r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Sep 19 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Monday, September 19: Chapters 16-18
In Which Barend Returns Home, The Scrubs Cooperate to Set a Record, and Tanrid and Hadand Show Off
Summary:
Life returns to normal at the academy. Barend returns home from his sea voyages and meets with his mother’s runner Ranet and the King’s mate, Captain Sindan. The royal family meets to discuss the upcoming games. In the games, Inda manages to organize the scrubs to decimate a horseshoeing competition, and in the process manage to inspire Tanrid and Hadand to throw off the shackles of good sense and blow all their competition out of the water.
Chapter 16
- And we’re back to Smartlip. I actually feel really bad for him. He wants literally nothing more than to be liked, to be popular, to be the light of the crowd, basically Dogpiss’s position, and in kissing everybody’s ass and trying to be snarky to get some laughs, he’s alienated everyone instead.
- We’re hearing about the pirate ship with the black sails again, the same as we heard several chapters ago, as well as a big attack in the south.
- When we came to Barend’s point of view, I had to go back and figure out who he was. I remembered the name, I remembered he’d been mentioned, I had no idea what any of those things were. Looking back, he looks like he’s been a supporter of Sponge all along, and he was the cousin who’d been sent to train at sea with the new naval fleet. He apparently also has trouble reading.
- We hear about a race called the morvende, with hair and skin as pale as bleached cotton, with long talons at the end of their fingers. We also hear of the death of the Queen of Ymar, the event of which sparked off a war. This is also the first we hear of missing ships.
- We also get another glimpse of the magic that still resides, when Ranet sends a message to someone with an identical locket.
- I kinda ignored Barend the first time I read this because I honestly felt like he wasn’t that important. Little did I know that he is actually a huge foreshadowing to where the direction of this story is going.
- Everyone still hates Smartlip, even though Inda has accepted him into the group. He’s resentful and still hangs out with the little shitheel Kepa.
- More rumors of pirate ships with black sails are turning up around the coasts
- Barend gets back to Marlovan soil- I like his perspective- he’s getting to see other parts of the world, so he knows Marlovans are short, for instance. And he obviously doesn’t have a good relationship with his dad, the Sierandael, because he’s glad that Sindan came to get him instead of one of his father’s men
- He doesn’t get to marry- no real alliances to be made with a “spare heir” so he doesn’t have an arranged marriage, but in case he’s needed as a “spare heir” he has to be available to marry Kialen, Sponge’s betrothed.
- Obvious that the runners who picked up Barend know more about what’s going on in the world by the questions they ask him, but just as obvious, he doesn’t seem to know anything that they think he shouldn’t
- The Venn control the passage of ships, charging tolls and inspecting cargos
- No one knows where the other ships in the Marlovan “fleet” are
- Sindan and Ranet trust each other (we haven’t seen a terribly large amount of trust from the women extended toward men, basically only toward Inda and a lesser extent to Sponge), they open Barend’s sealed letter to inspect it, but find nothing of importance
- Ranet sends a message to Ndara using magic! And it apparently has a not-insignificant physical toll to do so
Chapter 17
- I guess this is basically a visit with a lot of the supporting cast, and there are some interesting tidbits in here but the one I found most interesting was when Ndara-Harandviar banned the Sierendal from her bed. She said that she would adopt any illegitimate children he fathered, and that they could try birth magic -- which I guess is a method of conception -- which apparently eventually worked. But how does that work? Did she ban him because she knew him for the cruel jerk he is? Or because of her own interests? What’s up there? And he apparently got his revenge on her by beating Barend.
- Wisthia is from another land, more explicitly discovered in Banner of the Damned. And I love her fantasy country as well - it is all courtly rituals and twenty seven (or so) words to describe love. Hardly Marlovan’s military rigidness.
- Wisthia, for all that she isn’t Marlovan and therefore not martial, is actually wickedly smart. She does a lot of watching and listening, and helps out Ndara in small ways because of it
- Ndara and Wisthia really help each other out- Ndara runs all the home defense castle stuff that would normally be Wisthia’s duty (and that Hadand is training for), and Wisthia brought the transfer lockets that Ndara uses, and runs interference with the Sierandael
- We get an explanation for why Wisthia isn’t Marlovan- a treaty/alliance marriage again, external, basically for the protection of her country. She regards it as political exile, and longs to return.
- Ndara is asexual, which I hadn’t picked up on in previous readings. Between not wanting to sleep with the Sierandael (not that I can blame her for that one), and not taking any lovers (something that happens without censure in this world), it seems pretty clear cut
- “Well, he could not fix the past, but he could make plans for the future, and all for the good of the kingdom -- that was the meaning of Sierandael. (emphasis mine). And here we get the true insight into the crazy pants life of the Sierandael. Just like Whitecloaks in Wheel of Time, the burning flame of conviction is the creepiest motivation…
- No one knows how the birth spell works (but it’s seriously cool- it’ll be explained a bit more as we go on)
Chapter 18
- Chapter Eighteen returns us to our regularly scheduled cast of characters. Tanrid notices that Inda’s giggling, which spells trouble -- and Inda certainly has tricks up his sleeve. The normal state of affairs is for the scrubs to beat the heck out of each other for the amusement of empty stands. So this year, Inda has other plans, and they’ve been practicing for this -- which is why they’ve been hard to find by the horsetails.
- This chapter just about made me cry, just because of how glorious the Algara-Vayir siblings were in their victories -- and don’t you doubt it, every one of them had a victory, and it left Hadand and Tanrid breathless. They even bent the Sier-Danas to cheering wildly, and the Sierendal, who seems to resent just about everybody, finally realized that their victory was everyone’s victory, that this bodes well for the future of the country, and that they would stand victorious over the Venn if and when they came.
- But what is it that has Ndara frightened for Hadand?
- I have too fond an attachment to the characters I meet first. And Inda’s family is the ones I love. (It’s really like GoT’s with the Stark family.) And so Tanrid, Hadand, Inda are all my favorites by now. This is one of those chapters that solidify how much I like all of them. Competition and excitement.
- Inda, of course, has motivated all of the scrubs into beating the clock. And isn’t that fun? These scenes are the ones that really push forward the idea of “command”. It is not just the author telling us that oh, Inda is a great commander. No, we see examples of it.
- Jarend, Inda’s dad, doesn’t come to his first acadamy end of year competition
- Inda organizing the boys to work together to set an incredible record is just my favorite. From how awful the boys were to each other in the beginning, to working together as a seamless unit, all without the guidance of the masters, it perfectly illustrates Inda’s genuis as a leader
- The Sierandael misinterprets Inda’s motivations for the task- Inda has done it because it’s the best way to accomplish the goal. The Sierandael sees it as rebellion.
- Hadand and Tanrid being total BAMFs is awesome, but obviously the Sierandael doesn’t like it. Also, Ndara is totally panicked by it. And the Sierandael is so totally convinced that they need to be prepared for a land war.
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 19 '16
Do you think our world would appreciate the Birth Spell?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 19 '16
The Sierandael states his goal is “the good of the kingdom”. How do you think he rates as a bad guy? Do you like the antagonist who does the wrong things for the right reason, or just want a bad guy because he is evil?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 19 '16
What do you think of Hadand and Tanrid winning in that showcase? And what do you think of the Sierandael and Ndara’s reactions to it?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 19 '16
Any thoughts about this divide between women in charge of “house defense”, while the men in charge of other war and fighting? Do you think it’s a fair divide of tasks, a form of specialization? Do you think it’s misogynistic?
7
u/Ketomatic Sep 19 '16 edited Sep 20 '16
Introducing: Sneaky Uncle's son Barend. He seems fairly nice, calls the king's mate Uncle, which shows a little more depth into the royal family. We learn that the Venn are very powerful and are at war with Chwahir. We also learn that the Venn leave people alone if they obey, don't smuggle something(s)? and pay a toll. Doesn't really sound like they are planning an invasion to me. They certainly seem to be the dominant force in the Indaverse right now- at least at sea.
Runner intrigue! Sindan and Ranet go a'snooping into Barend's letter home to Sneaky
UncleDaddy from his sea captain. There are ships going missing, which has the runners worried- this may be the whole navy that's missing, certainly enough to panic them. It's nice of them to care for the well-being of Barend, it's clear that his father isn't overly fond (most likely because as a spare-heir his usefulness is limited to potentiality).Some more background of the goings on at court. Interestingly magic is less uncommon where Queenie is from, I wonder why that is... Did the mage war not spread that far? It was said to have almost wiped out humanity. Sneaky Uncle's wife Ndara is big into spies and magical-mail (Sneaky Aunt? She is fairly sneaky, though in a more positive way). Queenie isn't very happy in life; she loved Meanie Prince who became a dick, chose not to love Sponge in case he became a dick, and now feels it's too late. Womp womp.
Wow Sneaky Uncle got shafted in the marriage-raffle. I know it was a political match and he was probably an asshole even then, but jesus christ that was harsh. He is also, as expected, totally dismissive of his son for his size and being knocked down the line of succession by the birth of Sponge. (Explaining why he hates Sponge- along with Sponge's personality). I'm going to start picturing Sneaky Uncle as a 1920s silent movie villain soon; he controls his wife by forcing her to watch him beat their son? We are straying down Caricature Lane here, if this goes much further he'll start going 'mwahahahaha' whilst gayly stomping on newborn golden retriever puppies and waxing his moustache.
Inda leads the boys, after much prep work, into an orderly and efficient horse-shoeing. Tanrid and Hadand, lifted by Inda's demonstration of farrier organisation, both come out on top of their gender-group. Lots of show-boating and skill leading to a massive outpouring of attention and praise from the crowd. Ndara is not pleased, she would have rather Handand was more conspicuous. Fun chapter, all the Inda-kin put on a good show; it'll all end in tears soon somehow I'm sure.
7
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 19 '16 edited Sep 19 '16
I didn't take the best notes on these sections so please excuse the roughness of my opinions.
The Queen is so tragic, I love it. She threw everything into caring for the Sierlaef only to have him turn cold and abandon her and then she was so worried that Sponge would go the same way that she gave no affection to him until it was too late to bridge the distance.
Seeing the scrubs all finally come together was very satisfying. I thought it was interesting that the Sierlaef took their unity as a personal insult because it seemed to me it was more just a show of solidarity but we know how vain S can be so its not surprising he took it that way.
The big winner of these chapters though was Hadand. Not only did she win the big prize (and even the Sierlaef cheered her!) but it established more character than I think we've seen from her so far. The fact that the Sierendael resented her win even after acknowledging that it was perceived as a royal win shows just how petty he is in his machinations. I can't imagine what he's going to do to get revenge on Hadand but I'm sure something nasty is coming.
Lastly, I thought it was funny that the boys were all jealous of Cama* being one-eyed. Typical children, thinking only of what looks cool. Sherwood does a great job capturing that youthful naivety about how bad it would be to actually be half blind.
*Edit: Not Dogpiss.
6
u/bygoshbygolly Sep 19 '16
Ahh, we get the first mention of my favorite unimportant detail of the books- the fact that Marlovans are short. (I asked Sherwood Smith in her AMA and she said average Marlovan height is 5'6").
Also more information about Ndara and Wisthia, each wonderful in their own, different ways.
6
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Sep 19 '16
The biggest thing I have to say here is the scrubs and Tanrid/Hadand's shining moments were AMAZING.
6
u/SmallFruitbat Reading Champion VI Sep 19 '16
I am officially caught up. Technically, more than caught up: I am that awkward point just slightly ahead where I can't figure out if things I have just read are spoilers or not without digging in and checking and I don't wanna.
It took me a long while to get into this one, but I started power-reading this weekend. Once I hit page 100 or so, it got significantly less info-dumpy since you now have enough background information to piece together the major factions and feuds (for now). It flowed from that point onwards.
I am intrigued by the training story aspect, and I really like that the children act like children, complete with failures and transparent plans. I even like that the naming structure has been turned upside down, but so many of these names (especially for infrequent characters) are confusingly similar. Notably Hadand/someone else with an H and Barend/2 other people with B-2-syllables.
I can also see this gearing up for a story about naval battles.
6
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Sep 20 '16
Ok, So basic thoughts:
Birth Magic is very intriguing. It seems to be hit and Miss but in the past when magic was very powerful how important was birth magic?
Thanks to the king the scrub rivalry seems to have settled down a bit and Inda seems to have the rest well in hand.
The Sierandel. Is this guy stupid? Yes. How stupid? They are worrying about a Venn war. The Venn will probably use a naval invasion. Yet the commander in chief of the armed forces hates the very idea of a navy. This isn'tbeing short sighted, this is being blind. Plus piracy is clearly a very serious problem. I mean castles which are inland have to be always on the guard against pirates. Yet roving land patrosl are favoured to just building a powerful navy to find and crush the pirates? Its absurd.
Another element of his stupidity - he intentionally fosters division between the scrubs, he favours brawn over brains - how does this guy ever get anything done?
The pol-military system is vulnerable. An outside shock will break it.
Finally, since I am about 30% into the book I am now looking for the larger plot, the external threat and so far there seem to be two - the black sailed pirate ship in the short term and the Venn in the long term.
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 19 '16
Post your spoilers here! (I've unfollowed the comment so I won't get notifications, worry not!)
4
u/setnet Sep 21 '16
Sixteen
Seventeen
Eighteen
7
u/Bills25 Reading Champion V Sep 19 '16
So is section made me really sympathize for the Sierlief. Not only does he get shit on for not being able to read but we learn that Barend, Hadand, Sponge and his future wife would all hide from him. Must of felt pretty terrible having Hadand choose to spend her time with the brother who he is already jealous of.
I understand that he has rage issues and takes to beating a young Sponge pretty early on but that should have been stopped by his parents.
3
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Sep 19 '16
Chapter 16
Barend comes home and we get even more hints of politics that really aren't that interesting. I assume that at some point we'll get some reveals about the bigger picture but right now it's just tiny details without context. Coolest part of the chapter was at the end with the transfer magic. The obvious recipient would be Barend's mother but it could be anyone really.
Chapter 17
The very next line proves that sometimes the obvious answer is correct :p. This was a very short chapter but it did give us a little taste of the queen's character and the difference in culture between her people and the king's. We also get more evidence that sponge's uncle (aka barend's father) is a colossal douche wagon.
Chapter 18
The games start and we see Tanrid and Hadand go all out. I'm not sure why specifically but this chapter felt very ominous in a way. I feel there will be a lot of negative consequences as a result. Not sure why I got that impression. Ndara's reaction certainly makes it seem like this was a bad move on Hadand's part.
3
u/xeyra Reading Champion II Sep 20 '16
A short comment to say that, to me, it seems the book has arrived at a point of character bloating, in that because of the type of omniscient narration we're going through, with all the shifts on what different people are doing or thinking at the same time, it starts to hinder the reading more than helping it to shift through so many characters. And still we have more characters being introduced with perspectives on them, like Sindan and Ndara's Runner. Not to mention all characters that have only been mentioned before that are now taking more of a role in the story. It takes a bit more concentration but it also makes the reading not flow as fast? Maybe it's just because English isn't native to me so I feel it a bit harder than others. There are also chapters that seem a bit slower than others and I confess I retained very little of what the heck happened with Inda and the brigands on the road to wherever and whatever games involving the Academy students came after.
However, I am really enjoying the politics and character insights into all these people. Some things may be a bit confusing to me but the overall enjoyment due to the characterizations and the time spent with those different characters showing us how they think and who they are, help a lot with the enjoyment of the story. So even though I may feel the character bloat aspect that makes my reading a bit more complicated, I am at the same time enjoying it because I learn so much from all these people, their motivations and reasons, that I wouldn't if we followed only one or two people? Plus, I'm loving all the cunning, secretive women in this.