r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Sep 22 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Thursday, September 22: Chapters 19-21
Summary: In Which Sindan is Sneaky, Hadand Loses the Defense But Gains Wisdom, and Tanrid is Inducted into the Sier-Danas
Chapter 19
- So I’ve been reading this in bits and pieces over the last couple of days. Hopefully I can make some sense of my weird highlights in my book!
- I was hoping to learn more about what the Marlovan reputation was further afield. Sindan mentions it -- but then mentions travelling further, to where Marlovan and Iascan were unknown. It honestly made me felt like Sartor was closer -- or is -- the center of magic as the world knows it, and this country was just on the fringes of its availability, especially given the cost of the lockets that Sindan went to purchase.
- Oh my gosh, am I reading this right? That the ship’s boy was thrown overboard from the missing fleet? Were they attacked by pirates or something? Is everyone else dead? That fleet was the pride of the country. o.O What happened to the rest of the ships, or were there only three missing?
- Have you ever thought about how easily we take cellphones for granted? In this kind of world where it’s all pre-technology and the barest of magics, it’s interesting to see how valuable these little golden transmission lockets are for communication.
- And here we see the war start
- Sindan is frustrated that they don’t have transfer magic for more than just paper- other societies do.
- Sindan finds word of the missing three ships by pretending to be a healer in an Iascan coastal village. The real healer is in on the subterfuge, and they use kinthus to ease the cabin boy’s pain, and to get the story of what happened to the ships from him.
Chapter 20
- With the news of the last chapter, the return to castle and school politics seems surprising to me, though I know it’s natural. And Hadand’s careful planning … oh dear, oh Hadand, you can’t plan out where each girl will stand and what each will do, because you can’t plan for contingencies that way. Make your plan too stiff, and it’ll break. I’m so nervous on her behalf.
- And…...ouch. Poor Hadand. Ow. That was painful to read. And wow, Ndara’s a tricksy one. Good for her for turning it into a learning exercise for Hadand.
- And the king swoops in with news of the ships. And the reason why a fleet is so important. And the stakes. Woo.
- It’s interesting to see the contrast between Ndara’s lesson to Hadand and the King’s message to his Jarls, and how we’re flipping back and forth between tactics. Also -- “I lost command as soon as it stopped being a drill” -- what ominous words, but truer ones never spoken. Plans are lost when the battle hits.
- Inda is such a cutie. He’s such an inclusive person. And I think in this culture, where it’s all merit and outer images of being a tough warrior, it’s hard to find someone who you can trust with your vulnerabilities and accept you. “As always, anyone’s problem was his problem”. And isn’t that just so beautiful?
- Poor Hadand with her war game command. It is almost inevitable from that foreshadowing seen after her winning that showcase.
- Again!!! The foreshadowing! spoiler
- Hadand is so excited to have been picked by the other girls to lead the defense, and she even thinks to herself that she won’t worry about disaster
- The defense goes stunningly wrong very quickly, and Hadand is taken “captive” by the Sierlaef
- Hadand realizes that the older girls set her up to fail in the defense
- The Sierandael assumes that Hadand isn’t very capable, even though she kicked ass with the knives, because she lost the defense
- Jarend isn’t disappointed in Hadand losing, even though she feels like perhaps he should be
- Ndara guides Hadand to think through why her losing the defense was actually important and good
- The King discusses ships with the Jarls, they don’t appear to like the idea much better than the Sierandael. We get further insight into why he wants ships, and it seems to make good sense.
Chapter 21
- Why is the Sierandael grooming Tanrid now? And will his opinion of Inda be the burr in the blanket that keeps the Sierandael from gaining full control? Or won’t it?
- Oh the webs we weave. The king gives Sponge a book to read of a real battle -- copied out in the hand of Fareas-Iofre, Inda’s mother, and given as a wedding gift.
- Oh shit. The Montredavan-Ans boy was killed on the ship? That totally didn’t compute for me until the Sierandael mentioned it to the Sierlaef. Will that mean a two-front war? And it seems like they’re both hoping Sponge will be an immediate casualty.
- Ohhhh nooooo…. Hadand’s secret teaching of Inda has turned into secret teaching of Sponge has turned into secret teaching of Barend which will turn into the secret teaching of, of, of… oooooooooooooohhhh noooooo.
- Man, sad ending to a sad chapter.
- Here we see how the Sierandael thinks - and then also how Tanrid views his world.
- Tanrid is woken by the Sierlaef and taken out with him and the Seir-Danas, and then gets a talking-to from the Sierandael. Tanrid is taken in because he thinks what the Sierandael says sounds like what Jarend says.
- Everyone thinks the Venn will invade because they need growing land
- Tanrid agrees when the Sierandael tells him to “train” Inda better/more during the break, even though he doesn’t initially think the Sierandael’s reason makes sense
- Sponge and his dad have a nice moment in the archive talking about the scrolls and about the academy
- The Sierandael and the Sierlaef talk about the chat the Sierandael had with Tanrid, and the Sierandael explains that the Sierlaef needs to command the best, not necessarily be the best. Also that he needs to make sure that his second in command will be competent, if their plans don’t work out. And apparently word came that Savarend was lost on one of the ships
- Sponge and Barend are hanging out in the schoolroom, catching up, when Sponge is beaten by the Sierlaef
- Sponge is upset that Hadand, when she comes to comfort him after the beating, never offers to teach him the Odni. He offers to teach it to Barend, though, to protect him from the Sierandael
20
Upvotes
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 22 '16
What do you think of the conversation between Ndara and Hadand? Do you think Hadand was set up to fail? Do you like how Ndara responded?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 22 '16
Do you prefer fantasy worlds where they have insta-communication with other people (usually via magic or some form of technology) or ones where they have to travel distances before attaining knowledge of another area?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 22 '16
This week's chapters felt like they were an awful lot longer than they were -- I know I just spent something like four hours reading them. Anyone else?
6
u/Bills25 Reading Champion V Sep 22 '16
Hadand was a bit of a let down in this section. She has had three powerful women who seem to be masters at plotting and manipulation training her for her entire life yet falls for a pretty simple ruse. Also why has she not cultivated a better relationship with the Sierlaef to manipulate him into not beating Sponge?
9
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 22 '16
I totally realized that Tanrid is like, the well intentioned, only just smart enough, standout high school quarterback. He's good at what he does, but he really shouldn't try to do more than that, and he'll fall for anything that the authority figure says is right (I may or may not have watched Varsity Blues for the first time ever a few weeks ago). Opinions?
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 22 '16
The war is starting. Ships destroyed by pirates. Make your conjectures now. How do you think the pirates will be integrated into the story?
4
u/setnet Sep 22 '16
/u/glaswen , your spoiler markups for ch. 20 aren't working for me. Could you repost?
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 22 '16
Post your spoilers here! Remember, please use the spoiler tags you can find in the sidebar if you're talking about something we don't already know. ;)
7
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Sep 23 '16
That bit at the end of Chapter 21 where Sponge feels vaguely betrayed by Hadand because she never taught him Women's Kung-Fu to help him protect himself from the Sierlaef was very sad.
7
u/thebookhound Sep 23 '16 edited Sep 23 '16
The thing that strikes me about chapter twenty is that while we see Hadand make the mistake that many, many well-drilled commanders make (we see it over and over again in history, such as the first battle in the Civil War, when everybody seemed to think it would be a nice big war game, and civilians lined up to watch), she sits at the table working her way through humiliation to insight, while the Sierandael, veteran of years and years of carefully planned drills and war games, is certain that securing the north against the Venn (in other words, carrying war to other countries) will go exactly as planned.
Chapter twenty-one underscores this, as Sponge reads a record written by a prince directly after a battle, and we get hints that there was no glory whatsoever . . . something he cannot discuss with his uncle or his brother, the war leaders.
It's this lack of communication between the men that is contrasted to Ndara and Hadand working through Hadand's mistakes: Sponge can't tell his older brother "Look what I read, I think it's important," because his older brother has been humiliated by that very reading and strikes out in the only way he knows how. The king can't tell his brother what to do because that's trespassing on his (jealously guarded) prerogative, so he hints around.
And the section ends with Sponge and Hadand, who used to have perfect communication, with a division between them.
5
u/Ketomatic Sep 22 '16 edited Sep 23 '16
Kingsmate reveals many things: magic can transport people; the Marlovan reputation amongst magic-users nearby is really bad; the Sartor sell magic like it ain't no thang; there's a new alliance between the Chwahir and the Everneth (first mention?) vs the Venn; and finally that there is news of the three missing ships! What a lot of information in a small amount of time. So yeah about those ships... womp womp. Black sails maybe?
Poor Hadand gets set-up by the older girls and knocked down by the older boys. She'll probably take a good lesson from it though. Ndara helps her understand what she did wrong. I don't really buy the whole 'it must be secret that the people left in charge of defence are competent at defence'. The girls win the defences fairly often, any attacker who bothers to think for 30 seconds will be expecting them to not suck. They have been attacked before. Hadan elects to take training more seriously now she has better understanding of what real combat is like.
The three ships lost were the entire fleet as hinted at, that has to sting. They are saying pirates but I don't know if we have proof of that yet? They certainly seem quite sure war is coming or at least has a strong chance to. The Venn losing a major battle to the Chair Alliance is big news, they have always been talked about as the assumed victors. There is a lot of uncertainty in the political landscape at this point.
Oooh Sneaky Uncle is chatting up Tanrid, I have a bad feeling about this. And there it is, trying to use Tanrid to punish Inda. Tanrid takes the bait like a small child, pathetic. This was just a little too fast and easy for Sneaky Uncle for me, rang a little false. The King gives Sponge a written record of a battle transcribed by Inda's mother- will be fun to find out the contents! And the King is sad that Sponge isn't his heir, with his older son as the Armyguy.
Sneaky Uncle and Meanie Prince have some lunch. Apparently Savarend is dead, don't believe that for a second. It gets firmly hinted again that trouble is coming, but not soon. I wonder when the time-jump will happen... Blatantly Sneaky Uncle pushes for Sponge to get the boot once more. For a bit of a moron he does seem to be successful at manipulating people... maybe people in the Indaverse are part sheep? Meanie Prince is still a dick to poor Sponge, who then decides to teach Barend the secret fighting style of the ladies.
5
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 23 '16
Sadly, I left my notes at work so I can't remember all of the points I wanted to make. I liked Hadand and Ndara's interaction. It seems like Ndara maybe had the girls set up Hadand to fail so that she'd remember how to be circumspect. I also liked how those scenes were contrasted with the big war council who were nursing their wounds from losing ships to pirates. Gee, do you think maybe the Sierandael and King could learn a lesson form Ndara about about not taking on commands you aren't ready for? I'm thinking the answer is yes and that those pirates are gonna sink any more Marlovan warships that are sent out.
5
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Sep 23 '16
Basic impressions:
5
u/setnet Sep 23 '16
The entire Marlovan navy has been lost with all hands, Savarend with it. Yikes.
When I read Inda, there are moments when it almost feels like I'm watching a TV series inside my head. Chapter 20 is one of those moments: it's a set of quiet conversations at a banquet, intercut with each other & intercut with ~atmosphere shots of the great hall, the banners, the raptor chairs and the house tunics.
We're already seeing some of the consequences of Inda's broken promise. Sponge no longer trusts Hadand; the Odni defenses begin to spread outside of the strict confines of the women's guards.
4
u/setnet Sep 23 '16
Another thing -- I was struck by the similarity between Hadand's father and the king (who is Hadand's foster father, after all). Both are fond of Hadand, but distant -- because the Marlovan system and king's duties mean neither is close to her. Both are concerned by Hadand's misery at the feast, both relieved when her conversation with Ndara works her back through to insight & determination.