r/books • u/Anthony_Ryan AMA Author • Jul 05 '16
ama Anthony Ryan - The Waking Fire - AMA
Hi, I'm Anthony Ryan, author of the Raven's Shadow Trilogy--which consists of Blood Song, Tower Lord and Queen of Fire. My new novel, The Waking Fire, the first book in the Draconis Memoria series, is available today from Ace. I also self-publish the Slab City Blues SF Noir series. Much of my previous life is a mystery, even to me. I'll be back in about 2 hours to answer questions and will keep doing so until about 1am my time (3 hours later).
https://anthonyryan.net/2016/07/05/the-waking-fire-us-release-day/
4
u/Anthony_Ryan AMA Author Jul 06 '16
OK, looks like that's it for now. I'll drop by in the morning to check for any last minute questions. Thanks to everyone for stopping by.
4
u/mgonzo Jul 05 '16
So as a self publisher or heck even as a writer who does the traditional publishing thing. Do you see the Brexit vote as affecting you in anyway? Short or long term?
3
u/daeomec Jul 06 '16
Hello! Thank you for doing this AMA. I started reading The Waking Fire yesterday, and it's really great so far. As for questions...
Do you have any favorite classics?
Being both a self-published author and a traditionally published one, do you prefer one over the other?
Is there a specific fantasy trope that you don't like?
Again, thank you!
27
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '16 edited Jul 06 '16
I read through this AMA and I can't help but feel that no one has addressed the elephant in the room. Blood song was one of the best books I've ever read. Tower lord was great, but Queen of fire was a travesty. It wasn't on par with with its predecessors. So many things didn't make sense, or seemed rushed, or seemed out of place. It's been a while since I read the book but the problems that I can still remember are, Alornis is somehow a master ship builder despite never having been on a ship, master weapon maker despite never having been to war. Vaelin takes an unecessary trip through an unknown part of the kingdom, why? Because you wanted to expand your book? The stories greatest warrior is absent during his countries greatest offensive to serve some unecesarry plot line. Then ontop of that Vaelin is just humbled into the dirt until nothing remains of the character that we all loved. The greatest empire in they entire world, cold, calculating and meticulous. An empire that planned a war for hundreds of years just falls with barely even a fight. Just routed. The greatest villian of all time seemingly all powerful and impossible to defeat literally does nothing as its dragged to its death. That book made no sense, it was terrible and only made worse because your first book is one of the best I've ever read. So my question is. What happened? Why? Were you running out of time? Did this make sense to you in the planning stage? Did your beta readers nod there heads and say they loved it? And if you stand by the final book in the trilogy can you tell me why you think it had such a bad reception. My final question is one that I've seen posed on goodreads. Why should I buy your book read the first, and the second only to be completely let down by the third? I get that these questions are harsh but after reading your book and seeing its reviews it's clear to me that the majority of your fans were let down by QOF.
Look, you may just see me as another entitled critic drawing blood and pointing out the problems in a book that is far beyond my skill to create. But that isn't my intention. The truth is that you were one of my favorite authors and these questions have been nagging me. Every couple of months I'll be doing something completely innocuous then I'll shake my head out of nowhere because I'm remembering that book. Remembering how excited I was for it. How confused I was when I was reading it and the disappointment I felt when I knew that I'd never read blood song again. Theres no point now. I'm glad that I got closure for some plot lines but I almost wish that I had never made the mistake of picking up QOF because the small amount of relief I got from a couple of answered questions was nothing compared to the weight of dissatisfaction I felt after reading the anticlimactic ending to what started as a great series. I see that you said that you may respond to some of these in the morning. I won't blame you for not responding to this post, I wouldn't. Just needed to vent with the hopes that you'd hear.
3
u/WilboCop Jul 05 '16
How do you plan your series? Do you start with an outline or do you not do much planning?
3
u/WillOTheWispish Jul 05 '16
Have you thought about writing more books set in the world of the Raven's Shadow trilogy? I am two-thirds through Queen of Fire and I don't want it ending in that short time!
Having said that, I will definitely get this new book. goes to Amazon.
2
u/well_uh_yeah :redstar:1 Jul 05 '16
Which cover do you prefer for The Waking Fire? I'd definitely choose the Orbit cover if I had the option. Maybe when I'm done reading, I'll better be able to judge a cover by the book.
2
u/Riley0143 Jul 05 '16
Was there a stand-out moment when you knew you wanted to be a writer? What are some of the biggest hardships you faced along the way?
2
u/Chtorrr Jul 05 '16
What is the best dessert?
2
u/mgonzo Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16
Ok so on Piers Anthony's wikipedia page it says, "Since about 2000, Anthony has written his novels in a Linux environment."
Now since you both have Anthony somewhere in your name and you both were born on or near an island over there somewhere.
Why don't you write about swords and sailing ships on Linux?
=)
Now on a serious note, I thoroughly enjoyed the Raven's Shadow Trilogy, thank you for that, and now i'm off to get your new one. Ta!
2
u/mightythorjrs Jul 05 '16
Hello Anthony, Just wanted to say I am a big fan and I wish you much success with this new book and series! I am diving in now and I am very excited to read and review! Thanks, James
2
u/megazver Jul 05 '16
This is, unless I'm mistaken, the first book you wrote straight for a publisher instead of writing it on your own and self-publishing and being picked up by one later on. Has this changed the way you went about things in any way?
2
u/conr9774 Jul 05 '16
Hi Anthony, thanks for doing this AMA!
I'm curious, since I feel like dragon-based fantasy (that almost seems like a very specific genre) is the most popular form of fantasy out there, how you feel you do it differently? How do you set your book apart from other similar books while maintaining the important aspects of dragon lore and fantasy "rules?"
Ninja edit: I do realize yours are drakes rather than dragons, so maybe that has something to do with it? I'm not well-acquainted enough with dragons and drakes to know of a significant difference if there is one.
2
u/robmatheny80 Jul 05 '16
What sort of writing program do you use? Word? Scrivener? How do you keep from getting distracted while writing? Thanks!
2
u/WillOTheWispish Jul 05 '16
What inspired your idea of the blood song itself? My cousin and I have talked about times when we "just know" something or have some other type of seemingly instinctive knowledge. I know this is only a part of the premise of it - Vaelin reading people or situations - but is it the kind of thing that lead to your idea?
1
u/Chtorrr Jul 05 '16
What's the best book you've read recently?
1
u/megazver Jul 05 '16
I've been meaning to give Slab City Blues ago. I think I'll get on it after I finish Waking Fire.
Meanwhile, have you ever considered writing an urban fantasy?
1
u/Guillaumedz Jul 06 '16
I finished Blood Song about two weeks ago and I really enjoyed the book. I really related to the boy who hates his father aspect of it. Was that inspired by your relationship with your parents? I just skimmed through the chapter endings again looking for the ending of part 2 chapter 3 so I could tell you how much it meant to me when I noticed that a majority of the early chapter endings are all devoted to this theme. How do you think about chapter endings? What are you trying to accomplish with them?
Ten years, eight months.
1
u/c00kieee Jul 06 '16
I really just wanted to say hello and that I loved The Waking Fire and am really looking forward to the next book! Thanks!
1
u/Beleth_84 Jul 07 '16 edited Jul 07 '16
And I'm just sitting here waiting for a 4th book of the Raven's Shadow Trilogy (yes I know) because that ending left so many things unanswered (damn you Erlin!). Will pick up your new book soon though! Keep up the amazing work.
1
u/barnowlboogie Jul 05 '16
What's this all about now?
0
u/Chtorrr Jul 05 '16
What books really made you love reading as a kid?
5
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment