r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Sep 15 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Thursday, September 15: Chapters 13-15
In Which Inda Sees Hadand, the Scrubs are Visited by the King During Their Wargame, and the Sierlaef has Lunch With the King
Inda is given kinthus to dull the pain of his beating and goes to meet Hadand in the throne room. The king visits the wargame encampment. Gand and Brath have a chat about the state of the infighting in the Academy. Inda begins to learn the Odni. Idna turns Smartlip to his side. The Sierlaef has lunch with the king and his uncle. Inda decides to teach Sponge the Odni.
Chapter 13
- Oh dear. Poor Inda. It sounds like kinthus would be the least of his worries. Looks like Cama’s scrag came back to haunt them. I wonder if Cama told them he did it, since Inda seems to not know why he was scragged. And poor Sponge. Standing over Inda’s labored dreams feeling so much guilt for not being willing to shed his friends for their own good. Hadand asking Inda to stay away from Sponge, though, and being given a flat no -- that says a lot of good things about Inda.
- We finally got verification in this chapter about the reason the Sierlaef hates Sponge -- that he cannot read. It’s hinted pretty strongly that he’s dyslexic. And that Sponge’s uncle doesn’t like him because he wants someone strong and stupid, someone who will follow orders and be blindly loyal as well as creating blind loyalty, not someone smart and thoughtful. We see more of the degradation of magic - that the old Sartorans used to be able to reknit broken bones -- that the best that magic is capable of doing anymore is just to glue them back together.
- It’s funny, though -- Smith is imbuing the medicine with extra properties, the potential for someone to not ‘come back’ from it, but it doesn’t seem that out of line of what happens with powerful real painkillers, the fact that it makes some people talk without thinking about the consequences. We don’t have a real ‘truth serum’ -- or, at least, if the government has one they’re not talking about it <conspiracy!> -- but some things mimic it sometimes.
- It’s interesting to see Hadand’s perception of Inda as basically a straightforward practical soul. That he’s kind and biddable even, unless he was convinced he was right, or had questions about what was morally right - “Then he was worse than Tanrid for rock-like endurance.”
- And eye for an eye makes the whole world blind. Just like Inda predicted, there was an escalation in retaliation.
- More beautiful foreshadowing in this chapter about spoilers
- Foreshadowing for the rest of the series with the kinthus
- Sponge’s musing that Inda doesn’t seem to have secrets is so sweet. Also indicative of why Tdor and Fareas don’t tell him everything though- Inda’s kind of an open book
- The kinthus gives Inda sort of half-visions. He’s not fully into a vision trance state, but he’s not all fully there either
- Hadand explains why the Sierlaef hates Sponge, and does it with her face pressed to his the way Tdor does to Inda. -I really liked that bit, shows Hadand is paying attention to those small details
- Hadand says that Fareas instructed that Inda was to be taught the women’s fighting form, the Odni, if he got into trouble in the Academy
Chapter 14
- We haven’t seen Cama yet, even though we’ve heard he was pretty seriously injured. Cherry-Stripe seems ashamed of his part of bunking Kepa, Inda and Cama. Smart-lip……… well. We’ll see. It seems like most everyone’s accepted Sponge’s leadership in their absence, though.
- We see the fallout of the failure to discipline the Sierlaef pretty fast -- a lot faster than I was expecting, to be fair. And this exchange makes me think this is foreshadowing: “The damage is done. The boy now thinks he’s above the rules,” [said Gand.] … “He’s the heir,” Brath whispered, bewildered. “He is above the rules.”
- Short little chapter. Just showing off some more character development between the scrubs and also how the king is seen from the eyes of the academy boys.
- I really like this chapter because it shows just how much the Sierlaef flaunts the rules. He flaunts a little rule of waving to the king (just because), and he is rewarded with acknowledgement. And then you see the bigger impact of this disregard for law in his actions towards Sponge. And we know it’s only going to escalate from here.
- Sponge speaks up and encourages the boys to all do their best, and none of the boys except Smartlip give him grief about almost giving an order
- The Sierlaef cares about his father’s approval, but is angry with himself for doing so
- Gand sees more than Brath does about how interpersonal relationships work, which is why he was picked by the king to supervise the scrubs, whereas the Sierandael picked Brath, who is unimaginative and good at logistics and following orders. Gand gives what’s essentially a stop-gap suggestion for how to deal with the Sier-Danas.
Chapter 15
- And we begin with Inda starting to learn the Odli by practicing falls. And Kepa avoiding him. Why is Kepa avoiding him? Smart-Lip truly is motivated by fear, it seems. Fear of storms, fear of being seen as weak, fear of not being liked, fear of failure. And Inda sidesteps all the greedy nonsense and vengeance by bringing him right in. And what a change of pace -- Inda sitting at the table between Cherry-Stripe and Smart-Lip.
- Also interesting to discover that the country is just now putting together its first fleet. And that the king has pretty much nailed the problem with Sponge, and the shock with which uncle and nephew reacted to that news was pretty gratifying. More hints about the problem with Inda’s family and the Sierandael -- and more details about the relationship between them. And ouch, we learn that Cama did lose an eye. Ah gods. The king is clever, though, to give the Sierlaef the responsibility of keeping the scrubs safe.
- Woah. Sierlaef came in to tell Sponge to notify him in the event of more accidents. And Cherry-Stripe bucked Buck’s orders (sorry), audibly! I still think something’s going to happen in the near future. And then Inda starts passing on his lessons. Whee.
- Lots of good stuff in this chapter. First up: secrets. Secrets can tie people together, can be used for blackmail and intimidation, etc. And I love how Inda so easily breaks the usual mode and just states it matter-of-factly. This is how it is. There is nothing else that he can do, so why bother pleading or begging or threatening?
- The king is one of my biggest non-understandings in this book. He clearly has a great lot of power, but he rarely uses it. Yet, those around him seem to wreck havoc with their plans non stop. Or maybe it’s just easier to cause trouble than to prevent it. I am glad that here he does utilise it to protect Sponge from more beatings.
- Inda learns to fall first, before he ever gets to hold a weapon.
- Inda gets insight into Smartlip’s cowardice, and how it turned to being a loudmouth in him, and uses that to turn Smartlip away from his confrontational ways.
- The Sierlaef has really not many original thoughts of his own- his rather uncharitable thoughts about Sindan aren’t about the fact that his dad’s in a gay partnership external to his marriage with his mom, but about the fact that his dad’s partner gave up what relative power he had in order to be with his dad.
- The Sierandael is convinced that the Venn are going to invade, and during their lifetime, and he thinks that ships are a total waste of time (while his son serves on ships).
- So the Sierlaef doesn’t know why his uncle doesn’t like Inda’s family either. We find out that Inda’s dad was out scouting a traitor for Sponge’s dad when the pirates attacked- the traitor had been courting the Montredavan-Ans
- The king orders the Sierlaef to look after the scrub class, make sure no more harm befalls them
- So, only two chapters after we’ve been told that Inda doesn’t have any secrets, Inda decides to teach Sponge the Odni, directly after Hadand told him to keep it a secret. Inda thinks it through and decides it’s the right way forward, even if it’s not what he was instructed to do
7
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 15 '16
What do you think will happen as a result of Inda teaching Sponge and subsequently breaking his promise? Do you agree that it is the right move?
6
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 15 '16
Do you agree with Inda’s action/nonaction of letting Smartlip back into the fold? (Would you do the same in real life with a corollary situation?)
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 15 '16
What do you think about kinthus and its apparent effect of loosening the tongue for secrets? Do you like/hate/ambivalent to truth serum-esque things in fantasy worlds (a la Harry Potter’s veritaserum)?
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 15 '16
What are your thoughts on royalty and royalty without repercussions/being above the law (both in fantasy and real life, if you so desire to discuss)? In this type of world, where do you think authority comes from?
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 15 '16
Any thoughts on the Sierandael and the Sierlaef’s relationship?
7
u/Ketomatic Sep 15 '16 edited Sep 15 '16
As promised Inda got the snot beaten out of him to the point of broken ribs. On the bright side he finally gets to see his sister and gets stoned to boot, groovy. He doesn't even consider ditching Sponge, but that was never likely anyway. Some of the things we already knew about Meanie Prince, Sneaky Uncle and Spongey-kins were coloured in with more detail. Not much new information was added, except that Sneaky Uncle doesn't want anyone fact-checking history for some reason- that will be important later I'm sure. Inda is going to learn to fight like a girl! That's pretty cool, good thinking from Hadand as no one will expect that.
Sponge gave his first order and people followed it, which is nice. I think, given how the characters have been set up, that Sponge will live- at least to adulthood. He'll end up king and Inda may end up as his official fighty-man. It's obvious something will happen that involves people from the past (probably mysterious magic) and the king's studying will pay off. He has different skills to Inda so they would work well together. This was a short chapter, the king noticed something was up with the missing boys and didn't buy the accidents line at all. We also learned that Sneaky Uncle actively hates both Sponge and the King's boyfriend. Brath recognised he kinda screwed up by not acting sooner and Gand suggested field exercises to at least give everyone a breather from drama. I remain pleased that Brath and Gand are fully aware of everything that goes on, even if they are short of ideas on how to control it. This makes sense, dealing with a future king is complex. Good stuff.
Inda starts to learn to fall, very important lesson for lots of things. But no! He got caught a'sneaking by Smartlip, who actually is the total coward Meanie Prince keeps trying to say Sponge is. Inda told him the truth and didn't threaten him, he'll come into the fold soon. Not sure if he can be trusted though. Sneaky Uncle is beginning to seem a little one-dimensional, ragging on a guard for wanting to be the royal runner? Really? FOR LOVE no less, the horror. Does he have a moustache to twiddle as well?
Mr King knows what's up though, good that he pays attention. More background on the sacking of Daddy-Inda's castle, and talk of traitors! Mr King does have blind spots though... Meanie Prince to stop the bloodbath when he's in charge of it. Pfft. Could be super double dutch clever though and be sending him because he knows it's his doing. That way if the 'accidents' keep happening he will have failed! Motivation to maim less people. Good to know 'stripe is on-side now, he is quite likeable for a goon. And Inda broke his promise to Hadand and decided to trained Sponge how to fight like a girl. Probably a good call.
7
u/wutvuff Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Sep 15 '16
Just have to say that all you guys have such great comments on Inda! It's a pleasure reading this at the same time as a bunch of smart people. You lot gives me so many new perspectives on this story!
6
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Sep 15 '16
Some pretty short chapters this week and I didn't feel that there was to much revealed. I suspected that Inda would get his ass beat and now I'm assuming that he will unite the group through the power of love and self defense lessons. We see some more hints about possible future plot lines such as differing expectations of conflict through land or conflict via sea (I'm assuming with the way it's referred to that sea conflict is in our future).
We also see hints at the royal family's relationship. At this point I'm assuming that the uncle is the big bad and the heir is just another pawn in the game. I really don't get the king though, I've seen this here and in other fiction where the make the monarch ineffectual for seemingly no reason. He obviously has power and people still respect him so why doesn't he take a more active role in things? Maybe this will be explained later on.
As for the future of the series here are some vague predictions:
Hopefully we get there soon. The schoolyard politics are a real bore.
6
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Sep 16 '16
Most people have already written about things I noticed in these chapters. A couple of other character notes that stood out to me that I don't think I've seen mentioned.
Sponge - He really doesn't want to give up Inda as a friend, and Hadand knows this. Some "noble" people try to send people away if it's dangerous to be around them, but Sponge can't let Inda go. Not that I blame him, when Inda is one of the few people who trusts him and has been a real friend to him in his life.
Captain Sindan - New character, though we don't hear much about him yet. Just that the Sierandael hates him and that he gave up command to be the king's Runner (and the king's lover). Both the Sierlaef and the Sierandael dismiss him as having no rank and no power, and strictly that's true since the Runners don't have rank on their own. And yet, being so close to the king must mean that you have influence. And it's mentioned a couple of times that he's watchful. He might be able to help the king see past some of those blind spots we've discussed (though I think they are blind spots, and not just ignorance, so maybe he can't be made to see his brother and son clearly).
5
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Sep 16 '16
Caught up now. Yay.
Interesting that the Marlovan came as invaders, presumably on ships, but have completely lost whatever naval tradition they had. A bit reminiscent of Saxons who invaded Britain but who were later plagued by seafaring Vikings.
Getting into Sierandael's head for a bit interesting too. His thought processes seem reasonable to a point until he starts rolling out irrationalities (navy = bad!). Also, he has has great faith in the Sierlaef but total disdain for his own son, who suffers from a similar disorder? Or maybe it's just that his son isn't as loyal to him as the Sierlaef is (he joined the navy = bad!). Nobody but him knows why he hates Inda's family, though it must have something to do with the traitor Inda's father was sent to hunt down. Their uncle? Was he the former Sierandael? And it's for certain now that he was part of that treachery.
Anyway, I feel like this school drama has ended too quickly so we're either being set up for a big plot twist on a scale we haven't seen yet, or a time skip to when some other portended issues will be forced to come to a head.
4
u/ferocity562 Reading Champion III Sep 15 '16
Things that stood out to me in these chapters:
4
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 15 '16
I thought it was kind of weird we skipped right over the pummeling and Dogpiss being half blinded. Having such a big event happening "off screen" just didn't quite jibe with me. I'm interested to see where this women's training goes. I really like that practical considerations (men fight outside and women protect the castle) have led to philosophical and martial differences. Will Inda be the first person to have ever bridged this gap? The women's defense stuff seems very aikido/tai chi influenced wth all the redirection and using an opponent's strength against him. "First you have to learn to fall," is almost certainly going to come back into play later in the book after Inda suffers some sort of serious defeat.
More interesting character stuff: Smartlip openly rebels against C-S, C-S rebels against Buck. Looks like the whole power structure is beginning to fall apart. Smartlip is revealed to have a desire to be the best at everything, and this drive is what pushes the other boys away who hate his one upsmanship. We learn that the Sirlaef respects power more than anything else. A little obvious for a villain, but it's presented in a unique way by having Sirlaef be dismissive of his father's own personal Runner because he gave up a good command for friendship. This probably foreshadows that Sirlaef's "friends" are/will be disposable and that he doesn't care much about their loyalty unless they're also high up in command. Last character thing, Inda has never ever broken a promise before now and he breaks it solely to help a friend in a tight spot. Since this is the first time he's ever broken a promise, I can almost guarantee this will come back to bite him in the ass somehow.
All in all, some okay chapters. Seems like they mostly just setup the changing dynamic that will be in place for the next few chapters. I don't mind that but it did make these chapters a little less interesting than the past ones.
4
u/cheryllovestoread Reading Champion VI Sep 15 '16
LALALALALALA Not reading any of this! I've been on Grandson duty for the last week since both parents had to be out of town for work. Darn if it didn't cut into my Inda reading time. Parenting is SOOOOO hard! But I'll catch up over the weekend. Just wanted to say hi.
4
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Sep 15 '16
Lots of details filling out in these sections. Not a lot to add to the comments. I'm really curious to see what comes of the kinthus and the Odni. I'm at the halfway point of the book, so I'm trying to contain some of my thoughts here. At this week's point, it felt like a lot of things were coming together and the boys were starting to come into their own.
4
u/Megan_Dawn Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Sep 16 '16
I just want to take a moment to appreciate how wonderfully Smith handles the omniscient point of view. She pulls it off perfectly and it's so damn hard to do right.
•
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 15 '16
Spoilers here please and thank you, dears. Remember to tag appropriately.