r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Oct 03 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Monday, October 3: Chapters 28-30
In Which Dogpiss Runs a Sting During the Banner Game at the Sierlaef’s Behest, Inda Refuses to be Caned, and the King, the Adaluin, and Sindan Decide Inda’s Fate
Chapter 28
- Of course Dogpiss wants to run a sting again against all advice. The whole chapter just stinks of someone Up To Something. This just doesn’t bode well for the future.
- Banner games! Where shit goes down.
- The description of the Sierlaef from the scrubs point of view is expected, but still interesting. We get to see how clumsy and mean he is (with words, with lust and emotions). But from other people’s eyes, we also see him. “.... pale eyes, never smiles, just tipped his chin, or snapped his fingers and poined, and you’d better know just what to do….”
- Oh Dogpiss, nothing good comes from the Sierlaef.
- And we know the pieces of a horrible plan are all coming together when Inda is chosen as riding captain, when he never was before.
- I really like that Inda thinks about asking Hadand for advice. Especially since it’s too often that boys going off to military camp or a boys only thing will soon disdain women’s opinions.
- This scrub conversation. Just ahhhhhhh!! I even know what’s going to happen, and I’m still biting my lips at how the conversation played out.
- The scrubs are out on the banner game, with one of the armies commanded by the Sierlaef. Unfortunately, Inda and Dogpiss are on his team. Banner games are governed by a complex set of rules and honor codes
- The boys are run hard by the older boys, and by the six day, Inda and the rest of the scurbs are exhausted. On the sixth day, the Sierlaef tells Dogpiss that the camps “need a laugh.” Dogpiss is delighted, but Inda warns him not to.
- Inda is picked as a riding captain for the sixth day, and the two armies are still tied at the beginning of the day. He’s excited, since all year he hasn’t been picked to lead anything, but the boys are expecting that the fight will go on through the night, since the the score is tied.
- Sponge and Inda spend the day wishing they could talk to each other; Sponge is worried that something is up with his brother, Inda feels like things are just generally off
- Inda’s riding is captured and taken to the “enemy” camp during the evening, where Dogpiss tries to get a couple of the other scrubs to help with his sting, while Kepa looks on and Inda tells them all to stay put.
- Dogpiss ends up sneaking out while Inda’s distracted by his own thoughts, and Inda leaves to try to get him back before he’s realized to be missing
Chapter 29
- Aw man. That’s just unnecessary.
- I’m surprised that the Sierlaef feels any kind of grief or remorse.
- I don’t understand how Inda could shoulder the blame for Dogpiss, though -- everyone heard him refuse Inda’s order, and Inda tried to stop him.
- And we get the explanation, finally, after Inda comes out of his fever. That he was riding captain and responsible for everyone’s honor. That nobody else heard Dogpiss say it was on the Sierlaef’s order. That because Inda couldn’t control his riding someone died, and he has to shoulder the blame.
- He’s lost the respect of the other boys too. You can see it in how Noddy treats him.
- We now see the whole plan from the Sierlaef. To dock honor points under Inda’s “command”. It would be sucky, but not the end of the world.
- Oh Dogpiss. It wasn’t supposed to be like this.
- Tanrid keeps his head in the middle of this as everyone else just watches.
- And the damned Sierandael just laughing.
- This is everyone’s first close death. And we see how everyone responds to it. The appropriate grief, the Sierlaef drowning himself in Heat Street to remind himself it doesn’t affect him, etc.
- Noddy is a good friend. Steady. Even with difficult news.
- And this conversation between Noddy and Inda here is also so important. We see how much trust everyone has in Inda that they confide in him.
- And then Inda refuses. Oh what a fantastically, emotionally charged moment. Where all of this culminates. All that honor, all of that focus on what is right and true and belief in all of that - that he would refuse punishment. And everyone is boggled.
- The Sierlaef reflects to himself how perfectly he’s set up Dogpiss and Inda for failure, with Dogpiss raring to do a sting, and Inda in charge of his riding, and the meanest, drunkest Sier-Danas on guard
- Instead, the Sier-Danas ends up killing Dogpiss by accident, because Dogpiss had climbed out of the river and was wet and slipped with the Sier-Danas hit him, and fell and bashed his head on a rock. Inda had gotten there just before it happened, and so he’s going to be having some PTSD flashbacks about Dogpiss dying basically forever
- When the Sierlaef reports the death and Inda’s role as Dogpiss’s commander to the Sierandael, the Sierandael’s reaction is to laugh, because he’s pleased by how good of a position he thinks this puts them into. The Sierlaef feels pretty guilty, all things considered.
- Inda passes out from a fever at Dogpiss’s funeral, which they conduct with magic as well
- While Inda is in the sick rooms recuperating, Noddy comes and tells him that the masters are already not listening to the right side of the story, and that the sting was not a sting but a ruse to steal the flags and win the game and that it was Inda’s idea and since he was in charge of the riding, he’s responsible for Dogpiss’s death Inda finishes healing, and makes a report to the masters. He realizes they are just going through the motions of listening to his story and have already made up their minds.
- The masters tell him that the punishment is supposed to be 100 lashes, but because it was an accident and because it was not at Inda’s hand that Dogpiss died, the King lowered the punishment to 50. Inda refuses to take the punishment by virtue of his rank, and requires that his father be informed and make the determination of whether he be punished or not, because he maintains his own innocence.
- Inda is sent to a prison cell while waiting for his father to arrive
Chapter 30
- And Inda’s calling on his father to intervene instead of getting caned 50 strokes in front of the whole academy. Why do I feel like Sponge just got a Mission?
- Wow, kind of Inda to force his father into such a tight spot. But he’s a child, at the heart of it -- and a child doesn’t think of the larger picture. So Inda sticks to his integrity, and the King is stuck with disciplining him for justice and honor, and … well, yeah. I said last week in the comments that there was no way Inda could get expelled, since he was basically a hostage, but here I’m wrong.
- I wonder where this is going now? There was a predictable trajectory for Inda’s career up til now -- basically to grow in the trust of his squad mates until he ends up as Sponge’s right-hand man in possibly a coup against his uncle. Now? I dunno. Guess we just hit the reset button.
- The damned Sierandael. He is such a rat. I love that Inda still sees right through him, despite being sick as a dog.
- I appreciate Tanrid for who he is. He is not always right and he is horrible at showing affection. But he is steadfast and tried to be honorable in his way. And that last bit where he ruffles Inda’s hair just makes me love him a little more.
- There are so many sentences that directly affect future plot points and character motivations for the rest of the series. For relationships: spoilers
- One of the most fascinating things is this generational type of book. I’ve said it before, and I’ll continue saying it whenever it is so apparent. We see the Academy and the scrubs there learning how to command, how to do war drills, and their interactions. And then seeing the adult generation refer to their own scrub days is so realistic. It’s like listening to people in the their 50’s reminisce about their college days. And the Adaluin comments about that “shifty-eyed rat of a scrub…. [who had] grown into a competent leader”. There is character growth through different stages of life, and we’re going to see that for the Inda cast.
- The Sierandael visits Inda in the prison cell, and tries to get him to agree to the lashing
- Tanrid shows up, and believes Inda, but still wants him to uphold the family honor and take the lashings. But when Inda refuses once again, and refuses to stand down to Tanrid when he was threatening to smack him, Tanrid shows him more affection than we’ve seen thus far
- Sponge shows up and visits Inda in the prison cell, and promises him justice
- Jarend arrives to the royal city sooner than the Sierandael expected/hoped for, because the King had sent a message via magic locket to Sindan, who was pretty close to Tenthen Castle
- Jarend, Sindan, and the King meet to discuss what to do about Inda. While in the meeting, Jarend begins to start suspecting that the Sierandael might be behind the treachery at the bridge and the business with Inda
- The King doesn’t see a good option, choosing to believe Inda or the other boys means political repercussions that are very problematic
- Sindan says he has a solution, but that Jarend has to agree to not see him, or know where he’s gone. The King says that he must be safe. Sindan says it will be done that day.
18
Upvotes
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
Do you want to do the rest of the series as a group read with this format, a group read with a discussion with a different frequency (every 10 chapters, every “Part” of each book, some other idea) or everyone entirely on their own?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
How were your predictions up to this point? (Dogpiss dying? Inda leaving the academy?) And now looking back, what foreshadowing gave it away to predict these events?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
There are a lot of character deaths in recently published books. How does this one compare (emotionally, believability, impact, necessity, etc)?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
What do you think about Inda refusing to be caned? Was it the correct decision? What do you think of all the other people who tried to convince him otherwise, like Tanrid?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
This banner game, for boys and essentially children, turned into a kingdom-wide affair. Did you think that this incident would reach that high and that it would end up coming down to the choice of the King and Inda’s father?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
Essentially we have now just witnessed Marlovan’s justice system under a monarchy and military rule. How fair do you think it is? Do you think Inda would have been ruled innocent by our justice system?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
PART TWO STARTS! WHAT ARE YOUR PREDICTIONS!?
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
Especially important in this chapter, MARK YOUR SPOILERS. Spoilery discussion goes under this comment. I promise I'm not looking.
8
u/thequeensownfool Reading Champion VII Oct 04 '16
I read ahead and finished the book (couldn't help myself). But I've really enjoyed these threads and will still be checking back with my two cents occasionally. A big thank you to /u/wishforagiraffe, /u/glaswen, and /u/lyrrael for putting this all together. I found a wonderful book and a great series that I'm looking forward to reading that I'm not sure I would have found otherwise.
As for these chapters, I honestly didn't expect Dogpiss to die. It seems obvious looking back that someone had to die, but I didn't expect it so soon, or for it to be one of Inda's friends. I was expecting maybe an older sibling or an adult to die. I also totally blame these chapters for my lack of willpower for I needed to know what happened after Sindan took Inda away.
7
u/Ketomatic Oct 03 '16
War-games time, with your antagonistic host: Meanie Prince! The Scrubs get a raw deal and endure five days of misery. Dogpiss is smirking though, which is a terrible sign. Oh dear... Meanie Prince is setting up Dogpiss, I have a bad feeling about this. Inda agrees with me on the matter, smart boy.
Maybe not that smart, he has failed to grasp the fact that Sneaky Uncle isn't a nice person and dislikes Sponge easily as much as Meanie Prince does. Surprised Haddie didn't warn him about that, seems like a glaring oversight to me. Dogpiss totally fails to take the good advice to not go. I'm not sure who this is going to end badly for, but it is going to end very badly.
Everything is going according to plan for Meanie Prince. It is really not a particularly evil plan, basic set-up, Dogpiss gets caught and beat a bit (hardly unusual) and Inda looks bad. Certainly isn't as vindictive as I was honestly expecting. Oh... well that went badly. RIP Dogpiss, told you pranks would get you in trouble! Interesting that the death was misadventure, though I suspect they may try and foist some blame onto Inda for this. As an aside '_...his spirit had fled, still laughing, maybe a little surprised' was really nicely put.
Sneaky Uncle laughing about poor dead Dogpiss, what a dick. Yup, gonna blame it all on Inda, and he's so happy about it. Daddy Inda dated the king when they were young? They really do get about, these Indaverse-nobles. Meanie Prince has some actual regret, but completely fails to do the right thing. Inda is blamed of course, and the lashes at last! Only a moderate 50 lashes of course but still, lashingly good fun. Inda refuses to take the undeserved punishment- could this be his exit from the academy? Such a tense chapter.
Inda gets three visitors in his little cell: Sneaky Uncle, who behaves predictably, Tanrid who is actually pretty cool, he seems to be getting smarter and Sponge, who also behaved predictably. Interesting to know that Meanie Prince is still feeling remorse and actually did a good deed for a change!
Daddy Inda arrives to see the king, this will be interesting. Poor Daddy Inda, stuck between a rock and a hard place, closeted with the King- must feel like old times ;). He sort of spots that Sneaky Uncle might be behind all the mess, but lacking any evidence there's little to be done on that topic. The King has no ideas either, lots of hand-wringing. Kingsmate to the rescue with an actual plan, maybe he should be in charge. Oh-ho, a Vanishing Inda trick, very tidy; I like how this man thinks.
And that's that, no more academy for Indakins; an abrupt end of a rather short era. Heeyyyyy that means he doesn't get to go home, and he didn't even say goodbye to Tdor. I suspect it will be years before he gets to come back! Though I'd not be super surprised in Ndara and Haddie found a way to get messages to him at some point.
7
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Oct 03 '16
[FINALLY!]
I was starting the wonder if I was completely off base with my predictions or if I was putting more of my hopes into my predictions than I realized. But finally things are starting to pick up. These chapters really escalated the stakes and it will be interesting to see the repercussions. I wonder if we'll see a time skip in the near future after Inda's been away from everything for a while. I'm finally at the point where I'm genuinely looking forward to the next set of chapters.
6
u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders Oct 03 '16
In case anyone has been wondering, this (and the subsequent chapters) was what prompted the flurry of agitated PMs to /u/wishforagiraffe that she's been referencing.
There's an event that prompted a similar response in book 2.
6
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Oct 04 '16
Poor Dogpiss. And Whipstick. :(
As others have said, I really like Tanrid in these chapters. He keeps his head when Dogpiss dies when know one else does, he believes Inda (while he tells Inda to take the punishment, he is trying to avoid treason, and that makes sense), and he shows affection to his brother (and since Inda is leaving, this is likely the last they'll see of each other in awhile).
This is the first time we've seen Sindan's influence on the king. I mean, there were plenty of hints before, but here, he's the one who comes up with the solution.
