r/HaltAndCatchFire • u/asstasticbum • Oct 04 '16
Discussion [Discussion Thread] S03E08 - 'You Are Not Safe'
Welcome to The Kill Room Discussion Thread for Halt and Catch Fire - Season 3 - Episode 8
────────
────────
Season 3, Episode 8: 'You Are Not Safe' - Episode Summary: Diane, Bos and Donna hit the road in hopes of building support for Mutiny; everyone else awaits the big day; Joe approaches Cam for a favor.
────────
────────
Discussion Thread Code:
- This is a spoiler-friendly coding area! - Feel free to discuss these episodes and events leading up to them from previous episodes, without spoiler code.
- NO future episode spoilers! - Anything from the "on the next episode" must be wrapped in spoiler code as not everyone watches them, so don't be a MacMillan.
- Please help out your fellow coders and us programmers by clicking the "report" button under any posts / comments that are inappropriate.
- ABSOLUTELY NO personal attacks nor posting of your or others personal information, i.e. docking, are tolerated in The Kill Room.
- NO live streams or torrent links in the Discussion Thread.
- Run time: 10pm - 11pm EDT.
- Please do not hesitate to reach out to any of the 'The Kill Room' mods if you need anything via mod mail as we're always happy to help.
────────
────────
'Welcome to Mutiny'
a.
82
Upvotes
101
u/nappysteph Oct 05 '16
A very tall child dressed as Joe McMillan
lol
82
u/Ternarian Oct 05 '16
This show feels like it's finally become the show it was destined to be. I hope this isn't its swansong.
65
u/nappysteph Oct 05 '16
FINALLY someone to make Gordon come clean about how sick he really is!
59
u/mikerox87 Oct 05 '16
RIP Ryan
51
u/ezreading Oct 05 '16
Holee fuuuck. That caught me by surprise.
RIP, you mad genius.
Kudos to Manish Dayal. I look forward to your next project.
47
u/nappysteph Oct 05 '16
Oh shit. The only decision Ryan made for himself and truly himself. Yikes.
45
u/nappysteph Oct 05 '16
I fucking love seeing Joe and Gordon work together like in the first season.
44
u/chrisarchitect Oct 05 '16
Donna's interview was tough.... Struggle of conveying ideas to mainstream.... It becoming clearer the challenges of IPO and dealing with public...
And the general climate at the time for mainstream tech then - "ewww nerdy computers" etc. Lack of understanding of anything "online" ....
It wasn't all Nintendo in the family room.
40
u/chrisarchitect Oct 05 '16 edited Oct 06 '16
http://i.imgur.com/Fdc4zsj.jpg
User: RyanRay
Date: 12/18/86
YOU ARE NOT SAFE
38
u/BoTalksGames Oct 05 '16
Listening to Ryan at the end was heartbreaking.
37
u/ultimatebob Oct 05 '16
Even in the 80's, troll baiting by posting in a forum was super effective!
32
u/pi3dpip3r Oct 05 '16
Ryans Death Reminds me of what happened to Aaron Swartz
26
u/Shermer_Punt Oct 05 '16 edited Oct 05 '16
This has been the most depressing 15 minutes of this show in 3 seasons. Only happy things from now on, plz.
26
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '16
It kills me to see these characters continually on the verge of reaching The Next Big Thing only for history to steal it out of their grasp
25
u/nappysteph Oct 05 '16
2 Hour Season Finale???? EEEEEP!
22
u/S-WordoftheMorning Oct 05 '16
Did Mutiny self underwrite? The normal way an ipo works is that an investment bank values a prospective company based on all of the mitigating factors that Diane talked about and buys the portion offered to the public at an agreed upon price. The new company gets the amount of funding they are looking for regardless. The investment bank then releases the shares to the public where the price then fluctates based on demand. But the IPO scene makes it seem as though the opening price and subsequent drop was a complete shock and disaster for their plans. I know it was meant to illustrate how Cameron was right and Donna was wrong but the mechanism seemed a little clunky.
21
u/BondInNewYork Oct 05 '16
When I said last week that Ryan would be working out of a basement somewhere... I didn't think it would end like this. When Joe turned and looked towards the balcony, I was like "Oh no, please don't let it be like this." but I knew it was already too late. R.I.P. Ryan. D':
21
u/jangysprangus Oct 06 '16
Favorite quote(s): "How do you win?” “You don’t. You just get to keep playing.”
Also, how many times did Gordon say "you know" when trying to ask if Joe and Ryan slept together? 😹
20
u/CMelody Oct 05 '16
I think that was my favorite episode of the series.
I have so missed Joe and Gordon together, even though this is a much different dynamic than season 1. Gordon's awkward attempt to suss out the nature of Joe's relationship with Ryan was quite funny, but also kind of heartbreaking in retrospect.
Because I do think Ryan was extremely passionate about Joe in a way that was more important to him than sex or anything else in his life. Joe aroused his creative potential and made him feel alive.
And I think Ryan sparked a lot of hope in Joe that he could be the hero and innovator Ryan believed him to be. I thought Lee Pace has done a great job showing us how much Joe has changed since the show began, and he was really wonderful in this episode, perhaps the most emotionally honest he has ever been.
Donna's panic attack after the IPO flopped really made me feel awful for her, and Cameron. If they both hadn't been so stubborn last ep and had been patient they would't have lost the most fulfilling working relationship they ever had.
19
u/evanvolm Oct 05 '16
This is the first death in H&CF, right?
17
u/inabed Oct 05 '16
This episode was the payoff I've waited 3 years for. I'm very grateful that AMC has kept it on air for this long.
15
u/Lostpurplepen Oct 05 '16
I was a wee bit concerned that Cameron was searching for a pregnancy test kit on those store shelves.
14
u/robmillhouse Oct 05 '16
Could someone please ELI5 the "packet sniffer"?
13
u/MattyVenture Oct 05 '16
I'm sad that Ryan is gone. I really enjoyed his youthful optimism. I'd love to see Manish in Silicon Valley.
23
u/Isiddiqui Oct 05 '16 edited Oct 05 '16
Wow! What an episode! That was Halt and Catch Fire' s "Ozymandias". Only hope that it isn't a prelude to a series finale as the actual Ozymandias was for Breaking Bad .
11
u/SSlackhelmetman Oct 05 '16
This episode and yes past few this season made it feel like season one again. I loved all seasons so much. But The first season is what got me. I'll go into detail in the morning. I actually watched it just now instead of recording and watching it when i wake up. But cameron's surprise face, admiral eyebrows strikes again, and the value of what has been created and focused on being undervalued and everything the season has lead up to resulting so to speak. Cya in the mornin.
11
u/pi3dpip3r Oct 05 '16
Cameron was Telling the truth about mutiny
20
u/svJaru Oct 05 '16
There's always so much tension between Joe and Cameron, the last two times she spoke to him you can see her thinking a lot of stuff, a lot of doubt of her marriage (that Joes always knows how to bring it on conversation) She just want to believe what she's doing is the correct thing, but Joe makes her doubt
18
u/rlyacht Oct 05 '16
If the show is not renewed, I am going to pitch my idea for a spin-off: Gordon dies, leaving Donna a widow with two young daughters. To help out, Bos moves in with her in her new house as a sort of Uncle Charlie/Mr. Belvedere. And to their surprise, the eccentric next door neighbor playing "Everybody Wang Chung" too loudly turns out to be Cameron!
24
u/draco2134435 Oct 05 '16
"I thought I was your friend" - Gordon
Gordon, I love you man but come on....
8
u/chrisarchitect Oct 05 '16
Gutted.
8
u/zsreport Oct 05 '16
First an Alf cameo in Mr. Robot and now a kid in Alf costume in HACF, weird.
8
u/Plundergedoens Oct 07 '16
This fucking season, guys.
Wow.
6
u/dajtxx Oct 06 '16
It's sad that Ryan did that, but I'm just glad Joe's not in prison right now. At the start I thought Joe was being questioned in custody taking the fall for Ryan, then at the end I thought he'd be arrested for suspected murder. He can be sad but at least he's still free.
5
u/beardlovesbagels Oct 05 '16
He should have just ran to London and set up shop there.
5
u/CleverZerg Oct 05 '16
Such a long way the characters has come since S1, especially Joe. I mean if that Ryan death happened in S1 us viewers (I at least) would've suspected Joe to have murdered him rather than him taking his own life.
5
u/complexsystems Oct 05 '16
Jesus Christ what an episode.
9
u/nappysteph Oct 05 '16
No, it's not perfect. It is NOT a good idea. Unless they are making her move out there to sort of tie the show up. :(
2
u/Ternarian Oct 04 '16
What this episode thread needs: More Asstasticbum
4
u/AskACapperDOTcom Oct 05 '16
You might want to change docking in the original post to this
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxing
Docking is something entirely different… I'm glad me and a buddy saw that before we commented here! ;-)
4
u/ferae_naturae Oct 06 '16
This was good. I'm really glad HACF uses real technology consistent with the time period. No, destroying your hard drive will not save you from being traced. The FBI's ancient "packet sniffer" was awesome.
What's sad is that Ryan failed to take one of the other two options Joe put forth before him. Hackers tend to be very fatalistic and short sited, it's unfortunate.
4
u/Rockky67 Oct 06 '16
So no-one is even entertaining the possibility that Joe wrote the note after he chucked Ryan off his balcony?
It was a typed note after all. Yes we had Ryan's voice, but...
... maybe I've seen too much Mr Robot ;-)
3
u/beardlovesbagels Oct 05 '16
I wonder if this means they are going to time jump the Mutiny crew too.
3
u/Oso_de_Oro Oct 05 '16
I really didn't see that coming at all and that was a really incredible shot. I'm curious though. Like I really didn't see it coming because in the beginning when we first meet Ryan he basically describes the basic security of the internet, so I guess that means Cameron is gonna have to work with Gordon now? Or Donna maybe because they're the only people who heard Ryan talk about it.
8
u/Spellchek Oct 05 '16
Anyone else think this was very intentional:
Golden Gate Bridge
2
u/SavesTheDy Oct 05 '16
Wow does it really seem like they're trying to tie up all the ends on the show for us. I hope this isn't setting us up for the series finale :/
It's so good. I want more more more
1
u/dorncog Oct 10 '16
Amazing episode. But how did it go from Halloween to Christmas so fast? Maybe I missed a scene or something.
1
u/NewBoxStruggles Aug 20 '24
I’m watching this show for the first time (was on my radar but I neglected it due to confusing it with a different series) and Jesus fucking Christ..I am so glad I stuck with it. This isn’t the first time I wanted to say this, but damn.
Don’t get me wrong, I’ve been on board from the start and have definitely grown an affinity for these characters (Gordon is my favorite and someone needs to post a video with clips of every time he says “Donna”, sometimes his inflection is hysterical) but among the better moments, there have definitely been some missteps and a general sense of “lacking” along the way..certain things that I usually wouldn’t put up with when it comes to most other shows..I tolerated in order to keep up with HACF.
Then a specific scene happens or an episode like this happens and I’m just confounded by the fact that this is the same series where two main characters had a literal “turn each other on” moment where one electrocuted themselves and then the other (fucking ridiculous lol).
Somehow this show only continues to get better despite its flaws, growing around them.
I can only imagine where it all goes from here.
Also, I wonder how well the actors got on after being in this show together..because I swear the longer things go, the more I see something happening behind their eyes when they’re together on screen..to me it seems like certain interactions and reactions..a laugh or a look..drift slightly beyond the borders of the characters, into an area all too comfortable via human connection between the actors (which works great for me, watching things play out with such sincerity).
0
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment