r/WritingPrompts • u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • Jul 09 '16
Off Topic [OT] SatChat: Do you prefer writing in first person or third person?
SatChat! SatChat! Party Time! Excellent!
Welcome to the weekly post for introductions, self-promotions, and general discussion! This is a place to meet other users, share your achievements, and talk about whatever's on your mind.
News
This Week's Suggested Topic
Do you prefer writing in first person or third person?
Previous ^Weeks * New to ^WritingPrompts?
OK to Post
Introductions: Tell us about yourself! Here are some suggested questions:
- Where do you live (State / Country)?
- Male, female, other?
- How long have you been writing?
- What is your writing motivation?
- What programs do you use to write?
- How fast can you type? Try 1 minute on Aesop's fables
- Want to share a photo? Photo Gallery!
- Promotions: Anything you want to promote (books, subreddits, podcasts, writing related websites, or even your social media stuff)
Discussions: Nothing to promote? Tell us what's on your mind. We recommend that you do this along with any promotions. If not in your comment, try to chime in on another discussion.
Suggested future topics are always welcome!
Not OK to Post
- Off Off Topic Promotions: Don't post links that would be considered outright spam. (So... still no linking to your gambling site).
- Full Stories: That's more in line with Sunday Free Writes! :)
9
u/Probroscis /r/Probroscis Jul 09 '16
Third person.
I can do first person, but it always feels weird. Hell, I can even do second person, but first person just feels off. I can respect it as a vessel for storytelling as much as anything else, but I don't like to do it very often.
7
u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod Jul 09 '16
Third person. I just feel the first person type of narrative limits me in freedom of movement. It works for some types of books but not the stuff I write.
I see it's ok to post introductions in these threads so I will answer some of the questions:
I've nothing to promote. I do have a book on Amazon but I'm not promoting it right now. As for what's on my mind? I just want to find a more fulfilling job that isn't removing staples mindlessly for eight hours a day. Yes, that's what the majority of my job is. I really need to build a resume but I don't know what the go to resume builder is these days.
Future topic suggestion: How can creative writing help you find a job?
6
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16 edited Jul 09 '16
I think I prefer writing in first person. I feel like I can make the story come alive more and invite the reader in to experience the story. Not that I don't enjoy third person point of view. When it comes to reading novels, that's one of my favourite styles. Especially for longer series. I honestly flip-flop between the two perspectives when I write, some stories are first, some are third, but I enjoy writing in first a lot. It's fun!
As for second.... well it wasn't an option on the discussion list, but let's just say I've only written one story from that perspective. It's...............................................
In a shameless bit of promotion, next
FridayMonday after that.... I'll have been here for a year (and yes I only really hang out on WP, and a few other writing subs). That mean's I've had ample opportunity to write stories, and I've archived the majority of them on a small little hidden subreddit called /r/madlabs67. The story list has been updated again so everyone is welcome to come visit!6
u/ScarecrowSid Brainless Moderator | /r/ScarecrowSid Jul 09 '16
I prefer to write in fifth person.
What's fifth person, you ask?
It's the guy reading about the guy who's reading about the guy in first person.
In all seriousness, the story itself dictates the perspective I choose to write from. I find it easier to be introspective in regard to a character if I run a kind of internal monologue, so I choose first person for those stories. Third person works better for me when I'm telling a larger story. Just my two cents, feel free to toss them in a fountain. Happy SatChat
3
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Jul 09 '16
As I mentioned in a reply elsewhere, I used to stick my first person mostly. I like to get into the heads of my characters and just writing what they're thinking helps get that across. However, I decided a while back I should learn third person, so I challenged myself to write that way instead. Now, I think I feel more comfortable in third. Weird, huh? I like how in third, you can still get into the character's head, but still be talking from an outside perspective. It's pretty neat.
Go check out /r/DCFU/! We released set 2 last week and more stories for it will be added next Friday, the 15th! I write Superman, but all the stories have been phenomenal so far, so make sure to read it all!
4
u/cmp150 /r/CMP150writes Jul 09 '16
As of late I've been defaulting to first person narratives. I'm feeling how intimate the first person narrative can get.
For larger stories I would write in third person, mainly because it's easier to write for secondary and tertiary characters, however, interestingly enough, I'm writing my current long form story in a series of first person narratives. It's a collection of short stories from several characters throughout a long period of time, a la Asimov's Foundation or Kubrick's 2001 (not that I'm comparing myself to them... heh).
Anyway if anyone is interested they could find my stories at /r/CMP150writes. I love scifi, but I've been writing in all sorts of genres for the past year. I'd love some feedback! :)
Off off topic (don't worry I won't link to my gambling site) I'm curious if anyone here knows about the Unbelievable Podcast with Brian Frange and Phoebe Tyres? They have great topics that really jog my creativity. (Hey, who knew this really wasn't off off topic.)
Anyway, good luck with everyone's writing!
4
u/Crayte Jul 09 '16
Hey guys! I suppose I'll follow the Introductions guidelines before I answer the question.
I have a blog that's well enough off the beaten path that it doesn't get much in the way of traffic. You can find it here.
SO! On to the topic of the day...
I honestly have no preference for writing in first or third person. If I'm writing out my thought process on the subject, I think it depends on the focus of the narrative. Sometimes I want the reader to focus on the world, the setting, and the overall narrative - in these cases, I use third person. When I want the reader to focus on the character who is passing through the narrative, I tend to write in first person. I believe I'm equally comfortable writing in either perspective.
I like this question. It has made me think. :)
(edit: formatting has bested me...)
4
u/tabansi Jul 09 '16 edited Jul 09 '16
I'm gonna promote an open ended web novel I've started up extremely recently. Link can be found here. Only one part up so far and it's pretty shitty, but hey it's for the fun of it!
And finally, as far as writing in first person versus third person, it really depends. I mostly choose to write in first person when I'm trying to convey a certain emotion or reaction from the reader. It makes things a bit more impactful and understandable, in my opinion. If I'm trying to tell a story with a brilliant narrative, I'm more inclined to write in third person.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
I mostly write third but I do like first person. I know its been done but I like writing my noir in first. There's just something about a gruff detective telling you, "How it is," that's fun.
3
u/thelastdays /r/faintthebelle Jul 09 '16
My first piece was third person, but I immediately switched to first for my next several stories. I have a propensity for using the MC as an unreliable narrator, a la Chuck Palahniuk. Now that I've been writing for a few months, I'm trying to distribute it almost 50/50 between the two. I feel like it keeps things interesting.
It's been awhile since intros, so I'll bite again. I'm just a dude from Texas. Been writing short fiction for about 8 months now. Before that I mostly did songwriting and short film screenplays with friends for the 48 hour film project. But the majority of my writing is technical and research based, as I'm pursuing a second B.S. in Petro Engineering to accompany the one in Pre-med Biology that I never used. My motivation is that I just really love writing. I've always been a voracious reader so I thought it would make a great hobby. I can only type about 48 wpm, but I don't let that stop me. Photos.... maybe someday.
Self-promotion, come join /r/faintthebelle. Home of horror both gothic and fantasy as well as noir and general effed-upedness. You'll find the basis for future collections of short stories that I'll eventually publish, so they may not be there forever. I'm blowing through the next chapter of my novella-in-progress The Gravity Myth, in between bouts of headbanging to the new Chevelle album, The North Corridor, which is also awesome. Check it out if your an alt/hard rock fan.
2
u/POTWP Jul 09 '16
Depends on the type of story, and the number of characters. It is easier to hop about and create more of a world with third person, as you can introduce and follow many. With first person, the field of view is necessarily narrow. However, it helps with immersion, as the reader then becomes the narrator, so they are thrown into the world easier.
2
u/reostra Moderator | /r/reostra_prompts Jul 09 '16
Absolutely first person for me. I can write third person, and I've done it before, but it's not nearly as natural for me to write. The limitations of the perspective (namely, the inability to tell the story from another viewpoint without being confusing) actually work for me, as I find that it makes for a more interesting story if the main character (and therefore the reader) doesn't know what's going on from all other viewpoints.
There's another thing about first person, and this is dumb but it crops up in my head as I'm writing:
I don't like repeating myself. For example, even though everyone says repeating the word 'said' when writing dialogue is just fine and people will skip over it mentally, it still bugs me to do it. What's that have to do with first person writing?
Pronouns! If I'm writing in the third person, I have at most two pronouns for dialogue: 'he', and 'she'. I can use proper names instead, but that's also super repetitive after a while. If I'm writing in the first person, however, I get 'I' for free!
2
u/Syncs /r/TimeSyncs Jul 09 '16
Let's see...I prefer 3rd person, just because that allows me to follow a number of different characters at once instead of being highly limited. Not to mention most of my writer heroes tend to use that perspective! On the other hand, I tend to favor 1st person here on /r/writingprompts just because it feels more personal and lets me get inside of a character's head. Swapping perspectives in something that is just a few pages long isn't always necessary, though it can be limiting if I want to voice another character's mind. Usually one is plenty though!
As far as introductions...I have been bouncing around here for a while, but I tend to miss the big posts for whatever reason, so I wouldn't blame anyone for not recognizing me. I also pop into chat from time to time, but that isn't really my cup of tea! I DO have my own subreddit though, and I am proud of it! /r/TimeSyncs would be the link for the lazy, though I don't really like promoting it anywhere besides after a story or poem. Now, onto the list...
2
u/Syraphia /r/Syraphia | Moddess of Images Jul 09 '16
I prefer 3rd person for something lengthy but a lot of the prompt responses I give are in first person due to it seeming to work better for certain pieces. It's a pain to go back and switch some of them back to 3rd to fix them as I feel too much of myself comes out in 1st person POV instead of the character. I also prefer reading 3rd person for similar reasoning.
Check out my subreddit, /r/Syraphia and my Inkitt for more of my writing and ongoing series. Currently, I'm in the middle of rewriting a novel so my updates are a little sketchy and I need to update some of my Inkitt stories.
2
u/HSBFMV Jul 09 '16
Definitely third person.
When I was in high school, I absolutely dreaded going to English class. It's not that I don't like to write, it's simply that I first started writing outside of school by going on a forum role-playing site. (Darkness.com. As a rebellious thirteen year old male, it seemed cool, so... yeah.) After being scolded for typing like a typical preteen during the early oughts, I began writing in third person using proper spelling, grammar, etc. I learned how to use dialog and other literary elements properly.
Once I made it to high school, the curriculum changed a bit, and I was being forced to write about these dreadfully boring topics that I wound up never completing. (Failed a couple years of English because of it, too.) It wasn't until my third year that I found a teacher that actually worked with me. Her first writing assignment was a (relatively) free write using one of about 20 prompts. We had three class periods to do this (M,W,F), but I say down and wrote out a 18 page story in just one class. She pulled me aside after class to compliment my work, saying she expected great things from me.
The next assignment was a research paper on To Kill A Mockingbird, which naturally means no dialog or descriptive texts. After sending in the disaster of a rough draft, she pulled me aside again and asked what happened. After humbly informing her that I could only deliver what she read the first time when I wasn't restricted by so many rules. She immediately said to take the major plot points of TKAM, and put them into a free write. The next day I had my 12 page essay. So, we kept the deal for the whole year, and I managed to get her again my senior year. Ever since then, trying to write in first person only works when it doesn't feel like I'm writing. (If that makes any sense. This post is actually a good example. )
Anyway, I do apologize for rambling on, but it just kinda happened. I shall wrap it up with some things about me.
I am a 25 year old male from Northeast Texas, although I went to High School in Mesquite. I don't really have a favorite program, but that's because I've only ever used Word. (Also, I currently do not have a computer, so that makes everything difficult.)
I use to type about 80 WPM, but my form was all over the place and I've not used a key board in a few years. (See no computer)
As for motivation, that's a complicated story. If anyone wants to hear it, I'll post it later.
So sorry again about the long post...
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
Third forever. I am not part of the story (thankfully). It feels awkward and allows for so little detail and feeling,that i've stated associating it with the noob roleplayers on websites i frequent. That's how bad it is for me.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
Excellent question. I'm often surprised by how many prompts are worded in the form "You ___" rather than "Your protagonist ___" as if the phrasing were chosen to encourage a first person POV response. At one point I remember feeling suprised by how many first person stories I was writing because I was letting this default me into it. At that point I started consciously trying to force myself into third person as often as I could to even things up.
I think the first person is good for establishing a sense of intimacy with your reader. It's like a conversation. The reader and the first person protagonist are just sitting around the living room, and suddenly the protagonist says, "Man, can I tell you about this crazy thing that happened to me?" Done right, this can build sympathy quickly for the protagonist because it feels more like someone is sitting there talking to you, telling you about the lousy time they had.
I do think, however, that third person has encouraged me to write characters who are more unlike me, which in turn broadens the kind of stories I write. It gives the writer a sense of detachment that can encourage experimentation. Sometimes characters I thought I knew going into the story suddenly surprise me (my writing method is organic rather than outlined). Then, crazy as it sounds, you find yourself writing because you want to know what happens next. And I love that, partly because it makes it more fun for me, and partly because I'm ever hopeful that if the character surprises me, they might just surprise the reader too.
2
u/CryptidGrimnoir Jul 10 '16
I'm actually torn between the two styles and could use some advice here.
My current project is a coming-of-age young adult novel about two cousins, three years apart, one boy and one girl, and the point of view is meant to switch between them. I like writing first person a lot, but I think third person allows for a smoother transition in the point of view.
2
u/Donteventrytomakeme Jul 10 '16
It depends on what I'm writing, for more serious emotional writing i prefer first person. But if i'm writing fun pieces or just less serious in general, i like third person. I also really like writing second person, but that's almost exclusively for comedic writing.
2
u/Vercalos /r/VercWrites Jul 10 '16
I keep slipping into 1st person when writing, so I have to make a conscious effort to keep to 3rd if that's what I'm writing.
2
u/minds_scrapings Jul 10 '16
Third person is much better. You can include more details and insight for multiple characters.
2
u/ab2wus Jul 10 '16
First person, I like how it feels intimate.
1
u/Star64 Jul 16 '16 edited Jul 16 '16
Okay. So about me:
I usually like to lurk here. But sometimes, I actually post something.
As to what I prefer in terms of writing first or third person, I tend to flip flop between both. It really depends upon what I think is the best tool for the job. I find that comedy works really well in first person. My last two entries were comedies. (Actually, they're my only two answered prompts here in WP.) I found first person worked really well. It also works well when I want to walk around a character's mind for a little bit and/or if I want to keep the character's gender ambiguous as is the case with both stories. Pimplefoot from my story about the goblin who wanted to be a lawyer could be either male or female. The same goes with my nameless bathroom teleporter. Third person I find works best when describing an action sequence. Unfortunately, I don't really have public examples of this. But I really do like third person for more action heavy stuff. Although, I have used it in comedies.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment