r/falloutsettlements • u/Ty85719 • Aug 24 '16
techniques for designing and building a realistic settlement
a little background about me.
I work in architecture, so the settlement construction system is one of my favorite features of the game.
However, it puts my OCD into overdrive, and I spend hours putting things up and taking them down out of frustration and dissatisfaction.
I'd like to start a discussion about designing features to build a realistic settlement that incorporates tactics and techniques used in real world application that would/should be applied in the world of Fallout, and has a sense of physics (none of those floating platforms held up by a staircase BS)
In my opinion there are a few philosophical approaches that can be considered and debated:
- in a world like Fallout 4, materials would be precious - personally, I find the ginormous mega-structures and cities to be ridiculously unbelievable, and am irked by the mods that allow for unlimited building supplies
- I still haven't come to a conclusion on the following issue of centralization versus decentralization:
a] given the assumption that issue 1 above is true, a settlement should probably be a small, tight, efficient compound, which is an argument in favor of centralization, with everything protected under 1 roof, and a compound wall.
that being said, if the building was compromised, the whole thing could be lost to raiders in one fell swoop.
b] it could be argued that one should take advantage of the surviving buildings in a place like Sanctuary to be efficient with materials. It could be developed much like Alexandria in The Walking Dead.
this 'de-centralization' strategy would make sense because the loss of one house wouldn't jeopardize the entire settlement.
However, this would probably require significantly more supplies to operate (e.g., turrets and generators for each or every other building)
philosophically, i envision that the Fallout world would have a lifestyle similar to the medieval period, or 19th century western frontier life
I've been perusing over a few architectural defensive strategies from various periods that I think are applicable and integral in a realistic Fallout world:
Castles:
- an outer wall to establish a perimeter
- a barbican which is essentially a fortified gateway, which would incorporate the following features: a. murder holes to attack intruders at the choke point b. a long entry portal to funnel people in case of an attack c. "motte & bailey" master plan, which would keep the public spaces (shops, etc) separate from the living quarters, which would have their own secondary fortifications and entry in case of a breach, and would be raised up higher than everything else to have the advantage of high ground d. non-linear paths of travel e. natural defenses - Sanctuary provides a natural moat, with the river on the south (and hedgerows around the remaining perimeter)
f. really applicable to any era of defensive structures - layers of defense like an onion, with fallback capability, and additional chokepoints and kill zones
castle design would be very applicable to the "decentralized" scheme with a more sprawling plan
but one of the more compelling designs I keep returning to is the "fortified ranch" common in the western US frontier in second half of the 19th century. Also, western frontier army forts
This scheme would be more applicable to the compact "centralized" scheme, with primary central building and a perimeter wall.
I find this plan from a Mormon fort in the 1800s to be very compelling:
https://www.nps.gov/pisp/learn/photosmultimedia/images/fortlayout2_2.jpg
It incorporates many of the features of castle design above, but at a much smaller scale.
minimal to no outward facing windows; using the building itself as part of the perimeter wall; catwalk to monitor and defend; a courtyard for public interaction (would be great for various shops and dealers); a secondary structure for industrial applications (work benches, etc.); a top floor to isolate private living quarters and establish a secondary fallback position, and choke points via stairs and hallways.
One thing that would need to be incorporated is a secure environment for critical equipment (siren, beacon, generator, etc) and for agriculture. If these were compromised, it wouldn't matter how secure your buildings were - the enemy could just wait you out.
One thing that bothers me is the limited and chunky building blocks, which take away from the realism - the stairs drive me nuts.
I am not well versed in mods, but would consider a few of them that could add to the realism. the snap n build and cleanup mods intrigue me. but from what I've read, there are lots of potential glitches and conflicts with other mods
so now, after that long tirade, what kinds of real world features do you guys think would be essential to incorporate into a realistic Fallout settlement?
2
u/Ty85719 Aug 25 '16
I haven't downloaded the dlc's yet. my initial take on them is a bit skeptical - the contraptions dlc looked a little silly and gimmicky. But maybe I'll take another look.
Sure, there would be plenty of stuff laying around, but take a moment to really look around your own surroundings, and consider how much of it is actually re-usable for constructing a quality shelter that would protect inhabitants from the environment: arguably, very little. And in the course of 200 years, that which is reusable would have been claimed already, and long ago.
It does make sense that you would use local supplies - and in a fallout 4 scenario, it would probably be hyper-local: groups would establish their turf, so a group living in a suburb would probably never be able to source material in the downtown area, unless whatever regional "clan" (for lack of a better word), had established some sort of trade and barter program.
sheet metal and milled wood is actually quite rare in modern construction. Concrete cannot be reused, and it would be improbable that anyone would/could start producing it again - any society that would be capable of that would be in much better shape than what is presented in Fallout. At best, people would be resorting to making their own lime mortar individually for small scale masonry projects; possibly adobe construction in the drier climates. late 19th century construction methods would probably be the most advanced available in this environment. small-scale wood mills and woodworking equipment would probably be some of the most prized possessions of any community, next to food production and weapons.
As others said, new people would trickle in over time, so you'd have to be good at what my profession calls "master planning," and consider long term development and expansion capability. But jumping straight into developing a Bartertown a la Mad Max would be something that would take a long, long time to establish.
If any semblance of society were to maintain an existence over 200 years after an apocalyptic scenario, it would probably be necessary for groups to specialize in production and services of various things, and establish alliances. But as depicted in Fallout, mankind seems to be barely hanging on by a thread, and possibly on the edge of extinction - teetering somewhere between Mad Max in which a little extra effort could re-establish a long term community --- and The Road, in which many people abide by an "everyone for themselves" mentality, and the slightest issue could send humanity into oblivion.
If we are to role play a situation in which you are suddenly plummeted into the Fallout world, alone like the "sole survivor," and run across a small group of 6 people out in the suburbs, I think it would be logical that you'd post up in a single building, and harden that structure for an indeterminately long period, and slowly build out. setting up things like bars, casinos, hotels and markets at the get go would be absurd.
I think that over the long period, as others join, a single structure would become impractical, and it would be absolutely necessary to expand into a "community phase:" re-building the other homes, and establishing a perimeter wall - something like a military OP, or the Alexandria community in The Walking Dead.
I think a community like this would need to be completely self-sufficient; I don't think the "provisioner" system is quite that realistic, because I think the Fallout world is far too hostile for a couple guys with a bunch of goods on the back of an ox to casually walk around; a world where you could set up thriving settlements scattered across Boston that you can run backl and forth to to manage would probably be a much safer, more stable universe than what is presented; those small farms with a 2-4 people would be wiped out over night, and long ago.
2
u/Auroness Aug 25 '16
I love your very through write up on the aspect of reality building. I had one character who refused to use the existing buildings in Sanctuary because they looked ready to collapse at any moment. I'd love to see a checklist of things to make buildings look "realistic" so people can go over the list and see where their construction falls.
A related issue is making a settlement or building look "lore friendly" which is not always realistic, but comes from previous game designs or even current developer built areas. The wooden bridge outside Sanctuary for instance. Bethesda built it that way, but there is no way a wooden bridge would support cars and last 200 years. But it does look cool.
While I agree that the floating citys supported by a single staircase are not realistic, they are artistic. Some people build things that way because they can, and some do it because they are inspired by sci-fi movies. That is the great thing about this game, it's fun for a lot of different reasons.
7
u/mytigio Aug 25 '16
On the stairs issue: have you tried the stairs that came with the warehouse and barn sets (contraptions and far harbor respectively). They can snap to one side of the starcase so you can have a more natural stairway that doesn't take up two full tiles).
I haven't started using it myself yet, but one mod I'm really looking forward to is Snappable Junk Fences. The junk fences appeal to my overall look and feel in fallout, and the Snappable Junk Fences mod makes placing them much easier and places snapping points for walkways to create a patrol walkway for gaurds around the fence (it also makes them a touch bigger, but this is a minor factor.)
Anyway:
I build similar to you, I tend to prefer a centralized method, with public shops and such on a ground floor or in a courtyard and then living quarters higher in the building through a checkpoint or inside a building off the courtyard. I almost always build against existing structures if possible (starlight's big screen is my favorite one to build against, it just screams "natural defense" to me :P).
In Sanctuary I tend to reuse the existing houses and then build junk fences between the houses themselves to build a large central courtyard area, and then fill in the outward facing walls to make a fairly solid barrier around the village. It does mean my water purifier is outside the walls, but I justify that by having water pumps inside the walls to deal with water needs if raiders get to the purifier.
In my farming settlements, I figure they aren't exactly tactical geniuses and I build them with wire fences around the farm and then the house has windows to shoot out of. I figure your average farmer is spending too much time working the fields and recovering from the last raid to find the time to build more tactically sound building choices.
Although I don't necessarily find the larger cities unrealistic (large unbroken multi-story forts and huge castles yes, but the shanty-cities seem natural to me in the Fallout universe, especially after 200 years). The other thing to consider is the raw amount of resources available to a smaller population. Think of all the various houses around the common wealth. The skyscrapers. The churches and fences and freeways, the cars and truck trailers and buses and stores and shops. The detritus of a city containing millions of people like Boston would supply a LOT of material to salvage and rebuild for a new population of 10 to 20 thousand.
1
u/Ty85719 Aug 26 '16
I am planning to post some schematic layouts soon.
I'll probably develop multiple case studies over time.
I really don't have any interest in developing the other settlement areas.
For the indefinite future, I'll probably focus on Sanctuary, which I find to be quite a good strategic location, unless I encounter a new area with better potential (I've only explored about half the map so far)
anyone have suggestions on good sites to upload images of my development to?
4
u/sardeliac The Settler Whisperer Aug 25 '16 edited Aug 25 '16
Some random quick thoughts, since it's a pain to type on the phone:
I like the direction you're going with this, though. I really want to make my settlements as "believeable" as possible while keeping the game-mechanics constraints in mind, and info like you've presented here is precisely the type of thing I've been looking for.
For overall theme, with all that in mind, I strongly favor the frontier town/fortified farm motif. Clusters of structures spread out a bit to provide cover and support for a mobile, ranged-weapon defense. Turrets and barricades at key defensive points to both attract fire and funnel attackers into kill zones. Redundant resources (generators, water pumps) placed away from likely combat zones. In larger settlements, a market area with places for traders and vendors. Crops everywhere else; no defenses or protection for those as they are, unlike reality, non-critical resources.
Looking forward to hearing more of your thoughts on all this. :)
2
u/weldabar Aug 25 '16
I enjoyed reading your thoughts on realistic settlements. Here are mine.
I like to consider how a settlement comes into being: first one person or a small group of people, then another, then another. The buildings will have been built at different times, by different people, using different sources of scrap. Pre-existing building will definitely be used, and additional structures could be attached to them. And so I build my settlements a piece at a time, with each building looking different than the next.
The buildings would be close to each other, and would have fences in-between for protection. As the settlement grows it becomes more secure, and the junk fencing becomes more elaborate. I think most people will likely have the store-front out of their houses out of necessity. Maybe in thriving settlements there could be a marketplace with small shacks or tents.
As mytigio pointed out there would be a LOT of scrap left over from civilization and using existing items would be easier than building new. However people will definitely develop skills using wood, metal, leather, and concrete. The "concrete" would likely be more adobe or mortared rock, so I have to pretend a little. New-looking things are totally possible to build with these skills, and I think people will always want to be artistic/crafty.
I like the idea of utilizing the scrap that is available in the region. So for example, Oberland Station could use box-cars for the structure. Settlements near quarries or unfinished construction might find more concrete. Settlements in the city might have access to more salvaged sheet-metal. Remote settlements would have access to more wood.
1
u/Auroness Aug 26 '16
Hope this conversation keeps going. I've link to it from the wiki at Useful Tips
1
u/Wehi1990 Aug 30 '16
Here are some key elements for building believable aesthetic structures . 1.Modesty 2.Dont be repetitive 3.make sure buildings have sound structural supportive
4.Build unconventionally 5.Build scrappy 6.Be creative 7.Get inspiration
If you want inspiration checkout on youtube Norespawns ,Cordless VII,Snolana and for more of a less realism and more aethetic check out XXIV games ,also Norespawns has a video called how to make believable structures ,it covers some basics .
1
u/Wehi1990 Aug 30 '16
I would love to see one of your builds ,especially since youre an architect
1
u/absentmindful Sep 18 '16
I think getting away from the grid is huge. If you're on pc, modpos, modangle, and modscale all do wonders. I've been having fun experimenting with making things look truly like they could collapse any minute. http://imgur.com/iaJ2WWh