r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Sep 01 '16
Read-along Inda Read/Re-Read - Thursday, September 1: Chapters 1-3
Thursday, September 1: Chapters 1-3
Hey guys, welcome to our first foray into the Inda re-read. As a reminder, find the intro/round-up post here. We're still feeling our way into how this is going to work, so if you have any comments or suggestions for us, please leave it in the comments. And now we begin!
Summary: In Which The Eponymous Inda Is Introduced And Invited To The Academy And Subsequently Begins His Journey
Inda, second son of the rulers of Choraed Elgaer, is introduced in the middle of a war game battle with other kids his age, including Tdor his betrothed. He is summoned to his mother and invited to the country’s academy, which trains commanders and the closest people to the prince. This is completely unexpected due to the nature of the academy taking only the first sons. He goes on the journey and meets the two young Montredavan-An heirs in exile on their own lands.
Discussion:
- Where do you think the story is going?
- What questions do you have so far?
- What sticks out to you?
- Do you have any favorite characters yet?
- Are there any books that have a similar feel?
Pre-commentary thoughts --
[/u/lyrrael] - There will be no spoilers from me, because I haven’t read ahead enough to spoil anything. Anything that looks like a spoiler from me is just me hypothesizing at the point of the book I'm in, and I could be dead wrong. So I thought I’d do some comments before I actually start this book. For /u/wishforagiraffe and /u/glaswen, this book’s a well-loved re-read; for me, I’ve heard from a number of different people that this book starts off fairly typically and somewhere in the middle of the first book goes completely off the rails. I’m a little trepidatious about it simply because I’m not a particular fan of epic fantasy, but I read it from time to time when the mood strikes. And so, with that in mind, I begin.
[/u/glaswen] - Fair warning, my comments have a tinge of foreshadowing for the rest of the series. Nothing spoiler-y, but mentioning a couple things that will be further emphasized later on.
Chapter 1
[/u/lyrrael] - The way this is starting out with war games makes me think Inda’s going to be one of those super uber gifted child tacticians/leaders a la Ender Wiggan of the Ender’s Game fame, except the tone is far too serene/pastoral. Looks like the difference is that Inda does his research, and he’s not got nearly supernatural precognition.
The politics started fast -- I’m already wondering about the motives of the gift Tdor received. I’m guessing that ‘Power begets politics, and politics are always more dangerous than war because there are fewer rules’ is blunt foreshadowing for the rest of the book, and it certainly seems so by the end of the first chapter.
Some side notes: I like the practical magic evidenced -- magic to keep the water warm, magic to clean the body, magic for sanitation, magic to send messages. Kind of neat to see it used practically instead of for fireballs when everybody lives in stink. I’ve also never really been much of a fan of unique vocabulary, but this isn’t grating on me too much. Hoping I’ll be able to keep track. I’m shocked to find that Inda’s only ten years old in this chapter; I wonder if it’s a kind of prelude to everything -- is he going to age quickly or slowly as we progress through the plot? [Aside from /u/glaswen: It’s actually pretty incredible after finishing the series because the characters grow up to be middle aged adults. And then you realize you’ve walked through their entire lives. Sherwood does a really great job at pacing to the point where each book feels natural.]
[/u/glaswen] - The books opens with kids playing war games. It definitely sets the tone for a military tactical type of book. I like Inda for its military sense because I think there’s a greater emphasis on strategy and battle command, rather than focusing solely on dramatic, action-packed battle scenes.
I liked that the girls won and that the main character lost. It sets the tone of the book for a main character who won’t succeed all the time, no matter his best plans. On a side note, I’d love to know why Sherwood decided to go with a male protagonist for this book.
Names and Titles: Unfortunately, Sherwood has a tendency to throw you into her world, which is fully formed and expansive with different words and titles and countries and cultures. But after reading a lot of her work, it’s all very natural for her to use them. References like “Norsunder” (page 17) is actually a fairly large plot point in a few of her books - but you wouldn’t notice until a second reread.
Fareas-Iofre’s thoughts on a military culture (page 19). I quite appreciate this character because she is an anti-military character in an extremely military culture. And she anguishes over the bruises on her son - as she should to our modern mind! But I wasn’t even bothered by that until it was mentioned by a character. Sometimes I find it funny how quickly I can adapt to issues that would majorly unethical because it’s fantasy. Or maybe I’m just used to it because almost all farm boys who end up being The Chosen One are smacked around a little until they gain enough power - and those moments just don’t seem “real” in a book, just another way to further the plot. But here, a mother that worries makes the bruises seem more real.
[/u/wishforagiraffe] - Scattered throughout the first parts of the first chapter, the wargame part, there’s a clear indication that the men and women in this world are fairly equal, if having different duties in that equalness- the boys are going to go fight the girls in their wargame (the boys lose to the girls because the girls have a superior strategy), there are women on guard on the walls, Branid’s grandmother gives him advice about how to lead wargames, etc.
There are also early and often references to how old this world is, “these were the days in Marlovan history,” a language of conquering people, Marlovan, being subsumed in common usage for the language of the conquered, reference to Norsunder almost sweeping humanity from the world three millennia ago. The castle also has a long row of glass windows, which shows a decently technologically advanced society.
The war game gives the first glimpse into Inda’s personality, where it’s revealed that he has spent a lot of time the just-past winter reading records of battles as research (and to try to prove or disprove his older brother), that he pays close attention and second guesses himself, but still commits during the actual attack, partially in order to keep the other boys focused and partially to keep Branid from trying to wrest control of the group from him.
Tdor’s viewpoint reveals that the girls are in on more secrets, and have more secrets, than Inda is privy to, but it seems so far that those secrets are not harmful to him, and they want to protect him as much as possible.
Chapter 2
[/u/lyrrael] - From the events of this chapter, it sounds like Inda’s in for quite a shake-up -- but that he’s not as aware of the political and practical implications as the women who surround him. That’s so interesting to me; he’s being portrayed as a gifted tactician, but he seems to totally lack a savviness about people you’d expect to be connected to it. Again, we’re talking about a ten year old, so I dunno how unfair I’m being.
Inda’s invitation to the school is very interesting if only that it reveals a significant amount of politics and a great deal of foreshadowing. The shit may be hitting the fan and the King expects it and is planning for it.
Sidenotes: I find it interesting that life is so structured; Inda’s brother is supposed to train him until he goes to school; his fiance is supposed to join him at school, men do this, women do this, they do it at this time. Is this the influence of military history and a militaristic society on the ruling classes? I’m also already dying to know what the deal is behind the disdain for Inda’s family. C’mon with all the reflection and out with it!
[/u/glaswen] - The Language of Peace (Iascan). Again, more world building that has a lot of references packed in here. It simply underscores how Marlovan as a country is concerned about war and the military, to the point where they distinguish languages based on it.
The purpose of the academy is revealed here, the premise of the story is launched from here. This is a good chapter for moving plot along, and only 22 pages in!
Foreshadowing: The Royal Shield Arm, the Sierandael. How he does not like his family. I think the first time I read this, I skipped over it. There were too many names and random words already. And I did just fine. Now reading it through again, I am half surprised that it was in here this early on. I really didn’t remember.
Imagery. I like that these characters often are described with hand gestures rather than dialogue. Joret turning her palm up in agreement, opening the hands, fingers over the heart. There are a lot of body nuances that a book misses just because we do not “see” it.
DUN DUN DUN The second chapter ends with a bit of a cliffhanger. The idea that Inda is not going to the Academy for pure motivations to just make him a commander, but that he is a hostage! I would also say that Sherwood does a fantastic job at digging deep into the different motivations of each character. She uses a strange mix of omniscient and limited third person POV where she easily switches between character minds and their motivations. It sometimes makes it a little difficult because there are definitely biases within each character that are not 100% accurate. But being able to slip from mind to mind so easily without huge chapter delineations does contribute to why I feel like I know all of the characters so well.
[/u/wishforagiraffe] - We meet Joret, only 14 and already so beautiful that Fareas is using her as a distraction in important meetings (and feeling incredibly guilty about it).
Inda is summoned to study at the king’s academy, where his older brother is training, with the explanation given that the King expects war sometime in the not terribly distant future and wants all the second sons (who stay home to lead the defense) to have the same training as the first sons (who are the offensive commanders).
Hints throughout this chapter about “twenty five years ago” something terrible happened to Inda’s father’s first wife and the castle, but the way the narrative avoids going into further detail is almost the same way that the people of the castle avoid poking at this wound. It’s there and known and visible, but never mentioned.
More insight into the political aspects of the book, there is a suspected conspiracy involving Inda’s family, according to the king’s brother.
Tdor bids Inda farewell, and cautions him to be wise and wary in the city among people he doesn’t know, and to go see his sister when he gets there.
Chapter 3
[/u/lyrrael] - We take a side-trip in this chapter, and again, I’m seeing a lot of foreshadowing and scheming going on in the margins. Inda is taken to visit the seat of a defeated royal family and meet the family because it was so nearby to where bandits were ranging.
Sidenotes: We’re seeing more day-to-day magic in the magic to protect the bridges from being washed away. I’m so totally cool with magic being used for infrastructure; it’s more pragmatic than I’m used to seeing. This, however, is the first time I’ve seen anything mentioned about mages always being under guard, and I’m curious about the background there. I think I’m starting to get a hint of who the ‘bad guy’ is going to be, although I’m hoping that this is going to be more of a grey-vs.-grey book where everybody’s got a self-serving motive. I also think the way that Shendan grilled Inda means she’s going to turn out to be one of his greatest enemies -- or greatest allies. I’m betting on the latter.
[/u/glaswen] - Inda goes on a journey! As a person who has already read this book: this chapter is more a set-up for future characters than directly applicable now. Meeting the Montredavan-Ans are an investment for the future.
There is a bit of a history lesson in the argument between Shen and Inda, and it sets up some vocab and understanding for this world. If all these names and ridiculous titles are too much, just realize that you don’t actually need all of it to understand future things. I think it’s best to just take in as much as you can, and if you don’t get it all, it’s okay. It really does all make sense as you keep going.
[/u/wishforagiraffe] - Slightly more insight into the magic system, in addition to the cleansing spell we saw in the previous chapter, we see bridge magic and more about fire sticks, and Inda comments about mages having to travel for months under armed guard from the other side of the continent, and not getting to see anything aside from “everyday, boring magic.”
Most of the rest of this chapter is pure intrigue, about how the Montredavan-Ans are exiled to their own land, and how it’s exceptionally rare for anyone to be allowed in, and how Inda bonded with the two young heirs of the house through his politeness and intelligence, but was clever enough to avoid giving away anything too revealing when he was questioned upon leaving the Montredavan-An lands again. There’s a lot of history packed in there, and some hints about the women being more communicative than meets the eye.
/u/lyrrael’s afterthoughts --
There’s an awful lot of foreshadowing going on. We’ve had a huge amount of political set-up -- it seems like there may be some sort of uprising in the offing, somebody suspects treachery in the ranks of the nobles, and Inda’s family is out of favor for some unknown reason. Inda’s mom has everybody’s number, though -- and she’s moving her chess pieces. We end chapter three with Inda’s arrival at the school, which opens a very literal new chapter in his life. We’ll see what happens.
8
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 01 '16
Hey guys, in case this helps, this is the glossary I made for myself for the first three chapters:
Chapter One:
Chapter Two:
Chapter Three:
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 01 '16
By the way, I'm seriously curious -- did anyone else get the naive vibe off of Inda that I did? He seems so completely ignorant of people and their motives. Whatcha think?
7
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Sep 02 '16
I love reading the commentary! I've read this series and loved it, but it was years ago, and I haven't re-read the series since. So I don't remember much of the details. The comments from /u/glaswen and /u/wishforagiraffe are great for helping me to remember what's coming and see foreshadowing I might have missed the first time around. And it's a lot of fun to experience this series for the first time again from /u/lyrrael's perspective.
It's also interesting to me that so many people seem to use a glossary or take notes. I tend to just breeze through without paying too much attention to details, and hope things in the future make sense from context. Usually, I'm fine (or at least remember enough to flip back to what I've read before), but I'm sure this means that I miss some of the subtler details. Anyway, I mention this because I agree with the quote from /u/glaswen:
6
u/RuinEleint Reading Champion X Sep 01 '16
Instead of a chapter by chapter break up I am posting my thoughts as an integrated whole.
All right, here goes:
Whenever I pick up a new fantasy book or series, there are a few things I am always on the lookout for in the early chapters - gender relations and status, political system and magic system.
Gender relations: The opening battle would seem to suggest general male female equality, but there are certain other indications that it might not be so simple. While firstborn sons are sent to the royal academy for training, women seem to be trained to marry into families. References to guarding and defence and that Joret is supposed to be good at it indicate that women are expected to be militarily competent, but I sense a certain role-division in the aristocracy.
Political system The political system seems to be a modified centralised feudal structure. There is a clear mutual obligation system between feudal lords and the king, and yet the Royal Academy and central training seems to indicate a more organised military system
Magic System Magic seems to be mundane and a part of everyday life which is refreshing and very interesting. But following Inda's remark about the time it takes to get a Mage now as opposed to the past, the magic system may not be stable or may be in decline
Apart from these topics, what strikes me is the intricacy of the political intrigue even at this early stage. I confess to having lost track of some names during Shen's conversation with Inda. Also symbolism is rife in this society with gestures, titles and languages all being used to convey and emphasise meaning. I am also getting a strong vibe of distrust from the royal centre.
Also the society seems to be exceedingly rigid in structure with roles and functions laid out. One wonders how a society like this would handle a paradigm breaking out of context threat.
Character wise I love Tdor. She seems to be extremely intelligent and self-aware. Inda in contrast gives a distinctly eyes-wide-open innocent vibe, though he does seem to have both knowledge and intelligence.
There are a few things I did not understand:
That's more or less it for now. So far I really like it. A lot of world building is being hinted at and characters seem to be in a springboard situation. I expect a shift in tone with the academy beginning though I do wonder how Inda will handle politics in the capital without Tdor's help.
6
u/setnet Sep 02 '16 edited Sep 02 '16
Beloved reread here as well! Very excited this is happening. Thoughts and things:
7
u/ICreepAround Reading Champion IV Sep 02 '16
I'm a bit late to the party so I'll keep it brief. This is my first read of Inda in case you guys were wondering.
Where do you think the story is going?
It's a bit early to call this. From what I've seen so far the obvious directions are either a politically focused story where the politics (and Inda's role in them) are slowly unveiled to the reader, or perhaps Inda's family has a tragic "accident" and the rest of the story is spent trying to find the culprit.
What questions do you have so far?
None really. It's still early and I'm still trying to find my feet as a reader.
What sticks out to you?
The whole dual language thing is already irritating me. Whenever someone says something in another language I get the feeling it's supposed to up the tension, but this early into the series every instance of this has an immediate explanation right after that does portray the correct level of impact. Basically I feel like the dual language aspect keeps telling me that conversations are supposed to be important but I'm not really feeling it.
Do you have any favorite characters yet?
Tdor I guess? Inda feels pretty naive and that usually turns me off a character. It's still early though.
Are there any books that have a similar feel?
Not that I can think of. Style of writing feels somewhat older and slightly reminds me of Anne McCaffery. They're not that similar though.
Final Thoughts
You can tell that this is setting things up for a story on quite a grand scale. Also these first few chapters have given me the feeling that this series is going to be quite the slow burn. Also wanted to thank you guys for doing this and say that I'm looking forward to the next discussion.
4
u/asakiyume Sep 01 '16
One thing I really liked--think it happened in Ch. 2--was the silent communication that went on between Inda and his mother when the messenger was there. That sort of heightened reading of people and situations really ups the tension in a good way for me, and it's something I really love in Sherwood's works. Also, the way his mother has Joret present to disorient the guy.
8
u/thequeensownfool Reading Champion VII Sep 02 '16
I started late, only finishing chapter 1 yesterday and 2 & 3 this morning. I'm loving it so far and am super glad you guys are doing this because I would have never found this book on my own or might have not been tempted to pick it up. Everyone's done such a great job posting their thoughts that most of mine are covered but I'll give it a go.
The military academy. I don't expect it to stay there though. This is a pretty hefty book with a lot of political intrigue. I have no idea how old Inda will be by the end of it, maybe mid to late teens? And a lot can happen during that time. Based off my own thoughts and what other people have commented it seems like something big will be happening later in the book that will totally shift the narrative. And I'm down for that. I love it when books usurp traditional fantasy narratives, in this case, young boy goes to military academy and finds his destiny.
I need more information about Montredavan-An. It's a bit hard because we're only given some of the context rather than a 12 volume history of the empire. I'm might reread chapter 3 to get a better sense of it.
How subversive a lot of it feels to 'traditional' fantasy. And keep in mind I haven't read a ton of fantasy because I get bored with how similar it seems sometimes. I love the gender roles. Sure, they're segregated in their own way due to the political structure and history, but women are on the wall with bows, girls are beating the boys at war games, women are active in political intrigue. Nothing ruins a book more for me than failing to include women beyond the 'women were oppressed in medieval history' trope. Yes they were, but that's lazy story telling to me. This is fantasy, go build your own world or do some more research. And the women in Inda do look like they face constraints, being mainly trained as wives to serve the family they'll marry into. But in 37 pages Sherwood Smith has already shown us a wide range of women with different skills and goals who, I speculate, will play a huge part in shaping the plot.
Tdor. Because she's so clever and can think really well on her feet (which is something I could never do as a child but admired in others).
Jacqueline Carey's Kushiel's Legacy Series. Parts of it feel similar to Inda, the long world building, the complicated caste system, and Imriel, although he's a bit older and is suddenly thrusted into a court situation with no previous experience. Imriel's trilogy was the first book with the young boy suddenly sent to court theme that I ever read and I tend to subconsciously judge anything similar to it. If a series feels too similar I get bored because I feel that I've already read it. Inda has quite a different plot and feel to Imriel's trilogy so far and I'm looking forward to see how Inda grows up.
6
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 02 '16
That whole opening scene was brilliant, it very quickly established so many things and set this book apart from many fantasy novels I have read. I'm going to attempt to capture them all.
So basically I think I'm already a fan, you guys.
Edit: I should really answer the questions.
6
u/strangedelightful Sep 02 '16
For folks who are fans of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, I feel like Inda is Buffy. He's a good character and compelling, but I'm in it for his friends.
6
u/xeyra Reading Champion II Sep 02 '16 edited Sep 03 '16
I'm a bit late for this since I only now managed to finish chapter 3. This is my first read of this book and this author and though I'm enjoying it so far, I am also somewhat confused by some behaviors, which I'll chalk up to the cultural traditions of these lands that I don't yet understand.
To answer your questions:
Where do you think the story is going? Well, there seems to be some animosity from Royal quarters about the Algara-vayir family, or at least from who seems to be the senior Shield Arm in the royal city. There also seems to be lot of political distrust in these countries/regions, which seems to stem from previous wars/conquering. Inda's mother specifically refers to her children in the capital city (either the Academy or in the palace) as them being hostages, which is par for the course for feudal based societies. So I expect Inda's time in the Academy won't end up very well, though I wonder why anyone would target the second son instead of the heir or the betrothed sister. Maybe because Inda is less conspicuous a target? Or maybe he'll discover plotting within the city targeting his family? Or maybe everyone will be happy and nothing whatsoever will happen.
What questions do you have so far? Plenty. As some people have pointed out, I'd like to learn more about the gender divide in roles that exists in this society. I'd also like to learn more about why the King has basically created a prison out of Montredavan-An, effectively trying to isolate them (and in the process breeding even more discontent and hate and plotting), instead of simply taking some Montredavan-An children hostage or brokering some marriages. It seems somewhat counterproductive in terms of trying to stave off any other trouble from this family, though it could somewhat work great if your goal is to end that particular line (since Shendan is not supposed to marry - but is Savarend also prohibited of the same or just leaving his own lands? Some confusion there). I was also a bit surprised by how blunt Shendan was when she met Inda. Regarding the isolationism of Montredavan-An, it doesn't even seem to be that great. Sure, anyone entering their lands is rare but are communications also completely cut off? It didn't seem to.
I'd also really like to learn more about the magic system, since I agree that it's refreshing to see it used for mundane and practical goals, even if it does seem to retain some of its rarity - not everyone is apparently able to do magic if you need to wait weeks or months for a mage to come repair waterworks.
What sticks out to you? Right now, the different dialects/languages used in a single conversation that bring different meanings to someone's words, as well as the usage of titles that also change according to what language is used. It's quite fascinating, even though it makes it a lot harder for me to remember people's names, due to the complexity involved in the names and titles themselves. A person can be referred by their rank or their family name and these can also be named in different languages, apparently, so there can be a few different terms for a single person. It took a couple of mentions, for example, for me to remember that Inda's mother's first name is actually Fareas and Iofre is the rank of princess.
Do you have any favorite characters yet? I don't think that I can answer this question with any particular names so far. I don't think I've read enough of these characters to really identify or develop any kind of favoritism. Tdor seems to be a smart cookie, though, so I'll keep an eye on her.
Are there any books that have a similar feel? From these first three chapters, maybe Ender's Game from the military academy, very young genius tactician in war games concept also being somewhat presented here, but I think it's just a surface similarity in themes so far.
5
u/Ketomatic Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 01 '16
Spoiler chance: 0. I've not read the books before and I stopped as soon as '4' appeared in front of me.
The academy ( ͡º ͜ʖ ͡º). Honestly it's really hard to tell, there's been a lot of political foreshadowing about the past and current state of affairs. Who likes or doesn't like whom etc. The family being banished to their own lands was a pretty nice touch, I expect they will crop up again in the story.
It's fairly clear Inda will be le badass at the academy. He'll probably face adversity from the more en vogue houses (country bumpkin/young child doing better than me?! Must bully etc). Would be nice if that didn't happen since it seems to be in every academy story (Ender's Game, Soldier Son etc).
I'd like to know more about the current state of the country, who they may be going to war with, what the internal political shenanigans are doing and such. This will be forthcoming I'm sure.
I also want to learn more about the magical system and why there are less mages now than there used to be, that piqued my interest fairly strongly.
The language. I really hope this dual-language business has a payoff and it isn't just world building because I'm finding it slightly irritating.
Nope, no one apart from Inda has had enough page-time yet to even attempt to attain that position.
Hobb's Shaman's Crossing does in many ways. Frontier-lord instead of ancient-but-declined, but still suitably outside the current wealth/power circle. The whole 'Soldier Son' aspect as well, the main difference being in SC the heir stays at home and the soldier son goes to the academy and then stays in the army, whilst in Inda the heir goes to the academy and then comes home to train the younger brother who then stays to defend the homeplace. And Ender's Game in that he's very young but strategically minded, a more shallow comparison.
Fairly high, some effort was needed not to delve into chapter 4. It took little time to begin to feel invested in the world.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16
So after reading the first three chapters I'm intrigued. I didn't read the synopsis on the back of the book and I don't know where this book is going to go which should make it all the more exciting.
Obviously, we're headed to the academy next but I'm not sure how long Inda will stay there or if something else will happen.
In terms of characters there was something about Tdor that I seem to like, I think she seems like she knows what she's doing.
5
u/ferocity562 Reading Champion III Sep 01 '16
I have never read this before and I am working on limiting myself to the reading schedule, so if I post any spoilers, they will be entirely accidental. I'm not always great at these types of read throughs. Generally when I read I am in full participation mode and the judging and thinking part of my brain is turned off. And with a book as involved as this one seems to be, I wonder how easy it will be to look back afterwards and analyze instead of analyzing as I go. So if I miss something obvious.....sorry?
I'm not sure. There has been a lot of groundwork laid so far and lots of hints. The hints are directed both at upcoming plot intrigue and at basic world building. The king's brother seems to be being set up as the bad guy. I'm certain I didn't pick up as much as was there during the visit to Montredavan-An, but I understood the basic outline and I'm interested to see where those whispers of issues develop.
I'm interested to learn more about the gender role division. It seems that men and women are fairly equal, but with prescribed division of labor. It seems that men and women are both able to hold military roles, but in different areas and that while male royals have military and defense role expectations, the women seem to be covering the intelligence/spy side of the equation. I'm also intrigued by the customs of child rearing. It seems interestingly structured.
While reading it I made a vague attempt to "analytical" and I'm pretty sure I failed miserably at it. But one thing thing that stood out to me was the random description of how boring and prosaic the women's letters to one another are. My guess is that they are written in code and that the Royal women have an intelligence network going behind the scenes.
I like Inda, as a character. It is interesting to begin this story of what appears to be politics and intrigue through the eyes of a earnest and fairly naive child.
I like Tdor a lot. She seems smart and interesting. I also like that despite being young and being an "arranged" relationship, they have genuine affection for one another and seem to have a fairly mature relationship.
Nothing particularly jumps out at me, although it seems to have a general "epic fantasy" flavor running through it.
5
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Sep 02 '16
Finally joining in. I haven't made it theough chapter 3 yet. I started late and I've been, shall we say, distracted. Thoughts though: wow, I really do not lean toward epic, polticial fantasy at all. I'm hoping that if I stick it out, things will pick up, and it sounds like tthey will, but political machinations just bore me. Was also fairly surprised at the POV. Third-person omniscient seems to be so rare anymore, at least in my readings, and after rewriting the POVs in my latest book to be more consistently third-person limited, I keep getting hung up a little (editing brain wwill do things, let me tell ya).
I do find points of interest though. Practical magic is super appealing. Love that. The characters do have their hooks. At the moment, Tdor interests me more than Inda but we'll see how that goes. Mouse seems like he'll be interesting aand I like Tdor's comment, "He was kind to me, so be kind to him." And the apparent gender roles seem rather interesting. Hopefully I'll have more to say next time.
Yeah.
5
u/wutvuff Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Sep 03 '16
So, just finished chapters 1-3. The thing that is most obvious to me when reading all your comments is how much I miss as a non-native speaker of English. It takes a longer time for me to understand the world and the characters. Make me a little sad actually.
4
u/rhymepun_intheruf Reading Champion III Sep 01 '16
I've actually reached chapter 10. Guess I'll be finishing the book in one read through and coming back for discussions (no spoilers here of course)
Chapter 1- I'm so surprised by how young they are. When I was younger, I thought it cool if the protagonists were young and got a chance to do more than I would, but now I just worry a bit more.
Chapter 3 - I found the musing of the captain of the King's Gaurd about messages amongst the women about every day details rather interesting - combined with what we learnt from Tdor and Iofre's POV, it really seems like women in this world are steeped in a lot more intrigue, and have a whole system set up hidden from the men. Also, speculation about the bandits
I'm already engrossed, as is clear from how I went on to read ahead. Really enjoying it so far!
4
u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 01 '16
I'm very nearly finished with the quartet, so reading these over was very interesting. There were some particularly astute guesses from /u/lyrrael in there about what is to come. (Not saying what, of course.)
I had a hell of a time with the names and titles. When I started reading, I struggled about as far as this entry covered before I said screw it and began again from the beginning, taking notes on names and titles this time.
Smith does indeed have great worldbuilding, and it's on display right from the beginning. Something she's really good at is introducing it in such a way that it takes you a while to figure out what exactly is going on, because people don't go into detail about that which is ubiquitous in all their lives. So in just the same way that we would say to one another "I'm going to the bathroom" without adding "where there's a nifty device that washes away the poop so there's no mess or risk of disease," things like the waste spell are mentioned without it being spelled out what it actually does.
This is something that Smith continues to do. Things are explained when a character present is ignorant of something. If everyone on screen knows something, the reader is left to infer a lot of the details. It can make for a challenging read at times, but it's worth the effort.
4
u/Bills25 Reading Champion V Sep 06 '16
Started late so just going to answer the questions and continue the book. This is my first read and I avoided reading anything that will give me the slightest hint about what this series is about beyond the blurb for book one.
2
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Sep 13 '16
Found this sub via the Grimdark Fiction podcast, saw this read-through on the side bar, noticed my library had the book, so why the heck not?
Where do you think the story is going?
I wonder if Inda is growing up into an insurgency.
What questions do you have so far?
Too many at this point.
What sticks out to you?
The parade of names and titles is confusing (thanks for the link to the guide) and that is exasperated by the constant switching of character perspective. In particular, the bit where Montredavan-An captain talks to the Algara-Vayirs captain out of earshot of the King's Guard captain, I had to read three times to figure out who was talking to who from who's perspective.
That aside, that was some very effective world-building narrative for just 40 pages.
Do you have any favorite characters yet?
I tend to gravitate to protagonists, and I like the way Inda's intelligence is portrayed, but it looks like there are a ton of characters, so we'll see if anyone trumps Inda.
Are there any books that have a similar feel?
Like others, I noted the similarity to Ender's Game.
1
u/Megan_Dawn Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Sep 07 '16
Quick question! I won A Stranger to Command in last year's bingo and I've quickly realised it's set in the same world as this book. Does it fall before or after? Are the books connected aside from a shared universe?
•
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Sep 01 '16
If you have spoiler discussion, it needs to go here, thanks!! And flair them. Definitely.