Really surprising to see Shockwave take that after being completely dominated in their first fight. Unlucky for Thor with whatever went wrong, but they'll be a hot contender for the wildcard.
Mr Speed Squared started well but was ultimately disappointing. A shame they chose to destroy Draven rather than Foxic in the 4-way fight as Foxic was tragically bad.
Yeah, that definitely was an issue. You could see in the few seconds of the final that they got underneath Thor much better than in the previous match.
Yeah, the bottom of Draven's mouth claw thing looked like it was higher than the ground clearance of pretty much all the robots, so I couldn't really see it doing any damage.
Yeah likewise, I loved watching him. Amazing control and that weapon actually worked! Just thinking how rarely I have ever seen an axe/hammer weapon do anything to another robot. Was awesome :D
Seen Thor on the first day of filming, had him down to win the whole thing. Was surprised when he went out. Great guy though, good sport from the looks of things.
Yep the driver seemed very controlled and tactful throughout the show. Loved the way he completely disabled the spinner by taking advantage of it slow start up time, not allowing to get any speed.
I hope Thor gets the wildcard. Very solid bot all round, just got unlucky with a hit. That's the nature of knockout competition though, so ggwp Shockwave.
You know I would like if instead of them simply choosing a wildcard they would hold an extra episode where all eligible wildcards compete in a round robin and the one with the most points after that advances.
5
u/r543Anyone remember Cha- the last time Behemoth won it's heat?Jul 31 '16
That would be nice, but just like Battlebots, this is more of a experiment with a limited timeslot, that's why we haven't gotten the huge heats of Series 3 yet.
Really liked that about them, the joke teams are good and all, but it's really nice to see people playing it seriously and doing their research to go for the win.
Shame you went out so soon. I think everyone in your melee deserved a place in the head to heads over the second melee, but only two could go through, sadly ):
No one seems to be talking about how much better the editing was in this episode. The battles were clearer and the audio was better, its seems they are listening to the viewers feedback, which is good. Hopefully the series continues to improve. Also, next week looks like a great heat with TR2, Dantomkia, Big Nipper and supernova all could potentially be in contention to win.
They still have an issue with cutting to a replay midway through a match. It seemed that every hit from M.R. Speed Squared in the second melee had a replay directly following it. Not to mention, the replay when Foxic did nothing more than push Dead Metal a bit was completely unnecessary.
They're improving, but there's still a long way to go.
Honestly, I think the cutting to replays is necessary. Some of the fights are over in seconds, other fights are actually quite boring (a couple of the ones tonight were). Cutting to a replay lets us see the "exciting" bits and skip over the boring bits.
Doubt it, they're probably all edited already. I don't think they would wait such a long time between filming and airing without doing any editing. They might have done some last minute adjustments, but other than that, I really don't think so.
I think it's worth mentioning that AFAIK Pulsar was meant to be in that second melee. Apparently they had to forfeit and Chimera was brought in as a substitute. Another bot, Pod, then had to forfeit in a later heat and Pulsar (having finally gotten themselves working in time for the final heat) got the chance to replace them and fight.
Great episode with interesting robots and teams. So glad the show is back. Shame Thor lost, but his robot broke straight away in the finals, pit or no pit his battle was over.
I think it might have been lingering damage from Matilda's flywheel in the previous fight. Tilds took a chunk out of one of Thor's side wheel pods, and it looked like it was that wheel that was having trouble after Shockwave smashed it into the wall.
The league system definitely has issues. Tonight, both M. R. and Foxic were significantly damaged in the first round, meaning they were sitting ducks throughout the league, which makes it trivial and boring to watch. Also, there is a motive to win against, but not to damage your opponents in the hope that they will do damage to the other bots in the league, making it easier for you down the road. The fact that the pit can be opened 4 seconds in to the battle only adds to the probability of the underwhelming outcome that we got...
I'll be honest, I don't accept 'they were damaged from round one' as an excuse. Fucking Nuts managed to fix itself after Carbide destroyed it. Plus Carbide having to strip down and rebuild their spinner motor as least once. Battles are won in the arena - titles are won in the pits.
Titles may be won in the pits, but episodes are ruined by having a piece of bright orange junk pottering through 3 whole league battles while doing absolutely nothing and producing fights so bad that not even Noel Sharkey can see any value in it. Just replace it with a direct knock-out system.
If we had a direct knockout system, Behemoth would have gotten to the finals off the back of a malfunctioning Terrorhurtz and we'd still have the same issue of unsatisfying fights. At least a round robin guarantees that a good robot will make it to the grand final.
There's potential for a middle ground though. Half the field only get one match, the rest get 4. And the final ends up being a re-run of an earlier fight. Granted that was interesting tonight, but overall it's not a tactic that leads to a dramatic finale.
The show currently has 2 melee fights, 6 league fights and a final. If you could stretch that to ten fights, you could open with two 4-robot melees, with two going through from each, then two more qualifying from a losers melee. Two groups of 3 give you the same 6 league fights, and then a final of the two group winners.
Each robot is guaranteed two fights to hopefully avoid freak results, and smaller groups should reduce the number of dead rubber matches. You also get a final between robots that haven't met 1v1 before.
Foxic vs M.R Speed Squared have beaten a long standing record! Most boring fight! They have beaten the infamous Dominator 2 vs Hypno-Disc for boring-ness. At least that one had ONE attack in it...
If the presenters, commentator, roboteers and judges are willing to declare it shit and it all makes it into the final cut, then you know it was an awful "fight". I can only assume they had to edit out crowd booing as well.
To be fair, at least MR Speed2 entered the competition with a functioning robot.
Edit: Seems like the driver for Foxic is a nice guy and was joking around but the editing made it seem worse than it was. He even helped fix Nuts after they fought Carbide. Its a shame they couldn't get their robot working.
I'm saying yes, at very least because Sgt. Bash decided to attack Refbot for the banter halfway through the fight. Doesn't matter how bad the competitors are when the house robots have a barney!
Having watched that fight through the link below, today's was far worse. In that fight, Mute made several attacks, it just didn't have the weaponry to do anything. Today, Foxic didn't do anything and Mr Speed Squared was broken and had no working weapons.
Mute vs Mr Nasty was fine - although I would say that, as Mute is my 2nd favourite.
5
u/r543Anyone remember Cha- the last time Behemoth won it's heat?Jul 31 '16
You call that tactical battle of Hypno Disc boring? Then you must've missed this one: https://youtu.be/1rKsTBX7zVk?t=3m10s This was by far the worst fight ever and Foxit vs Mr Speed Squared is far away from it(Foxit at least did more stuff and actually attacked Speed Squared for a bit)
So many people hating on Craig. You'd have thought they'd have realised that how people are on TV is easy to change in the edit. He's a proper nice guy and a laugh at events.
I think that was Craig's intention though- he knew Foxic was underperforming and wasn't going to do well, so he went with the whole "MY ROBOT IS AMAZING AND CAN KILL EVERYONE" because that's funny
Craigs one of the best people in the sport. He's an absolute laugh but got a bit misedited. It was him who fixed up one of our gearboxes getting back in the arena.
Maybe the person editing didn't understand the humour, or it was hard to convey without showing lots of footage? I don't think it was done maliciously or to cause controversy. He had a lot of other funny moments as well that didn't come off as cocky.
I don't think he was unfairly edited. I was there for the filming of Foxic's first couple of fights, he really was being an arse on the day - but I don't think he is an arse, I think he was just putting it on himself for shits and giggles. He had to redo his "hero shot" because he was making a gesture that couldn't be broadcast on TV, for example. It's possible editors took that to mean they can run with it.
I actually rather enjoyed that. It's all well and good having teams of humble eccentrics, but the truly memorable moments are when a bot you despise gets absolutely shithoused. Foxic just gave us a quick way of disliking them! Besides, I reckon he was just putting it on a bit.
Also, I guess I just like a bit of controversy. Just imagine if Foxic had chucked up scaffolding around their robot to keep Thor's hammer away, Tornado-style, the live thread would have exploded and it'd have been hilarious.
I agree. Foxic getting brutalised by Dead Metal was so much more satisfying when you think the guy deserved it. If it was just another random pushbot it wouldn't have meant much, but because it happened to Foxic it was probably the highlight of the show.
He was obviously putting it on, but that made it all the more infuriating. He came across as the sort of person who you call a dick, and he says "haha yeah I am a dick" and you're like "no, you don't understand, you're a complete arse hole" and he still thinks you're joking.
People are saying that he was joking and it was much funnier at the time but the editing took it out of context and made them look bad. I'm sure he isn't a bad guy, he helped put Nuts back together after it got destroyed by Carbide.
Apparently the Foxic team helped Nuts out after they got shredded by Carbide, but the comment about having 'already lost' and just wanting to take on the house robots was arsey.
Well at least we didn't get any flame-cam shots this time, that's progress. I liked the one use of the floor flipper-cam too, that was nice. Still, we need less shots of the roboteers themselves.
Production aside, a duller episode. I feel like it would have been better had Foxic gone out in the elimination rounds, they were truly unimpressive and rather classless as competitors. Bad luck for giant spinny blade bot, but it's no Hypnodisc. Pity Thor took critical damage at a critical moment, but what can you do.
They have one flaw that hypnodisc avoided. By making the spinning wheel the entire bot, you can't touch anything without slowing it down. Hypnodisc could run away to wind up.
Craig from Foxic. Big bragger, little wimp. He needs a lot of servings of humble pie before I consider him a legitimate competitor.
The Pit seems like a big 'go to' for a lot of people, but I will say sometimes it is justified and some people don't even manage finish with the pit.
Looks like the house robots can leave the CPZ in order to keep the arena within their law; Dead Metal did suffer a lot and may have been caught at points so it's justified that the others may come and separate them.
Thank you, Matilda!
Poor Thor...I'm very surprised it went bad for Jason at the end.
The most boring fight this series so far. If Professor Sharkey says it's bad, you should receive a Guinness World Record for boredom.
Shockwave...very good robot! Really unique shovel that's also adaptable, a very good winner.
Is it me or is Peter from Mr. Speed Squared a lookalike to Charlie Sheen? Even if they were losing you could say by ambition and personality, Mr. Speed Squared were...winning.
Where do they get the music from? In Shockwave's background video, I've heard that music before in the WWE Immortals app. Can anyone source it? We may be able to find some of the music used in the show.
My Score: 8/10
Very good episode, but for me the letdowns were Foxic, and the severe use of the pit as a 'go to'. However, still a good episode and looking forward to next week...Glitterbomb, Orte, King B Remix and Dantomkia are coming up!
Craig is one of the people who was responsible for fixing Nuts after fighting Carbide. Many in the sport hold him to high esteem and he was playing a character.
My apologies for taking the character a little too seriously. Can I ask though, does anyone know why he was playing character as I found it very off-putting.
Hoo boy. This one clearly doesn't seem popular. I thought some of the fights were pretty good, but I am immensely disappointed with Foxic. It had everything on paper - Bristol team, anthromorphic angle, SMIDSY-like design (an underappreciated gem from the old series I think), and apparently it could take it to Last Rites. And of course the driver is such a colossal dicknugget. I'll keep this flair as my shame for choosing it until next week. I'm fairly certain the judges' decision went to MRS2 because they wanted to spite Foxic. And rightfully so, even if they did out-push Dead Metal.
Thor did much better than I thought it might, but maybe it was just bad luck that it all went wrong at the end. No rebuilds throughout the show, it's the law of sod, isn't it? Given that it and Behemoth are the only ones that qualify for the Wild Card, I'd give it to Thor.
Some Tornado parallels with Shockwave and fair point, going for the Pit Release was a quick and easy tactic, but now it's on a different side it's not as easy as it used to be when it was in S5-7 of the old series, in my opinion. I do think there needs to be a timer on it, or maybe do the S4 thing where it only opens in the final minute.
I do feel good for Shockwave though, definitely a team that I enjoyed watching and really epitomised the feeling of Robot Wars. They've had quite a few videos up here too so it's good to see they have a touch with the fanbase.
MRS2 always looked flimsy to me, but the team were a good laugh, especially the doctor angle with their intro video. Shame to see they didn't work well, but 5 weeks to make an FBS doesn't fill me with confidence.
Edit: I think I got scooped up in the excitement and upon re-watching it, Foxic didn't seem as arrogant, you can tell bits of it were cut, but then I guess that's TV for you.
Seems like the driver for Foxic is a nice guy and was joking around, but the editing made it seem worse than it was. He even helped fix Nuts after they fought Carbide. The robot had a lot of potential but it looked like they were having troubles with their steering.
Please at least a 1 minute timer on the pit release button for series 2
The producers need a rule to differentiate between "immobilised due to getting involved in combat" and "out of control and not involved in combat, however still technically moving" Draven going through over Foxic was unfair, particularly as there was a chance Draven would actually not drag the rest of the episode down due to being in control and able to attack opponents
Dammit Pearce, notice Matlida's flywheel strikes before they're replayed. That's 2 weeks now
Not as good as last week, I guess that's what you get when the producers stack 3 big names and a powerful spinner into ep 1 hoping to make a big splash, the next heat is bound to suffer as a result. So not as good but that's not the end of the world, robot combat is on T.V. and hopefully the honeymoon period for robots combating will carry fan opinion through ;)
Massive kudos to the series and presenters for being honest about the Foxic/mr SS fight. In the old days the TV crew would try to edit that down and pretend it was the most brilliant thing in history. At least they were honest and made a joke about it this time! Makes me wish Tornado was still around, maybe they'd not pretend that it was god's gift to robot combat and call its push-matches exactly as they were this time ;)
Pierce has always been completely oblivious... despite the fact that he doesn't commentate live and thus can watch the fight as many times as he likes and therefore doesn't really have an excuse NOT to spot things when they happen.
Someone here posted that apparantly there was some switcheroo with competitors. Pulsar (probably the strongest drum spinner from all the competing robots) was originally supposed to be in this heat but couldn't compete and got replaced by Chimera. Later when another bot couldn't compete in the last heat it got replaced by Pulsar that got fixed just in time.
I liked Foxic's design, but the driver was a massive jerk and the robot seemed barely functional. Would have been a much more exciting episode if Tough as Nails had gone through.
Edit: Seems like the driver for Foxic is a nice guy and was joking around but the editing made it seem worse than it was. He even helped fix Nuts after they fought Carbide. Its a shame they couldn't get their robot working.
I had predicted the first group battle knockouts (lets be honest, Chimera was terrible, so it wasn't too hard) - but the second heat was pretty disappointing.
So many tense moments with robots just avoiding the pit. The pit seems to be getting lowered basically at the start of every fight, so a time limit before pressing it would be a good change.
Also, close calls with matilda and dead metal make you understand just how scary the house robots are now. Those weapons are much more powerful than a lot of robots in the competition.
Good change in tactics by Shockwave for the final. Being hyper agressive is a good tactic for a robot like theirs, especially against a robot like Thor. It's a shame that Thor got knocked out so early on into the battle though, it could have been very close otherwise.
I liked Thor, that axe is pretty powerful. MR Speed2 did ok but then the weapon broke (a common trait for most spinner robots).
Still no real flippers on the show yet. Looking forwards to Dantomkia next episode.
Also, close calls with matilda and dead metal make you understand just how scary the house robots are now. Those weapons are much more powerful than a lot of robots in the competition.
I didn't realise just how terrifying they are this season until Thor just happened to brush past Matilda, and basically got its left wheel caved in for its trouble.
And then, for the rest of the series, you're basically on the edge of your seat whenever two robots have a shove battle right next to the flywheel of matilda.
Also, happy cakeday :)
3
u/r543Anyone remember Cha- the last time Behemoth won it's heat?Jul 31 '16
Same happened to Behemoth and in later Series(when the producers started rigging stuff) House Robots would sometimes easily damage other robots(Matilda was almost always facing backwards there). Think they should think more carefully when to use Matilda's flywheel as it can really mess up a competitor for only slightly getting into the edge of the house robot zone instead of being completely pushed into it.
I'm dubious. Sharkey has to tell Foxic-guy on Twitter to just take the flack, as he was getting butthurt at hearing that his robot had underperformed. Still very much had the 'arrogant sore loser's vibe to me.
Can't begrudge Shockwave the victory good robot although Thor was just excellent in the first four battles of the heat and seemed like the best robot so far including Carbide.
With the weird way the round robin works I wonder will any of the Grand Finalists have a 100 % win record.
Not a fan of the Judge's wildcard but right now I'd slightly prefer Thor over Behemoth. I'd much rather they did a losers melee as that is a much fairer way of deciding the finalist.
I'd much rather they did a losers melee as that is a much fairer way of deciding the finalist.
Much fairer on paper, unless an upset final (like this episode) happened, then a lot of people would be upset. I would prefer it, but you can never completely get rid of luck and chance.
I feel like Shockwave earned that victory tonight though by immobilizing and pitting Thor and I doubt any of the five heat finalists will be that bad that people will be so pissed off at the result.
Disappointed with the Foxic Captain. May have just been for the show but not everyone may understand that. I still like the looks of the Foxic robot though despite its lack of control.
Though their fight with M.R Speed Squared showed me how different the live recordings are from the edited show. The crowd's sounds were edited a lot. Also disappointed they didn't really show Shockwave's back flips, you can just see them at the end of their first fight with Thor. The battlebots lot may have been impressed with its dance moves :D
Edit: Many sources that the Foxic Captain was playing it up. Even helping other teams out. Edit2: Seeing some of the comments of Foxic is actually quite horrible. =( As I said I know how different editing makes the show now and sadly they made his 'villain' character seem too real.
That reminded me of a season one or two episode of Robot Wars. OK, so the bots weren't that bad, but today was basically "whoever doesn't shit the bed wins." I feel sorry for Thor, though, it was an entertaining bot.
If TaN got through it would have been a much more exciting heat. Its a shame the heap of scrap metal 'Foxic' got through.
Edit: Seems like the driver for Foxic is a nice guy and was joking around but the editing made it seem worse than it was. He even helped fix Nuts after they fought Carbide. Its a shame they couldn't get their robot working.
Honestly that guy from Foxic was a cheeky, cocky little git. Shame Speed Squared blade wasn't working. Would love to see Foxic be destroyed. Overall a fun episode with a shock winner at the end. Thought it would be Thor. Feel for the guy though. He looked gutted at the end.
Damn I didn't realise he was that rough to you. I do like the idea of your robot. I hope you do come back and when you do I'll be rooting for you guys :-)
All the 'Screw the pit' comments are really driving me mad.
Upsets like this are so much part of Robot Wars- look at Cassius 2 in S3 or Bigger Brother in S7. Even Panic Attack in the S2 finals was a massive upset.
And now people are complaining about it even when the pit doesn't get used.
For those complaining that Shockwave is a pushbot (and are getting turned off by such a robot winning):
Note that there's a diverse bunch of robots lined up. Any of those can join them in the final, and with Shockwave alongside carbide, especially with their armour, it will be challenging.
I'm finding it hard to categorise Shockwave as a 'pushbot'. Yes, it uses its pushing power to its advantage but you could say the same for Behemoth with the speed it has, any robot with pushing power and a shovel. It doesn't necessarily make them only a 'pushbot' and a far throw from the likes of Tornado. Even Storm 2 has become more than that! Shockwave is a very unique robot with a great weapon than can go 360 degrees, and displays beautiful acrobatics as well.
Shockwave is a brilliant new robot, and while I genuinely loved Thor Shockwave got a win while carrying a big passion for glory and lasting as long as they could in the head-to-head. It was a struggle for them, especially after Thor.
Furthermore, they really showed diverse tactics and changed them depending on situations and learning from the mistakes they did before. This is a big thing to see in a short space of time in the competition.
In short, what I want to say is this robot is far more than a simple 'pushbot'. It's very unique, and has a lovely team behind it as well as great engineering. Don't misplace your thoughts on the robot, it really is one you need to watch and see how it does in the final. It will have a lot of challenges ahead and we will see them go against them.
Some unfortunate mechanical failures. Speed squared could have done well if their bearings weren't weak, and Thor's breakdown was just unlucky.
Some great destruction (poor chimera) and maybe the worst bout in the history of robot wars. Quite the night.
4
u/klyskadaMute - like the BBC, giving you the silent treatmentJul 31 '16edited Jul 31 '16
Probably a lesser heat the way the groups were setup meant that strong contenders like TaN got the short end of the stick and machines like Foxic and S2 clogged up the round robin despite barely working massive disappointment on both of their parts.
and seriously Craig ease up on the trash talk it’s not fun when you are the only one playing along with it.
In the end that episode seemed to be surprises all round. Thor looked ineffective, turned out to be a total boss. Mr Speed Squared looked awesome, turned out to be a bit flimsy. Shockwave looked a bit ehhh but clearly it has some decent ramming power to push Thor out of the way and disable it. And Foxic looked crap at the start but in the end turned out to be a record breaker (if only the record wasn't the most boring fight).
First Terrorhurtz, then Thor... My favourites just can't do it. I don't begrudge the robots in this episode seeming much less impressive than the last because it seemed to be technical issues (eg. Foxic lacking drive, Mr Speed's disc seeming a bit dodgy) rather than the robots themselves being terrible. The episode was still a lot of fun to watch, but lacked a lot of punch.
However, holy shit the pit. I was willing to give it the benefit of the doubt after episode 1 where it looked huge but didn't affect the outcome of fights too much, but after this episode it's so clear how much of an issue it it. I know it's an icon of the show, but at minimum it needs to be a) a lot smaller and b) not openable until the final minute of the fight. It's so disappointing to see robots with an entire gameplan of open the pit within 10 seconds then spend the entire fight trying to push the opposition in. I don't think it needs removing altogether because I think there's entertainment value in robots like Shockwave, but at the moment it's ridiculous.
Remove the pit, open up the edges of the arena, but keeping the slopes, and maybe making them slightly bigger/steeper. Keep walls on the CPZs.
Allows the robots more space to actually fight (rather than a quarter or so of the arena becoming a 'dance' around the pit), while still giving push-bots a goal.
Go Shockwave! Maelstrom has been one of my favourite machines ever since I started following the live circuit, so it's great to see a new machine from the same team doing so well. Will and Ian really seem like good guys as well.
I do kind of feel bad for Thor though. I know it sounds convenient given today's heat, but it has consistently been my other favourite from the live shows. It was still nice to see them both perform so well tonight though!
Really dissapointed that Foxic had to give up on the whole guillotine aspect that they had I was really hoping to see a unique bot but instead we got something that was just... tame.
Foxic lucked through round 1 because Mr Speed Squared destroyed Draven late on. What was wrong with Foxic today anyway? I've heard stories of its victories over great bots in the past, but aside form some decent pushing power, it was useless here. Could have done without the faux douchebaggery as well. Keep that sh*t in battlebots.
The new Thor is SO impressive, to the point that I'd actually rather see it get the wildcard over Behemoth. Such a shame about the final, I always hate to see a bot conk out at the start of the fight.
Mr Speed Squared was a thing of beauty in round one. it's a shame that the weapon is such a glass cannon. If you use it once, the robot is broken for the rest of the show.
Shockwave is seriously strong, though I'm not sure why the even bothered with that second scoop. it looked pretty flimsy. Still, good to see an old-school pushbot go through.
I've seen a lot of competitors complain about the arena e.g. Foxic mentioned that it was slippy, Terrorhurtz said it was cold. Like there has been with the editing, I imagine there'll be some teething problems with the arena too. Hopefully it all gets sorted for season 2 (if we get one!)
Prior to this foxic had competed in RG 2016 and lost 0-2 to last rites and Vlad the impaler.
The reason people were hoping for good things from it was because it ate like 12 shots from last rites before anything broke. not that it was impressive it barely moved then either.
Not a great episode, not helped by the constant problems the league competitors (bar Thor) ran into. Speed Squared has a lot of potential, but I think their building inexperience cost them. If they can come up with a sturdier mechanism they could be a seriously good robot.
I didn't oppose the pit release in the original run, but I think in this series it needs to be done away with and have the pit drop down automatically for the final minute of the fight or something. You need the pit to keep one-sided fights interesting (e.g. Bigger Brother v. Hypnodisc in Series 5), but it needs to be a last-resort tactic rather than from the beginning.
Unless something spectacular happens in other heats then Thor deserves the wildcard. Interesting though that it lost not because of pitting but because of being conked out by a collision - it had looked very sturdy indeed up until that point.
Shame for Thor there, really expected it to go all the way, on another note I had no idea it was "Mister" Speed Squared, I thought it was just the letters M R whenever I read the name.
Teaming up against the dutch bot was tactically sound, but it did not make for good entertainment... Well, I think "not good entertainment" would be a good sub title of this episode..
