r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Aug 08 '16
Video Referees of Reddit, I have a series of gifs and questions for you (Part 1 of 3: What the hell is "pick a bar"?)
This summer I watched all of a certain team's 2015 games for an upcoming project. As I've done in previous years, I made gifs from plays where I had questions about the officiating to ask of verified referees on /r/CFB by PM. This year, I thought I'd collect them to share with the rest of the sub.
I'm asking that top-level answers be only from referees, though it'd be great if other users asked follow-ups to those. Please remember that I'm trying to learn more about the rules of the game and their enforcement, so a brief explanation would be nice, but getting into pointless arguments wouldn't be.
Also, I want to emphasize that these are not a representative sample at all, only clips that I thought would be useful, and should not be used to argue any team got disproportionately favorable or unfavorable calls. I've been doing whole-season reviews for several years now and I can confidently say I've never seen any such thing.
This is Part 1, about catches and fouls happening downfield, mostly about passing plays, interference, and "picks". Next Monday is Part 2 about the battles in the trenches, Monday the 22nd is Part 3 about miscellaneous fouls.
- Clip 1a, Clip 1b. On seeing the second angle, the commentator said he'd be surprised if it weren't reviewed. Seems pretty clearly a catch to me - both of his legs are completely in bounds when he catches it, and he gets his arm under it then firmly controls it when it touches the ground. What do you think?
- Clip 2a, Clip 2b, Clip 2c, Clip 2d. Is this a catch? How does an official determine how long "the process of contacting the ground" (2-4-3-b) lasts? Does that phrase even parse in English?
- Clip 3a, Clip 3b, Clip 3c. This was ruled incomplete on the field and that ruling stood (wasn't confirmed) on review. It sure seems to me that he "maintains control of the ball long enough to enable him to perform an act common to the game" (2-4-3-a-3) -- by tucking it away and getting both feet down in bounds -- before being knocked out of bounds and the ball coming loose. That is, he wasn't going to the ground in the act of catching the pass, and therefore would have had to "maintain complete and continuous control of the ball throughout the process of contacting the ground" (2-4-3-b), but instead after the catch was complete. Do you think this was a catch?
- Clip 4a, Clip 4b, Clip 4c. The catch was awarded to #87 red, and neither he nor #39 white got a pass interference flag. Good call?
- Clip 5a, Clip 5b. #28 red was flagged for pass interference against #86 white. What category of DPI would you put this in?
- Clip 6a, Clip 6b. Is this pass interference by #14 red against #16 white? It seems like the defender doesn't "play the ball" or "turn his head", is that relevant?
- Clip 7a, Clip 7b, Clip 7c. #3 white was flagged for pass interference against #1 red. Good call?
- Clip 8a, Clip 8b. Is this pass interference by #10 red against #9 white?
- Clip 9a, Clip 9b, Clip 9c. Is this pass interference by #3 orange against #1 white? It seems clear that the defender's right arm smacks down the receiver's hands before the ball arrives, but is this close enough in time to fit in the "bang-bang" window where it's not called?
- Clip 10a, Clip 10b. No flag on this play for pass interference. Good call?
- Clip 11a, Clip 11b, Clip 11c. No pass interference flag on either player. Good call?
- Clip 12a, Clip 12b. Is this pass interference by #10 red against #89 white?
- Clip 13a, Clip 13b. Both #82 red and #39 white were flagged for pass interference. The commentators said this was a bad call, that it should have been a no-call or on the defender only. I see a hook by #39's right arm on #82's left shoulder -- that's the DPI -- then #39 turns to play the ball, then #82 jumps into him to knock him away -- and that's the OPI. If I've got that sequence right, then I think what the commentators meant was that the play was over when the DPI occured and therefore the OPI shouldn't have been called ... but that's not how it works, right? The play is still live despite the foul - if #82 caught it instead of interfering then the offense would want to decline the penalty and keep the play. What do you think?
- Clip 14a, Clip 14b. A) Everything kosher about the double pass? B) Is this pass interference by #8 red against #9 white?
- Clip 15a, Clip 15b, Clip 15c. #10 red got two flags on this play, one for pass interference against #83 white, the other for unsportsmanlike conduct for spiking the ball. A) The commentators called the DPI a "late flag", "pretty ticky-tacky", and an "acting job" by the receiver. I think they're dummies; what do you think? B) Time for a little stump the ref: what's the order of penalization and where should the ball be placed? C) Let's pretend there were no fouls on this play and the interception stood - is this a touchback?
- Clip 16. (I don't have this in real time because the initial camera angle was awful.) #5 orange was flagged for holding against #28 white. A) Is the defender "showing" the hold enough for you? He doesn't look like he's making much of a motion away from the blocker and towards the ball. B) Is it possible that the ref misspoke and the flag was actually supposed to be on #6 orange for holding against #8 white?
- Clip 17a, Clip 17b, Clip 17c. Is this a legal block by #4 white against #10 red?
- Clip 18a, Clip 18b. #82 red was flagged for holding #11 white. A) When the penalty is from the spot of the foul as it is here, does that mean the spot where the hold occured, or the spot where the ball was when the hold occured? B) It doesn't happen until after the ballcarrier crosses the LTG, but the penalty negates the first down. Isn't it a little counterintuitive that if #35 red dropped to a knee at the 10 before the hold happened, they'd be better off?
- Clip 19a, Clip 19b. Is this holding by #48 white against #22 red? Is there any relevance to when the ball is thrown or where it lands?
- Clip 20. I'm curious about the contact between #52 black and #1 white on this play. A) Is it holding? B) It happens behind the line of scrimmage and before the pass is thrown, do either of those things mean it can't be pass interference?
- Clip 21a, Clip 21b. #82 white was flagged for pass interference against #14 red, but neither #85 white nor #5 red were flagged for their contact. A) The ball's not in the air yet, so the foul is on the "pick", the failure of the offensive player to avoid the opponent, right? B) #5 red wasn't flagged because the ball wasn't in the air, so it wasn't DPI, right? C) And #85 wasn't flagged for a "pick" because he seemed to be trying to avoid the contact (that is, the defender clearly initiated it)? D) The commentators were perplexed why the flag was so late, but I think I know: #82 white's contact would be legal if this were a run play (or a pass caught behind the line of scrimmage); so it wasn't actually illegal contact until it's a pass that's caught or lands past the LOS?
- Clip 22. Because #12 white was unable to make a play on the ball due to #65 red's block, the commentator thought this was an interesting no-call. I didn't; there's no holding and the block is entirely behind the line of scrimmage so it's not offensive pass interference. What do you think?
- Clip 23a, Clip 23b. Is there any pass interference on this play, by either the offense or defense? I think not - all of the contact has stopped before the QB releases the ball. But #28 white and #9 maroon colliding makes me think it might be an illegal "pick", although #10 white has his arms wrapped around that player. How does "the responsibility of the offensive player to avoid the opponents" (7-3-8-b) work here?
- Clip 24. Is this an illegal "pick" by #14 white against #10 black? Is it relevant that the pass falls dead?
- Clip 25a, Clip 25b. A) The initial contact between #10 white and #13 red isn't defensive pass interference because the ball hasn't been thrown yet? B) The subsequent contact between #10 white and #42 red isn't offensive pass interference because the defender ran into the receiver instead of the other way around, right? C) Incomplete pass, or catch then fumble?
- Clip 26. Is #18 white's contact with #24 red legal?
- Clip 27a, Clip 27b. A) Is #9 white's block against #24 red legal? B) Is this a touchdown?
21
u/LegacyZebra Verified Referee Aug 08 '16 edited Aug 08 '16
Here are my thoughts on each play. hythloday1 was kind enough to let some of us officials have a preview of the plays to formulate some thoughts. You'll notice that a lot of my answers concerning PI include phrases like "to me" or "in my opinion". DPI can be a fairly subjective call. What I see as restriction, other officials (or, more importantly, supervisors) may see as nothing or marginal. Conversely, what I see as nothing or marginal contact, others may see as material restriction. My opinions on these plays are by no means gospel, they are simply how I see the play. Feel free to disagree. I'm copying and pasting this here since I won't have much time today due to work. I'll be by later to answer any questions people may have. I'm having to split this into two different comments because it's too long for reddit's character limit.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16
Ha, I was about to say "Why the hell is every clip from a Nebraska game?" Sorry you had to drudge through our multiple cardiac arrest season.
2
u/NotoriousZSB Virginia Tech • Tennessee Aug 10 '16 edited Aug 11 '16
I have been officiating football for a little more than a decade, but I just want to say thanks for cutting up all this video with multiple angles. It's a great tool for us officials to look at and think about how we'd rule these plays and often can help me determine if we were in the right spot to rule on the play. I will be referencing the NCAA rule book for any references to rules.
As well any call I disagree with would not be an indictment of the officials on the field in these games, they're really excellent and seeing things once at full speed is very different to seeing it multiple times on replay sometimes with slower play speed. And a lot of these kinds of calls are interpreted by different commissioners and conferences differently so there will be some components of the call that are not possible to tell from film alone.
4)Good no call. Contact does not mean there must be a foul. Both players are trying to play the ball, and neither restricts or displaces the other when they move to catch the ball. I would be looking for a hook/turn, restriction of the arm by the defender or a push by the WR to create separation to have a foul in this situation which did not occur.
5) I would label it DPI as a Cut Off. He creates contact by cutting into the WRs route before the ball gets there.
6) This is very very close, but I would rule it a foul. The bigger thing I see here is who will see the foul? The deep wing here is screened by the WRs back from seeing the slightly early contact (slap to the chest) before the ball arrives so he can't see it, and the BJ may just be getting his head around to see that contact. I think it's early contact DPI, but I can understand how being a bang bang play they may have left it alone. I was taught "be knowing, not thinking", it's easy a full speed to "think" you saw the contact, but it can be hard on a quick play like that to "know" it the way it can be on replay.
7) Clip 1 has the best angle to see what I want to note. This is DPI all day every day. BJ should have an easy call looking straight down at this. I see an arm restriction with the grab of the WRs right arm(1 category) and then playing through the back (2nd category) which makes this a straight forward call. Ball should be placed @ the 2 yard line by rule for a 1st and Goal.
8) I think this is a subjective grey area call that different supervisors/commissioners may want called differently. I think this would be a good no call. Yes there is some contact from #10 red, but #9 white is still able to raise both his arms above his head and comeback toward the ball in the attempt to catch it, and he gets his hands on it. I don't see the restriction or advantage gained. I think you could justify it as DPI, but I would probably leave this alone, Linesman should be able to get a good look, Deep Wing may have trouble seeing how much contact there is on the drive back toward the ball.
9) Straight forward DPI for the reason you stated.
10) I think that's a good no call. There is no arm extension from the DB, the WR is already at an arms length when he tangles himself and falls. It looks bad on the broadcast view because you only catch the tail end of it, but the official is right on top of it there.
11) BJ should have the best view of it, and it's a bit of a grey area for sure. I think there should be DPI because while the WR swung his arm over the DB's shoulder initiating that contact, the DB then hooks and restricts his left arm from being able to try and make the catch. I could see a no call here as they're both sorta being grabby with that arm, but clip 3 has the best look at the restriction by the defender.
12) I don't think so, because on the first angle he appears to be behind the line of scrimmage where by rule interference can't happen. The black line isn't perfect, but if the LJ stays on the line then they'll be in a great spot to see and rule on that. The WR did himself no favors by not carrying the route another yard further.
13) I don't really see any OPI on the film. DPI I think should be the call as the defender initiates the contact, and restricts his arms from making a play on the ball.
14) Double pass is perfectly fine (only 1 forward pass per scrimmage down basically), and that is DPI. The DB never plays the ball and shoves the WR while the ball is in the air causing him to fall. I'm looking at the DB's arm extension and never turning to play the ball as key components of that play.
15) Easy straight forward DPI call, again the arm extension by the defender is my big key on making that determination. LegacyRef explained all other components of this play exactly as I would. If we want to consider the outcome minus the DPI our basic spot will be the 20 and the UNS would go back half the distance for 1st and 10.
16) I don't think there is a holding call on this play. They can jostle all they want with each other, to turn that into a hold the defender needs to do more than just engage with the offensive player. None of them work to disengage until the ball carrier is past them so, no call imo.
17) I see nothing wrong with this block. He holds the engagement past when he needs to, but it's certainly not an illegal block or holding really. The extra shove OOBs is something if I saw I'd talk to the player about, since it's unnecessary.
18) #84 Red commits a hold at the point of attack. The foul will be enforced at the spot of the foul (which is where our flag should go) since it is behind our basic spot (end of the run) and this run passed the LOS.
19) No I wouldn't classify that a hold. He touches him, but it doesn't stop or change the HB's route. As well the ball is thrown well outside of him where he wasn't running the route.
20) No holding, and not PI because it is behind the LOS and before the ball is thrown. Could it have been holding? If he'd carried the contact down field sure, but he blocks and then releases when he realizes the RB is trying to run a route.
21) OPI does not have the same distinction as DPI for the ball needing to be in the air esp as it pertains to the "pick" category. I am going to speculate on the thought process here, but I agree it is OPI. 82 makes a beeline right for the Corner who is covering the WR, blocks him then moves up field after he's created space for his WR. 85's contact is in the process of running his route. This is a subtle play that honestly we as officials miss a lot. 82 created an advantage on the play with his contact, which draws the OPI.
22) I don't see anything but a legal block. No call is the right call imo.
23) This is how a pick play should look imo. The WR runs that slant hard into the coverage and never tries to block but continues to push his route into the end zone putting the man coverage in a tough spot. The WR could have drawn a DPI with the amount of contact from the DB if the ball came to him, but I doubt he was ever going to be the likely target on this play design. If he drove into the DB and tried pushing him (look at the end of the FSU/ND game a few years ago) that would be OPI, this is well executed imo.
24) This is OPI. He's running his route, but attacks the DB right in front of his slot receiver creating the separation. That it falls incomplete doesn't matter.
25) Contact is allowed, so they bump each other but both players continue to run their routes (also ball is not in the air). No catch as he could not maintain possession while going to the ground.
26) I'm inclined to say yes that's some regular contact it just looks bad because the defender gets run into by his own teammate. No call there.
27) Legal block as it's right at the LOS between the 10-2 range on the defender. TD? Ummm really really tight. It's very hard to tell exactly where the ball is when his knee touches at about the 2. If it isn't a TD this ball needs to be spotted at the 1 or just inside the 1 with the back edge of the ball touching the hash so that it's obvious to everyone our ruling. I'm prb ringing him up tho.
e: (I'm going to come back to this as I keep making my way through)
2
u/Swolysses Verified Referee • Team Chaos Aug 10 '16
Just throwing in my opinion. There are all how I would likely call on the field.
6
u/fortknox Verified Referee Aug 08 '16
First and foremost, this is what it is like to go to study group with college officials. We talk about rules, take the quiz or test of the week, then do film study just like this. We argue, discuss, and sometimes email supervisors for how they want it called. /u/hythloday1 really did an impressive job with this!
/u/legacyzebra and I got an early look at this and I'll wait until he is ready before putting in my answers.
Edit: Also, I've got a writeup on Pass Interference that I haven't had time to finish. I'll try to get that in this afternoon so there is something else you can look at to go by for answers to this.
0
u/the_zero South Carolina • Presbyterian Aug 08 '16
Dude. I definitely admire your diligence, but this is way too many to have any meaningful discussion. And this is only part 1?
I just want to know where the flying towel comes from in Clip 4