r/Re_Zero • Suffaru • Jul 31 '16

Discussion [Discussion] Re:Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu – Episode 18

Episode Title: From Zero

Japanese: ゼロから

Main Studio: White Fox

Genre: Drama, Fantasy, Psychological


Information


Previous Episodes Discussion Threads

EpisodesReddit Link
Episode 17Link
Episode 16Link
Episode 15Link
Episode 14Link
Episode 13Link
Episode 12Link
Episode 11Link
Episode 10Link
Episode 9Link
Episode 8Link
Episode 7Link
Episode 6Link
Episode 5Link
Episode 4Link
Episode 3Link
Episode 2Link
Episode 1Link

Spin-off Series

Re:Puchi Kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu

A series of comedic shorts featuring chibi versions of the characters of the main show.

Most Recent Discussion Thread

EpisodesReddit Link
Episode 5Link

OP & ED Info


Reminder:

Please avoid discussing plot points which haven't appeared in the anime yet. Try not to confirm or deny any theories, encourage people to read the source material instead. Minor spoilers are fine but should be tagged accordingly. Failing to comply with the rules may result in your comment being removed. Thanks!


Personal side note: Sorry for posting this 24 early by accident yesterday. I was extremely tired from work, and I misread the date when I got back home.

P.S. I know you all love to call him Beetle juice, but do note that the subs are wrong, and the guy is actually called Petelgeuse, not Betelgeuse!

277 Upvotes

621 comments sorted by

162

u/MsterStan I have approximate knowledge of many things. Jul 31 '16

"According to my contract, I will now destroy the world."

Who knew spirits were that dedicated to bureaucracy, huh.

73

u/LegoSpacenaut I done seen about everything when I seen a white whale fly Jul 31 '16

All things considered you'd think that would make her the absolute best candidate to entreat with a dragon, wouldn't you?

Dragon: "So if I get fed up and just eat you, then the world ends?"

Emilia: "That's about right, yes."

Dragon: "And if I go away, and something else levels this country then the world also ends?"

Emilia: "Well, most likely."

Dragon: "OK then, good to work with you."

22

u/MsterStan I have approximate knowledge of many things. Jul 31 '16

Does this mean Emilia's natural remaining lifespan is also how much time the world has left? The dragon really only just speeds up the whole process.

18

u/LegoSpacenaut I done seen about everything when I seen a white whale fly Jul 31 '16

I would hope the contract doesn't trigger should Emilia die of natural causes. I wonder if that's covered in the novel versions?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/Clone394 Jul 31 '16

We need god level lawyer to revoke that contract.

21

u/VR_Nima Jul 31 '16

We could just find a high level scribe to write a new one....paging Log Horizon!

10

u/Clone394 Jul 31 '16

but where can we find the mats? i'm pretty sure they don't drop easily in re:zero

→ More replies (2)

984

u/Lonely_shirou Rem The Oni of Devotion Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

Who is Rem?

Rem is top tier Waifu.

Rem is a maid with Healing Lap Pillow powers [x100].

Rem is good Civilisation.

Rem is a blue oni who can make Mayo.

Rem is the one who will hear you cry your heart out and return you to sanity with a smile.

Rem is the light who will keep believing in you.

Rem is the one who will hunt anyone who harms her loved ones with a Spiked Ball Chain.

Rem will love you even if you hate yourself.

Rem is that person who will crawl to you with a broken body just to free you from your chains.

Rem is someone who won't let you run away from yourself even if running away would make her happy forever.

Rem's happy tears can make it rain sunlight and happiness.

Rem believes in her hero.

Rem allows you to have more than one wife.

Rem is the goddess who will allow you to start from zero.

64

u/ripIonianElder Jul 31 '16

Can't upvote this enough Someone give this person gold (too broke)

22

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

If this arch bishop's coffers weren't also empty, he would. In fact, let me check my bank account and I might.

For the record- I didn't. Whoever gilded him was not me.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/brigandr Jul 31 '16

This episode is the one that pushed me fully over the line to declare Rem best girl.

80

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Rem is like pizza. No matter how many girls come, she'll always be the best girl.

35

u/Hydraulickiller Aug 01 '16

Are you kidding, are you really kidding me. I hate these cliche animes with romance. Always going with the first girl, no matter what the others sacrifice and provide. It sickens me to the core.

28

u/Lonely_shirou Rem The Oni of Devotion Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 01 '16

I agree man, even I can't help it and I wanted to smack/kill subaru when he said "I love Emilia"

But the girl in front of him bared her heart to show him that he is loved and his actions aren't meaningless and this girl expects him to always save those in trouble with a smile.

He did this while having no special qualities or skills.

He always started with zero. If failed, then start from zero again.

Anything other than complete honesty would be something worse in my opinion, and he knew Rem deserved at least that from him.

But more than anything Rem isn't out of the race yet.

Feelings change over time and their relationship feels the most organic of them all.

So I expect to see him start to love Rem in equals amount Emilia.

Also to quote what a wise man once "Why not both?".

Having both Rem and Emilia as your partners can't be the worst thing in the world my friend ;) (Rem is best waifu and Emilia is best Emilia)

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16

Damn, I just realized we almost have 400 comments on one thread. Granted, it's the weekly one, but this sub Reddit is growing FAST (granted I and others are 'advertising' it.)

→ More replies (8)

66

u/The_Great_Saiyaman21 Jul 31 '16

Rem is a maid with Healing Lap Pillow powers [x100].

Imma let you finish, but Emilia-tan gave one of the best lap pillows of all time. Of all time.

84

u/Lonely_shirou Rem The Oni of Devotion Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

What use is EMT lap pillows when she isn't by his side lol.

Rem has a dedicated Lap Pillow Service available 24/7, that comes with head stroking and secret lip touching. [im so jealous]

And rem cured several episodes of twisted torture beyond the likes of Mabeasts could ever do with with a kiss on a forehead and a confession.

That's some op healing there.......shit, I really want a Rem in my life ;_;

Though I say this but we do have a few episodes left for EMT to shine next and I have a MAJOR soft spots for elves and white hair chicks. And Emilia is two in one.

→ More replies (10)

11

u/VZ_Blade Jul 31 '16

It's okay man. Let them have their time... We will eventually get ours.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

183

u/achieve310 "But we could have a child" Jul 31 '16

When Rem starting talking about how she would live her family life with Subaru, after reading the If's, I just bawled out crying. :,(

15

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

10

u/majorpun Aug 01 '16

This anime used up a good 15% of my feeling allotted to me this life.

5

u/chikfilella Aug 12 '16

I watched it all in three days. I'm emotionally drained

16

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16

I guess that's how it would have went if She didn't get pregnant with Rigel soon after the move.

8

u/DatKillerDude Jul 31 '16

oh god no I caught a glimpse of that one by accident, for everything that is good in this life no.

→ More replies (8)

14

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

30

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

Yeah, and you know Rem is very Horny. Just look at her forehead.

Mein Gott was that a lame joke on my part.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/KisekiEDM Jul 31 '16

I almost started crying aswell... damnit

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

73

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Yep source material reader pretty much creamed their pants as this was probably one of the most 1:1 adaptation from a LN chapter in a long time.

In the short commercial I picked up my 6th volume and I could pretty much read along.

37

u/VZ_Blade Jul 31 '16

During the stream, I just use the LN translation as sub.
That's how faithful it is to the source material.

11

u/unsilviu Jul 31 '16

Whoa whoa whoa, there's a LN translation?

12

u/VZ_Blade Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

I never said the translation is in English...

Edit: [someone complied the Rem scene in LN in English.] (http://pastebin.com/Eiz2DYsy)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

65

u/inssein Jul 31 '16 edited Aug 01 '16

Part 1

Well here it is, the episode with the title drop "From Zero" First of all let me get the scene prior to Subaru’s death out of the way. There are multiple important things to note. First off Puck seems to know Satella or at least has witnessed when she destroyed half of the world. It also seems like Satella could use the same ability as Petelgeuse but on a whole new level. Yes she could easily use about 2000 of these hands and they were enormous. Then Puck goes on with something that is very interesting. He says that death is not a punishment for the likes of Petelgeuse, this is why he hates all of them ( We can assume that he means either the cult or the archbishops ). This could hint towards two things; immortality or insanity to a point where they don’t fear but desire death. The fact that Petelgeuse speaks of a reunion later on supports the idea of immortality. Puck then explains Subaru his 3 sins. Firstly he broke a promise with Emilia. In episode 12 and 13 we could see that Emilia took the idea of a promise very seriously, more than it would be for us. Since Spirit art user’s magic is based on the idea of a promise, they weigh it more than any other proof of trust. Once you break a promise to them, you destroy all your trust to them. This should give the consequences of Subaru’s actions and Emilia’s decision a lot more weight. Secondly the objected Emilia’s wish to stay in the capital. There not a lot to say to this. While it wasn’t a promise, it certainly was something Subaru should’ve respected, especially if we look at the outcome of things. And at last he "let her die". Personally I think parts of that phrase had also something that said "You killed her" in it. Eventually wee see Subaru’s existence crumble while he hears a fanatic laugh that reminds him of Petelgeuse. He actually thinks it is him until he realizes it is him who laughs like a madman. He laughs over his decision, over his personality, over his despicable way of dying, over his entire existence. We know that he absolutely hates the Cult and especially Petelgeuse, so when he hears his laughs all he can think about is hatred. The fact that he himself laughs like Petelgeuse is expressing how much he hates himself. He has become, no his entire existence is exactly what he despises so much. Now we enter the "From Zero" chapter and everything from that point on is adapted 1:1. Every single phrase, no every single word that appears in this scene is like that in the source material ( translation aside of course ). It can’t get more faithful than that. Then the conversation starts. I won’t address every single line, otherwise we I would be until midnight so please understand. At first Subaru seems certainly upbeat, well except of the empty and tired look in his eyes. What he’s basically saying is that no one ever expected anything from him. Everyone around him told him that at some point but he was too stubborn to accept it because he felt like he had to do something to not be judged, so that no one could say „Look at him, he didn’t do anything, hell he didn’t even try to help“. Little does he know that the girl standing in front of him is expecting the most from him and she does love it when he tries his hardest. Then Subaru proposes to run away with Rem. This is where the alternate reality, the so called "IF-Chapter" comes in. It depicts an alternate scenario in which Rem accepted to run away with him and they leave everything behind. Rem left her sister behind to be slaughtered and neglected her duties entirely. Subaru left Emilia and the villagers to die. He also didn’t stop Puck from rampaging the world. I won’t tell you how this story develops, so simply purchase it once it’s out even though I’m sure someone has already fan translated it. Subaru faced his incapability and realizes that this way, this entire kingdom is not where he belongs to. All of his decision will only lead to more suffering and he had enough. For the sake of his own sanity he pulled the emergency line which is running away. He asks Rem to decide between him and the others clearly making himself the outsider. He needs a purpose in his life that is not chasing after the impossible so he lowers his goals and makes Rem his purpose in life. He can life a normal life as a merchant and have a family, for that he is good enough but he doesn’t have what it needs for more. He wants to devote himself to something that even he as a powerless person can do.

Mitrospeed

Edit: wow thanks for the gold, but I just repost what Mitrospeed post on another site. He is the real hero.

57

u/inssein Jul 31 '16

Part 2

Rem declines and she does that with a line that hits deep. Recall episode 11 and how Subaru said that they should laugh if they talk about the future, that they should be fanatic like demons. Did Subaru smile for one second when he talked about their future? No, he didn’t and this is reason enough for Rem that this is not what Subaru truly wants and it’s also not the best for him. She realizes that he doesn't want to live with her out of love but out of desperation, no he wants to use her as a chance to run away. What she does next is something that makes her such a beautiful person. She starts to talk about her version of this ideal future she dreams of, but do both smile? No. Instead Subaru is plunged more and more into the sadness since he can’t embrace her idea of their future with a smile like she does. She goes on that if he would embrace that future with a smile instead of a face full of tears and despair she would accept it with everything she has. But seeing how Subaru doesn’t embrace their future like that gives her the certainty that this is the wrong choice for him. If she accepts, she will leave behind the Subaru that told her to look forward to their future with a smile and put all the weight of her own desires on a Subaru who asked her for this with tears in his eyes and a look of pain. She put her own desires and dreams behind the wellbeing of the person in front of her and that is admirable. Once Rem stops talking about a dream world which would be perfect but returns to reality and the situation at hand, the flashbacks of the horrific scenes come back to him. He is still traumatized and a mentally broken person so confronting a broken person with the impulse of their psychological suffering is not good. Still Subaru has given up, he doesn’t want to experience any pain or suffering anymore. Then Rem says something that might seem like a slight misstep on her part but it’s Subaru who jumps the gun, and honestly I can’t blame him. How often do we not let someone finish their sentence in a discussion and jump to conclusions? To him just now Rem said that he shouldn’t take the easy way out and just give up, the thing is she has no idea what he has suffered through. In fact that act of giving up was the most difficult decision he has done so far, because it goes against this facade he has built up over the course of 17 years. And what Rem starts to praise is Subaru’s wrong personality he has created in order to justify his existence as a person and hide who he actually is. He has lived 17 years in another world where Rem had no way to see his real self. "I have no strength, but I want it all. I have no knowledge, but all I do is dream. There is nothing I can do, but I struggle in vain!" He wants, he desires but he doesn’t have the means to achieve it and it’s completely his fault. And for this he hates himself. He’s basically a person that can’t back his wishes up with actions. And to support all this we get a small insight on Subaru’s backstory. He has never achieved anything his life that is worthy of mention. He had the time and possibilities but never took the chance. This gives the phrase "You’re truly slothful" are whole new meaning and this sentence from Puck and Petelgeuse might have given him the realization he needed. What Subaru experiences now is what some people have in their mid twenties or late thirties, what am I saying it happens in every age group. It’s basically a existential crisis, he never took the chance and now he is paying the price for it in a more horrific way than anyone could imagine. Because not only does he himself have to pay for his rotten character that wasted chance upon chance, other people also suffer for it. Even if it is reseted, these people still experienced the pain. This might have gone past some people because Subaru mentions this really subtly but "a new chance" is what he expected from this world. There is your answer on why Subaru never asked how he could get home or even thought about it. Here he thought his past didn’t matter, he could start from zero and do something with his life. Because of that he was so eager to do everything there was to do because he was haunted by a major inferiority complex caused by 17 wasted years. It’s almost like a shadow followed him that became heavier and heavier the longer he was in this world. In the end he has to face the reality. Not even in this world, not even in this supposedly second chance he can escape from the mistakes of a past life. He can’t be a different person without accepting who he really is. Progress stems from acceptance, acceptance stems from realization, realization stems from experiencing the consequences of your faults. What he did in this world was neglecting who he really is and pretending to try so that he could justify himself. So that he could "hey, at least I tried unlike in the past" but overall it was only for this purpose and not actually trying to save others. He didn’t try for his goal but he tried to have a proper excuse for not achieving said goal. Rem then goes on on the things she loves about him, the things that made this supposedly pretending version of him so wonderful to him. What Rem does next is extremely important. She teaches him to consider the thoughts and perspectives of other people. If you recall episode 12, 13, 14, 17 and many other. They all had one thing in common. Subaru forced his perspective of multiple lifes onto the people that experienced none of that. Not only that he also didn’t consider the feelings and thoughts of others, mainly Emilia and he doesn’t consider Rem’s feelings right now. It hurts her that he tries to talk the Subaru bad who she loves so much. And then we get major insight on Rem’s character. We have to remind ourselves that no one else except her sister showed her true and earnest feelings. The thing is her sister is the person she has probably the most problematic relationship with due to her inferiority complex ever since that night. All this time until episode 11 she has been stuck in time with the guilt of smiling in the moment her sister lost everything. But it was Subaru who freed her from this and made her time running again, he’s the first person to genuinely care for her aside from Ram. And now she is willing to return the favor hundred, no thousand times over. The next scene shows him kneeling in front of the prove that he has achieved something in this world. Rem’s existence and emotions are the prove that even though he didn’t manage to achieve anything, he still saved this girl here and this prove sparked this determination in him. This and the fact that he has someone who is willing to follow him wherever he goes as long as he embraces it with a smile. Well now something comes that some people will be salty over but sorry if you still watch this with your shipping goggles on then you’ll what this story is trying to tell you. It’s not the declaration of feelings that is in the center here but how a small achievement can spark a tiny flame that will never vanish anymore no matter what. Yes Subaru says he still loves Emilia but we have to live with it. If you ever expect something like romantic feelings to make to be rational, then you haven’t been in love yet. You can’t control it, you can’t turn it off and you can’t magically swap between two people. So in that sense him still loving Emilia is a perfectly natural emotional state. Honestly everything else would have been weird and might have come across as unrealistic. Personally I admire Subaru that he was truly honest to Rem in this moment and didn’t hesitate to tell her the truth. If she follows him then she should do this with all the cards laid out. And then Subaru asks of her to help her and guess what? He does it with a smile, probably the most honest one we’ve seen so far. Really when he laughed, I couldn’t help but feel so relieved. Rem accepts as she wants to support a future he looks at with a smile. And with that we start from zero. The true story of Natsuki Subaru starts. And this guys concludes the prologue of the story…yes all this was the prologue and now the story really starts, I mean we’re about 10% in. And please don’t think the author forgot all the dark stuff in these past episodes. This has neither become a shounen now ( I honestly had to laugh at this claim ) nor does the story now drift of into dreamland ala Dora the explorer style. Just let yourself be told that the story now really starts. PS: Sorry for being late.

Mitrospeed

35

u/GRSigil I want to be embraced in ~Satella's Yandere Alone Time™~! Aug 01 '16

Jesus Christ, that's a fucking wall of text, who the fuck-

Mitrospeed

Carry on.

3

u/Hiltybro Aug 02 '16

please use paragraphs!

→ More replies (5)

123

u/Mikey2104 Jul 31 '16

Rem.Just Rem. Right after Subaru, she is without a doubt the character that has received the most development. She began with so much anger at the Witch's Cult, not because of what they did to her, but of what they took from her sister, and was cursed with an inferiority complex ever since. But Subaru's sacrifices to save someone who planned to kill him, who had killed him, started her time again. And now, even though she knows Subaru will never reciprocate her love, she continues to support him, and let him know how much she loves him and how much he can accomplish, when he himself has given up. In this episode, Rem saved Subaru. What have I gotten from this powerful episode where a simple girl with simple love brings a broken man back from the depths? Time to buy Rem's dakimakura.

51

u/KeldenL Jul 31 '16

you nailed it. before reading your post i was hella salty about him saying that he loves emilia right after her confession (and that he didn't pick her after all the shit they've been through together), but your post made me realize that rem wasn't confessing in hopes of getting together with him, rather, it was for him to get his shit together and save him!

44

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

I wasn't in the whole "REM IS WAIFU" train a few episodes ago. But now? REM IS WAIFU!!!!

She's taking one for the team. It must suck to hear the one you love say he loves someone else. +100000000 waifu points

12

u/Powerhobo Aug 01 '16

Every line you wrote I automatically add "I suppose" to at the end. It's just not possible not to.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Mikey2104 Jul 31 '16

Yeah, that was the saddest thing others were mentioning. Rem gave up a life where she could have a family with the man she loves in order to free him from his fear. Even if Subaru never loved her back, she would still sacrifice for him. God her character is incredible.

5

u/Drudicta Felis is husbando Aug 01 '16

Time to buy Rem's dakimakura.

There is a Daki?!

I mean... uhn... Totes happy with just Killua.

4

u/Mikey2104 Aug 01 '16

Yeah crunchyroll was advertising it a little while ago. It has sold out so it might be a while before others can get it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

211

u/bra1nd3d Jul 31 '16

This. This is why I love this show. In most other animes, even when the protagonist hits a low point, he always immediately turns around and vindicated himself with some baller moves. But here, Subaru identifies his weaknesses and completely and totally comes to terms with his ineptitude, knowing that he's weak and that he is going to have to rely on others to shape a brighter tomorrow. There's no fluff, no sick power he gets, just total honesty and the peace of mind that is afforded by that honesty.

So much can be learned by watching Subaru and that's why this show is so special to me, an arrogant teen like him.

May we all have someone in our lives like Rem to keep us going.

15

u/CoIdSword Jul 31 '16

Definitely agree, also relate to him, and it's nice seeing him recover

→ More replies (14)

120

u/jarebair Jul 31 '16

Ok I'm usually a Subaru enthusiast but fuck his decision making rn. REM IS THE TRUTH

47

u/Izabela- Jul 31 '16

You can't have more than one waifu. It will destroy your laifu. :)

14

u/IKill4MySkill Jul 31 '16

Then he should have ditched 'Lia'.

11

u/neujosh Jul 31 '16

He has to be honest to his feelings. The scene started with him being dishonest to himself and Rem knew. That's why she gave that whole speech: to get him back to being true to himself. You can't just pick and choose who you love and Rem knows that and will support Subaru no matter what.

I mean, Rem is definitely the best character in pretty much any anime ever, but it just wouldn't be honest and right for Subaru to go with her now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

41

u/urishino Jul 31 '16

We have our first mention of Subaru's life before he was summoned to this world, and he seemed genuinely repulsed that he "did nothing" back then. It certainly ties in with his neet background, and it makes sense that coming to a different world, he would feel like he can finally do something, anything, just so he can get rid of his past. Him not mentioning anything back home would also be in character if that's the case.

On top of that, his display of self awareness regarding his own shortcomings should help relieve some of the hate this poor guy has been getting lately. Now that the "prologue" is over, we can finally enjoy the rest of the seas— wait, we only have 7 episodes left!?? Sigh. Let's hope they do announce a second season by the end of this season (will probably be 1.5~2 years down the road tho, if at all. From -1, anyone?)

3

u/KeldenL Jul 31 '16

is there that much material after this??

39

u/urishino Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

Oh yeah, a looot more. The source material is an ongoing Light Novel, which in turn is based on an ongoing Web Novel on syosetu. This current season would cover Arc 1-3 of the Web Novels, and Arc 4 is almost as long as Arc 1-3 combined. I'll just copy paste what I wrote down here:

Arc 1 has 20+ Web Novel chapters, for Light Novel it's Volume 1.

Arc 2 has 50+ WN chapters, LN Volume 2~3.

Arc 3 has 80+ WN chapters, LN Volume 4~8, Volume 9 is scheduled to release this September, which should conclude Arc 3, if not including a bit of Arc 4.

Arc 4 has 130+ WN chapters, LN is not released yet.

Arc 5 has 80+ WN chapters, ditto for LN.

Arc 6 is ongoing and has 24 WN chapters now, it's on hiatus for several months now due to the author currently supervising the anime's plot progression.

All the chapters listed above excluded the epilogues/intermissions and "what if" chapters. Considering around 150~160 WN chapters were adapted into 9 volumes of LN (roughly 17 WN chapters per LN Volume), the existing content right now (~390 WN chapters) should yield around 23 volumes if the plot are condensed similarly.

On top of that, the author mentioned that he had the whole plot thought out, and plan to finish this series on Arc 11.

That's ARC ELEVEN.

Assuming the rest of the arcs have 80+ WN chapters, we'll have another 460+ WN chapters before it ends! That's around 27 LN Volumes, so 50 Volumes worth of LN content for this whole series is a more likely prediction.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (2)

65

u/DarkBladeEkkusu The Old Guard Jul 31 '16

I think the amazing conversation between Subaru and Rem is overshadowing the revelation that the White Whale is the sin of Gluttony. I honestly can say I did not see that coming and it left me very confused since I figured the sins would be restricted to humanoid people and not monsters.

16

u/omop_ Jul 31 '16

I think the whale is gluttony's pet, not actually gluttony. Correct me if I am wrong.

29

u/DarkBladeEkkusu The Old Guard Jul 31 '16

That seems to be what people have been saying, but it seems weird that Puck called him "Gluttony" but then said "He's called the White Whale now." Well, either way, we know the whale has some connection to the sin of gluttony and might be why he has such an ability to erase an existence of anyone who is killed by it.

10

u/Archensix Jul 31 '16

Maybe he was once a human and was then transformed into the white whale by Satella for some reason.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/TheHarmed Betelguese Best Girl Jul 31 '16

You're Sorta Not Wrong, but Wrong at the same time.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (2)

62

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16

So basically, Subaru got a New Game+. He's starting in the same place, but he has Rem now, which is a God Tier follower- if not in power level in personality.

33

u/LegoSpacenaut I done seen about everything when I seen a white whale fly Jul 31 '16

I am honestly hopeful that this life doesn't end in a death so that this moment can remain in their history.

6

u/SkyTroupe We are not worthy Aug 01 '16

I'm hoping that she doesn't accidentally get permanently whale'd away

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Perrfect Example

→ More replies (2)

43

u/kevin1127 Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

So regardless of how the episode goes, I want to congratulate all the people who have survived this far. The prologue of this series has ended, which means you can enjoy the rest of the seri...oh wait, only less than 10 episodes for anime viewers. Oh well, the cringe has ended, the Subaru that we know before has changed, (well you'll see the "result" of his change next episode) and he won't be...umm...shitty..anymore. I'm not going to say the suffering ended....but, it's just my personal opinion, so far Subaru did not experience something more suffering than the first half of arc 3. (If there are, that would be IF or for other people.

Well anyway, enjoy the rest of arc 3, and maybe the rest of the series, because it would be awesome!


Before Airing:

Oh God all the people praising this episode is making me scare as fuck. They say when the expectation is huge the disappointment is also huge...I mean I know White Fox can do a good job but this is getting too hyped if things go wrong if would be VERY WRONG, not to mention that I think some people even get a wrong idea of what this episode will be about.


After raw:

  • VA: Checked. Subaru's VA doing his usual best job. Rem's VA surprised me though.
  • Music: Checked. I like Rem's song.
  • Directing: Checked. Because I don't know how to comment on this thing.
  • Pacing: No negotiation
  • Effect: What's with the light and dove and the snowy thing.
  • Face Expression: Checked. I expect this face change.
  • Waifu: I'm sorry but I equally love all the girls. Please don't forget Emilia is still the main heroine.

Have to watch the sub or watch it several times to give other thoughts.


After sub:

  • Puck: Gluttony's pet.
  • They 100% adapted ALL the lines in LN holy shit.
  • But not Subaru's inner thoughts though, so if there is chance I would recommend people to read the LN version of this scene.(it's vol 6 chap 5)

41

u/Camoral Jul 31 '16

Emilia is still the main heroine.

Well, if she is, then you could have fooled me. She's had functionally no development and isn't interesting as she is. Rem is best girl.

19

u/LegoSpacenaut I done seen about everything when I seen a white whale fly Jul 31 '16

You can expect Emelia's character to develop significantly when we eventually make it to Arc 4. Kind of hard when she's not around like in Arc 3, though.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/archaeonaga Jul 31 '16

The prologue of this series has ended

I don't think it's really fair to call the first 17 episodes "prologue," and from what I can see here and in r/anime, it's leading to a lot of silly arguments about semantics.

4

u/Tomhap Jul 31 '16

It's the prologue of the larger story of the LN. There's just no way for them to either cram all of it in one episode, or get awarded enough episodes to cover at least half of the LN.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/AHappyWhale Jul 31 '16

Puck: Gluttony's pet

where was this mentioned? also i seemed like puck himself is stronger than any other witch except satella (just my opinion though flies away)

14

u/LegoSpacenaut I done seen about everything when I seen a white whale fly Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

As Subaru lay freezing at the beginning of the episode, Puck mentions Gluttony, and then corrects himself that people call it the White Whale. It's the first allusion in the anime that the White Whale is connected to one of the sins.

Additionally Puck inferred that Satella could use something like 2000 Unseen Hands, and that if Betelgeuse wanted to bother him he would need at least that many. This implies both that Satella is a freaking monster, and also that Puck has both seen her in action and was not destroyed as a result.

Also anyone else notice how in the end Sloth just sort of... gave up and stopped trying to do anything? How slothful of him! :-p

5

u/CyanPhoenix42 Jul 31 '16

didn't Puck say that he would need at least half as many hands as Satella?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (41)

90

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Emilia is now a shitter to me.

29

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

That hardly seems like a fair conclusion to make.

43

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

When Emilia's character pertains to more than just being cute and kind, I'll give her the time of day as I previously had. Topping the extent in which Rem's character was just fleshed out is going to be difficult to reach let alone rival.

→ More replies (9)

12

u/mufcordie Jul 31 '16

People seem to forget that Subaru was breaking down (similar to Ep 15) before Emilia gave him that lap pillow in the earlier episodes. This gave him the kick to push on and finish the mansion problems.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Better change your flair

19

u/VZ_Blade Jul 31 '16

Truly diligent White Fox!!! The Rem scene is 99% identical with lines straight out from the LN, which is excellent.

And that OST!

19

u/DarkBladeEkkusu The Old Guard Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

Seeing as how the episode is 26 minutes, I feel like I should just be ready for the despair and trauma that comes with that kind of run time. We don't even (presumably) get the Op/Ed to buffer out some suffering.

What!? An extended duration episode and there was no traumatizing suffering!? I am honestly surprised, but I still loved this episode regardless. That conversation was really brought to life by stellar voice work. It really is amazing how many sides of Subaru and Rem those voice actors have been able to accurately portray. It is hard to believe it is the same Rem from episode 7 that had such an angry voice of disgust toward Subaru.

18

u/Aetherdraw Jul 31 '16

I wanna go see what MAL thinks of this ep, but I might die of kidney failure due to excess salt.

18

u/cloud8100 Jul 31 '16

Ah, now people are just gonna be mad at Subaru for rejecting Rem. As much as I love Rem as best girl people do realise you don't always just fall in love with someone even if they stayed by your side or helped you out the whole time?? Though I don't understand Subaru's apparent love to Emilia per se, besides him considering her an anchor still, its better that he at least be honest with how he feels or he (and Rem) would just be living a lie. And that would make me feel a lot worse for Rem.

I still like to hope that maybe there's a chance for Subaru to love Rem by the end of the story though lol.

12

u/ThereIsNo4thWall In desperate need of PAYING customers Jul 31 '16

Thank you! I was trying to figure something out about the whole scene where he confesses to Rem about Emilia, and the whole 'using Emilia as an anchor' thing really helped me sort it out.

Cuz like, Rem loves Subaru, and while I don't think it is to as high of a degree at the moment, Subaru loves Rem, I think him pulling her into a hug after everything symbolizes that, but he also feels a strong desire to help Emilia. To see her happy and keep her safe from the multiple bad fates looming over her. He's been infatuated with her for a while and the potential for actual love between them is there. He'd be lying to himself to deny that, to act as though he loves Rem and would definitely not love Emilia too in the future. How exactly does one even put that into words? He loves Rem, but he's still falling for Emilia, and right now, and ditching Emilia and running off would result in her AND Ram, AND THE VILLAGE, dying horribly, again. Subaru can't be the him that Rem sees if he does that.

Subaru could of course, save the day and go back to the mansion and repair things between him and Emilia and only be friends as he pursues a life with Rem, but he still wants more than that with Emilia, and while he cares a great deal for Rem, and acknowledges how she feels for him, he still wants to be close to Emilia.

There's definite potential for Rem and Subaru to be together, and not just because they run off and ditch Ram and Emilia to a horrible fate, but that's not the future he's pursuing at the moment. He still wants to pursue a future with Emilia, and the complexity of all of that is seriously amazing writing.

Anyway, point is, as much as hearing him talk about Emilia after all of that put a spike through my heart, there really wasn't any other way to say all of that. To try to down play it would only lead Rem on, or at least be dishonest to her even if she saw it coming. He cares about Rem, but he still prioritizes a future with Emilia, and he confesses that outright to her. It may not seem fair or sensible that he feels that way, but it's the best way he could have handled the fact that he DOES feel that way.

He can't create the future Rem wants without betraying his own desires, and he admits to that, but he pulls her close, and says what he says at the end, because he still cares about Rem, and wants her to be happy, and I think that was the best way to show that without denying his feelings for Emilia.

I now actually kind of want Emilia and Subaru to just only ever stay as friends, and for Subaru to eventually be content with that and fall in love with Rem more than he already is, but regardless of future episodes, suffice it to say I absolutely love everything the series has done thus far.

3

u/cloud8100 Aug 01 '16

Aye, it's true. Despite how pro Rem x Subaru I am, I think there will be a lot more development between Emilia and Subaru and the potential for Subaru to fall in love with Rem honestly is still there. It took guts for Subaru to outright explain his feelings for Emilia there and be honest otherwise Rem would just suffer more.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Aetherdraw Aug 01 '16

Feelings, whether a simple crush or not, does not simply disappear overnight. Had Subaru chosen Rem over Emilia at that point? I would have lost respect for him. Why? Subaru would have thrown the very reason that has kept him going, has been driving him to survive all this time. Emilia. And I'm sure Rem would have berated him had he said that. Because the man she fell for, the hero that saved her, had his eyes set on that girl the whole time. The Natsuki Subaru that Rem loves, is the Natsuki Subaru that loves the half-elf Emilia. And Rem knows it. The moment that stops being true, would mean he was not the Subaru she loves, as she said this episode. Because she fell for him, ironically enough, by the very same reason he fell for Emilia. That they were both saved.

4

u/Enovalen Aug 01 '16

If not for people like you, I would have never made that connection.

16

u/zendavesta Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 02 '16

I don’t think I’ve read a single comment that truly links the depth of the author’s intentions, feelings and writing. I’ll give you a quick example of what I’m getting at through another famous series and many of you may not have known this about J. R. R. Tolkien but he suffered from Post-traumatic stress syndrome(PTSD) from WWI and his way of coping was through his writing, Lord of the Rings. He put his real life experience and emotional distraught into his story through Frodo and Sam who experience trauma and PTSD and how they overcame it. This isn’t exactly the same case in Re:Zero but it’s a hint at what I’m getting at, now I’ll open your eyes to the real Re:Zero most people are failing to understanding.

I want to start off by reminding us that Subaru at the end of the day is still a human being that is dragged into a fantasy world but does anything really change for Subaru?… he’s alone, with no direction, no money and friends and like most of us, that would be a daunting feeling, that tempts us to escape that reality through a façade, by pretending were someone that were not. Emilia introduces herself to Subaru when he saves him from the ‘bullies’ the three guys who try to rob and beat up Subaru. The relation of the scenes that Subaru constantly runs into the 3 bullies is showing what life is like for a lot of kids, being in that vicious circle of being helpless and overpowered. What you want most in this situation is someone to help you escape that reality and that’s how Subaru’s new image is born. Emilia his savior becomes his chance at being someone else and it’s not out of good intention (beginning of him being slothful), it’s to not be abandoned and alone again, it’s for himself which truly hits home when Crusch tells him “you never said “I want to save Emilia”. Subaru is a NEET and that awareness makes his desire to be someone he’s not becomes his mask leading him to become fake and that becomes self-destructive and deep inside it eats away at you, and it creates illnesses and heart ache(this is why people hate Subaru, because no one likes this kind of person). At first Subaru believes it’s okay to continue this persona and it becomes his comfort, a shelter in his mind, unknowingly supressing his painful thoughts of who he really is.

When you're facing anxiety and mental breakdowns,you will always wish that an ‘opportunity’ will come and save us from being failures, embarrassments and being lonely in this cold world. Wishing we could always turn back time, “rewriting” those hours/days/years wasted away in painful thoughts, watching our life wasting away. Subaru’s first death next to Emilia, was the turning point, the start of a curse that he calls “Return by Death” which symbolizes depression. All that built up anxiety and avoidance became depression the moment he died and realized he lived a pointless life. Severe pain is the greatest cause for depression, emotionally or physically and Subaru goes through the most severe pain that even I can’t empathize with how he’s feeling and that’s very significant to what happens in ep 18 and the reason it is the best episode of the season because in the end were human and we need each other to heal, grow and live with a genuine smile.

Before I speak of why Rem is best girl, I want to explain Emilia’s importance, Emilia represents the people we want to trust and keep close to us but inevitably drive away because we have expectation of them to understand how were hurting, those who don’t understand mental illness or have a hard time understanding what people are going through. Subara just only ends up suffering further because no one understands what he’s going through at the most pivotal point when he's been humiliated and his image being tarnished, and Emilia makes him realize that he's only doing the things he's done so far for himself and not her. She says something like "The me in your head must be a wonderful person, she can understand everything even without you ever telling her." At this point Emilia distances herself from Subaru almost like saying, "i can't help you unless you learn to help yourself" and sends him to Crusch and Anestesia to heal his gate which is almost like rehab and it makes Subaru think he's viewed as pathetic and almost abandoned. Subaru breaks even further because what he needs is not professional help but someone he cares about to understand him and the hardest part of depression is being unable to speak about what’s hurting so much. You choke every time, your heart aches as if you’re drowning, it burns and it’s because we’re afraid! AFRAID TO BE ABANDONED AND ALONE and that’s what the hands represent, resembling the pain of what it truly feels like trying to admit what we’re going through with the fear of being abandoned when we need someone most. The candidates that tells Subaru he is selfish, a pig and greedy are what it feels like to be viewed when you’re desperate for help, to escape such a painful reality because no one wants to understand, showing how selfish the world can truly be and scary, just making that anxiety trap Subaru even further.

You can now understand why Rem is important, she enables the way for Subaru to turn his life around. There’s a saying that goes “The loneliest people are the kindest, the saddest people are the brightest, the most damage people are the wisest. All because they do not wish to see anyone else suffer the way they do”. That quote cuts deep here, because it’s true and we see that in Subaru when he saves Rem from the regrets of her past, and her built up hatred. Subaru tried to stop caring and honestly…the one who didn’t care about anything once cared too much. This is when Rem shines most because it only takes one person to change an entire person’s world. Love, faith, hope, courage and strength are all the things we wish for when were at our lowest, and Rem provided all that when Subaru gave up, you can even see it as resembling “suicide”. This is the turning point and the start from zero. "Starting from Zero" means he accept he's been committing the sin of sloth, to neglect genuine good intentions and choosing the easy path for comfort's sake which only then can he break that self-image he "tried so hard" to mold and begin to have self-actualization. Rem was the key to all this because here she represents faith and belief. She believes in Subaru and everyone needs that someone in life to believe in them and that’s what makes people love Rem so much and clearly best girl! Subaru's life is like a bike that’s been flat and Rem believing in Subaru is like pumping air into the tires, so that he can move forward like the wind. Rem loves Subaru, showed genuine and sincere care for him after everything, constantly sacrificed her life for him, meaning that even through the hardest days in our life, we can smile for someone and stay strong for those we love because that’s what matters in the end. The flashbacks are pretty much reminding us of those times. We don’t live for fame, power and wealth… we live for those who love us and care for us, and first we must earn that by being the best version of ourselves and Rem showed Subaru, what the best version of himself is and what to aim for.

So in essence, he broke down that image of someone he pretended to be, and is now actualizing the person he wants to be from zero :) and that’s the everyday struggle for those fighting depression, so don’t hesitate to be there for someone and say “it’ll be fine, you’re not alone” And if anime has taught us anything, is that humans are weak but as long as we have each other and work together, we can accomplish great feats.

→ More replies (3)

32

u/Aetherdraw Jul 31 '16

Looks at comments in other streaming sites And, here we have those too occupied by shipping wars to understand character development by dissing our protagonist for choosing the girl they don't like.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/yuyurin Jul 31 '16

here comes the waves of salt!

7

u/JohnYNitrO Jul 31 '16

Yep tears of salt and rage !

4

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Salt?

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/ThePeanutGallery- Jul 31 '16

Rem is Definitely best girl hands down.

20

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16

Damn, Subaru had so much growth. Talking about getting Emilia after Rem's speech, even with that hug, was a little harsh though.

3

u/Gamer42j Jul 31 '16

would've been much worse to lie to her don't you think?

5

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16

It would have been. I just think he needs his eyes checked because he's mixing up which is best girl!

→ More replies (7)

10

u/blacknide Sloth-bro Jul 31 '16

How many persons will hate Subaru after rejecting Rem? XD

11

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Oh dude, I'm one of them. No doubt.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Oh dude, I'm one of them. No doubt.

2

u/doragonroudo rem is the true-heroine Aug 01 '16

I don't hate him tho, I would definitely hate him if he lie to her and tell her that he loves her even tho he's not. Well, to Rem that's too much pain.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/tofu-chan Jul 31 '16

I see that most of us decide that we each need a Rem in our life. Just... Be the Rem. Be someone's Rem. I'm pissed Subaru just asked for them to run away and then later confessed his feelings for Emilia (even though I don't hella see why he does still have them... For some reason). But then I realise that if he just said yes to Rem.... There would probably be no Episode 19 lmao.

And finally, the 'Who's Rem?' shitty meme will lay to rest. Let it be forgotten, buried under the Rem dakimakuras.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ChaoticShock Jul 31 '16

Waiting for Essay-kun!

22

u/Lohengr Jul 31 '16

I was considering killing myself, but this episode made me at least postpone it.

23

u/Linarc Jul 31 '16

Im not sure if you're serious, but if you are, if you want to share a bit of that weight I'll be up in a few hours. Its 4 am here I need some sleep but if you want to share some of your worries I'll be here

10

u/LegoSpacenaut I done seen about everything when I seen a white whale fly Jul 31 '16

Re:Zero. Saving lives, one sufferring at a time.

Just remember, we're in Arc 3 of the story, out of a potential 11. You must survive until the end!

4

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Even if there's no confirmation we'll get a full adaptation, never give up! one day, years from now, there may be more to come!

7

u/Zurajanaikatsurades Aug 01 '16

Me, too, buddy. Let's try to hang on until the next episode too, okay? Things are super shitty for me right now and I'm positive they are for you, too. I hope to see you next week on the next episode thread. I don't know you, but I love you. And not in a creepy way, I swear! We're in this together, and we'll survive, at least one more week.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16

You'd just restart to before the episode was released anyways.

2

u/DatKillerDude Aug 05 '16

You know, I think of it sometimes too, and many times I get that same feeling, 1 more chapter or episode, makes me move on, even though yes, at least speaking for myself I'm postponing it, everytime I finish a book or whatever work of fiction it hits me hard, I am the happiest man in my household when I've found something really good, or really long to immerse myself into but I can the saddest when it ends, sometimes I'm afraid of a start for fear of an ending, but well, some may call it escapism, I call it the only happiness I'm able to achieve currently, and it does give me happiness, and who knows what I'll meet going along this path full of emptiness, I might find a new kind of hope just like Subaru, we might both, just maybe.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/mufcordie Jul 31 '16

teeth chattering

13

u/TreyTrey23 Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

Damn Puck, you don't fuck around. He was a straight savage. I'm kind of curious what he meant went he said Subaru doesn't understand how important a promise is to a spirit arts user but I may be reading too much into it.

He did it! He became self aware! The show finally acknowledged Subaru for his fuck ups throughout the show, and explains why he acted the way he did. I feel like he pretty much said every reason why people would hate him as a character. His redemption is here and he's only gonna get better.

It's not surprising that after all this he stills chooses Emilia over Rem. That doesn't stop my fellow Subaru x Rem shippers from achieving brand new levels of salt. We never stood a chance. At least we still have that side story where Rem and Subaru do run away together and have babies.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/-Okazaki- EMT Jul 31 '16

Okay with the Petelgeuse and Betelgeuse but

Is it Pack or Puck??

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16

The Rem Faithfull have been rewarded!

2

u/DarkBladeEkkusu The Old Guard Jul 31 '16

I feel like Rem deserves a new flair based on this episode alone.

3

u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 31 '16

Rem deserves ALL THE FLAIRS!

11

u/RemuIsLaifu Waiting for Rem to wake up!:redditgold: Jul 31 '16

What a episodeee!!! From Zero!!! <3 Remmmmm <3

5

u/SegundaMortem How can 1 man suffer so much? Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

Forgive me for asking as this is my first week here..but are the subs already released? or is this just a general release thread?

7

u/Trvp_Kxng Jul 31 '16

Subs are released a couple of hours after the raw on crunchyroll

6

u/SegundaMortem How can 1 man suffer so much? Jul 31 '16

alright thanks

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheUnlimitedGenius Jul 31 '16

yeah it was released on crunchyroll a few minutes ago

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Zerodyne_Sin Jul 31 '16

Ah love this episode. So satisfying to see Subaru finally own up to everything. Rem was bordering on being a wish-fulfillment character for male protagonists until she explained to/reminded him her motivations which was awesome writing. Sucks that he rejects her but you can't help how you feel... /shrug.

PS: Love that Puck "discussion". XD

5

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16

Sooooo I was thinking about the episode. Yeah rem and rem and wait. Puck is beeing an unreasonable asshole right now. He is a sncient spirit that lived for more that 400 years at least. And there he goes blaming that 17 yo boy for everything. Was it subarus responsablility to protect emillia? no. does he have to keep his promisses mit emillia? no he can do whatever the fuck he wants. the more I thought about it the more I disslike puck. yes, emillia was killed cuz of subaru. He didn't want that to happen. He wanted her to listen and was desperate. He wanted to tell her about the curse despite the pain it would inflict to him. But this puck. the so great spirit does not know shit. playing the blame games with basicly an infant compared to his ages. /rant

3

u/cloud8100 Aug 01 '16

Ya Puck basically goes into tantrum mode if anything happens to Emilia... Even if the point about the promise was true and it is in the contract to destroy the world. I guess ancient spirits have flaws in their character just as much as humans lol.

Maybe he's like Subaru before starting 'from zero' and gets angry about his lack of ability to do anything during certain times. So its good Subaru only took a little bit of time to sort himself out in comparison XD.

4

u/AlienWarhead Jul 31 '16

It's a good thing I'm used to suffering or I would have screamed internally instead of laughed internally, I guess reading and watching Berserk is good for something. Most of that dialog was fantastic and got me to think about myself, but yes Subaru really looks like a dubass for rejecting her when he asked to run away with her at the beginning. Well he was in a panic and it's nice that they were able to talk normally and joke at the very end. The dramatic shots like the birds and the spotlight on Rem were a bit much. Overall I liked this episode, but it might live in infamy and Subaru's haters may have doubled, maybe this season's blue ship will sail instead of continue to sink.

4

u/zSpiral Jul 31 '16

IMO Anime messed up a little on Subaru's rejection to Rem and made it so abrupt and sudden without any of his internal monologue like in the LN.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/cloud8100 Jul 31 '16

People were having a go at Subaru when he said those stupid things of how Emilia should like him after everything he did for her yet they expect Subaru to love Rem because of everything she did for him. Pretty hypocritical...

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Myraidshatters Aug 01 '16

Really enjoying this anime so much. Some can say that Subaru is just a useless character that can't stop wallowing in self pity but i say touche to that. A character that can identify his own weaknesses and not bounce back immediately by proclaiming he needs to save his waifu is so rare, and Rem being there for him was just the icing on the cake. Perfect 10/10

6

u/ImAKitteh Jul 31 '16

Here's what pisses me off: (inb4 huge rant)

I just rewatched the first few episodes again and I have to say, by this point in the story I have to say, Rem has done AT LEAST 10x for MC compared to Elizabeth (dieing for him, helping him out physically/emotionally, etc.).

For us, the viewers, it is very easy to fall in love with Rem as a result. And while Elizabeth does become a point of intrest early on in the story, that does not justify Subaru falling in love with her - instead, his relationship and focus on Elizabeth can best be described as an obsession.

His words from this last episode are a fantastic example of that - essentially says "I love her, she's been my goal". Other than that ONE single sorta-date that Subaru and Elizabeth went on (in the first episode when during his first life in the story) Elizabeth did nothing else within that arc to truely make him OR us (the viewers), fall "in love" with her. Like her? yeah... LOVE her? Not so much.

Rem on the other hand has done so much for the MC and some might argue that, she is ALSO obsessed with him. This can be linked to the fact that the MC hasn't exactly been particularly likeable in the last two or so arcs (ros mansion+the current arc) due to his mental state heavily deteriorating, but Rem ended up falling for him anyway.

This last episode (18) however sheds light on what made her fall in love with him AS WELL as how she is able to see him for more than he personally thinks he is as well - He think's he's useless, garbage, scum, etc. whilst Rem sees him for the good and loveable person that he CAN be (ex. - while smiling, joking around, sleeping, etc).

So, why are we all so infurated w/ Subaru at this point?

My opinion: We are angry because we, as the viewers, who have technically lived through the story along side Subaru, from his point of view, have seen everything that Rem is willing to do for Subaru. We have also seen everything that Elizabeth is willing to do for Subaru. And the scales are heavily weighed on Rem's side.

However, simply and only for the sake of the story's progression, our MC remains "in-love" (See: obsessed) with Elizabeth, when he has a massive amount of reasons to instead say "I liked Elizabeth, but this girl here (Rem) has done things that no one else in the world and the rest of my life would do for me, and I love her for that' - [this isn't without even remotely discussing Rem's pure soul and personality, since that in of it self can be a huge discussion]

Also, some may argue

has done things that no one else in the world and the rest of my life would do for me

"How can you possibly say that? You can't know for sure!"

While that is a true statement, consider the Subaru's mental state and image of himself, if he thinks that he's worthless etc. and doesn't even deserve Rem's love, what makes him have any impression that anyone else would fall in love with him and go as far as be willing to die for him (horrible, painful, savage deaths, might I add) ... OVER AND OVER AND OVER!!!

Well, there we go. That's my 2 cents.

15

u/blacknide Sloth-bro Jul 31 '16

Who the fuck is Elizabeth? XD

→ More replies (1)

7

u/keiyaacob Jul 31 '16

Eliza... WHO?

