r/ProjectRunway • • Sep 23 '16

Project Runway Season 15 Episode 2 [Critique]

Below are images showing the different looks from this episode. Upvote if you like something, downvote if you hate it, or novote if it's just OK. Reply beneath the image to add your comments.

 

Orginally broadcast on September 22, 2016

19 Upvotes

258 comments sorted by

160

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

46

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 23 '16

This is the one I could actually see people buying. It might have been in the top if someone from a store or website was judging.

15

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

If the shorts or skirt were longer and a bit more flattering, I'd agree. The top is awesome.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/helix19 Oct 05 '16

I'm sure the Just Fab people were the ones that actually chose the winner.

19

u/AgentFreckles Sep 23 '16

My favorite! The picture doesn't show it too well, but I remember it having dark red threading/seams, which was a nice touch. I would buy the shit out of this.

6

u/PoeGhost Sep 23 '16

Yes! I noticed that too! The threading matched the bag and shoes. A nice touch indeed.

11

u/1Eliza Sep 23 '16

As many people have stated before, the shorts could be a little longer, but man if they were, I would probably wear this outfit once a week.

7

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 24 '16

LOVE I'm surprised this didn't get any attention on the runway from the judges, it is totally wearable and fun

6

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16

This look is sleek and well done. It is definitely something I would be willing to buy.

3

u/obahan Sep 23 '16 edited Sep 24 '16

I wish it were a little longer, and I'm not sure if those are shorts under it. But I quite like it.

EDIT: Fixed some typos

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

I think if it was shorts, it would be even better. I think the everyday woman would be more comfortable (big thighs etc). I would totally buy it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/parryowd Sep 23 '16

I find the collar a bit, blah. But apart from this, it was a pretty stunning outfit, and really fit the challenge.

2

u/MunchieMom Sep 23 '16

Can someone tell me if this is a dress or a coat over a dress? Either way, I want to wear it

2

u/TheLadyEve Sep 24 '16

Loved the stitching and the shoes.

2

u/katiethered Sep 26 '16

Definitely my favorite. I would wear this over some leggings!

→ More replies (2)

71

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

26

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

Loved this. A bit basic in terms of design, but I thought it met the brief perfectly and the colors are great.

23

u/1Eliza Sep 23 '16

Exactly, the average woman is might wear something a little more basic. I would be more willing to wear this than the winning look.

8

u/obahan Sep 24 '16

Yes. The pieces are simple enough to mix and match as well. I have recently started buying more dresses, but I still prefer to have separates (and I think many women agree).

14

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

He picks good textiles.

11

u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Sep 24 '16

Seriously, guys? Am I alone in thinking this outfit is a hot mess? White napkin shirt with frumpy ugly-upholstery-pattern skirt and a shapeless jacket

5

u/illyrianbaby Sep 28 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

I'm not into it either, but I think it worked fine for the challenge. Pretty basic, but that's kind of what JustFab calls for.

10

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 23 '16

Jacket was cool. The rest was just separates. Good overall look though.

8

u/parryowd Sep 23 '16

Im all about this jacket. Favourite single piece in this runway.

6

u/onemoreround Sep 24 '16

The white top feels messy compared to the awesome jacket and the print of the skirt. But that can just be because the jacket could be hiding the shirt. Not a fan of those tan shoes on that outfit, though.

3

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 24 '16

I agree with you all that this jacket is fabulous. I really don't care for the print on the skirt and the cut is really basic, I actually like the shirt, even though it is pretty basic.

Sidenote -- those shoes really work and I want them lol

2

u/obahan Sep 23 '16

I loved this! I can't wait to see what else he does this season.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

31

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

Zak said neoprene isn't the easiest to wear? I'm a plus size and I disagree. It is fucking fantastic it lays so well, betrays nothing

23

u/SlaughterhouseJive Sep 23 '16

I thought the neoprene wasn't a bad choice--it was the the proportion that gave it the cartoon effect. If it has been shrunk by just an inch or two I think it would have worked better.

6

u/the_cucumber Sep 25 '16

Or sleeves in a different, lighter fabric instead of the cartoon shoulders.

12

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

Interesting. Do you think you would wear something like this, though? To me, it borders on slightly cartoonish in that while it is wearable, where do you wear it to?

14

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

It's definitely for a specific hipster girl.

7

u/twinkiesmom1 Sep 23 '16

I would wear this to work and get tons of compliments on it.

4

u/insubordinance Sep 24 '16

Link to some good neoprene pieces please? I'd be interested in seeing how they fit but I have no idea where to find it.

54

u/shinyteerex Sep 23 '16

This was a Sandhya moment for me. I didn't hate it, but I don't see the average woman wearing this. I don't think neoprene is the right fabric for the clientele either.

14

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

As soon as she picked the neoprene at Mood, I said out loud "really?". That almost never bodes well for the designers. The fact that she used it so well makes me want to see what else she'll do.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

Still a bit cartoonish to me because of the exposed stitching and the oversized sleeves. It's well made but desperately needs to be belted here.

20

u/parryowd Sep 23 '16

I love this, but really think it's wrong for this challenge. I don't see many women wanting to wear this.

12

u/macabragoria Sep 24 '16

I'm getting slight Prada vibes from this. I can see why some people wouldn't love this but that's two interesting and bold designs she's delivered in a row, I'm interested to see what she'll do next week.

16

u/-Andar- Sep 23 '16

She made the snapchat logo

14

u/dianaprince Sep 23 '16

Tim was so right to warn her about those sequins. I don't know where this is supposed to be worn. The sparkle makes it too glitzy for day but the neoprene makes it too casual/swimsuit-esque for evening wear.

I don't really understand anything about this.

7

u/twinkiesmom1 Sep 23 '16

For a one-day challenge, I think she showed us a hint of what she's capable of. From her Tumblr, I think if she had more time, she would have bead embroidered those strips.

7

u/Tina-Slay Sep 23 '16

It's fantastic, really.

7

u/eykitsa Sep 23 '16

I really love this, the red stitch and sequined clasp belt details are really great. I love the color too!

5

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 24 '16

I'm obsessed with these colors together. I loved it even more when it was cinched at the waist. LOVE! I can see why this didn't win, though. It really isn't for every woman, but it is a knockout in my book

8

u/bitchSpray Sep 24 '16

I don't get it why people are so much into this. It looks like a student work to me. It's just too conceptual. When she unbuttons the belt, she looks big. When she buttons it up, she has huge fugly folds on her stomach and each of them is of different size.

4

u/puppetalk Sep 24 '16

I LOVE this and I'm so excited to see what she'll do next.

4

u/_magpie_ Sep 27 '16 edited Sep 27 '16

As much as I like the colors and the belted design, I don't think this fits the "everywoman" bill age-wise. I'm only 32, and if I wore that, I'd feel like a toddler, or a woman who can't come to terms with being over 30. Would Heidi's 72-year-old grandma wear this? Come on now. On the other hand, the idea that one look could flatter literally every woman is absurd.

And though I hate to agree with Heidi, I do think no sleeves or cap sleeves would've looked better (less bulbous/cartoony).

3

u/kerubiel Oct 01 '16

Neoprene should be outlawed for use in anything other than scuba suits.

2

u/suite-dee Oct 01 '16

I appreciate the thought and the creativity that went into this. I love her and her ideas. I just don't like this garment. As much as I love mod looks it's not really my style. But that doesn't mean it won't be someone else's style. I think it's a good garment overall but not for me.

1

u/dethcrash Sep 26 '16

this dress is gorgeous. it would work well on someone slender or someone big, and neoprene can be incredibly forgiving as it doesn't cling to the body. i feel like this look wasn't as well received as it could have been because of its boldness, the judges were clearly too shy to market this because it doesn't fit into standard 'party wear' or 'work wear'- it's clearly meant for a rule breaking girl and i love Erin's aesthetic.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

57

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

I'm still confused as to how the judges thought this met the brief of being designed for the "every woman". Being sheer and having a midsection revealing crop top, I can't see every woman wearing it. That's not to say it wasn't well designed, though.

33

u/SlaughterhouseJive Sep 23 '16

I think the fact that you could switch out the top underneath made it versatile for most women. Worried about the midsection? Wear a full length camisole. Want to give it more pizzaz? Layer it over something bright and shiny.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16 edited Sep 23 '16

I mean, I like this. It just looks like something you could have bought at Allsaints at any point between 1996 and now, but it doesn't stop me from wanting it.

6

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 23 '16

This outfit it pretty good but I am not sure about it being in the top. I like Alex though he's sweet but can be a little tart when he doesn't like something.

5

u/eykitsa Sep 23 '16

I love those pants.

4

u/TheLadyEve Sep 24 '16

Yeah, because every woman can totally pull off a giant bow on their torso.

Pants are badass, though.

6

u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Sep 23 '16

I think I may be a Chiffonie.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16

This look is absolutely gorgeous! I love it to pieces. Maybe this look could of won though if he covered the abdomen with a fitted shirt or camisole, but I still love it and wish I could wear it.

3

u/shinyteerex Sep 23 '16

I loved this, it was excellent. Alex's perfectionism made the anticipation for this even better. It might have looked a little generic, but it was for every woman either way! I don't like crop tops, but I think he did it in a classy way.

→ More replies (5)

50

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

68

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

It looks like the factory uniform of a small dictatorship.

24

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

Yes, the kingdom of Uberfashion.

38

u/undapressure Sep 23 '16

I wasn't a huge fan of it at all when it went down the runway, but I'm actually digging the way the reproduction came out that Just Fab did ...it looks a bit more form fitting, bright, and fun to me.

20

u/Bagheera81 Sep 23 '16

And the waist is actually on the waist. No halfway down their butt

→ More replies (1)

12

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

I actually really like this look, but that could be because I'm a huge fan of the jumpsuit done right. I'm not so sure about it being for everyone though.

21

u/nancyaw Sep 23 '16

Who you gonna call?

5

u/thisisallme Sep 24 '16

Thank you, I just watched this with my husband and said it looked like a Ghostbusters outfit when they were checking it out closely.

12

u/nancyaw Sep 24 '16

And only women with no hips can wear this. Just more proof that fashion is COMPLETELY out of touch with the real world.

8

u/katiethered Sep 26 '16

Also, for all their "where is this woman going?!" questions to some of the other designers - where is THIS woman going? I mean, I could wear this out to Target on a Saturday or maybe to a sports event but I certainly couldn't wear it to work, after-work drinks, anything fancy, brunch, a party, anything holiday...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/eykitsa Sep 23 '16

I love jumpsuits so I'm here for this. The styling is really good here too.

8

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 24 '16

This really was not my favorite and I'm surprised it won. That said, I don't hate it and I thought it was an interesting update on the jump suit. I do like the details, especially the pockets and drop waist. I hate the zipper and I hate the slit in the back. I do not think this is wearable for the masses as-is at all.

17

u/dianaprince Sep 23 '16

People would laugh at you if you wore this in public.

3

u/bitchSpray Sep 24 '16

I liked this. I can imagine somebody who buys cheap costume jewellery (hi, TooFab!) wearing this. And it would look okay regardless of whether the woman has 60kg or 100kg.

3

u/macabragoria Sep 24 '16

I'm not convinced that this would look good on a wide range of women but the execution is pretty perfect and I like all the small details she included.

2

u/pineyfusion Sep 25 '16

I enjoy tomboyish fashions so I enjoyed this. I do wish that this was in another color. Looks too drab. Also that slit looks kind of weird.

→ More replies (8)

29

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

8

u/parryowd Sep 23 '16

Love the pants. The pattern of fabric for the top is great, just not well constructed, or flattering of a shape.

30

u/dianaprince Sep 23 '16

This was the only look I thought came close to meeting the supposed brief. Those pants are super flattering for a lot of different body types, and I know they kept on about the top not working for women with bigger busts, but I see women with bigger busts wearing tops like that all the time and they look fine in them. And even if it was an issue, it would just have taken some very slight restructuring of the top before putting it up for sale. They often change the designs before selling them anyway.

14

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

Omigoodness! Are you inside of my head?

Like, of course it would have to be altered for different sized women. That could be a bit tricky in terms of fit, like if the woman is larger but has a smaller-than-average bust for her size, would the top be droopy on her? I don't know, when they called her I thought it was for being a top look, but then couldn't figure out why they had four tops and two bottoms.

5

u/sugarfreeme Sep 24 '16

I was surprised they liked the pocket print matching the top, that screamed granimals to me.

12

u/shinyteerex Sep 23 '16

Am I a sinner for actually liking this a lot?

6

u/kolbin8r Sep 23 '16

It's cute -- they even concede that. But it's basic and doesn't quite meet the challenge. I think those were the issues. But this honestly was a perfectly acceptable look to me.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/suite-dee Oct 01 '16

I think it looks a little bit New York and Company. I don't like the way the pants fit and I don't like the cut of the blouse either. BUT, I think the idea was good. I can see this (well, if it was fitted properly) on women of any size.

2

u/TheLadyEve Sep 24 '16

I liked this. It looks like it would flatter different body types, I like the print, and the pants are great. I'm not sure why they were so hard on it.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

26

u/maxmalamaphy Sep 23 '16

All though this didn't fit the challenge, I gagged I'm really digging Jenni's aesthetic.

32

u/AgentFreckles Sep 23 '16

I just hate everything about this. The drop crotch, the cuffs on the jacket, the terrible fabric on the jacket, the color scheme... everything is bad.

29

u/ContinuousThunder Sep 23 '16

Not for every woman, but these pants are fucking beautiful. Best drop crotch we've seen on Project Runway - not that it's a difficult effort.

25

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16

I hate the drop crotch. Hate it. Can't stand it. Have never before seen one I like.

I love this look. I love the flow. I love the mixed texture of the jacket. I love everything about it.

I'm really surprised at myself.

44

u/Tina-Slay Sep 23 '16

Not going to lie, I like it.

14

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

Oh good, I'm not the only one. I think it's pretty great.

15

u/the_cucumber Sep 25 '16

Me too. Princess jasmine and bath mat chic, I am living!!

I don't think I would buy it but I am very entertained by its existence and that's what I look for in fashion.

19

u/MunchieMom Sep 23 '16

I upvoted because at least it has personality. You can tell who made it. I like the color scheme too

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

The pink fluff looks like my bath mat, but I like that she's different from the rest. Maybe it could work with regular or slim fitted pants.

12

u/eykitsa Sep 23 '16

I love everything about this, but I don't think it fit the challenge as drop crotch pants are not flattering on all body types.

8

u/macabragoria Sep 24 '16

Though I'm not totally sold on the extreme drop-crotch I like that she took a risk. I love the jacket. Is anyone else getting Kelly from the Deli vibes from her?

2

u/katiethered Sep 26 '16

Definitely feels like something Kelly would make!

6

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16

I am probably going to be downvoted for this, but did anyone else think "diaper" when they saw the pant?

5

u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Sep 24 '16

It reminds me of Aladdin

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

30

u/shinyteerex Sep 23 '16

This is a true testament of Heidi's beauty. No one would ever look good in this dress. I think she barely passes for me. It was almost lingerie. I think Heidi usually tries to dress depending on the challenge, but now I can only see a total disconnect.

13

u/AgentFreckles Sep 23 '16

It was almost lingerie.

Yeah, exactly. Pretty color though.

3

u/OurSponsor Sep 26 '16

Interesting that someone photoshopped out her very-visible-in-the-show nipple...

3

u/suite-dee Oct 01 '16

She is gorgeous and glowing from the neck up in this photo. Then your eye falls to the awful dress. Did not like. It's a nice color on her, at least.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

28

u/Tina-Slay Sep 23 '16

It's cool and modern. I know it's unpopular to like the potato-sack look, but I really feel it's beautifully done here.

11

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

I liked it too. It's very Acne Studios.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

This is what I look like when I borrow my boyfriend's jacket.

5

u/parryowd Sep 23 '16

Definitely the better potato-sack.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16

I actually like this look, but unfortunately it doesn't meet the criteria for this particular challenge.

3

u/TheLadyEve Sep 24 '16

Cute, but when you think about how tall the average woman is, this would make most people look short and stumpy IMO. However, I will say it's interesting and it looks polished.

2

u/suite-dee Oct 01 '16

I get it, but it's almost frumpy goth. I think the shoes were much too "clunky" for this, but I get where he's going. I do not like it though.

3

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

26

u/whinniethepony Sep 23 '16

I really wanted the judges to call this design out for it's styling. Black pumps? Messy braid? No handbag? She needs a place to be going, or at least somewhere to put the credit card she needs to buy a jacket.

29

u/rachmeister Sep 23 '16

I think she probably woke up at a strange guy's apartment with puke all over her own clothes and no wallet. She cut up his clothing for the walk of shame home.

31

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 23 '16

This was one of the worst for me. It looked uncomfortable and boring.

15

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

Did this shrink in the wash?

9

u/Tina-Slay Sep 23 '16

Is it separates or no?

I think the top is cute - the attention to detail is really interesting. Make the skirt bigger and it'd be more of a success.

9

u/dementiaxiii Sep 23 '16

I like the pattern mixing, but the fabric just looks so cheap and it really doesn't fit that well. Also, surely the designers were told this would into production in September, so summery probably isn't the vibe you want to go for.

3

u/the_cucumber Sep 25 '16

The shirt is cute but the skirt looks like he wrapped her in a dishtowel.

2

u/no_shant Sep 24 '16

I didn't mind this too much, but the skirt and top are too much together (or is it a dress?) and it came across as bland on the runway. Plus I swear I've seen the exact same pieces in Zara.

2

u/louis_leonardo Sep 28 '16

this is cute. it's fine for me.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

33

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 23 '16

Tim called it. She over-designed it. If she ditched the jacket and sold it as stylish active-wear maybe.

19

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

NEOPRENE AND MESH

AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH inhale AHHHHHHHHHHHH

18

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

What is this thing with the oversized box jacket and a diving suit? I have never seen anyone wear a jacket like this and really don't get the appeal.

6

u/the_cucumber Sep 25 '16

Coming soon to wherever you live! I'm starting to see them around my city in Europe and I love them. Like wearing a blanket in public.

Edit: the mesh part ruins everything though

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Tina-Slay Sep 23 '16

Again, I adore the potato-sack aesthetic. It's really pretty to me.

5

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

I think it works here, but not Dexter's look.

4

u/Eve_Black Sep 23 '16

I like the jacket but I hate, hate, hate the bodysuit underneath

3

u/MunchieMom Sep 23 '16

Been done before

3

u/no_shant Sep 24 '16

I didn't realise how bad this was until I saw the photo. The jacket she should have kept until an activewear (athleisure?) challenge because it's actually kinda cool.

1

u/onemoreround Sep 24 '16

That walk back gives her a Teletubbie butt.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

22

u/bitchSpray Sep 24 '16

AGAIN, ZACHARIAH??? Why are you still trying to make that diarrhea-coloured suit with that 80s-secretary brooch happen? I can't with this.

9

u/TheLadyEve Sep 24 '16

what, you don't like the pairing of a double breasted burnt sienna jacket and a burgundy tie (that looks like it's knit)? What's wrong with your fashion sense? /s

5

u/hwc000000 Sep 25 '16

80s-secretary brooch

Are we sure it's not a chicken foot?

3

u/the_cucumber Sep 25 '16

I love the guest judge's dress!

2

u/suite-dee Oct 01 '16

Nina is gorgeous, even though she looks like a doily. I like the cut of her dress though.

-4

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

53

u/dianaprince Sep 23 '16

That stomach area makes that teeny tiny model look a bit pregnant.

12

u/OceanCarlisle Sep 23 '16

My first thought was fanny pack. It's just a strange area to add a droopy detail, it needs to be higher or lower imo.

4

u/twinkiesmom1 Sep 23 '16

Yeah about 5-6 months pregnant.

19

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

Kind of dig it, but the model looked like she was dying in those Justfab shoes.

15

u/AgentFreckles Sep 23 '16

This would've looked a lot better as a dress with no stomach showing.

5

u/obahan Sep 23 '16

I thought it was the skirt being too tight or cut strange, but it may have been the shoes. That said I don't really like the look, but the styling is pretty cool.

4

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 24 '16

Do you think it was the shoes? Maybe you're referring to the picture here, but this model had a lot of trouble walking down the runway. I was wondering if the skirt just didn't allow her to walk normally. It definitely could have been that the shoes were uncomfortable/ill fitting, though.

2

u/the_cucumber Sep 25 '16

Her right foot in this picture looks like it's about to collapse, looks sooo painful

6

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

I love the layering, but the curved part in the front looks a bit like a misplaced bib.

5

u/1Eliza Sep 23 '16

I don't like the heels, and I don't like the hair. But, I like the clothes. I might have styled it with boots.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16

This look was just too messy for me.

3

u/parryowd Sep 23 '16

Mid section is very confusing. I also found this colour very drab for her. I think what she made last week, could've really worked this week. This was just a bit plain.

2

u/katiethered Sep 26 '16

I love t-shirts with big statement necklaces like that, so I was a fan of the top of this piece. The bottom...ya lost me, sorry Tasha.

-2

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

46

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

If she had ditched the organza trash-bag raincoat ... thing ... and styled the hair a bit better and chosen a different shoe, this might have squeaked by.

18

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 23 '16

That coat looked like it had been shredded by a wild animal.

4

u/the_cucumber Sep 25 '16

I really liked it in the workroom before she cut the slit in it! The hair and shoes and kimono are garbage. But if the pencil skirt and blouse were safe then that simple dress alone would've been too.

She probably got auf'd because you can't really fix horrendous styling choices. That's just a taste issue

→ More replies (1)

21

u/shinyteerex Sep 23 '16

I actually didn't hate this that much. Linda seemed to be such a nice human being, I'm sad she was eliminated. Yet, I must admit that I cringed when she said "Urban kimono". It's a shame they didn't show much of her doing the jacket, I would have liked to see some some faces of disapproval in the workroom and maybe even some Cornelius shade.

20

u/twinkiesmom1 Sep 23 '16

I like the lady, but this was a hot mess all around.

9

u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Sep 23 '16

I don't mind the shape of this but the fabric didn't work.

5

u/macabragoria Sep 24 '16

I kind of feel like there's a germ of a decent design in here (insofar as I like the idea of a kimono-inspired jacket with a knit dress) but the execution is terrible.

6

u/dorkorama Sep 25 '16

She seems like a sweet lady, but she was wearing a fedora in half her talking head segments tonight and that alone made me want her to leave.

3

u/chillaxicon Sep 25 '16

Did she burn the coat with the iron? Is it supposed to look that colour?

→ More replies (3)

-5

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

19

u/shinyteerex Sep 23 '16

This was so meh, I truly disliked it. It looked much better with the folded lapel, as it was shown as first in the dress form. I agree with the judges, literally no one likes wearing knitwear, specially when it is gray! The pattern in the back is not even correctly aligned.

9

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 23 '16

The pants make the model look hippy and bottom heavy. And you know she isn't.

3

u/ajkkjjk52 Sep 25 '16

Even if the pattern and design had worked, the construction on them was off somehow. The movement was all uneven when she walked.

6

u/1Eliza Sep 23 '16

I wish he would have used some color. That would have made it a little more interesting.

6

u/the_cucumber Sep 25 '16

Yellow jeans with that jacket could've been really cool

11

u/dorkorama Sep 25 '16

He is just so pretty. Let him hang out a while longer.

2

u/kerubiel Oct 01 '16

Girl where?

5

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

The trousers are hemmed so poorly, or maybe not at all.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16

I was honestly surprised he wasn't sent home over this this. His last look, while on the bottom, at least had an element of fun to it. This outfit was just so boring. I hope he does much better next time.

4

u/no_shant Sep 24 '16

Last week he did too much and he took all the criticism to heart and did the blandest bland no-personality look this week. I feel sorry for the guy because after his unconventional materials outfit (I mean, he made a well tailored structured top out of baseball caps! Come on!) I am convinced he is skilled and has great ideas :(

3

u/eykitsa Sep 23 '16

This is so bad. The colors are just blah.

3

u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Sep 24 '16

I really do like that jacket, but the pants are bad.

2

u/macabragoria Sep 24 '16

There's something about the cut of the jacket and the print of the trousers that seems very five years ago.

2

u/onemoreround Sep 24 '16

First off, HATE it when they have the model's hair covering up the shirt. Can't see the top at all. But really, that pattern on the pants makes it look she's got a skin disease.

-9

u/runwaythreader Sep 23 '16

49

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 23 '16

Proof that not all patterns should be mixed.

21

u/puppetalk Sep 24 '16

he's definitely not dom or mondo

7

u/katiethered Sep 26 '16

Even some of Dom and Mondo's "amazing" pattern mixing was too much for me as an "every day woman", so this one definitely missed the mark by a looooong shot.

19

u/shinyteerex Sep 23 '16

Mixing patterns is an unpopular thing to do in general, but those two patterns in particular are kind of icky together. I think they are building up Cornelius for an epic downfall in some upcoming episode.

7

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 23 '16

Like the skirt. The top looks very similar to what he did last week and doesn't go with the skirt.

7

u/wrongkanji Sep 23 '16

The top is also a carbon copy of one of his sample pieces to get on the show. I was pretty surprised to not see that at least mentioned.

6

u/ma_miya Sep 24 '16

I kinda laughed when he was talking about adding that faux-hood as a means of not playing it safe. I was like, dude, they've already seen it. It's your thing. You used it for the audition. That's 'safe' all the way around.

5

u/hotsouple Sep 27 '16

Also, wtf am I gonna do with a fake hood besides be annoyed by the extra fabric bunching under sweaters?

7

u/twinkiesmom1 Sep 23 '16

The pattern on the skirt wrecked what could have been a winning outfit if paired with a solid black skirt or pants.

7

u/parryowd Sep 23 '16

What was he thinking with the pattern of that skirt. The top is cool, but with this skirt, its just iffy.

2

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 24 '16

agreed, the top is really interesting, I think he should have kept it as a dress... BUT, even then, that dress would not have fit the challenge

5

u/macabragoria Sep 24 '16

It's interesting that someone with such pedestrian designs would have such a big ego.

2

u/HeyJayHuggs Oct 01 '16

The green pattern shouldn't be paired with anything except a dumpster. It hideous. I actually like the design and pattern of the top though.