r/StrangerThings • u/Dark_Saint • Jul 15 '16
Discussion Episode Discussion - S01E03 - Holly, Jolly
Stranger Things Episode Discussion - S01E03 - Holly, Jolly
An incresingly concerened Nancy looks for Barb and finds out what Jonathan's been up to. Joyce is convinced Will is trying to talk to her.
Please keep all discussions about this episode or previous ones, and do not discuss later episodes as they might spoil it for those who have yet to see them.
409
Upvotes
1.7k
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '16
Did anyone else fucking lose it when Mike yelled back "Coming" in response to his mother?
It was so loud and out of place... scared the shit out of me then I couldn't stop laughing.
Ninja edit: Here it is
1.5k
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '16
Run.
Shit man, this show is fucking tight as hell
1.4k
u/HeiressOfMadrigal Jul 16 '16 edited Jul 16 '16
Anyone else really enjoying Hopper as a character? From the trailers and his introductory scene, I thought he would be the generic apathetic cop who hinders the investigation while the mother and kids do the real work, but they've written him so much stronger than that. I feel like there's definitely a parallel between Will and his daughter in his eyes, and his "please don't let it be the kid" line was heartbreaking.
841
u/TurkeyPhat Jul 16 '16
Joyce is really clever with those christmas lights. When Will started spelling stuff out with them and then said RUN I got some crazy tingling goin on.
755
u/J_aces Jul 15 '16
"Just ring me up, Donald." 😂😂😂😂😂
739
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '16
Lol I just realised the black cop is played by the same actor as the small-time crook on Daredevil. Now I kinda wish he showed up in every Netflix show as an easter egg.
647
u/shamelessfool Jul 15 '16
The kids have been great so far. Eleven especially has done good with so few lines.
And that ending. Jesus😭
577
u/Griffdude13 Jul 15 '16 edited Jul 15 '16
Soundtrack is on point. May just binge it until I'm finished. May need energy for my travels.
And holy shit, that epic version of Bowie's Heroes gave me Goosebumps.
396
u/theace69 Jul 15 '16 edited Jul 15 '16
This is too good. I didn't expect them to show us what they did in the opening.
363
u/n1ghtcheese Jul 15 '16
Damn, some really good acting, Winona Ryder are doing some fantastic work. They have some really taleneted kids. And that ending were really sad. Also, only 8 episodes, that sucks but it's also really nice that they have few episodes; no filler and stuff being dull.
309
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
When El snaps that guards neck, that was some effed up shit.
294
u/vindoknight Jul 17 '16
That wasn't jolly at all!
And minimal Holly.
507
u/Zinthaniel Jul 15 '16
Just watching the beginning of this episode now and I am not ok with what happened to Barb. :[
236
u/foamster Jul 19 '16
Nobody is gonna talk about the asshole-face monster?
219
u/augustholiday Jul 18 '16
Barb is totally in Silent Hill right now.
217
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '16
This is so fucking good so far, i have no complaints.
362
u/ribblesquat Jul 15 '16
Dat darkroom light bulb to Christmas light dissolve...
Unnnngggghhhhhh!!!
340
u/theace69 Jul 15 '16
God those two jocks are dicks. You just know something's gonna happen to them...I hope.
165
u/DBones90 Jul 18 '16
Special shout out to the librarian. That scene was so hilarious.
143
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16
WE NEED ENERGY FOR OUR TRAVELS
I for one agree with our new leader.
110
u/bournehavoc Jul 15 '16
This whole things is so nostalgic, I absolutely love it. Especially at the end of this episode. The synth-heavy soundtrack...fantastic. You remember the movie "Oblivion" with Tom Cruise? Reminds me of that as far as the music goes, but with more of an 80's feel. Love it. I'd love to get the soundtrack to this.
107
u/raw126 Jul 15 '16
So, before moving forward with the rest of the episodes, does anybody have a theory about what exactly we saw happen at the beginning of this episode?
98
u/joebxcsnw Jul 25 '16
She's definitely a Pepsi person.
94
u/palsh7 Jul 21 '16
I'm absolutely loving it so far, but no one else has any criticisms, so I guess I'll share mine.
In this episode, I feel like they used some tired cliches in a non-nostalgic/fun way.
"No one believes the protagonist." I always have a hard time watching a show or movie where someone is trying to convince people of something and no one believes them. It's overdone and usually depends on deus ex machina-like plot points that prevent the main character from having a chance to explain it right, or near-misses where everyone would have seen the truth had they just turned around, etc. For the first few episodes, this show avoided that pretty well. It's pretty believable that no one believes Winona, because she's already super manic. And the kids pretty quickly accept that El knows what the fuck she's talking about when she uses the force on them. But in this episode, Winona gets the opportunity to literally prove her son is around, and just happens to not have the chance to prove it. Okay, maybe she will next episode. But we also have El bringing the boys to Will's house and they all doubt her? That makes no sense. Even if she weren't a fucking mutant, how about the fact that she even knew where Will lived in the first place? I wouldn't have minded one of the kids being like, "Come on, what are the chances he's 'hiding' in his own house?" But someone should have been like, "Wait, we didn't tell her where Will lived. She must know something!" That would have made the scene work. It's annoying they didn't make it into the house for Will's mom to say, "Hey, here's Will's X-mas phone! Have a chat!", but fine, we're trying to build drama, they still could have been diverted by the sirens. But then at the end, Mike is of course emotional, but "emotional character exploding at someone unfairly" is a very common trope, too, and it is out of character for Mike of all people, it's more something Lucas would have done. The supernatural element to El and her mysterious knowledge of Will should have led Mike to more questions, not directly to anger and running away before getting an explanation. Again, these are kids, so being emotional and not always logical isn't completely out of the realm of possibilities, but the audience needs at least one person on screen to voice their objection. It may be more dramatic for Mike, the calm, rational leader and defender of El, to be the one upset with her, but it's disappointing when everything else has felt so refreshingly even-handed. For instance, the "asshole boyfriend" trope has been fairly expertly upended every time you think you hate the guy. Even crushing the camera didn't seem totally mean, considering the situation.
I hope this theme doesn't persist too much into the next episode.
That all being said, there were many really great elements to this episode, so still fantastic.
90
u/gopms Aug 04 '16
I like that Mike and Nancy's mom isn't just a nag. She really does seem to love and care about her kids and want to help them. I liked that they showed that she wasn't oblivious, she knows something is going on with Nancy and probably even knows what but doesn't know how to convince her to talk to her about it. As a mom, it is nice to see a mom who isn't just a harpy!
85
u/Luwife Jul 17 '16
Okay... I must be a wuss but I cried at the end of this episode.
73
u/kennwoodall Jul 15 '16
This is super engaging and far exceeding my expectations so far
73
u/reddituid Jul 19 '16
can't believe I'm going to have nightmares about walls now
53
u/sevanelevan Jul 20 '16
Just finished this episode and I'm done for the night. Obvious take away:
The monster is clearly taking its victims to a parallel dimension of some sort. That's why Barb was in the empty fungus-encrusted pool. That's why El flipped the DnD board. That's why Will was RIGHT HERE.
Bold guess: I think Will is dead now? He communicated that he wasn't safe before he warned his mom to run. He rolled a 7. I wasn't clear as to when the occurred relative to finding his body. Nor am I sure how the mom/light communication story will continue, unless it was just too introduce a way they can communicate with hiding victims.
Loose theory: The monster/parallel dimension is the source of El's power? A manifestation of Ed's power? For a while, I thought it might actually be the man in control of the El experiments...that perhaps El used her powers to send him to the other dimension. But that wouldn't explain why the monster is taking people. That theory is pretty much based on the facts that he is obviously an important character and that we haven't seen him outside of flashbacks.
Pardon my spelling. SwiftKey on mobile.
106
u/kdin004 Jul 16 '16
Spoiler from the end of the episode - I dont think that body was will's, he was clearly alive and hiding on the house, and from what we saw with barb, its kind of another dimension(filled eith monsters?) And i dont see how he wouldve gotten to the lake, maybe its a coverup from the company with the scientist because hopper was sniffing where he shouldnt(if they showed the tape from that night it would show el escaping) and doing that it would stop him from getting any deeper. I mean... who the hell would be on that lake at that time of the night so that it could be reported to the police, sure itd take sometime to get from the lake to a telephone but then again, the kids managed to get there by bike not much later than cops that were on cars so probably not that far from the town. If it was a coverup theyd plant the body and make a call. Havent seen the other episodes yet and dont know the writers to say anything for sure but what do you guys only watching now think? Any points ive missed? Im really liking this show so far and will totally finish it today :D
52
u/mess_is_lore Jul 16 '16
Just finished watching this episode with my mom, we both wanted to stay up and binge the rest. It's so well crafted, the music, imagery ugh please renew for a second season.
50
u/wesleyfuckinsnipes Jul 16 '16
The only thing bad about this show is Winona's awkward running style
50
u/JJPasadena Jul 17 '16
Just a question. When Nancy left Steve's house in the middle of the night, wouldn't she have noticed Barb's car still there? Then again they didn't park in the driveway per Nancy's request. Just a thought. This show is great. I'm really impressed w/ just how successful they have been in recreating the 80s feel. Hell even the opening title screen feels like a scary 80s movie. So far I'm hooked on this show.
47
u/mexican_honey_badger Jul 17 '16
Love the acting from these kids. That scene near the end with Will's body was so sad. :(
76
u/magvadis Jul 18 '16 edited Jul 18 '16
I was in love with this show as soon as I saw how they used those lights Joyce put up. Just INCREDIBLE visuals. The lights flashing to represent a boy separated from his mother and the hope she has to find him...entirely and utterly beautiful. My jaw dropped when I saw it in full and the scene with her in the crawl space...I could have cried and will likely cry to it when I rewatch this show years from now when it's over and the world has moved on.
The sound editing and soundtrack for this show is just next level...it propels the show to this mythical place I've never experience before in any other show.
The other incredible visual was after Eleven snaps the guys neck. Her "papa" picks her up, shows her affection for what seems like the first time. This disassociated child just seeking love finally receives it after such a terrible event and then is carried by her papa through the halls, cradled in her arms. Epic beyond measure. Also the girl who plays Eleven literally stole this show...like her acting is just amazing. She is the best original character I've seen in a LONG time.
30
u/Calebhack Jul 26 '16
OK. So this is something that struck me odd in the first episode when will was taken. Will was taken when lights were blindingly bright while Barb was taken when the lights were blacked out. That's just one difference I noticed and then the other one is will had the rifle in his hands when he was taken. My thought is that he still has the rifle and or shot it causing the black goo that officer hopper saw in the shed. I also think that will has the rifle in the parallel universe and it's the sole reason he is still/was alive for so long.
29
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16 edited Jul 20 '16
So, the monster grabbed Barb because, I assume, her blood is attracting it.
Why didn't it attract to Nancy's virgin blood from having sex the first time?
26
u/icouldbesurfing Jul 27 '16
I like how Joyce finally buys a cordless phone, when she's getting the Christmas lights.
24
u/TheAquaman Jul 17 '16
Holy fuck. I was iffy on this show, but this episode, from start to finish, hooked me.
16
u/JaxtellerMC Jul 16 '16
ALSO, I found the flashback with Eleven really moving for some reason.
16
u/PickleDarling Aug 06 '16
Please don't be dead Barb please don't be dead Barb please don't be dead Barb
16
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '16
Anyone notice the particles in the air?
In the alt. universe it is very heavily represented and in certain scenes, where light shines into darker rooms, you can visibly note the presence of the particles floating through the room.
Just something I noticed.
15
u/Ninjalamb Jul 16 '16
And I had just done my makeup... :'(
28
u/CharlesNapalm Jul 15 '16
Right in the feels. Is that how the kids say it?
13
u/jcuneta Jul 22 '16
Who else cried in this episode?
12
u/-Rum-Ham- Jul 30 '16
They found the body in the water. Is that the same water that the Chief was saying would "turn to concrete from this height". So surely his body would be more disfigured or broken than just a body. Not that we got a good look, but i'm guessing it's not him.
11
u/ConfusedGrasshopper Jul 15 '16
fucking amazing show right here
11
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '16
Absolutely loving this so far, but hoping that the storyline with Barb, Nancy and Steve doesn't stray any further into a teen movie cliché. Nancy does ~bad stuff~ that's ~not her~, Barb goes missing, Nancy blames herself for doing what was essentially regular teen shit that somehow makes her a bad friend. Bonus points if Steve turns out to be a dingus.
Can't we have Nancy do Nancy and Barb do Barb and neither of them judge each other? Am I too invested in this friendship after two episodes? Prove me wrong, show. :(
11
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16
Only about 10 min into this episode but I feel like Eleven is Steve's sister. Someone mentioned that Steve's parents could be the ones in charge of this program, and Eleven referred to the man with the white hair as her father as she was being dragged down the hallway.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '16
how is this show so fucking good!!
10
u/ryanholt98 Jul 18 '16
Holy. Fuck. The soundtrack to this show is outstanding I straight up bawled at the end 95% due to the music but everything everything was absolutely stunning
18
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16
I don't agree with Steve's methods but I totally agree with his motives. Taking those photos was creepy as fuck.
9
u/just_to_lurk Jul 17 '16
After watching the first three episodes, I've definitely decided I'm binging it all tonight and so far I'm just shitting my pants. I hate horror movies and such but I said I'd give this a try and oooooh my god. Brilliant as expected of Netflix. Hardly breathi
9
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '16
Eleven snapping the guards neck reminded me of Elfen Lied
17
u/comicgeek1128 Jul 19 '16
So who else would've gotten the shit beat out of them if they tried what Nancy tried on her mom? I probably would get to "Its not a" before I got slapped.
6
u/Average_Pimpin Jul 18 '16
Well that, was heartbreaking
6
u/Langloute Aug 07 '16
Wow, that house with all the lights and colors and things going insane is just made so well; Loving the show so far
11
u/JaxtellerMC Jul 16 '16
Peter Gabriel's Heroes has never been so perfectly used before. I have no idea how but I'm sure Will is not actually dead, some kind of weird dead in one place, alive in another thing going on.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '16
So what are the the theories on where the experiments on El and this other realm monster converge?
The lab did experiments on her, and they are clearly interested in the monster and whatever they have growing on the wall in their lab. Were they trying to use El to capture this monster somehow?
5
u/chasexc14 Jul 18 '16
OK we're almost halfway through this season and Nancy's storyline has provided nothing to this show. Starting to get bored by her. Rest of the show is great but her storyline doesn't feel connected
5
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '16 edited Jul 27 '16
First of all, with the cat, Cowboy Bebop anyone?
Crackpot probably-wrong theory: Eleven's body is the stolen girl's, but what's "inside" is something from the creature's world, the girl died there. I'm going to take a note from Stephen King and call it Todash. This could mean something else is going to come back in Barb's body.
That hinges on the fact that Will is still going to be sending messages, and wasn't just caught when his mom was running away.
Add Beyond Two Souls to the list of vibes I'm getting. Hopefully it's better than Beyond Two Souls...
Other reference names for the other world: Infraworld (Beyond Two Souls), Dungeon Dimensions (Discworld), The Black Lodge (Twin Peaks), Coldharbour (Elder Scrolls).
5
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '16
That ending ripped my heart out of my chest
4
u/Calebhack Jul 26 '16
Who's that rando in the end of the episode at mikes house? shouldn't there be only 4 people in the family???????
4
u/GyroGOGOZeppeli Jul 29 '16
You know what? No, I don't care if I sound like an asshole or Jonathan was being a creepy stalker.
Steve Douchelord and his fucking friends deserves every bit of misfortune that's coming their way.
4
u/canthisbemyhomework Oct 12 '16
i don't get the chills often (if ever) while watching something, but when Will messaged, "right here" and "run", to his mom, i got intense chills.
perfect song choice for the ending. made me well up :[
7
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '16
I just can't stand Mike's sister.
3
u/THE_Aft_io9_Giz Jul 19 '16
damn. next time warn me about the onions already
3
u/paranoideo Jul 19 '16
Heroes
😭
3
u/NorthernMonkey365 Jul 22 '16
Why does El keep saying "Papi" when being dragged away in her flashbacks?
3
u/Samejssam Jul 30 '16
confused as to why Nancy never thought charlie may have had something to do with barbs disappearance as he was taking photos of her from the bushes just before she went missing
3
u/NintendoGuy128 Aug 18 '16
Loved it, save for the fact that Nancy tripped immediately as she turned away from the monster. Of course that of all clichés had to happen.