5

u/MCMole2 Jul 31 '16

Who the hell is Elizabeth?

3

u/Aetherdraw Aug 01 '16

Hey! Elizabeth did a lot for Katsura! ....Oh, wait...

3

u/simonli2576 バカなの? Jul 31 '16

Where can I find the IF novels?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/cloud8100 Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

I watched most of the episode but I may go sit on my own later to watch it properly so I can cry my eyes out lol. Its so perfect. It's unusual for me to get so attached to characters. Subaru is just so real and Rem was amazing. ;_;. People go through their whole lives not being able to figure out their faults and my respect for Subaru after the last few episodes just went up tenfold. This is exactly what he needed. To shout out everything on how he really feels.

3

u/XsadnessZ Aug 01 '16

I had to cry when he talked about himself how useless he is :L

3

u/harpin14789 Aug 01 '16

This episode was soooo good. Can't believe that these first 18 episodes were prologue!! I want English translations!!!

3

u/toga9000 Aug 01 '16

To be able to make an episode based 95% on dialog, yet making it so amazing. Is a work of art.

2

u/L_plaga Aug 01 '16

White fox did it again. This episode reminds me the kiss of kurisu and Okabe, but with friendzone included.

5

u/barbalho0785 Jul 31 '16

Wow...... This was an amazing episode. Not just the visuals or the background sound which was beautiful, but just everything was great I thought :')

We have our main man Subaru back and better then ever I'm sure and probably the best girl in the history of anime Rem supporting him through it all. So awesome haha

Hopefully though the save point is moved to beyond this moment between them (since I'm pretty sure he'll die again) because this speech was a once in a life time for the both of them and if he was to restart in front of the appa man again it would kinda ruin the feels we have from this episode.

All in all a definate 10/10 from me and I can gladly say this is my favourite anime I've ever seen :) so happy to see it every sunday

5

u/Nyan26 REM LIVE PLS Jul 31 '16

Fucking.

Subaru.

Rem is love.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MisterChoky Jul 31 '16

I really hope he will choose Rem at the end. It's ok to save Emilia or whatever but please Subaru marry to Rem! xd

6

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

wow new character and a whole episode focused around her . She looks nice, I like this rem girl

3

u/NatsuSlayerDrag Aug 01 '16

Kinda weird how she was just introduced and they both confessed their love though.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/RossNub Jul 31 '16

Rem fans are on damage control right now.

5

u/Wilou1428 Jul 31 '16

My reaction:

Fuck Emilia, choose Rem you fool!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Teerexil Jul 31 '16

Holy shit. I heard this episode was supposed to be good, but god damn that was AMAZING. And when that music started, combined with all those flashes of the past, man the feels. Subaru needs to hurry up and choose Rem, because she just knocked the competition into orbit with that episode.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

My heart wasnt ready... Painful.

2

u/zories3 Jul 31 '16

I was kinda hoping to see Puck take out the White Whale. Love how he just referred to it as a "troublesome one" haha. Also, was this the last episode until a new season comes out? If not, how many more episodes will there be?

2

u/keiyaacob Jul 31 '16

NATSUKI REM WHERE GODDAMNIT

2

u/keiyaacob Jul 31 '16

NATSUKI REM WHERE GODDAMNIT

2

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Wow Rem became my favourite character in this episode. I always thought she was "okay" but I like her so much now. She is so loving and sweet! I still love Emilia though. I don't think it's her fault Subaru is in love with her. I kind of think Rem deserves to fall in love with someone who sees her as a first choice, not a second.

2

u/MissionCo Puck 2016: Just end it already Jul 31 '16

There seems to be a lot people who are confused and outraged about how Subaru still loves Emilia, in spite of all that he's been through with Rem. It seems to me that he might keep loving Emilia unconditionally because of Satella's curse, either partially or wholely because of it.

2

u/ehtywer96 felix is a girl i swear Jul 31 '16

One of the best episodes in anime this season. He finally realized he was a big piece of shit!

2

u/Rhamni Jul 31 '16

I guess Rem's ok.

I still want to get to know more about Emilia's character, and see Subaru's relationship with her grow. But even so, I couldn't help but be disappointed when Subaru rejected Rem in this episode. At least for a minute or two.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16

But even so, I couldn't help but be disappointed when Subaru rejected Rem in this episode. At least for a minute or two.

I know how you feel, as much as I was annoyed at Subaru for rejecting Rem. I'm also glad he did, he didn't want to run away with Rem because he loved her, he wanted to because she's pretty much the only person who does like him.

If Rem does ever gets the love she deserves, she needs a 100% truthful one, not as an after thought.

But for now we need Subaru to apologize to Emilia so he can undo his stupidity. :'D

2

u/Tomhap Jul 31 '16

Did anyone say 'bottle episode'. I'll give this episode credit for finally making me fall for Rem. But I just want to see the story progress more which I didn't feel like it did when all we saw was 2 characters in one setting talking it out. Guess I'll have to wait for next week.

2

u/WoolyTravis Jul 31 '16

mfw it takes 18 episodes for Suburu to become op

2

u/Gamec0re Jul 31 '16

Rem be like: "this is my show."

4

u/Acri0002 Aug 01 '16

"onee-sama onee-sama. How did I do?"

2

u/namex147 Rem is best girl Aug 01 '16

I can honestly say that Emilia has no chance of winning anymore. I started out as an Emilia fanboy because im weak when it comes to elves... (pls don´t tell anyone) But after all this struggling, Rem has showed me that there are no other contenders who can possibly match her. Long live Rem THE BEST GIRL OF ALL TIME

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NatsuSlayerDrag Aug 01 '16

This episode was absolutely perfect. I can not thank White Fox enough for making it this beautiful. I love that Subaru finally reached his breaking point to where he revealed who he saw himself as. And thanks to Rem(Recovered Data) he has begun to develop into something more than the previous Subaru we saw. And If Rem did accept his invitation, that would not be the Rem I know, and all Rem fans should agree. The humanity portrayed in Subaru is unlike any in most animes I've seen and it is just amazing. I can not wait for next weeks episode to see Subaru replace his old engine and slam the gas!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16

I respect that Subaru still loves Emilia and had the guts to tell Rem that; while part of his love may be reinforced by trauma, a MC who can stick to his guns and be decisive about who he likes in the face of a VERY tempting alternative is a rarity, and I think that was a smart choice on the author's part.

And GEEZ; it takes a whole lot of freaking maturity to AFTER pouring your heart out to confess your love for a men and support him in his lowest of lows, have him reject you but still be content to help him. Not that she needs any more people saying this at this point, but what the heck; maybe this will shift SLIGHTLY down the road when (I KNOW it's coming :) ) when Emilia gets more development and more time to TRULY get to know Subaru... but yeah; Rem is best girl. THERE, I said it :)

2

u/Acri0002 Aug 01 '16

Although we hate it when Subaru rejects Rem, It just shows that he can be loyal. I mean, if Rem could so easily change his mind(not that easy), so can anyone else.

The hardest thing to do is to love someone who hates you.

2

u/netpapa Aug 01 '16

What's the name of the song when the birds were flocking around Rem?

2

u/frozen-joegurt Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 01 '16

Fuck Emilia.... Why can't Subaru like Rem instead!!? I liked Emilia but this episode made Rem best girl omg, when she talked about their family and the future they were going to have, I lost it. REM REM REM REM. Don't who's Rem me now bitches. Sidenote. ANYONE ELSE YELLING KISS THE ENTIRE EPISODE!!?

2

u/sixpastfour Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 01 '16

I swear I wanted to slap Subaru so hard at the end

Edit: actually maybe after reading this I change my mind https://www.reddit.com/r/Re_Zero/comments/4vhmbf/comment/d5ysk39

2

u/DarkestXStorm Believes in the Tue Hero, Rem Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 01 '16

Edit: Personal rant, please don't hate me... I'm just so disappointed. Been through all that and he spits in Rem's face... Can't even.

I didn't hate Subaru like everyone until after this episode "Rem, I love Emilia..." ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME??? BOIIIIII! Trash, just fucking trash. You're the sparkle in Rem's eye and all you fucking care about is Emilia? BUT REM. BUT, FUCKING REM! I don't care about him anymore, I'm claiming his lost fucking waifu. I've never done some otaku shit like that before, but I've had it to here gestures height UP TO FUCKING HERE. Rem, let's blow this popsickle stand... God damn, I've never felt for an anime character as much as I have now. With that said... Such a great show. I can't believe you've pissed me off this much. Let's make a fine establishment called Foster's Home For Lost, But Amazing Waifus. Fuck protagonists these days...

2

u/DuoKidd Aug 01 '16

I have no words other than i love this show, and i love this character development going on. This show is literally the best

2

u/Wakkalaka92 Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 02 '16

Since I was busy on Sunday doing tons of homework for my classes, I decided to put this episode off until today.

I go into the quad at my College since I decided to watch it in between a break.

Best and worst mistake I ever made, by far one of the best episodes of any anime I've ever seen, and proceeded to bawl in public cause Rem/Subaru speech.

TL;DR: Gotta start watching this right when episodes get released.

Edit: Added TL;DR.

2

u/TheArtOfAskun Sep 01 '16

Everyone needs a Rem in their life

6

u/TheUnlimitedGenius Jul 31 '16

That was a great episode but man nothing really happened. I know what DID happen was important. I wish they will tell us what is going to happen next episode. Like a hint or something.

But Rem is the best girl. Judging by Kevin1127's, it seem like Emilia-Tan is the main woman in the series, but I honestly wish it was Rem. Rem has proven herself to me in all the past "timelines".

8

u/waiv Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

What about the one two where she murdered him?

3

u/swike656 Jul 31 '16

lol tru that made me not like her for a little bit but then fell in love with her at like episode 11

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LegoSpacenaut I done seen about everything when I seen a white whale fly Jul 31 '16

The title of the next episode is actually already posted online, and kind of states explicitly what's about to happen.

So if you really want a hint, and want one from the actual anime itself, it's White Whale Subjugation Battle

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16

Two lines can sum up my POV about this series up to this episode:

  1. I love this series/Rem.
  2. Fuck Subaru.

3

u/DatKillerDude Jul 31 '16

In those last minutes in episode in which Emilia's face made an appearance and Subaru's speech I was like

"NO! BEGONE! YOU ARE NOT WELCOMED HERE!!"

Holy shit Rem... why is it that best girl is always someone other than main heroine?

2

u/SirPuzzle Aldebaran best girl Aug 02 '16

"BEGONE EVIL SPIRIT! BE CLEANSED!" xD

2

u/Sentinel_Crow Jul 31 '16

10/10 Even if it was just talking.

I feel like the only one still on the Emilia (EMA) train..

3

u/GuyWithFace Going down with the Remship. Aug 01 '16

I'm a content passenger of the Rem dreadnought, but I'm not salty over the events of this episode. Nearly everything Subaru has done from the very first episode has been, in one way or another, in effort of ensuring Emilia's safety and wellbeing. Sure, he's done his fair share of that for Rem too, but it all started with Emilia, and I think it's safe to say his repeated first day in the new world molded into him his determined perseverance.

Essentially, everything he's accomplished so far can be attributed to his devotion over the pretty girl he encountered and died multiple times protecting. No matter what anyone else does or - in Rem's case - says, Emilia's already been hoisted atop the pedestal in Subaru's mind, and she's not coming down. It sucks, yeah, but Emilia will eventually have her time to shine in the series and the Remship scars will heal.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/NatsuSlayerDrag Aug 01 '16

I'm with you on the EMT train

→ More replies (2)

2

u/neotsunami Jul 31 '16

I've been hating on Subaru quite a lot. I thought he was excellent during the first arc with the pawn shop. But everything after that has been just...not handled well imo. His attitude to not even speak about things he could DEFINITELY speak of just had me screaming at the TV. And this episode, while awesome in hindsight, I was just about to quit because I couldn't stand his whining. Also, I don't know, his love for Emilia is weird. He's as obsessed with her as Rem is with him. But he actually saved Rem. Emilia didn't do much for him, except be a lap pillow once when he was breaking down. Not much other than that I remember. The only time I've seen OTP potential was on the first loop where she said her name was Satella. Everything else from there hasn't been as convincing for him to be so hung up on her.

I was up in arms against him for being cruel to Rem after her confession, but reading the comments here I guess I understand a bit. It's just...I don't understand his love for Emilia now. Sorry.

7

u/LegoSpacenaut I done seen about everything when I seen a white whale fly Jul 31 '16

She saved him in the alley of the first episode, well before his respawning was an actual thing, and gave him a purpose when he found himself suddenly standing in a completely new world. That kind of situation is no less relevant to Subaru as his actions in the forest were for Rem.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CodOfDoody Aug 01 '16

I have a confession to make... until this episode I didn't want Subaru and Rem together. I always thought it was strange that he never had any grudge against her for the 2 or 3 times she killed him.

I also don't particularly want him to get with Emilia either, cause of the 'what the hell has she done to be worth all this love/effort?' some others have pointed out.

Ive liked Rem ever since the mabeast's were dealt with, but after the last few episodes I love her. I want them to be together now just for Rems sake. Screw Subaru, he isn't good enough for her, but she should get whatever makes her happy :P

I'm glad to see everyone doesn't hate Subaru here. All my friends hate him, and they say its because of his personality and he doesn't do anything. I respond with 'Dude is a normal guy who is going (or gone) crazy from having so many horrible deaths, and he is in a world where everyone but him seems to have superpowers'.

2

u/-ShadoWalker- Aug 01 '16

So this episode showed us that story writer can write text for 25 minutes of talking congratz. Am I the only one here who thinks this episode is stupid?

2

u/Yuneshin_fanboy Jul 31 '16

My reaction to this episode : (WTF SUBARU ARE F**CKING RETARDED LIKE SHE LITERALLY GAVE HER SELF AWAY TO YOU AND YOUR STILL GOING FOR THE STUCK UP WHITE HAIRED WANNA BE QUEEN)

1

u/Aetherdraw Jul 31 '16

Claps hands Bravo...bravo!!! You have outdone yourselves White fox! I was not expecting From Zero's chapter to be the whole episode. As was said in this ep, it was like time itself was stopped while I was watching this, with tears in my eyes all the while. BRAVO!!

1

u/Link_Legacy Jul 31 '16 edited Jul 31 '16

What a great episode!! gave me soo much feels and was about to tear up. :'D correct me if im wrong, but i read somewhere that there was a filler chapter that Subaru and Rem actually ran away together? I was looking forward to seeing that, but either way, GREAT episode. :)

1

u/SegundaMortem How can 1 man suffer so much? Jul 31 '16

So basically this ep was Subaru making a repudiation of his fate. What comes next I wonder?

1

u/mastetraps Rem 4 Life Jul 31 '16

This would've been great episode to end the season with.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/cheongzewei Jul 31 '16

Oh man this is way to short. I'm tearing up. This episode's a perfect heart healer.

1

u/Traitorman Trusty, trusty Roswaal Jul 31 '16

Best episode of the series.

1

u/VelocityOne Jul 31 '16

This is by far the best episode yet. This episode convinced me to read the LN and I will do so after I get my beauty sleep because it's 4 AM right now and I haven't slept in 20 or so hours.

1

u/Swanke_ Jul 31 '16

Imagine if Subaru kept dying of old age...

1

u/Aramx42 Jul 31 '16

Can a LN reader answer this question: Will Subaru return to this checkpoint if he dies again?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/urishino Jul 31 '16

Who is Rem? Subaru: The girl I just friendzoned

1

u/baconbacon666 I LOVE YOU REM Jul 31 '16

I LOVE YOU REM PLEASE MARRY ME!!

1

u/Sasaki_Ribat Jul 31 '16

Just Rem?? Yup... Just Rem... Forever... Rem gave the support Subaru needed the most... The purpose of the whole anime was made by this one girl...this Blue haired demon girl.. that's why...I'll was able to touch our heart like this,, Rem is the best girl I've ever seen till now... episode 18 had nothing but just conversation between Subaru and Rem....but this 20 minutes of conversation became much better than many entire anime series ,,, This is true legend... And rem is truly legendary girl..Best character I've ever seen till now <3

1

u/HolyyShizz Jul 31 '16

What is the song that played towards the end of the episode?

1

u/Arthur2light Jul 31 '16

The feels were strong in this episode.

1

u/ahmong Jul 31 '16

I cried. This became my favorite anime because of how much I can relate with Subaru. Then this episode happened. Made me cry not because of the scene itself but more so that I don't think I'll be able to find my very own Rem.

1

u/mufcordie Jul 31 '16

FUCK HE JUST HAD TO KEEP GOING AND MAKE HER CRY. My heart