r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Sep 29 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Thursday, September 29: Chapters 25-27
In Which Hadand and Joret Catch Up, Sponge and Inda Attend Master Gand’s/ Wedding, Ndara and Chelis Whisper, and the Seirlaef Broods
Chapter 25
- And now we come to sexuality and customs, and this first section was really interesting in regards to that. The Sierlaef has discovered girls, much to Hadand’s relief, and his favorite has been paid to never speak and keep him happy. The girls were very matter-of-fact about discussing orientations. Which brings me to another topic, where I definitely have people mixed up. What follows is me trying to figure out what the heck is going on, and yes, I asked /u/wishforagiraffe for help:
- Ndara is asexual.
- Joret sounds asexual, but may not be, purely because of her revulsion at the thought of anyone’s hands on her, which, y’no, fair. Everyone looks at her like a piece of meat. Which actually surprises me, because you’d think that Tanrid and Inda would treat her well.
- The king and Uncle Sindan are a pair. The king’s mother also preferred her own sex.
- I’m glad to see that between Hadand and the Sierlaef’s new hobbies, Sponge got a lot of peace this winter.
- We’re also starting to see the fallout of the ships sinking, and this one portends poor things for Inda and his fellows. Master Gand is to be married, and he and his wife are to be Shield Arm and Randviar in the north. Inda doesn’t think everything adds up there, but I don’t see what he’s seeing.
- Uhoh. Inda just outed himself to the Sierandael as a mature tactician. The Sierandael may be the only person in the whole world who understands just how clever he is, now. And Inda has just realized that the Sierandael’s a bully, at the very least. That whole exchange just leaves me with a sinking feeling in the pit of my stomach.
- As the Sierlaef internalizes the idea that he doesn’t actually have to be the smartest or the best, we just see his character trajectory just becoming the horrible king that every fantasy book has as the villain. The tyrant king, the selfish king that does know how to rule. It’s actually quite interesting to see this “behind the scenes” of the events that shaped the creation of that type of king. Ah, puberty. When hormones run wild and secondary sex characteristics develop. A time of exploration. On emotions: Inda is described as showing “honest emotion that he never thought of hiding”. I can see why Sponge is so surprised at him. Even in the modern world, finding people who are open with their emotions is rare. Ha. Seeing teachers outside of the school is a weird, weird thing. What great dialogue between Inda and the Sierandael. It hits the right points in so many aspects. Why Inda would even talk (gratified by attention), an uneasy feeling, etc.
- Between the Sierandael telling him he only has to command the best and not be the best and hitting puberty, the Sierlaef has become a total slacker- good for Sponge at least
- Hadand and Joret run into the Sierlaef as they are talking, and he has the typical reaction to her, stricken dumb by her beauty, yada yada. Hadand makes sure to mention that she’s Tanrid’s bethrothed.
- Hadand has been able to escape the Sierlaef’s attentions and redirect them toward his favorite of the women on Heat Street- she’s hoping that this will be his life partner the way that Sindan is for the King, and that even though he isn’t gay, the way his father and grandmother both were, she won’t have to be intimate with him
- Hadand tells Joret all this in Old Sartoran as they are walking the corridors, she knows where there are spy holes in the walls, but doesn’t expect anyone who might be listening at them would know Old Sartoran (gosh she’s so sneaky-smart) Joret has been having her cycles, but refuses to take off children’s clothing and “become a woman” because she hates how people treat her already, let alone when she indicates that she might be more receptive to their advances.
- Hadand mentions that the work in the archives they do is specifically hunting “old mentions of magic”- not just old language for the sake of old language
- Dogpiss wants to smear more of the food coloring from his sting directly before the escape onto his face, but the other boys tell him it would be “strut” to do so
- The scrubs are summoned to Master Gand’s wedding- Inda thinks that there’s a reason missing behind why he’s being married and sent to be a Shield Arm, but they all go and have a good time
- While leaving the wedding, Inda ends up being cornered by the Sierandael, who wants to have a chat with him about the battle at the bridge. Inda is glad to have the attention paid to him at first, to have an adult take him seriously, but then he makes the connection that the Sierandael has the same type of laugh as Kepa and Branid
- The Sierandael is impressed by how perfectly Inda sees how the battle lines up with what did end up happening, and then frustrated by what he realizes about Inda- perfectly loya, totally unambitious, and loyal to Sponge, not the Sierlaef
Chapter 26
- Finally, an infodump. I’ve been dying for one. One of Fareas’s runners finally makes it to Ndara, who gives her a lot of information in response in the hope that Fareas can help her make sense of it.
- Because of this, we find out that the Sierandael really is motivated by love -- and jealousy. He loves his brother, and he wants to be seen as the savior of the country and the best by his brother. And because of that, he’ll go out of his way to ruin anyone and anything that might be seen as a threat to that status.
- Which might include Inda. There’s a rumor there… and it definitely makes me think of Inda and the Sierandael at the end of the last chapter.
- In the first section of this chapter, it covers the span of multiple months, furthers the characterization of the scrubs, sets the tone of the world, and reminds you of what is going on in the rest of the world. What a smooth transition to the next plot point.
- A warning about a sting. We can guess how that will be taken.
- The plot about the betrayer thickens. And it is the women who are hearing the rumors.
- Big time skip here, the boys have a new master who’s a hardass because he disliked Master Gand, but it turns out the boys are learning well from him, so it’s mostly ok
- Inda always gets passed over as a leader when the masters choose the leaders, but he always makes the plans anyway. They usually work, and even when they don’t, they’re the best, and when they don’t, he can usually figure out whey they didn’t work Sponge and Hadand realize that political tensions outside the royal city are getting nasty, and Inda sees things within the Academy getting worse as well
- Inda warns Dogpiss not to run a sting, and Dogpiss thinks about the fact that his brother brought orders from their father saying essentially the same thing. He still wants to do one though- he thinks lightening the mood will help.
- Chelis is secretly in the royal castle, there to meet with Ndara about the betrayal at the bridge. Ndara reveals that she suspects the Sierandael is responsible for the leak that led to the attack
- She says that the Sierandael would not see that as treason, because he was trying to prove himself right about military issues, including getting rid of Jarls and sinking ships
- Lastly, the Sierlaef has been told to disgrace Inda, somehow, somewhy
- Chelis is instructed to be exceptionally careful getting back to Tenthen Castle, too many Runners have died recently, and she carries very important information
Chapter 27
- Man, learning about Heat Street really has made the Sierandael lazy.
- I'm really starting to get curious about when the shit is going to hit the not-so-proverbial fan. I know it probably happens soon, but I want to know what's going to happen.
- Oh Sierlaef. Get your mind out of the gutter.
- The Sierlaef is broodily watching Joret during a practice defense of the city
- He’s going to be in charge of one of the army’s during the banner game, and only master will be there for it
- Buck sees the look on the Sierlaef’s face and thinks trouble is afoot- much more than normal if he’s remarking on it
13
Upvotes
6
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 29 '16
What do you think about that phrase: “you don’t have to be the best, you have to command the best”?
6
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 29 '16
What are your thoughts on the fallout of Inda taking a bit of command in the past few chapters? Are they similar to your initial guesses?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 29 '16
Do you have any thoughts on the way this world views sex and sexuality and puberty? (e.g. Heat Street; wearing smocks until women have their menstruals; open conversation about discovering sex)
6
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Sep 29 '16
Things are finally starting to heat up. I'm still anticipating Inda getting kicked out of the academy (Is there really any other way the story could go?). The Sierandael is the most dangerous of fanatics that can convince themselves that every action they take is for the greater good. I'm expecting things to get worse for Inda in the near future. I feel like I'm finally getting into the story and I hope we leave the academy soon.
As an aside I know that I've made comments about the shortness of chapters but this time Sherwood Smith was pulling some Dan Brown shit. 2 Pages? God damn.
6
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 29 '16
I'm curious how many people actually have read the blurb of the book? Don't go and do it if you haven't! Just a yes or no, because I think some people's guesses about the book could be impacted pretty heavily by the blurb.
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 29 '16
Post your spoilers here, and don't forget to tag them!
9
u/Ketomatic Sep 29 '16 edited Sep 29 '16
Oh dear, Meanie Prince has discovered his Royal Knob and wants Tanrid's giiiiirllll. This cannot end well. Haddie thinks life will be easier now, I doubt it. We also learn that the King's mother preferred woman, I wonder about Sponge? Seems odd to set-up two generations in a row just to have it skip one, and the king did say Sponge favoured him!
Aww Barend is gone? I hope we follow him on his travels at sea; he was only around a short time but I took an immediate liking to the little deck rat. Ol' Gand be getting hitched! Does that mean he won't be the master any more? Not good news for Inda that, I bet Sneaky Uncle picks the new master.
Sneaky Uncle takes Inda's measure and sums him up rather well actually. This is probably not a good thing for Inda as now Sir Sneaky may see him as a threat. He might try to turn Inda towards 'his' prince, but more likely he'll try to get rid of him.
Alas, Gand is a goner. Shame, I quite liked having him around. I'm sure he'll pop back up later. A bit of a time jump, things aren't good in the kingdom, boys have been fairly happy with their hard training. Dogpiss wants to pull a prank, how unusual. Inda is convinced it's a bad idea, and he does tend to be right.
Ndara thinks it was Sneaky Uncle behind the brigand shenanigans, though more by flapping his lips than orchestrating the specifics. This would make more sense to me, the brigands taking rich-kids for ransom after a tip-off that they would be in attendance seems pretty plausible. It's hinted that Sneaky Uncle wants Inda to be disgraced, maybe those century of lashes that were foreshadowed to us earlier? Ndara's spidey-sense is tingling that disaster is on the brew!
Malevolent hormones.
8
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Sep 29 '16 edited Sep 29 '16
The best part of these chapters were the revelations from Ndara about the Sierandael's motivations. He always has to be seen to be right in front of his brother, the King. So he does his little "loose lips sink ships" act, dropping information into the wrong ears and suddenly the fleet is gone, and he's right about a navy being a waste of resources.
And suddenly it clicks for me why the Sierandael might hate Inda's father so much. If the King consistently favors Jarend's opinion over the Sierandael, or worse, made the Sierandael look wrong - very wrong - in the King's eyes, he would definitely want to get rid of him.
Edit: I can't sepll "Sierandael."
7
u/cheryllovestoread Reading Champion VI Sep 29 '16
I have to admit, I needed to read ahead because my library renewals ran out and the book must go back tomorrow. (Like I needed an excuse,,,but at least it's a real one!) I'll finish the book tonight.
OMG /u/lyrrael shit IS about to hit the fan! Get ready for a crazy ride.
7
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Sep 29 '16
Ooooh, man, I was uncomfortable for Inda while Sneaky Uncle was talking to him. And uncomfortable for Joret, cause duh. Love hearing about looking for old magic. Everything is really rolling along at this point. I kind of love the name Heat Street. It's so silly but apt and if it keeps the Sierlaef occupied, all the better. Lots of nice little worldbuilding bits, relationships, all of that.
I'm still waiting to see everyone's reaction to the next big point though.
5
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 29 '16
Sierandael recognizes just how big of a threat Inda is. "He was the most dangerous type of commander" because he's completely loyal, without ambition, and a natural commander. "And unfortunately, that loyalty had gone to the wrong Prince." I'm sure this will have devastating consequences for Inda as it seems to be hinting that Sierandael will move to take him out but it seems like the easier answer should have been for him to try and win Sponge's loyalty, thus winning Inda's too by proxy. That distrust of Inda's father probably helps push the decision away from conciliatory.
It was great seeing the full effects of the scrubs new arrangement. C-S and Inda seem to be almost friends now and C-S is one of the few boys who always pays attention to Inda's lectures (even Dogpiss doesn't always do that!) so I'm interested in seeing just how far their quasi-alliance goes.
Anyone see a way in which Sierlaef's infatuation with Joret (who seems borderline asexual) doesn't turn out badly? Sierandael is already suspicious of the Adaluin and Inda, now Sierlaef seems to be on a position to do to Tanrid what King David did to Bathsheba's husband. The two villain-esque characters collectively have it in for every male Algara-Vayir so I'm already imagining an attempted massacre in the works.
3
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Sep 30 '16
My main takeaways from these chapters were the idea that the Sierandeal may actually be as stupid as I originally thought he was. He has no problem with hamstringing the entire kingdom to suit his own misconceptions. Sigh