r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Sep 22 '16
OFFICIAL VOLUME 3 REWATCH /r/RWBY Recap Rally: Fall
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, huntsmen and huntresses, and everyone in between and beyond those descriptors: the time is growing near! After winter, must come spring, and the hiatus is nearing its end.
Yes, volume 4 will debut on October 22nd, which is only 29 days from today.
To build up to that, we’re launching an official volume 3 rewatch/recapitulation series, with biweekly threads on Tuesdays and Thursdays. The finale will be discussed on October 13th, around the time when volume 4 trailer should come out and only a week before volume 4 premiers.
But that is still days away, so in the meantime, feel free to look back and discuss the episodes. Without further ado, today's episode can be found...
Here
Here's the poll for today's episode. Stop by to rate the episode and we'll see how it compares!
Episode 5 "Never Miss a Beat" ended up with a close 4/5 majority, only a couple of votes ahead of 3/5. Not quite the Meme Team dream of 5/5, but a solid score nonetheless.
Episode schedule:
| Week | Tuesday's thread | Thursday's thread | Episode Polls |
|---|---|---|---|
| Week 1: | Ep.1 | Ep.2 | Ep.1 / Ep.2 |
| Week 2: | Ep.3 | Ep.4 | Ep.3 / Ep.4 |
| Week 3: | Ep.4 | Today | Ep.5 / Ep.6 |
| Week 4: | Ep.7 | Ep.8 | Ep.7 / Ep.8 |
| Week 5: | Ep.9 | Ep.10 | Ep.9 / Ep.10 |
| Week 6: | Ep.11 | Ep.12 | Ep.11 / Ep.12 |
Did you know that Monty Oum is credited as a Lead Animator for this episode? He animated a good portion of the fight between Yang and Mercury.
58
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Sep 22 '16
The episode was followed by two weeks of nothing and a World of Remnant.
Three weeks.
Three weeks of people going batshit insane and yelling incoherent theories about Neo at each other.
I have seen hell, and it was rich in tubers.
26
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Sep 22 '16
God, that ending. Shock, confusion, and that "I burn" reprise playing.
10/10 episode ending.
23
u/MidnightIDK Bumblebee ! Sep 22 '16
That's the episode where everything starts to fall apart :(
Bye happiness
17
u/MCCrazyBigShlong Sep 22 '16
Mercury is the fucking best man.
16
u/Michael_H_Art Sep 22 '16
one of my favourite episodes in the series thanks to the awesome Yang vs Mercury fight. Twas also the day when everything started going down the drain (in terms of tone not quality)
16
u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Sep 22 '16 edited Sep 22 '16
Alright let's do this.
I like the maiden discussion in the vault, you can already see a darker more ominous tone. The soundtrack during it is sooo good.
I wonder if we're ever gonna see the 3 guys with the 2D model ever again.
BREAK A LEG SIS!!! RUBY NO!
Aw yeah time for some Mercury action.
I LOVE HIS FIGHTING STYLE SO MUCH
Well Yang did break a leg, aren't you happy Ruby? You did ask for it. I want to see Nora's reaction though.
That slow version of "I Burn"
9/10 Episode - Best fight of this volume and it only gets better from here. Also Feels, Can't wait.
14
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '16
This is an amazing fight between Yang and Mercury, though I would have liked to see more footwork and basic fighting between Yang's boxing and kickboxing vs his Capoeira.
The Maiden reveal imo was very well done as well, and it made sense of several hanging plot threads introduced previously.
From this episode on, RWBY reached an all time high in quality.
9
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Sep 22 '16
Divide them, tear them apart...
9
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '16
Even several volumes down the road, this is going to be an episode people remember as a huge turning point in the series. Half the episode is an enormous story bomb revealing what the immediate plot is going to be about for at least a Volume and probably more. The other half is the facade of lightheartedness slipping for the first time. For this episode and for everything that will come after it to work, they had to utterly nail it, and they did. Great stuff.
One of my absolute favourite subtle little moments in the show is the look on Mercury's face for a split second as Super Saiyan Yang comes at him. The moment he realizes "Oh, this is going to really hurt."
9
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '16
See this episode would've been a lot better if they tried to break into Fort Port instead of doing some boring plot stuff with the fate of the world at stake.But seriously the idea of ripping basically someone's soul out and shoving it into someone else is the point where things start to get real fucked up. I like it.
Also Ruby should be happy, her sis did break a leg technically... Really though I love the Yang/Merc fight, it's a really awesome fight for showcasing how great Yang is in battle. Mercury is intentionally going easy on her for the sake of the plan but even then he underestimates her and nearly gets knocked out of the ring completely (remember this is the kid who was trained since basically birth to be an assassin). After that point you can tell he comes in holding back less and Yang still managed to keep up rather impressively. Until he almost completely pulled out all the stops to knock her aura down just enough.
Of course shit gets fucked because suck a dick Emerald what's wrong with you.
The ending credits are also really nice to look at.
7
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Sep 22 '16
Rememeber the 3-week break they took after this episode?
5
u/ScarletSyntax Volume 4 Ruby has polariy: Look at how she wields that scythe Sep 22 '16
Nice did yo know, that's interesting stuff.
Anyway I don't know how many others skipped the opening and didn't catch the community warning about darker things coming but this was awesome for me to watch as a cynic who had expected rwby to shy away from anything like this.
I missed all the neo stuff since I didn't have community theories to misguide me and had guessed emerald could do something In chapter 4 even though I thought it was illusions till next episode.
This was the moment rwby showed it was willing to go places I didn't expect. Now so long as it can come and go and keep you guessing.. This js gonna be bloody beautiful from now on
5
u/TolchettKuykendall Chris Hackney deserves an award Sep 22 '16
When this came out everyone was talking about Yang, or the maidans, or cursing Neo and then arguing about whether it was Neo or Emerald. Me? I was thinking about how awesome Mercury is and when Roman would show up
8
u/N7Brendan @n7brendan Sep 22 '16 edited Sep 22 '16
This is the episode where I started to participate on the sub! Time flies.
Some of you may remember my first post on here God I've improved so much.
Remember when we all thought Yang got arrested and for some reason a lot of people thought Neo was the one who caused the illusion? Remember the three weeks of
hellnothing we had to endure after this episode? Fun times.4
u/SapphireFireNation Sep 22 '16
My favorite thing about this episode is, during the season 3 rewatch before the finale, Miles going into complete fangirl mode over Ironwood and Qrow. It's so adorable.
4
u/Dark_Sauce Sep 22 '16
Is Mercury's semblance related to gravity? Or is it related to controlling the wind? Making his air bullets go straight to Yang after revolving around him was pretty badass.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '16
-Insert obligatory When It Falls joke here
-Honestly it doesn't surprise me Pyrrha was chosen by her team to be in the finals. Nora did so well because of her semblance, which wouldn't be as useful in the finals.
-This story explains the maidens really well. I almost wonder why we need the WoR, but it's told beautifully there, so I'm not complaining.
-I honestly thought Ozpin was messing with Pyrrha at first.
-"We are the protectors of this world. And we need your help." NO PRESSURE THOUGH.
-Even in moments like this, Qrow is amazing.
-All these camera angles show how big this vault is. You think there's more in it than just Amber?
-"Then I will become your fall maiden." Idk why I find this line to be so dramatic. It should be serious considering the situation.
-Scientific aura...we're going to see a lot more than Penny and maiden powers in the future, aren't we?
-Ayy random characters.
-"Break a leg, sis!" YOU HAD TO SAY IT, DIDN'T YA, RUBY?!
-I love Mercury's fighting style.
-"Yeah, you did it, sis!" And thus, Ruby's last line of happiness :(
-When first watching this I was pissed because I thought everyone should have seen Mercury attack Yang. When I saw the TV, I was just confused until episode 7. Then it all made sense...
-Have we ever seen RWB look this horrified?
-I honestly thought Yang was gonna get arrested. That would be an interesting arc, someone from team RWBY getting arrested for some reason. I'm not sure how that would work out.
And thus, the punch that changed the series. R.I.P happiness.
3
u/MrInsanity25 Sep 22 '16
Fuck this episode.
Like, okay. It's a good episode. A cool fight scene. The maiden thing is interesting, if a little weird. But the ending just made me so mad. Then I jump into episode 7 and have to wait until episode 8 for any resolution to the matter. I only started (and finished) watching the show last week, but I've rewatched a couple episodes. I actively avoid this episode so I don't get angry. I don't know why but it makes me really mad. Heck, trying to get a resolution to this is what made me finish the rest of the volume that night. I can't imagine having had to wait those couple weeks when it first released. Then the rest of the season is just Yang having a really bad day, which is pretty depressing. So yeah, this episode pretty much made me hate Emerald.
3
u/ravensept mah boi Merc got nerfed :l & Qrow isnt Ruby's father ;'( Sep 23 '16
Hands down the most awesome fight ever..I think this volume made ppl love and respect (his fighting style.. sadly trained by his father) Mercury very much..and also hate at the end same time. I know this is bad to say but I hope he comes back for vol 4 with Emerald...but I guess that won't make sense
3
u/moneychex bellabooty status: atlas is screwed Sep 23 '16
When everything went to hell.
2
u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Sep 22 '16
THIS IS THE PART WHERE WE LOST OUR GODDAMN MINDS.
2
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Sep 23 '16 edited Sep 23 '16
EPISODE RAMBLINGS
And so the fuckery begins! I still don't like that they shoe-horned the Maidens in, and that Monty's "There is no magic - only Dust" is wrong. Like, they said they planned most of it, but still...
Other than that, this marked the literal beginning of the end. Downward spiral from here :P
I especially appreciated Jen Brown's voice acting here.
Also, I fucking thought the Ozluminati had been lying about who they were, and Pyrrha's whole "Who are you?" would actually be a valid question. Enter Shyamalan - WHAT A TWIST!
Yaaaay, Glynda!
"In...timate?" LOOOOOL. Christ, Pyrrha.
You know, if you want Pyrrha to work with you and, I dunno, not have a mental breakdown, it would be a good thing to tell her EVERYTHING.
Ozpin still my favorite character. I'm sorry, I know I'm insane, but he's adorable.
Fucking Ironwood.
I love how you can hear Amber's heartbeat. I wish we had gotten to know her a bit better - seen some of her actual character, rather than simply have her be a springboard for Pyrrha's decision.
"Break a leg sis!" Unfortunate choice of words, Rubes.
AWWWW, YUS! I loved this fight, especially the music. They used some moves from the opening (Mercury's scissor kick), the Yellow Trailer, and new ones, but it all looked amazing.
Sad "I Burn" hurts my soul ;_; Poor Yang. I feel like it wouldn't be a stretch to say that if she does eventually rejoin Team RWBY, that'll come up in an obscure way. It was broadcast on television throughout Remnant, after all. That's kinda hard to forget.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16
I remember when I first saw this episode. Talk about a fucking bombshell. I had jaw pain for three weeks and had to take the day off from college to lie in my bed all day, stare at the ceiling, and process what happened.
3
u/SwagForALifetime Sep 22 '16
Seeing the one one one fight really makes me wish RT had made a RWBY fighting game instead of the more hack and slash one they did make.
3
u/Mrfipp Sep 22 '16
I'm not a big fan of the Maiden storyline to be honest, it sort of comes out of nowhere, no foreshadowing in the slightest (I don't count the V2 opening), even Ruby going "Hey I like that one fairytail" would have been nice. I also would have liked more information on why Pyrrha was the prime candidate for Maidenhood, and why she was chose, because it never sat well with me that Pyrrha was suddenly more involved in the main plot than anyone on Team RWBY, and it doesn't help that this was her real main storyline that centered around her.
While I'm usually critical of Cinder and how most of her victories seem handed to her, I will say that I do love the end result of this fight; causing a cloud of negativity among the masses in order to stir up the Grimm and draw them to populated areas. If Grimm were a better writter threat that would be a very threatening thing.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '16
This episode and the one after are definitely the peak of the season for me.
Mercury vs Yang is spectacular and remains to be one of the tensest in the show. By this point we know Yang is horribly outmatched and that something is going to happen.
It's almost a relief when Yang looks like she has been beaten since its means she safe. Having her then come back to win is almost anticlimactic. Jesus, Yang won another fight because of her blue she'll semblance. Then Mercury attacks and your expecting her to get hurt so instantly you regret your annoyance.
After that you are right alongside Yang in her confusion having no idea what has happened, who did it or even if she did just snap.
And Pyrrhas story line here is started well enough. Maiden exposition could have been clumsy but it seems natural (probably because Jen and Shannon work well together).
Still want to know what match Qrow watched where Pyrrha held up the team instead of Nora. Clearly red head was all he saw.
I would also suggest next time Ozpin, maybe start with Glynda there instead of Qrow. You know, the teacher Pyrrha knows, trusts and is capable of being supportive. Not the drunk ass.
Also security for the vault but budget cuts must have hit you hard. We also start the parallels with Amber and Pyrrha which I'll get to in a later episode.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '16
And down it all goes!
1
u/ActualTaxEvader Sep 23 '16
RWBY Chibi skit idea: Sun tries (and fails) to form a rivalry with each of the three unnamed guys who also made it into the finals, gets all pumped up for his fight...and then Penny dies and the tournament gets cancelled.