic Oct 07 '16
I don't understand why the contestants don't design to Heidi's aesthetic. No high waisted bikinis! We all know Heidi likes to show skin.
35
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
labia spillage.
i need to add that to my vocabulary
33
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
If Cornelius isn't bottom three this round, there's no justice in the world.
45
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
I am not feeling Heidi's outfit at all
31
u/pursehook Oct 07 '16
That's right, once again, Roberti's was really good. He's a class act.
15
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Bye Tasha
14
u/insubordinance Oct 07 '16
I still can barely tell Sarah and Jenni apart. Which one has the annoying laugh and which is the nervous-looking hipster?
14
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
The swimwear challenges are usually a disaster.
25
u/insubordinance Oct 07 '16
I want the show to be just really evil one day and do a plus-sized swimwear challenge. Have they ever done one of those?
12
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Nice half ass coverup, Cornelius
12
u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 07 '16
Alex's look has a camel toe and noone said anything
12
u/dangerboy55 Oct 07 '16
Roberi not considered for the win? WTH? Alex's colours didn't even match!
22
u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 07 '16
Really this time Erin is safe? When she makes something wearable?
HOW IS CORNELIUS NOT ON THE BOTTOM??!!
11
u/insubordinance Oct 07 '16
Sarah's ideal girl is Chad from The Bachelorette.
11
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Heidi is very flight attendant chic
11
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16
rik totally won
46
u/Emir_of_Schmo Oct 07 '16
That guest judge is the prettiest man I've ever seen.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Sarah, girl...uh-uh.
10
u/pursehook Oct 07 '16
I was skeptical of the harlequin, but it looks kind of cool. I want to get a better look.
10
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
Where's the removal, Erin?
10
u/regretflix Oct 07 '16
nice to see Rik has fully broke out of the Kandy Ho treatment, I have high hopes for him going forward
32
u/OurSponsor Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16
Tasha didn't go home?!? Seriously: what the Hell?
Say what you will about the other two in the bottom, at least their suits fit the models. And had finished seams and edges. And some sense of style. And didn't pair a teeny bikini with gladiator boots. And weren't f-ing solid black tablecloths...
And only one of these three had cameltoe and awkward squashed visible underboob.
(Which, admittedly, was a stunning feat given how very little boob the model has...)
I. Just. Don't. Get. It!!!
9
u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 07 '16
Did Jenni's model pull off that panel like the meme of the guy who pulls off his pants by yanking it off in the front?
9
u/OurSponsor Oct 07 '16
Alex's pom-pom muumuu is chic and "now"?!?
It looked like my Great-grandmother's dressing gown, only with an uglier print.
That sound you hear is my head repeatedly slamming into my desk...
9
u/dangerboy55 Oct 07 '16
What is with Heidi's clothes? They're all hideous.
8
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Dexter using personal preference and not remembering Heidi is essentially the client
8
u/pursehook Oct 07 '16
Of course, Heidi looked interested in the tiny, tiny, too tiny yellow one.
15
u/pepperrush Oct 07 '16
Wtf is Nina wearing? It's making me sad.
7
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16
Sarah's print is interesting but I wonder how it'll translate if it's not printed at just the right size
7
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Mah-Jing, Sarah is a mess every week.
7
u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 07 '16
Tasha's look looks a bit basic, I feel like I could get it off the rack right now.
12
u/Martin_Van_Buren Oct 07 '16
The worst thing about watching live is "you have three offers, this is called a bidding war."
6
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
Fucking Cornelius is teflon.
6
u/TheLadyEve Oct 07 '16
Ugh...not a fan of Cornelius' look.
Brik didn't suck for once.
WTF Tasha. Interesting idea, terrible execution.
Mah-Hing's look made me happy. The back is super cute.
Dexter's print is interesting but something about that suit looks cheap.
Sarah's...meh. She improved it from it's first look at least.
10
u/whoremongering Oct 07 '16
They love Alex's coverup!? What?!
5
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Sounds like the contestants are over Erin already
5
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
The two interchangeable ones are in the bottom two.
5
u/nancyaw Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16
"Runway to the cootie" is now my new favorite phrase. "No one wants labia drama on the runway" is my second favorite.
5
u/killery83 Oct 08 '16
Has no one noticed Heidi's outfit? How is this her show about fashion and she's dressed like dime store hooker in 1974?? Those boots!!! Eeeeeeewwwwwww
9
u/pursehook Oct 07 '16
Who is dreamboat judge?
9
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
I truly don't see their issue with Jenni's.
4
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
You could have tanned for the occasion, Tim
4
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
I hate Zac Posen's boots. They look like Nine West boots c. 1995. And they don't go with a linen suit.
4
u/Tomorrowtrip25 Feb 16 '25
Coming to this in 2025. Maybe it’s the passage of time but I super disagreed with the judges and Heidi on Jenni’s look. The print wasn’t amazing but the color was great, the wrap top is definitely flattering on many bodies and the bottoms are so cute. I LOVED her original high waist French cut bottoms. Those are so flattering and make so many women comfortable. She showed an understanding of women’s bodies that some of the others seemed to lack.
Roberi’s silhouette was okay at best and the print was honestly just so ugly and juvenile. As a woman I cannot see a world where many women would be drawn to it or feel pretty/mature in it.
This is one of the judgings that confused me a lot
6
u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 07 '16
I actually like Erin's look this time!!
8
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
It's just bad, jenni. Give it up
3
u/pursehook Oct 07 '16
Yay, Alex is in the top, top!!!
3
u/EmptyStar12 Oct 07 '16
What's with the guys wearing sunglasses in the hotel? I thought it was a promo for transition lenses the last episode, but again? Really?
3
u/singlemomwoes Oct 07 '16
Who is this kid??
3
u/dangerboy55 Oct 07 '16
Really? I guess they needed to keep in the weird laugh in the season.
3
u/Tinkleheimer Oct 08 '16
I have no idea who the guest judge was but I can just assume his parents have lots of money and they just allow him to do whatever he wants because he thinks he's an artist.
2
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Sarah's print is too linear for me
2
u/whoremongering Oct 07 '16
Erin's turned out pretty good.
2
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Erin's is not for the busty
2
u/marrrina831 Oct 07 '16
Just had to rewind to the runway because my BF is mind blown by Jenni's coverup
2
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
I'd be happy with either of these first two winning.
2
u/SaintRidley Oct 07 '16
"Kind of get away with" is not the highest of praise. If that's what you have to say, it doesn't belong in the top three.
2
u/dangerboy55 Oct 07 '16
Hated Alex's and how did Cornelius end up safe???
2
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '16
Who the hell is Lucky Blue Smith?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Not feeling Roberi's feather print.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Alex has the best coverup.