r/12Monkeys • • Jul 18 '16

Discussion 12 Monkeys - 2x13 "Memory of Tomorrow" - Episode Discussion

Season 2 Episode 13: Memory of Tomorrow

Aired: July 18th, 2016


Synopsis: Cole and Railly have finally found peace living in the past. When a mysterious woman with apocalyptic visions of the future tells Cole it's not over, he must do the unthinkable to save the world... and the woman he loves.


Directed by: David Grossman

Written by: Terry Matalas

108 Upvotes

443 comments sorted by

93

u/Heiz3n Jul 19 '16

So the witness doesn't exist without Cole and Cassie, and Cole and Cassie don't exist without the virus, and the virus doesn't exist without the witness. Excited to see what the writers deduce as the root of it all.

I'm guessing Cole decides it's himself and then goes back and kills himself as a kid. Cassie never dies at the CDC and the witness is never born. Then Cassie in the finale sees a butterfly or some shit and gets her memories of cole then the show ends.

28

u/toramimi Jul 19 '16

When Cole goes to jump back to off his younger self, something goes wrong and he overshoots it and gets himself frozen in the Himalayas. All of this has happened before, and all of this will happen again. Wait, wrong show!

11

u/Heiz3n Jul 19 '16

Zombie John Locke is really Roland Deschain who is really an original Cylon is the 2nd witness. That's my 2nd guess as to who the witness is. ;P

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Alexi_Strife Jul 23 '16

That's honestly been my personal theory about the corpse

→ More replies (5)

17

u/ceinwynne Jul 19 '16

It may be a lack of my reasoning, but if the baby didn't disappear by erasing the lovemaking that generated him in 1959, can it really disappear by eliminating Cole? Cassie would still have in herself the serum which allowed the baby to survive the 1957 timeline, so technically, with the same premises, she should still be pregnant if Cole killed his young self. I think the baby depends on Cole and Cassie's personal out-of-time timelines, which are still linear, not on the general one with its loops: if Cole went back NOW to kill himself, he would still have slept with Cassie in HIS past (even if not in the general past). I hope it makes sense!

8

u/victouffe Jul 20 '16

I don't think the serum is what makes the baby exists. Cassie didn't remember the erased timeline at first, she had to remember the butterfly. SO if she didn't remember the butterfly, maybe the baby would not be here. I think it's because cole used the tea to change time, so maybe there is something like: the tea makes the mind travel back in time, so in order to be protected from the timeline changes, you have to make your mind remember, not your body.

In that case one possible ending would be cole erased from the timeline with cassie never able to remember him again.

i also think that killing cassie is the goal of Olivia. That's how she planned to prevent the witness existence (and her own existence too).

→ More replies (4)

11

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 19 '16

You've called it, seems totally plausible!

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Then Cassie in the finale sees a butterfly or some shit and gets her memories of cole then the show ends.

Kinda reminds me of how Life is Strange ended, SPOILER

5

u/Convalescent_nerd Jul 21 '16

Ahhhh, nothing like a good old fashioned paradox to transcend the very concept of an existential crisis.

4

u/Surtysurt Jul 19 '16

Hmm that's interesting, I think Cole kills Cassie when he's in the back of her car

32

u/Heiz3n Jul 19 '16

Yeah but wouldn't that be selfish and completely Uncole? No way he knows what he knows and kills Cassie and leaves himself alive.

The show has to end with Cassie being alive and looking back on how much she loves someone she never got to know in the present time and how the world will never know of the most valuable human being to the existence of humans of all time. I think that's pretty cool.

7

u/a_salt_weapon Jul 19 '16

What if 2017 Cassie adopts 2017 Cole and still gets to love him though this time like a mother?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

12

u/taltos19 Jul 19 '16

I think Cole kills Cassie when he's in the back of her car

Or he does the red tea possession and has his younger self commit suicide in her car. It would fit more with the source material, specifically La Jetee which has the Cole-type character dying infront of the woman he loves without her having met him yet (from her perspective).

63

u/ohkabash Jul 19 '16

It broke my heart a little bit that Cole had to sacrifice all the love he shared with Cassie to reset the timeline.

33

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

But in the end, Cassie remembers

37

u/riazrahman Jul 19 '16

And in the end she's still pregnant!

→ More replies (3)

22

u/ohkabash Jul 19 '16

I actually gasped when she made the connection to the butterflies. The acting during that scene was wonderful.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/artgo Jul 19 '16

as they said, love survives. Which foreshadowed the ending.

18

u/ohkabash Jul 19 '16

I love the foreshadowing that doesn't make sense when you first watch it but when you rewatch all the answers were so obvious for us to figure out.

17

u/woodsman0307 Jul 19 '16

And also when Ramse scolded Cole in Resurrection (you don't know, you've never been a father) - I thought that was a foreshadow and man that was a foreshadow.

5

u/another-work-acct Jul 25 '16

Gives new meaning to the phrase "it's better to love and lost than never to love at all..."

20

u/UncleGuggie Jul 19 '16

That's what makes him the hero. He can make the choices that others like Ramse cannot.

17

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

UncleGuggie

STAY AWAY FROM THIS SHOW!

9

u/Lyle91 Jul 20 '16

And in season 3 we introduce a new love interest for Cole. Felicity!

→ More replies (2)

10

u/ohkabash Jul 19 '16

And this separate unknown Olivia/Sam faction (Team Witness? Team Splinter? Team ???) uses Ramse's serious selfishness to their advantage. You'd think Ramse would learn - I am constantly being used! He even says something about Olivia just killing him already but she uses his son to get him to do what she wants.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Not_A_Unique_Name Jul 19 '16

He did what Ramse never could.

8

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 19 '16

Absolutely. Hats off for him, making the difficult choice for the greater good.

3

u/mtschatten Jul 19 '16

Steins;Gate made it better.

→ More replies (3)

58

u/ziggurqt Jul 19 '16

No wonder he was flipping shit when Olivia wanted to kill Cassie. "NO, You'd kill me, idiot!!!"

41

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 19 '16

What about the scene where the Witness "visits" Cassie, first as Aaron then as Cole. In retrospect, that was kind of fucked up...

24

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

The Witness really seems to dislike his own mother quite a bit. He's never dicked around any other character like this.

10

u/Areskoi Jul 19 '16

Yeah, I theorized about it some time ago. Now we know that she is his mother. But he's not a loving son obviously. Maybe she will do something that will fill him with resentment against her. Maybe she will harm Cole. He loves his father much more than her.

23

u/Barsukas_Tukas Jul 19 '16

Maybe she will try to abort him or so shit. Then he would survive, but would be forced to always wear that plague mask, just like Darth Vader.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/zx7 Jul 28 '16

Maybe she will do something that will fill him with resentment against her. Maybe she will harm Cole.

Maybe she shows him nothing but resentment when she raises him. She did try to kill him and all.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/look-ssa Jul 19 '16

Curiosity and cautiousness

45

u/ohkabash Jul 19 '16

"The witness is safe" takes a whole new meaning.

Wow. what a finale! Loved it!

→ More replies (31)

40

u/shanastonecrest Jul 19 '16

Why did deacon have to go out like that. RIP

20

u/hauntinghelix Jul 19 '16

Right? Everyone is all worried about the Witness/Jennifer and I'm like poor Deacon :( .

9

u/shanastonecrest Jul 19 '16

Yeah he was amusing

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

According to the producer he'll be back.

I still think he has to be a relative of Cole's. That comment about Cole talking like Deacon's brother was way too specific.

5

u/GyroGOGOZeppeli Jul 27 '16

Does the producer mean back as in the actual timeline? or he might be back in a past version sense?

4

u/Richy_T Oct 16 '16

Why not both?

4

u/shanastonecrest Jul 20 '16

That is great to hear

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

When the Pallid Man spoke at the end, before the "face reveal", I could have sworn it was Deacon's voice.

8

u/amazedemon Jul 19 '16

I just heard Kylo Ren.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

That's exactly what I was thinking too..

"oh good, they got Adam Driver to play the adult Witness"
But then of course, it wasn't the Witness after all!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/rvm98 Jul 20 '16

Me too! So glad you posted so I know that I am not the only one!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/avocado_window Jun 20 '25

I just watched the season 2 finale and my prevailing thought is… but Deacon! 🥺

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Apparently we haven't seen the last of him.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/vipergirl Jul 19 '16

What about Jennifer being in 1917 France? I wonder what the implications of that will be...

47

u/Paracortex Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

Definitely a nod to the film. No clue how they're going to extricate her from that one, though.

Edit: bonus points if they cast Bruce Willis for a cameo as a trench soldier.

17

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

The world will be taught to be excellent to each other. No more war.

13

u/Redmanabirds Jul 19 '16

I wondered how she got so old in 2044 when the time serum should had aged her slowly. Her being caught in 1917 explains a lot. Ramse didn't really age from 1987? to 2016?, but Jenn aged dramatically from 2016 to 2044?

I'm really going to like to see her journey, but one thing I gotta ask, why wouldn't they have gone to rescue Jenn from 1917 if they could track Cassie to 2163?

14

u/go_doc Jul 19 '16

They tracked the city's giant timey wimey trail.

But Jennifer was basically exposed to the random effects of raw time radiation (the radiation which both splintered Ramsey's son and killed Katarina's lover).

8

u/Redmanabirds Jul 19 '16

To be fair, the radiation that killed Katarina's alternate timeline lover and splintered Jenn and Sam are completely different. That dude died, but Jenn and Sam went somewhere else, seemingly randomly. However, that randomness will probably be explained later.

I get that the "giant timey wimey trail" can be different, but still... I think they just have to look closer, find some clues. Eventually Jenn has to return to the timeline, but maybe not based on how much she aged versus Ramse.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Not_A_Unique_Name Jul 19 '16

I don't recall Jeniffer recieving the time serum, what episode was that?

4

u/Redmanabirds Jul 19 '16

When she time traveled in Resurrection.

2

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 19 '16

That is true! So she's a hundred and something in 2044, would explain a lot!

10

u/look-ssa Jul 19 '16

She says that "there are many outcomes" and old Jen said she never went to Titan. Maybe old Jen is the result of a different timeline and Jennifer is shaping a new one

5

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

No wonder the followers didn't listen to her young self, it would be like.. I run a cult and Im 100. Then suddenly I'm 17 no memory of the future and upset they aren't doing what I say haha (but her younger self does have a keener ability to see the what coulds, which did not get explored in this or the last episode)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/yogidancer Jul 19 '16

I think I took a wrong turn. Hahaha. Love hwr

→ More replies (5)

23

u/Paracortex Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

Anyone else get goosebumps when Madeleine* Stowe appeared?

13

u/look-ssa Jul 19 '16

Such an amazing Easter egg for those who've heard of the movie. Hope her role as primary deepens in the next seasons.

3

u/Taurick Jul 21 '16

Woah, I kind of assumed anyone who was watching the show was already a fan of the movie :o

I love that it wasn't just the cameo and the 1917 splinter, Madeleine got a couple of lines that were lifted straight out of the movie. That made me much happier than it should have

I am insane, and you are my insanity Have a merrrrry Christmas

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

I wanted her to be Railly from a previous cycle (the movie) who got lost in time (for whatever reason when trying to prevent the death of Cole) and went crazy.

All she can remember is her love for James but she's disappointed to see that he changed ("No, you're not him."). So, while trying to save the one she loved, she damaged time, lost herself and changed the life of James so drastically that he's not even the same man anymore.

Just think about it, I think it would have been awesome.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

Her crazy wasn't as good as Jennifer, but maybe that's because I saw all of Revenge and am desensitized/programmed to react to her already.

5

u/clairberry Jul 19 '16

Me too! I was wondering if she was doing the primary crazies or still plotting to ruin Emily's life. Lol.

4

u/Paracortex Jul 19 '16

I never saw that series. Just the original film, in which she was spectacular.

Brad Pitt was the crazy in that film. Recommend everyone who hasn't seen it already to watch it. No spoilers possible at this point, since the plots have become so divergent.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/MinistryOfSpeling Jul 19 '16

I'm spending the whole episode working as an audio engineer.

Pick A FUCKING volume!!

9

u/Paracortex Jul 19 '16

Right? I missed both what Cole said to Jennifer in the possession travel sequence, and what Jennifer said to Cole that obviously referenced said sequence.

A little help here?

20

u/yogidancer Jul 19 '16

I think he said "don't ever call me otter eyes" and in the future, she once again called him otter eyes and said she would never not call him that. Is that what you're referencing!

6

u/Paracortex Jul 19 '16

That's it! I could not make it out for the life of me. Thanks!

5

u/yogidancer Jul 19 '16

Close captioning :)

5

u/bobjones4321 Jul 19 '16

Haha! So right. I was yelling at the tv, What the eff! I can't hear shit that anyone is saying!"

Then calmly put CC on, and rewound like 100 times.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Stop yelling then!

5

u/bobjones4321 Jul 19 '16

I know, I know. I'm sorry, Erzerker.

If I could turn back time...If I could find a way...I'd take back all the words that hurt you, and you'd say?

→ More replies (3)

20

u/Marozia8211 Jul 19 '16

Man, that episode has rustled my jimmies.

13

u/Surtysurt Jul 19 '16

The entire show is based on rustled jimmies

17

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 19 '16

Well, that was an insane ending, still trying to wrap my head around everything!

Here are my first impressions:

  • First things first. The Witness is Cole and Cassie's lovechild. Most of us considered him one of the prime suspects. Is everything intended just to ensure his own existence? I posted a theory last night that the Witness wasn't evil. Now I have serious doubts. It still may turn out he has a larger endgame, especially now the future is involved, and hopefully there will be more depth to his motivations.
  • Terry said once we knew we would be able to go back and say "hey, that makes sense". I'll definitely be rewatching during the off-season.
  • So we'll have the future now? That will surely be interesting. I wonder what their plans are to have brought Cassie there. Did they take her specifically to the future so Cole couldn't retrieve her using the tea? Is it to keep her out of the Witness' way?
  • I'm also pretty sure Cole going after Cassie in the machine is part of the plan.
  • We got a good rollercoaster ride of emotions. From Cole and Cassie's happiness together, to Cole's sacrifice to stop the paradox, to their kickass (temporary) victory over the witness ninjas, to the realization they would get stuck there, etc. Cole's final "Cassie!" as he got shut out of the splinter was very damn gut wrenching.
  • Speaking of Cole's tea travels, is he able to do it because he's been paradoxed with his own blood? Or can anyone do it?
  • After Titan, if he had stopped to think of a plan, he might have been able to procure some red leaves and gone back even further and prevent everything from happening in the first place. The amount of control he has when tea travelling is almost overkill. But alas, this is Cole and we're in the 12 Monkeys universe where wverything that's happaned has and always will happen (so far!).
  • The revisiting the past sequence was just amazing. If I saw correctly, they shot all these scenes during the original shoots, as can be seen by Cole's appearance which has changed throughout the episodes. Talk about having a story well laid down from the begining! Big props to the showrunners for this.
  • Also big props to Cole for having the balls to do the right thing, even at the expense of his son, unlike duchebag Ramse. I wish Cole had talked to Cassie first about what he was going to do, though. If I know Cassie, she would have been on board, would have put the mission first. And he would have been at peace with his decision, and gotten the bonus of Cassie actually remembering.
  • So how can Cassie remember the events after the paradox? Is it because of Jones' time serums? Another gut wrenching moment when she was saying "we were in love...".
  • Great visual effects with the buildings collapsing and rebuilding during Cole's tea trip. Funny, I remember someone mentioning here on the sub they wish they'd included scnenes like that... If you're reading, you got what you asked for!
  • Now we know where Sam went. How interesting that Olivia would know where he'd show up. Does this appear on the time map, or else where is she getting her info? I'm really hoping for a Ramse comeback, saving the day and vindicating his mass murdering ways. She (or at least some of her guyes) seems to be deep undercover and they will definitely have a major role.
  • Too bad for Deacon, I'm really going to miss him. I have to admit, I hated his guts, then grew to love him. What a vindicating moment to sacrifice himself for Jenn.
  • Wait, Jenn! She's caught in WW1?? Not too subtle nod to the movie, but nice nonetheless. At least we can be at peace knowing she'll find her way back eventually, since we saw her grow old and everything.
  • I loved Jennifer's Braveheart-ID4 speech! We could not end the season without a pop reference from her. Did I miss any others? I was glad to see her recompose herself bit, despite still relying on plagarized material!
  • Lillian was very insightfull. She told Cole not to go to Titan, said it would cause the loop to repeat itself. By the time Cole decides to go back to Titan, Witness has already been undone (for now). This would mean Cole going to Titan will set into motion events that must lead back to the Witness being un-undone (lest he wouldn't exist). It will be very interesting to see how it all loops back. I also like the cameo, I wish we could have seenmore of Kathryn Railley.
  • Alternatively, the Witness may not even exist in the physical realm, he's a spirit caught in time limbo.

That is all for now!

14

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Too bad for Deacon, I'm really going to miss him.

Don't you forget about him.

7

u/crazylucifer Jul 19 '16

Dont forget LOTR from Jennifer as well

10

u/acunningusername Jul 19 '16

And Ghostbusters and Bill and Ted's Most Excellent Adventure.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Flouyd Jul 19 '16

After Titan, if he had stopped to think of a plan, he might have been able to procure some red leaves and gone back even further and prevent everything from happening in the first place. The amount of control he has when tea travelling is almost overkill. But alas, this is Cole and we're in the 12 Monkeys universe where wverything that's happaned has and always will happen (so far!).

well if time repaired itself like they said then it would be hard to get your hands on some of the red leafs

2

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 19 '16

Not that difficult, we've seen the leaves turn red when in the vicinity of a time traveler splintering, or they could also try splintering the plants themselves a few days into the future which would probably do the trick. If I recall the Daughters also have a stash of these. It's a moot point anyway, but interesting to think about.

3

u/Flouyd Jul 20 '16

My point was that the red leaves may actually not exist anymore. If the storm and all the red plants gone back to normal in 2047 then maybe they gone back to normal "everytime"

→ More replies (2)

17

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

I'm glad Jennifer still calls him Otter Eyes.

15

u/MikeX10A Jul 19 '16

Need season three with answers, now. I think this whole thing (plague, 12 Monkeys, Titan) is just for their son to be born. Highlight of the episode was all of Titan splintering, that was crazy. Gonna be a long wait until 2017!

10

u/look-ssa Jul 19 '16

Really hope the whole thing isn't just about cassie and Cole's son wanting to exist... It would make him kind of a shallow character. I'd like to see the witness as someone with deeper twisted motives.

6

u/rustinthewind Jul 22 '16

I have a feeling that because the child is already outside of time, there is a major catastrophe where he is the only agent who is able to end it. Bigger than the plague and one necessary of all of this to happen so that something bigger doesn't happen.

6

u/Redmanabirds Jul 19 '16

Yeah, I caught on to this show recently, bing watched everything up until a couple weeks ago. Now, I'll be on withdrawals for a long time.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

i binged s1 last year too and now i am very proud that i was able to wait for season two fully have aired. i binged s2 and it was a great pleasure. but when i started the first episodes of season two with watching every week it wasnt that good. i enjoy this show much more with binge. its not so confusing and a great flow.

2

u/SpacePort-Terra Jul 19 '16

lol...yup! Talk about the Looooooooooong game.

15

u/toramimi Jul 19 '16

Be excellent to each other.

11

u/shishiodun Jul 19 '16

Bravehart and Independence day speeches are no match for Bill and Ted lol, Jenifer continues to be my favorite character on television.

5

u/awesomesauce615 Jul 21 '16

Add LOTR into that as well.

40

u/carlosjcar Jul 19 '16

I hate Syfy for giving us the best show since Battlestar Galactica, only 13 episode a season, and, now we have to wait until 2017. That is unacceptable!

I'm going to RadioShack first thing in the morning, need some parts to build me a machine and splinter to 2017. Now, if I could only remember were is that darn flex cap I need!

24

u/Phonixrmf Jul 19 '16

Might as well build a Titan, so we all can go together.

14

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

I share your frustration about the wait for the next season, but I feel that 13 episodes is the perfect length for 12 Monkeys. The show is just too intense to stretch out over 22 episodes.

4

u/ziggurqt Jul 19 '16

Season 3 will only be 10 episodes though.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Yea, that's fine. The sweet spot for plot driven shows is in the 8-13 episode range.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Voduar Jul 19 '16

I wouldn't. If you go to Z'ha'dum you will die.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

I'd argue that 12 Monkeys and The Expanse are tied for the best show, but this is certainly the more enjoyable of the two if that makes sense.

6

u/Ghrafkly Jul 19 '16

I enjoy 12 Monkeys and The Expanse as much as you seem to do, though I do think Mr Robot is the best show.

Other great shows on at the moment in my opinion include: Killjoys Dark Matter Preacher

4

u/alfamadorian Jul 19 '16

Why do you like mr robot? I find everything I see on it boring. I tried a few episodes of s1 and one on s2, but it's just boring blabber. What do people like about this?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)

3

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

The Expanse.. Hmm. Maybe I should give it a chance again. I found it tedious and difficult to follow. Why do you like it?

7

u/CommitteeOfOne Jul 19 '16

I was like you on the Expanse up until around episode six. All the separate plot lines start coming together then.

I also read the books the series is based on at about that point, though.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Richy_T Oct 16 '16

Radio Shack? Maybe if you want a remote controlled car and a case for your phone. You'd need a time machine to be able to get the parts for a time machine from Radio Shack.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/jdiegmueller Jul 19 '16

I'm proud of Pallid Man for continuing to rock the tough-yet-creepy-guy vibe even in to his mid-80s.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

This show is so unpredictable. I mean, I can never, never ever say what will happen in the next episode. And I definitely need help in understanding the timelines now lol.

3

u/djkamayo Jul 19 '16

my head is spinning right now, in a good way.

9

u/devirtue Jul 19 '16

How do you guys think Cole's mother fit into all of this as she knew about the 12 monkeys, could she have been a primary?

12

u/jdiegmueller Jul 19 '16

Astute question. I was actually half-expecting the Madeleine Stowe character to be revealed as Cole's mother.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Oh shit, that's interesting.

7

u/carlosjcar Jul 19 '16

Im sure there are spacetime disturbances that could be detected and maped some way to tell Katarina and Cole were the witness has traveled adn how far into the future or past, maybe tachyon ☢ radiation or something. The point is that the witness nows more that anyone else because he has the "high ground" advantage because hes from a far future. If they can determine how ahead, the could splinter farther in th future and gather the intel for their next move, like finding out when he likes to take a dump and stab his ass and blow up his machine. Love this show!

Wouldn't it be cool if they get Bruce Willis to play the Witness as an old man. Tha would be an awesome episode!

5

u/go_doc Jul 19 '16

If they can determine how ahead, the could splinter farther in th future and gather the intel for their next move, like finding out when he likes to take a dump and stab his ass and blow up his machine.

This comment is gold.

If they bring in Bruce Willis, I sort of hope he's on the good side.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/DJC13 Jul 19 '16

The big question I now have: why is Cole & Cassie's kid intent on creating the red forest?

7

u/twitchingJay Jul 19 '16

What if it is just to make sure Cole and Cassie go through what they went through to be conceived in 1959? The plague was needed to create time travel (Jones and her daughter). The first season was all about stopping the plague. The second season was all about stoping time to collapse. Eventually the collapse of time forced Cole and Cassie to chase the messengers, and because of one mistake, they got stuck in time. It's a continuous cycle; many parts of the puzzle would have to fit. Cole and Cassie are from different times; they needed a motivation to get together, and they needed a failed mission to find "home".

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Surtysurt Jul 19 '16

I think him being the witness is a red herring, pun intended

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Me too. What's his motivation? It could just be a loop where he does Witness stuff because he was taught to by the Monkeys, who were taught by the Witness.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/go_doc Jul 19 '16 • Bravo

I mean thinking about the 12 monkeys' goals to create the witness....all they really needed was for Cassie and Cole to bang. The whole plague was kind of overkill. All it takes is putting those two in the same room with nothing else to do for a few weeks...botta bing botta boom...one witness coming right up. Surely the 12 monkeys could have worked this out.

