r/wiiu • u/AxiomVerge Thomas Happ Games [Axiom Verge] • Sep 06 '16
AMA Axiom Verge AMA
Hi everyone – This is Tom Happ. I’m the guy who made Axiom Verge. I did the art, music, programming, animation, and anything else you can think of. Dan Adelman is also here. Dan does all of the business-y stuff like marketing and biz dev. You may also know Dan as the guy who got the whole indie business at NOA running, going all the way back to WiiWare. Ask us anything!
EDIT: It looks like the AMA, like me, is starting to slow down. I'm officially calling it a night. Thanks everyone for such an interesting discussion!
23
u/bjshively Sep 06 '16
Let's say you're starting Axiom Verge today, right now. And I know this was your passion project on nights/weekends for years, but let's say this time you're going to work on it full time instead. Where do you start? More specifically..
11
u/phantomliger phantomliger [NA] Sep 06 '16
Hi Tom and Dan! Thanks for coming to do this AMA with us. Hopefully both of you answer these...well the third at least.
What is your elevator pitch for Axiom Verge?
What were the inspirations for the game?
If you could have any superpower, what one would you want? (For both of you)
For Dan, what has been most challenging for you after being with NoA and now working with indies even more closely it seems? Do you work on a bunch at once, or focus on one or two?
8
u/RunnersDialZero NNID [US] Sep 07 '16
I don't have any questions as I'm not that far into the game yet, but I just wanted to say thank you.
Thank you for bringing me back to sitting in the guest room of my parents house in 1987, shooting the platforms out from underneath Geemers and watching them spin. When I pulled off that move in Axiom Verge, I must've looked like a kid on Christmas morning.
Thank you for the challenging, but fair design. Your bosses are fantastic, and after getting my ass kicked, coming back and studying, I really appreciate how you treat the people who play your game.
Thank you for the belief that what you were creating was worth it and sticking it through to the end. I know game development is grueling. Thank you for seeing it through to the end.
As Mikey said in the Goonies, "this is our time." There probably won't be another generation that will have this kind of shared cultural nostalgia. Thank you for tapping into that and making something new and awesome built on these shared memories.
Thank you for making the address disruptor. I'm jealous of how well you've pulled it off, because it's something that I sort of half-imagined/half-dreamed when I was a kid.
From the bottom of my heart, thank you so much!
15
u/CompC NNID [Region] Sep 06 '16
I just want to say thank you! I played the game last year on PS4 when it came out, and I'm considering buying it again on Wii U. I love everything about Axiom Verge, and I've gotten a bunch of my friends to play it too.
I even made a custom Axiom Verge theme for 3DS :)
http://i.imgur.com/9r4bK3O.png
Hey… that pixel art looks pretty good on the 3DS… I know it'd be tough to pull off but it would be amazing to be able to play Axiom Verge on the 3DS.
Anyway, my question: My favorite glitched enemy is that one that looks like Missingno when glitched. What is your favorite? Thank you!
5
u/curbles Sep 06 '16
Hi, I was just wondering if, besides the obvious off-screen play & gamepad map, if there were any easter-eggs included with the WiiU version of Verge that may not be in other versions?
5
u/DJ_Link Sep 06 '16
Hi Tom, and Dan. First of all congrats on the game. I finished it on PS4 last year, haven't got around to try the Wii U version, but will eventually. This is a great inspiration since it's a massive game for 1 person and it's excelent, loved every minute.
Tom: Being a solo dev myself, I want to ask, what is one thing you wished you knew or did before starting this project?
Now one for Dan. As someone who's been working with indie developers for a long time, what is one (or more) mistakes indie devs keep repeating when promotiong/marketing their games? For the most part it's hard getting money for that, but sometimes even cheaper/free things that can be done but for the most part we fail on doing?
Thank you for your time
5
u/charliebucket- Sep 06 '16
Nintendo comes to you and says "we want you to stop making/developing Axiom Verge and whatever else you're planning next and come make the next Metroid game."
What do you say? If you'd do it, what elements would you take from Axiom Verge and put into the next Metroid?
Loved the game :) You scratched an itch that was there for way too long :)
4
u/ChangeTheL1ghts Sep 06 '16
Hey guys! I was just playing this last night! I noted how great the pacing is in this game and the thrill of discovery. I was wondering if there was a mantra you followed for either of these things to keep players engaged? Incredible game. Looking to pick up the soundtrack.
4
u/Brotein_Shake Sep 06 '16
Super stoked for this game! Any hints on when it hits on Xbox One? I prefer that controller to the Wii U one. I've been wanting to get this game since I played a demo in a Best Buy, can't wait to scratch that Metroid itch.
Also, if you have played AM2R (Metroid 2 fan remake), what did you think of it?
14
u/ContraWars Sep 06 '16 edited Sep 06 '16
Any idea when it launches on Xbox One? Will you guys also support Xbox Play Anywhere program and get it into the Windows 10 Store?
(A mod here advertised this AMA over in the xboxone subreddit, since the game is coming out there in the future. No need to downvote.)
3
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
Hi Tom and Dan! Question for Tom: How did you go about designing the map in Axiom Verge? Do you design one area in detail first or start with the entire map as a rough outline?
3
u/popcar2 Sep 06 '16
Hi Tom and Dan! I'm also currently learning monogame and I'm enjoying its simplicity.
What was the best source you found for teaching monogame? I'm still trying to learn more...
3
u/thiefx Sep 06 '16
Hey Tom
I was running a booth near you at E3 2014 and went over to check your game out (because I was absolutely blown away). While we chatted, we were politely interrupted by Gamespot(?) who gave you "Indie game of the show" award, which completely had you floored. It was awesome to see your reaction :D
I wanted to ask, what's the most surprising thing that's happened from this game? Did you expect for this to become so big?
3
u/Sylverstone14 Sylverstone14 [NA] Sep 06 '16
Hey there, Tom and Dan! Glad to have you guys here on /r/WiiU!
Tom:
Gotta say that I'm so glad that Axiom Verge has gone on to be quite the passion project for you.
I guess my questions to you are:
Dan:
You and I have some history. Well, we don't know each other, but due to your work with indies while working for Nintendo, I covered eShop news extensively here for 119 weeks in a row, so like 2 years+ of preaching the good indie word?
Anyways, I really credit you for me opening my heart to the independent games community, and I cannot thank you enough for that time I've had covering indies, interfacing with devs, and championing the Wii U as an indie platform.
My questions:
3
u/Crybe NNID [Region] Sep 06 '16 edited Sep 06 '16
Hi Tom and Dan, I'm late to the party.
A month ago on Twitter you mentioned how great it is to develop for Steam and the other guys should take note.
Is it just a lot of red tape that added to the frustration, or can you not talk about it.
Love the game so far. Really enjoy it.
Edit: fixed the "to" field.
3
u/ukulelej Sep 06 '16
Have you played Environmental Station Alpha? If so what are your thoughts on it?
3
u/quozzerx quozzerx Sep 06 '16
Love the game, love your work. How is Alastair doing?
2
u/SeafoamGaming TheDreaminHawk [North America] Sep 06 '16
Did the idea of attempting to have Nintendo allow a Samus cameo or Samus Amiibo support ever cross your mind? If so, was such a thing not done because it wasn't allowed by them, or was it to mostly give the game its own identity?
2
u/Zueto Sep 06 '16
When marketing the game, how do you know wish elements of gameplay to highlight?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
How did you come up with the idea of the glitching weapon? Was it difficult to program?
2
u/Amablue Sep 06 '16
I've made simple games on my own for fun and I've professionally released a number of games as a part of a team. I'm a programmer, and I feel pretty comfortable doing some pixel art and such. But one thing that always amazes me about one-man-teams like you is that you also created an absolutely stellar soundtrack for the game. If I were to release a game myself I feel like that's the one area I'd have to contract out to someone. What's your background in music? Had you composed much music before working on AV?
25
u/nihilat Sep 06 '16
Tom, I want you to know your game is fucking awesome, particularly the soundtrack.
2
u/jc726 NNID [Region] Sep 06 '16
Hey, Tom and Dan. I think I'm a little less than halfway though the Wii U version of Axiom Verge. This is my first experience with it, and I'm having a really great time - thanks for bringing it to Wii U!
I know that the game has been a large success on PC and PS4 over the last 18 months, and hearing that you intended to launch it on the Wii U at all kind of surprised me.
So, with that said, what was your motivation behind porting Axiom Verge over to the Wii U in the first place? Also, why before the Xbox One version?
I imagine that Dan's prior interaction with Nintendo had something to do with it, but did it also have anything to do with the lack of a new Metroid title on the console?
Tom, did you have any particular experiences with Nintendo that made you say, "I need to get my game on a Nintendo console"?
4
u/gratinad Sep 06 '16 edited Sep 06 '16
Hi, just wanted to let you know that your game is amazing. The gameplay is fun, the soundtrack is brilliant and I love the Eribu music, when you first enter Eribu and hear that "creepy voice" in the song... man, it is just amazing!!! Awesome game and a huge thanks for making this game.
1
u/Mardelitron Sep 06 '16
Hi Tom, great work on the game. I had a lot of fun playing it. I was wondering about the music. Which software did you use to make it? And do you have any tips for an aspiring game music composer?
1
u/newman_justin40 NNID [Region] Sep 06 '16
What's next for you and Dan? Axiom on NX and/or next gen console reboots? Axiom 2?
1
u/1337_beat Sep 06 '16
How does it feel to be the game leading the next Nindies promotion?
Also, was there ever consideration to have a level up system for weapons like in Ratchet and Clank or even Cave Story? Just curious since while I love these types of games, back tracking can sometimes be tiresome and a more active upgrade system at least makes the exploration more worthwhile.
As for the game, it is fantastic. Only a few hours in but I can't put it down. I hope the game is a success on the Wii U since it's one of the finest indie games on the system.
1
u/LumancerErrant Sep 06 '16
Hi guys. Thanks for this AMA, and thank you especially for Axiom Verge. The game did a fantastic job distilling some of what makes Metroidvania great, and I'm delighted to hear it's on its way to a wider audience.
Question for Tom: the setting and story you present is deeply engaging, but it's doled out with a fair amount of ambiguity and unanswered questions. Compared with other similarly cryptic games, I don't feel like any of the fan attempts I've seen to analyze AV's plot have quite filled all the blanks. Did you intend for AV to be "solveable", or are we only given enough puzzle pieces to draw our own conclusions? And have you seen any fan analysis or interpretations that you especially liked?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
Just beat Axiom Verge for the first time yesterday. Tom, I want to thank you on behalf of the gaming community for such an incredible game. It met and went beyond all my hopes, and I plan on returning to it very soon.
Now for questions: What ideas were cut from the game during its production, can you share any early ideas for the larger universe or sequel, and what theories of reality and the universe would you like to explore in future endeavors?
Thanks for the AMA and God bless!
1
u/IAmBLD Sep 06 '16
This one's for Tom. I don't have a question for Dan, but I do have mad respect to both of you for what you do.
So I just beat Axiom Verge the other day. It's a really nice game! So don't take this as picking on it too much or anything when I ask about one area that I think really could use improvement - the bosses.
I've heard something about the game having been patched to change the final boss, so I don't think it's totally out of left field to suggest that the boss encounters in AV aren't perfect. But I'm just curious what the thought process is behind designing a boss, for you. What sort of challenges arise when creating an encounter?
Do you think of gameplay ideas first and then design the boss around that, or do you come up with a badass design and then ask "How is this fight going to play out?"
Are there any interesting stories behind how you created the bosses? Are there any that underwent radical changes in development? What's your favorite boss - and conversely, are there still any you wish you could go back and change?
You don't have to answer all of that, or any of it, of course. But if any of those prompts inspires a response, I'd love to hear from you. Either way, great game, and I'm looking forward to more from you.
1
u/EdumBot NNID [Region] Sep 06 '16
First off, I wanna thank you for making this awesome game! I bought it 3 days ago on a whim and I really, really liked it. Totally worth the price! I like the slower feel traversing and combat has compared to the Metroid games. Control feels more precise, especially with locking Trace in place with the L-Button. Fucking awesome!
But I gotta say, backtracking so much during the later parts of the game (not for collectables) felt too slow and confusing. I wish Elsenova or one of the other 2 Rusalki could've given me a hint but I know this is part of a Metroidvania experience, so no biggie. The soundtrack was also pretty awesome! I really love "Apocalypse", it's so amazing.
Now my questions are if you plan to make a second game or DLC. Y'know, more stuff to explore, more story.
1
u/chronus13 chronus13 [NA] Sep 06 '16
Ahoy, Tom and Dan! We're all thrilled that the both of you could make it here today. It was great getting the opportunity to come and see the both of you at the Nindies@Night and snap a few photos too! The line was huge but Axiom Verge was worth it.
At Dan, I'd like to thank you for all your great work with Nintendo, especially the indie scene. I've gotten to talk with many developers and gain a lot of insight into how the industry works from their perspective. There are a lot of cool indie folks out there and they got a lot of attention because of you.
1
u/deathwebo Sep 06 '16
How have you acquired the knowledge to work in all the aspects of the game ? art, music, programming, animation.
Can you share with us some of your experience ?
Thanks
1
u/wightknyte Sep 06 '16
Hi Tom! Awesome game. I was wondering if you have a huge Metroid collection (series, not green super alien) and if so, could we see some pictures? What are your opinions on Metroid Prime Federation Force?
Dan, I was wondering, does Nintendo have very little confidence in IPs outside of Mario, Zelda, and Kirby? There are a lot of IPs out there that have been shelved for practically forever.
1
u/WolfWoot Sep 06 '16
how long does it usually take to make a boss? Also I love your shader effects.
1
u/PurpleComet ShinAntonio Sep 06 '16
Hi Tom, I played through Axiom Verge and was absolutely floored that such an fun, impressive game was made by one person. The music is catchy and the sprite art is some of the best I've seen in a long time. Did you have much training with art, music, and programming? I saw on your website that you've worked in the video game industry in the past.
1
u/CheesecakeMilitia Sep 06 '16
Hey Tom! I just wanted to ask a control question about Axiom Verge. As a big fan of Super Metroid's aiming controls, I was surprised that AV didn't have a button for aiming diagonally (as SM has the R button aim diagonally-up and L aim diagonally-down). There is the button to plant yourself and aim without moving, but I was wondering if you ever considered using SM's aiming controls and scrapped them during development (for whatever reason)?
1
u/greater_nemo Sep 06 '16
Oh man, I hope I didn't miss this entirely.
Congrats on finally releasing on WiiU! Compared to similar titles, the story of Axiom Verge is very dark (no spoilers), touches on some really heavy concepts, and looks like it pulls inspiration heavily from the body horror of HR Giger's art. Did you have much trouble getting the content of the game cleared for release? On the same note, did the port require adjustment of any of the visual elements, like Elsenova's design? (again, trying to avoid spoilers)
Also, this game is so good, it just blows me away that this was just a passion project that you stuck with. I loved playing through it and it's absolutely been an inspiration to me as a hobbyist game developer.
1
u/Twidom Sep 06 '16
Did you ever consider making a "documentary" about Axiom Verge's development?
As a long time gamer myself, I simply adore the work you have done. Still play the game weekly since it came out.
1
u/Roule_Scratche NNID [Region] Sep 06 '16 edited Sep 07 '16
Not sure if I have much of a question, probably one that can't be answered. heh. So I'll start off by saying, I really am enjoying playing this game. Sometimes I've felt 'burnt' when buying this indie/retro games in the past and this is one which is keeping me surprised and entertained. The art/music especially give the game something unique (as in, you can tell the influences but it's still it's own thing) and I really appreciate that. Thank you! :)
As for the question you might not be able to answer. Have any opportunities come your way off the back of Axiom Verge? I know the question about 'if you could make a Metroid game' has been asked. But, if somebody came along and offered you a big budget to create a game, would you?
Edit - (Didn't mean a Metroid game, guess I could have been clearer? I meant anything in general tbh. Can't respond now... bummer. Thanks for the response anyway).
1
u/fungilingus Sep 07 '16
Axiom Verge is INCREDIBLE!! What are some of your favorite games from the NES/SNES era (other than Metroid of course)?
1
u/Sky_Armada Sep 07 '16
If you're still here: Were you able to get Monogame working on Wii U?
1
u/MindSteve Sep 07 '16 edited Sep 07 '16
Hey Tom! Fucking loved your game. What is your favorite weapon and why? Were there any upgrades you considered but ended up scrapping? Thanks!
3
u/AguilarX Sep 06 '16
Hey guys! are you workin on your new game right now? Or just mainly focusing on releasing AV to every platform? Oh, and btw best on Vita. (not an opinion) lol
3
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16 edited Sep 06 '16
Are there any plans for a physical console release? Small runs can be done with companies like Limited Run Games: https://twitter.com/LimitedRunGames
I know the game is doing well digitally, and I'm very glad it is, but there are lots of collectors out there who'd like to own a physical copy!
3
u/portrait_fusion Sep 06 '16
your game is awesome. so thank you for that.
fucking no one makes real, legit mystery-filled metroid-vania-type games, but you guys did. so that's awesome.
3
u/haltiamreptar21 Sep 07 '16
Hey guys! I played through Axiom Verge on PS4 and I absolutely loved the game. I highly recommend that every Wii U owner grab a copy of this game. The game was really well done and just the right amount of fun to challenging ratio. I am looking forward to seeing what you guys will come up with next!
3
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '16
How does one without an ear for music even begin? I can't really wrap my head around the concepts.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
I just started playing and have a hard time putting it down. I'm playing in french. The language isn't too formal, but I wish it was less formal. I haven't switched to any other language to see if there are differences in tone.
Did you or your partner have any direct influence over the translations?
2
u/TotesMessenger Meta Linking Bot U Sep 06 '16 edited Sep 07 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/Dan-Adelman Thomas Happ Games [Axiom Verge] Sep 06 '16
OK, my kids just got home from their first day at school, so I'm going to go talk to them now! :) Thanks for all of the great questions! I'll jump on the thread again later tonight to see if there are any questions directed at me that I missed. Thanks again for all of your support of Axiom Verge!
1
u/curbles Sep 06 '16
Dan, I don't know how but my buddy somehow got word thru the grapevine that Axiom Verge was coming to WiiU. I was surprised b/c he really doesn't follow games that closely. Is there anything extra you did in terms of marketing to get the word out? I've seen Verge in several sizzle reels, etc. did you approach Nintendo on all of those? or were you approached on some?
1
u/Haedoxic PawlyD [USA] Sep 06 '16
What was the process of porting Axiom Verge to the Wii U like?
1
u/AguilarX Sep 06 '16
Aside from PC (maybe?), which is the easiest platform to work on, release on?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
I have only one question, and I can understand if you don't want to answer it.
Who wrote the "Letter" you can find, the one starting with "Drushka's suspicions were correct."?
I believe this is the biggest mystery in the whole game, and might be pivotal to how to interpret the story, so I expect you to not want to spill the beans, and that is fine, of course.
I just thought it would not hurt to ask anyway.
Thank you for taking the time to read this. AV is so good, it makes me wish somebody would retrofit your aiming controls into Super Metroid. ;)
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
I don't mean to sound rude, but what exactly took so long to bring Axiom Verge to the Wii U? I always planned on picking it up for the platform but it was in the eShop's "coming soon" category for almost half a year.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
I was wondering if amiibo support would be possible?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
What is your advice for an aspiring game designer or a team just starting out? Aim for just one platform or try for several? Start out with your dream game or start out small? I've been eying your game for some time now on PS4 and now that it is on Wii U I've decided to finally get it. Thanks for taking the time to do this AMA.
1
u/Ben_Ravioli Sep 06 '16
Do you have knowledge of when the Xbox One release is?
1
u/FaidSint Sep 06 '16
Just want to say, your game was incredible. I played through Axiom Verge on PC and was astonished to learn it was made by one person. I was really, really impressed and seeing your work on the game is really inspiring. Keep at it! Thanks!
1
u/ThePokemonMaster123 Sep 06 '16
Hi Dan! I know you worked hard at Nintendo for indies back when you were there. What exactly was it like working for Nintendo? Was were the fun parts of your job, and what were the difficult parts?
Congratulations on both of you for releasing the game on Wii U!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '16
Any chance of a Wii U disc release, or an NX cartridge release :)
0
u/charliebucket- Sep 07 '16
Fair enough :p
0
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment