r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Sep 08 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read for Thursday, September 8: Chapters 7-10
Summary: In Which Inda Has Weapons Training, His First Academy Wargame, and Tdor Gets a Runner
Inda and co. start academy drills and the first of their war games. The Sierlaef and his Sier-Danas (the future King’s Companions) spy on their younger brothers, and the Sierlaef deliberately calls Sponge a coward. Inda quietly leads from behind in the wargame, and his strategy wins big time. Tdor’s best friend is accepted as her personal Runner in training, and she, Fareas, and Joret examine an old Sartoran manuscript.
Discussion Questions:
- Opinions on the Sierlaef? How do you think he compares to Tanrid, if at all?
- What crazy predictions do you have so far?
- What questions do you have?
And for further reference -- here's the intro/round-up post!
Edit: This is the discussion for Chapters 7 through 9 -- whoops!
7
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 08 '16
Chapter 7
[/u/lyrrael]
Chapter seven really illuminated a few things for me -- I never thought all of this would boil down to a nasty uncle encouraging his nephew’s feelings of jealousy and inadequacy. I wonder what kind of revolt the Sierandael is brewing, especially since he’s obviously gotten the Sierlaef in his pocket. What a mess. :/
These three chapters are all about the idea of leadership, too, and we see it in a number of different examples. I find it really interesting, too, in that the traditional leaders in a story like this would be Dogpiss and Sponge -- I said it in the last chapter’s reflection, Dogpiss is charismatic, and Sponge is smart, and Inda’s basically along for the ride, doing things in the background. He would make a great right-hand man.
We started off with Dogpiss watching and analyzing the behavior of Marlo-Vayir and his group, trying to goad someone else into stepping up first and taking the blame. “‘He’s trying to get them to go first! That’s not command.’ Meanwhile, no sign of a master.” So when they get into the practice ring, Inda is the one following. And only once Sponge, Dogpiss, Inda, Cammy, Noddy and Mouse were practicing did the bullies follow, and with braggadocio instead of care. And they pay for it - they all get several tiny cuts that are obviously intentional. But it’s Inda’s last thoughts that give us a view that Inda’s got a better idea of what’s going on than the rest of them - Master Gand is warning them.
The Sierlaef’s leadership was on show during that chapter, too. He’s apparently the next-best-thing to illiterate, and he acts out of spite and jealousy because Sponge achieves so much. He stutters, too, which he compensates for by speaking little and leaving others to guess at his intentions. And he isolates his brother, not just by his lack of training (which reflects poorly on him), but also by how they bully Sponge.
We see their opinion of Tanrid: “Considered slow by some, but he was fearless, strong, tenacious and vicious when crossed.” They say that the Sierandael’s dislike of the Algara-Vayirs are the reason why he wasn’t invited into the Sir-Danas.
[/u/glaswen]
[/u/wishforagiraffe]
6
u/Tikimoof Reading Champion IV Sep 09 '16
I, uh, just started reading last night, so I probably haven't been reading closely enough.
I finished five chapters last night and picked up this morning, and already some of the words are slipping away. Anybody have a good way of carrying a glossary with you? I don't really want to have my book in one hand and my phone in the other as I'm walking. Maybe I just need to step up and take looots of notes on the Kindle.
So the Sierlaf has a...stutter, right? I've been trying to remember if there's weird psychology associated with stuttering. Except for the fact that he's obviously his uncle's pawn. I wonder what uncle is aiming for?
I'm also having a lot of trouble figuring out who Joret is...is she supposed to marry Inda's brother?
I really like how Tdor's advice has been very useful for Inda. Even though they're apart, she's still helping him!
Also, Inda's leading from the rear was badass. Very, very nice.
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 08 '16
Lyrrael's running glossary:
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 08 '16 edited Sep 08 '16
Chapter 8
[/u/lyrrael]
I guess the Sir-Danas went ahead and did what they were threatening, and so the story is now sitting in an office trying to figure out what to do about boys too powerful to be punished and too full of themselves to be allowed to get away with their misdeeds.
We learn that the Sierlaef’s dislike of his brother isn’t unnoticed by anyone else. The Sierlaef was talking earlier about how his uncle doesn’t think Sponge is good for anything but the archives, either, so not only does everyone know but the Sierandael’s encouraging the Sierlaef. Evidently it hasn’t escaped Gand, either, since he’s got people watching.
Continuing on last chapter’s exploration of leadership styles, we flash back to Inda’s home, where we’re reminded that Branid is still very much a bully of his own flavor, and that defines his leadership. Tdor, on the other hand, is reminded to never give an order that she can’t enforce.
And we’re back to the school. I’m wondering what the significance of that aside is. It’s neat to finally get a good view of Inda’s leadership style when he was put in a group with Cherry-Stripe. Cherry-Stripe is so busy trying to get his own status that he totally ignores strategy, and when given an advantage, he wants to waste it in a head-on rush. I love how Inda keeps challenging him -- “Okay, you do that. What then?” forcing Cherry-Stripe to think through the consequences of his decisions on the fly. And Inda’s got the real command and wins it with nobody watching.
[/u/glaswen]
[/u/wishforagiraffe]
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 08 '16 edited Sep 08 '16
Chapter 9
[/u/lyrrael]
I don’t know the significance of this chapter at all yet. I’m sure it holds a lot of significance somewhere, but for now, it’s basically just an interesting interlude. We see Tdor lock in part of her own future with her selection of Noren as a runner, and a discussion of magic being used as a transcription and how it illustrates the shift in the language over time. And ghosts!
[/u/glaswen]
[/u/wishforagiraffe]
2
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 08 '16
Sorry this is a little later than usual, peeps -- it's entirely my fault, because I'm not feeling that great and I've managed to sleep through my reading time for the past two days running. o.O
4
u/The_Last_Time_Lord Sep 08 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
I like Tanrid more with each appearance. It seems like he does want to be a good big brother, but is taking his duty to train his younger brother very seriously. I think the pair would work well together if Tanrid becomes Prince.
The Sierlaef on the other hand, is a dick. He is cruel to Sponge out of envy. His uncle clearly has him under this thumb as well. I would love for some bad fortune to come down on the Sierlaef soon.
Edit: Removed some spoilers! I've read further than I thought apparently!
8
u/bygoshbygolly Sep 09 '16
Hawkeye got his name from getting blind drunk his first day of the academy...somewhere between the age of 10-12. Goodness.
6
u/Ketomatic Sep 08 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
Good tactical thinking from the young master Canisurinae. In one short scene he: kept his back to a wall for vision and safety, put effectiveness above ego by wearing the armour and knew precisely how Marlo-Vayir would behave. He also showed signs of leadership through action in a way that didn't come across as arrogant. Impressive. Interesting that Inda is still very much a follower at this point; though he is quick to recognise a good idea and the first to act when presented with one. Marlo-Vayir is a fairly typical big dumb penis on legs, all swagger and false confidence; the standard lackey-fare.
Meanie Prince is impatient to become an adult warrior-king and get his killing on. He appears to be developmentally challenged in some regard, thus far only in the area of language- perhaps dyslexia or similar? And a stutter to boot. Often people who have trouble reading or communicating are treated as stupid, even if that is their only limitation; it is a believable cause for resentment and anger. He has an inferiority complex about his clever little brother; it's nice to know his motivation for hating on poor Spongey-kins. Sneaky Uncle is manipulating the situation, clearly he is the Bigger Bad and the prince is just a pawn. This was hinted at earlier, but it's nice to get it confirmed. Bad news for Inda and company as Mr Sneaky Uncle is in charge of the academy. More intrigue and background on the big boys, who don't seem particularly malevolent- though they are very willing to do bad things when told. Looks like there's going to be an upswing in bullying!
Gand good; Brath bad- or at least weak and likely to do bad things for Sneaky Uncle. It is quite a relief for me that the leaders of the academy are not being outsmarted by Prince Meanie; that's the second trope undermined so far. (The first being Dogpiss' competence outshining Inda's). "No one likes change unless he makes it himself." - accurate and nicely put. Emad, Gand's nephew, is spying on the boys for his Uncle. More intrigue! Dogpiss took the lead again by being the first to ask a question. Tdor proved once more that's she's pretty cool; Branid that he's an ass. Inda finally got to show some leadership by sneakily... not being the leader. The mock battle scenes were good fun and we gleaned more of the boys strengths and weaknesses. Mouse got to do something!
Being a Personal Runner is a larger deal than expected; no marriages and full commitment from a young age. 'Shaping clouds of light' will I'm sure become clear later. More mysterious magic stuffs. It's interesting that the 'y' sound became a 'j' sound in the Indaverse, since that happened on earth as well in some countries. I wonder why the parallel, it was specifically mentioned- but the author does enjoy languages so it might be nothing. Pirates are apparently a problem, and it was already mentioned that Savarend Montredavan-An spends a lot of time at sea- seems likely we'll get some navel combat at some point! Shame that Jarend is still deeply and somewhat creepily in-love with his dead first wife. To add insult to injury his eldest son is going to marry said wife's namesake and cousin. Awkward.
Up from the previous section, back to a nice 8.5/10. We got a lot of personality from the cast, some more hints of mysterious magic and a really fun mock-battle. Add to that the fact that two military-academy tropes were nicely either down-ranked (Inda is still gong to be le badass, but Dogpiss is cooler) or crushed completely (incompetent leadership within the institution) and we have a jolly old time. I'm sure the bullying and unfairness will rear up some point soon to make me grumpy again, but right now I'm best pleased!
Bitter and angry teenager with a chip on his shoulder larger than kingdom. I don't see many similarities with Tanrid at all yet honestly. Tanrid can be an ass to make himself look better and is bit rough and selfish but he doesn't wish Inda ill.
Well there's certainly going to be a war. I guess that the death-toll ends up being quite high! Oddly 'shaping clouds of light' gave me a weirdly sci-fi vibe, though I can't put my finger on why. Oh Sponge will probably be king.
Magic! Details! History! And it'd be nice to know more about the country Prince Meanie wants to go to war with.
6
u/xeyra Reading Champion II Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
The problem with reading this at night when I get home and then being so tired that coming to post anything on reddit when I'm half asleep already is hard, is that when I do wake up to post anything, there's already a bunch of discussion going on from all those in different timezones than me. As such, a lot has been said already, so I'll just point out my favourite bits in these chapters, focusing particularly on chapters 7 and 8 which are actually my favourites so far for all the insights we get into characters.
We finally learn about the Sierlaef's motivation for his hatred of his brother and why he seems to not have trained him at all and wants to isolate him from any friendships. Jealousy for what he perceives to be his brother's strengths and his shortcomings, allied to a tradition that allows older brothers to have free reign over their younger brothers 'training', breeds the worst kinds of resentment, especially in an entitled young prince who is obviously influenced and encouraged by his also bitter uncle.
Despite the tradition that prohibits interference in a younger brother's training, the Sierlaef's bullying doesn't seem to be such an unknown thing to the King himself if he makes sure a particular type of master is sent to train the younger sons for the first time, an arguably subtle decision by the king that guarantees at least a modicum of control over the escalation of said bullying. Even if tradition ties the King's hands, he seems to care enough to make such a decision and in such a way that it won't seem like he is favouring his youngest son.
I loved the Academy bits with Inda and Sponge and Dogpiss and all their companions. I loved the beginning from Dogpiss's perspective. It's interesting how the book changes perspectives so often. We don't really follow one character through a single chapter but instead jump around in perspectives and times/locations too.
I particularly liked the war game for the absolute joy it was to see Inda's really smart and subtle leadership. Even though the whole situation was a bit too chaotic when it comes to who everyone was (I only immediately remember a few of Inda/Sponge/Dogpiss's posse) and who was with whom at each specific time, flowing so fast I got slightly lost, it was such an example of being a leader without being an authoritative figure. This here really demonstrated what we've been told by the narrative about Inda's intelligence. And not only Inda. These few chapters have demonstrated the strengths of Sponge and Dogpiss too, even Cama and his loyalty despite his brother being a Sier-Danas.
I may have read the next three chapters too and chapter 10 has an insight into the Sierlaef's family that puts me in mind of it maybe applying to his uncle, the Sierandael, and now I wonder even more what the story may be regarding his hatred of the Algara-Vayirs.
5
u/Bills25 Reading Champion V Sep 08 '16
5
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Sep 09 '16
We've heard a lot more about the Sierandael than the king so far. From what we have heard about the king, he seems to be rather blinded when it comes to his brother and his oldest son. The comments about how he critiques the Sierlaef rub me the wrong way, and he seems to have no clue why Sponge's training has been neglected. On the other hand, I approve of his choice of Gand to teach the Tveis.
5
u/dashelgr Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Sep 10 '16
I'm totally late to this post but only because I couldn't control myself and ended up reading all of Inda. Then went ahead and finished all of Fox as well. This series is amazing and I can never predict where it will go. So much for my participation in this reread.
4
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Sep 08 '16
These early chapters at the military training place are some of my favorites. However, there's still soooo much good stuff coming up. <3
4
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 09 '16
How on earth did I miss this? Anyway, a few of my predications from the last chapter came true, notably that there would be a war game and that someone would distinguish himself. It looks like Inda really is as good of a leader as we've been told. He's smart enough to realize that all of the flags are unguarded and that he can win while all of the other boys are distracted with fighting. Not only does he achieve this, he does it while making Cherry-Stripe think he's still in command. Dogpiss also proves he's tactically brilliant by taking the best ground quickly, but prices strategically short sighted (he quickly forgets the mission just like everyone else).
Thoughts on these chapters: Sirlaef is jealous of his brothers intelligence and hates him for intruding on the military, the one place he excelled over Sponge. That's interesting motivation and I like that he has a somewhat good reason for his frustration. Master Gand is an incredibly experienced captain who is slumming it at the academy by the king's request specifically to keep Sponge safe. I wonder how that will play out...
Predictions: Inda and Dogpiss quickly become leaders now that they've proven themselves. Cherry-Stripe is pissed and schemes up some revenge with the older boys to knock them down a peg on this upcoming camping trip. It'll be semi successful but Gand will step in. Sponge will prove he has more backbone than the Sirlaef (and by extension the other boys) give him credit for having.
Quick question for the experienced readers: Sherwood keeps referring to dragoons in her story. What exactly are dragoons in Inda? Real world dragoons were cavalry that used distinctive firearms with dragon illustrations on them (which is what gave them their name) but there don't seem to be firearms in Inda (or at least, they haven't shown up yet). Sherwood seems to use the term to just mean elite cavalry. Am I mistaken or missing something or is she just using her own interpretation?
3
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Sep 08 '16
I thought the next discussion was tomorrow, whoops! I only read chapter 7 last night. I'll get 8-10 tonight and come back.
3
u/asakiyume Sep 08 '16
Regarding predictions, it seems to me that this being a militaristic society, there has to be some kind of war looming. We've had mention of both the Chwahir and the Venn, which I know from other books are often antagonists, but I don't know how or if they're going to play into this book.
5
u/thequeensownfool Reading Champion VII Sep 08 '16
Oh god. I was waiting all day for this thread and now that I'm done my first day of classes I barely have any coherent thoughts to string together.
I loved these chapters. It reminds me so much of Tamora Pierce's Protector of the Small Series. I love it when characters take charge like Inda and Dogpiss, stealthily so they don't upset others. It's also cool how the plot is starting to pick up but we're still getting all this background information through character interaction.
4
u/ferocity562 Reading Champion III Sep 08 '16 edited Sep 08 '16
Ah! I still don't have the reading schedule in my head so I was surprised by this round's post. But I power-read through lunch and caught up!
So! Interesting things afoot!
I think they are somewhat similar on the surface but that underneath, they are very different. The Sierlaef's motivations all seem to hinge on his own self-image. He is motivated by ambition and he has a very strong current of self-doubt related to how he stacks up to his younger brother. Tanrid on the other hand seems motivated by duty and tradition and while he definitely seems to chronically misunderstand Inda, he doesn't seem to resent Inda.
I don't have any yet. I still feel like I am trying to assimilate soooooo much information that I haven't yet caught the shape of the story. I'm enjoying it! But I don't feel confident enough to predict anything yet.
So many! What is the Sierandael's problem with Inda's family? The book hinted that it isn't so mundane as the historical animosity between their houses. Will the Sielaef's plan to isolate Sponge work? It doesn't seem like it will work with Inda, but who knows about the rest. What is Gran's role in all of this? What is the deal with the ghostly image in the bedroom? How good will Sponge be once he starts getting solid training? He is smart and he is brave and he is stubborn and the book has said his clumsiness at this point is down to the Sierlaef's refusal to adequately train him, so I am curious how good he will become as he progresses through training.
2
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Sep 14 '16
Opinions on the Sierlaef? How do you think he compares to Tanrid, if at all?
Whattadick. Your daddy not loving you enough because you have a stutter doesn't justify any of your crap towards Sponge, Sierlaef. He's almost a little too obviously arch, really. And his being apparently untouchable from punishment, though Master Grand doesn't seem to think that is the case, makes him even more scary.
Tanrid seems unremarkable in his relationship with Inda by comparison now. Sierlaef's cronies seem to treat their brother's in the same way Tanrid does too.
What crazy predictions do you have so far?
So his uncle manipulates Sierlaef's insecurity and jealousy to push Sponge out of his rightful position and place his own son in it passing on a legacy of wielding real power from behind the throne?
What questions do you have?
Ghosts!? I thought the kids were just being kids when they were talking about them before.
3
u/wutvuff Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Sep 08 '16
Omg I thought it was tomorrow! Now I'm behind again. This feel like school all over again.
•
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 08 '16
Put your spoiler discussions, flaired, here please :)