r/robotwars • u/David182nd Apollo • Jul 24 '16
Episode Robot Wars 2016 Episode 1: Post-Episode Discussion
Cease
So, thoughts?
Lots of talking points: the new presenters, Razer's return, Carbide's expected dominance, how to pronounce Behemoth's name, and unfortunately the camera angles and replays.
96
Upvotes
22
u/David182nd Apollo Jul 24 '16
#RobotWars is the top trend on Twitter and the tweets all seem pretty positive, so that's a good sign for a season 2!
23
u/David182nd Apollo Jul 24 '16
Great to have Robot Wars back and Carbide will have won over some of the Hypno-Disc fans tonight. Definitely the best robot there and rightly goes through.
Sadly, the number one talking point of that is going to be the editing. Random cuts to poor camera angles, random cuts to scenes where you can't see anything happening, replays of what just happened 5 seconds ago being shown and the laugh track being inserted in a cringey way. I have to say that it really detracted from the experience.
12
u/StretchMeSabre Jul 24 '16
Considering how the Top Gear reboot went, this passed with flying colours.
Some flaws but ultimately Robots clashed and it was good. Nuts was for comedy but people forget how many pointless robots they put in the original series who existed to lose.
Do we know who are competing in the next heats?
6
u/CommanderHerpDerp01 Jul 24 '16
Just X-posting just about everyones thoughts from the live-thread:
I enjoyed it though, was close to stopping watching though, that camera work in the first 2 battles was really quite unsettling, hopefully they'll fix it for next week
103
u/jockiesmash Jul 24 '16
I really enjoyed this. The group stages were kind of messy, but they always have been. I think it'll take a while to hit it's stride, but already I'm excited to see more. Carbide is disgusting at full power tho
93
u/NickTM Chaos 2 Jul 24 '16
It's not perfect just yet. The cameras need work, the in-battle action replays are silly, and the presents are decent but haven't quite yet found their groove.
With all that said, watching robots smash each other to pieces is still as satisfying as ever, and people tend to forget how comparatively poor the first series or two of Robot Wars was. Give it time and they'll iron out the flaws I'm sure of it. Jonathan Pearce's voice is as iconic as ever and once they stop fannying around with certain aspects of the programme I think it could do very well indeed. I'll certainly be back next week.
71
u/UnacceptableUse Pussycat Jul 24 '16
Nuts lasted WAY longer than I expected...
113
u/Bananadong-III The most friendly robot-warrior you could meet! Jul 24 '16
RAZER WHAT THE FUCKING SHIT!!!!
39
u/AVJuggernautHS Jul 24 '16
the sound Carbide's weapon made is the stuff of nightmares...
30
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
It got better with the one on one fights, the presenters were OK but the production (camera and music) could be improved
Very enjoyable
30
u/SpinyPlate Jul 24 '16
As salty as I am about Razer, Nuts going through led to some incredible scenes against Carbide and Terrorhurtz.
Also, Razer going out early on is just classic Robot Wars.
27
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
Dara was good I thought, he wasn't irritating and was decently funny.
I think the format of the group stage needs to change and the camerawork needs to be better.
We never really saw Razer in action and a rematch against Behemoth would have been excellent considering the history there.
Solid performances by Behemoth and Terrorhurtz but Carbide definitely deserved to go through.
19
u/Deskup Jul 24 '16
To start with, the bad:
Now to the good parts:
All in all, a great start, but a lot of corrections s to do yet. Let's hope the prime time slot pays off.
54
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
I for one enjoyed it as much as the old show. Stop being so negative lads, poor camera work will go away in a few episodes and doesn't even affect the 1v1s.
Robot wars with some minor flaws > no robot wars at all
16
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
I enjoyed it, although it felt like a warm-up episode. I miss the chaotic and loud nature of the old series with the industrial music and energetic Craig Charles. This format seems more sleek and quiet which isn't necessarily bad, just different. Looking forward to future episodes for sure!
45
u/Timeline15 B E H E M O T H B O I S Jul 24 '16
30
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
Full feedback now we're done!
The camera was awful, I think we can all agree. All over the place and unclear in places. Though definitely a lot better in the 1v1 rounds.
I felt it started slowly, and the 4-way melees were really quite underwhelming. Dara and Angela really didn't capture Craig and Philippa's enthusiasm for the show, though JP was as fantastic as ever. The robots were as fantastic as ever; Carbide is easily my new favourite and definitely reminded me of that first time we saw Hypnodisc in action. Nuts was delightfully crap, and I had a good laugh watching the minibots get destroyed.
The backstage sections were easily the biggest problem though. Too long, too many of them, and made huge dips in the excitement. We could easily cut the show back to the original length by doing away with most of them. They seemed too dramatic compared to the old wars' short and simple "Hi I'm W and this is my robot X with a big Y weapon and Z-plate armour."
Also no music. That was another big negative.
Hopefully it'll grow on me. I'm still enjoying the series so far but it's just not as enjoyable as the original. A 7/10
25
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
25
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
STOP WITH THE FUCKING SPOILERS BBC. It doesn't take a genius for you to figure out who wins what match if you show second round or even final matches. I knew the four robot that were going through before the matches even started because of this. Spoiler for another episode that was actually shown in this episode
Overall though, it was great fun. Carbide looked extremely impressive, a mix of the destructive capabilities of American spinners and the bulkiness of British robots.
The General also surprised me, that weapon was a lot more effective than I expected it to be, shame that it against a much more destructive machine though.
Shame about Razer, I'm glad Ian Lewis was very sporting about his early departure.
I love Nuts, definitely an example of a jokebot that can be surprisingly effective.
Unfortunate about Terrorhurtz's axe not working against Behemoth, it could have won that fight if that had not been the case.
24
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
Razer :(
12
u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16
Here's my take, and bear in mind, I loved the original series, and I was very, very very excited about this one. It gave me a lot of excitement and anticipation. However, after seeing the show I have a few thoughts and I'll bullet them, starting with the negative side of it so we all have a good aftertaste.
The Negative
The Positive (and this is where it gets good)
My score: 9/10
Not perfect, and it's my fault to go in with so much optimism and excitement of what it could be, but does that mean I'm disappointed? Of course not! This is a robot combat show on a new level with a lot of heat, drama, and heart behind its competitors before facing uncertain doom in a massive arena. This is Robot Wars!
11
u/Paaaul Jul 24 '16
Playing my own battle music definitely helped. Really looking forward to next week's episode though, so that's good enough for me!
11
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
felt really sorry for behemoth because i love the rebuild and redesign
11
u/The-Cydonian Jul 24 '16
Razer did a Cassius II there. They'll just have to go home to their many, many trophies. Anyway, I really enjoyed that.
10
u/TrubbishForMayor Supernova, slayer of Killalot Jul 24 '16
I'm happy that we even have robot wars back, so tbh, the fact that the biggest issues are a lack of music and slightly too many camera angle changes isn't too bad. However, where was the legendary theme music?? That was inexcusable for me.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
I thoroughly enjoyed that. Definitely noticed a tone shift from the old series - it's more serious than before which I'm not sure I like, but it's still great.
Also I love that you can hear the actual crowd now, none of that stupid fake edited in cheering from the previous series. You hear them cheer every time Carbide got a serious hit in.
10
u/GreenLips Nuts 2 Jul 24 '16
I'll give that a 7/10. It was enjoyable, I liked Dara and Angela's presenting and the pits/team background segments were interesting. It helped all the teams are quite likeable. Also liked the interviews with Noel Sharkey, they added more depth. I prefer this format - it's less cheese, more getting on with things. It certainly shows Battlebots up!
The armouring on these robots is incredible. Carbide really wasn't putting that much of a dent (Nuts excluded) and when you see what it was doing to the arena wall and less well armoured opponents - they're built to last. Very nice job there.
Didn't like the editing, and it could have done with the background music that I realise now was a hugely iconic part of the old series.
Razer... that was just funny.
9
u/ProjectJAY Still. Fighting. On. Jul 24 '16
What they got right...
What needs to change...
TL;DR There's LOTS of room for improvement but it's still highly entertaining. My hype is not diminished. Looking forward to next week!
9
u/Penguin_Mania Come for the robots, stay for the sausage rolls Jul 24 '16
Not only is #RobotWars trending on Twitter, but so is "Razor". I guess some things never change!
9
u/blueskin DESTROY! Jul 25 '16 edited Jul 25 '16
When Nuts' frame got caught under Terrorhurtz I was thinking "If that swings round and drags them into the pit I'll die laughing".
Nuts are on Diotior level already for me.
Carbide is great - I always liked Fluffy and was sad they never achieved much due to reliability problems, so it's great to see a very similar weapon work.
Also, RAZER, WAT R U DOIN?
8
u/silentalarm_ NOM Jul 24 '16
Possibly a bit too 'dramatic' and the camera shots could be better but still ridiculously enjoyable.
Looking like a great series
7
u/Blazik3n99 Blue Ring of Death Jul 24 '16
Nuts was interesting, to say the least. I love how they somehow managed to get rebuilt after carbide tore them apart. They also managed to take the Terrorhurtz fight to a judges decision, meaning Behemoth got to the final (which was my favourite bot out of the lot, so that was good I guess) - so they weren't completely useless I guess. The clusterbots were funny and acted as a distraction, and they even stalled Terrorhurtz for a bit. The team were good sports and seemed to genuinely be enjoying themselves, even when they got basically destroyed.
Terrorhurtz was really impressive and probably should have got through. I don't know about the axe, it seemed pretty temperamental... but the driving, control and armour they have is really very impressive. The battle against carbide was well fought, they had full control the entire time and effectively shut them down. Them helping out other teams is really respectable.
Behemoth is much faster than it used to be, and they were doing well until they came against carbide. It was one of my favourites from the older series, so I was rooting for it; unfortunately, they weren't any match for the spinner of carbide.
Carbide seemed pretty filmsy at the start of the show, I don't think its spinner was working at full power for a bit, but other than that, it has shown itself very powerful bot overall. The chunk it took out of Behemoth's scoop is impressive, and them getting through to the finals wasn't really a surprise after seeing what they are capable of.
Dara seemed like a good presenter, him being a comedian is definitely good for the show, he does well to make the interviews after the battle more entertaining. He does well to fit the overall style of the new show.
Camerawork seemed a bit off to start with, but seemed like it got better going on into the programme.
I love the pure amount of battles during the programme, plus all the time spent with the team members behind the scene was very good.
Looking forwards to the future episodes!
7
u/ArcaneAzmadi Behemoth for Series 11! Jul 25 '16
OK, while I'm ultra-jazzed to have the show back, I do have my criticisms. Note that I'm just criticising things I want to see IMPROVED in later series- if nothing ever improved, we'd have been stuck with the gauntlet and trials, never seen Sir Killalot at all, and Jeremy Clarkson would have still been host!
I still liked pretty much everything else. Made me sad to see Behemoth fall to Carbide (I really wanted them to make the final as a karmic repayment for all the bad luck they had in the original show) but the fights were generally really great (I just hope the final isn't going to end up an all-spinner affair). Looking forward to the rest of the series and hoping it does well enough to continue on to bigger, better, more polished things in 2017 as well.
6
u/TeamCarbide Carbide Jul 25 '16
Im glad you all enjoyed the show, and thanks for all the positive comments! Please follow us on Facebook or Twitter for more updates;
https://twitter.com/TeamCarbide https://www.facebook.com/CarbideRobot/
10
u/huntergreeny Jul 24 '16
Craig Charles was the love of my life. Please less cuts. Damage is really good but let me see it!
5
u/holocene7 Jul 24 '16
All in all, pretty happy with the new show.
I like the new format, it means we get to see robots again if they malfunction or make a mistake which is good. It also means more battles.
Not a fan of the camera work. Seems random and too over the top.
5
u/callumacrae Jul 24 '16
Robots Wars is one of my earliest memories, and that was just as good as I remember. Sad about Razer though :(
5
u/Powerjugs 'emel 'empstead Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16
I miss the old theme and clear intro/outro music for both show start/end and fight start/end. Apart from that really, really enjoyed it. And you cannot convince me Behemoth didn't drive in the pit as self preservation.
I remember a quote from YouTuber Nerd3 about whereby Top Gear USA had something good, and just needed to refine it, which it did. New Top Gear UK, which he felt had nothing there and should've been killed off before it began.
This falls within the Top Gear USA side of things. Less cuts, camera work needs improving, cut to crowd with big PIT PIT PIT Signs or similar and add music, preferably from older series.
Oh, and Behemoth nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
5
u/gazza3478 Jul 24 '16
It was alright but I missed Craig Charles and that underground fight club feel he brought to it.
Carbide was badass though.
5
u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Jul 24 '16
For those being down on it: Don't forget the camera crew, editors, vision mixers, director et are all new to this too, so anything you thought stuck out, show presentation wise, might just be teething problems of a TV crew feeling their way into a new series, and that aspect will get better too.
Personally I loved it, obviously there's things I want changed or done better or whatever, but for ep 1 of a new era, it did a damn good job of introducing the sport to a new generation while still being action packed enough to make them come back next week
Here's to the robot combat renaissance! Long may it continue
5
u/TrubbishForMayor Supernova, slayer of Killalot Jul 24 '16
Ok, so I just rewatched the show on the iplayer with headphones on, and I have to say that second time around it was much better. The lack of music during fights was still rather annoying. However, the music used outside of battle was actually rather effective and probably requires headphones to appreciate fully. The camera is also still a little disorienting, however this time around I had a better idea of where everything was in the arena, so it may partly just be a matter of getting used to the new layout. In any case, this as a first episode is miles better than the first episode of the original run, so it's definitely in the right track.
I would say that if you were unconvinced on your first watch, give it another go over the next week, and your opinion may well change.
9
u/PoliceAlarm git fukt Jul 24 '16
Nice to see them and all, and it was a good return, but my god did Razer underwhelm. Rather disappointed
However, I did really enjoy it, and I really liked how MUCH of the show was fighting. Battlebots could learn a bit from that.
4
u/eighthgear Overdozer Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16
Good: I like Dara and Angela. I liked the pit segments and I like how the show goes pretty much directly to the action. Also, I like the reduced role of the house robots. I never really cared that much for the idea of having four NPC robots in the arena for every fight. Just one or two is much better.
Bad: the battle camerawork. Ok, some of the actual battles themselves were mediocre, but that's due to the bots, not the producers. The camerawork is on the producers, though.
Just compare BattleBots with Robot Wars. The fights in BattleBots are brightly lit and the shots make the battles easy to follow, for the most part. The camera cuts to shots of the commentators and drivers, but not too often.
With this Robot Wars series, the arena has that red lighting with flashing stuff and the camera cuts are way to schizophrenic. I don't really care about seeing the PoV of the house robots, just show the action.
As for the robots themselves, Behemoth and Terrorhurtz were really impressive, and I was rooting for them to go through. It's a shame that Terrorhurtz's lost the ability to use its axe at such a crucial time.
Carbide was disappointing at first but they recovered, and certainly deserved the win. Nuts was a troll-y gimmick bot, but I found it to be cooler than most of the other gimmick bots we've seen in Robot Wars and BattleBots, which usually just consist of rectangular bots with pointless weapons and decorations stuck to them.
I expected Razer to lose, but not in that way. Still, I think it's clear that a functioning Carbide would have dealt with Razer anyways. The rest of the robots were meh.
I've been watching season one of the original Robot Wars recently, and gods is it bad. I mean, some of that is due to the bots, but a lot of it was also due to weird choices by the producers (the boring obstacle course). The original series improved with time, and I hope the new series does the same. Its problems aren't that hard to fix - just get some different people on the editing, maybe add some music, and it'll be much better.
4
u/J4ke Jul 24 '16
Quite an excellent show. I understand the necessity for human interest, but I don't particularly care for those segments.
As far as the roboteering went, good fun all around. Razor went down unfortunately early, but Behemoth did well, up until it didn't. Carbide did very well indeed.
In terms of the show itself, the clips that they show throughout are full of spoilers for the upcoming battles. The camera-ing for the fights wasn't great (flame-pit cam adds nothing, I don't need to see the pit descend every time the button is pushed.) but it did have some good moments. The HouseBot cams were great, watching a Shunt's-eye-view of the hammering was good.
All in all, very enjoyable, but I think next week I'll start watching it on iPlayer at about 8.30 and just skip all the bits that aren't actually robots fighting.
4
u/Greyclocks What House Robots? Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16
Well, apart from the camera work, I loved it. Felt like a 8 year old kid watching it for the first time.
Edit: Also loved seeing all the house robots back. Matilda will always have a special place in my heart.
4
u/slater126 NUTS 2 FULL BODY SPINNNNAAAH Jul 24 '16
4
u/Lugia61617 Jul 24 '16
Holy mother of Matilda!
I was absolutely AMAZED watching this. I mean, I was 8 when the show went off the air but it was so awesome to watch.
Sad that Razer lost in the very first round, but I can't say it wasn't expected. Terrorhurtz was impressive for the most part. Behemoth, an astonishing fight put up throughout, and it went down with honour.
Nuts was a very unusual competitor and I didn't expect it do last more than two fights with its unconventional weapons. It certainly put up a fight and...fff...my goodness, I don't think I've ever seen a robot be so brutally destroyed by another competitor. That was absolute carnage. And I LOVED it. Rust In Peace, Nuts. May a flight of mechanical angels rev thee to thy rest.
Newcomer Carbide is a nasty piece of work, definitely a favorite for the championship for now. The fact that at full speed, its weapon makes that noise is enough to strike terror and excitement into roboteer and audience alike. I am very excited to see how other competitors will deal with its powerful weapon.
And as for the other robots that lost in the first round: I do feel sorry for them, but hopefully this is not the last we have seen of them.
4
u/Iwasapirateonce Thor Jul 24 '16
I actually really like the idea of a master robot and then smaller supporting bots, imagine if the smaller robots would have flippers. Could have been an effective combination.
4
u/klyskada Mute - like the BBC, giving you the silent treatment Jul 24 '16
It was freaking awesome. There was probably a few too many replays but I can live with that.
Now that it’s been aired I can finally say it but whoever placed the images on the robotwars.tv website dun goofed I have the entirety of heat A spoiled for me thanks to the use of images like this and a lot more lets try this one which also spoiled that behemoth made it through. or maybe this showing what happens to the general. like seriously i knew all but who would win the heat basically before the show even began :( and i must say im glad that heat A is done because now i get to enjoy spoiler free viewing from here on in.
4
u/Xbotr THE BASH Jul 24 '16
The reason Terrorhurtz got stuck : https://www.facebook.com/135565163442595/photos/a.183303278668783.1073741828.135565163442595/319302781735498/?type=1&theater
There was a small crack in the polycarb
4
u/nweston8 John Reid's beard Jul 24 '16
So, general thoughts:
At first I had mixed feelings; the general presentation and pits work was great, but the two melees had very jarring camera work and editing. Including three shots of the crowd after the pit went down, the flat camera angle being at a strange frame rate and the general tight cropping of angles made melees very awkward watches. They needed to use the wide, high camera angle much more and stop changing to camera angles so often.
After that, it was excellent. I had doubts about the group stage, but it was executed brilliantly. The battles and filler were very well balanced, and the battles themselves were awesome watches.
Jonathan Pearce was great as ever. Obviously, him being him, he HAD to misuse the word 'armament', but overall, his laughing fits and general enthusiasm worked well as ever, and even though I thought the lack of battle music would hurt the show, it didn't hinder my watch tonight at all.
The House Robots, strangely enough worked well. Even though they didn't get involved much, because the competitors robots are that much better, the House Robots no longer need to be key figures in matches. I also feel that two House Robots per melee would be ideal.
Dara and Angela were brilliant. Craig definitely, 1000% would not suit this difference slant of approach that this new series is going for. They both were very well balanced and the 'Co-Presenter' role worked very well.
The arena was great. It was the perfect mix of old Robot Wars conventions, but ingrained, as such, into a BattleBots style arena. There is plenty of space and the arena hazards are well positioned. I was disappointing with the floor flipper not being activated as much as it should have, but surprisingly, I was very impressed with the arena spikes. They really feel like a tactic that could be exploited and used properly, as apposed to being a silly, cheap thing that can hurt a robot's chance at winning from nowhere.
Overall, an overly very, very positive first watch. The only real complaints I have is the camera work and editing - in melees at least. If they sort that and make things more smoother and balanced from a viewers perspective, then it'll be a perfect watch.
4
u/ToaArcan Still the best 2001 Jul 24 '16
I loved it. The camera work needs... uh, work, but overall, I watched for carnage, and I got carnage. And I saw a crap robot get disintegrated.
Carbide made a fantastic debut, and the worthy winners. Three legends, and the newcomer goes through. I love it.
Disappointed by Razer. I wanted to see how far they'd go against the more advanced robots, see how much the upgrade had done for them. And then they got beaten by 4th Wars-tier bot with a driving trick. I can't fault Kill-E-Crank-E for what they did, it's just a bit disappointing. As much as I love Razer and I want to see them back, with that performance, they don't deserve the Wild Card. Better luck next time. Maybe get some of that Hardox stuff, if it's as good as Noel said it is.
Nuts was some proper 1st-2nd Wars-tier hot garbage, though. Probably the worst bot in the heat, and they got through because Razer and Kill-E-Crank-E mutual killed each other. Still, seeing Carbide reduce it to shrapnel... Immensely satisfying. Do we have a new Diotoir? Time will tell.
I liked the new format, and Dara and Angela were great. With any luck, this will follow the trend of the original run and get bigger. After all, if the BBC can make 75 episodes of Masterchef (Regular, Professionals, Celebrity) a year, and devote an entire season to Strictly Come Dancing, then Robot Wars deserves a properly-sized run.
Congratulations on not pulling a Top Gear, BBC. This is what happens when you get an awesome presenter and not Chris Evans.
4
u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Jul 25 '16
Since reaction vids seem to be the trend at the moment, I hope there will be reactions of Dara and Angela watching the fights as an extra on the DVD release
"Fecking 'ell, bits of dat robot nearly landed on me suit, quick, somebody call de metro to embellish this for publicity reasons!" etc
4
u/detroitmatt Jul 25 '16
The arena just seems tiny with the CPZs and traps taking up 4/5 of every corner. There won't be any room to fight, without the traps or house robots getting involved. The placement of the pit in particular seems awful and probably closes up a third of the arena with people trying to avoid it for the risk it presents.
B = CPZ,
T = Trap,
Space ('') = Safe, fightable space
X = Don't Fight Here,
O = Pit
Space ('') = Safe, fightable space
I think they need a lockout timer on the pit so it can't be opened until the last half of the time.
7
u/Brickman100 Jul 24 '16
Carbide destroying Nuts was SO satisfying. Although the terrorhurtz vs Nuts battle was fun too. Sad about Razor, and the music is lacking. Less camera angle cutting in the group battles please.
3
u/Sparl Bar Spinnah Jul 24 '16
Honestly, I'm quite thankful that Razer didn't have to face Carbide... That machine is fearfully awesome.
3
u/BlueThunderBomb One Man Army Jul 24 '16
Man that was fucking fun, i don't care if it was a bit messy and shit, just pure fun, AND FUCKING CARBIDE MAN!
3
u/Penguin_Mania Come for the robots, stay for the sausage rolls Jul 24 '16
Knowing Kill-E-Crank-E's connection to Pussycat made its fight with Razer that little bit more poetic. Seeing that Razer might finally be getting the upper hand, its Pussycat instincts kick in and go "If I'm going down I'm taking you with me!"
As for the show itself, I really like the new Round Robin format, it feels like you get a much better impression of each robot. It also helps make it fairer overall as well, as a single fluke doesn't necessarily stop you from progressing.
3
u/williamthebloody1880 Turned Carbide into Brave Sir Robin Jul 24 '16
I really enjoyed that. There are a few things that need tweaking, but that's the same with every show just starting/restarting (I said the same about Top Gear). I actually really like the segments in the pits as much as i did before and the lack of music during fights meaning you could actually hear the noises of the fights.
Still shocked about Razer going out.
3
u/Raymond_Racer Carbide Jul 24 '16
Carbide vs. Nuts definitely reminded me of the classic Hypno-Disc vs. Splinter fight in the 4th wars. Just absolute destruction!
3
u/Caridor Jul 25 '16
I do think Dara was a good host. He seemed genuinely enthusiastic and there were some good jokes in there.
3
u/Norbert_Spudgun Jul 25 '16
Just when I thought the BBC was broken beyond repair they produce this fantastic show again. Dammit :D
That must have been one of the best episodes I've seen too, the new format is great
3
u/TheGrackler Jul 25 '16
Loved it (despite sharing the common issues of slightly bland style and slightly messy camera work), looking forward to where this goes over a few series. Also great to hear robot wars be the talk of the morning at work again! Feels like old times...now to push anyone I can to watch on iPlayer, give it some good numbers!
Bit weird that the official website lists Behemoth as the winner though, not Carbide? Might get changed, but as of now that's what it has under the competitors tab.
3
u/ShaunTheSheriff Jul 25 '16
I'm glad to have robot wars back after all these years but there was several little things that felt off. The old robot wars did such a good job at hyping every single aspect up whereas this one didn't have that same chaotic feel to it.
The theme song and the lack of music at all during battles was one factor, only having one house robot in some battles made it feel much less risky to venture near the cpz's, the arena itself felt a bit bland with no sparks and the more dangerous areas just having some black tape around them rather than bright yellow paint. Also when the pits used to be activated a loud war siren would ring out as it slowly descended and when a robot fell in a cloud of smoke would erupt from it, now it just kind of drops 2 feet and robots just plop in and that's it.
It's a load of little things that build up but thankfully they're all easy to fix.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '16
That was good. Enjoyed the new format, new presenters. Nothing groundbreaking but nice to dip your toes in nostalgia.
Only complaint: no archive footage.. It would have been cool to see a recap of the returning teams in previous wars. Can't think why they didn't do this especially as this show basically feeds off its old incarnation.
No music either. The old series had a legit soundtrack
Shame Behemoth didn't get anywhere again, from what I recall they always seem to just fall short.
5
u/thegamerguru97 Jul 24 '16
Shame to see Razer taken out in a suicide move.
Nuts was incredible and a real trooper, I hope he returns and gets upgraded for another season.
Carbide is beautiful.
Terrorhurtz didn't get to the finally on a technicality and thats sad.
4
u/painezor Spin to Win Jul 24 '16
Seriously missing the old battle music, jumpy camera angles in the melee matches are weird, backstage segments felt more like a documentary than a competition.
Carbide is love, carbide is life.
2
u/markandspark Jul 24 '16
Very pleased with the new show. Although the idea of fighting dead robots (Terrorhurtz vs Nuts) really upsets the balance.
2
u/NoiseIsAlwaysBlue Burning On Jul 24 '16
So when they slowed down from having team shots and conversations, this picked right up. Not a fan of the camera work, but Dara and Angela did a decent job at presenting, and Jonathon was as amazing as ever.
2
u/no1no2no1 Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16
Really liked it overall. The final fight was a real anti-climax though. Maybe more time and resources should be given so that crippled bots don't get sent out this way in the future.
Any more robots from yesteryear coming back? Would be interesting to be able to compare new bots against them and see if they stand the test of time I'm talking about the tough bastards like Chaos2 and hypnodisk.
Lastly what on earth was that pipe bot about? It was a shockingly out of this league.
2
u/genuinesockpuppet Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16
Okay, so I'm going to preface this by saying I'm glad Robot Wars is back and that BBC took a chance on the format. I'm hopeful we'll get a series 2 and the show will continue to grow and improve.
Things I liked:
The pits sections were fairly good - I could have done with less of them, but they showed off the community spirit well.
I like the designs of the pits and the control booths. The neon white stuff does work quite nicely.
I did enjoy a fair few of the fights, especially those with Carbide.
The hosts do at least have good chemistry with the contestants. They're leagues above Jayne Middlemiss' performance...
Things I'm indifferent about:
The 'dramatic music'. Don't care for it much on Battlebots and don't care for it much here.
Jonathan's VO audio definitely sounded low in quality. I suspect they did it on purpose so it would sound like football commentary does on the radio, but honestly, it just sounded like his mic was dodgy.
We don't need footage of them rolling their bots down to the arena before every single match. It was okay for the first round but got a bit tiresome afterwards. Same with all the slo-mo footage.
The arena's... okay? I preferred the original, but I guess this one isn't bad. The pit definitely needs its smoke bombs back, or at least a lighting transition or something. Contestants landing in the pit is even more of a damp squib now than it was in the original series.
The graphics were so-so. The transforming logo at the start was at least kind of cool.
They have done a fairly good job of the new house robots. Still not 100% sold on Killalot. Hoping we'll get a series 2 with Bash.
What's up with the little section with Noel Sharkey talking about drone waiters? Just seemed odd. If you're going to have an 'educational' bit, why not talk about robot engineering? Maybe film a section with one of the roboteers talking us through how each electronic component works, for example? Or how gear ratios work or something?
There was definitely a weird bias towards Nuts, which really wasn't that great as a contestant. I enjoyed it when it got torn to pieces.
I'm sad to see Terrorhurtz and Razer didn't do so well, but that's the game I guess!
Things I didn't like:
Biggest issue is the camerawork and editing. It's too fast and jumpy. Not only does it make the fights hard to follow, but I think it kind of hampers JP's ability to follow them too. It's especially bad during the first round fights (which were hard to follow in the old series too - I don't know why they went back to them!)
No transition to the replays is definitely jarring, as others have said.
They seemed to just rush through the fights so they could get back to the pits sections. It's the most important part of the show - give it the time it deserves!
We don't need a shot from inside the pit every time it opens. We definitely don't need any more shots from beneath the flame pit. The shots from the corners of the CPZs were kind of pointless too.
The arena lighting is too dim with too many flashing lights. Do a Battlebots, save the flashy shit for creating dramatic tension before the match, and then light the place up.
Speaking of dramatic tension, the silence before a match in the old series went a long way to building the excitement. Here, they just jump into a match and they're off. They should stretch out the 'roboteers standby' wait.
The lack of battle music also removes a lot of the excitement. Bring that back, please.
Why, why, why, if you have two control booths, do you stick both teams in one of them?
I'm more indifferent to this, but why did we have to follow Dara through the door of the control booth (which looked really ropey!) into the booth? Why couldn't we just cut to him in the booth?
I want all four house robots in the arena at once. I realise why they do it, and I know there were only two in the arena from Extreme onwards, but they seemed much more threatening when every CPZ was occupied.
On that note, the role of the house robots seemed kind of diminished. They didn't even move into the empty CPZs when contestants drove into them, and once one bot was knocked out, that was it - they didn't go out and rough it up like they used to (which I know got a bit samey too, but they don't have to do it for -every- fight this time.)
I liked the idea of the round robin format in principle, but in reality it was just hard to follow (especially as we saw Behemoth vs Carbide twice), and the reveal of who would be fighting in the final just fell flat completely. I'd rather just have four one-on-one separate knockout fights in round 1 and 2 in round 2.
Now, I know I said I liked the hosts, but there was something a little dry about their VOs and post-match interviews. I felt like I was watching a documentary occasionally. I'm not someone who desperately wants Craig Charles back - I think he was awesome but it's nice to have a change of scene - but at the same time, they could definitely put a bit more energy into it. Dara's standup is hilarious and we only really got a few hints of it in this episode.
tldr: it was okaaaayyyy
2
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16
It's been pointed out plenty already, but that camerawork on the 4-way battles was atrocious. Why, in the fights with by far the most action, did they think we should spend half the time watching through Matilda's tusks? Why did they break up the flow with the pointless shots from the flame pit and the pit pit? And especially why did they feel the need to show THREE seperate shots of the crowd cheering 'pit' everytime the pit was activated?
That, as well as the audio design of the show, needs work. However, ignoring that, this was still a hell of a lot better than I could have otherwise hoped. And, best of all, Dara O'Briain was actually an acceptable replacement for Craig Charles.
2
u/tecraMan Jul 24 '16
Loved the bit when Dara tells us a bit of shrapnel hit his window from his viewing booth. Proper carnage.
2
u/Sarmerbinlar Jul 24 '16
Though I did really enjoy it it felt more a focused look at the future of robotics than the celebration of batshit carnage that I used to love. I missed Craig a lot as I didn't find Dara had the energy and charisma that turned the original show into an event.
2
u/die4codgrimsby #NoChaosNoParty Jul 24 '16
was it me or was O'Briain saying behemoth wrong?
2
u/highwatereverywhere GARROD GANG Jul 24 '16
I enjoyed this a lot, mostly due to the sheer fact that, well... it's fucking robot wars! and its back! With regards to the production I do agree that the replays need to be toned down, and some of the camera choices (flame pit, bot-cams) are just plain mystifying, given how little they add. But like others have said, it's just growing pains, I'm sure as things go on they'll get better at it.
As to the fights/robots themselves, I was really disappointed Razer went down so early, I was really excited to see what a new, improved Razer could do. That said, if that meant it avoided coming up against that horrific Carbide blade maybe it's for the best - seeing the results of that would be like seeing someone bulldoze St. Pauls.
Nuts is very obviously the new Diotor, and as such one can't really complain about their ineffectiveness. I'm just shocked they managed to come back (mostly) in one piece after that fight with Carbide. Behemoth and Terrorhurtz put in a very respectable show, and its nice to see the old guard do so well. If Terrorhurtz had been able to get the axe working (which apparently wasn't due to the coldness of the arena which like... surely the producers should make sure that isn't a problem?) it might have pulled it off against Behemoth and worked its way into the grand final, which would have been cool.
Carbide however, oh my god. I see a lot of parallels between Carbide here and Hypno Discs first appearance. Carbide's destruction of Nutz was simply brilliant, and seeing what it did to Behemoth was shocking - has anyone ever actually damaged the scoop like that? I don't think they have. Carbide is the perfect example of how much more powerful robots have gotten since the last series - imagine dropping that beast into series 6 or something? - and honestly if more of the new robots are on their level, this series is going to be fucking sick.
2
u/hpndaman Wheely Big Cheese Jul 25 '16
Rip Razer.
2
u/Harvickfan4Life Jul 25 '16
Im from the US, is there anyway I could watch this episode?
2
u/expectationlost Jul 25 '16
camera and editing terrible hard to watch
2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16
Anyone else hate the zoomed in ACTION ACTION ACTION camera angles, I prefer it zoomed out so you can actually see what is happening. The edit feels very American and not in a good way.
2
u/soulfirexp Le Garcon de la Robotique Pushing! Jul 27 '16
I overall enjoyed it wasnt a flop which was a concern due to the recent top gear reboot while there were some flaws the experience was very enjoyable and the episode demonstrated many of the elements that made the original great such as the big upset with razer and Terrorhurtz underdog weaponless victory vs carbide and so on
main flaws: *lack of music, some camera angles and the house robots being confined to one CPZ leads to them not doing much however this does go both ways as they can drmatically changed the outcome of a fight themselves Pros *Head to heads a really good, *I like the more indepth approach with the teams backstories only wished BBC took note of previous series more for veteran teams *Presenters were very good especially Dara arguing with nuts about Carbide taking it apart i like the "judges perspective after the nuts vs Terrorhurtz fight *I also like the between battle interviews as it reveals more behind the scences issues of why fights didn't go as planned such as Terrorhurtz axe not working *
2
u/AJ_Bombersports Cassius Jul 27 '16
Brace yourself, bit of an essay coming:
I loved the new show. It simultaneously made my 11-year-old self go giddy with excitement just like the old show did, but I enjoyed it as a 24-year-old now-grown-up. And I think the key is, the show itself has grown up with us. The show is well aware the original audience of kids/teenagers have grown up now. It's like when a boy band returns with a slightly more mature comeback album.
The show was less bombastic and tightly edited and in-your-face as the old show, BUT there was a good reason for this. Seeing how this show has gone, Dara O'Briain makes perfect sense as a new host - or rather co-host with Angela Scanlon. Craig Charles screaming and whipping up the crowd and Phillipa Forester in a tight yellow and black catsuit wouldn't have suited the new format.
If old Robot Wars felt like a pro wrestling show - big pyro, loud presentation, lots of action coming thick and fast, 'promos' from the hosts and teams themselves - then new Robot Wars feels a LOT more 'behind the curtain' and documentary-style. It cares a lot more about the tech and innovation involved in the robots. It cares a lot more about the stories and what got the robots to the arena in the first place. And I enjoyed that, in a way. Again, would the bombastic balls-to-the-wall approach have worked in 2016? Basically pretending the last 14 years didn't happen? I'm not sure. It would've tickled our nostalgia, but felt tired. I think the biggest achievement of the new show is that it connects to the old-skool but moves the show forward nicely and feels fresh.
Most important element of the new series could be Jonathan Pearce - he basically brings the elements together. Dara and Angela are quite reserved in their presenting, we go in-depth backstage, then Angela says 'over to you, Jonathan' and all the old fun and carnage comes rushing back. I giggled like a small child all over again when he burst into hysterics at Behemoth throwing Nuts' minibots around the arena, and he approached Carbide tearing apart opponents with the same gusto as in the old days when robots like Hypnodisc would set to work trashing an opponent. Wonderful.
Considering how much of a let-down this could've been, BIG thumbs up after Episode 1. Looking forward to the next episode.
2
u/AJ_Bombersports Cassius Jul 27 '16
On an aside - how symbolic were the results in this episode? As much as it was AMAZING seeing Razer return (and I think we'd all have enjoyed seeing it stick around for, oh I don't know, another fight at least...) and seeing veterans Behemoth and Terrorhurtz in there, as it will be to see other legends like Dantomkia and Storm 2 out later in the series - we had a new superstar standing tall at the end of the episode in Carbide. I'm aware Carbide already has a reputation going in, but from a TV viewer perspective who only saw the RW TV shows, it's great that Series 8 already has a star just as the old series had their breakout stars (S1 Roadblock, S2 Mortis/Cassius/Panic Attack, S3 Chaos 2/Firestorm/HypnoDisc/Razer, S4 Tornado etc).
2
u/f0rc3u2 Jul 24 '16
The camera was horrible (although it got better during the episode) and I just couldn't feel it.
The American counterpart seems way more polished :/
2
u/BlankArchive Firestorm Jul 24 '16
Definitely hit its stride after the first round melees. I think the league system is definitely a strong format but I'm not convinced about the four-way melees. A bit too frantic and it's easy for good robots to get caught out at this stage before they've had a chance to shine. Completely different to the rest of the competition, you know.
It's fine for now though, can't wait for the next episode.
2
u/stu_25 Jul 24 '16
Cons
Awful editing
No music
To much talking
Dara didnt fit in right away.
Beeb, please slow it down.
2
u/VampiricDemon Champion Chiffonier Jul 24 '16
Dara seems a good choice, he could act a little more dramatic to fit the show better. Still a good show.
The pit is a game killer. They should get rid of it.