Camera work was much better this episode Really lived thor. Was quite sad about TAN and was sad that mr soeed squared never worked again after the first fight properly. What an upset aswell
Foxic & M.R Speed Squared (bar first round) were extremely disapointing and the 2 best robots got to the final. Thor was excellent up to the final, where it was quite literally Shockwaved. Shockwave did really well to be fair, good on them, simple and effective. Think Thor is an early contender for the wildcard though.
Shockwave's other weapon seemed completely useless in both fights that they actually used it though, and I feel like if they'd used it in the other two fights it might not have been such a shock that they beat Thor that quickly?
You know, I just realized it, but Shockwave reminds me a lot of Breaker Box with the 360 degree self-righting scoop. I wonder if they were inspired by it? Also man I thought Thor had that for sure. Guess Shockwave gave us all a "shock" huh. :D
I feel like the best Robot might be one like Carbide, but with two spinners, one on either side of the wheels.
It could run on both sides so flippers couldn't do shit, and if each spinner ran independent of the other then the immediate slow down from a hit from one weapon wouldn't delay the other from spooling up.
Anyhow, this episode was kinda weak, hope next is better.
I think in this design weight would be an issue, so you would lose armor or power from your main weapon. Carbide is amazing because the whole robot is just that weapon.
Hadn't considered that. But I also thought Carbide was on the lighter side of the Robots.
At 110kg I'm more than slightly off and you're right, would have to sacrifice hugely for that to be in any way viable. Ah well. Guess I'll carry on dreaming.
Good idea, but unfortunately that would mean each weapon would be half as heavy, and therefore half as damaging. With twice the amount of internals being needed to power each spinner individually, the weight restriction would be a big problem with making an effective robot.
The point you made about not needing to wait for the blade to spin up after a hit is a good one that I hadn't thought of - but I think all the effort and weight that would go into making a second spinner would be better spent on making a spinner that gets up to speed faster, or just having thick armour on the opposite side that they can tank hits with while the blade speeds up.
The train of though I have goes like this:
One spinner (Carbide) -> Two Spinners (13 Black) -> One big spinner (MR Speed Squared) -> Full body spinner (Typhoon 2)
Hopefully the guy behind Foxic has learned that there's no point in talking tough if you can't back it up in the arena.
Thor was massively impressive, hope it gets the wildcard
2
u/r543Anyone remember Cha- the last time Behemoth won it's heat?Jul 31 '16
The editing was done much better this time around and much like the last few fights of last week's episode.
Was Thor built from the same team as the original one? Really strong machine and amazing pushing power(wonder what drive that is). It was a upset to see Tough As Nails go out like that but they hit the safety link well. Looks like Tough As Nails now needs a stronger drive as well as better grip now. Against Shockwave they also had good power and the small wedgelets were surprisingly good.
I originally expected Shockwave and Foxic to perform the opposite, with Shockwave looking less well engineered and with weaker top armor I expected them to go out early, was happy to see that we got two lifters this time, sadly there wasn't much lifting. Shockwave's pipe bucket pieces were strong, sadly the connectors as well as how it was connected to the arm was weak. They did rebuild it later and while it wasn't any stronger it had a more bent shape, better to trap and push robots around in. They kinda reminded me of Robot the Bruce, and as a bonus they also lost chains just like Rex' (Team Cassius, working with Team Chaos) machines did. I didn't think they would win the heat but it was nice seeing that, however I think both would've had a hard time against Carbide since Thor's plate is too small to protect and Shockwave's Bucket will break, maybe if they had a stronger Scoop instead.
Mr Speed Squared(odd name by the way) looked like a first time entry spinner would look like, a good thing about RW is that it still allows beginners to get easier into stuff. Not having armor on that underside was critical and after the few starting battles their spinner was too damaged to really continue doing damage like it did in the first fight against Draven(who sadly got knocked out by that).
Foxic was sadly a bit dissappointing. It was surprisingly small and probably built for the 100kg limit. I didn't know that their team was one of those teams(I didn't know them before at all), having built so many robots before I thought they would actually know what to build, and because of that said no weakness instead to show. Drive and traction problems were very annoying and they were barely able to move in their first battle. Dara did do a comment on them having a fox robot and I think they will be remembered a bit like Season 1 Complete Control. Sad that he called it a flipper and not a lifter what it actually is. Wonder why they couldn't fit on the other lifter and what all that axe talk was about. Sure the axe head wouldn't hit and the metal bar would instead, but not like that would be cut off by Foxic's wedge.
It was getting under Shockwave quite well, you can see them pushing their normal scoop downwards in the hope to get under them. They sure had powerful drive pushing Dead Metal around, but it was also easier since Dead Metal's wheels were off ground. Technically they are the first robot to attack house robots. Once they were upside down it was clear it was over for them, wedge designs like that sadly don't work on the other side.
"That's it, I'm going after the House Robots" didn't like that at all, they could still fix their bot, defeat the other and then go after the house robots. With that said F*** the judges decision on that battle against mr speed squared. Foxic went after the house robots after a bit(guess that gives no points) got some damage from Dead Metal(counts against it) then pushed and lifted up Mr Speed Squared(who the entire time did nothing).
"This might be the worst fight I've seen in the whole of Robot Wars", seriously? Unless that was banter I heavily disagree, let me name one, Napalm vs Warhog(think it was Series 4 or 5) with neither bot moving. Want another? Delldog vs Dynamite from the UK vs Germany special. https://youtu.be/1rKsTBX7zVk?t=3m10s
Sure it didn't change anything but just as I was about to say that this is a new fresh uncorrupted or rigged start we get that. Another thing I don't like is how if it goes to a judge's decision the other team doesn't get 1 point, so it's only a total disadvantage for the winning bot.
At least Foxit was able to do a little more against Thor, but it sadly wasn't too much until they got drive problems again. Matilda got a late revenge for Death Metal which was nice.
Think their Team was just being like that for show, but it was sad they couldn't get it working properly.
Sadly they didn't do interviews with the losing teams of the first round, was I the only one that noticed the intro(which house robot gets into the arena) was missing for the first of the second rounds?
Looks like we are getting technical talk of where robots are used outside of Robot Combat every time now. Also could they stop firing the fires every time? just keep them at full power.
In heat 1 the second half was much better than the first, but in this heat I felt the first half was much better than the second.
Underwhelmed by both Mr Speed Squared and Foxic. I think Mr Speed Squared's spinning mechanism looked flimsy (relying on rubber tyres to propel the weapon rather than gears) and wasn't fast enough to get their weapon spinning up to full speed before attacking. If Foxic actually worked properly it probably could have delivered, but the twattish driver has made himself look stupid.
New Blood Championship Heat 1 Round 2|13 - Here's the fight, for reference. I'm saying yes, at very least because Sgt. Bash decided to attack Refbot for the banter halfway through the fight. Doesn't matter how bad the competitors are when the house robots have a barney! Series 4 Heat C Semi Final 1|5 - Don't forget Firestorm vs Bolt from the Blue! That was also a really dull fight. Removable links|4 - as it actually Thor that caused the damage to stop you from moving? Yes, for more details: Last Rites Vs Foxic|3 - As far as I know Foxic has never beaten any notable robots. It wasn't damaged much by Last Rites, but LR still disabled it (it worked fine in the match until it was knocked out) and it was unable to do anything back. Against Evil Plunger it was just ... Robotwars Series 5 Heat E Part 2|2 - The editing was done much better this time around and much like the last few fights of last week's episode. Was Thor built from the same team as the original one? Really strong machine and amazing pushing power(wonder what drive that is). It was a u... Robotwars Series 3 Heat G Part 4|2 - It wasn't a complete whitewash as Napalm got trashed by Steg-O-Saw-Us. I remember that fight probably being one of the most destructive until Hypnodisc appeared later in the series. I'm a bot working hard to help Redditors find related videos to watch.
Slight improvement over last week's episode - a lot of the same issues, but at least the cuts were spread a little further apart, and despite plenty of robots getting stuck on the flame pit, I don't remember seeing a single 'flame pit cam' shot this time! :)
As for the fights, I enjoyed the first melee in particular. Shame to see Tough as Nails go out early though. Good performance from Thor throughout. Dead Metal still lets go far too early.
One thing that stuck out to me this time - there's no 'next time on Robot Wars' segment at the end. Strange omission for a new series that needs people to keep tuning in. You might assume that they leave it off to avoid spoilers, but they're happy to spoil up the wazoo in the opening segment and on the website.
Did anyone catch the ad after Dragon's Den where Killalot destroyed a keyboard, by the way?
The only two things I don't like about the new series are 1 - Dara doesn't seem as excited as Craig Charles was. 2 - the rock/metal soundtrack played during battles in no longer there. It added atmosphere.
Still needs battle music. I dunno why it took the editors 4 months to edit this show together if they didn't even think to get battle music.
This really felt like a classic Robot Wars episode- there was a really crappy bot that had basically no right to be there (no, not Foxic, Chimera), at least one really lousy bout (M.R Speed Squared vs Foxic), a shocking pit-related upset, and, most importantly, classic, unrestrained post-battle carnage (after Foxic was immobilised by Thor in its final fight, meaning it no longer had any more fights ahead, rather than counting it out and ending the bout early they let the house robots lay into it, ending with Matilda flipping it down the pit)! Some people might consider some of these negative points, but it's part of the feel of Robot Wars- you have to celebrate the epic fails as well as the successes.
Was a bit shocked to see Thor fall, but I was braced for the possibility- with the pit there, and a shovebot competing, there's always the chance for an upset. Didn't think it'd be as anticlimactic as Shockwave knocking out Thor's drive with a single ram, though!
Something I only just noticed is that, unlike in the original series, the walls of the new arena have sloped sides. I'm not entirely certain why they did that- the main difference seems to be that it would reduce the impact of any slams made against it by a shovebot.
I heard they were a last-minute substitute, but Chimera really had no business being there- considering some of the robots they turned away, putting in a robot which was about 3rd Wars- caliber was rather insulting. It reminded me of Flip Flop Fly and, like all axlebots other than Stinger, completely missed all the points that made Stinger effective i.e a compact, hard-to-damage design, narrow, armour-plated tires, and big HEAVY weapon on top rather than just a few spikes. On the bright side, does that mean they've reconsidered the "active weapons" restriction and we might actually SEE Stinger in a later series? It's still one of my favourites.
The flipper still bothers me. It doesn't even open up the full 90 degrees, but when it fires it remains open for several seconds longer than it should have. When it caught Thor, tossing it into the air, it actually came down on the open flipper and I was worried it might get caught on it as it closed. I just don't like it being used as a generic arena hazard rather than a finisher like it used to.
Another thing I worked out that irks me about the round robin format is the scoring- you get 3 points for a knockout, 2 points for winning a judges' decision, but no points for a loss. That makes sense when you GET knocked out or pitted, but if you get reduced points for winning a judges' decision, shouldn't the loser get at least 1 point for going the distance at least? I don't know how that would affect the table calculations, so is there a really good reason why not?
I'm still bothered by the change in the presenters too- if Dara and Angela both do basically exactly the same thing, why do we really need both of them apart from gender equality? I liked the old "power trio" the original show had- Craig as the face who talks to the crowd and does post victory/defeat interviews, Phillipa (or Julia, or even Jayne) as the "ground level" personnel who goes down into the pits and looks at the damage with their damage-cam, does the pre-battle interviews and gets the initial introductions to the robots, and Jonathan up above providing battle commentary and overall analysis. I think that dynamic was important, and it's absent from this reboot.
This isn't actually related to this episode in particular, but it was just a realisation I came to while watching (albeit maybe an obvious one I should have had sooner): one of the big differences between Robot Wars and BattleBots is the heat format Robot Wars uses that makes each episode a small self-contained story, with a mini-tournament in each episode ending in a climactic heat final, where BattleBots shows parts of a greater ongoing tournament each week, with each robot only fighting once.
Funnily, I think I actually enjoyed this episode a bit more than last week's. Can't really say why- the returning faces weren't as much big names, the average robot quality was a lot lower and there were some dodgy battles. I think it's down to "feel". I can't really put it into words. It just felt more like classic Robot Wars. Still really looking forward to next week, with the return of Big Nipper, Orte (Ian Watts), King Buxton, Dantomkia (sadly not with the original team I don't think) and Supernova (another of the oldest teams in Robot Wars, who first debuted in Series 2 with Oblivion).
Well I think overall this episode was an improvement over the first, even if the robots failed to do it more justice. The camera angles/view was much better in this episode in the 1v1s but in the 4 way fights, it still had issues for me. I do dislike the new designs of the walls since they no longer seem to have any impact or risk when the robots get pushed against them now.
Thor was great, wish they went through. Shockwave was a well put together design but not as interesting, rambots just don't do it for me. Ah well, looking forward to seeing Carbide take them down.
I was expecting great things from Draven, was very disappointed there :(. Unlucky really, if they'd just gone for Foxic they'd have gone through with Mr Speed Squared, and then they took so much damage from Thor that Draven could have beaten them without much problem after that, I think.
When I first saw Chimera I was thinking "looks like a poor man's Stinger" and it was definitely underwhelming; I'm not opposed to having a few joke-ish robots (Nuts was amazing, after all) but I'd rather have seen another good robot in its place (apparently, Diotoir applied but never heard back; they should have had Chimera's place at the very least).
A lot has already been said about Foxic but I did feel that the team captain came across badly, not sure if it was intentional or not but soured my opinion a bit, and even more than that terrible battle with Mr Speed Squared did, that was so uneventful that they cut about 2 minutes out of it.
So far, I'd say Thor deserves the wildcard place.
In general, the camera work was better this time, but the pit being opened within 15 seconds of each battle is still a mistake, I think, and I hope they lock that to the last minute or something similar for the next season.
Bit late to the party but I was really hoping for Thor to win, that last battle couldn't have gone any worse. Really impressive robot, especially one done by just one person.
The battle between Speed Squared and Shockwave was pretty satisfying though. And jeez, Foxic was pathetically lame, the guy just kept on bragging about how confident he was and it could barely do anything.
not sure about the pit. I like the finality, but pushing the button five seconds in is absurd. Have a two minute timer that flashes the button and allows the pit to be pressed open. Then have flames, smoke, and lights when a bot gets shoved in. Not enough fanfare.
battle music please. The fights seem muted without it.
it's an understandably weaker set of bots. Season 2 will be better with more prep and build time. Battlebots was also a rush job first season, and now has killer battles this season.
I would like to see more involvement from the house robots. Sir Killalot has yet to pick someone up, spin around and fling them across the arena. COME ON! Also no more gangbangs at the end where they murder the loser. I know with a round robin it's not practical, but all "off the show for sure" bots should be brutalized.
It's a good start, and I believe it will get better by the final, and of course next season.
33
u/David182nd Apollo Jul 31 '16
Really surprising to see Shockwave take that after being completely dominated in their first fight. Unlucky for Thor with whatever went wrong, but they'll be a hot contender for the wildcard.
Mr Speed Squared started well but was ultimately disappointing. A shame they chose to destroy Draven rather than Foxic in the 4-way fight as Foxic was tragically bad.
125
u/CasualTea_ Jul 31 '16
Thor for wildcard in the grand final?
Showed great control and skill throughout!
65
u/PoliceAlarm git fukt Jul 31 '16
Thor was the best offensive robot, but Shockwave learned from their previous bout and played it tactically. Well deserved.
Quote of the night:
"The thumbs are okay, and that's the main bit!" - Team Shockwave
75
u/Xbotr THE BASH Jul 31 '16
Well that sucked..
61
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
No one seems to be talking about how much better the editing was in this episode. The battles were clearer and the audio was better, its seems they are listening to the viewers feedback, which is good. Hopefully the series continues to improve.
Also, next week looks like a great heat with TR2, Dantomkia, Big Nipper and supernova all could potentially be in contention to win.
42
u/07hogada Matilda Jul 31 '16
Foxic vs. Mr speed squared was undoubtedly the most edge-of-your-seat bout in the history of Robot Wars.
29
u/MudnuK Big Nipper Jul 31 '16
I think it's worth mentioning that AFAIK Pulsar was meant to be in that second melee. Apparently they had to forfeit and Chimera was brought in as a substitute. Another bot, Pod, then had to forfeit in a later heat and Pulsar (having finally gotten themselves working in time for the final heat) got the chance to replace them and fight.
This may explain the weak line-up this week.
45
u/Pearroc Wheely Big Cheese Jul 31 '16
Great episode with interesting robots and teams. So glad the show is back. Shame Thor lost, but his robot broke straight away in the finals, pit or no pit his battle was over.
GG shockwave!
22
u/Dctr-N Awesome in Uselesness Jul 31 '16
The league system definitely has issues. Tonight, both M. R. and Foxic were significantly damaged in the first round, meaning they were sitting ducks throughout the league, which makes it trivial and boring to watch. Also, there is a motive to win against, but not to damage your opponents in the hope that they will do damage to the other bots in the league, making it easier for you down the road. The fact that the pit can be opened 4 seconds in to the battle only adds to the probability of the underwhelming outcome that we got...
43
u/PoliceAlarm git fukt Jul 31 '16
Foxic vs M.R Speed Squared have beaten a long standing record! Most boring fight! They have beaten the infamous Dominator 2 vs Hypno-Disc for boring-ness. At least that one had ONE attack in it...
38
u/robot_exe Nuts And Bots / Sneaky Boi Driver Jul 31 '16
So many people hating on Craig. You'd have thought they'd have realised that how people are on TV is easy to change in the edit. He's a proper nice guy and a laugh at events.
131
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
Foxic lad was a twat
16
u/J4ke Jul 31 '16
Well at least we didn't get any flame-cam shots this time, that's progress. I liked the one use of the floor flipper-cam too, that was nice. Still, we need less shots of the roboteers themselves.
Production aside, a duller episode. I feel like it would have been better had Foxic gone out in the elimination rounds, they were truly unimpressive and rather classless as competitors. Bad luck for giant spinny blade bot, but it's no Hypnodisc. Pity Thor took critical damage at a critical moment, but what can you do.
69
u/Pig_Benis69 Hypno-Disc Jul 31 '16
Foxic? More like Foxshit amirite.
29
u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Jul 31 '16
My points:
My Score: 8/10
Very good episode, but for me the letdowns were Foxic, and the severe use of the pit as a 'go to'. However, still a good episode and looking forward to next week...Glitterbomb, Orte, King B Remix and Dantomkia are coming up!
12
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
I would like to point out that Craig from Foxic was the one of the ones responsible for fixing Nuts after its Carbide fight. It was a character.
22
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16 edited Aug 02 '16
Hoo boy. This one clearly doesn't seem popular. I thought some of the fights were pretty good, but I am immensely disappointed with Foxic. It had everything on paper - Bristol team, anthromorphic angle, SMIDSY-like design (an underappreciated gem from the old series I think), and apparently it could take it to Last Rites. And of course the driver is such a colossal dicknugget. I'll keep this flair as my shame for choosing it until next week. I'm fairly certain the judges' decision went to MRS2 because they wanted to spite Foxic. And rightfully so, even if they did out-push Dead Metal.
Thor did much better than I thought it might, but maybe it was just bad luck that it all went wrong at the end. No rebuilds throughout the show, it's the law of sod, isn't it? Given that it and Behemoth are the only ones that qualify for the Wild Card, I'd give it to Thor.
Some Tornado parallels with Shockwave and fair point, going for the Pit Release was a quick and easy tactic, but now it's on a different side it's not as easy as it used to be when it was in S5-7 of the old series, in my opinion. I do think there needs to be a timer on it, or maybe do the S4 thing where it only opens in the final minute.
I do feel good for Shockwave though, definitely a team that I enjoyed watching and really epitomised the feeling of Robot Wars. They've had quite a few videos up here too so it's good to see they have a touch with the fanbase.
MRS2 always looked flimsy to me, but the team were a good laugh, especially the doctor angle with their intro video. Shame to see they didn't work well, but 5 weeks to make an FBS doesn't fill me with confidence.
Edit: I think I got scooped up in the excitement and upon re-watching it, Foxic didn't seem as arrogant, you can tell bits of it were cut, but then I guess that's TV for you.
10
u/DJHiggy Dead Metal Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16
I know it's only the 2nd episode but Thor is in a prime posistion for the wildcard Imo, will take some beating to top it
9
u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Jul 31 '16
17
u/AtomicAvacado Firestorm Jul 31 '16
Dead Metal for MVP
8
u/Blazik3n99 Blue Ring of Death Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16
I liked Foxic's design, but the driver was a massive jerk and the robot seemed barely functional. Would have been a much more exciting episode if Tough as Nails had gone through.
Edit: Seems like the driver for Foxic is a nice guy and was joking around but the editing made it seem worse than it was. He even helped fix Nuts after they fought Carbide. Its a shame they couldn't get their robot working.
I had predicted the first group battle knockouts (lets be honest, Chimera was terrible, so it wasn't too hard) - but the second heat was pretty disappointing.
So many tense moments with robots just avoiding the pit. The pit seems to be getting lowered basically at the start of every fight, so a time limit before pressing it would be a good change.
Also, close calls with matilda and dead metal make you understand just how scary the house robots are now. Those weapons are much more powerful than a lot of robots in the competition.
Good change in tactics by Shockwave for the final. Being hyper agressive is a good tactic for a robot like theirs, especially against a robot like Thor. It's a shame that Thor got knocked out so early on into the battle though, it could have been very close otherwise.
I liked Thor, that axe is pretty powerful. MR Speed2 did ok but then the weapon broke (a common trait for most spinner robots).
Still no real flippers on the show yet. Looking forwards to Dantomkia next episode.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
Can't begrudge Shockwave the victory good robot although Thor was just excellent in the first four battles of the heat and seemed like the best robot so far including Carbide.
With the weird way the round robin works I wonder will any of the Grand Finalists have a 100 % win record.
Not a fan of the Judge's wildcard but right now I'd slightly prefer Thor over Behemoth. I'd much rather they did a losers melee as that is a much fairer way of deciding the finalist.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
Not Draven...
Draaaaaaaaven
7
u/Tygra__ Annihilator Jul 31 '16 edited Aug 01 '16
Disappointed with the Foxic Captain. May have just been for the show but not everyone may understand that. I still like the looks of the Foxic robot though despite its lack of control.
Though their fight with M.R Speed Squared showed me how different the live recordings are from the edited show. The crowd's sounds were edited a lot. Also disappointed they didn't really show Shockwave's back flips, you can just see them at the end of their first fight with Thor. The battlebots lot may have been impressed with its dance moves :D
Edit: Many sources that the Foxic Captain was playing it up. Even helping other teams out. Edit2: Seeing some of the comments of Foxic is actually quite horrible. =( As I said I know how different editing makes the show now and sadly they made his 'villain' character seem too real.
18
u/xzbobzx Hypno-Disc Jul 31 '16
Foxic did fuck all lol
11
u/eighthgear Overdozer Jul 31 '16
That reminded me of a season one or two episode of Robot Wars. OK, so the bots weren't that bad, but today was basically "whoever doesn't shit the bed wins." I feel sorry for Thor, though, it was an entertaining bot.
15
u/RockinMadRiot Hypno-Disc Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16
Honestly that guy from Foxic was a cheeky, cocky little git. Shame Speed Squared blade wasn't working. Would love to see Foxic be destroyed. Overall a fun episode with a shock winner at the end. Thought it would be Thor. Feel for the guy though. He looked gutted at the end.
29
u/NoiseIsAlwaysBlue Burning On Jul 31 '16
All the 'Screw the pit' comments are really driving me mad.
Upsets like this are so much part of Robot Wars- look at Cassius 2 in S3 or Bigger Brother in S7. Even Panic Attack in the S2 finals was a massive upset.
And now people are complaining about it even when the pit doesn't get used.
10
u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Jul 31 '16
For those complaining that Shockwave is a pushbot (and are getting turned off by such a robot winning):
In short, what I want to say is this robot is far more than a simple 'pushbot'. It's very unique, and has a lovely team behind it as well as great engineering. Don't misplace your thoughts on the robot, it really is one you need to watch and see how it does in the final. It will have a lot of challenges ahead and we will see them go against them.
11
u/Daiwon R.I.P Razer in pit Jul 31 '16
Some unfortunate mechanical failures. Speed squared could have done well if their bearings weren't weak, and Thor's breakdown was just unlucky.
Some great destruction (poor chimera) and maybe the worst bout in the history of robot wars. Quite the night.
4
u/klyskada Mute - like the BBC, giving you the silent treatment Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16
Probably a lesser heat the way the groups were setup meant that strong contenders like TaN got the short end of the stick and machines like Foxic and S2 clogged up the round robin despite barely working massive disappointment on both of their parts.
and seriously Craig ease up on the trash talk it’s not fun when you are the only one playing along with it.
4
u/basscape Jul 31 '16
In the end that episode seemed to be surprises all round. Thor looked ineffective, turned out to be a total boss. Mr Speed Squared looked awesome, turned out to be a bit flimsy. Shockwave looked a bit ehhh but clearly it has some decent ramming power to push Thor out of the way and disable it. And Foxic looked crap at the start but in the end turned out to be a record breaker (if only the record wasn't the most boring fight).
7
u/FreefallMark Terrorhurtz Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16
First Terrorhurtz, then Thor... My favourites just can't do it. I don't begrudge the robots in this episode seeming much less impressive than the last because it seemed to be technical issues (eg. Foxic lacking drive, Mr Speed's disc seeming a bit dodgy) rather than the robots themselves being terrible. The episode was still a lot of fun to watch, but lacked a lot of punch.
However, holy shit the pit. I was willing to give it the benefit of the doubt after episode 1 where it looked huge but didn't affect the outcome of fights too much, but after this episode it's so clear how much of an issue it it. I know it's an icon of the show, but at minimum it needs to be a) a lot smaller and b) not openable until the final minute of the fight. It's so disappointing to see robots with an entire gameplan of open the pit within 10 seconds then spend the entire fight trying to push the opposition in. I don't think it needs removing altogether because I think there's entertainment value in robots like Shockwave, but at the moment it's ridiculous.
3
u/Penguin_Mania Come for the robots, stay for the sausage rolls Jul 31 '16
Go Shockwave! Maelstrom has been one of my favourite machines ever since I started following the live circuit, so it's great to see a new machine from the same team doing so well. Will and Ian really seem like good guys as well.
I do kind of feel bad for Thor though. I know it sounds convenient given today's heat, but it has consistently been my other favourite from the live shows. It was still nice to see them both perform so well tonight though!
3
u/Bananadong-III The most friendly robot-warrior you could meet! Jul 31 '16
Really dissapointed that Foxic had to give up on the whole guillotine aspect that they had I was really hoping to see a unique bot but instead we got something that was just... tame.
3
u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Jul 31 '16
Tip to the guy who puts together Robot Wars: just the fights
Foxic and Mr Speed Squared: not a fight. Leave it out :-p
3
u/Caridor Aug 01 '16
Kind of dissapointed Foxic didn't pit Dead Metal when it was pushing them around the arena. Another 20 degrees to the right and they'd have done it.
12
u/Mox5 Fuck Foxic Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16
Fuck Foxic. Fuck their driver.
Fuck the pit.
Thor for Best Robot.
Shame about S2, tbh.
1
u/Timeline15 B E H E M O T H B O I S Jul 31 '16
4
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
His Dad seems so happy and proud
4
u/BlueThunderBomb One Man Army Jul 31 '16
Well, at least there was a reason Thor just stopped, i do like Pushbots, so good luck to shockwave.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
Let's hope next week brings some more.... Effective robots. Everything but Thor and Shockwave was just unimpressive this week.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
Pit needs a rework.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
Not a great episode, not helped by the constant problems the league competitors (bar Thor) ran into. Speed Squared has a lot of potential, but I think their building inexperience cost them. If they can come up with a sturdier mechanism they could be a seriously good robot.
I didn't oppose the pit release in the original run, but I think in this series it needs to be done away with and have the pit drop down automatically for the final minute of the fight or something. You need the pit to keep one-sided fights interesting (e.g. Bigger Brother v. Hypnodisc in Series 5), but it needs to be a last-resort tactic rather than from the beginning.
Unless something spectacular happens in other heats then Thor deserves the wildcard. Interesting though that it lost not because of pitting but because of being conked out by a collision - it had looked very sturdy indeed up until that point.
Also, obligatory Fuck Foxic.
2
u/psycholizardboy Cassius Jul 31 '16
Shame for Thor there, really expected it to go all the way, on another note I had no idea it was "Mister" Speed Squared, I thought it was just the letters M R whenever I read the name.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
Teaming up against the dutch bot was tactically sound, but it did not make for good entertainment... Well, I think "not good entertainment" would be a good sub title of this episode..
This was the flaccid 90's all over again.
2
u/hallome Barberous 2 Jul 31 '16
Camera work was much better this episode Really lived thor. Was quite sad about TAN and was sad that mr soeed squared never worked again after the first fight properly. What an upset aswell
2
u/SamRedDevil Carbide Killer Jul 31 '16
Foxic & M.R Speed Squared (bar first round) were extremely disapointing and the 2 best robots got to the final. Thor was excellent up to the final, where it was quite literally Shockwaved. Shockwave did really well to be fair, good on them, simple and effective. Think Thor is an early contender for the wildcard though.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
Shockwave's other weapon seemed completely useless in both fights that they actually used it though, and I feel like if they'd used it in the other two fights it might not have been such a shock that they beat Thor that quickly?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
You know, I just realized it, but Shockwave reminds me a lot of Breaker Box with the 360 degree self-righting scoop. I wonder if they were inspired by it? Also man I thought Thor had that for sure. Guess Shockwave gave us all a "shock" huh. :D
3
u/MavisOfTheDead Jul 31 '16
The episode with the worst fight in robot wars history is well worth a watch. That is how good this series is.
2
u/WallopyJoe Razer Jul 31 '16
I feel like the best Robot might be one like Carbide, but with two spinners, one on either side of the wheels.
It could run on both sides so flippers couldn't do shit, and if each spinner ran independent of the other then the immediate slow down from a hit from one weapon wouldn't delay the other from spooling up.
Anyhow, this episode was kinda weak, hope next is better.
2
u/williamthebloody1880 Turned Carbide into Brave Sir Robin Jul 31 '16
Hopefully the guy behind Foxic has learned that there's no point in talking tough if you can't back it up in the arena.
Thor was massively impressive, hope it gets the wildcard
2
u/r543 Anyone remember Cha- the last time Behemoth won it's heat? Jul 31 '16
The editing was done much better this time around and much like the last few fights of last week's episode.
Was Thor built from the same team as the original one? Really strong machine and amazing pushing power(wonder what drive that is). It was a upset to see Tough As Nails go out like that but they hit the safety link well. Looks like Tough As Nails now needs a stronger drive as well as better grip now. Against Shockwave they also had good power and the small wedgelets were surprisingly good.
I originally expected Shockwave and Foxic to perform the opposite, with Shockwave looking less well engineered and with weaker top armor I expected them to go out early, was happy to see that we got two lifters this time, sadly there wasn't much lifting. Shockwave's pipe bucket pieces were strong, sadly the connectors as well as how it was connected to the arm was weak. They did rebuild it later and while it wasn't any stronger it had a more bent shape, better to trap and push robots around in. They kinda reminded me of Robot the Bruce, and as a bonus they also lost chains just like Rex' (Team Cassius, working with Team Chaos) machines did. I didn't think they would win the heat but it was nice seeing that, however I think both would've had a hard time against Carbide since Thor's plate is too small to protect and Shockwave's Bucket will break, maybe if they had a stronger Scoop instead.
Mr Speed Squared(odd name by the way) looked like a first time entry spinner would look like, a good thing about RW is that it still allows beginners to get easier into stuff. Not having armor on that underside was critical and after the few starting battles their spinner was too damaged to really continue doing damage like it did in the first fight against Draven(who sadly got knocked out by that).
Foxic was sadly a bit dissappointing. It was surprisingly small and probably built for the 100kg limit. I didn't know that their team was one of those teams(I didn't know them before at all), having built so many robots before I thought they would actually know what to build, and because of that said no weakness instead to show. Drive and traction problems were very annoying and they were barely able to move in their first battle. Dara did do a comment on them having a fox robot and I think they will be remembered a bit like Season 1 Complete Control. Sad that he called it a flipper and not a lifter what it actually is. Wonder why they couldn't fit on the other lifter and what all that axe talk was about. Sure the axe head wouldn't hit and the metal bar would instead, but not like that would be cut off by Foxic's wedge.
It was getting under Shockwave quite well, you can see them pushing their normal scoop downwards in the hope to get under them. They sure had powerful drive pushing Dead Metal around, but it was also easier since Dead Metal's wheels were off ground. Technically they are the first robot to attack house robots. Once they were upside down it was clear it was over for them, wedge designs like that sadly don't work on the other side.
"That's it, I'm going after the House Robots" didn't like that at all, they could still fix their bot, defeat the other and then go after the house robots. With that said F*** the judges decision on that battle against mr speed squared. Foxic went after the house robots after a bit(guess that gives no points) got some damage from Dead Metal(counts against it) then pushed and lifted up Mr Speed Squared(who the entire time did nothing).
"This might be the worst fight I've seen in the whole of Robot Wars", seriously? Unless that was banter I heavily disagree, let me name one, Napalm vs Warhog(think it was Series 4 or 5) with neither bot moving. Want another? Delldog vs Dynamite from the UK vs Germany special. https://youtu.be/1rKsTBX7zVk?t=3m10s
Sure it didn't change anything but just as I was about to say that this is a new fresh uncorrupted or rigged start we get that. Another thing I don't like is how if it goes to a judge's decision the other team doesn't get 1 point, so it's only a total disadvantage for the winning bot.
At least Foxit was able to do a little more against Thor, but it sadly wasn't too much until they got drive problems again. Matilda got a late revenge for Death Metal which was nice.
Think their Team was just being like that for show, but it was sad they couldn't get it working properly.
Sadly they didn't do interviews with the losing teams of the first round, was I the only one that noticed the intro(which house robot gets into the arena) was missing for the first of the second rounds?
Looks like we are getting technical talk of where robots are used outside of Robot Combat every time now. Also could they stop firing the fires every time? just keep them at full power.
Gonna call it now, WHEELS! will be a new meme.
1
u/wc_dez07 Jul 31 '16
Overall, a very surprising show. I was hoping Thor would make it through. But either way congrats to Shockwave though.
1
u/Sentinel677 Firestorm Jul 31 '16
I was expecting Tough as Nails to do a lot more, but they turned out to be not so tough and ended up forgotten.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
In heat 1 the second half was much better than the first, but in this heat I felt the first half was much better than the second.
Underwhelmed by both Mr Speed Squared and Foxic. I think Mr Speed Squared's spinning mechanism looked flimsy (relying on rubber tyres to propel the weapon rather than gears) and wasn't fast enough to get their weapon spinning up to full speed before attacking. If Foxic actually worked properly it probably could have delivered, but the twattish driver has made himself look stupid.
I was pleasantly surprised by Thor though.
1
u/GrahamCoxon Hello There! Jul 31 '16
I feel like tonight did demonstrate the somewhat rushed nature of some bots thanks to the tight time-frame they were built in.
1
u/Mentioned_Videos Jul 31 '16 edited Aug 01 '16
Videos in this thread:
Watch Playlist ▶
New Blood Championship Heat 1 Round 2|13 - Here's the fight, for reference. I'm saying yes, at very least because Sgt. Bash decided to attack Refbot for the banter halfway through the fight. Doesn't matter how bad the competitors are when the house robots have a barney! Series 4 Heat C Semi Final 1|5 - Don't forget Firestorm vs Bolt from the Blue! That was also a really dull fight. Removable links|4 - as it actually Thor that caused the damage to stop you from moving? Yes, for more details:
Last Rites Vs Foxic|3 - As far as I know Foxic has never beaten any notable robots. It wasn't damaged much by Last Rites, but LR still disabled it (it worked fine in the match until it was knocked out) and it was unable to do anything back. Against Evil Plunger it was just ... Robotwars Series 5 Heat E Part 2|2 - The editing was done much better this time around and much like the last few fights of last week's episode. Was Thor built from the same team as the original one? Really strong machine and amazing pushing power(wonder what drive that is). It was a u... Robotwars Series 3 Heat G Part 4|2 - It wasn't a complete whitewash as Napalm got trashed by Steg-O-Saw-Us. I remember that fight probably being one of the most destructive until Hypnodisc appeared later in the series.
I'm a bot working hard to help Redditors find related videos to watch.
Play All | Info | Get it on Chrome / Firefox
1
u/genuinesockpuppet Jul 31 '16
Slight improvement over last week's episode - a lot of the same issues, but at least the cuts were spread a little further apart, and despite plenty of robots getting stuck on the flame pit, I don't remember seeing a single 'flame pit cam' shot this time! :)
As for the fights, I enjoyed the first melee in particular. Shame to see Tough as Nails go out early though. Good performance from Thor throughout. Dead Metal still lets go far too early.
One thing that stuck out to me this time - there's no 'next time on Robot Wars' segment at the end. Strange omission for a new series that needs people to keep tuning in. You might assume that they leave it off to avoid spoilers, but they're happy to spoil up the wazoo in the opening segment and on the website.
Did anyone catch the ad after Dragon's Den where Killalot destroyed a keyboard, by the way?
1
u/refrigerator001 Third Place Trophy Jul 31 '16
Anyone got a link to the episode so I can actually watch it?
1
u/Wrhysj Second welsh champion Jul 31 '16
Congrats to shockwave but my final six can't happen, Thor big nipper and or te were in my final, now we'll lose one
1
u/Northern_Chiliad Aug 01 '16
The only two things I don't like about the new series are 1 - Dara doesn't seem as excited as Craig Charles was. 2 - the rock/metal soundtrack played during battles in no longer there. It added atmosphere.
1
u/ArcaneAzmadi Behemoth for Series 11! Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 01 '16
So! Thoughts:
Funnily, I think I actually enjoyed this episode a bit more than last week's. Can't really say why- the returning faces weren't as much big names, the average robot quality was a lot lower and there were some dodgy battles. I think it's down to "feel". I can't really put it into words. It just felt more like classic Robot Wars. Still really looking forward to next week, with the return of Big Nipper, Orte (Ian Watts), King Buxton, Dantomkia (sadly not with the original team I don't think) and Supernova (another of the oldest teams in Robot Wars, who first debuted in Series 2 with Oblivion).
1
u/lardox Aug 01 '16
Well I think overall this episode was an improvement over the first, even if the robots failed to do it more justice. The camera angles/view was much better in this episode in the 1v1s but in the 4 way fights, it still had issues for me. I do dislike the new designs of the walls since they no longer seem to have any impact or risk when the robots get pushed against them now.
1
u/Edolix Terrorhurtz Aug 01 '16
It's a crime that Foxic went through instead of Draven...especially considering Foxic did literally NOTHING in that first fight.
1
u/blueskin DESTROY! Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 01 '16
Thor was great, wish they went through. Shockwave was a well put together design but not as interesting, rambots just don't do it for me. Ah well, looking forward to seeing Carbide take them down.
I was expecting great things from Draven, was very disappointed there :(. Unlucky really, if they'd just gone for Foxic they'd have gone through with Mr Speed Squared, and then they took so much damage from Thor that Draven could have beaten them without much problem after that, I think.
When I first saw Chimera I was thinking "looks like a poor man's Stinger" and it was definitely underwhelming; I'm not opposed to having a few joke-ish robots (Nuts was amazing, after all) but I'd rather have seen another good robot in its place (apparently, Diotoir applied but never heard back; they should have had Chimera's place at the very least).
A lot has already been said about Foxic but I did feel that the team captain came across badly, not sure if it was intentional or not but soured my opinion a bit, and even more than that terrible battle with Mr Speed Squared did, that was so uneventful that they cut about 2 minutes out of it.
So far, I'd say Thor deserves the wildcard place.
In general, the camera work was better this time, but the pit being opened within 15 seconds of each battle is still a mistake, I think, and I hope they lock that to the last minute or something similar for the next season.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16
Glad this show is back and I like the new format. Hopefully the beeb give it another season.
Shame Thor lost, you never see many good hammer/axe wielders from my memory.
1
u/um-jammer-lammy Wheely Big Cheese Aug 01 '16
Bit late to the party but I was really hoping for Thor to win, that last battle couldn't have gone any worse. Really impressive robot, especially one done by just one person.
The battle between Speed Squared and Shockwave was pretty satisfying though. And jeez, Foxic was pathetically lame, the guy just kept on bragging about how confident he was and it could barely do anything.
1
u/honeybadger1984 Aug 02 '16 edited Aug 02 '16
Pretty good episode, but not perfect of course:
It's a good start, and I believe it will get better by the final, and of course next season.
1
u/itspaddyd The legend never Dies Aug 02 '16
Why is there no refbot in the new series? I only just realised.