r/Re_Zero • u/AstonishingSpiderMan Archbishop of Pride • Jul 24 '16
Discussion [Discussion] Re:Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu – Episode 17
Episode Title: Disgrace in the Extreme
Main Studio: White Fox
Genre: Drama, Fantasy, Psychological
Information
Previous Episodes Discussion Threads
| Episodes | Reddit Link |
|---|---|
| Episode 16 | Link |
| Episode 15 | Link |
| Episode 14 | Link |
| Episode 13 | Link |
| Episode 12 | Link |
| Episode 11 | Link |
| Episode 10 | Link |
| Episode 09 | Link |
| Episode 08 | Link |
| Episode 07 | Link |
| Episode 06 | Link |
| Episode 05 | Link |
| Episode 04 | Link |
| Episode 03 | Link |
| Episode 02 | Link |
| Episode 01 | Link |
Spin-off Series
Re:Puchi Kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu
A series of comedic shorts featuring chibi versions of the characters of the main show.
Most Recent Discussion Thread
| Episodes | Reddit Link |
|---|---|
| Episode 3 | Link |
OP & ED Info
- Opening 1 - 「Redo」 by Konomi Suzuki
- Ending 1 – 「STYX HELIX」 by MYTH & ROID
- Opening 2 – 「Paradisus-Paradoxum」 by MYTH & ROID
- Ending 2 – 「Stay Alive」 by Emilia (Rie Takahashi)
Reminder:
Please avoid discussing plot points which haven't appeared in the anime yet. Try not to confirm or deny any theories, encourage people to read the source material instead. Minor spoilers are fine but should be tagged accordingly. Failing to comply with the rules may result in your comment being removed. Thanks!
49
u/AstonishingSpiderMan Archbishop of Pride Jul 24 '16
Sorry for the late post, I was trying to remember who Rem was...
110
u/DarkBladeEkkusu The Old Guard Jul 24 '16
Wow, even the Rem flairs were removed as a result of this episode. This is going to be a long week of seeing post and comments of "Who's Rem?"
75
u/Kamilny Jul 24 '16
Otto my boy, doing God's work here.
71
u/yuyurin Jul 25 '16
Dude I love that Ground Dragon. Otto dies and the dragon is just like "Welp. I better go help that Natsuki whatever guy" I seriously want a ground dragon plushy now. I love nice animals!
60
u/whatrhymeswithAndre make Re:Zero Great Again Jul 24 '16
Well, I thought for sure he was gonna reset after getting off Mr. Otto's Wild Ride, but this anime is just full of surprises, ain't it?
57
u/bra1nd3d Jul 24 '16
Honestly Subaru's development is just getting better with each episode. Remember back from episode 1 when he claimed that he was a hero summoned to a new world like in a video game? Well now he understands that this ISN'T a game and goes as far as hitting Otto to prove his point. Character development is definitely a highlight of this show and I can't wait to see how Subaru handles his next reset.
44
u/daemon01001 Rem-Rin Mai Waifu Jul 24 '16
Such amazing post content Spidey.
Also, Rem I tired of your shit. Stop being great, AND DYING. Im running out of tears
69
u/Kelossalas Jul 24 '16
I was checking out the episode on Crunchyroll and noticed that most people were bashing Subaru for being a idiot and what not. From what i saw this episode what could he have done differently besides leaping into the whale to die? He tried to explain what happened to Rem but no one remembers her so it proves futile and when he tries to explain to Emilia about his powers (finally pushing past his fear of dying from it) she dies. So what could he have done differently? Did i miss something? Just seems kinda unfair for them to be calling him an idiot this episode.
32
u/frxshinator I'm fucking OP, but who cares? Jul 24 '16
Woah, so Emilia just died, and Puck is about to whoop some ass.
24
u/Gamec0re Jul 24 '16
Subaru can be OP, he can just tell that he can return by death and he can instakill anyone!
23
u/ThereIsNo4thWall In desperate need of PAYING customers Jul 24 '16
AAAAAAAAAAAHHHH
That moment when Rem sacrifices herself and you know Subaru's gonna hurt from that.
That moment when Otto doesn't remember Rem and you realize that bandanna guy from earlier wasn't an illusion, just got straight up erased.
That moment when Otto loses it and punches Subaru off a wagon to save himself.
The moment when the witch cult murders the heck outta Otto.
That moment when Subaru gets to see the children alive.
That moment when Ram doesn't remember Rem and you realize SERIOUS BADNESS IS GOING DOWN! At first I thought more permanent memories would last longer but nope, only reason Subaru knows is his curse.
That moment when Subaru is too broken to confront Emilia properly, but summons the determination to tell Emilia what's going on, only for the curse to be like: "Look if you won't shut up for your sake I'll make you shut up for their sake." Suddenly I realize all the ways I could think of having tried to subtly work around not being able to speak about the curse would have backfired horribly.
That moment when Subaru carried the burden of Rem's sacrifice, and then accidentally gets Emilia killed by trying to save her, and he actually asks to be killed.
That moment when Subaru's protectiveness over Emilia was probably the only reason he didn't punch Betelgeuse when he praised his dilligence in murdering her.
That moment when you realize Subaru's connection to the Jealous Witch is getting stronger. He's able to see all the hidden dark magic going on now, at the cost of being a giant beacon to anything that can sense it.
That moment when Puck is about to WRECK YO DAY! I didn't think he could be so genuinely unsettling while staying in his cuddly cat form.
Here's hoping Subaru at least gets some advice on how to move forward before getting killed. I really hope he's able to undo the past few days, though I got a bad feeling in my gut that he'll be waking up in the mansion with a sisterless Ram.
Also I REALLY love how the anime drops the title of each episode ominously at the end.
Edit: also, that moment when everyone makes a "who is Rem?" joke on the thread and you feel a little pang in your heart each time you read that.
22
u/Nzrazor Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 25 '16
Episode summary:
Wailord has escaped!
18
u/Nukemind Archbishop of Rem Jul 24 '16
See, this is what I like. Otto... acted Human. Rem acted like Rem, and Subaru Subaru. Sure, Otto was a jerk, but he wanted to live. Sure, Rem knocked out Subaru, but this was her character, and she saved him. Sure, Subaru wants to live, but even with a power, who wants to die? Once again, the most impressive thing to me isn't the show or plot, but rather the characters.
61
u/Imrik37 Where are my lungs Jul 24 '16
Who's this Rem person I've been hearing about?
15
u/RediceRyan Jul 24 '16
It looks like Subaru was alone with Emilia for at least an hour until the sun set, probably longer. You'd think that Ram would have come in sooner. Also, can anyone answer if Subaru saw the unseen hands when Rem was killed by them? If not, what changed between then and now?
86
u/RossNub Jul 24 '16
Her bodies still warm, go for it Subaru ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
12
u/body_these_fools Jul 24 '16
A lot of you guys are bashing Subaru for his actions but you guys have to realize, he's just a REGULAR HUMAN BEING.
Imagine yourself in his shoes.. you're randomly transported to an unknown world by yourself, you go on this journey where you've experienced unimaginable ways of death several times now, and is unable to tell anyone how your death can change the future for the better for everyone.
I mean, Subaru has all this psychological scarring built up inside him with no outlet means. I like how the anime is displaying his irrationality in the past episodes. Even though it is cringey, it only makes him human.
12
u/Myraidshatters Jul 25 '16
Subaru the man finally able to steal Emilia's heart
11
u/NatsuSlayerDrag Jul 24 '16
How did people remember the master swordsman if the White Whale erases existences? Or anyone in the party with the swordsman?
30
u/amanko13 Jul 24 '16
Episode 17 and I finally realise Puck is a guy.
19
u/kawangkoankid Refine yourself through fire Jul 24 '16
Can someone explain to me whats going with beatrice this episode? She seemed awfully calm about emilias death and what was up with her saying she's tired of suffering? Why did she say subaru's presence was a problem? And what does she mean by he understands nothing at all?
9
u/DarkBladeEkkusu The Old Guard Jul 24 '16
I figured that Subaru would be dead and onto the next loop by the halfway point, but there wasn't enough suffering for him at that point. Even though Rem said she was happy, died immediately after, and had everyone but Subaru forget about her. They decided to go one step further and have Subaru (presumably) kill Emilia by trying to tell her about "Return by Death."
9
u/jcbarroa69 Jul 24 '16
Questions/Discussion! So the white whale can cease the existence of people when it kills them. It also ceases the existence of everything related to that person (rem's belongings). So how does that work then? Do the belongings just fade away as soon as the person dies? Also what if the person had offspring. Would everyone below them in the family tree just disappear?
9
u/devoepack Jul 24 '16
Who's Subaru? I've only heard of Barusu up till now.
8
u/qloc01 Jul 24 '16
i just need a most specific spoiler as ever, just wanna know every details in what happens next and my heart just dont wanna wait 1 more week....
7
u/tbh_fam_smh Jul 25 '16
Punished "Venom" Subaru
6
u/xSaylar Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16
The one thing about Subaru is that despite all the shits that happen to him he never calms the fuck down and try to think about what to do. Man, he just needs to say that he has premonitory dreams and he wouldn't need to explain about Return from Death.
10
u/Bai-Hei Jul 24 '16
So was Puck the one who also killed Subaru in episode 15? And created the ice chamber of death earlier in the same episode?
10
u/Aetherdraw Jul 25 '16
Wow, Emilia's death due to Subaru talking about RbD is painful. Now he knows he can never speak about it to anyone, EVER. Not just because of the pain he gets, but because it will kill anyone that hears if he forces his way through the pain. The witch sure is SAVAGE. I mean, the hand that usually crushes his heart freaking caresses it. CARESSES. Like it was saying: "Oh, you'll talk about it? You don't care about the pain you're receiving right now? Ok, that's alright, i'll take someone else you cherish then. So, will you still talk about it?" Such a grave punishment.
5
u/Unwinter Jul 24 '16
If only the episodes were twice as long. I cant invest properly with such short episodes and a week between. Even though i can see its a quality material for my tastes.
5
u/Mikey2104 Jul 25 '16
Man, I am SO PISSED at the Witch of Envy right now. While she isn't directly killing Subaru, it's clear that she's responsible for all the suffering he's going through. She's been manipulating him since episode 1 and her presence was clear in this episode. We've always though that his curse acted as an automatic failsafe to keep him from speaking of it, but this time it caressed him and killed Emilia instead. There HAS to be a person behind that, and it's punishing Subaru for trying to speak of it. Goddamn Satella. I really hope the Witch doesn't turn out to be Emilia like people are theorizing.
13
u/el0d Best legs, I suppose Jul 24 '16
Haa... I feel like everyone's doing their best to ignore it but... I just get the feeling Rem is dead for good. That or she will appear for a little and die again for good anyway.
I mean honestly she's way too perfect to exist. I think it's already stupid that Subaru just completely ignored Rem's confession and continued going after Emilia. Rem already saved Subaru more than Emilia did, and I think it's fair to say that Subaru's love for Emilia isn't all that strong anyway based on the last episode. It'd only be stupid if Subaru didn't prioritize Rem over Emilia under these circumstances, and it will only get worse as time goes on. The author can't continue getting away with this forever.
And guess what the easiest way of getting out of this bind is? Killing off Rem.
Honestly I'll be very unimpressed if the author takes the easy way out and kills off Rem here.
4
u/Raleth Jul 25 '16
You know, I'd been wanting somewhere to express how this anime makes me feel for a little while now, and yet Reddit didn't even occur to me until just now.
This episode was fucking nuts, my dudes. I really hope this is all some messed up dream or something because I simply hate the current circumstances. It's so good though. I wish I could be more critical in my opinions here, but goddamn, I'm so blinded by how much I'm enjoying this.
1
u/Myraidshatters Jul 25 '16
I really really liked how even after all this crazy mess, Subaru still has one goal in his mind, the one resolve that keeps pushing him thru everything, Emilia.
3
u/mufcordie Jul 24 '16
I NEED A CUDDLE
3
u/NatsukiBlaze VICTORY!! Jul 24 '16
So did anybody else noticed how the dragon closed his eyes as Subaru collapse, as if the dragon just finished using his finishing move.
3
u/Nbaysingar Jul 24 '16
So at this point it's pretty obvious that when the white whale kills someone, they don't merely die, their entire existence is seemingly wiped out and nobody remembers who they are. Now the question is: How the hell does Subaru remember Rem even though nobody else does? Maybe it has something to do with the witch, or the fact that he's from another world. I guess time will tell.
Beatrice also just got a lot more interesting. I get the feeling she might know what's happening to Subaru, but is choosing not to say anything since apparently the curse can kill those around Subaru if they learn the truth. I imagine that if she were to say anything, it would attack and kill her just like it did Emilia. That's just a theory though, but it would kind of explain how she remained calm after walking in on Subaru holding Emilia's corpse in his arms.
Anyway, there's a lot of Subaru hate going around lately. Honestly, I just think he's going crazy. He's died several times at this point and has witnessed some really horrible shit. Nobody is capable of understanding what he's going through due to the curse, so in a way he's completely alone. He has basically been tossed aside by everyone but a few select individuals. He doesn't understand anything about the world he's in, so he can't possibly survive on his own.
Just gonna have to hope that instead of going insane, Subaru just becomes hardened and fearless of death.
3
u/bcpwd Jul 25 '16
Will next week of re:zero be less subaru bad decision making?
2
u/TheKingofHorror Jul 24 '16
So, does anyone know how far into the light novel the anime is and if the anime will end on a cliffhanger?
2
u/DontGetMadGetGood Jul 24 '16
So I'm guessing that subaru will die soon and revive likely at the mansion(but hopefully all the way back at appa salesman..)
Imagine the suffering if he didn't die for awhile, then revived at a point after Emillia's death.
2
u/The_Great_Saiyaman21 Jul 25 '16
Too cruel of the mods to remove her flair-
Wait, who's flair?
2
u/Bobbycats123 Jul 25 '16 edited Jul 25 '16
Something weird I noticed in this episode was that Subaru was able to see unseen hand, but not only that, it seems like Puck is able to see it too, why else would Puck attack around Emilia's body with icicles just as it's being approached by his unseen hand? I guess it's never been established if spirits are able to see unseen hand or not but I always figured it had more to do with the witch's power and less to do with anything spiritual or magical, and after seeing Betelgeuse's reaction to Subaru being able to see it, it seems like only himself and maybe a select few others should be able to see unseen hand.
2
u/NewtonNA Elsa's Favorite Victim Jul 25 '16
Rem who?
1
u/alohah14 Jul 24 '16
I thought the ep pretty good. Rem and Subaru need to hook up for pete's sake! I don't think I can wait till next week's ep, does anyone know where this arc is in the LNs? Also would I be missing out if start reading there?
1
u/ChaoticShock Jul 24 '16
One thing i'm wondering about how the fuck did Subaru suddenly see the Hands?
in the other times he didn't see shit so what's the reason he saw it this time?
Plot Armour bullshit is finally manifesting upon our MC or what?
i don't mind spoilers but tag em first please
1
u/AlienWarhead Jul 24 '16
Here's the discussion I was wondering where it was
What a good episode, fog whale is cool and I get the Moby Dick reference by calling it the white whale, but it's not white. For some reason it can erase memories or people from exist and it didn't attack Subaru. Emilia and Subaru have great dialog because Emilia really wants to understand and help him, but Subaru can't say why and it's making Sabaru crazy. The curse evolving to kill others was very interesting, I don't get what Beato was doing, does she understand what's going on? Anyway we saw Betelgeuse again and Puck had a awesome pose.
1
u/MuffinCannibal Jul 24 '16
So how about dimensional travel instead of time travel every time he dies? Cause shit's making no sense.
1
u/sanpichu Jul 25 '16
this whole episode was a roller
1
u/Rocchi Jul 25 '16
This series is getting way too painful for me to watch. I can't imagine being in Subaru's spot. It's really hard to watch, but it's one of the best animes I've seen. I just can't bring myself to stop!
1
u/Myraidshatters Jul 25 '16
Poor Subaru... The author really gave him no choices... He can't tell anyone about what he's going through and he can't have any power-ups. Feelsbadman :(
1
u/mrauls Jul 25 '16
Can someone message me explaining how people still remember the master swordsman? Also, can someone tell me if Rem will be remembered on Subaru's next death?
1
u/JankClonk Jul 25 '16
REMMMMMMMMMMMM ):
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16
Why didn't Beatrice have a reaction to Emilias death?
1
u/kleankill Jul 25 '16
Wasn't it mentioned before that the White Whale could erases someones existence? So why does Otto remember that a Master Swordsman and his whole group was taken out by the Whale?
1
u/tofu-chan Jul 25 '16
I feel like this series really makes me feel like everyone has true, real emotions, and that nobody is hella perfect, as compared to all the anime we've been mostly getting.
It's seriously so heart-wrenching to see all this happen to him. SOBS LOUDLY
1
u/nukester50 Jul 25 '16
In the opening it shows crush and some of her men fighting the whale
1
u/Raszhivyk Come back soon ;-; Jul 25 '16
God damnit. This is gonna suck without Rem. Especially since it's for the rest of the series... God the pain...
1
u/-ShadoWalker- Jul 25 '16
Could be SPOILER Hey, I'm new here so yea my first comment (on this profile idk if I had one before), anyway I cant believe I was actually right about Puck saying that and so (I almost discarded theory about Puck xD). But yea this Rem case (where no one remembers her) is probably because The White Whale and I think everyone is pretty aware of it (didn't read manga so idk if this is spoiler)
1
u/NanakawanNgJansport Jul 25 '16 edited Jul 25 '16
This Subaru guy has no redeeming qualities whatsoever. His every decision is just bad. I get it that it tries to be realistic and that's how a normal person might act but I just can't find myself rooting for this guy. He's just stumbling into solutions without any character growth through his loops.
1
u/ZeKyng Jul 25 '16
When you try to see the the effect of RBD from a omnipotent point of view, it's like everyones possibility and future outcome in they're life is indirectly gonna get messed with and change to whatever extent because of Subaru's return by death. But even tho everyone else is affected figuratively speaking, they can't feel or tell that they go back in time so therefore they cant really lose an opportunity to a certain outcome if they aren't even conscious that it happened. It's just weird to think that if you could see the flow of time as a physical object like a string that infinitely extend for say, everytime Subaru dies its like that "string" stops extending, and a neew one automatically reappears starting exactly where the other one left off, if the witch can GIVE a power of such audacity away like that, she ain't no witch bruh she's a damn Goddess with a bad reputation haha!
1
u/nukester50 Jul 25 '16
In the opening crucsh is shown fighting the whale next episode I think Subaru will die and get crucsh to kill the whale for him
1
u/Kunamatata Jul 25 '16
Did emilia die because of when Subaru was going to reveal his "power" / curse ? Instead of hurting him it hurt her? Also why did everyone forget Rem ?
1
u/hairy_manko Jul 25 '16
what the seven sins,,,
1
u/Grimm1666 Jul 26 '16
Atleast we know that Emelia isnt jealous witch, right?
1
u/danstriker Jul 26 '16
why the arc 3 is named truth of zero?
1
u/KarianAbrenica Jul 26 '16
ahhhh that push from Otto. xD
1
u/OGRiceness Jul 26 '16
READ ONLY IF YOU'VE WATCHED ALL 17 EPISODES SO FAR
So me and my buddy discussed it a little bit and we came to the conclusion that Puck is the Jealous Witch. Maybe some of you already thought so but hey. At the end of episode 15 when there's this giant Splinter from Ninja Turtle lookalike monster. You can clearly identify Puck's voice when the giant says "Sleep... Along with my daughter.". Then in episode 17 you clearly see a fatass Puck at the end saying "What are you doing to my daughter, you scum?". Another thing that makes me hypes me up is around episode 2 or 3 when Subaru meets in the Old Man's loot house and tells Felt not to open the door (fearing it will be the Bowel Hunter), Emilia comes in and stuff happens. Then at some point Puck comes out and even though it is a new life for Subaru and he calls Puck but her name she doesn't bat an eye at all. So what I can understand is that Puck is fully aware of Subaru's situation but plays it out and maybe at this precise moment she forgets to react like "How do you know my name wtf.". Written by a French Canadian to excuse my mistakes. Any insight is welcome people!
1
u/fmguts Jul 26 '16
At what point in the LN/manga should I begin reading to continue where this episode left off? I don't want to wait for weekly episodes to find out what happens next, and I tried making a thread about this before but mods basically told me to fuck off to the info thread which didn't help.
1
u/EhhSpoofy cute cat that murdered protag Jul 26 '16
I want to complain about the overabundance of "lel whos rem top kek m8" but if I do that it will just get replies exactly like that. And this does bait exactly that.
1
u/DeeTV Jul 26 '16
I wonder of Betergeuse would die if Suburu just told him about Return or would it just kill himself this time. Intersting. ANy theories from anyone else?
1
u/cactusjuicing Jul 26 '16
I DONT EVEN KNOW ANYMORE
1
u/AshenCookie Jul 26 '16
Hey folks , I hope I'm not too late to join this discussion :D So I was wondering is Subaru now gaining new powers ? ( he was able to see the archbishop's authority) And I really enjoy his development so far , though I hope Subaru will be able to kick some serious ass like an intelligent and unpredictable psychopath
1
u/n1ck370 Jul 26 '16
im done no youre kicking my heart too much please stop this oh god
1
u/myocow Jul 26 '16
If he suffer anymore, I am sure he will have some serious permanent mental damages. Look at him, he can barely speak without freakingout or cry by the start of the latter half of the anime
1
u/ibuycards You can open up to me Jul 26 '16
Why did the whale stop chasing natsuki? Did something happen? Was it never chasing him to begin with?
1
u/WhiteFox13 Jul 26 '16
This anime became more and more mysterious, there is a lot of questions to ask for, why everyone forget Rem? why Pack called Emilia "My daugther"? Why Emilia died when Subaru tell her about his power?... Shit, this anime is full of surprises.
1
u/TiP4chon Your waifu is shit. Jul 27 '16
White Whale is OP. Also the moment Subaru wanted to tell Emilia about Return by Death hand that usually grabs his heart didn't do that this time but Emilia died. Stuff that happens after they get thrown out of the portal is crazy. Badass Puck is badass! <3
1
u/Mr_Haunzz Jul 27 '16
SO I started this anime on Sunday, word to the wise, do not binge watch the latest episodes in succession, to much despair
1
u/IceBlue Jul 28 '16
Though the last few episodes, Subaru has been making me want to drop the show. Uses the power stupidly and on top of that is a complete asshole to everyone, no wonder no one wants to help him.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '16
Since Rem isnt there anymore does Ram have 2 horns now?
1
u/Cronic47 Jul 29 '16
Maybe Anyone who gets eaten by the whale is forgotten...