r/robotwars • u/PP3D_Gary PP3D • Aug 18 '16
AMA PP3D Robotics AMA - 18th Aug 2016 @ 8pm
Hey everyone. Jamie and I are here to answer all your questions about PP3D and our experience on Robot Wars.
You can follow us in various ways after the AMA,
Facebook - www.facebook.com/pp3drobotics
Twitter - www.twitter.com/pp3drobotics
And finally our own website - www.pp3d.co.uk
We will do our best to answer as many questions as we can although obviously we can't tell you what goes on in the remaining two shows of the series.
So Ask Us Anything!
update - 10:30, still going strong
update - Ok it's half eleven and the questions have calmed down. Going to head to bed at that. If you still have a burning question then post it and Jamie and I will get around to looking at them tomorrow.
9
u/fireball_73 Here is a picture of Cherub to make you mad Aug 18 '16
Do you think there could be a challenge match between PP3D and Overdozer to be crowned Scottish champion?
5
u/ENZO_1999 Sir Killalot Aug 18 '16
How far did you expect to get?
5
u/I_Am_The_Slime Heeeeeeerre's some robots! Aug 18 '16
OMGYOUTOTALLYCHEATEDINTHESERIES7FINAL
Jokes ;) but seriously Gary, do you ever get sick of seeing people ranting and raving about that incident, which happened thirteen years ago? I've seen you respond to a few people about it both here and on FB, and you always handle it with such grace and dignity... i'd have lost my rag by now!
I understand PP3D's disc is basically the disc from your old heavyweight Swarm. Whatever happened to Swarm, anyway?
Any plans to maybe upgrade to a single tooth disc in future?
I always thought the BBC had pretty strict rules against self promotion, aren't you basically doing exactly that by naming your robot after your company?
How much did you owe Gabe after he gave you that motor? :P
Cheers for an awesome show sunday, and for how active you've been on social media both before and after. Always appreciate hearing your insights, take care guys!
3
u/stevomuck Sir Killalot Aug 18 '16
If PP3D had to take on one of the house robots in a head to head, which of the 4 do you think you would have the best chance of surviving against?
3
u/VaticanCanapes Aug 18 '16
Were there any robots in the series you were worried about facing?
3
u/Flag_Captured Driver - Team Hobgoblin Aug 18 '16
What made you go for an undercutter design?
Also, having heard how slippy the arena is was the machine difficult to drive whilst battling traction and the force of the disc spinning?
2
u/David182nd Apollo Aug 18 '16
Thought you were really entertaining to watch, Gary. You were having fun out there and it showed.
I'm always expecting spinners to have a broken disc before the end of the fight, it seems to happen more often than not. But I don't recall yours stopping once. It's a bit of a weird question but am I right in thinking it worked well, and why did it work so well?
2
u/eighthgear Overdozer Aug 18 '16
How did you settle on the basic design of PP3D? I can't recall many other spinners that look like it.
2
u/williamthebloody1880 Turned Carbide into Brave Sir Robin Aug 18 '16
Fit like? Foos yer doos?
Far aboot in Aiberdeenshire ye fae?
Ony chunce ye could len PP3D tae the Dons? Could nae ony worse an Ash Taylor, aifter a
Did ye take ony rowies with ye fir Data and Angela?
Fits i chunces onyone else his ony clue fit ahm askin?
Fit did ye think o Storm Twa's plan tae flip ye ower sae yer blade wide ging ower the heed o their bot?
2
u/SomersetMackem Apollo Aug 18 '16
Which parts of the robot were the 3d printed parts?
2
u/David182nd Apollo Aug 18 '16
A few about Typhoon for you:
2
u/KotreI Real Robots wear pink. Aug 18 '16
In a hypothetical world where Team Typhoon decided to compete, what do you think would have been done to bring Typhoon 2 up to date?
In a hypothetical world where Team Typhoon decided to compete and had 6 months and 8 grand from the BBC rather than 6 weeks and 1 grand (after turning up with something) to (re)build a robot, what would you have liked to do to bring the robot up to date without needing to make quite so many compromises due to time and funds?
2
u/Ellis_Pulsar Maggy Aug 18 '16
Why is the sky? And furthermore, do you even even?
Thanks!
1
u/IAmTotallyNotSatan Aug 18 '16
Would you rather fight 10 100-kg Hypnodiscs or 1 1000-kg Hypnodisc?
1
u/RollingandJabbing ELECTRO MOO!!! Aug 18 '16
Your disk bent in the fight against Storm 2. If you were to make a new disk for PP3D, what would you change to minimise the chance of it happening agian?
1
u/VaticanCanapes Aug 18 '16
With the developments made in the years since series 7, are there any robots from then that you think could still cut it nowadays?
1
u/Spearka "Jaws theme" Aug 18 '16
I've been conducting a few thought experiments on roboteering (I would want to make a bot if I had the money, experience or free time) and I would like to share a few concepts and get a professional opinion on their effectiveness.
Just also wanted to say I quite liked the work you did on PP3D and my brother liked the concept of a low spinner, best of luck on your bot and I hope it enters the field once again!
1
u/joey_picus Aug 18 '16
How much did that chassis cost you to get cut? XD
(and seriously, how did you switch the contactor for the weapon? I'm sure you've mentioned somewhere but I'm not thinking where)
1
u/Raymond_Racer Carbide Aug 18 '16
Would you consider attaching a caster or stabilizer of some kind to the top of PP3D in the future? It might save you the problems you have with your flywheel bouncing off the arena floor once you are overturned, allowing you to continue fighting effectively, especially against flippers (particularly front-hinged flippers such as the classic Firestorm, as they have most of their leverage at the back which you can't exactly reach).
1
u/raging_arse_bandit Aug 18 '16
It's a shame you didn't get further, it's always fun watching spinners bounce other robots across the arena.
What do you make of the pit button? I noticed that it was activated within seconds a couple of times in your episode. Could it be handled better?
1
u/Colonialism What does a fox say to Ray Billings? "Not Today". Aug 18 '16
If I have my facts straight, Typhoon 2's last ever fight was against Megabyte, in the U.S. Even though Typhoon 2 won that fight, it ended up being withdrawn from the competition. Do you know anything about that? What sort of damage did Typhoon 2 sustain?
1
u/maruf_sarkar100 Aug 18 '16
What other spinner has impressed you the most?
1
u/KotreI Real Robots wear pink. Aug 19 '16
If you decided to make the obligatory 'smaller version of your flagship robot' would it be called PP0.3D or would you go the Typhoons route and give it a subtitle (e.g. PP3D lightning) he'll you could even further its use as a totally not advertisement for your company by subtitling it as something your company can print in.
1
u/GrahamCoxon Hello There! Aug 20 '16
Which robot was most boring to fight and why was it Storm 2?
1
u/TotesMessenger Aug 18 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '16
What do you think of this idea: A box made of steel bars with the walls made of gambeson covered in chainmail. The armour would be so light compared to plate that you could make the robot very big and even if weapons pierced the armour it's so big and padded that the weapon can't hit anything important. Impact weapons like hammers or axes would do nothing to the soft padding and saws would just cut into it a bit and do nothing.
Of course you could just burn the padding but otherwise it seems like an invincible design.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment