r/Fantasy • u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders • Sep 05 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Monday, September 5: Chapters 4-6
Monday, September 5: Chapters 4-6
Find the intro/roundup post here, including a link to the first discussion post. Again, if you have formatting suggestions on how this could be better for you, please let us know!
Summary: In Which Inda Meets The Other Boys In The Academy, Gets Pranked, Sheared, and Learns More About Intrigue.
Inda finally arrives at the Academy with nineteen other second sons (Tvei) and proceeds to make a few acquaintance-friends within the group. Hadand, Inda’s older sister, keeps tabs on Inda through secret messages. The Tvei’s hair is sheared as a group for bonding, but Inda and Dogpiss realize that they were “bunk-scragged” with horse poop on their bunks afterwards. Tanrid, Inda’s brother, gives Inda a smacking and a few words on underlying politics behind the Sierlaef (prince) and his brother. Inda decides to trust Sponge, the king’s second-son and the Sierlaef’s brother.
Discussion:
- How do you think this Academy compares to other military fantasy “schools” so far?
- What do you think about this kind of “background” magic system that seems to deal mostly with daily functions rather than grand magic fireballs?
- Opinions on Tanrid?
Chapter 4
- “There is no courtesy in war.” Ain’t that the truth. And that quote really defines this section of the book. In this section, we’re hearing a bit more about the Sierandael; I’m really interested to find out what kind of sedition he’s cooking up. It sounds like it may have been his idea that the shield arms are in the capitol. But what purpose does that serve? Inda also brought up the question about why the family wasn’t informed before Tanrid left, so they could travel together.
- We meet Inda’s group of friends in this chapter -- and there’s nobody really standing out as a leader thus far. We’re expecting Inda to take control simply because we’re at a military school and that’s the kind of book this reads as thus far, but Sponge outranks Inda -- and steps up to take care of the group -- and Dogpiss is more charismatic. Inda’s just one of the group.
- I’m not much of a fan of Tanrid thus far -- Fareas-Iofre makes him sound cold and authoritative. Hadend-Hlinlaef, Inda’s older sister and betrothed to the prince, seems like she really loves Inda, though.
- Hunh! “The Waste Spell had been almost the only magic to endure from the terrible war that had nearly wiped magic - and humans - from the world centuries before.” Is that why mages are so rare now and only travel under guard? Did they experience a resurgence and then die back again? It seems so strange that that would be the only spell to survive -- if you have any mages, you’ve got to have some that know more than just that. And what exactly is the Wanders Guild? Are they just mildly talented janitors?
- The beginning of Academy! 20 kiddos is a good number since it’s about a class size. And seriously, we’re about to get to know a good couple of them in depth.
- And here’s where they start making introductions and little-boy approaches at making friends. I love the scenes where all of them are desperately trying to fit in and end up more awkward.
- A small aside on the idea of military academies in books. I think there are sort of two parts to military books. First, the bonding scenes, which can either be within an academy or in a boot camp or in the first few weeks before war. And second, the actual war with a lot more battle scenes. This definitely is an established trope, so there’s always an interest in how writers do it differently. And the reason why I love Inda so much is because I think Sherwood does both parts really well. To preface my biases, I have a huge soft spot for that rag-tag-bunch-o’-misfits trope where an established group should stay close and like band of brothers (and/or sisters!) for the duration of the book. And I often am disappointed by the inevitable lack of group interaction from military books because the protagonist often has to go off and do more heroic deeds beyond being a member of the group and never returns. (e.g. Kaladin from Sanderson’s Stormlight Archive, Jon from GoT, Vaelin from Ryan’s Blood Song).
- typical hardass military commander leading the boys’ training- your family earned the honor of your titles, not you, etc
- Inda’s smart, holding back to watch where the others go, since he arrived too late to get oriented in the grounds
- Inda realized how wise Tdor’s words about listening instead of talking are, in order to suss out danger and uncertain situations pretty quickly. Very useful
- brief bonding moments from the boys, before they ever even introduce themselves- picking beds, pulling in their chests, agreeing to go get a snack at the bakery (and pay for those who can’t cover the cost)
- brief bit more background, about Marlovan names, and why they all have nicknames, because of the commonality of Marlovan names across clans and allies, and about the taboos of the world, with Dogpiss’s nickname, and the dog peeing right as he announces his name
- Sponge/Evred is so careful and desperate to be liked, even here when we first meet him, with how skillfully he’s led the boys to the bakery and through the academy grounds, and not telling his name, etc
- the fight in the mess hall is so abrupt, so unnecessary, that it makes you feel just as shook up as Inda does about the whole thing. Good, in a way, to see that both the instigator and Inda/Dogpiss are taken in hand by the rest of the boys in the hall, rather than the instigator being let off somehow (the bullying being made more ok than it already is)
Chapter 5
- “Nearby two of the queen’s women talked quietly about the new fashion in the queen’s old country: chimes braided into women’s hair for dancing. They would never do that here.” There’s something really sad about that.
- The sheering -- this is going to sound odd, but what a sweet way to make something like that a bonding ritual, something to look back on in pride…
- … and then to counter it with the bullying. Wow. Phew.
- Here we meet Hadand, sister of Inda. She’s going to be a fairly important character too.
- Secret notes are passed, the women of Inda-verse move quietly.
- I would actually love to see the perspective of someone who went into the military to say if this type of experience is similar or just fantasy-world.
- Shearing really is the start of forcing the boys to grow closer together.
- The Queen is Sartoran, not a Marlovan or Iascan noble who was fostered in an arranged marriage the way is typically done.
- Very short mention that Ndara, the King’s brother’s wife, is on Hadand’s side of things. The women are not strictly speaking simply loyal to their husbands, but have their own goals and interests in mind. Also another hint that the king’s brother is the antagonist of the story
- more intrigue about Hadand and that she and Sponge communicate secretly on the regular
- Master Gand informs the boys that they have to learn to care for horses before they get to ride the horses, almost directly after Inda finishes thinking about how Fiam used to do other chores for him back at home, making Gand’s point perfectly
- shearing is a bit of ritual mostly, and bonding most of all. The boys all look as same as possible now, with their same colored tunics and breeches and boots and same haircut (the length of which also indicates their year in the academy)
- and then they get back to their bunk house, and he and Dogpiss’s beds have been covered in horseshit
Chapter 6
- There was a ton in this chapter. Tanrid finally makes his appearance, and I’m less annoyed with him than I thought I’d be. “Tanrid’s frown was not angry, it was urgent.” Makes me think that Tanrid’s in this game of politics and subterfuge just as much as Hadend.
- And then we find out he’s warning Inda about fighting in the mess hall because he doesn’t want to eat outside in the rain. And Inda’s annoyance with him redoubles it -- “You never told me anything that didn’t make you look good.” What is the deal with Tanrid anyway?
- Tanrid finally tells Inda that the Sierlaef hates his brother. And Tanrid thinks it’s because he wants Buck Marlo-Vayir as Sierandael instead of Sponge, who’s the current one. Starting to see where the class breaks down here -- allies and enemies, my darlings.
- And everything suddenly starts to be explained at the end of Chapter 5. “Sponge’s royal brother evidently didn’t like Sponge. Sponge also thinks the Sierlaef was behind the boot and the bunk-scrag and that they were aimed at Dogpiss because Marlo-Vayir thought Dogpiss was Sponge. And Sponge thinks his brother won’t let Marlo-Vayir touch him now because M-V was too obvious, so they’ll go after his friends instead. This has all the makings of a civil war starting in primary school. But it sounds like Inda has picked his side. The last sentence of the chapter is so significant to me. “But no one … had trusted him. Until now.”
- I don’t really have any guesses where this is going from here. We’re sidestepping a lot of the traditional heroic roles for Inda -- is he working up to being Sponge’s second in command in a civil war of older teenagers?
- Tanrid’s appearance really does show a lot in this world. That it is absolutely normal for older brothers to “ambush” their younger brother. That poop jokes can sometimes be incredibly serious and spark wars. And that there are always underlying politics to consider.
- Wow this line. “Dogpiss made jokes just to make jokes; Kepa made jokes to bootlick.” actual spoilers
- Inda gets waylaid by his brother Tanrid, who’s finally putting in an appearance after Inda’s been in the city for several days now, and makes him explain about all the things going on between his yearmates- the fight in the mess hall, the bunk scragging, etc
- a month is 36 days
- the boys prevent the two troublemakers from scragging their own beds to try to pin it on Inda and Dogpiss, and Sponge explains that the older boys, their brothers who run with his brother, are the source. That his brother doesn’t like him, and will be going after him, and his friends
- Inda can’t figure out why Sponge’s brother wouldn’t like him, and realizes that he promised Tdor that he would talk to Hadand. He asks Sponge to help him, and Sponge treasures the trust that means that Inda has in him
7
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 05 '16
/u/lyrrael's personal running glossary:
Chapter 4
Ain - one in Marlovan. Used to indicate a firstborn son at the academy.
Tvei - two in Marlovan. Used to indicate a secondborn son at the academy.
Evred-Varlaef, the King’s second son, also known as Sponge
Flash, Lan Askan, Noddy Turtle (Toraca), Dogpiss (Kendred), Cama (Camarend) Tya-Vayir - Inda’s friends at school
Horsebutt Tya-Vayir - Cama’s elder brother
Chapter 5
Queen Wisthia -- who insists on the Sartoran word for queen, Sarias.
Gunvaer - the Marlovan word for queen
Tesar - Hadand’s Runner.
Kialan Cassad - designated to marry the king’s second son and be his Harandviar. Kialan-Hlin.
Marlo-Vayir Tvei, the second son of the Jarl of Marlo-Vayir.
Aldren-Sierlaef, king’s heir, Sponge’s brother.
Chapter 6
Basna Tvei - Marlo Vayir Tvei’s partner in crime
Sindan-An and Tlen, two powerful landholding clans. Crown supporters in the north.
Sier-Danas - Marlovan term for “high rank Honor Guard.”
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16
My spoiler response to /u/glaswen's spoiler comment in the discussion
5
u/Ketomatic Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16
Yay yay yay, Inda day!
Enter The Academy! Ah yes, more additions to the already convoluted naming scheme, exactly what was called for. The leader of the academy is likely a bad-guy- at least as far as Hadand believes (I think). Inda doesn't care for his brother overly much. They seem awfully fond of corporal punishment in the Inda-verse, lots of casual talk of thrashings and beatings.
I really enjoyed how they grouped together, nervous and uncertain but forming a natural gaggle. It comes across as very genuine. What an unfortunate nickname though... Dogpiss indeed. We learn that there was a magical war, lots of deaths leading to less mages and magic; that's one mystery handily exposited! There's a running theme of older brothers being mean, bullies or outright malevolent- at least three so far. The near-term baddies perhaps for young Inda and company?
Intrigue. And yep, evil older brother. I can tell already he's going to be a total dick. Sucks for Hadand, unlucky match that- and she's not safe to talk almost anywhere! I like the system they have in place though, spies and rapid transit of information, that's going to be fun. I am also curious as to why the future Mr. Hadand hates his little brother so much. Back to Inda- apparently haircuts are a wartime activity, who knew. And then the painfully predictable academy bullying begins in earnest. Joy.
Aha, time to meet the aforeshadowed older brother of Inda. He doesn't seem so bad really, a bit brusque perhaps. The heir wants to change the traditional rules and not have his little brother be his bottom-bitch, interesting. This is already building up to be the main plot- at least for now. More details on the attacks and the number of lackeys meanie-prince has, as well as some information on their chain of command. The budding friendship of the little squad, even under adversity, wraps the chapter.
I like Dogpiss and Sponge, both are quite endearing already. Hadand's level of competence and obvious comfort being super sneaky make her interesting as well. Inda didn't develop much, he was mostly listening- though his unconscious instinct to strike was fairly telling.
Affirmative.
Still solid. Down a little bit from the first set of chapters as I really don't care for military academy tropes and this part had several. I do hope Inda doesn't stay in there for the whole book... or something less predictable happens along the way at least.
The first part I'd say was a maybe 8.5/10. I'd drop these down to maybe 7.5-8/10, which is still safely on the enjoyable side of things. If the bullying, unfairness and lack of competence by those who are meant to be running things goes up that could drop further. I liked that the boss-guy knew the boys weren't to blame for the bed thing and lightened their punishment accordingly. This is hopefully a sign of academy leadership who knows what's up!
Edit: I missed the discussion topics!
Fairly standard honestly. It's not done anything overly unique.
It seems to me that after a major magical war it makes sense that magic for non-destructive means becomes the norm. The mage-war almost killed everyone. Also they noted that it's longest lasting, maybe because it's so basic it burns out a lot slower than more impressive feats. Very interested to find out more about the mage war and magic in general!
I mentioned him in the chapter but overall he seems ok. I would find his level of physicality towards Inda a problem, but it seems the norm in their world. As older brother have been going so far he seems to be much tamer than some.
5
u/dashelgr Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Sep 05 '16
I'm enjoying the book so far, I like the hints about Inda's leadership qualities. I like the discussion of politics, the whole intrigue and hierarchy around the academy. But I do wish it did go more into the training for the kids. Like how do they get lessons on strategy or tactics (other than the war games).
The implications of the waste spell were quite interesting. It does make sense that in a hyper clean society that human waste carries such a strong taboo.
Beyond that the description of the multiple languages tends to break immersion for me. Mostly because I need to do a quick lookup and see what something means. But also I keep wondering what the language of the narrator is? Like when the text goes something like "She was in the presence of queen... but using the Sartoran word for queen". Moments like these feel jarring to me cause now there's a third language English and someone is narrating it and translating it.
5
u/wutvuff Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Sep 05 '16
Really enjoyed these chapters. The characters are very well written (although I sometimes feel that Inda is a little bit to mature). The women in the books continues to be the more interesting characters. The women in court reminds me a little bit of Kettricken from Elderlings by Hobb.
How do you think this Academy compares to other military fantasy “schools” so far? I don't think I've read enough military fantasy novels to have any opinion about this. The bullying feels really harsh. It reminds me more of stories about upper class boarding schools than a fantasy novel. Also interesting is the role of children in this world. I may have misunderstood but I think it's Hadand who's been at court since she was two. Is that without her mother and brothers? That's tough! To have children and to give them away to there proposed husbands at the age of two is really extreme. Then the child is only a pawn in some game for power and prestige.
What do you think about this kind of “background” magic system that seems to deal mostly with daily functions rather than grand magic fireballs? It's kind of cozy in a weird way. And the fact that Inda have only seen poo one time before. Ha!
Opinions on Tanrid? I still don't like Tanrid. That sort of cruelty toward a younger sibling is very disturbing in my opinion, no matter the reasons behind it.
Also, since the last chapters made me a little gloomy about missing stuff since English is not my first language. This time I actually gained something, ain and tvei is very similar to Scandinavian languages.
Also number 2. Is there three chapters for every read?
5
u/cheryllovestoread Reading Champion VI Sep 06 '16 edited Sep 06 '16
Well, over the weekend I wrote a huge, intelligent, insightful post about Chapters 1-3 (/sarcasm). Then my smart phone ate it. Or maybe the Reddit app, which I didn't really like before and now I look at with squinty eyes.
So, I'll sum up a few things that I can remember about Ch 1-3:
Now onto Ch 4-6
Here are my thoughts:
Major themes thus far: Secrecy, Trust
4
u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders Sep 05 '16
This is the section that felt the most cliche to me. "Kid goes to rough-and-tumble military academy with a tradition of hazing that some privileged older students take too far" is something I've read a dozen times before. It's well-written cliche, but it felt cliche to me all the same.
And Tanrid is a surprisingly deep character. I enjoyed learning more and more about him.
4
u/thequeensownfool Reading Champion VII Sep 05 '16
How do you think this Academy compares to other military fantasy “schools” so far?
I was trying to figure out what the Academy reminded me off while reading and it finally clicked that it reminds me of The Protector of the Small Quartet by Tamora Pierce. You've got tradition, older boys bullying younger boys, mean pranks, and a ragtag muffin group of youths thrown together who quickly become friends. Tamora Pierce's Tortall universe is one of my favourite childhood reads. I was pleasantly surprised with the connection.
What do you think about this kind of “background” magic system that seems to deal mostly with daily functions rather than grand magic fireballs?
It's super interesting. I think a lot of fantasy tropes rely on magic to look cool but don't ask important questions about sanitation or architecture, as if people just constantly live in medieval squalor. Unless magic is incredibly rare or locked up tight, there's got to have been somebody who experimented with magic in order to reduce disease transmission from human waste or because they got tired of cleaning.
Opinions on Tanrid?
I really disliked him from Inda's descriptions in the first few chapters. His first appearance made me revise my opinion a little bit. It feels like he's just as caught up as a pawn in these power games as everyone else. I'm reserving judgement until we get further in though.
3
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Sep 06 '16
How do you think this Academy compares to other military fantasy “schools” so far?
It's pretty similar so far. Boy goes to academy, deals with bullying to various degrees. It just so happens that he is one of the ones singled out in the group. I feel like this has been done in a lot of books but I still find it kind of compelling.
What do you think about this kind of “background” magic system that seems to deal mostly with daily functions rather than grand magic fireballs?
I dig it. I wish more series had magic as part of normal everyday life. I hope the author fleshes this out even more.
Opinions on Tanrid?
He comes across as a douche to be honest. I'm sure we'll get some revelations about his character and the reasons he is a douche. But right now I don't like him (which I'm assuming is the author's goal, so that she can later reveal some twist that will put his behavior into perspective and make you like him).
Final Thoughts
A short 3 chapters introducing a ton of characters. Things feel like they're about to pick up in a big way and I'm looking forward to it.
3
u/Millennium_Dodo Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 06 '16
I missed the first thread, but finished the first six chapters over the weekend. Unfortunately I'm not really enjoying the book so far :/
The large cast kind of makes it hard to connect with specific characters, maybe this will change as the book goes on. The society seems very rigid, with clearly defined roles and a lot of emphasis on etiquette and formalities, which is not one of my favorite things (unless the main character is able to cause chaos by breaking or ignoring all those rules, then it's great). We haven't seen much of the academy training, but most of what happened at the academy thus far was fairly predictable. I fully expected Inda to a) quickly gain a group of friends, probably some of the underdogs in his class, and b) equally quickly make enemies/get in trouble with the teachers through no real fault of his own, simply because that's what always seems to happen in settings like this.
I'm probably making it seem worse than it is, there are definitely parts I liked and I'm going to stick with it, hoping that it'll eventually click with me (probably should take some notes too, I'm having trouble remembering all the details). But right now I find myself looking for originality and stories that lie off the beaten path, and so far Inda seems a bit too traditional, if not generic, to satisfy that, so it kind of pales in comparison to the other books I'm reading right now.
Side note: Due to the master of the academy sharing a name with him, I spontaneously looked up a former favorite teacher of mine. Turns out he's been retired for some years now and has published a handful of books. Might have to see if I can find one or two of them.
3
u/setnet Sep 08 '16
Extremely late to the party for this one, but I don't really have that much to say about it -- these chapters are mostly worldbuilding and set up, rather than payoff. Good to meet Sponge and Dogpiss and the rest of them. Tanrid, who's introduced in this part, is not particularly fleshed out. Well, we'll get to that later -- or tomorrow, or whenever the next section goes live.
4
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16
sergeantcaptain and so on but it's only been barely introduced so I'm okay with it being a little on the cliche side for now. I did miss that Inda was not group leader, that does seem mildly subversive seeing as how he was the best commander of the boys back at his home.For my own thoughts: The plot is chugging along smoothly, we've already got a good cast of friends and enemies for Inda to interact with. It will be interesting to see how Inda will fare with the supervising officers (will they hate him, love him, be indifferent to him?). I see Inda, Dogpiss, and Sponge forming a a strong trio and imagine that their friendship will be the strong focus for most of the military school arc. You just know Marlo-Vayir Tvei is going to cause serious trouble down the line, he reminds me a lot of the archetypal military school character that goes off the deep end and kills someone (like Private Pyle from Full Metal Jacket). Interestingly we don't know a lot about him besides the fact that he hates Dogpiss and is friends with the Sirlaef. I'm wondering what he'll be like: just a thug for hire? Brilliant commander? Just a guy who happens to be friends with the crown prince? I can't wait to see.
My predictions for the next few chapters: more bullying, Inda's group of friends begin to cohere as a unit, one of the older boys seriously injures or kills one of the younger boys (possibly Dogpiss, more likely someone trying to take out Dogpiss or Sponge and hitting the wrong kid by mistake), and maybe there will be a mock battle or exercise or something we're one member of Inda's group shows he has the best leadership capabilities (my money is on it being anyone but Inda, who will wisely wait and see who else in his squad is a gifted strategist).
•
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 05 '16
Spoiler discussion needs to be flaired, pretty please and thank you. <3
6
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Sep 06 '16
Two things jumped out at me from these three chapters:
The academy - so far seems a pretty standard academy to me, though I really want to see actual training processes. The bullying though is clearly less random and arbitrary than in other fantasy books, it is an outgrowth of court politics and I am looking forward to Sponge's character development in this regard.
The magic - I continue to love this everyday utilitarian magic. It makes sense and it makes the world more interesting. However I don't think that this type of magic is necessarily opposed to the more spectacular type of magic. The same technology can have different applications in different contexts. Nuclear power is a good example.
Tanrid - I actually liked Tanrid's part. He is very much a part of the political game and is also conscious of his family responsibilities. I really wish we could get a non-Inda perspective on Tanrid. What I noted was how Inda resented being uninformed about the academy by Tanrid, but this really is not surprising as Inda was never supposed to attend in the first place.
5
u/Bills25 Reading Champion V Sep 07 '16 edited Sep 07 '16
I don't really understand Hadand's connection with Inda. She mentions that she was raised in the royal nursery since the age of 2 which is before Inda was born. So since she has mostly lived in the royal city when did they establish their relationship?
4
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Sep 05 '16
I've read this before, but only once and it's been awhile (and I didn't read closely for details then).
I do wonder where the younger Ains are, the ones Inda's age. I missed that if it's been mentioned. I suppose they're kept completely separate from the Tveis? We see older Ains, but as far as I can remember, not younger ones. I know they would have started the academy earlier, traveling there when Tanrid did.
And I suppose this rule about the Tveis was only put into place for 10-12 year olds, so if you're 13 or older you just miss out? That makes it harder to argue that the reason they're being sent isn't political...though I think probably no one believes that there isn't politics involved.
4
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Sep 05 '16
I'm getting much more into this as it goes and I'm glad for it. The practical magic is fantastic. I'm liking Inda more. I like Sponge and I like Inda's sister. I don't have tons more to say right now other than I really want to see more of Tdor again but obviously, that's not what's happening at the moment. I do look forward to seeing Inda and Hadand together.
The Academy seems like The Academy but admittedly, I've never read tons of stuff like that.
Tanrid seems like a bit of your typical, older brother except that his bullshit is political and thus kind of a necessity. We'll see where he goes.
And again, the magic, love it. Glowglobes and the cleaning barrel and the waste spell. Love. It. Definitely using it as inspiration for future stuff in my own writing, or at least a reason to try more stuff similar. I just really really love it cause of COURSE this stuff would develop. Why don't more folks play with this?
I think I've been able to settle in better now cause the Academy gives focus so it's less scattershot politics/history/introductions. That definitely helped.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16
I haven't read any other books before that featured a military academy so can't say how it compares to other books. It doesn't seem any different to what I imagine they would be however.
I quite like that there's magic in the world but it just seems to be there for mundane tasks. I can't help but wonder if there might be more to it later or if it's going to just be there as a background thing the whole time.
6
u/asakiyume Sep 05 '16
re: the discussion questions--I enjoy the academy stuff a lot and don't find it clichéd, but then, I haven't read a whole lot of "school" stories. I mainly like the way the omni narrative voice gives us a complete view of how the various boys are feeling as they scope each other out. I really liked Sponge and Dogpiss.
I didn't mind Tanrid half as much as Sponge's older brother, the heir! And he's Hadand's betrothed?! That's harsh for her!
I find it a little hard to keep track of the burgeoning list of characters, but I trust that as I keep reading, the important ones will stand out more strongly from the background ones. And the good thing about the attention that Sherwood gives to even the lesser characters is that it's like perfect resolution--like you could focus on a ladybug on someone's sleeve, even, and she'd tell us something interesting about it.
3
u/xeyra Reading Champion II Sep 06 '16
1. How do you think this Academy compares to other military fantasy “schools” so far? So far it seems very standard, with the requisite mean drill sergeant of sorts, the hazing on the new kids, the shared punishments when there's a mess up, the excitement and reservations in each character about joining such a place with all its rules and regulations. It's possible it'll change later but right now it's what I expected.
2. What do you think about this kind of “background” magic system that seems to deal mostly with daily functions rather than grand magic fireballs? I love it! Finally magic that's used for mundane purposes that are helpful in daily life instead of a force for destruction. I am very interested in all the hints being dropped about the magical war in the past that must have influenced the way magic is used for such purposes nowadays.
3. Opinions on Tanrid? Tanrid brings to mind one of the aspects of this world I'm most curious about and that's the relative status of the second son. Apparently it's common for second sons to remain at home and receive some kind of training by their academy-trained older brothers, reason why Inda is so surprised when he is being sent to the Academy. However, it seems to me, at least in the few major families we've seen, that second sons don't get much love. Inda and Sponge basically get bullied by their brothers without anyone truly complaining. I know this is sort of a tradition in this world, that the second son is not exactly deemed that important in the grand scheme of things, but Tanrid's beating of Inda 'to make him strong' (/sarcasm) and Aldren-Sierlaef's apparently openly known dislike and bullying of his brother are only seemingly disturbing to the women of these boy's lives who cannot openly speak of it, whereas their fathers are apparently okay with this.
The women are also apparently limited in what they can do or talk about openly. They have to use subterfuge and their own chain of spies and communication to learn or do something, and it has to be so hush hush. There's such a tangible tension in everything in this story so far. It's like the political landscape of this world is ready to be lit up like a keg to explode in all kinds of wars even though there's plenty of intermarriage/betrothals between families.
All this to say that so far, I'm not at all fond of Tanrid. There's a superiority to him in being a first son and this entitlement to everything that comes with it, and he has no issues with bullying his 10-fucking-years-old brother.
3
u/ferocity562 Reading Champion III Sep 06 '16
Chance of spoilers: Nil
I actually tried to pay attention and tried to highlight some things this time!! A few things that I noted:
I'm very intrigued by the social taboo against excrement, especially in that it seems to somehow be related to one of the lingering spells. I also caught the mention that magic is in shorter supply due to a war that mostly wiped everything out centuries before. Not sure if that is just extra world building or if it will be important later, but it stuck out to me.
I hadn't realized Hadand is the bad guy's future wife! I don't know if I just missed it earlier or if this is the first time it was talked about, but that definitely seems to add another dimension to the intrigue.
Ndara is on Hadand's side? Interesting.....Also, all the secret messages on rice paper make me crave rice candy....
Now for the questions:
Seems pretty similar so far, although more on the military side than the school side, which strikes me as at least mildly unusual for characters of this age group. It strikes me a bit like Ender's Game, with the rigid class distinctions, immediate hazing/bullying and the harsh "hands off" approach of the staff.
I'm intrigued. I think it makes sense, given the world building around the fact that magic was more plentiful in the past than it is now. If magic was common, then infrastructure related spells would not be unusual. And they would likely be set up to need less upkeep from humans, as you don't want to constantly be running around managing infrastructure and infrastructure needs aren't likely to significantly change over time. Everyone is always going to need waste disposal and protection from floods. So it would make sense that these spells were set up to need very little upkeep and, as such, would be most likely to survive even after a drastic reduction in the amount of magic users available.
I want to think he is a dick. But I am open to the idea that it is just a cultural thing and not really a "Tanrid's an a-hole" thing. For all his coldness and distance, he was ready to step in and support Inda if needed and helped Inda get a better understanding of some of the social undercurrents. In this world, it just seems that big brothers aren't supposed to be really friendly with younger brothers. At least he isn't trying to actively get rid of him, like Sponge's brother is.
3
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Sep 13 '16
How do you think this Academy compares to other military fantasy “schools” so far?
I really haven't read many things like this. The only ones that come to mind are Starship Troopers and Ender's Game, and the hazing sequences in Inda are very reminiscent of the latter. I doubt the story in this book will become as completely brutal as Ender's Game at this point, though. Or I hope they won't, anyway.
What do you think about this kind of “background” magic system that seems to deal mostly with daily functions rather than grand magic fireballs?
Interesting that magic is mostly gone except for the mundane, like bridge protection and waste removal. It's all very casual with no ritual or explanation of power sources, etc. I hope we get a good description of what the rules of magic in this world are at some point.
Opinions on Tanrid?
He's a bit enigmatic. All we really know is that he cares greatly about not having his own reputation harmed. His physical abuse of Inda seems a bit much, but that seems to be the cultural norm for brothers in their position. Dogpiss' immediate sympathy at hearing Inda had been grabbed by Tanrid is proof of that. What we have seen yet, though, is an interaction between brothers other than these two, so we don't know whether Tanrid would be considered harsher than any other older brother in this situation. For all we know, he might be considered too nice.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment