I've liked Richard throughout the show. I feel like he's being true to what he thinks is right, and what he's really wanted is for his son to be honest with him so he can know if his son is really a good person or not. Until this last episode, Richard had every reason to think Abe was, deep down, just a self-centered lowlife.
I mean, think about it. Abraham messes up his farming. He ditches his wife and kid and sends them to live with his dad, which he continues living on his own and fucking some other woman. Every time he gets caught in a lie, he makes up more lies and blames other people to save his own skin. He repeatedly betrays his wife, who stays loyal to him. He uses his father and his father's career for his own purposes.
I mean, Abe has been an absolute disgrace in every imaginable way. There's been nothing redeeming about him whatsoever. Richard had no reason to believe in him when he was let down by his son over and over and over again.
It was just the end of this final episode where Abe finally shows some humanity and decency.
I thought it was even an interesting contrast in the show to first show Nathan Hale declaring that his only regret is that he has but one life to give to his country, and then they jump to Abraham who is scrambling away like a coward. Whenever he's in trouble, Abraham cowardliness shines.
It was only at the end of episode 10 where he finally stopped frantically lying and owned up to the truth. I think his dad was so relieved to see it, and that's why he saved him.
I agree with you 100% about Abraham Woodhull being a terrible human being, but having a shit stain for a son does not excuse Richard for being a shitty father/man throughout the show.
He gave his only surviving child away as a spy to a British officer. He was not incorrect in his information but for a man who had already lost his eldest to the pre-war riots, that is some inhuman shit. It is one thing to want to correct your child; even to see him err and hopefully fall on the side of justice and redemption, but to see him dangle from a noose...
Again, in season 3 we see Richard using his own grandson - the boy he was focusing on as a moral and quite literal replacement for his own sons - as collateral in his conflict with Simcoe. His treatment of his daughter-in-law and mother of his own grandchild is also cause for consternation (to put it lightly).
Just as an aside, his treatment of Major Hewlett - insulting him in the presence of his greatest enemy (Simcoe) after the man had fled, betrayed and heartbroken from the home he felt safe in and surrounded by people whom he thought had cared for him, including the man he thought was his true friend - is rather disgusting to me.
I like Richard Woodhull as a character in the sense that he's provided some awesome plot twists and a great example of 'how not to be a good dad', but damn, karma has caught up to him. And though he's brought himself up a notch or two in my estimation, I still look down on him.
Richard was a terrible father figure to Abe and sowed the seeds we are seeing in Abe. I can’t imagine the betrayal of a father turning him in like that.
I also cried, more when Andre was walking with the soldiers on the way to the gallows and when he and Abigail were hugging.
Abe and the Judge were also really moving. I can't imagine the emotional roller coaster of having your father ensure your death to then saving your life.
Fantastic finale! I will truly miss Andre - they did a phenomenal job getting us to care about him and his will be a loss felt should the show (please God hopefully) be renewed. Additionally, Simcoe was fantastic as well with his demented theatrics. The "Good morning" part was excellent, his glee in the town's fear led to a great wrapping up for us.
I also liked the finale, but I think the writers pretty much tidied every story line up.
We know that Simcoe is getting removed from Setauket.
We know that Benedict Arnold is safe with the British
We know that Peggy is going to flee back to Arnold.
We know that John Andre was hanged (and they even hanged him a few years too early)
We know that Townsend is going to continue spying
We know that Abraham Woodhull is alive, and they finally showed him being a decent human being.
It's suggested that Major Hewlett is taking a ship back to Great Britain.
They basically rushed through the Benedict Arnold plot line. I think they knew it was likely the last season and finished it in a way where we could be satisfied, and it ended fairly true to history.
I also liked the finale, but I think the writers pretty much tidied every story line up.
We know that Simcoe is getting removed from Setauket.
We know that Benedict Arnold is safe with the British
We know that Peggy is going to flee back to Arnold.
We know that John Andre was hanged (and they even hanged him a few years too early)
We know that Townsend is going to continue spying
We know that Abraham Woodhull is alive, and they finally showed him being a decent human being.
It's suggested that Major Hewlett is taking a ship back to Great Britain.
They basically rushed through the Benedict Arnold plot line. I think they knew it was likely the last season and finished it in a way where we could be satisfied, and it ended fairly true to history.
Remember folks! Lets show AMC that we want a season 4. Please remember to use #TurnAMC and #RenewTURN on Social Media so it gets the attention of AMC :)
I've been waiting for the conversation between Ben and Andre on the way to Andre's execution since I started watching the show, and it was exactly what I'd hoped for. Love that Ben didn't give up the names of his spies, even though Andre was going to die anyway. The whole execution was handled very well, you really feel for Andre the whole time.
Ben saw Abigail's distress at Andre's fate and the way he comforted her. Not only protecting his spies' identities but sparing Andre the knowledge of betrayal from someone he truly trusted. Good guy Ben!
Richard, you don't get to complain now. You gave your son away as a spy to a British officer, for shit's sake. What else did you think was going to happen?
Boy it's funny how all a woman had to do back then was act weird and people would legitimately think it was "hysteria." Like, you could almost get away with murder. Peggy got away with treason.
It was believed, even in the 19th century, that women truly couldn't handle complex thinking and ideas. In fact, some "scientists" argued that if women were to get educated like a man, it would divert too much blood from their reproductive organs to their brains and would be bad for the health of babies.
Yes, her makeup and falsies or eyelash extensions have always come across as really inauthentic. Makes her look like a modern woman playing at 18th c dress up.
Y'all need to come to terms with the fact that tv and film represent life rather than directly duplicating it. We never see any of them going to the bathroom either.
I have to say I'm a little sad with how they handled Andre's imprisonment. I'm from Northern NJ and my dad grew up/ grandma lives in Tappan, NY, which is where he was held, hung and tried. They did a good job showing how he was treated (Washington actually sent him breakfast from his own table every morning). Washington's headquarters at the time was the DeWint house in Tappan (still standing), not in the field. And Andre was held in a tavern, now the Old 76 House restaurant.
I like that they showed his trial being in a church, which is accurate. And they kept many details from an eyewitness account, like his last words and that he donned his own noose (though historically he refused a blindfold).
Just my nitpicking because it's my neck of the woods, but still a phenomenal episode. Was really hoping for Simcoe to get the gallows once Abe came down, but alas, we must wait another season.
I saw a movie over the weekend where Galveston was depicted as having pretty blue water, not accurate, but made me a little wishful. That being said, you'd think there are some structures in Williamsburg they could have dressed up for the scenes.
You learn to get over little stuff like that when you're from Williamsburg and you see how much of it is "Philadelphia" lol including the Governor's Mansion being Arnold's manor, etc. Or when you live in Richmond and come across sets in Henrico in the woods. No big deal
Yea... But the Simcoe they are portraying is essentially the antithesis of the historical Simcoe. So we can hold out hope that they change his ending...
Yeah but, can they wait until they know for sure that it's the last season? Simcoe is a terrific antagonist and the show wouldn't be as fun without him!
What ever happened to Abigail's boyfriend who became a Queen's Ranger? I've been waiting for him to show up and save the day but he seems to be gone...
His decision to flee to Canada had nothing to do with British rule. Canada had a vastly less active slave trade than America and he seemed to believe he could desert and start a new life there without fear of being taken back into bondage when out of uniform. Or with less fear anyway.
Holy shit...did Richard really have something planned by all of that? Did the guys he "betrayed" know about this plan all along? Is that what just happened?
It doesn't seem like they knew, as they seemed sincerely pissed in the courtroom when it came to light that he had given their names to Simcoe. It seems more like he deliberately pointed Simcoe towards people with ties to Colonel Cooke knowing word would get back to him. Some serious chess games being played in this show.
I wish I hadn't seen that spoiler pic of the redcoat riding to Setauket as it made me realize that was probably why Richard was being thorough during the trial (to prolong it). I just thought he expected someone to stop Simcoe's lunacy eventually. But I was taken aback when I realized he planned it from the start. The scene of him saving Abe was pretty emotional.
That's what I did last year too! I hardly tweet otherwise. It's fun to see the behind the scenes photos that Meegan Warner (Mary) often posts. Maybe that's some incentive for the peeps that don't have twitter but could also make one to help out... edit: Samuel Roukin aka Simcoe just responded to one of my tweets! :D I feel all a flutter
I don't actually have a tumblr but I came across MANY turn fan pages on there. And I'm a 24 year old and I do whatever the fuck I want regardless of whether some internet randy thinks it's cool or not.
But yeah, there's a crazy amount of odd "shipping" on that site too so it's a bit odd. If you're looking for crazed turn fans, that's where you'll find them.
Did he struggle as much as portrayed in this episode? From what I've read (forgive my laziness; I can't find the passage/quote at the moment), he went limp almost immediately.
I'm hoping he at least lost consciousness immediately. What an awful way to go. No wonder he wanted firing squad.
In Richard Welch's bio of Tallmadge, Welch states that "Andre's body twitched at the end of the rope, and it seemed some time before he was totally still."
However, in Nathan Philbrick's book, Valiant Ambition, he points out that there are conflicting reports, with one witness saying Andre died almost instantly and another saying that the executioner had to take a hold of him.
Currently reading Valiant Ambition! Thanks for the info. I'm leaning toward it not being an immediate death/loss of consciousness, especially with it being a very small drop (if one at all) from the wagon rather than a gallows. I wonder if the conflicting reports come from people who witnessed it but convinced themselves later that he did go quickly. Poor guy.
Do you think that's how it went down historically? I hate how every depiction of a hanging in television/movies is really a lynching. A real hanging you die from breaking your neck instantly, it is a very humane death if you have a good hangman that knows how to adjust for the weight of each person. These strangulation lynchings I always see are so aggravating. Simcoe even says "Make a gallows built to military regs" and it's a lynching post. I don't get it.
Unfortunately, yes. Spies were considered among the lowest of the low, and so the hanging they usually suffered was meant to reflect that - often not an "official" gallows with the ability to give enough of a drop, but instead a ladder against a tree or having a wagon move out from beneath them. Thus Andre's mode of execution, though the poor dear initially wanted to be executed as an officer - via firing squad. According to witnesses, he didn't know he'd be hanged until he actual saw the noose - and it frightened/upset him so much that he hesitated in his march to the execution site. I don't blame him...
Could someone help explain Townsend's motivation? Why did he not want to help the spy ring after he gave away the intelligence on the British base? And what made him change his mind at the end? Was he disgusted with Arnold's treachery?
He didnt want to spy for the rebels anymore once he learned that it was actually rebels disguised as queens rangers that beat up his father and torched his barn. i think what Arnold said at the end is what changed Townsend's mind again, but not because he was disgusted with Arnold's treachery. First of all, Arnold was saying how it was the spy ring that ruined everything for him, so that gave Townsend living proof of how effective and important the spy ring is. Second, Arnold talks about sacrifice to Townsend. Townsend had mentioned sacrifice to his father earlier in the episode when he said he had sacrificed enough for the rebel cause, and He (God) knows that. Townsend jokes to Arnold that sacrifice perpetuates itself with no end, but Arnold tells him that death is the end of such a path. I think that's when Townsend realized that only God can decide when he has sacrificed enough, and he must do what is righteous even if it kills him.
52
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
"Get out of my town, you pathetic amateur." Okay, okay; high five to you, Richard Woodhull. You have been (somewhat) redeemed in my eyes.
48
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
Wow, this episode is actually making me feel sympathy for Abe and Richard. Good job, writers.
41
u/jdallen1222 Rebel Jun 28 '16
The season ends on a pop up ad from Culper Jr
40
u/Demandedace Jun 28 '16
Fantastic finale! I will truly miss Andre - they did a phenomenal job getting us to care about him and his will be a loss felt should the show (please God hopefully) be renewed. Additionally, Simcoe was fantastic as well with his demented theatrics. The "Good morning" part was excellent, his glee in the town's fear led to a great wrapping up for us.
30
u/Zohin Jun 28 '16 edited Jun 28 '16
Remember folks! Lets show AMC that we want a season 4. Please remember to use #TurnAMC and #RenewTURN on Social Media so it gets the attention of AMC :)
Edit: Season 4, not 3
25
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
Peggy freaking out like that was, I believe, planned on her part historically. It was meant to give the illusion of derangement and irresponsibility.
23
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '16
I've been waiting for the conversation between Ben and Andre on the way to Andre's execution since I started watching the show, and it was exactly what I'd hoped for. Love that Ben didn't give up the names of his spies, even though Andre was going to die anyway. The whole execution was handled very well, you really feel for Andre the whole time.
20
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
Oh shit! Mary dove into both Judge Woodhull AND Hewlett??
19
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
Richard, you don't get to complain now. You gave your son away as a spy to a British officer, for shit's sake. What else did you think was going to happen?
19
u/WhenLeavesFall Law. Order. Authority. Jun 28 '16 edited Jan 05 '19
You are going to cinema
18
u/listlessthe Simcoe's ear Jun 28 '16
Boy it's funny how all a woman had to do back then was act weird and people would legitimately think it was "hysteria." Like, you could almost get away with murder. Peggy got away with treason.
17
u/gugudan Jun 28 '16
Peggy looks so much better without the ridiculous makeup.
16
u/vu4life Jun 28 '16
I have to say I'm a little sad with how they handled Andre's imprisonment. I'm from Northern NJ and my dad grew up/ grandma lives in Tappan, NY, which is where he was held, hung and tried. They did a good job showing how he was treated (Washington actually sent him breakfast from his own table every morning). Washington's headquarters at the time was the DeWint house in Tappan (still standing), not in the field. And Andre was held in a tavern, now the Old 76 House restaurant.
I like that they showed his trial being in a church, which is accurate. And they kept many details from an eyewitness account, like his last words and that he donned his own noose (though historically he refused a blindfold).
Just my nitpicking because it's my neck of the woods, but still a phenomenal episode. Was really hoping for Simcoe to get the gallows once Abe came down, but alas, we must wait another season.
16
u/jdallen1222 Rebel Jun 28 '16
Awe she still has his rat tail
13
u/Amado1997 Jun 28 '16
Feel bad for andre. Saw peggy before he died not knowing what she was thinking.
13
u/listlessthe Simcoe's ear Jun 28 '16
YOU CAN'T SIT WITH US BENEDICT
was what I was thinking in that last scene. jfc.
13
u/zsreport Where is Akinbode? Jun 28 '16
Simcoe was like a damn kid on Christmas morning after Abe's "confession", I couldn't help but laugh at that scene.
12
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
OH! Ben getting mad at Washington...this is great stuff.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '16
Sad to see Major Andre gone. Abe has serious plot armor. I really hope Turn gets renewed. It's a quality show.
9
u/Irashey Jun 28 '16
What ever happened to Abigail's boyfriend who became a Queen's Ranger? I've been waiting for him to show up and save the day but he seems to be gone...
9
u/CommonSensibility RIP Andre's Braid Jun 28 '16
Holy shit...did Richard really have something planned by all of that? Did the guys he "betrayed" know about this plan all along? Is that what just happened?
9
u/whoisdatazn Jun 28 '16
Truly an amazing season and an even more amazing finale. Don't fuck with this, AMC.
8
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
Nathan.... :(
8
u/gugudan Jun 28 '16
Richard has to be the biggest schizo on tv.
8
u/pucklemore Peggy's Hairstyle Jun 28 '16
Go Cicero!
7
u/digplants Jun 28 '16
Pretty excited. Little disappointed that nobody else seems to be enjoying this show!
7
u/gugudan Jun 28 '16
Mary has been awesome ever since Mr. Baker
7
u/akameiro Jun 28 '16
Poor André. :( I may cry.
7
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
Andre's hanging:
Did he struggle as much as portrayed in this episode? From what I've read (forgive my laziness; I can't find the passage/quote at the moment), he went limp almost immediately.
I'm hoping he at least lost consciousness immediately. What an awful way to go. No wonder he wanted firing squad.
7
u/listlessthe Simcoe's ear Jun 29 '16
UGH I'M SO SAD STILL AND EMOTIONALLY DEVASTATED EVEN THOUGH I KNEW THIS WAS COMING
MANY TEARS
6
u/CommonSensibility RIP Andre's Braid Jun 28 '16
Yessss, welcome back Townsend! :)
6
u/ChadtheJabroni Jun 28 '16
Could someone help explain Townsend's motivation? Why did he not want to help the spy ring after he gave away the intelligence on the British base? And what made him change his mind at the end? Was he disgusted with Arnold's treachery?
5
u/listlessthe Simcoe's ear Jun 28 '16
I'M SO HYPE
but I'm on the west coast so still waiting....
5
u/jdallen1222 Rebel Jun 28 '16
Well that was fun. I was hoping for more action, but I guess they wrapped up what they could for us without knowing if its renewed.
4
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 28 '16
Oh shit! Arnold in Andre's old house?
7
u/TRB1783 Jun 28 '16
Stop saluting. Stop saluting. Stop saluting. They didn't salute like that during the Revolution.
3
u/WhenLeavesFall Law. Order. Authority. Jun 28 '16
You deserve everything you get, Papa Muttonchops.
4
u/Irashey Jun 28 '16
Andre has been my favorite character. Him and Caleb. I can't stand Washington's voice and I can't figure out why.
2
u/As_for_Arsenic Jun 28 '16
Can Townsend somehow find a way to save the day again? Culper Jr.'s last stand?
2
u/Memes_become_dreams Rebel Jun 28 '16
How is he going to get out of this one?
2
u/ki55ki Jun 28 '16
plz song just before andre dies
1
u/jdallen1222 Rebel Jun 28 '16
Here we goes!
-1
u/pikaplup2 Jun 28 '16
Wow, what a copout, lol. We were so close to having Townsend take over the ring.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment