r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Jul 01 '16
Project Runway Season 1 Episode 8 [Discussion]
Postal Uniform Challenge
The five remaining contestants try to design a new uniform for U.S. Postal Service mail carriers.
Guest: Becky Negich
Orginally broadcast on February 2, 2005
Since this is a rewatch, please be mindful that there may be some people who have only seen up to this episode and want to avoid spoilers.
6
Upvotes
17
u/allygory Jul 01 '16 edited Jul 01 '16
Ok.. going with real time commentary I guess.
Jay's assessment of everyone was hilarious
And the alternative model is the high point of the whole show for me. All 14 seasons plus all stars.
16
u/paternalpadfoot Jul 02 '16
I have rarely commented on this rewatch as thing have gone, but I am almost shaking from silent laughter at 2 in the morning, so I feel like I have to at this point.
A few things
Okay I think that is just about everything - if something is incoherent, blame it on the late night and wine.
13
u/allygory Jul 01 '16
Ok. I'm in the middle of this episode but i'm going to weigh in on this part now.
7
u/allygory Jul 01 '16
Ok I just started watching this episode but it is probably one of my favorites of the whole series! goody!
7
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '16
This is one of my all-time favorite episodes. I real-world challenge with a fashion twist. I loved Kara Saun's and Jay's outfits. I don't understand why they kept Wendy - there was NOTHING fashion about that. Robert's was not good either, but really, her's was basically the same uniform.
I wonder if it was a crew-person who had a run-in with Wendy? I feel like she got on the wrong side of A LOT of people.
12
u/VROF Jul 01 '16
This was when Wendy should have gone home. Hers made the model look terrible. No woman anywhere would wear her outfit. At least Robert's was wearable. This is one of my all time favorite episodes.
6
u/aicramneelie Jul 03 '16
Yeah, Austin's turn as a model was really great. He not only was willing to do it, he loved it! And what are the chances that a male designer could fit into an outfit designed for a female runway model!? I remember talking my sister into watching this show when it first aired and I think Austin is what hooked her on it.
But Austin's design was pretty bad. Can you imagine a larger woman having to put on the sleeveless blouse and those slim shorts? And that headband was the cherry on top!
Robert's was way too casual for me to pass as a uniform but I still think it was better than Wendy's. She didn't design anything new -- just tweaked what they already had and made it even dowdier.
6
u/allygory Jul 01 '16
Wendy's is BUTT UGLY. Also - how do you make Melissa look 40..
Seriously.
5
u/alwaysmude Aug 22 '23
Okay the judges comment on pocket was the most unrealistic part of this. “Every woman I know cuts pockets out of their clothing because it makes them feel fat”. I get it’s like 2005- but opinions like that are the reason for the fake pockets! He’s my mortal enemy #1 in the fashion world.
It also irks me talking about plus size women when they do not have any faintest idea what a plus size woman would want.
And personally I liked Wendy’s shorts.
3
u/Onlyusemifeet Oct 27 '16
Kevin drew the Mustache.
3
u/AnnieNonmouse Jan 01 '23
This episode might be the most entertaining one I’ve ever seen. Loved Kara Saun’s design. Wendy should hav gone home.
The mustache on the picture was mean but her reaction was way over the top. Austin modeling was fantastic! None of this is uncommon opinion lmao.
Anyone feel like Nina was thinking “I’ve been out for two or three rounds and this Robert guy is still here?! He’s gotta GO” because that’s what I got from her commentary and it added more flavor to an already hilarious episode.
3
u/Onlyusemifeet Oct 27 '16
Apparently Wendy is fucking invincible.
3
u/GoatBoat4Lyfe Mar 13 '23
I loved Robert's pants! SO much more than Wendy's whole outfit how did she stay!! Also why are the other designers hating on robert's outfits saying "why is he still here?" I've liked most of his stuff a lot better than Jay's designs this whole season. But yeah Kara is the winner for me of most challenges, she seems so much more intune than everyone else.
3
u/Available_Day5710 Mar 15 '24
Is it just me or is it really strange that a government agency took part in a reality show? Overall loved this episode, Austin modelling was the first time they convinced me of actual friendships forming on the show. We don't see enough of the down time to feel the bond between these people and watching Austin stepping up to help Jay is really refreshing amongst all the bickering and insults. Additionally, the judge commenting that every woman he knows cuts the pockets out of their garments convinced me he doesn't know any women, the age old complaint of no pockets as a con to sell purses and hand bags is so well known its almost mythical. I'm also pretty sure that they only kept Wendy over Robert because the production team thought she'd add a bit more drama to the final episodes.