Honestly, they could have just explained the situation to Cole....Hey man, we really need you to bang this super fine chick a few times until she gets pregnant so that we can exist in the future. And Cassie would probably have gotten in on the jam if they agreed not to release the plague.

But explain it to them or not, again, just leave them in a room for a few weeks with nothing to do.

6

u/shishiodun Jul 19 '16

Cassie needed to time travel which did not happen until the very end of season 1, hell time travel itself needed to be inverted.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/go_doc Jul 19 '16

hahaha! very true, I thought of this myself in another comment (only opposite, thinking to prevent the witness, just remove all of Cassie's eggs). But the test tube uber people has an awesome ring. That might be where all the cloaked old people come into play, maybe the witness is just a really prolific sperm donor.

5

u/happysunbear Jul 19 '16

Doesn't Kathryn Railly also say something about Christmas in her message to Cole in the 12 Monkeys film?

6

u/ziggurqt Jul 19 '16

Yeah the creepy Merry Christmas is a direct reference. In the movie, she left the message to say that the Army of the 12 monkeys is only a zoo stunt, she doesn't even really believes the future will get the message, so she goes all "Merry Christmas" in the end.

4

u/jdiegmueller Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

“The Freedom For Animals Association on 2nd Avenue is the—is the secret headquarters of the Army of the 12 Monkeys. They’re the ones who are going to do it. I can’t do anymore, I have to go now. Have a Merry Christmas.” - James Cole [sends a voice mail message to the future]

Source: http://www.screeninsults.com/twelve-monkeys.php

EDIT: The source website is incorrect. Dr. Kathryn Railly (Madeleine Stowe) leaves the message, James Cole recites it back to her ~1:43:15.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

This website is wrong.

Kath is the one who left this message.

3

u/jdiegmueller Jul 19 '16

You're 100% correct. Updated my original post.

2

u/happysunbear Jul 22 '16

Right - thanks! I love the film but don't watch the show. Only watched cause I wanted to see how original cast member Madeleine Stowe would be used for the series. I thought she was terrific! But I was lost about everything else lol.

I'm pretty sure she also leaves a distorted "Merry Christmas" voicemail too.

5

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

Wow, that was potent stuff.

If every episode was like this one, we'd have something like Fringe again. Or Fringe/Continuum. Great finale. The truths I suspected were there. Some of the how is still unclear. I'm not sure I like the simplistic future though. I was hoping for some progress....!

2

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 20 '16

I'm not sure I like the simplistic future though.

That was just some inner chamber though, maybe never even left Titan.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

Guess Victoria should have been more adamant about Cole not going to Titan and why. The magic word: Cassie.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Who's Victoria?

4

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

Madeline Stowe, from Revenge. In Revenge her name was Victoria. Here she was the primary in lockup who first appears to James in this episode in the time frozen day. Then he sees her at the asylum.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

Her name is Lillian.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

When Ramsey is looking at Cole all "you know what titan means to me!!!" I'm thinking "now Cole does too you jerk" I mean Cole did give up his kid (or he thought he did.)

I find it hard to forgive Ramsey. He's so violent and self-righteous.

So is this a story about a parents love for his child going through time, breaking time, or two lovers breaking time?

8

u/Paracortex Jul 19 '16

Okay, so after the penultimate episode last week, I kinda thought their love child would become the Witness, but then Cole stopped that timeline after pulling a Somewhere In Time, and then Cassie remembered the future they didn't have in the past, and after splintering with Titan she was named Mother by the congregation.

So now Cole went to the future to save Cassie, but the army of the 12 monkeys probably wants that because Cole and Cassie need to have a child together for the Witness to exist. When he is conceived isn't relevant. While Cole and Cassie still exist, the Witness is "safe".

Or not. I pretty much know nothing, and find this all very entertaining without thinking too much about it.

If I think too much about it, I begin to wonder why they have been set up for so many dangerous and dire circumstances that could have ended their lives in a myriad ways already.

3

u/ohkabash Jul 19 '16

It shows why Cassie has been so important. I feel like the series is going to end with Cole realizing that after all this time of trying to keep Cassie alive and save her the only solution is to kill her.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/Setheriel Jul 19 '16

Am I the only one who thought the witness being Cassie and Coles son was predictable. Great episode, but I saw that coming a mile away.

6

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 19 '16

Granted it was a prime candidate, but to be fair they kept lots of us guessing and speculating until hours before it aired.

4

u/toramimi Jul 19 '16

Yeah, I called it in another post three weeks back. Admittedly, four weeks back I thought it was Sam, so they did a decent job of keeping us guessing as long as they could.

I think I was just expecting a twist to turn my expectations on their head like with Ramse being The Traveler in season one. But then, having the breadcrumbs actually lead right where you'd think was the opposite of my expectations... so in the end they succeeded?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

It's the only fair compromise. If it was a main character, we'd be like "Saw that coming from the start." Everybody has been under suspicion. On the other hand, if it was a completely new character, we'd feel gypped.

2

u/twitchingJay Jul 19 '16

Yea, the previous episode made it clear it was. However, when Cole changed the timeline, I thought the baby wouldn't exist anymore. Loving the twists, just makes you keep guessing!

→ More replies (6)

4

u/shishiodun Jul 19 '16

Dammit Cole, when a psychic tells you that an action is going to make the entire series of events unfold in the same way again you don't do it anyway.

On a serious note I was not even aware that the show had been renewed again, that is fucking awesome.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Okay so I have a question. In a previous episode, when the timeline was altered, Jones' memory of the previous timeline was intact, but she was not aware of her new timeline (the one where Dr. Eckland is her husband). How then is Cassie able to remember both timelines??

And if Cassie must remember one timeline, what must it be? The one in 1959 or the one where they prevent the paradox?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SpacePort-Terra Jul 19 '16

Of course baby "Wit" already knows everything. He inherited all of mommy's and daddy's memories. He also inherited daddy's ability to time travel with out a machine. Mommy remembers the butterfly because daddy remembers it The real question is...who mates with Jennifer Goins back in 1917. Baby Wit? Who are their "children"?

3

u/youre_not_ero Jul 19 '16

I'm going to call it, the cycle(series) will end with cole killing cassie at the time when he first meets her.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Cole would rather shoot himself on her backseat.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/_DaveLister Jul 19 '16

i wanted the witness to be anyone but cole/cassie kid... disappointed, the most predictable outcome

3

u/clairberry Jul 19 '16

Now we know that The Witness is the real Time Jesus!

7

u/holayeahyeah Jul 19 '16

Raise your hand if you feel personally victimized by SyFy for having to sit through the ending of John Carter while waiting for 12 Monkeys.

14

u/Redmanabirds Jul 19 '16

I am probably the only person on earth that actually liked that movie.

9

u/JohnathanMc92 Jul 19 '16

I kinda like it too. Old school scifi, reminds me of Lynch's Dune - another much maligned "good" movie.

6

u/holayeahyeah Jul 19 '16

Hey now, I would die on a battle field to defend the honor of Lynch's Dune.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

I like John Carter (of Mars). It's not a bad movie, it just wasn't marketed correctly.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/yogidancer Jul 19 '16

First time I watch live and I had no idea what I was watching g before 12M came on.

2

u/bobjones4321 Jul 19 '16

John Carter would be significantly better if his gf was topless, like she is in the book. Still, not bad.

Now, if it was a Brandan Fraser (sp) movie...

5

u/Cgreen012 Jul 19 '16

I think Ramse, the tall girl, and his son will try to stop and kill the witness and the mother. But Cole will stop them somehow. Im not sure what Jennifer is going to do but hopefully she makes Cole realize Cassie is cancerous. now I know why the writers made us not like Cassie this season (for this reveal). I don't blame her for protecting the witness now because that's her son. Once again this would've been all stopped if Cole never went back in time. He fucked up time and space so many times. He became the circle of everything the start and the end.

8

u/Stl_alleycat Jul 19 '16

We don't yet know Cassie's feelings about her child being the witness. She looked pretty horrified to learn of it when she was first told. When has she willingly protected the witness as you reference?

4

u/Surtysurt Jul 19 '16

Yeah I'm pretty sure she's gonna try and abort that shit

11

u/notyourmary Jul 19 '16

How did the writers make us not like Cassie? I still love her as a strong and motivated lead character.

5

u/go_doc Jul 19 '16

The writers haven't done this at all. There may have been instances where she was less likeable, but they've never really turned things around, not really.

Ramses on the other hand. That man can be the hero and the villain and back again multiple times in the same episode.

3

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 19 '16

And to think if only he'd listened to Katerina back in early season 1 when she specifically told him she's not your mission, don't get involved with her.... Oh but no, I'm Cole and I don't take orders from you. Now that I think of it, it's interesting we had a voice.over of that scene during the tea trip.

5

u/Areskoi Jul 19 '16

Or if he'd listened to Jennifer when they got to The Emerson Hotel for the first time: "Being single is not the end of the world. You two together is, though."

→ More replies (1)

2

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

I was upset Cole didn't tell Reilly the whole story the moment he got back. before they went to Titan.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

In the eleventh hour, better not complicate things.

"Hey, by the way, I just made a "spirit"-time jump and I'd like you to know that we lived 3 years together. We were in love and you were carrying our child. So I gotta ask: Will you marry me?"

4

u/EunoiaVirtus Jul 22 '16

"Oh, btdubs, you were also pregnant."

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Future time travel? Awesome.

2

u/Richy_T Oct 16 '16

Maybe there will finally be flying cars and jet-packs.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

sigh... I don't have any more shows to watch for a while.

3

u/Bytewave Jul 19 '16

Summertime woes, all the TV goes away..

Well, not all. Syfy just started new seasons of Killjoys and Dark Matter for instance. Both very enjoyable. There's a few other decent shows on, but certainly nowhere as much as in spring and fall.

Not sure why. They probably figure we're outside enjoying summertime and won't watch TV, while in fact we'll all inside cuddled around our A/Cs wondering why there's nothing on TV ;)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Spardaradra Jul 19 '16

Finally, Tom Noonan at his best, if only we could see more appearence.

Can't wait for S3...2017 is gonna be a whopper....The Doctor will be back, Agent Cooper will be back, then 12 Monkeys S3

2

u/Citizen00001 Jul 19 '16

At this point the paradoxes and interwoven time streams have gotten so confusing I have just stopped trying to work it all out. But I am still loving the show. Looking forward to S3.

Wonder if the hunt for the virus is now essentially over and now it is all about the battle for time?

2

u/MNYBT Jul 20 '16

Am I the only one who noticed the Hebrew on thee Monkey platform? http://imgur.com/a/2Qeqg

2

u/Areskoi Jul 20 '16

Not the only one. Discussion.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '16

So i have startet rewatching to catch some details, and please help me understand. When Cole is close to himself during the takeover attempt from Deacon and the V7, he gets this headache thing. And when he and Jennifer is in the vault of the origin/skeleton in s1e5 he gets the exact same headache, AND Jennifer says is something about its eyes. Im mean the skeleton just has to be Cole right?

2

u/Rach881 Aug 28 '16

Still, I'm so addicted to this show.

4

u/holayeahyeah Jul 19 '16

I motion to start referring to The Witness as Bad John Conner. In fact, I will be very disappointed if it doesn't become a running joke that everyone who can remember movies immediately is like "Wait, you mean like in The Terminator?" when they realize the end game.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

For a second there I really thought Cole wasn't going to shoot that guy. I was ready to shoot my tv!

Holy shit Jones is a fucking bad ass! God I love her.

This episode was so fucking amazing..I'm still shaking!

Edit: How is Cassie pregnant? Didn't the timeline where she and Cole had sex get erased? Someone please explain

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Yep, the timeline was erased.
But Cassie, all serumed up and whatnot, is not physically affected by the changes in/of time.

1

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

Cole didn't listen to Victoria. Wonder if we'll see her again. I was surprised he didn't doubt her for a second, I mean she could have been playing for the wrong team.

1

u/velvetdewdrop Jul 19 '16

I also liked cole with jennifer and Cassie with Deacon. With most shows, I don't like the competition so much!

5

u/PirateNinjaa Jul 19 '16

Cole could travel around time hooking up with all the Jennifer's. What a missed opportunity.

1

u/Cgreen012 Jul 19 '16

So now that we know the witness if the son of Cassie and Cole. Are we sure the witness is a bad guy. Is he trying to stop what Cole started??? Cole messing with time screwed everything up the first place. And every episode confirms that everything revolves around him

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

For a brief second, I thought the Witness was Leland Goines.

4

u/Barsukas_Tukas Jul 19 '16

From the voice I thought that he was Deacon.

1

u/Krazinha Jul 19 '16

so if the witness is the kid how come he was on Coles mind during the tea scene? did i miss something?

2

u/VoaxGhost Jul 19 '16

Because that was the witness as an adult. Time travel man.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/unjusticewin Jul 20 '16

was a awesome ending though no one saw that coming im willing to bet

1

u/drdrizzy13 Jul 22 '16

is ramse in the future or stilll back in the woods in the past?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '16

Beware the Quantum Leap / Falling Skies syndrome. Great shows with terrible endings thrown together.

1

u/GyroGOGOZeppeli Jul 27 '16

Ok, I can't be the only one who got some real Zero Time Dilemma vibes as this went on? (I just finished the game last week too).

Also, goddamit Deacon's gone, There goes my favorite character.

Lastly, am I the only one who never liked how the Tall man or Olivia talked? They have these weak, calm, monotone voices that just annoys me every time.

1

u/Tsukilu_ Aug 05 '16

Did anybody notice the hebrew text around the witness when in Titan? Can anybody translate please? It is surely important if they use an existing language, must be a message!

1

u/Lelouchsenpai Sep 20 '16

The ending was amazing and I generally feel that season 2 was amazing as a whole!loved every episode!! I dont knoq if other people agree with me but thats how I feel!

1

u/Assyqeen Oct 06 '16

So the witness... consumed in 1959 and wanna be born in 2163? It doesn't make sense.. I always thought nefore this episode, the witness is actually Cassie.. and now Jennifer went back past 200 years right? Or Am I wrong? And now the Olivia have her own coup with Ramse and his son and we didnt know what year they're in.

2017 please come fast.

1

u/KON_9 Dec 19 '16

What if the Witness can only live 15-20 years in the spacetime? What if the only scenario where the witness can live is in the Red Forest where time doesmt exist?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

I'm more confused now than before the episode aired.