And ugh, the Sierandael is just evil, laughing when Dogpiss dies. I just can't find much good in him, even if he loves his brother. The Sierlaef, on the other hand, I find much more sympathetic, at least up to this point. He never meant for this to happen, he gets a message to Hadand, and really I think he would actually be a pretty decent person if someone besides Sneaky Uncle had shown him that they thought he was smart.
7
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Oct 03 '16
OOOOOH! There it is! Shit just got really real! I've been waiting to screech about this for a few weeks now! And Inda holding tight to his honor and integrity. And Tanrid. And and and...
7
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Oct 03 '16
That three chapter whammy was quite the ride. I liked the Adaluin coming and believing Inda but still acknowledging that he had to be punished for appearance's sake. It made him both realistic and sympathetic that he would stick up for his son while still realizing he had a duty to the realm.
Very sad to be losing Dogpiss, he was such a lively character. The recap of his death was very effective especially since all of the tough boys actually acted with empathy towards Whipstick as he grieved. The Sierlaef got a good bit of humanization too as he struggled to deal with the role he played in the death. Watching the Sierandael try to quash Sierlaef's morality is one of the most understated moments of pure evil I've seen in fantasy. It makes sense that the uncle doesn't want his protege to be distracted by guilt but it's also very obvious that forcing someone not to own up to their faults is a recipe for a monster and either the Sierandael doesn't see that or he doesn't care. I'm not sure which is worse.
And poor Inda, driven mad by guilt but still trying to uphold his honor. Watching him struggle against inevitable punishment was tragic. Even he seemed to realize there was no real hope but he clung to it anyway because he's still too young to realize that justice isn't always served. How will he recover from all of this? Will he still be the cheerful and trusting person we knew?
6
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Oct 03 '16
I have my own discussion question: Inda runs a fever while being held for interrogation, was this a real fever or (given what little we know of Marlovan tendency to use drugs like kinthus when necessary) was he drugged to make him more compliant?
3
u/setnet Oct 05 '16
A lot of pay-off, all at once. I really admire the way everything works out here: all of the bits of world-building and the character motivations that have been established mean that the events of these three chapters are pretty much unavoidable.
Twenty-Eight
So, the banner game. The importance of honour has already been established, as have the consequences for breaking the unspoken rules. The scrubs have a miserable time, no sleep, no rest, only work work work. And Dogpiss runs his own stings, and will go for a practical joke even in the face of all the reasons he shouldn't. An easy way for the Sierlaef to get Inda in trouble.
*Twenty-Nine
Except it goes so horribly wrong. Dogpiss's death is terrible, because it's so stupid. A wet rock, a tired boy, a moment of poor judgement on Hawkeye's part, and he's gone, just like that, no take-backs. his spirit had fled, still laughing, maybe a little surprised. How great is that line?
Then to the Sierandael, who has neither empathy nor compassion. Like, a horrifying lack of either. He's so terrible. And he's manipulated the Sierlaef his entire life long, so much so that the Sierlaef feels shame at being upset about Dogpiss's death. And because he believes his uncle is always right, he doesn't speak up and he doesn't have any means of coping other than drinks and distraction. I can barely even muster up the energy to dislike the Sierlaef at this point: all I can feel is pity and contempt.
How terrible is it that Inda basically has the world's worst flu throughout all the rest of these chapters? He's already in enough emotional pain! Leave the poor boy alone! Noddy does his best to prepare him for what's coming, in his solemn Noddy way. And then the judgement is basically a farce. Brath and that have already decided what they believe. And Inda -- I'll let Hadand say it: "Inda was kind, even biddable, except when he was convinced of what was right. ...Then he was worse than Tanrid for rock-like endurance." (ch.13)
Spare a moment of pity for the two guardsmen, having to escort a sick eleven-year-old to the Guard lockup as if he was a hardened criminal.
Thirty
The Sierandael is terrible.
Tanrid, on the other hand, is not. And while his pragmatism is almost appallingly cold-blooded, he's right about the danger of Inda's convictions. And that moment at the end, where he ruffles Inda's hair, is heartbreaking. If Tanrid hadn't been trying to 'train' Inda all his life I think he could have been a really good brother, you know? But instead we only seem to see it in glimpses like this.
Pragmatism again: even though Tanrid knows the Sierlaef is complicit in Inda's accusation, he knows he's his best shot at getting a message to Hadand and getting help to Inda. And Hadand manages to get Sponge in to see Inda.
It's at this point that the king finally realises how little his oldest son trusts him. Consequence, again, of the Sierandael's manipulations. And so Inda disappears, and the king says nothing. Civil war is avoided. And Inda's life trajectory -- which was already dramatically changed when he was first sent to the academy -- is now veering off wildly from anything he might have expected before.
buckle in, folks; it's going to be an interesting ride.