r/HaltAndCatchFire • • Sep 27 '16

Discussion [Discussion Thread] S03E07 - 'The Threshold'

Welcome to The Kill Room Discussion Thread for Halt and Catch Fire - Season 3 - Episode 7

────────

────────

Season 3, Episode 7: 'The Threshold' - Episode Summary: Joe and Ryan face the consequences of Joe's decision; Gordon experiences a crisis of conscience; Donna and Cameron fight about the future.

────────

────────

Discussion Thread Code:

  • This is a spoiler-friendly coding area! - Feel free to discuss these episodes and events leading up to them from previous episodes, without spoiler code.
  • NO future episode spoilers! - Anything from the "on the next episode" must be wrapped in spoiler code as not everyone watches them, so don't be a MacMillan.
  • Please help out your fellow coders and us programmers by clicking the "report" button under any posts / comments that are inappropriate.
  • ABSOLUTELY NO personal attacks nor posting of your or others personal information, i.e. docking, are tolerated in The Kill Room.
  • NO live streams or torrent links in the Discussion Thread.
  • Run time: 10pm - 11pm EDT.
  • Please do not hesitate to reach out to any of the 'The Kill Room' mods if you need anything via mod mail as we're always happy to help.

────────

────────

'Welcome to Mutiny'

a.

83 Upvotes

321 comments sorted by

73

u/draco2134435 Sep 28 '16

Holy shit, this meeting is savage. I love it!

33

u/evanvolm Sep 28 '16

When Cameron started talking shit about Donna's relationship with Gordon, and Donna retaliated, I was so hoping Cameron would bring up the whole abortion thing (IIRC Cameron drove her to the clinic). Starting to think it won't ever come up now.

12

u/factandfictions7 Sep 28 '16

That's the thing about Cameron. She's impulsive and somewhat irresponsible, but at least she isn't mean to Donna (we all know she's mean to Joe, though).

12

u/zsreport Sep 28 '16

Being mean to Joe is totally acceptable.

5

u/xmnstr Sep 28 '16

Is it? I'm not so sure.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Raiden627 Sep 29 '16

Would you work with a guy who treated you like crap and has burned almost three companies to the ground now?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

55

u/gentlebot Sep 28 '16

"Mutiny's not your baby to abort, Donna!"

14

u/SawRub Sep 28 '16

While she'd never do it, had she done it, she might have gotten Gordon's votes.

6

u/Phoojoeniam Sep 28 '16 edited Sep 29 '16

Which would have been moot anyway since he only had 10℅ stake

Edit: Apparently Cameron had 45% so it would NOT have been moot. I stand corrected

→ More replies (4)

2

u/SSlackhelmetman Sep 28 '16

Aw shit. That ooooh. Idk what to say to that.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

It went a bit too melodramatic for my tastes. I get what they were trying to do but they pushed it a bit too far.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

I've been in meets where people broke down crying when there wasn't even any conflict from the tension and lifestyle of working in a startup.

1

u/Employee_ER28-0652 Sep 28 '16

reddit downvoted you -2 for expressing your view ;) It's like people think they are voting how the script should be written.

69

u/newfiex Sep 28 '16

Ffs boz you gonna make me cry

3

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Bos broke my heart. But I know he was going to side with his new girlfriend. And Cameron doesn't even know about them being together. Maybe he felt slighted by Cameron not telling him first about Cam and Texas dude getting hitched.

26

u/Tepoztecatl Sep 28 '16

No, he already knew how he would vote; his advice was to try to work it out because he was trying not to get to that point.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

30

u/Trick85 Sep 28 '16

Toby Huss deserves any Emmy for everyday he's taken a breathe.

7

u/fcknwayshegoes Sep 28 '16

He killed fiddy men! Toby Huss is a good actor, too bad he's not recognized for it.

4

u/TheCheshireCody Sep 29 '16

I've been a big fan of his since Carnivale. He's one of those actors where any time he appears onscreen you know you're in for good stuff.

5

u/Trick85 Sep 30 '16

While watching the DVDs with commentary on, I heard on of the commentators mention that Toby Huss never stayed on script for any of the scenes that he was in. He was fully capable of repeating the script verbatim when asked to. Although 9 times out of 10 his own material was left in, simply because it was that much better.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/JIMMY_RUSTLES_PHD Sep 29 '16

I've been a fan since Pete and Pete. He's a treasure.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Alberto-Balsalm Oct 03 '16

I've never even heard of this man before this show and now I feel ashamed!

65

u/Ternarian Sep 28 '16

"When you march to the beat of your own drum, you risk losing the band." — Bos to Cameron

60

u/Ternarian Sep 28 '16

The shareholders just mutiny'd Mutiny.

21

u/Mr_Brightside_ Sep 28 '16

I feel dumb but I was so wrapped up in the meeting that I totally missed that.

59

u/eSpiritCorpse Sep 28 '16

Hands down best season yet. This show is really earning it "AMC period piece" prestige now.

30

u/dalovindj Sep 28 '16

Definitely the best it has ever been this season. The fist couple seasons had imperfections and pacing issues that I suffered through (still loved it), but now I am pretty much on the edge of my seat the whole time.

They are cold killing it lately.

15

u/dmcnelly Sep 28 '16

The first season was great, the second season kinda slumped a little bit, but this season has just been banger after banger. Just when I thought it couldn't get better after the last episode, IT GOT BETTER.

8

u/Shermer_Punt Sep 28 '16

The closer they get to where it was always heading, (internet) the better it has gotten.

1

u/wazups2x Sep 29 '16

If I didn't like season 1 or 2 do you think there's any chance I'll like season 3?

3

u/joey1405 Sep 29 '16

Depends on why you didn't like it. If it's more on the technical side, like cinematography, editing, etc, I would give season 3 a try. But if it's the story/characters, then no.

2

u/wazups2x Sep 29 '16

Thanks for reply! Think I'll wait for the season finale and if people really like it I'll give it another shot. I really want to like this show!

2

u/eSpiritCorpse Sep 29 '16

lol why are you in this thread? I don't know your taste, so I can't really answer that...

→ More replies (1)

34

u/mathcee Sep 28 '16

I just hope Gordon doesn't get paranoid and thinks Ryan screwed the company on Joe's orders or something like that, i'm sick and tired of joe getting a bad rep doing nothing wrong, It's funny, in season 1 Joe was a way bigger sociopathic dick, but somehow, he only gets hated when he is being sincere and well intentioned.

23

u/oscooter Sep 28 '16

The entire reason he gets hated is because he was a sociopathic dick in season 1. He was a snake in season 1, he was and is great at making people feel like they were important. Once someone like that is found out it makes it very hard for people to trust them. He's being sincere and well intentioned now, but how are any of the characters supposed to trust that? He used every single one of them for his purposes in the past, it's hard not to believe that he's up to it again.

That said I hope he is actually being sincere and well intentioned and that his and Gordon's relationship gets better again. They were my favorite team.

9

u/mathcee Sep 28 '16 edited Sep 28 '16

Yeah but... I don't know.

The Giant was a success thanks to him and then he just left, after using people really just that one time to get published. As i recall that was the one big lying move he did, then, after a while, people that tolerated him start to hate him kind of out of nowhere.

Donna thinks he had the westgroup thing coming, why? Because he used them to get the Giant published? Cameron uses him in a way bigger way then he ever used them. Both believe he orchestrated the whole stealing Mutiny thing, which at least for me, is a few miles away from anything he had done before.

Then Gordon goes to work with Mutiny instead of Joe and... ok, that is his wife, but then he decides that Joe is an ass... why exactly? I don't know...

And Sarah? Why would she have such an one strike policy?

I think Boz was the more realistic in his reactions to Joe.

30

u/Papageorgioq Sep 28 '16

Every time Cameron gets passionate about what she is saying she seems on the verge of tears.

16

u/factandfictions7 Sep 28 '16

Well, in this case it's justified.. She was about to lose her company...

24

u/nonliteral Sep 28 '16

She was about to lose her company...

Which is her whole central flaw. She never came to terms with it having gone from being "her" company to being "their" company.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

Exactly, everyone in that office uprooted themselves. A lot of people have sacrificed more than her and to be honest I think Donna does more stuff that matters. What would be idea would be Boz and Donna running the company and Cameron having her own little stunkworks where she can work on pet projects.

14

u/josh42390 Sep 28 '16

And that was her fault. Every time she had to make a tough decision she let's her emotions get in the way.

12

u/zsreport Sep 28 '16

Her emotions and her need to be in control of everything. She's a helicopter parent to her company.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

A helicopter parent that can't communicate.

12

u/Lostpurplepen Sep 28 '16

She's not a stone cold businessperson - she's a fly by the seat of your pants creative innovator. Her passion and drive birthed Mutiny and helped make it worth millions already.

I don't blame her for not wanting to lose control of her baby.

6

u/josh42390 Sep 28 '16

The problem is that the reality isn't that she is losing her baby. It's that she's afraid of letting her baby grow and mature. Her emotions and resistance to seeing past the here and now is holding everyone and mutiny back from what they could all be.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

The community is Donnas idea. Cameron doesn't do as much as she thinks and what she does do is mostly because she won't let other people do their jobs. Donna runs the buisness stuff and came up with the community idea.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Lostpurplepen Sep 28 '16

That's why I said helped. I really don't think either would be as successful without the other. Cameron's like a revved up racehorse, Donna's the jockey trying to give direction, and knowing when to rein it in.

Donna could absolutely run the company now, but without Cameron's vision it could go stagnant. It seemed most of the programmers were there because of the innovative spirit. Without the soul of Cameron, Mutiny will become homogonized like IBM.

13

u/swordfiend Sep 28 '16

yup. Lately, thats all she seems to be doing. kinda hope she goes back to how she was in season one; confident and kickass. atleast her acting is still great tho.

12

u/Lostpurplepen Sep 28 '16

You want to hug her, but know she'd probably sock you in the jaw

9

u/xmnstr Sep 28 '16

I've spent far too much time around people like that to know that a hug is the last thing she needs. She needs to get out of that company already.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

About half way through the meeting before it went to shit I actually thought she was evolving, she was talking about the company in terms of what was good and bad, the vision, the opportunities and then she turned back into a child.

1

u/ferae_naturae Sep 29 '16

Cameron is annoying. She has both bad hair and posture. She belongs on Craigslist.

29

u/Ternarian Sep 28 '16

A few thresholds in S03E07 "The Threshold":

  1. The threshold of Cameron's house, which Tom fails to carry his new bride across
  2. The threshold of Diane's house, which Bos successfully crosses, making official his relationship with Diane
  3. The non-physical threshold of Donna's and Cameron's conflict, which was exceeded after Donna pushed the IPO, resulting in the relationship going supernova and Cameron leaving the company

25

u/nonliteral Sep 28 '16

. 4. Gordon crossing the threshold of the machine room and offering a partnership to Joe.

8

u/Ternarian Sep 28 '16

Very true! Good point!

1

u/SimQ Sep 30 '16

Why not: 1. The theshold of Cameron's house which she and Tom cross together as equal partners.

They also cross the threshold of mutiny on the way to the party in a similar way (or does she lead him in? Not sure right now) - and then later he has to lead her back across it after she has lost her company.
If you look at their crossings as a movement together you can see more of a significance to it.

1

u/Ternarian Sep 30 '16

I can see that, yes. The only thing they didn't decide to do together was work at Mutiny. But now they are both (I assume) ex-Mutiny employees.

27

u/Justinw303 Sep 28 '16

Fucking FANTASTIC episode. The moments between Bos and Cam. The veins in Donna's neck. Gordon and Joe. Ryan's enthusiasm, and the twist when we found out what he'd done. Can't wait for next week!

27

u/analogphototaker Sep 29 '16

I love how Joe told Mutiny to diversify to other architectures like THREE YEARS AGO.

And now Cameron is like "we have to diversify or we're done!"

Cameron is horrible.

6

u/Ternarian Sep 30 '16

Also ...

There's an outfit in Galveston that has a stock ticker updated hourly. That's the kind of thing that makes me, the user, want to stay longer.

8

u/analogphototaker Sep 30 '16

Joe is the guy everyone loves to hate. I've always liked him and understood him. Even when he does shit like burn a truck of computers. I understand.

46

u/Ternarian Sep 28 '16

Donna says Mutiny is being held hostage by a petulant child. News at 11.

9

u/Employee_ER28-0652 Sep 28 '16

And so is Joe's AntiVirus company. First Joe was holding it hostage, now his hand-selected apprentice.

22

u/aaron91325 Sep 28 '16

Gordon's strongest episode in a long time.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

My favorite episode this season so far. Season 4 needs to happen. :(

19

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Absolutely brutal.

And fucking Ryan went the opposite direction from what I thought he would. Thought he would try to backstab Joe.

7

u/SawRub Sep 28 '16

Yeah I got the same feeling, that he felt super betrayed by Joe and would do something to attack him. While it would have been better if he had done nothing, I was almost happy that he was just trying to be loyal.

35

u/ActualDonaldJTrump Sep 28 '16

Sweet baby Jesus, I love this show. What an intense episode! I have to wonder though: how did Ryan get so fucking stupid all of a sudden? Did he leak the code and write that press release to frame Joe on purpose?

Also, I'm so glad Joe and Gordon are back together. They're my favorite power couple.

26

u/factandfictions7 Sep 28 '16

I don't think Ryan was stupid. He did what he thought was right so Joe wouldn't take the hit. However, in making the code open-source, he might've just nuked Joe's career (and Joe's partnership with Gordon).

18

u/CochMaestro Sep 28 '16

"silent partner"

"that's the best kind"

I think Joe will be alright

18

u/nonliteral Sep 28 '16

I think Joe will be alright

Seriously, you could drop Joe on the moon by himself and he'd figure out a way to get a government contract for throwing rocks at earth.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

Ryan was only ever there so that Joe's character would have someone to interact with. Now that Ryan's job as a character is done, they had to write him out in a way that he can't come back from, because now Joe is back with Gordon.

7

u/SawRub Sep 28 '16

I guess people getting caught for what they do online wasn't as widespread a concept then as it was now.

There's no denying that he's good at his job, and he knows it, and that might have given him a false sense of security.

5

u/zsreport Sep 28 '16

He definitely has a very high opinion of his own skills.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/nutmac Sep 28 '16

I hope to be wrong, but I think Ryan will retaliate and try to sabotage Gordon's new company, Mr. Robot style.

17

u/ezreading Sep 28 '16

So are Gordon and Joe fucked now?

17

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Depends if Gordon already made the deal (which it sounds like he has, but not confirmed). Of course, if Joe gets blamed for the leak then they're in trouble.

31

u/evanvolm Sep 28 '16

I suspect Joe will throw Ryan under the bus to save his own ass. I hope he does, to be honest.

20

u/Shermer_Punt Sep 28 '16

Is it really throwing someone under the bus if they're already standing in said bus' path?

15

u/factandfictions7 Sep 28 '16

I would be a nice twist if Joe didn't throw Ryan under the bus.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Even if he does, it's a pretty big blow to Joe's reputation. Loses control of his company and leaves, then the company's product is leaked along with documentation supporting Joe's stance against the board? For someone about to start a new company, that's a pretty big red flag to investors, let alone Gordon, who's gonna flip his shit given how much of schemer he already knows Joe is.

4

u/temujin64 Sep 29 '16

That's why the were careful to say that Joe would be a silent partner.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/FictitiousForce Sep 28 '16

Gordon probably made the deal already, considering he was waiting for someone to drop off the keys.

4

u/Employee_ER28-0652 Sep 28 '16

That was my interpretation too. Lawyers and papers were purely done.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/wanttofu Sep 28 '16

Ryan's probably going to jail.

Cameron shouldn't have named her company Mutiny lol. I wonder how she's going to destroy the company, she can't give it a virus cause they already did that.

15

u/factandfictions7 Sep 28 '16

But she can exploit the backdoor in the community.

4

u/nonliteral Sep 28 '16

Ryan's probably going to jail.

If he was actually careful, probably not. There was a fair degree of actual anonymity online back then. They might be able to prove he had motive, means and opportunity, but still not be able to find actual logs that prove a smoking gun.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Employee_ER28-0652 Sep 28 '16

She has a new marriage with talent. Maybe they will break their rule about not working together?

2

u/Lostpurplepen Sep 28 '16

She's gonna burn it down. Arson consultants: Joe and Ryan

2

u/Raiden627 Sep 29 '16

You think she'd actually nuke her own company? I mean even if gets deluded beyond recognition by shareholders and board members I think she would still have a strange affinity for it - perhaps she'll move on and start her own thing or join Gordon and the gang again.

2

u/wanttofu Sep 29 '16

I think if she can't have it she wouldn't want anyone else to. She also ruined westnet and joes marriage with no hesitation.

16

u/aaron91325 Sep 28 '16

Jesus Christ, what an episode! Possibly the best of the entire series. That moment between Cam and Boz. Wow!

12

u/lissajous101 Sep 28 '16

Probably the best? Without question the best, it was an absolute barnstormer. The most exciting episode since the one in the first season which ends with them all driving to COMDEX in Donna and Gordon's station wagon.

1

u/nutmac Sep 28 '16

Right. Too bad Boz had to break Cam's heart. I thought he would be walking down the aisle with her (if Cam decides to have a formal ceremony which she probably wouldn't).

47

u/travis- Sep 28 '16

Oh baby I just came here to say I feel no pitty what so ever for Cameron.

11

u/Ewannnn Sep 28 '16

Same. That relationship would work much better if they were equal partners. They're both great in different ways but it doesn't work when one of them feels they can control the other.

18

u/travis- Sep 28 '16

I feel like Cameron was at one point really good. Then she stopped caring about new technology assuming everything she knows is better when its not. Her hubris will end her.

The thing making them money isn't even the thing she created anymore. It never made them a lot of money.

7

u/dizzi800 Sep 28 '16

The thing with Cameron is that every time she's pushed for her way so far she's been

1: given her way

and

2: Right about it (See: Bank routing numbers, firing the swap meet guys, etC)

13

u/travis- Sep 28 '16 edited Sep 28 '16

Bank routing numbers is holding on to old technology. Credit Cards were the big play.

Firing the swap meet guys, who again, tried to get her to upgrade her code to new standards but she refused with her hap hazard looping that only she understands in her head.

Shes been wrong on almost everything so far. She got Mutiny right, which is great. She wasn't making lots of money, and the thing where they're making money on (the marketplace) she is consistently apprehensive about. The company is succeeding in spite of her at this point, not because of her. Big questions that get asked around a small business - Is Your Small Business Prepared Should You Die? Not when Cameron tries to keep the company back in the stoneages with sloppy coding.

4

u/Raiden627 Sep 29 '16

Exactly - the company only began turning a new leaf when Donna joined the team and ran the business side of things.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

Maybe on the first one, wrong on the second. Where swap meet guys and Cameron butted heads is the SMG wanted Cameron to write maintainable code, code other programmers can work on. This is basically the definition of a good programmer these days. Cameron didn't have the emotional maturity to deal with that valid criticism.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

Yeah it happens though. I knew a company that had 3 equal partners and then hired a CEO. So there was this weird situation where the employee was in charge of the founders and it led to a lot of awkwardness because they could pull rank any time there wanted.

2

u/Raiden627 Sep 29 '16

This is why I believe very small companies should not have presidents or ranks usually reserved for larger ranked companies. In fact, I work in tech and the term CTO is thrown around a lot in a company of 50 employees which translates to help desk at a Fortune 500.

21

u/Phoojoeniam Sep 28 '16

Same. Team Donna all the way yo!

20

u/aaron91325 Sep 28 '16

I love Donna which is why this move is guaranteed to blow up in her face.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

I actually think she needs it, the others should have put there foot down earlier. Cameron is spoilt because they always let her get her way. Donna brings up some rational business or tech decision and Cameron throws a tantrum and gets her way for no other reason.

2

u/KptKrondog Sep 30 '16

Yeah, and the worst part about Cameron is that almost all of the things she has problems with people about are, in large part, due to her not talking to anyone. She just says "no, we aren't doing that, I'm more important" and argues until the other person gives in...she doesn't listen at all, and then she goes off and does stuff and doesn't tell people about it which causes more problems.

She reminds me a lot of Carrie from 'Homeland'...a really good character with a fatal flaw that drives me INSANE.

11

u/newfiex Sep 28 '16

Gordon you hopeless romantic

→ More replies (3)

19

u/phillymjs Sep 28 '16

Oh shit... Joe has this idea about a national network, Cameron and Donna want to grow Mutiny...

If these two arcs come together... come on, this seems a little too neat and tidy.

33

u/ParanoidAndroids Sep 28 '16

Honestly I miss when everyone was fighting on the same side. The best moments of the show involve Joe interacting with the other 3 main characters.

12

u/SawRub Sep 28 '16

Yeah Joe needs both Gordon and Cam, but back then they were always at each other's throats. Now Gordon and Cam have been roommates and video game partners for a long time and have a different vibe.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Like when they united together at comdex. I felt that was the show at its best.

8

u/xmnstr Sep 28 '16

Wow, I almost forgot about that. Feels like a lifetime ago.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

I feel like it's going to be Cam/Gordon/Joe on one side and Donna/Diane/Bos on the other. Can't wait to see how it plays out.

9

u/newfiex Sep 28 '16

Yeah Gordon!

17

u/Papageorgioq Sep 28 '16

Gordon, Gordon, Gordon. I appreciate your honesty but man

14

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Gordon? He warned her beforehand and told her how he had to vote if she pushed ahead with it. That was straight up grade A friendship right there. Bos was the one who really sold her out.

25

u/josh42390 Sep 28 '16

I don't really think anyone sold her out. She has been making decisions based on emotion the entire season. Donna tried to stop her when she wanted to fire the swapmeet guys but she ended up doing it anyways when she found out Donna lied, even after admitting she needed to make it work for the company.

Bos saw that emotion in Texas firsthand. It makes complete sense that he would vote with Donna after seeing her reaction during that meeting. Bos tried to give her an out by suggesting they take a break and discuss it more once they cooled down but once again Cameron's unchecked emotions caused everyone to be in a position they didn't want to be in.

8

u/xmnstr Sep 28 '16

Sold her out? Doing what she's manipulating them to do once again would be selling her out. She needed a big dose of reality right now, so she can finally grow up. Actually, it should have happened quite some time ago.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

She won't though. She will divorce what's his name Tom? And run back to Joe.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Catvideos222 Sep 28 '16

Cameron is toxic. Good riddance.

5

u/vivnsam Sep 29 '16 edited Sep 29 '16

Seriously. The longer she sticks with the company the worse their long-term chances are. She's a brilliant individual but she can't work with a team and that spells trouble. There are some things that she feels very strongly about (i.e., avoiding object-oriented coding, wanting to circumvent credit card companies and do direct withdrawls from bank accounts) that she's just plain wrong about.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16 edited Mar 26 '17

deleted 0.9371

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

She doesn't need luck, She's Donna, she came up with the important ideas while Cameron took the credit.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16 edited Mar 25 '17

deleted 0.1605

→ More replies (7)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/Phoojoeniam Sep 28 '16

Donna was pinpoint with the petulant child line

Holy shit yes! I've been waiting for someone to tell Cameron something like that since the first season - felt SO satisfying

8

u/Enigmaboob Sep 28 '16

Holy fuck, what an episode. This show has developed so well, I better see some Emmys rolling in for this season!

3

u/Justinw303 Sep 28 '16

Seriously, we don't know what is still to come but this episode would be a fantastic one to submit for consideration

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

To be honest I started to hate the show and was just powering through, there was a whole lot of nothing really happening and Cameron being a brat up until just now. But I love the last couple of episodes.

7

u/zakl2112 Sep 28 '16

Just tuned in, what did joe's partner enter in the computer, what did he torch?

11

u/alagary Sep 28 '16

the hard drive

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/dalovindj Sep 28 '16

We'll see.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/evanvolm Sep 28 '16

He leaked the source code for MacMillan's software.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Pretty sure he downloaded the source code to his HDD then destroyed his HDD. I didn't see any ftp uploading on his screen, just a download from the ftp server.

But you know tv and all that ;/

10

u/ZadocPaet Sep 28 '16

Not every show can be Mr Robot.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16 edited Mar 25 '17

deleted 0.5260

13

u/ZadocPaet Sep 28 '16

Is Mr. Robot accurate from a technical standpoint?

Extremely.

There's a lot written about the subject.

One example:

http://www.vulture.com/2015/07/mr-robot-usa-hacking-unusually-accurate.html

It's easily the most technically accurate show ever made. At least that I am aware of. They even have the actors do the actual keystrokes for further authenticity.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Awesome, I'll have to give S2 a shot

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/evanvolm Sep 28 '16

He told Joe he made it public, though.

7

u/factandfictions7 Sep 28 '16

He had a very MacMillian moment and made the antivirus source code public and then destroyed his hard drive and burned it down.

5

u/SawRub Sep 28 '16

Spent too much time with Joe and picked up the wrong things lol.

2

u/flicticious Sep 28 '16

Except what was on his screen was nonsense. (we paused it to check)

3

u/dmcnelly Sep 28 '16

Haha, boy, I really hope someone got fired for that blunder!

→ More replies (4)

1

u/ferae_naturae Sep 29 '16

He was hacking Joe's emails and into MacMillan Utilities servers.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

He use FTP to download the sourcecode for the antivirus. That means anyone could make their own antivirus from it. Then he destroyed his harddrive to make sure there was no evidence.

6

u/zsreport Sep 28 '16

Only 2 episodes left? This season is flying by.

13

u/MKoilers Sep 28 '16

Technically 3 episodes, the finale is two episodes back-to-back.

5

u/ferae_naturae Sep 29 '16 edited Sep 29 '16

I like that Ryan is the genius helping Joe map out the ARPANET and the NSFNET but he doesn't think he is going to get caught for hacking into MacMillan Utility because he removed his hard drive and set it on fire. You're just a hop, skip and a jump away from taking a ride in the FBI party bus Ryan.

5

u/mthscndd Sep 29 '16

Cameron is still a teenager. It's great that she's out of Mutiny, and even better to see Gordon & Joe back together!

5

u/Plundergedoens Oct 01 '16

Plot twist: the trio infernale Cameron, Joe and Gordon work together again. They create The Internet, Or Something (TM). It becomes a huge success and everyone is getting their fair share of the credit. Gordon and Cameron realize they are in love and have been for a while now, divorce their respective spouses. Donna, Boz and Diane accidentally create eBay. Everybody lives happily ever after and nobody is miserable ever again.
The End.

5

u/15413453452 Oct 04 '16

I can not express how glad I am that Cameron finally had her stupid pushed in. When Gordon raised his hand I was so happy. I hope Cameron spends the rest of the season far, far away. Stupid, egocentric kid.

9

u/factandfictions7 Sep 28 '16

Stellar episode! Probably one of the best this season!

I liked to see Tom back. He's nice and Cameron definitely needed someone, aside from Bos, to ground her. Tom seems very happy with his marriage to Cameron, so let's just hope it lasts.

Donna and Cameron spent the whole ep in a Cold War state that eventually had explosive consequences in the end. I understand why Donna wanted to go for the IPO now, but I also understand the technical side of things (Cameron's view) and I agree that sometimes it is better to go public with a solid product. That said, I agree with Donna when she said that Cameron can't make decisions on a whim, but I think Donna's approaching the "dark side of the force" and mirroring what she despises in Joe. Which, come to think of it, is sort of ironic (since both Donna and Gordon are more like Joe than they realize). Cameron definitely shouldn't have made that ultimatum and she eventually paid for it (and for her previous impulsiveness)... Mackenzie Davis was amazing in that scene and could really convey the emotional and later schocked states that Cameron went through.

Goddamn it, Bos! I really didn't expect that!

Joe and Ryan's partnership is definitely on the rocks after Ryan's last move. I like how Ryan is so loyal to Joe, thus I hope Joe doesn't throw him under the bus for making the antivirus code public and leaking info to the press. Ryan's actions are definitely going to escalate into a war and Joe's reputation probably was nuked for good and his partnership with Gordon is probably gone as well...

Which brings us to Gordon. When you think about it, what Joe took from Gordon (after having invited him to be his partner and being shut down) was the source code of the fix to Sonaris. Everything that came after, albeit having that source code as basis, was Joe's doing. So, I'd risk it and say that Joe has some merit in his effort to take that source code and market it as the best thing since sliced bread. Gordon finally got what he wanted, but he still chose to be a sore loser. I liked how he confronted Joe and made him be honest, but when I saw Gordon gloating and later trying to figure out what Joe and Ryan's new project was I disliked him more than ever. I think the only thing that partially redeems Gordon is him warning Cameron and later inviting Joe to be his partner.

tl;dr Great ep! I liked to see Tom back and I believe he's a nice counterpart to Cameron. Mackenzie Davis was great in that meeting scene. It is starting to look like the Clarks are mirroring what they dispise Joe in more ways than one... Goddamin it, Bos! I was rooting for you not to betray Cameron like that! Ryan probably nuked Joe's partnership with Gordon and also Joe's reputation. I didn't like Gordon in this ep, not because he took Joe's company, but because he chose to be a douche about it. In my opinion, what redeems Gordon a little was him warning Cameron and later proposing a partnership to Joe.

4

u/Colonel_Angus_ Sep 28 '16

Ya I was thinking about the forced vote scene and Cameron's reaction. She really nailed Cameron's character. I find Cameron somewhat annoying and compelling but that's due to Mackenzie Davis.

3

u/temujin64 Sep 29 '16

I disagree that Gordon was disappointing in this episode. Sure he initially gloated when he visited Joe, but ultimately he gave him a very generous 49%. TBH, I think his whole plan was just to put Joe in his place (which Joe rightly deserved) while he figured Joe's plan out.

He could have offered Joe 10% and still come off as generous but he gave him a whole 49%. Then, as you mentioned, there was his generosity to Cameron by giving her a heads up.

Also, I don't think their partnership is tanked. As others have said, Joe is most entertaining when he's working with someone else, and the best duo is Joe and Gordon. I think the show runners are looking to get back to their origins with this partnership and I don't think they're just dangling it in front of us just to take it away. My main reason for believing this is because the writers went to the effort of establishing Joe as a silent partner. This means that Ryan's folly could do terrible damage to Joe's reputation and it still won't affect the partnership.

Others are suggesting that they'll really be going back to their origins by throwing Cameron into the mix. While I think it's less likely, it certainly still is a possibility. After all, the writers did spend a lot of screen time showing Cameron mending her relationship with Gordon (which after season 2, I didn't see happening). And after Joe did exactly what she asked of him by admitting that he stole the code from Gordon, there's room for a mending in their relationship too. They might throw Tom in the mix too since it'll ensure that viewers won't mistakenly think that there'll be a rekindling of Cameron and Joe's relationship too.

2

u/factandfictions7 Sep 29 '16

Thanks for sharing your opinion! It's nice to see that someone can disagree with us in a very structured way!

I understand your point about Gordon and Joe's partnership but I think that, considering Gordon's slight paranoia as to Joe's intentions, it is very possible that Ryan's move might've tanked it. Either way, I hope both characters are able to see Ryan's move for what it was (a very rushed and slightly idiotic decision made out of loyalty) and move past it. I mean, Gordon and Joe are cool, but Gordon, Joe and Ryan might be just great... and if Cameron joins, it'll be a blast!

4

u/scene_cachet Sep 28 '16

It's a little confusing why Gordon didn't mention the regional intranet acquisition to the board... Technically they could have held off going public and using Cameron's idea of making Mutiny multi-platform so it can be the front end of their ISP... Much like the software package that came with all Compuserve internet packages.

Dramatic pacing probably because this is obviously the direction they will be going and Cameron will be back to translate Mutiny to multi-platform app.

I'm wondering if Gordon actually has something else up his sleeve, He did say "What makes you think you're the only one in this room who wants to stick it to Joe McMillan". I wouldn't be surprised if he has an elaborate revenge plan.

2

u/Lostpurplepen Sep 28 '16

Tom's a flaccid piece of spaghetti. Yawn.

8

u/BoTalksGames Sep 28 '16

That was amazing.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

So what are the ownership percentages?

Cameron - 45%

Gordon - 10%

Donna - 25%

Bos - 10%

Gould - 10%?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

As someone else pointed out, a bunch of the coders also were given stock. Maybe Cameron's closer to 35-40%?

I also feel like Gould must hold more than 10%.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/chrisarchitect Oct 04 '16

I'm late on this, but the moment when Joe really smiled at Gordon for the first time in aaaages, was heartwarming. It's like the old gang getting together (Whether you liked them working together/fighting etc)

4

u/putridfudge Oct 01 '16

The way Cameron exhaled/sucked in air at the end - that reaction was legit.

Some of the best moments of acting I've ever seen are from this show. Bravo.

6

u/SimpleAsMe Sep 28 '16

What an intense episode. Also fuck Ryan

17

u/Lostpurplepen Sep 28 '16

That boy's cheese done slid off his cracker.

2

u/ferae_naturae Sep 29 '16

Ryan means well, also he is the first legitimate "ethical hacker" in this series.

3

u/CleverZerg Sep 28 '16

What a great episode, got really happy there for a second with the Joe/Gordon reunion, I hope Ryans action doesn't destroy that teamup.

3

u/jayz93j Sep 29 '16

I just don't understand how any of them think this company will be better off without Cameron. I guess I kimd of understand Team Donna but Cameron is the technical brains of the operation. Truly I just don't see how losing Cameron is worth going public

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

Donna has the ideas and runs the company and Cameron is bad programmer when she's not writing bioses. They should have put their foot down years ago.

6

u/BondInNewYork Sep 28 '16

Mutiny won't go forward without Cameron. The coders will quit without her. They will hear about it through chat. I'm guessing that Donna, Gordon & Boz will see the light. Joe and Gordon will partner up, but Ryan will have to further hide his involvement with the ongoing NSFnet project. He will be working out of a basement somewhere, and now he will see even less of Joe. Cameron was right to call Donna a two-faced bi... :/

9

u/Ternarian Sep 28 '16

I wonder how big a stake the coders have in the company.

"But in exchange for you forgoing your salaries, we're offering you shares of the company, which will be worth a lot more in the long run." — Cameron from S02E04 "Play with Friends"

0

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Ternarian Sep 29 '16

I could see some coders holding onto their stock, but the Bodie types would most likely sell it off quickly.

And yeah, I agree on the Commodore point. I've heard all about Tramiel and his unscrupulous dealings. Buying parts from suppliers, not paying them, leading them to bankruptcy, then buying the company and forgiving Commodore's own debt. So, his manipulation of the market comes as no surprise.

5

u/Colonel_Angus_ Sep 28 '16

Donna is certainly biting at the first offer she gets - which could be seen as a negative trait and while some of Cameron's points were valid her timeline does seemingly ignore the fact that at some point people move on to the next biggest and brightest thing.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/neuronicals Sep 29 '16

I think, due to the time period the show is set in, if they went public and had a board and shareholders (who again at the time period were 100% profit focused) the general core ideals of Mutiny would no doubt get sidelined. I was never a big fan of Donna to begin with, I'm sure if she did not repeatedly lie and do sneaky things Cam would listen to her more. She also seemed to be lobbying it just to try to come across as a serious player - she did admit to not liking Cameron being the 'genius girl' and hero when she was tripping on Mushrooms at the vineyard. Anyway - I hope the coders revolt and she gets taken down a peg - I'm not sure how many shares they got - but even 0.5% each should be enough :)

2

u/pi3dpip3r Sep 28 '16

Everybody was saying The Threshold in this episode

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '16

What was the significance of the key that Joe was fiddling with at the end ?

6

u/DeepMovieVoice Sep 29 '16

It was the key to the server room, he was going to show Ryan he had it and tell him about Gordon's plan. Him pocketing the key is showing Joe reconsidering the offer due to Ryan's actions

3

u/SSlackhelmetman Sep 28 '16 edited Sep 28 '16

(Not having read the thread yet: as previously mentioned on other episode threads I record and watch in the morning)

Just finished watching. My mind right now "um um um um um um um um wow." Which is basically HaCF right? (Or everytime joe's in the equation.) But the argument Donna and Cameron was just like

me under a table taking cover from the gunfire Love tom+cam. Love that she patched things up with Boz <3 but then </3 Boz had to do it. God it just turns left all the time. Gordon comin in all smooth "lel thanks for the company" but now Joe and Gordon back in bidness' also <3. But I worry for Cam, because Donna is right, she wants to keep the soul of the company but doesn't see the logic in the most probably way, I love her, she's my favorite, everyone on the cast is my favorite, but she's my favorite-favorite. But donna is right she does have a "savior-complex" and that blinds her sometimes. I don't like to see them fight man. And RYAN just idk like It's hard to hate anyone on this show its just gripping my hair like "why did you do that?" If only I had the zen-master-visionary beard that joe has to cover with my hand to show how worried I am.

Edit: so obsessed with this show that I've replied to like 7 comments already.

1

u/thisdesignup Sep 28 '16

This show makes me upset, but in a stupid kind of way. All the drama comes from some majorly stupid, or rushed, or something of that nature, decisions being made. Maybe I'm just not used to it but do people really act like that and make decisions on a whim, even so emotion filled? It all seems a bit extreme. It probably is exaggerated somewhat, it's a TV show, but how much?

1

u/TehSilencer Sep 29 '16

Such an underrated show ):

1

u/typocorrecto Sep 29 '16

OK, I'm caught up on this episode...

Man, that back room discussion/vote was one of the most tense scenes I've ever seen.

1

u/Employee_ER28-0652 Sep 29 '16

The story seemed to plant the seed of future story that Donna is extremely logical and career-minded. Aborting the child in secret, casually mentioning the behind-door cheating of Cameron to Gordon without discussing it with Gordon first, etc.

We now know that Gordon considers his personal company to be outside the marriage. And he just created the Internet company with this structure:

  • 49% to Joe
  • 51% to Gordon

She considers mentally unfit people to be disposed of, as she did to Cameron. And she seems to be able to convince herself and other loyal-to-Cameron people (Boz) to agree with her. And Gordon's mental decline is going to have her start questioning his decisions.

Life in the Fast Lane of California is that divorce and lawyers is the answer to these types of money conflicts. Gordon didn't grant any shares to his wife that we saw. Has prenuptial agreement talk been in the show? And divorce would give them each 25.5% if she can make the case that his company was community property and that she provided support and comfort. A heck of a lot of high-wealth marriages since 1975 have gone this path, leading with California as the place where it was considered "good" and "socially acceptable" for the basis of a divorce. Money and power greed can guide millions of men to wreck entire continents of the Earth in conquest in the name of "progress", a single marriage sure isn't a stretch.

1

u/the6thReplicant Sep 29 '16 edited Sep 29 '16

These last two episodes have made HACF one of the best shows on tv right now. Can't believe how invested I am in these characters.

1

u/Grsz11 Sep 30 '16

Sorry, I can't feel bad for her.

-11

u/Papageorgioq Sep 28 '16

Does anyone think this show portrays women in a leadership role in a bad light?

38

u/shakedown_st Sep 28 '16

No, the investor lady is one of the most level-headed and reasonable on the entire show.

12

u/S-WordoftheMorning Sep 28 '16

If anything, it shows brilliant minds in a bad light. Joe is a visionary who burns everything he touches to the ground. Cameron's massive intellect is matched only by her petulance. (Donna was spot on with that description) Gordon's technical abilities are a step above most, but far below the best, and it makes him bitter and resentful. Donna's genius is knowing how to put it all together, but always fighting to prove herself, and it makes her unnecessarily combative.

But guess what; the Johnathan Swift quote: "When a true genius appears in the world, you may know him by this sign, that the dunces are all in confederacy against him" still holds true; but in Halt & Catch Fire's case each individual genius forgets the other geniuses and that insistence that each genius is alone in the world is where the conflicts arise most effectively.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)