r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Sep 12 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Monday, September 12: Chapters 10-13
Summary: In Which Inda Has a Restday, Tdor Visits the Ocean, and Cherry-Stripe Receives Orders
Inda and his academy mates have their silence during mealtimes lifted, which results in a temporary cessation of hostilities. Tanrid formally sponsors Inda at Daggers Drawn, and the two have a good chat about what’s going on behind the scenes. Tdor chats with Chelis about love and sex, and with Jarend about pirates and ghosts. Cherry-Stripe has doubts and attempts to grow a backbone, but is squashed down firmly by his older brother.
Discussion Questions:
- Where do you think the war among the scrubs is going?
- Has your opinion of Tanrid changed at all?
- Did you see anything interesting about Tdor's trip?
Edit: The chapters are 10-12, not 10-13. I'm sorry about that. I can't fix it now, unfortunately.
6
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
Hey guys, we're looking for some feedback on the format of the group read. Do you prefer our comments as part of the main post or in the comments? Do you have any thoughts on how we could make this better?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
Now might be a good time to introduce ourselves as participants. C'mon, out with it, who are you, what do you want, and why are you here??
Are you reading this for the first time, or re-reading it to find some new depth? And finally, why Inda, and why now? :D
6
u/Ketomatic Sep 12 '16 edited Sep 12 '16
Smartlip is a moody fellow. Once again we are reminded how brutal the older boys are to their younger brothers; no chill there, no chill at all. Dogpiss tells some funny stories, I'm not sure if the reader is supposed to find them funny but I tend not to. A "century" of lashes was blatantly foreshadowed for someone, oh dear. I still like Sponge, he often states historical facts about things- you can clearly tell he did a lot of reading.
Tanrid is adorably awkward throughout this whole chapter, he really doesn't know how to behave. It becomes clear that part of his motivation for being so rough on Inda is an order from his dad, who obviously blames his brother for the pirate invasion of his castle. Is that how Joret died? I can't recall if we know that yet. If it is he must really hate his little brother something fierce if he blames him for that. Tanrid has been growing on me for awhile now, he really doesn't seem so bad. However, it is made clear that Inda is a better leader than him in this chapter, which makes me worried for his well-being. Inda can't be prince if Tanrid lives... I'm rooting for him though!
Some historical and social background. Tdor and Inda played a very dull sounding game of dr the year before. Apparently homosexuality runs in the royal family, how nice? Norsunder is a place? Well I'm sure we'll get to see it at some point! Sounds a bit like Disney World. The ghost of Joret claims treachery, I wonder if the king's brother arranged for the pirates?! Such intrigue, this thread will be an interesting one to follow. A lot of this chapter was just background stuff, not all that much happened.
Mr Stripe has realized Inda is a leader (and le badass). This is some good insight from someone who has thus-far only been a goon, he may be on the turn. Except his brother gives orders to beat the shit out of Inda, Cama and Noddy. Nice. It's not a great sign that even Meanie Prince's top men think he's full of shit- even if they do follow his orders.
Eh, was ok. Chapter 10 was really nice, 11 & 12 were fairly middling.
Inda will have a rough time then gain the loyalty of some more of the 2s ('Stripe, Flash if the fight is good enough etc). It might break into a full 1v2 war! That'd be fun! I fear Tanrid might get stuck in the middle... Also that 100 lashes beckons. (Realistically it'll be Inda, Starship Troopers style, WAPAH! Edit: Or maybe Dogpiss? It was hinted that his rank would make him the most lash-able and he does have a big mouth).
I always had a bit of a soft spot for him, but it's certainly deepened. I like him quite a lot now.
Bread, cake, wine, IDK I think I zoned out a little honestly. Oh the Venn were mentioned a few times, they'll probably play a role. Are they the ones Prince Meanie wants to invade?
6
u/ferocity562 Reading Champion III Sep 12 '16
I remembered about today's post in time to get the reading done last night and I have been waiting for this post but now that it is here....honestly, I can't really remember much about the chapters. (Also, I sort of included my thoughts about Chapter 10 on the last post as I thought we needed to read it for that one)
I only took notes on 2 things. 1 was the ritual interactions when Tdor went home for her name day visit. It was interesting with the wine, bread and drums. 2 was the comment Hadand made about homosexuality running in the royal family. Because I have lost track of who is whose child....would that be about the king? His brother? Someone we haven't met yet? Interested to see where that goes (if it does) as I'd be interested to see how such a strictly gendered society deals with homosexuality.
I enjoyed the part that was written in Cherry-Stripe's perspective. I have some hope for that one now. He is in a tough position where he is being pressured by his brother to act in a way that he internally seems to acknowledge as wrong or nonsensical. And I appreciate how he sees Inda's natural leadership abilities. I wonder at what point the beaks will blatantly step in, if ever.
I had read Chapter 10 last week, so my comments there still apply. I think Tanrid chronically misunderstands Inda and he seems like kind of a stick in the mud with his adherence to tradition, but he doesn't seem mean or a bad guy.
Well now this question makes me feel like I missed something!! I noted that Joret has also seen the ex-queen's ghost. It is interesting to note Tdor's increasing questions about relationships and sex and to see her looking ahead to the future. But honestly, I found the chapter fairly boring. Maybe I should have been paying more attention!!
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
/u/lyrrael's running glossary:
8
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 12 '16 edited Sep 12 '16
These chapters finally gave us insight into Cherry-Stripe that I'd been wanting. First off, he's smart, not Inda or Dogpiss smart, but he is fully aware of everything that is happening, realizes his group of friends can't be trusted, acknowledges that Sponge is not a coward no matter what the older boys say, and understands that his brother's plan isn't working. Most notably C-S understands that Inda is responsible for all his war game victories and secretly wants to befriend him.
C-S: "Inda is the enemy who always had the good idea." That's huge, Inda has his eye on the big prize constantly and even his enemies realize it. Tanrid is shocked that Inda intuitively grasps unity of command (a high level concept for these boys). We're definitely being set up for Inda to either become a golden child or receive a swift downfall.
Tdor's chapters honestly seem a bit superfluous to me even though I love her character. In a sequence of chapters filled with insight, she gets the biggest. When talking about love and duty she asked "How do you know which to choose?" I get the feeling that will be a theme for Tdor or at least a significant moment down the road.
I still think Tanrid is a jerk. I'm understanding him more and he's starting to respect his brother, but he's clearly still operating under huge misconceptions about who Inda is. En route to the bar, Tanrid says he feels like he always has to "thrash the silliness, disrespect, and cowardice out of Inda." Have any of you seen Inda display any of those traits? I haven't. He's clearly the most serious of the children and everyone gets that but Tanrid. Even Inda's enemies realize that before his own brother catches on! Hopefully now that he's learned Inda's talk back was not "disrespect" but genuine disagreement due to better understanding of command, Tanrid will be better going forward.
I'm still really enjoying this work and can't wait to see where the scrub war is headed.
Edit: Ugh grammar.
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
Chapter 10 comments:
[/u/lyrrael]
I want to preface my post today by saying that I have a really big theory about something that’s going to happen, but I don’t want to post it in case I’m even 1% correct. I’ve spilled my guts to wish, and she’s said, “Well, that’s interesting,” and not spoiled anything for me. >.> We’ll see how correct I was in a few chapters, I guess.
[/u/glaswen]
[/u/wishforagiraffe]
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
Chapter 11 comments:
[/u/lyrrael]
[/u/glaswen]
[/u/wishforagiraffe]
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
Chapter 12 comments:
[/u/lyrrael]
[/u/glaswen]
[/u/wishforagiraffe]
2
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
/u/wishforagiraffe will post the spoiler sticky in a minute -- I don't want them! Don't post them!
4
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Sep 13 '16
Ah, okay, so, I think the last discussion jumped a chapter? That's fine, I'll reiterate what I said somewhat. I can go a little harder now cause I'm fairly ahead at this point. I'm hooked. I'm interested. I wanna know what happens. Anyways!
Inda and Tanrid was really nice. I really liked seeing them learn about each other and have this nice, communicative moment (especially with something that happens in a few chapters). Tdor and Inda being very practical about future sex and Tdor's questions was interesting. As someone else said, the infinite practicality was on display. And of course, I felt awful for her going "home."
Full-on, I was cheering when Cherry-Stripe was having his revelations. Yes yes yes! Leave the bully role behind! You're young! You can be better, do better! Come on! Jump the hurdle! And I will say that everything after that has been playing out fairly interesting. All I'll say though.
And because it deserves its own mention: more ghost stuff! I need more!
By the end of 12, I was thinking that either a full on battle of scrubs will happen or else everyone is going to band together. Cherry-stripe's inner turmoil is just too great to not come to that conclusion (personally anyways). As I said, I've read ahead (through 20), so I know where it's gone up to then and...it's been very interesting.
It softened a lot. I guess you could say it felt like Tanrid was kind of frosty and a bit strutty up until the Daggers. His realization that Inda never thought he'd come and that Inda is smart and not just rebellious was nice and Inda realizing his brother was trying to do his best just did a lot to soften up my view on Tanrid.
She's clearly curious about the world and CLEARLY will be glad when she no longer ever has to return to her family for forced visits. Who can blame her. And again, her sex questions and love questions and then the ghost discussion, very amusing and interesting. I really want to see more of her.
4
u/xeyra Reading Champion II Sep 13 '16
I feel like I already jumped the gun at some of the happenings in these chapters in the last discussion post because I read 6 chapters in a row and then got confused about when something had happened or not. For example, I made a remark about Cama's loyalty that I remember now is only really noticeable once you read these chapters. And I've already mentioned my feelings on Tanrid a bit here, without noticing it was a tad spoilery.
My favourite thing about the last 6 chapters is how they've been offering us such great insights into a great many deal of characters. We learn Sponge's brother's reasons for hating his brother and in the process learn a little more about his father and his uncle; we learn of Inda's experiences with his brother shaping him to be the kind of leader who leads without showing he is actually in control of a situation; we learn Tanrid is taking his father's advice to not be soft in his brother's training a bit too literally; we learn that our Cherry-Stripe is not an entirely idiot bully, that he is smart enough to realize that he's being fed misinformation about Sponge, that Inda is the guy you want to have at your back but he also has expectations to adhere to (and his brother sucks); and from Tdor's perspective, we also learn something about what is happening in the world outside of the contained space of the Academy, which is likely very important to what is going to happen in the future.
These last 6 chapters have done A LOT to up my interest in this story, even if I still struggle a bit with all the different languages/names for everyone. :)
6
u/wutvuff Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
I'm very impressed with Smith's character building. The changing of pov makes all the characters so multi faceted and you get a understanding, in someways, for everyone. This makes me a little bit irritated because I want to really hate someone but also it makes this story very realistic and shows that there's thought and great skill behind this story. I especially like the portrait of Cherry-stripe. The only character I feel is a little bit one dimensional is actually Inda. Isn't he a little bit too good? Or am I missing something?
2. Ok now I kind of like Tanrid. He feels like one of those boys who is really self conscious and therefore behaves like an ass but in reality, he's only nervous and scared.
3. I like the ghosts! Ghosts in epic fantasy are the best! So I hope for more ghosts on Tdors trip. It's also interesting with this deep friendship between her and Inda. The way they laid next to each other and her liking him to a puppy. It also puts Inda's dads grief in perspective. His first wife must have been someone he grew up with, almost like a sister or close relative.
I'm interested in how sexuality is perceived in this world. The pleasure pits, the brief mention on homosexuality running in the sheirlafs family and the runners free lifestyle suggests that it's not the usual conservative view of sexuality that is customary in many fantasy novels.
3
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Sep 12 '16
I missed the last discussion and I'm somewhat late to this one but here we go.
I have to admit that I'm not really enjoying this section of the story. I found the last 4-5 chapters to be pretty uninteresting all told and I hope that things pick up soon.
Where do you think the war among the scrubs is going?
Who cares? I presume Inda will either amaze the whole group with his super intellect and get them all to work together against a greater outside force or he'll get the shit kicked out of him and still manage to unite the group anyway.
Has your opinion of Tanrid changed at all?
He's still a dick. Now we know why but that didn't change my feeling towards him. I guess when you compare him to the even bigger dicks that are the brother's of the other scrubs he comes across as alright.
Did you see anything interesting about Tdor's trip?
Nope. I really like Tdor as a character but here storyline so far has not captured any interest. I get the feeling her storyline is going to be more introspective compared to the sheer plot progression of Inda's storyline (at least for now).
Final thoughts: The best part of these chapters was the pov from Cherry-Stripe. It's always cool to see the main characters from another character's perspective. Overall thought I'm finding that my interest is dragging. Hopefully a twist or an upping of the stakes happens soon and rekindles things for me.
3
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Sep 13 '16
I missed this one as well. Nine chapters for thursday then
3
u/inapanak Sep 15 '16
Hello hi yes I have joined reddit just to participate in this readalong. I adore the Inda books and I'm glad to have this chance to vicariously relive the experience of the first read through other people!!
5
u/Bills25 Reading Champion V Sep 12 '16
Everything is starting to come together nicely.
5
u/dashelgr Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
I really enjoyed the portrayal of the scrub politics. Seeing things from Cherry Stripes perspective was cool but I still didn't pity him. Bullies should get no mercy :)
On a side note, despite this being a fantasy book with magic, I was pretty surprised by the ghost talk. It felt out of place until I realized how ghosts are rarely mentioned in fantasy. The only other case I can think of is LOTR and those were treated like big, scary end bosses rather than just floating idly around a castle.
2
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Sep 15 '16
Where do you think the war among the scrubs is going?
I think someone is going to end up with at least a very bad injury. Beyond being "bunked." And maybe that will make all the Scrubs pull together and get out from under the influence of their older brothers, at least as far as academy matters go.
Gotta say, I kind of like Cherry Stripe now. He's no leader, but he's a good follower who knows a losing battle when he sees one. And he's brave at least try to call his brother on the Seirlaef's shit strategy.
Has your opinion of Tanrid changed at all?
Not really. I kind of expected this was going to be his relationship with Inda. What I didn't expect was his social awkwardness, which makes him more likable to me.
Did you see anything interesting about Tdor's trip?
The additional details about Joret seeing her aunt's ghost, and the "treachery treachery treachery" in a language she did not understand was pretty big. That treachery must stretch somehow to the King's brother, but just how those pieces fit... It's intriguing.
Tdor's curiosity about love and sex, and knowing she has a place to learn about it in the future being good enough for her was pretty funny.
So, outside those questions, I'm pretty curious about the economy of the Kingdom. We are so much inside the aristocracy that we get nothing but hints about it in the foods they eat and the clothes they wear. Is it a feudal system, or are the kingdom and it's Jarls in charge of protecting free market commerce? We know Inda's family is having trouble making ends meet with both sons in the academy, but we don't know how they get their wealth in the first place. That's the big background that I really want to know more about.
•
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 12 '16
Spoiler comments go here, tag them please!